As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

March 1905

3 articles

Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper

The article recounts Billy the Kid's unusual method of aiming by pointing his finger rather than the gun, as told to General Lew Wallace. It also relays banker John W. Poe's claim that Pat Garrett's famous tracking of the Kid was accidental luck rather than skill, placing the fatal encounter at Fort Stanton.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 16 days earlier.

Wrong

Evening Star · 4 March 1905 · page 40 · transcribed from the page image

PAT GARRETT'S NERVE

GEN. LEW WALLACE AS A REFORMER OF BAD MEN.

See moreSee less

Billy the Kid Was Good as Long as Wallace Remained Governor of New Mexico.

"I recently had a look at the room in the old palace in Santa Fe in which Gen. Lew Wallace, while governor of the territory of New Mexico wrote a large part of 'Ben Hur,'" observed a well-known government official who travels a great deal through the southwest. "It was in this room that he spread out his maps and charts and elaborate topographical data and wrote his colorful and painstaking piece of fiction before he had ever had so much as a glimpse of the Holy Land.

"To a good many folks in Santa Fe, however, that room in the old palace has an element of interest entirely separate from its having been the virtual birthplace of the 'Ben Hur' book.

"It was in that same room that Gen. Wallace had his famous conference with William Bonney, better known as Billy the Kid. Shortly after taking up the reins as governor of New Mexico Gen. Wallace sent for the Kid, who was then living under cover in the territory, a fugitive from justice. Gen. Wallace had somehow or another gained the impression that the young fellow was more sinned against than sinning, and, in the natural kindliness of his heart, he wanted to give the Kid another chance for his taw marble.

"So he got hold of a man known to be one of Billy the Kid's friends and told him to bring the Kid to the palace for a little talk. The Kid made his appearance at the palace a couple of days later. Gen. Wallace gave him a kindly talking to. His fatherly words made a genuine impression on the Kid, who was really only a slender boy—he wasn't much past his majority when he met his finish—and I am told that there was something very much like a frog in the young fellow's throat throughout the interview.

Index Finger Shooting.

"The general told the kid that if he'd promise to behave and lead a decent life from then on he, the governor of the territory, would see to it that he wasn't molested. The kid promised, and it is a matter of record that he did behave and cut out the gun business as long as General Wallace was in the territory. He kept his word faithfully, and didn't jump the reservation until General Wallace had left New Mexico.

"It was at this interview in the old palace that General Wallace asked the kid where he had picked up his marvelous marksmanship. It was known to everybody that Billy the Kid never had a sight on any of his guns, and yet he had earned the reputation of being the most unerring shot in the southwest.

"Billy, who was a quiet, shy sort of a chap in ordinary circumstances and without a trace of bluster or swagger, explained the thing curiously enough to General Wallace.

"'I just point my finger at what I shoot at, that's all,' he said to the general, and he illustrated his way of 'pointing,' using a pistol to do it.

"He simply permitted his forefinger to rest along the barrel of his pistol, and then, instead of attempting to point the pistol at his mark, he pointed his forefinger at the target, pulling the trigger with his middle finger. His theory was that when a man points at anything with his finger he points unerringly, and with a certainty of aim that is instinctive and quick as thought, whereas in aiming with a gun he has to employ a trained system of eye-measuring, holding his gun steady, get the approximate focus with the aid of foresight and hindsight and then take a swell chance of going wide from hurry or nervousness. So he just used the system of pointing with his forefinger and, with his eye following his finger, blazing away at his mark. I don't know how sound this theory may be as practiced by other people who have tried it, but Billy the Kid certainly made it work like a charm. He was forked lightning with a shooting tool, and a study of the many close-hand gun fights in which he figured shows that no man ever succeeded in beating him to it on the draw and fire up to the hour that Pat Garrett got him.

John Poe's Account.

"From a talk which I had on this same trip with one of the most prominent citizens of Roswell, New Mexico, I learned that the popular story as to the way Billy the Kid met his death is wrong in most of its details. The accepted story is that Sheriff Pat Garrett tracked the Kid to his finish with an infallible sleuthing instinct. The truth of the matter is that Garrett stumbled upon Billy the Kid purely by accident, and that Pat was strangely lucky to get away with his own life instead of getting the

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Labor World · Duluth, Minn. · 25 March 1905

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

This article recounts anecdotes about gunfighter Bat Masterson, including a tale of facing down boxer John L. Sullivan, noting the same story circulates about outlaws like Billy the Kid and Jesse James. It also covers Masterson's 1902 arrest in New York on a gambling fraud complaint that was later dismissed.

Omaha Daily Bee · 18 March 1905 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

is one of an encounter with John L. Sullivan when the Bostonian was in his prime as a fighter. The "big fellow" was declaiming against the climate of Colorado, and Masterson was equally vehement in its defense. Finally, losing his temper, Sullivan made a vicious swing at the border hero, who dodged and came up smiling with his gun pointed on a level with the fighter's stomach.

"How do you like the climate?" asked "Bat," softly.

See moreSee less

"Fine," said Sullivan, seeing the force of the argument.

The same story has done good service for every famous outlaw, from "Billy the Kid"

See the clipping

Pinedale Roundup · Pinedale, Wyo.

This 1905 article recounts how Gov. Lewis Wallace faced threats from Billy the Kid and other outlaws, noting Wallace's prior meetings with the Kid before his escape and death. It then details Wallace's 1881 reward proclamation against the Stockton gang, describing the outlaw careers of brothers Porter and Isaac Stockton, including a jailbreak they staged together.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 19 days earlier.

Pinedale Roundup · 23 March 1905 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Wallace and the Bandits

Author of "Ben Hur" Helped Rid the Frontier of Bad Men.

See moreSee less

Denver, Colo., Dec.—The serious illness of Gen. Lew Wallace at his home in Indiana has brought concern to the Southwest, where the author of "Ben Hur" is remembered as one of the most courageous and efficient governors that ever came to the frontier in the days of its lawlessness.

Gen. Lew Wallace was territorial governor of New Mexico at a time when that grand commonwealth was infested with outlaws and "bad men" of the worst type. It was under his regime that Billy the Kid, the worst shedder of human blood the West has ever known, was run to earth and killed. It was under the Wallace administration that the great Lincoln county cattle war raged its fiercest, hundreds of opposing cattlemen and bandits being killed; and it was while "Ben Hur" was being written at Santa Fe that the notorious Stockton brothers and other gangs of cattle thieves and desperadoes were marking all the trails in the Southwest with newly made graves.

Almost any other man would have been dismayed at the prospect that confronted the governor of Mexico when he took his seat. But Gen. Wallace was made of too stern stuff to falter at any prospect, and he began at once the task of ridding New Mexico of its undesirable characters. The task was a wholesale one, for it seemed as if the Southwest had become the one point where all the scum of the earth had gathered. Cattle thieves held forth everywhere, and the new railroads that then being built across the territory brought the usal desperate crew that followed the shining steel rails across the continent. Organized gangs of bandits held forth in mountain retreats and openly defied the authorities. Riot and bloodshed were common, and human life was the cheapest thing in New Mexico.

Chief among the terrors of the Southwest was Billy the Kid. This slender youth boasted of having killed twenty-three persons, yet he was only twenty-one years old when he was killed himself. Billy was the chief of the bandits that hung out in Lincoln county and that kept the great cattle war going. The organized cattle thieves and "bad men" under the captaincy of Billy the Kid, were fighting it out with the cattle owners for the control of the range, and the vast herds that roamed upon it. Every cattle owner had to protect his own property at the point of the rifle or pistol, so bold had the rustlers become. The cattle owners hired gun fighters to espouse their cause, and the rustlers constantly gained recruits from the lawless elements that were continually drifting into the territory. Thus the war was continued for over two years, and it is estimated that 200 or 300 men on both sides were killed in the numerous sanguine encounters that took place. If Billy the Kid's estimate of his victims is correct—and there is no reason to doubt the eloquent testimony of his notched gun handle—this one bandit must have killed from twelve to fifteen men during the progress of the Lincoln county war.

The Kid did not confine his talents to Lincoln county, however, but slew indiscriminately in various parts of the territory. He never wasted words with an enemy, but shot him on sight. He was captured once by Sheriff Pat Garrett and two deputies. But while in jail Billy killed both of the deputies and made his escape. Before he left the jail he expressed his regret at not being able to get a shot at Pat Garrett and "that blankety-blanked Lew Wallace," but said he would never leave New Mexico until he had killed both of them.

Instead of being frightened at the threat of this human tiger, who was as fearless as he was crafty, Gen. Wallace increased the amount of the rewards for the capture or killing of Billy the Kid. Sheriff Pat Garrett was sent on the trail of the outlaw, and got track of Billy near Fort Sumner, N. Mex. Billy and the sheriff met one night as Garrett was talking with Peter Maxwell in the latter's room. Garrett had come to Maxwell's room to ask about information regarding the Kid's whereabouts. He had been there only a few minutes when the Kid himself entered, armed with a knife and revolver. Garrett fired first and the Kid fell, shot through the heart. In a modest report to Gov. Wallace, Sheriff Garrett recounted the circumstances of the killing. Thus Gen. Wallace's most formidable enemy was removed, and the friends of the governor breathed easier, for the threat of Billy the Kid against any man's life was not a matter to be considered lightly.

Before the escape of Billy the Kid, Gov. Wallace had met the desperado on several occasions and talked with him. No doubt his knowledge of this notorious man-killer will form some of the most interesting portions of the Wallace autobiography, which is said to be about ready for publication.

But the ending of Billy the Kid's career did not mean that the trouble of Gov. Wallace with bandits was at an end. Other desperate men were at work, and there were other gangs of bandits to be run down. One of the worst gangs was that headed by Porter and Isaac Stockton, and generally known as the "Stockton gang." One of the most interesting of the official documents issued by Gen. Wallace is a brief but significant proclamation put forth in the spring of 1881. It offers rewards aggregating $2,250 for the capture or killing of Isaac Stockton, James Garrett, Hugo Eskridge, Thomas Redigan, Charlie Alison, Lark Reynolds, Wilson Hughes, alias "Texas Jack," and Bill Hunter, alias "Tex." This proclamation is signed by Lewis Wallace, governor of New Mexico. Porter Stockton was not included in the proclamation for the reason that his stormy career had been cut short by a bullet a short time before the document was issued.

The Stockton brothers, Porter and Isaac, began their careers as cattle rustlers in Texas, but, after a few years of outlawry, the Lone Star State became too hot for them, and they moved to New Mexico in 1874, operating in Colfax and Lincoln counties. They stole, robbed and murdered indiscriminately, anything from cattle to purses being their booty, and red men and white and Mexicans being numbered among their victims. The first murder traced to them was on the Cimarron in 1875. It was the deliberate murder of a cattleman by Porter Stockton. The desperado eluded the sheriff for several weeks, but was finally captured and put in jail. Isaac Stockton, who seems to have been a royal supporter and avenger of his brother, made a descent on the jail, single-handed. He rode one horse to the jail door and led another. Fastening both animals, he coolly stepped into the jail and held up the sheriff at the muzzle of a gun and made him unlock Porter's cell. Then the two brothers, without wasting any words in mutual congratulations, tied the sheriff like a trussed turkey and threw the unfortunate official into the cell recently occupied by Porter, the door being slammed and locked on him. Then they mounted their horses and rode gaily away to the mountains, firing a few shots as they clattered out of town, just to quiet any overambitious person who might be wanting to take a shot at them.

For years the Stockton brothers kept New Mixoco in an uproar. They organized a gang of faithful confederates and took a prominent part in the Lincoln county cattle war, on the side of Billy the Kid. No sheriff was able to capture them again, and they robbed and murdered about as they pleased until the coming of Gov. Wallace. That official got after the Stocktons with a vengeance. He offered large rewards and made it so hot for them that Isaac went to Texas, where he apparently quit the strenuous life of banditry for awhile. Porter found it more agreeable to seek other fields, so he took his gang to Durango, Colo., then the objective point of the Denver & Rio Grande railroad. Durango at that time was one of the most lawless towns in the country, taking rank with Dodge and Tombstone in their worst days. Porter Stockton and his gang not only found shelter there, but, it is claimed, even secured supporters among certain officials and residents of the county. From Durango the gang would make raids on the surrounding cattle and mining country. Generally the raids were made across the New Mexico line, for the bandits liked to

See the clipping