As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

June 1905

3 articles

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

An Outing magazine piece reprinted in 1905 describes 'Billy the Kid' (calling him William Antrim, alias Billy Bonny) as the most wantonly evil outlaw of the frontier. It claims he killed three Mexicans purely for amusement, saying he did it 'just to see them kick.'

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Evening Journal · 12 June 1905 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

the Kid," should be the worst desperado in the history of the frontier. Yet in considering the so called "bad men" of the west his name must stand forth as the superlative of badness. Some of the gun fighters of frontier days killed in self defense, and others killed when they were in liquor or inflamed with anger. But "Billy the Kid" was the only white man who slew out of pure wantonness. Three of his victims—Mexicans they were—he bowled over "just to see them kick," as he laughingly explained afterward.—Arthur Chapman in Outing.

See the clipping

Greene County Herald · Leakesville, Miss.

This article by Arthur Chapman paints Billy the Kid as a wantonly murderous gunfighter who killed for pleasure, including shooting three Mexicans just to watch them die. It recounts his biographical origin as a New York street waif turned New Mexico desperado, killed at 21 by Sheriff Pat Garrett after allegedly killing one man per year of his life.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 76 days later.

Wrong

Greene County Herald · 16 June 1905 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

By Arthur Chapman. T is one of the anomalies of Western life that a pale, slender, high voiced light haired, and altogether effeminate individual named William Antrim, some times called Billy Bonny, and generally known as Billy the Kid, should be the worst desperado in the history of the frontier. Yet, in considering the so-called "bad men" of the West, his name must stand forth as the superlative of badness. Some of the gun fighters of frontier days killed in self-defense, and others killed when they were in liquor or inflamed with anger—but Billy the Kid was the only white man who slew out of pure wantonness.

See moreSee less

Three of his victims—Mexicans they were—he bowled over "just to see them kick," as he laughingly explained afterward. If he had a grudge against a man he never harbored it long, but simply confronted his victim and slew without making any explanation. Only sturdy John Chisholm bade defiance to Billy to the end of the desperado's red career, and only one man ever proved himself a quicker shot—Patrick A. Garrett, one of the nerviest sheriffs that ever served in the days when the Southwest needed nervy men in that office. Billy the Kid was only twenty-one years of age when he gasped out his life at the feet of his most implacable foe, and it was known that he had killed one man for every year of his existence. In early boyhood he was a New York street waif, from where he was sent to Silver City, New Mexico, where a stepfather volunteed to make him a worthy member of society. But at the mature age of fifteen, Billy quarreled with his stepfather—one of the few quarrels in which the Kid's pistol did not speak the final word— and the youth left home, becoming a waiter in a hotel at Silver City. Soon Billy was convicted of stealing sup plies from the hotel larder, and clothes from a Chinese laundryman. He was put in jail, bu[t] the jailor little reck oned with the budding desperado in his charge. Billy worked his slender form up through the chimney and made his escape. It was not to be his last successful jail break, for no des perado since the days of Jack Shep pard showed the Kid's wonderful fac ulty of turning the devices of lock smith and the watchfulness of guards to naught. After his escape from the Silver City jail he began life anew as a blacksmith's apprentice at Camp Apache. But one day he quarreled with the blacksmith. The apprentice shot the forge-master dead and made his escape. Thereafter Billy's ways when the poss[e] house with th[e] when it becam[e] cluded to surre[nder] stepped out i[n] his hands, sho[wing] he surrendere[d] Pickett follow[ed] shackled hand[s] Las Vegas. When it be[came known at] Vegas that B[illy the Kid was a] captive, a mob[—] rett had antic[ipated this and] had put his pr[isoners, among] which he, Olli[nger and the] little band stoo[d—] Mexicans and[?] Garrett and h[is] prisoners. Th[e mob] shook his man[acled hands] and begged Ga[rrett] with a brace [of pistols] mob to fury. [For] for an hour, b[ut in a few] minutes Garre[tt] with weapons [kept the mob at] bay. Could th[e mob have gotten] on the outlaw[s they would have] been made of [them] the mob knew [that Gar] rett and the n[o] train finally p[assed and the des] peradoes unsc[athed.] The outlaw[s, including] Billy the Ki[d, were later] sentenced to b[e hanged for] having murde[red a sheriff] the year befor[e.] shot the forge-master dead and made his escape. Thereafter Billy's ways were the ways of the desperado, for at last he had reached the proud distinction of having a price put on his head. At the time of Bill's first essay in supreme crime the Lincoln County cattle war was making Southwestern New Mexico a delectable place for gentlemen who cared not so much for clear consciences as for well notched gun handles. This war was waged between the horse thieves and cattle rustlers on one side and the cattle owners on the other. A few bold cattlemen had entered the Pecos country with their herds, despite the fact that in doing so they were invading the haunts of men who had been driven out of the more settled portions of the Territory by sheriff's posses and vigilance committees. One class determined to despoil the other class of its herds and to drive it out of Lincoln County, and the other class determined to fight for its range. A guerrilla warfare went on for two years and upwards, and Emerson Hough, in his "The Story of the Cowboy," estimates that two or three hundred men on both sides lost their lives in the long series of assassinations. Chief among the stock owners was John Chisholm, whose brand was on thousands of range cattle. Billy worked for Chisholm a short time, but soon he had his inevitable quarrel with his employer. It was over a question of wages, Billy claiming that Chisholm had not squared their account. Only the fact that Chisholm was surrounded by a guard of hard fighting cowboys, with reputations as "killers," kept him from assassination when he and the young desperado parted. As it was Billy managed finally to exact a terrible penalty from Chisholm. It was more than likely that the Kid swore his vendetta against Chisholm and other cattle owners simply as a matter of course instead of a punctilious affair of principle. Billy would naturally take sides with the rustlers who were making life miserable for honest men in Lincoln County. He soon became a leader of the desperate crew and was in the thick of many of the deadly encounters that took place during the course of the "war." It is estimated that he put a round dozen of notches on his gun handle during this fiercest of range feuds, every notch representing a human life. Two of his victims were a sheriff and his deputy, who had driven him and part of his gang into an adobe house. The name of Billy the Kid became such a terror in the Southwest that the people of Lincoln County cast about for the right sort of a man to literally camp on the trail of this outlaw and rid the world of his presence. For this sole purpose Pat Garrett was elected. Garret* who is now Collector Garrett, who is now Collector of Customs at El Paso, and who looks mildly bored when anyone mentions Billy the Kid, had earned a reputation as a man who ne’er wasted speeches or lead. Cool headed at all times, skilled in handling firearms, and thoroughly acquainted with the habits and haunts of the ruffians of the Southwest the tall, easy-going Garrett was elected to try conclusions with the desperado. It was not an enviable task this, to essay too overmatch a man who knew the desert as the average matinee idol knows his Broadway, and whose "gameness" matched his ferocity, but Garrett undertook the responsibility with open eyes. He invaded the territory of Billy the Kid and carried out his plans so cleverly that he succeeded in trapping the desperado. Organizing a posse of twenty-five determined men, many of whom had lost friends at the hands of the Kid, Garrett set out after his man. Bob Ollinger, who was as brave, faithful and skilled a man as ever hunted a desperado in frontier days, and a deputy named Stewart, were Garrett's lieutenants. On the Kid's side there was a resolute band, including Billy Wilson, Dave Rudebaugh and Tom Pickett, these three being almost as desperate criminals as their beardless In July, 1881, after Billy had been at large some two months, Sheriff Garrett heard that the Kid had been seen in the vicinity of Fort Sumner. Accompanied by two deputies, Garrett remained in the vicinity of Fort Sumner a week, but information about the Kid was hard to get, in view of the bonds of terror in which the desperado held the entire community. One night, after vainly watching a suspected house until midnight, Garrett suggested that a call be made on Peter Maxwell, who lived in one of the old buildings at the fort, and who was brave enough to tell what he knew about the. Kid's whereabouts. Garrett stepped into Maxwell's room to talk to him, while his deputies sat on the porch in the bright New Mexican moonlight. Soon a man, clad in shirt and trousers, and carrying a knife in one hand and a revolver in the other, hurried toward the building, and as he stepped on the porch, cried: "Quien es? Quien es?" ("Who is it?") One of the deputies, having no idea that this could be Billy the Kid, told him to put up his gun and not be alarmed. At the same time he rose and walked toward Billy, but, lithe as a cat, the desperado leaped through the open doorway into Maxwell's room. Something—probably the sixth sense said to be given to all hunted things—told Billy that all was not right in the room. Coming into the dark from the bright moonlight he could not make GAS AND WA[TER] IS ONE AS NECESSAR[Y] OTHER? Citizens of Large Cities New York, June 13.—I[n] agitation here about the [l]the demand for lower rat[es] ported by the argument tha[t] dent is as dependent upon gas as upon a supply of go[as] It has come to pass that borer uses gas as his o[nly] cooking, because of econo[my] rich man uses gas on ac[count of] convenience. Gas for lig[ht and] modern improvements in [the home is] cheaper, better and more [economical] than any other kind of [light. It] sells at $1.00 per thousan[d feet] in large cities, and from th[at up] as $3.00 in smaller towns. The consumer of gas in [the home] uses Acetylene (pronoun[ced Ace-ty-] lene), and each user makes [his own] and is independent of Gas [Light] Companies. Acetylene is [a per-] fect illuminant than the [gas of] the big gas companies in t[heir] the cost to the smallest u[se of] the equivalent of city gas [at $1.00] per thousand. Acetylene is the mod[ern] light, the latest addition room. Coming into the dark from the bright moonlight he could not make out objects distinctly, consequently he could not see Garrett sitting at the foot of the bed. Coming to the edge of the bed, and putting his hand on the coverlet within a few inches of Garrett, Billy asked Maxwell: "Say, Pete, who are those fellows out there?" Garrett recognized the voice as that of Billy the Kid, and slipped his holster around so he could get at his revolver. At the same time Billy caught sight of the figure on the bed. Covering Garrett with his revolver, he sprang backward, crying: "Quien es?" The instant's pause was fatal to Billy the Kid, for, almost before the Spanish words had dropped from the desperado's lips, Garrett's revolver had spoken. The Kid fell to the floor, shot through the heart, his revolver being discharged by his convulsive movement as he fell. The qualities that caused Pat Garrett to be known as the coolest head in the Southwest were shown in this encounter. As he fired, Garrett leaned to the left, thinking that he could get Billy's bullet in his right side. "That would give me a chance to get another shot at him," explained the Sheriff grimly. As soon as the shots were heard the deputies outside called Garrett's name, but again the presence of mind of the born gun fighter was manifested. Garrett did not answer, thinking that per[haps his gasping foe on the floor was] Acetylene is the mode[rn] light, the latest addition [to the] inventions that have beco[me ne]cessities. The light from an acety[lene is] soft, steady and brilliant, [its purity?] is only rivaled by the [sun]. If water and a solid mater[ial like] Calcium Carbide are brou[ght in con]tact, the immediate result [is the mak]ing of this wonderful gas. [The prepara]tion of acetylene is so sim[ple no ex]perience or even apparatus [is neces]sary, to make it. If it [is desired to] make it for practical ligh[ting and to] keep it for immediate use, [a small] machine called an "Acety[lene genera]tor" is employed. There [are also re]sponsible concerns maki[ng larger] generators. In practice th[ey are dis]tributed in small pipes [through] buildings, grounds or ent[ire] towns in the same manne[r as] city gas. Acetylene is th[e] factory means of light[ing] buildings located in the[ir] suburbs at a distance fro[m] electric plants. Boy Not to Be Te[mpted] The following story is t[old of a] little boy in Forest Hill: He stood at a corner ne[ar his] day, soaking in the sunsh[ine, when anoth]er boy strolled along, dra[gging] "Come on, and go co[asting," said] the older boy. "I dassent," replied t[he smaller boy,] "my mother told me t[o] born gun fighter was manifested." Garrett did not answer, thinking that perhaps his gasping foe on the floor was not fatally wounded, and that the sound of the Sheriff's voice would give Billy the Kid a chance to get in an effective shot. Could a Lombroso have studied this mere boy, who seemed to have been born with a tiger's blood thirst, no doubt science would have received an interesting contribution. Without a spark of pity for his numerous victims, and with no fear of his enemies in his heart, Billy the Kid presented a peculiar phenomenon. His desire was to kill, and it seemed to make little difference to him whether he killed in the most cowardly manner or whether he boldly faced the weapons of his enemies. Few men have been the Kid's equal with the revolver, and none ever made a more terrifying record with that universal weapon of the frontier. Dying, as he had lived, like a wild beast, this beardless, soulless youth who had about him none of the attributes that usually gain the Western desperado a certain sort of admiration, must remain wholly the most unaccountable figure in frontier history.—From Outing. "I dassent," replied t[he girl], "my mother told me to [stay right] here." "Aw, come on—just do[n't.]" "No, I dassent; my mo[ther told me] to stay right here." "Shucks! She won't e[ver know; I'll] haul you on my sled if yo[u want to.]" "I'd like to, but I dasse[nt; my moth]er told me to stay right h[ere.]" The older boy looked [illegible]. "Go to h----l, then," he said. "I dassent," the little [girl an]swered, "my mother told [me to stay] right here."—Newark Ne[ws.] A Case of Mistaken [illegible] On the occasion of the [illegible] parade, during the recent[ ser]vices inaugurated by Eva[n]son of London, Eng., in [illegible]ters and men of all denom[inations and] walks in life took part, [illegible]astic divine, on seeing [illegible] from a brilliantly lighte[d illegible] join the ranks, exclai[med], equally enthusiastic, bu[t illegible]formed friend: "See, ev[illegible] from the saloons come t[illegible] "That a bum?" replie[d] "why, that is the presiden[t of the] Theological Seminary. The president had b[illegible] saloon to get recruits.

See the clipping

The Roswell Daily Record · Roswell, N.M.

A feature on New Mexico pioneer Sally Roberts recounts her girlhood on John Chisum's ranch, where she saw Billy the Kid and other outlaws, noting he never actually worked for Chisum. The bulk of the story covers her later founding of Artesia and its first artesian well.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Evening Times-Republican, 10 April 1905, Yorkville Enquirer, 23 May 1905.

The Roswell Daily Record · 28 June 1905 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

ARTESIA PIONEER STORY OF A BRAVE WOMAN WHO WAS ONE OF THE FIRST. FORTUNE ON PRAIRIE

Land of Milk and Honey.

From Carlsbad Sun. Mrs. Sally Roberts, one of the most remarkable pioneers of New Mexico, came to South Spring with her father from Denton, Texas, in November, 1876, and spent four years of her girlhood days on the famous John Chisum ranch. Here she saw Billy the Kid and other border outlaws, but says the Kid never worked a day

See the clipping