As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

May 1905

2 articles

The Roswell Daily Record · Roswell, N.M.

The Republican county executive committee in El Paso endorsed A. L. Sharp over Pat Garrett for customs collector, arguing Garrett is a New Mexican while the office is a Texas post. The article notes Garrett was a former Lincoln County sheriff and one of three men who killed Billy the Kid.

The Roswell Daily Record · 5 May 1905 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

OPPOSE PAT GARRETT.

Former Resident of Roswell Being Fought on the Grounds That He is a New Mexican.

See moreSee less

The following special from El Paso will be of interest here, inasmuch as Pat Garrett, the man mentioned in the dispatch, is a former resident of this section, having been sheriff of Lincoln county when this city and vicinity were a part of Lincoln county, and Garrett having been one of the three men who killed Billy the Kid.

"The Republican county executive committee today indorsed A. L. Sharp of this city, the only Republican representative in the legislature of Texas, for the position of collector of customs here, in opposition to the re-appointment of Pat F. Garrett, a personal friend of the President. They will make the fight on him on the ground that he is a New Mexican, while the office is a Texas office."

See the clipping

Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.

This 1905 magazine piece (by Arthur Chapman, reprinted from Outing) recounts a romanticized tale of Billy the Kid's feud with cattle baron John Chisholm, claiming the Kid killed Chisholm's cowboys as payment for unpaid wages, charging five dollars per death. It frames Billy as a vengeful outlaw-hero during the Lincoln County War, embellishing his killings and motives decades after his death.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 36 days later.

Wrong

Yorkville Enquirer · 23 May 1905 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

the neighborhood of King's Moun- (30.) , had been taken prisoner, and was Wylie.

when he and the young desperado parted. As it was, Billy managed finally to exact a terrible penalty from Chisholm. It is more than likely that the Kid swore his vendetta against Chisholm and other cattle owners instead of a punctilious affair of principle. Billy would naturally take sides with the rustlers who were making life miserable for honest men in Lincoln county. He soon became a leader of the desperate crew and was in the thick of many of the deadly encounters that took place during the course of the "war." It is estimated that he put a round dozen of notches on his gun-handle during this fiercest of range feuds, every notch representing a human life. Two of his victims were a sheriff and his deputy, who had driven him and part of his gang into an adobe house.

See moreSee less

One day the Kid turned up at one of the Chisholm cow-camps. He had not forgotten his old feud with the cattle king of the Pecos. Three of the cowboys were at a fire, cooking sup-

See the clipping