As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

August 1881

27 articles

Smyrna Times · Smyrna, Del.

New Mexico towns are collecting money for Pat Garrett in recognition of his killing of Billy the Kid, described as a notorious desperado. The item appears as a brief news filler among other miscellaneous facts.

Smyrna Times · 3 August 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A bald eagle was recently caught at Wilmington, Del., while trying to carry off a large Newfoundland dog.

Mr. Powers had begun to make a bust of the president in his studio at Florence on the day that Gen. Garfield was shot.

See moreSee less

The principal towns of New Mexico are raising funds for Pat Garrett, who killed "Billy the Kid," the notorious desperado.

Mayor King, of Philadelphia, intends to appoint two more good colored men on

See the clipping

The River Press · Fort Benton, Mont.

The report states that Billy the Kid, a notorious Western outlaw, was shot through the heart by the sheriff of Lincoln County, New Mexico. It claims he was twenty-one years old and had boasted of killing twenty-one men.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The River Press · 3 August 1881 · page 7

DRIFT WOOD. The Marquis of Lorne's term of office will end in December of next year, and it is likely that he will then quit Canada. Five thousand persons, or one-sixteenth of the population of 80,000, have joined church at Indianapolis in the last six months. Col. J. A. Sumner, of Akron, Ohio, wit nessed the launching of the first steamboat west of the Alleghanies, at Pittsburg, in 1816. He rode on the first steamer, "Walk-in-the Water," that navigated the lakes. ~He is noted locally for his long white beard, which is three feet in length. "Billy the Kid," one of the most noted

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

A brief dispatch reports that the notorious outlaw 'Billy the Kid,' blamed for fifteen to twenty killings, was finally killed by a deputy in Lincoln County, New Mexico. The account says the deputy cornered him in a house and shot him dead.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 3 August 1881 · page 4

States Express company's safe of eoveral thou sand dollare and escaped on horseback. Th< outrage is attributed to the notorious Jamei brothera. In one week there were 204 deaths in Cincinnati from sunstroke and 150 from the ox cessivc heat. The town of Wallace, Mich., consisting of f saw-mill and twenty-one buildings, was totallj destroyed by fire. Paul Held, a Swiss emigrant who recently bought a farm in Eagle Croek Valley, Minn, becoming insane through homesickness ant the failure of his crops, killed his wife ant five children, mortally wounded his remaininf two children and then committed suicide.

See moreSee less

Heniiv S. Smith was hanged at Corinth, Miss, firr tho murder of James Burt. "Billy the Kid," tho notorious outlaw, who has killed from fifteen to twenty men, hai at last mot his fate at tho hamls of a pluck} deputy Bnenii, who oveniuuiuu mm iu u unuu

See the clipping

The Weekly Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

The notorious outlaw 'Billy the Kid,' long the terror of cattlemen in New Mexico and Colorado, was shot dead by Lincoln County Sheriff Pat Garrett on the 14th of the month. The report notes that cattlemen and others will cheer the news as a deserved end to his criminal career.

The Weekly Oskaloosa Herald · 4 August 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

—"Billy the kid," one of the most notorious outlaws known in the criminal annals of this country, and has been for several years the terror of the cattle-men of New Mexico and Colorado, has at last met with a deserved fate. He was shot dead by Pat Garrett, the Sheriff of Lincoln County, N. M., on the 14th inst., The cattle-men and other men will exclaim on hearing the news, "Good for Pat!"

See the clipping

The Lake County Star · Chase, Mich. · and 1 other paper

The report notes that principal towns of New Mexico Territory are collecting funds to reward Pat Garrett for his services in killing Billy the Kid. This item appears amid a miscellany of unrelated national news briefs.

The Lake County Star · 4 August 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

of Nevada.

The principal towns of New-Mexico are raising funds for "Patsey" Garrett for his services to the Territory in killing "Billy, the Kid."

See moreSee less

A construction train on the Richmond and Allegheny road in Virginia jumped the track yesterday and two men were killed.

There was a furious tornado in the district north of Troy, N. Y., reaching Saratoga and some towns in southern Vermont. Barns and other buildings were destroyed, and crops and trees ruined by wind, rain and lightning.

Fire this morning destroyed a portion of the Exchange hotel at Columbus, O.

The 100 Chinese students withdrawn from America will be sent to England, France and Germany, the Chinese fearing that American institutions are too progressive.

Inter-state reunion of veterans of Indiana,

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Owosso Times · Owosso, Mich. · 5 August 1881

Mexico Weekly Ledger · Mexico, Mo.

This short item jokes that 'Billy the Kid' was not the son of 'William the Goat,' and notes that no one ever knew whose son he was. It adds that now, after his death, people will care even less about his parentage.

Mexico Weekly Ledger · 4 August 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

D. Henderson and wife, Mrs. Vangalder, Josiah Wright and wife will return from Europe about the middle of September.

"Billy the Kid" was not the son

See the clipping

The Pinal Drill · Pinal City, Ariz. Territory

A Las Vegas dispatch states the Gazette has confirmed that Billy the Kid, the notorious outlaw, was killed on July 14th by Sheriff Pat Garrett of Lincoln County. The report adds that the Kid was a native of New York City, real name McCarthy.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Lexington Weekly Intelligencer, 30 July 1881, The River Press, 3 August 1881.

The Pinal Drill · 6 August 1881 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Western mails would be brought here if not by the regular trains, by a special. It is impossible, however, to state when the Eastern mail will arrive, as the breaks in that direction, beyond Benson and Deming are serious and require a great amount of labor to repair. As the skies are now clear of clouds, and weather prophets declare that there will be no more rain until a change of moon, it is probable the trains will soon again be running regularly.—Tucson Journal.

Death of Billy the Kid.

See moreSee less

A Las Vegas, N. M., distpach of July 18, says that the Gazette has positive information that Billy the Kid, the notorious murderer and outlaw, who for several years has been the terror of New Mexico cattle men, was, on the 14th ist., killed by Patrick

See the clipping

Las Vegas Daily Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

The item reports that journalist Pat Donan has published a letter in the Globe-Democrat recounting the life and exploits of Billy the Kid, written from Lamy. The local paper notes that while Donan only tells half the story of the Lincoln County troubles, it is the best account of the Kid's story yet to appear outside the Territory.

Las Vegas Daily Gazette · 6 August 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Pat Donan, the "fire-eater" journalist, contributes to the Globe-Democrat a letter from Lamy on the life and exploits of Billy "the Kid." Although he

See the clipping

In the story →

Lyon County Times · Silver City, Nev.

This article reports that a friend at Fort Sumner sent the Las Vegas Optic the preserved index finger of "Billy, the Kid," which many office visitors viewed, prompting jokes about opening a side show.

Lyon County Times · 6 August 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The Fatal Finger. An esteemed friend of the Optic at Fort Sumner, has sent us the index finger of "Billy, the Kid," the one that has snapped many a man's life into eternity. It is well preserved in alcohol and has been viewed by many in our office to-day. If the rush continues we shall purchase a small tent and open a side show, to which complimentary tickets will be issued to our personal friends.—Las Vegas Optic.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A humor column quip claims Billy the Kid was born in New York and jokes that had he stayed there he might have become a legislator instead of a notorious outlaw. It presents his ambition as simply wanting to be considered 'as bad as possible.'

The Portland Daily Press · 8 August 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Billy the Kid was born in New York. Had he remaind there he might have been a member of the last Legislature. It was Bill's ambition to be considered as bad as possible.—Boston Post.

See the clipping

Las Vegas Daily Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

A brief item reports that Chicago has produced testimony claiming the slain outlaw Billy the Kid once worked as a waiter in a Chicago hotel. The editor dismisses the story as dubious ('tissue') while wryly praising Chicago's eagerness to claim the famous outlaw.

Las Vegas Daily Gazette · 12 August 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

claimant of Billy "the Kid." Testimony is put forth to show that the dead desperado was a waiter in a Chicago Hotel. But the story is decidedly tis

See the clipping

Democratic Messenger · Snow Hill, Md.

A humor column of one-liners and puns includes a quip that no one ever knew whose son Billy the Kid was, and now they will care even less. It is one of many unrelated jokes printed together as filler.

Democratic Messenger · 13 August 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

no wonder the loose waves smash things. — Wit and Wisdom.

We move that in case our country ever becomes involved in another war, that our enemies be furnished with toy pistols.

See moreSee less

Billy the Kid was not the son of Wil

See the clipping

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

A brief political item notes that opponents have taken to calling Virginia politician William Mahone 'Billy the Kid,' with a sarcastic remark that politicians show no respect for the dead. This shows the outlaw's name and recent death being used as political shorthand within weeks of the real Billy the Kid's shooting.

Shepherdstown Register · 13 August 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

neous. They call Mahone "Billy the Kid." Politicians have no respect for the dead.

Administrator's Notice.

See moreSee less

THE undersigned having qualified as Administrator of the Estate of Mrs. Margaret McKevitt, deceased, hereby in-

See the clipping

New York Dispatch · New York, N.Y.

A satirical filler column of jokes and short humorous items notes that states rush to claim both Guiteau and 'Billy the Kid' as natives. It jokes that this fame-seeking inspires small boys to practice marksmanship on cats to become assassins.

New York Dispatch · 14 August 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

SMALL CHANGE.

"NEVER go by a pin," said the bank president to the office boy, "Never go by a pin under any circumstances." And the next day when he sent the boy out to buy a paper of them, the boy spent the money for chewing tobacco, and was thus saved the dishonor of growing up to be a cashier and robbing the bank.

A "FOREIGNER" objects to the conglomerate bathing of men and women at Coney Island, and attributes it to a lack of morality on the part of Americans. Most foreigners would do well to try a bath once in a while, just to see how it feels, even if they have to pay some woman to go in with them.

See moreSee less

THE avidity with which every State in the Union rushes forward to claim Guiteau and "Billy the Kid" as natives, detracts the attention of the small boy from the idea of becoming

See the clipping

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A dispatch from Galveston, Texas reports that Harris, described as a road agent and friend of Billy the Kid, was mortally wounded while resisting arrest. The stolen money was recovered.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 16 August 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Nebraska's Grain Crop. OMAHA, August 15th.—According to the best information obtained from the elevator men, who have just made a thorough tour of the State, the wheat crop in Nebraska is pretty light. The average will not be over six or seven bushels per acre. A Friend of "Billy the Kid" Brought to Grief. GALVESTON (Tex.), August 15th.—Jack Harris, a road agent and friend of "Billy the Kid," was mortally wounded to-day while resisting arrest. Half the money stolen was recovered.

See the clipping

Savannah Morning News · Savannah

Texas lawmen captured two highwaymen, Charles Day and Albert Black, who robbed stagecoaches near El Paso, while a third suspect, Jack Harris, was shot and badly wounded resisting arrest. Harris was identified as one of Billy the Kid's most trusted followers, and about half the stolen money was recovered.

Savannah Morning News · 17 August 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MAIL ROBBERS CAUGHT.

GALVESTON, August 16.—A special to the News says: "Judge Foster, of the postal department, and Sheriff Wolfe, of Lampasas county, arrived with Charles Day and Albert Black, two of three highwaymen who robbed two stages between El Paso and Fredericksham on the night of the 6th. The third man, Jack Harris, made a desperate resistance and was shot through the body and left lung, and is at Lampasas in a precarious condition. Harris is from New York, and was one of "Billy the Kid's" most trusted followers. About half of the stolen money was recovered. A preliminary trial was held at Lampasas and each was put under $15,000 bonds, in default of which, Day and Black were brought here for confinement."

See the clipping

In the story →

The Russellville Democrat · Russellville, Ark.

This article reports a Fourth Ward belief that Billy the Kid, shot dead by Sheriff Garrett at Fort Sumner, was actually a local named McCarthy who fled New York in 1876 after fatally stabbing a man named Tom Moore.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Russellville Democrat · 18 August 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

CLAIMING BILLY THE KID.

New York People Who Think He Was Born Among Them.

See moreSee less

New York Sun.

There is a general belief in the Fourth Ward that, notwithstanding statements to the contrary, "Billy the Kid," who on Saturday last was shot dead by Sheriff Garrett at Fort Sumner, New Mexico, was born and brought up in that ward. The dispatch announcing his death reported that his real name was McCarthy, and that he was a New Yorker by birth. The Fourth Warder's name was McCarthy. He is described as answering in personal appearance to the description of the Kid, and it is said that he fled to the West in 1876 after committing a murder in this city.

"I'm convinced that Billy the Kid and McCarthy are one and the same persons," said Policeman Thomas Dwyer of the Oak street station last evening. "McCarthy was of the same height as the Kid, had hair and eyes of the same color, and the same projecting teeth. I remamebr McCarthy well, and the murder he committed was the most brutal that ever came under my notice. It happened on the night of Sept. 9, 1876. He had been on bad terms with Tom Moor, a brush maker, living at 9 Vandewater street. Moore worked in a factory in Fulton street, and was the only support of his mother. He was not 20 years old, and was a fine, broad-shouldered fellow. On the night of the 9th he went to the grocery store of Matthew Dwyer at the corner of Pearl and Hague streets. There McCarthy met him, and they quarrelled, McCarthy ran into the grocery store, and picking up a beer glass with one hand and a large knife, such is used to slice ham with, in the other, came out. He threw the glass at Moore, who dodged it, and attempted to clinch with him. McCarthy met him with the knife, sending it through Moore's chin, cutting into his throat, and burying the blade ten inche deep in his breast. One of Moore's thumbs was cut off as he held up his hand to ward off the blow. McCarthy ran down Hague street and through a passage to 84 Frankfort street where he threw away the knife. Moore staggered to the front of 357 Pearl street, and fell dead into the arms of a friend. McCarthy was traced to Brooklyn, where he was lost sight of. His father kept a fruit stand at the corner of Nassau and John streets, and was thought to have money. Shortly after his son's disappearavce he left the city, and was gone for several months. It was said at the time that he had taken McCarthy to Ireland. When he returned I know that his son came with him, and I afterward learned that son went West. In 1878 the old man died, and Dad' McCarthy, his other son, and Mrs. McCarthy died a few months later. There are two girls of the family still living. McCarthy was bad from a child, and had some Western experience before he fled West in 1876. When 13 or 14 years old he was sent to the House of Refuge, and through the Children's Aid Society, I think he was bound out to a Western farmer. He stayed a year or so, and then he escaped and came back to this city. He was born in Vandewater street and went to the Vandewater street school. His given name was Michael, but I have heard that he changed it after the murder. He was a little pased 17 when he killed Moore, and looked younger. His teeth were strong and white, but the two front upper teeth were longer than the rest and projected. He was then about five feet five inches tall, but may not then have got his growth. He had blue eyes and brown hair. His face was somewhat tanned. He learned to ride, I know, while on the farm out West."

"As soon as I read the account of Billy the Kid's death, and saw that his real name was McCarthy," said the man into whose arms Moore had fallen after being stabbed, "it occurred to me at once that he was Moore's murderer. The descriptions tallied, and McCarthy was just the man to turn out a desperado."

A Sun reporter talked last night with twenty Fourth Warders, all of whom had known McCarthy. They were all of the opinion that he and "Billy the Kid" were identical. "There is one way to make sure of it" said a young man employed in a grocery shop in Pearl street, near Hague. "McCarthy when 10 years old, was badly burned with acid, and was treated at the Chambers Street Hospital; but I think he must have a scar on the upper part of one of his legs and on his body."

See the clipping

The Emporia Weekly News · Emporia, Kan.

A brief notice states that Billy the Kid once lived in Wichita, where early settlers remember him as a young street urchin in the cattle-drive era. The item appears amid miscellaneous local news notes in an Emporia newspaper.

The Emporia Weekly News · 18 August 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

"Billy the Kid" formerly lived in Wichita and many of the early settlers remember him as a street gamin in the days of long horns.

The registry books are open at the office of the city clerk. Those who have not registered since January will have to do so to secure a vote at the fall election.

See moreSee less

The citizens of Emporia are raising a purse of $300 for a novelty running race, to come off at the county fair next month. W. T. Soden heads the subscription list with $25.

Kansas City Journal: It is reported that Rev. Geo. Wolf, the "poet lariat" of Emporia, is about to publish a volume of original poems. Peacock shall not wear all the laurels.

John Prince, the man who assaulted Charles Ashley last week at Cottonwood Falls, had a preliminary hearing at that place on Monday, and was bound over to the District court.

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

A miscellany column of odd items includes a quip that 'Billy the Kid' was not the son of 'William the goat' and that no one ever knew his parentage. It adds that now, after his death, people will care even less.

Mineral Point Tribune · 18 August 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

IN A NUTSHELL.

The time to dance is just after stirring up a den of yellow-jackets. Parties who attend picnics will do well to remember this fact.

See moreSee less

"There is no use in blinking the fact," says the Springfield Republican, "King Kalakaua is a disgrace even to the Sandwich Islands."

"Billy the Kid" was not the son of William the goat. Indeed, no one ever knew whose son he was, and now they will care less.

The latest order of exclusion at the Grand Union Hotel, Saratoga, is not against the Jews, but admits no man to the ball-room who doesn't wear a swallow-tail coat.

Atlantic city is swarming with sharpers, who play the dogs with church people who would much rather pay up than suffer exposure.

A newspaper lawyer in the Washington Law Reporter has discovered that Guiteau's crime can be punished by imprisonment for twenty years.

A Norristown man, the father of a large family, calls his flour barrel "Maud S." It goes so fast.—Norristown Herald.

A belle of Narragansett is writing a novel in which the hero is found in the desert chained to the bare back of a

See the clipping

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

This brief item notes that the Tombstone Nugget marked Billy the Kid's killing with the headline 'A Corner in Hell Filled.' It reflects press reaction and commentary following his death rather than new facts about the event itself.

The New North-West · 19 August 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

"Billy, the Kid," the suggestive sentiment: "A Corner in Hell Filled."

AT THE recent term of Supreme Court Beaverhead county was detached from this and made a part of Judge Conger's judicial district. The Court term at Deer Lodge was deferred from September to the third Monday in November, and a September term set for Butte.

See the clipping

Louisiana Capitolian · Baton Rouge, La.

Charles Day and Albert Black, described as stage robbers in Western Texas, were captured. One of the pair, Jack Harris, resisted fiercely and was shot through the body and lung, and is noted as one of the late Billy the Kid's followers.

Louisiana Capitolian · 20 August 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Charles Day and Albert Black, two stage robbers of Western Texas, were harnessed lately. Jack Harris, one of the party made a desperate resistance and was shot through the body and left lung. Harris is one of the late lamented Billy the Kid's pet lambs.

See the clipping

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

The Saturday Review lauds Sheriff Pat Garrett for shooting "Billy the Kid" and jokingly suggests he would be suited to a post in County Galway. The item appears amid a roundup of London news and gossip.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 21 August 1881 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

THE LONDON SEASON is dead. Society is on the Continent or in Scotland, and the society papers, to fill up, are chronicling the movements of the Messrs. Irving and Toole, the actors, while one large daily, despairing of keeping public interest in its columns, has sold the right to the Alexandra Palace Company of exhibiting the last letter received from its lately-imprisoned correspondent at Merv. The Saturday Review devotes two columns of laudation to Sheriff Garrett, who shot "Billy the Kid," and thinks him exactly the man for County Galway. Commenting on the suggestion made by a New York paper that dynamite should be tried on O'Donovan-Rossa, it says that this suggestion has already been anticipated by every factious schoolboy in Great Britain.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A London letter notes the Saturday Review devoting laudatory coverage to Sheriff Garrett, who shot Billy the Kid, suggesting he would be ideal for a post in Galway County. The item is a brief aside within a wider roundup of London society and political news.

The Salt Lake Herald · 23 August 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The Saturday Review devotes two columns of laudation to Sheriff Garrett, who shot "Billy the Kid," and thinks him exactly the man for Galway County.

See the clipping

Claiborne Guardian · Homer, La.

The piece reflects on how notorious criminals like 'Billy the Kid' can still attract friends and admirers even among law-abiding people. It argues that the boldness and daring shown in committing crimes can inspire a kind of respect, even while the acts themselves are condemned.

Claiborne Guardian · 24 August 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the waters I have been wonderfully benefitted. HOWELL TATUM. It appears strange that such bold and daring criminals as "Billy the Kid," should have friends and even admirers among the class that do not themselves violate the law. Yet strange as it is, such was said to be the fact. There were those who conformed to the laws of the land, and at the same time cherished a friendship and admiration for this bloody and daring desperado. People condemn the deeds of such criminals, but at the same time the glare of courage displayed in the perpetration of their crimes, inspires a certain kind of respect and even reverence for the perpetrator.

See moreSee less

The horrible manner in which these qualities are displayed is not enough to cause many people to lose sight of what is only commendable when displayed in a way that does not tend to the subversion

See the clipping

The Daily Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash.

The item clarifies that the Chapman mentioned in an account of Billy the Kid's deeds was H.I. Chapman, a one-armed surveyor and lawyer from Pierce county known to many local readers. It notes he was killed while working for an accomplice of the young murderer known as 'the Kid.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.

Wrong

The Daily Intelligencer · 24 August 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Benedict.—Sunday Welcome.

In an account elsewhere of 'Billy, the Kid's' terrible deeds, is a mention of one Chapman, a lawyer, who was killed while working for an accomplice of that wholesale young murderer, the

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 1 other paper

A brief news digest reports that Jack Harris, described as a former companion of Billy the Kid, and twelve others were being held in jail at Austin, Texas. The item appears amid a roundup of unrelated crime stories from across the country.

Wood County Reporter · 25 August 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The federal officials in Texas have nearly broken up a gang of stage-robbers who have been very bold in their operations. Jack Harris, a former companion of Billy the Kid, and twelve others are in jail at Austin.

The coroner's jury at New Haven was in session all night taking the testimony

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Canton Advocate · Canton, S.D. · 25 August 1881

River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis.

A miscellaneous national crime digest reports that Jack Harris, described as a former companion of Billy the Kid, has been jailed in Austin along with twelve others as federal officials break up a Texas stage-robbing gang. The item is one of many brief crime notices from around the country.

River Falls Journal · 25 August 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The federal officials in Texas have nearly broken up a gang of stage-robbers who have been very bold in their operations. Jack Harris, a former companion of Billy the Kid, and twelve others are in jail at Austin.

See the clipping