As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

September 1881

12 articles

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

This item reports that Billy the Kid actually killed only eleven men, not the twenty-seven previously claimed. It wryly notes he was 'not of such industrious habits as at first reported.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The New North-West · 2 September 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Captain Paul Boynton is on his way to Fort Benton whence he will start on a voyage down the Missouri river to St. Louis, a distance of 3,580 miles.

It is now discovered that "Billy the Kid" killed only eleven men, and not twenty-seven. William was not of such industrious habits as at first reported.

See the clipping

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

A humor filler item jokes that Billy the Kid was born in New York and might have become a legislator had he stayed, noting his ambition to be considered as bad as possible. It's part of a satirical newspaper filler column mixing various quips and anecdotes.

The New North-West · 2 September 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

carefully laid away for the next.—Detroit Free Press.

On account of the unsuccessful season at the seaside resorts, the hotel proprietors there will stick to the unrevised edition.—Norristown Herald.

See moreSee less

A little girl in a London Sunday school, on being asked why God made the flowers of the field, replied: "Please, ma'am, I suppose or patterns for artificial flowers.

Letters intended for Hackensack, N. J., go to "Sackerhack," "Sock Hat," "Sara Hackett" and "Hatchet Satch." Why didn't they name the town Smithville in the first place?

Billy the Kid was born in New York. Had he remained there he might have been

See the clipping

The Arizona Sentinel · Arizona City Yuma, Ariz.

The article quotes and rebuts a San Francisco Stock Report piece that criticized Arizona businessmen for promoting mining investment despite rampant outlawry, citing Curly Bill and Billy the Kid as examples of celebrated criminals. The Arizona writer dismisses this as exaggerated 'twaddle,' arguing all new territories face similar dangers and that the press does not glorify outlaws as claimed.

The Arizona Sentinel · 3 September 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A WARNING WAIL.

recording the deeds of Curly Bill, Billy the Kid, and that sort of human wild beasts at large.

That this is a direct falsehood, no one should know better than

See the clipping

St. Landry Democrat · Opelousas, La.

A correspondent describes Pat Garrett, now a celebrity in New Mexico for killing Billy the Kid, detailing his appearance, soft voice, and modest manner. Garrett corrects exaggerated reports of the Kid's killings, saying he only knew of eleven, while towns like Las Vegas raise reward money for him.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Daily Intelligencer, 24 August 1881, The New North-West, 2 September 1881.

St. Landry Democrat · 3 September 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Dr. William H. Murray, the Supervisor of the Sixteenth Ward, is the owner of a gray horse that, at times, seems to be possessed of human reason. This horse is devoted to his master, and it would be next to impossible to steal it in the street, for it will not move after Dr. Murray has left it until he returns and gives it permission. To-day the Doctor was driving at a rapid gait down North Pearl street. When opposite the Homeopathic Hospital at Clinton Square a man, who was crossing the street, suddenly became dizzy with the heat and fell down in front of the horse. Stepping carefully over the prostrate form, the horse was suddenly stopped by the Doctor, who pulled the rein the moment he saw the man fall. There lay the man under the horse and between its fore and hind legs. In a moment the animal, apparently understanding the situation, raised itself on its hind feet, and with fore feet in the air backed over the body and away from it. The prostrated stranger arose and went away. If the horse had not been possessed of such intelligence, the stranger would have been run over and badly injured, as his head lay in line with the wheels.—Albany Times.

—The Western cyclone blows everything from the farm except the mortgage.—N. Y. Graphic.

See moreSee less

said to me this morning: "Do you know I couldn't help feeling sorry when I heard that boy was killed?" He was a splendid horseman and a dead shot, and at the time of his death was only about twenty-two years old.

The hero of the hour in New Mexico now, the king lion of the Territorial menagerie, is Patsey Garrett, the slayer of the Kid. His name is in everybody's mouth. The papers are full of his exploits and his praises. The very children in the streets stop and honor him with a curious and admiring stare as he passes. I met him yesterday in Santa Fe, and a milder-looking, gentler-spoken fellow I never saw. He is about twenty-seven years old, six feet five inches tall, and of almost willowy slenderness, with the slight tendency to a stoop in his position that is natural to one of his build. His complexion, naturally fair, is sun-tanned to a ruddy brown. His eyes are greyish brown and keen as an eagle's, and his hair and slight mustache are of a light brown tint scarcely deeper than golden. His voice is as soft as a woman's, and he rarely uses it to talk of himself. He spoke very kindly of the Kid, and, having occasion, in reply to a question, to allude to the exploit which has made him famous, simply remarked: "He was taken the night of the fourteenth of this month." I asked him if the Kid had really killed as many men as the papers report, from nineteen to twenty-six. "No," he answered, in his musical, feminine voice, "he only killed eleven that I know of." I thought one for every two years of his life was nearly enough.

Some itch having occurred in regard to the reward Garrett expected to get from the Territorial authorities, the people of the cities and towns in the Territory have gone to work to raise a subscription for him, and Las Vegas alone has already made up a purse of $1,200 in gold. If other places do as much in proportion, the fund will amount to a good many thousands.—Cor. St. Louis Globe-Democrat.

—"How delightful to enjoy the companionship for which the soul longeth," said he, as his arm naturally drifted across the back of the next chair. "Indeed! And is that companionship you speak of so feelingly anything—that I can—assist—you—to?" inquired she, with hesitating languor. "Ye-s-s. Oh, Adelaide, even now the stars seem to look down upon us with their benedictions and the comet lights up with additional glow, as if our happiness added a new ray to its luster—" "Augustus, you're just too sweet for anything, we will go to the excursion to-morrow, won't we?" But Augustus replied not. He hadn't but $1.13 in his purse and tickets for the round trip were 75 cents each.—New Haven Register.

"Billy the Kid"—Some of His Exploits.

During the early part of the present year Deputy Sheriff Pat Garrett, of Lincoln County, captured the Kid and took him to Mesilla, where he was tried and sentenced to be hanged in the town of Lincoln. He was taken to Lincoln ironed and under a strong guard. Soon after reaching the town he managed to knock Deputy Sheriff Bell in the head with his handcuffs, and before he could recover from the stunning effect of the blow the Kid seized his pistol and shot him dead. Deputy United States Marshal Robert Ohlinger, hearing the shot, came running, gun in hand, to Bell's assistance. The Kid, armed with Bell's shot-gun and pistol, saw Ohlinger coming, and coolly hailed him with, "Hello, Bob!" Ohlinger paused a second and it cost him his life; the Kid poured a charge of buckshot into his heart, killing him instantly—two murders in half a minute, The young monster then stepped out on the portico of the old house in which the dead men had been guarding him and defied the whole town. He made one man knock his irons off, and covering another with his death-dealing shot-gun, ordered him to saddle a horse that was standing in the street, walked out, mounted and galloped out of town in the presence of the whole population.

But such a career must have an end, and "Billy the Kid" was rapidly nearing the inevitable close of his blood-stained career. He had heretofore carried death with him, but death was now close after him. Deputy Sheriff Pat Garrett, with two companions, started on his trail, swearing to capture or kill him or die trying. In some way known only to himself Garrett learned that the Kid would probably visit the house of Pete Maxwell, at Fort Sumner, in Lincoln County, some time during the night of Thursday, July 14. Shortly before midnight Garrett went to Maxwell's, and had just seated himself in the dark on the side of Maxwell's bed when the door opened, and in walked the Kid. Instantly detecting, in spite of the darkness, that there was somebody in the room with Maxwell, he leveled his pistols, exclaiming, "Quien es! Quien es?" (Who are you? or Who's there?) But the delay of asking was fatal. Before the words were off his lips Pat Garrett's bullet was through his heart, and "Billy the Kid," the terror of New Mexico, lay a gasping, quivering corpse, while his life-blood dyed the dirt floor of Pete Maxwell's dark adobe hut. Eleven gory ghosts stood waiting to escort him to eternal shades.

In personal appearance the Kid was anything but a desperado or a monster. He was very small and slender, being but about five feet two inches tall, and weighing scarcely 120 pounds. He had a plain but pleasant face, with thin sharp features, blue eyes and light hair. He was calculated to make friends, and, strange as it may seem, left many who sincerely mourned his death. One of the best men of the Territory, who, though identified with the opposite faction, knew him well, said to me this morning: "Do you

See the clipping

Las Vegas Daily Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

Prisoners in the Las Vegas jail got into a fight during supper, split along American and Mexican lines. One inmate struck another with handcuffs in a style likened to Billy the Kid's methods, until the sheriff intervened.

Las Vegas Daily Gazette · 6 September 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Americans took one side and the Mexicans another. One fellow knocked the other over the head with handcuffs after the manner of Billy the Kid, and Webb punched Marino Leiba in the back with a fork. The sheriff came in and stopped their fun.

See the clipping

Eureka Daily Sentinel · Eureka, Nev.

Pat Garrett, who killed Billy the Kid, is described as a celebrated figure in New Mexico. Since he faces difficulty collecting the official reward, a public subscription has raised $1,200 for him.

Eureka Daily Sentinel · 8 September 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SLAYER OF "BILLY THE KID." Patsy Garrett, the man who killed "Billy the Kid," is quite a hero just now in New Mexico. As there is some difficulty in the way of his receiving the reward for the killing of the outlaw, a subscription has been taken up for him, which already amounts to $1,200. Patsy is described as "a young man of 27, tall, slender and agile, with brown eyes, golden hair, and a soft voice, and as he walks through the streets even the children stop to gaze at him with an admiring stare."

See the clipping

The Weekly Democratic Statesman · Austin, Tex.

The report describes a gunfight near Lampasas in which mail robber Harris was severely wounded by officers and believed likely to die. Harris recovered and was later transported to jail for safekeeping, being identified as a former right-hand man of Billy the Kid.

The Weekly Democratic Statesman · 8 September 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

"Billy the Kid."

Report of city sexton for the month of August, 1881: Total deaths, 21; white, 14; colored, 7. Age—from birth to 5 years, 10; from 5 to 20 years, 1; from 20 to 40 years, 3; from 40 to 60 years, s; from 60 to 80, 2. Of three the age is not given. Still born, 4.

See moreSee less

Respectfully, C. L. NITCSHKE, City Sexton.

See the clipping

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio

The Arizona Citizen notes that Billy the Kid, the notorious desperado, was actually born in New York, not the West. The piece argues that most Western outlaws are actually Eastern transplants who fled westward to escape law and church influence.

Perrysburg Journal · 9 September 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

committees in Cincinnati, Baltimore, Philadelphia, New Orleans, New York, Boston and Chicago, who are taking active interest in the undertaking.

The Arizona Citizen, referring to the fact that "Billy the Kid," the notorious desperado, was a native of New York, says that the desperadoes who commit their depredations in the West over which Eastern papers express such horror, are mostly Eastern graduates. Very few of them are natives of the West. This is a fact that but few people consider when they talk about the need of Christian influences in the West. Outlaws go there to get out of the reach of the laws and the church.

See moreSee less

The certificate of the action taken by

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Citizen · Tucson, Ariz

The report describes a gunfight between Jeffords and Fleres after a quarrel, in which both men exchanged shots and Jeffords was wounded in the head. After fleeing, Jeffords was confronted by Justice Holt, who ordered 'Billy the Kid' (Billy Clabrone) to disarm him before he was taken into custody.

Arizona Weekly Citizen · 11 September 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Zeckendorf's building, where he met Justice Holt and Billy Claybrone, better known as "Billy the Kid." The Judge was armed with a double-barreled shotgun and at once commanded Jeffords to halt, and commissioned "the

See the clipping

The River Press · Fort Benton, Mont.

A humor column snippet claims Billy the Kid was born in New York and jokes he might have become a legislator had he stayed. It adds that his ambition was to be considered as bad as possible, treating him as a figure of comic infamy rather than factual reporting.

The River Press · 14 September 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Billy, the Kid, was born in New York. Had he remained there he might have been a member of the last legislature. It was Billy's ambition to be considered as bad as possible.

An Ohio woman owed her hired man $320.

See the clipping

Lexington Weekly Intelligencer · Lexington, Mo. · and 1 other paper

Five prisoners at Las Vegas, New Mexico jail seized a pistol, broke their cell locks, and attacked three guards; one officer killed inmate Thomas Duffy before the others were subdued. The revolt's leader was identified as Dave Rudabaugh, described as a member of Billy the Kid's gang.

Lexington Weekly Intelligencer · 24 September 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Las Vegas, New Mexico, having secured a pistol and burst the locks off their cells, made a bloody charge on three of their guards. One of the officers blew out the brains of Thomas Duffy, and the others were soon secured. The leader of the revolt was Dave Rudenbaugh, of the gang of Billy the Kid. As our republicans friends assert that the Jamee boys grew out of the teachings of the democratic party we suppose it is no more than fair to suppose it is out of the republican party.

See moreSee less

Capt. Howgate! Now he was a pretty steep sort of a robber. They say he got away with $400,000. Is he a result of the teachings of the republican party? He can't be fastened on the democracy, and he stole more than all the train robbers put together. More than that, he got away with the swag and the harlot for whom he made himself a thief, while the poor devil of a darkey who stole $1,200 was duly nabbed, as was his colored cook, who had

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • American Citizen · Canton, Miss. · 1 October 1881

Batesville Guard · Batesville, Ark.

Five prisoners in the Las Vegas, New Mexico jail seized a pistol, broke their cell locks, and attacked three guards; one guard killed inmate Thomas Duffy before the others were subdued. The uprising's leader was identified as Dave Rudabaugh, a member of Billy the Kid's gang.

Batesville Guard · 28 September 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

volt was Dave Rudenbaugh, of the gang of Billy the Kid.

W. F. Marney, recently Secretary and acting Governor of New Mexico, died in Topeka on the 18th. He was formerly a well-known citizen of Kansas.

See the clipping