As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

August 1878

2 articles

In the story →

Arizona Silver Belt · Globe City, Ariz.

The article reports that nine people were killed, including McSween, the "Kid" Henry Antrim, and Bob Beckwith of the Sheriff's posse, in an eight-hour fight at Lincoln after which the McSween party retreated.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 848 days later.

Wrong

Arizona Silver Belt · 8 August 1878 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Lincoln County, N. M., is still in the hands of the respective factions which have so greatly disturbed the peace of that community for months past. The latest news from there is that nine persons were killed in the town of Lincoln. Eight of the McSween party including McSween and the "Kid" Henry Antrim, and Bob Beckwith of the Sheriff's posse. The number wounded is not stated. The fight is reported as having lasted eight hours. The McSween party, after the fall of their leader, retreated.

See the clipping

In the story →

Las Vegas Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

This report lists the sequence of violent deaths in the Lincoln County War from February through early June 1878, including the killings of Tunstall, Brady, Hindman, Brewer, Roberts, and McNab. It attributes the clashes to the rival McSween and Murphy-Dolan-Riley factions.

Las Vegas Gazette · 17 August 1878 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The Results of the War Thus Far.

The results of the Lincoln County War, thus far, have been most fatal. There were two parties, generally designated as the McSween party and the Murphy, Dolan & Riley party.

See moreSee less

On the 18th of February, J. H. Tunstall, alleged to be in partnership with McSween, was killed by the posse of Sheriff Brady, while serving a warrant of attachment. The posse, it is claimed, were in sympathy and were working in the interest of Dolan & Co.

On March 9th, Brewer's party of regulators, claimed to be in sympathy with McSween, killed Frank Baker, W. S. Morton and McClosky, to revenge the death of Tunstall.

On the 9th of March Tom Hill was killed and Jessie Evans wounded, while robbing an emigrant train near Tulerosa.

April 1st, Sheriff William Brady and George Hindman ambushed and killed by Brewer's party, in the town of Lincoln. Antrim, the "Kid" and Jim French, of Brewer's party, wounded.

A soldier shot and kiled, while attempting to pass a sentinel at Murphy's house.

April 5th, Andrew L. Roberts, alleged to have been present at the killing of Tunstall, shot and killed by Brewer's party, at Blazer's Mill. Roberts, however, in the fight killed Brewer, leader of the regulators, and wounded Middleton, Charles Bowdry and George Coe.

About this time John N. Copeland was appointed sheriff by county commissioners to fill the vacancy occasioned by the death of Brady.

April 29th, Brady's deputies rallied and killed Frank McNab and wounded James A. Saunders, of the regulators. A fight afterwards occurred in Lincoln, in which three of Brady's deputies were mortally wounded.

June 1st, John N. Copeland removed by the Governor, for failure to give bond, and George W. Peppin appointed.

During the first week in July two of Peppin's posse wounded and two horses killed in a fight with the regulators.

Several skirmishes and much manoeuvreing between both parties, from the 1st to the 20th of July, without important results, during which time slight engagements took place at Lincoln, San Patricio and on the Pecos, in one of which Charley Crawford, of Peppin's posse, was mortally wounded.

July 20th, a heavy battle between the sheriff's posse and McSween's party, in which the latter was killed and his house in Lincoln burned; also of that party Harry Morris, Vicente Romero and Francisco Samora were killed. Robert Beckwith, of the sheriff's posse killed.

On the 5th of August, the Indian Agency was attacked by some thirty men and Morris J. Bernstein, the clerk, who had no interest on either side, killed.

The above constitutes the causualties, up to the present time, as near as we can determine from data at hand. It is quite probable that several were killed, or died of wounds, whose names have not been reported in the papers.

To sum up briefly, and taking no account of the wounded, property destroyed and horses killed, the results are as follows:

Of those alleged to have belonged to the side of McSween, sheriff Copeland and the regulators, were killed: J. H. Tunstall, Richard Brewer, F. McNab, A. A. McSween, Henry Morris, Vicente Romero and Francisco Samora, or seven in all. Of those reported to belong to the side of Dolan & Co., and sheriffs Brady and Peppin, were killed: Sheriff Wm. Brady, Geo. Hindman, Andrew L. Roberts, Frank Baker, W. S. Morton, McClosky, Chas. Crawford, Robert Beckwith and three others mortally wounded; but names not given, or eleven in all. These, added to the soldier, Tom Hill and Bernstein, make 21 men slaughtered in the Lincoln County war.

The numbers killed on each side indicate that the fight has been as equal as desperate, while barbarism and lawlessness have marked the contest throughout.

See the clipping