Colored Citizen · Fort Scott, Kan.
The report explains the dispute over Fritz's insurance legacy, which pitted the Murphy/Dolan firm against lawyer McSwayne, leading to his arrest for embezzlement. It also describes how Tunstall's conflict with Sheriff Brady over disputed property set the stage for further violence.
Colored Citizen · 9 November 1878 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
NEW MEXICAN CIVIL WAR.
The Reign of the Mexican Desperadoes---The Bloody Pranks of the "Modocs" and "Wrestlers."
See moreSee less
[Special Correspondence of the Globe-Democrat.]
Before giving an accurate and impartial account of the troubles which have existed in this country since February last, and which have assumed national importance, your correspondent desires to furnish a brief description of this place (Fort Stanton, Lincoln county, New Mexico,) and its surroundings. Fort Stanton is situated in the beautiful valley of the Rio Bonita (or Pretty Valley), a name well deserved from the magnificent scenery presented to view. The valley is wailed in by high, peaked mountains, the principal being the White and Capitan ranges. The Bonita river winds its way in close proximity to the fort, its banks covered with a fine growth of cottonwood trees. The mountains are covered with a species of timber called pinyon, which in the eastern country is known as the spruce. The Post is laid out in the form of a square; surrounded by a large growth of cottonwood trees, resembling the weeping willow, a fine stream of cool and sparkling water flowing
AROUND THE POST.
The quarters are built of stone, well plastered, and neatly finished, both inside and out. There are stationed here two companies of cavalry and one company of the 15th Infantry, the post being commanded by Col. N. A. M. Dudley, one of the oldest officers on the frontier--a strict disciplinarian and a brave and accomplished soldier. The infantry company is commanded by Captain Thos. Blair, another old and trusty soldier. There are two tribes of Indians stationed near the post, on a Government reservation, viz: the Jicarrilla Apaches and the Mescarelo Apaches, who are very friendly at present writing, but it is difficult to say how long they may remain so. Horse thieves--whether white, Mexicans or Indians, your correspondent is unable to say--ran off a number of the Jicarrillo Indians' ponies on the night of the 12th of last month, and on the morning of the 13th Lieutenant G. W. Smith, with a detachment of the 9th cavalry, started out to recapture the stock, if possible. Nothing has been heard of him up to the present time. The troubles in this county commenced in the middle of January last in the following manner:
A firm in Lincoln known as the Murphy firm, which latterly merged into the firm of Dolan, Riley & Co., claimed that they had a mortgage on a legacy bequeathed, in the shape of an insurance policy, by a man named Fritz, formerly a partner of the Murphys. The amount left on the policy was $10,000. Dolan and a Mrs. Schoeling, the legatee, employed a lawyer named McSwayne, of some notoriety in this part of the country, to collect the above amount, which he did, at the same time placing it to his own credit in a bank in East St. Louis. On being requested to transfer the money, McSwayne flatly refused to do so, alleging as a reason that if he did the Dolan firm would gobble up the money and leave Mrs. Schoeling with nothing. Threats were of no avail, and proceedings were instituted in the latter part of January. McSwayne left Lincoln at the time, and endeavored to reach St. Louis, but was overhauled at Las Vegas, and arrested on a charge of embezzlement. He was taken from Las Vegas to Messilla, before the District Court, then in session, Judge Warren Bristol presiding, where the charges against him were sustained and a writ of attachment was levied on his property, real and personal; to the amount of about $7,000. In taking an inventory of his goods, a man named Tunstall, who had sworn in court at Messilla that he was not a partner of McSwayne's, claimed a part of the above goods, and on Mr. Brady, sheriff of the county, serving the attachment writ, Tunstall met him with abuse and threats, refusing to give up the goods. The following day Sheriff Brady sent a deputy and posse to take account of the stock, or, as it is called here, to "round it up." The deputy sheriff, Billy Matthews, on attempting to take an inventory, an employe of Dolan's, was also met with.
ABUSE AND THREATS
by Tunstall, who, under some trivial excuse, departed from the place, and managed to run off some thirty horses. So far as the above is concerned, it is admitted by both parties; but mark the conflicting testimony which here follows. Mathews' testimony is to the effect that he started after the herd of horses, and he and his followers state that on nearing them, after a four-mile chase, Tunstall, seeing the party gaining on him, turned, and met them with the contents of his revolver. The fire was immediately returned by the Sheriff's posse, and Tunstall was shot dead. The remainder of Tunstall's party escaped, Mathews gaining possession of the plunder. Tunstall's friends, on the contrary, affirm that Tunstall was cut off from the rest of his party, driven into a canyon and assassinated, without firing a shot. This occurred on the 19th of February last. On the morning of the 20th Mexicans and Americans flocked into Lincoln from the surrounding country, and took up their quarters at and about McSwayne's residence. Dolan's firm summoned in all the help possible from their ranches, and this was then the beginning of the famous Lincoln county butchery. The factions were styled at this time "the McSwayne party" and "the Dolan party." Matters remained in statu quo for twenty-four hours, when Company H, 15th Infantry, at the earnest request of some of the leading citizens of the county, was dispatched to Lincoln, which is but nine miles east of Fort Stanton. On the morning of the 22d, a partly amicable settlement was arrived at, the effect of three soldiers being left at each house as a guard having a tendency to put a quietus to the matter. The company of soldiers returned here on the evening of the 22d, leaving the guard stationed at the two houses, the followers of either party dispersing for the time being. The guard remained four days, when, McSwayne decamped with a Deputy Sheriff from Las Vegas, name unknown, asserting that his life was in danger, and that he would remain away until the ensuing term of Court at Lincoln was held, when he would appear before that Court to answer to the various charges preferred against him. Matters remained comparatively quiet, with the exception of some bushwhacking, during which one American and a Mexican were killed. On the 18th of March Mr. Brady, Sheriff of Lincoln county, formerly a Major in the New Mexican Volunteers, and in command of this post soon after the late war, was assassinated, and also a man named Hindman, his deputy. Mr. Brady was walking along the main thoroughfare of Lincoln about mid-day, when he was fired upon by a party of desperadoes posted in a corrall near by, his body being actually riddled with bullets. This happened within fifteen yards of McSwayne's residence, although it must be stated that McSwayne was absent from home at the time, being somewhere on the Picos River with the Deputy Sheriff from Las Vegas.
THE GANG OF DESPERADOES
who perpetrated this dastardly act escaped to the mountains. Within three quarters of an hour after the tragedy occurred a detachment of cavalry arrived at Plaza from Fort Stanton, and at the request of Deputy Sheriff Long the inmates of McSwayne's house, consisting of McSwayne's brother-in-law, Shields, his wife, a clerk named Wiedemann and two colored men were arrested and taken to the post, where they remained nearly a week under guard. Although strongly suspected, there being no substantial proof against them they were released. In the meantime sundry scrimmages took place between the Sheriff's posse and the desperadoes, the officers alternately taking sides the different Sheriffs were appointed by the partisans and sympathizers of either faction. After the passage of the act preventing the military taking part as a posse comitatus, affairs which had been kept in check by a wholesome dread of the military, became more serious. Reports of men being shot down in cold blood throughout the country coming in daily. Houses were broken into by both parties, women insulted and ravished and Lincoln county became a perfect hell. About the beginning of July Sheriff Peppin reinforced his posse with a large number of rather questionable characters, McSwayne doing likewise. On the 18th of July the parties came in collision at a small Mexican town called San Patricia, about twenty-eight miles east of Lincoln, when a lively skirmish took place. The Sheriff's posse, or Dolan's crowd, obtained possession of the town, only two men being wounded. McSwayne fell back to the mountains, and making a flank movement, entered Lincoln early on the following morning, and fortified himself and party in his own house, situated on the west side of the town. This party numbered ten men. He then placed a second squad of about twenty, headed by one of the most notorious men in Southern New Mexico, Doc. Scurlock, in an adobe building in the center of the town. A third squad, consisting of about sixteen men, was placed in an adobe house in the eastern part of the town. Sheriff Peppin returned that afternoon to Lincoln, and with his posse occupied the hills surrounding the town, at the same time opening a lively fusillade on the houses occupied by McSwayne's followers. During
THE HEAVY FIRING WHICH ENSUED,
one of the Sheriff's posse was badly wounded, and the army surgeon, Dr. Appel, who with Capt. Blair, 15th Infantry, volunteered to go to his assistance, was fired on from the house occupied by Scurlock and his party. Nothing daunted, however, they reached the wounded man and carried him to an ambulance, bringing him to the hospital at Fort Stanton, where he died shortly afterwards. The courage displayed by these two officers, in thus assisting a wounded stranger, continuously under fire until he was brought from the field, is well worthy of mention. The engagement was kept up without intermission until the morning of the 21st, yet, strange to relate, but two men stationed in McSwayne's house were killed, and one man, Crawford, mentioned above, dangerously wounded.
About noon on the 21st of July, General Dudley, commanding at Fort Stanton, took up a position on the outskirts of the town, for the purpose of protecting innocent women and children and such non-combatants as deserved protection. The two detached sections of McSwayne's party, under Jourlock, left the town on seeing the military approach, and the sheriff's posse immediately surrounded McSwayne's residence, abandoning their position on the outskirts, and keeping up a heavy fire on the house and its approaches, contrived in the most daring manner to fire the building. During the remainder of the day an incessant fire was kept up on both sides, the houses being barricaded, and no one except the parties interested daring to show themselves. The house being of adobe, burned slowly. McSwayne and party contrived to hold possession of their position until sunset. When driven to desperation, in twos and threes they broke for the shelter of the surrounding brush. Of the ten men composing the first squad, but four escaped. McSwayne, a man named Morris, from Missouri, and four Mexicans being killed. McSwayne killed one of the posse before he met his death. The house was completely gutted. The McSwayne faction, after the death of their leader became demoralized and scattered throughout the county; the posse also becoming broken up, the respectable portion of both parties returning to their respective abodes. The remainder organized themselves into two bands, styling themselves the "Modocs" and the "Wrestlers," and still infest the county, robbing, murdering and ravishing all before them. They have been joined by some Texans. They discriminate in no manner, until it is not safe for any man to traverse the county, as these parties shoot for the fun of seeing a man fall. The Modocs are commanded by this desperado Scurlock, and the Wrestlers by a man named Gunfer. The people throughout the county are fleeing to Lincoln and the Post for protection, leaving their crops ungathered and neglected. Not a week passes but reports come in to the effect that some one has been shot down by these parties. A proclamation has just been received at this Post by General Dudley, the commanding officer, from the President of the United States, warning all persons against these outrages.]
WHERE WILL IT END?
A copy of this proclamation was received at this Post on October 12th, by Col. Dudley, commanding, and printed copies were immediately circulated throughout Lincoln county, giving a timely warning to all persons engaged in these difficulties. What the effect may be remains to be seen. The newly-appointed Governor of New Mexico, Gen. Lew. Wallace, is expected here at any moment. What action he will take in the matter your correspondent is unable to state, but will endeavor to keep you posted on anything serious that may occur in the future.
H. W. C.