As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

July 1878

2 articles

In the story →

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The article recounts how Murphy's faction used Sheriff Brady and a posse to attach Tunstall's property, leading to Tunstall's murder; it then describes the Regulators' formation and their killing of Brady, followed by Captain Purington's illegal arrests of McSween's allies. It frames Governor Axtell as favoring Murphy's side throughout the escalating conflict.

The Sun · 14 July 1878 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

RING-RIDDEN NEW MEXICO.

GOVERNOR, JUDGE, AND DISTRICT ATTORNEY ABETTING CRIME.

See moreSee less

The Reign of Terror that Three Thieving Ex-Sutlers Brought About--Tunstall's Fate--A Town Attacked by Cutthroats.

FORT STANTON, New Mexico, June 30.--The causes of the troubles in Lincoln county in this Territory, that have excited so much interest, go back four or five years. That they originated in the operations of three men, Murphy, Dolan, and Reilly, who were working in the interests of the Santa Fé Ring, may be supposed, from the fact that the citizens of Lincoln county drew up a petition setting forth that they were the cause of the disturbance, and requesting them to leave the county, which they did before the petition was presented.

Their firm was first styled L. G. Murphy & Co., of which Murphy was the principal. They were post sutlers and contractors at Fort Stanton, and contractors for the Indian Department. In these contracts there was so much suspicion of dishonesty that the sutlership was taken away from them. Murphy and Dolan were confined in the guard house, and ordered to leave the post, Murphy in three days and Dolan in fifteen minutes. They then established themselves in business in Lincoln, about nine miles from Fort Stanton, where they despotically controlled the country for miles around. The firm name was changed to J. J. Dolan & Co., as Murphy could no longer secure a contract in his own name. They put in their bids at figures which could not honestly be made to pay. Having secured the beef contract at Fort Stanton, and continuing to fill it, it was suspected that the cattle furnished were stolen. This was confirmed beyond a doubt by an account book of theirs accidentally falling into the hands of Mr. McSween and others, containing a record of the number of cattle stolen and delivered to J. J. Dolan & Co. by Jesse Evans, Frank Baker, Tom Hill, and others, at the rate of $5 a head. Such was the style of business carried on by Murphy, Dolan, and Reilly. Many murders committed in this county have been laid to them. They controlled the country, the commercial and the political powers; in fact, at one time Murphy was a little king.

In their wicked course honest men opposed them, and these men were singled out as proper objects for persecution and vengeance. Two of these were Messrs. McSween and Tunstall. The first named was at one time the attorney of Murphy & Co., and being an honest man, he quit them. From that time they sought an opportunity to remove him from their path. Mr. Tunstall was an Englishman who had considerable means invested in Lincoln county in merchandise, cattle, and other property. He was an honest, straightforward man. In such a person Murphy & Co. saw a dangerous rival, and they determined that he too should be removed.

An opportunity occurred in which they thought they could see a way to rid themselves of both McSween and Tunstall.

Murphy had at one time a partner by the name of Fritz, who had a brother named Emil Fritz. This brother died, leaving a life insurance policy amounting to $10,000 to his sister, Mrs. Scholand. Murphy & Co. pretended to have a bill against Mrs. Scholand for merchandise amounting to $7,000, which they claimed on this policy. The policy was given into the hands of McSween for collection. Murphy & Co. made a demand on him for the money, which of course he refused, as without the consent of Mrs. Scholand they had no right whatever to it. They did not then arrest McSween, but waited until he had occasion to go East, when, to make it appear that he was running away, they had him arrested on a charge of embezzlement when about two hundred miles from home. He was thrown into prison at Las Vegas, where he was approached by parties from Murphy, Dolan, and Reilly to compromise. He refused, saying that he had committed no crime, and therefore had nothing to compromise. He was then taken to Mesilla, where an examination was held before Judge W. Bristol, a partisan of Murphy's, who practically prevented McSween from giving bonds by saying that he would not accept any not approved by District Attorney W. L. Rynerson, a bitter partisan of Murphy's. Rynerson refused to approve any and all bonds brought forward by McSween, although perfectly good, and over the amount called for.

The Deputy Sheriff, seeing how matters were, said to them:

"I see that you wish to murder this man, and I will not give him up to you until court is held."

He then returned with McSween, remaining hid in Lincoln county.

Murphy & Co. then prevailed upon Judge Bristol to issue warrants of attachment against the property of McSween & Tunstall. A posse was organized by Sheriff Brady, a tool of Murphy's, and there were placed on it the notorious thieves and murderers, Jesse Evans, Frank Baker, Tom Hill, and Rivers. After attaching the cattle of Tunstall and Richard Brewer, they started in pursuit of Tunstall, who, after surrendering himself, was brutally murdered by them with his own pistol. They then shot his horse, and crushed in the head of Tunstall with a rock. One of their victims was disposed of.

This murder created the most intense excitement. Warrants were issued by J. B. Wilson, Justice of the Peace, for the arrest of the murderers and placed in the hands of Richard Brewer and others as a constable's posse. Brewer succeeded in arresting two, who upon attempting to escape were killed. The Governor, S. B. Axtell, then arrived, and going to Murphy to ascertain the cause of the trouble, was so much enlightened that he refused to listen to the representatives of the people, Messrs. Ellis and Shields. He issued a proclamation, in which he set forth that his only desire was to preserve law and order; announcing also that J. B. Wilson was no longer Justice of the Peace.

Notwithstanding Brady and posse had murdered Mr. Tunstall, the Governor still gave him authority to act as Sheriff and the privilege of procuring as many soldiers as he wished to hunt Brewer and posse, the men who were trying to arrest the murderers of Tunstall, to the mountains.

The citizens then banded themselves together as regulators with the outspoken intention of hunting down Murphy, Dolan, Reilly, Sheriff Brady and posse, the murderers of Tunstall. They succeeded in killing the Murphy tool, Brady, in the town of Lincoln. Then Capt. Purington, commanding officer at Fort Stanton, came rushing out with a large body of soldiers, and without warrant or authority, arrested and took to Fort Stanton and confined in the guard house Messrs. McSween, Widdeman, and Shields, merely on suspicion of being concerned in the death of Brady. A citizen present protesting, in the name of the Constitution of the United States, against his illegal acts, Purington damned the Constitution. He also abused others present in language too shameful for publication. He had previously expressed, in the strongest terms, his disapprobation of Messrs. Murphy, Dolan, and Reilly, pronouncing them thieves and murderers. He was removed from the command of the post (Fort Stanton), and it is expected that he will be court martialled. As nothing could be found against McSween, Widdeman, and Shields, they were discharged.

Murphy's partisans then gathered together a band of twenty-five of the worst cutthroats and cattle thieves on the Pecos and Rio Grande rivers, and made an attack on the town of Lincoln. Frank Coe, Frank McNab, and A. Saunders were waylaid by them, McNab murdered and Saunders wounded. They fired into the houses of Ellis, McSween, and others, but fortunately harming no one. The news reaching Fort Stanton, soldiers were sent down, and the fighting stopped. Sheriff Copeland made some arrests of the Murphyites, and took them to Fort Stanton.

Several days afterward Lieut. Goodwin, a Murphy partisan, made his appearance in Lincoln, and arrested Messrs. Ellis, McSween, and Widdeman. Goodwin took all the opportunities he could to vent his spleen and spite on the prisoners, who were confined in the guard house and made to sleep on the bare floor, while the Murphyites were allowed the liberties of the post, armed.

The Governor has issued a second proclamation. After the death of Sheriff Brady, the County Commissioners appointed to the vacancy John Copeland, an honest man and one respected by the honest men of Lincoln county. The Governor removed Copeland upon the pretext that he did not file bonds for the collection of taxes. Copeland had never been notified nor asked to do this, but could have done so to treble the amount required. In his place was appointed G. H. Peppin, who participated in the murder of McNab and wounding of Saunders, and for whom the officers of the law had in their hands three warrants for three several murders.

At the instigation of Axtell and Catron, Col. Hatch, the district commander, issued orders to his troops to disarm every man in Lincoln county, which, of course, meant to disarm the people who were fighting the outlaws, and leave the friends of the new Sheriff, the outlaws, to run and harry the country as they pleased. Under these orders the officers at Fort Stanton disarm travellers, ranchmen, and everybody except the retainers of Catron.

In the face of a charge by Judge W. Bristol, and the efforts of the District Attorney, W. L. Rynerson, the grand jury of Lincoln county exonerated Mr. McSween from any dishonorable intentions in regard to the collection of the insurance money, and refused to indict him. They also rebuked the Governor for the unmanly and partisan course he took while present at Lincoln to preserve law and order. Dolan and Riley were indicted for cattle stealing, and Dolan and a number of others for the murder of Tunstall, in spite of the efforts of the court officials in their behalf. But no steps have been taken to have any of these criminals arrested.

Murphy, Dolan & Co., before taking refuge in Santa Fé, transferred their property to T. B. Catron, the United States District Attorney and Elkins's partner. The outlaws who had been in charge of the firm's cattle having been scattered the cattle began to stray. At the request of Catron, the Governor calls upon the United States troops to go after these refractory beasts, round them up, and gather them in. Forthwith orders issue from district headquarters here to Fort Stanton, and a captain, lieutenant, and forty soldiers, with a camp outfit, provision train, and five wagon loads of corn belonging to the United States, sallied forth in search of Catron's beef. I suppose they are supplied with bull whips at the expense of the Government, and I see no reason why, having rounded up the cattle, they should not be retained permanently to keep them from straggling again. It would be much more economical for the United States District Attorney, and the profits of the Ring would be enhanced.

There are not troops enough in the Territory to protect the Indian agencies against outbreaks; at least there are none to spare for that purpose. It seems they are too busy in disarming the citizens of Lincoln county--who also live in an Indian country subject to frequent outbreaks--and in herding the United States District Attorney's cattle. Let the army be increased by all means.

See the clipping

In the story →

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A Santa Fe special reports that McSween and 64 men tried to seize Lincoln from the Dolan faction, leading to a four-day battle with roughly 10,000 shots fired. The Dolan party set fire to McSween's stronghold on July 19-20, killing McSween and eight of his men along with Robert Beckwith of the Dolan side.

Daily Globe · 31 July 1878 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A NEW MEXICAN RIOT.

Desperate Fighting Between the Factions--A Large Number Killed--The Governor Inactive.

See moreSee less

[Santa Fe Special (July 28) to Inter-Ocean.]

Rumors of a desperate collision between the factions in Lincoln county have been afloat here for the last three days, and the fact of a bloody engagement having taken place is to-day confirmed in a letter received by the United States attorney of this district. The facts are that McSween, accompanied by sixty-four of his men, appeared in the town of Lincoln on the 16th inst., for the purpose of capturing the place from the Dolan party, which was assisting the sheriff in holding it. All of the women had been sent to Fort Stanton five days previously for safety in anticipation of the fight. McSween found the Dolan party as strong as his own, and well fortified in various houses, whereupon he took up his position in barricaded buildings, when an exchange of shots began. Skirmishing was still going on when the letter was written (July 20) and 10,000 shots were estimated to have been fired in the four days. On the 20th the Dolan party made a charge on McSween's quarters, and fired the building, which dislodged the occupants, and a hand to hand combat ensued, in which McSween and eight of his men were killed; also Robt. Beckwith, of the Dolan party. A number are said to have been wounded, but how many is not known. We are expecting further news hourly. McSween's party fired upon and wounded a military courier, a few days since, which is now being investigated by a board of officers at Stanton. This party recently fired into the home of the widow of the late Sheriff Brady, compelling Mrs. Brady and her children to seek protection at Stanton.

Your reporter has just seen Gov. Axtell, who says that the recent order forbidding the use of the military leaves him powerless to prevent further slaughter. Four companies of soldiers are stationed within nine miles of the bloody scene, but were not used, as they could not be, unless in violation of orders, to prevent the collision. It is even rumored that a large number of the military witnessed the fighting as mere spectators.

See the clipping