As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

December 1926

8 articles

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

A Boston probate court heard testimony in a will contest over actress Lotta Crabtree's estate, including witness recollections of old Tombstone, Arizona days. A physician's deposition vaguely recalled the Clanton boys' gunfight with the Earps and Doc Holliday, mistakenly claiming nearly everyone involved was killed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 7 December 1926 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

their wives. But in the case of Jack Crabtree, he declared, Crabtree always spoke of the woman and baby as his wife and child. "There were a few marring people in Tombstone, you know," Gilberson explained.

Mrs. Derwood, in whose care the baby was left when the mother went seeking Crabtree, began her story at the time she was the wife of Mike Killeen. Mike, she said, started shooting at her, and one of his bullets struck "Buckskin Frank" Leslie. So Buckskin Frank started shooting and he killed Mike Killeen. Then she married Buckskin Frank, but later she got a divorce.

See moreSee less

The adoption papers shown whereby Ed. Bullock, then stock raiser but formerly partner of Crabtree in the livery business ,took in the homeless baby girl and gave her his name. There was also brought in the marriage license of Lottie, Lota or Carlotta (the name appeared with all three spellings) and Robert Cockburn.

See the clipping

Winslow Daily Mail · Winslow, Ariz.

Wyatt Earp, testifying via deposition in a Boston probate case over Lotta Crabtree's estate, defended Tombstone's reputation, claiming it was less violent than Los Angeles. He recounted several killings from his days as a lawman there, including those of Mike Killeen, Marshal White, and others.

Winslow Daily Mail · 10 December 1926 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

OLD-TIME OFFICER DEFENDS NAME OF TOMBSTONE IN CRABTREE CASE

BOSTON, Mass., Dec. 9, (AP)-- zona, was defended in a deposition read in Suffolk Probate court today, by the man who "arrested pretty nearly every man that done any killing there."

The deponent was Wyatt Earp of Los Angeles, deputy sheriff and United States Marshal at Tombstone during the eighties and his testimony was introduced in support of the contention of Mrs. Carlotta Cockburn of San Gabriel, California, that she was niece of the late Lotta Crabtree and entitled to a share in the former actresses $4,000,000 estate.

See moreSee less

Looking back on the days when he enforced law on the frontier, Earp declared that witnesses who have described Tomstone as a

See the clipping

Winslow Daily Mail · Winslow, Ariz.

In a 1926 interview, Wyatt Earp downplays Tombstone's reputation for violence, claiming he could count the killings on one hand. He recounts incidents involving Curly Bill, Bradshaw, and Storms, and mentions vague memories of Jack Crabtree.

Winslow Daily Mail · 10 December 1926 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

OF TOMBSTONE IN CRABTREE CASE

BOSTON, Mass., Dec. 9, (AP)—zona, was defended in a deposition read in Suffolk Probate court today, by the man who "arrested pretty nearly every man that done any killing there."

The deponent was Wyatt Earp of Los Angeles, deputy sheriff and United States Marshal at Tombstone during the eighties and his testimony was introduced in support of the contention of Mrs. Carlotta Cockburn of San Gabriel, California, that she was niece of the late Lotta Crabtree and entitled to a share in the former actresses $4,000,000 estate.

See moreSee less

Looking back on the days when he enforced law on the frontier, Earp declared that witnesses who have described Tomstone as a

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

Wyatt Earp, giving a deposition in a Boston probate case about Lotta Crabtree's estate, defended Tombstone's reputation, claiming it was tamer than Los Angeles. He recounted several killings from his days as deputy sheriff and U.S. marshal there, including those of Mike Killeen, City Marshal White, and a man named Bradshaw.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 10 December 1926 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TOMBSTONE IS DEFENDED BY AN OLD TIMER

000,000 estate. Looking back on the days when he enforced law on the frontier, Earp declared that witnesses who have described Tombstone as a rough town

See the clipping

In the story →

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz. · and 1 other paper

An elderly Wyatt Earp disputes Tombstone's reputation for lawlessness, claiming he could count all its killings on one hand. He recounts the deaths of Mike Killeen, Marshal White, Mike Clyntyre, and Storms, before mentioning the Clanton-McLowry affair.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 10 December 1926 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TOMBSTONE IS DEFENDED BY AN OLD TIMER

BOSTON, Dec. 9.—(AP)—The good name of Tombstone, Ariz., was defended in a deposition read in Suffolk probate court today by the man who "arrested pretty nearly every man that done any killing there."

See moreSee less

The deponent was Myatt S. Earp of Los Angeles, deputy sheriff and United States marshal at Tombstone during the 80s, and his testimony was introduced in support of the contention of Mrs. Carlotta Cockburn of San Gabriel, Calif., that she was a niece of the late Lotta Crabtree and entitled to a share in the former actress' $4,000,000 estate.

Looking back on the days when he enforced law on the frontier, Earp declared that witnesses who have described Tombstone as a rough town were all wrong, and that "in its wildest days it wasn't half as bad as Los Angeles." In fact, he asserted he could count all the killings on his fingers.

"The first man killed was Mike Killeen," he began. "Then City Marshal White. He was killed by Curly Bill. I arrested him and took him to Tucson and put him in jail. Then the next man was killed by a man named Bradshaw. He killed his partner, McIntyre. Bradshaw had bought a kind of funny looking shirt, a red striped shirt, and he went out in the street, and everybody was making fun of it and saying, 'Where did you get that shirt,' and he got hot over it, and he says, 'The next man that kids about that shirt I am going to kill.'

"The next man he met was his partner, and of course he said to Bradshaw, 'Where did you get that shirt?' and Bradshaw jerked out his gun and killed him. That's three. The next man killed was Storms, and he was killed by Rufe Short. That is four, and that's all, except the Clanton-McLowry affair."

Earp said he remembered Jack Crabtree, but did not know that he was related to Lotta, the actress. He knew that Crabtree had a child, but (Continued on Page Eight)

Tombstone is Defended by an Old Timer

(Continued From Page One)

wasn't sure whether it was a boy or a girl.

Earp denied that "Doc" Halliday was a notorious character, "outside of this other faction trying to make him notorious," although "of course, he killed a man or two before he went there." There was another little fuss in which "Doc" wounded a man named Joyce and the latter's partner, Earp recalled, and then there was a fight in which Billy Clanton and two of the McLowry boys were killed and two of Earp's brothers and "Doc" were wounded.

"Wasn't one of your brothers killed?" Earp was asked.

"Not in a fight. He was assassinated—shot through the window."

A deposition by O. Gibson, mayor of Tombstone in 1925, was offered to explain common law marriage in Arizona, but was excluded on the ground that the court would take judicial notice of the laws of Arizona and that lawyers could file briefs on the question. Such parts of the deposition as referred to matters of fact were admitted. Gibson testified that assessors' records showed that Mary A. Crabtree, presumably Lotta's mother, was assessed for 14 lots of real estate in Tombstone in 1881.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me. · 10 December 1926

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

During a 1926 legal proceeding—apparently concerning an Arizona common-law marriage and inheritance dispute—Wyatt Earp gave testimony recalling the OK Corral gunfight, denying that Doc Holliday was notorious, and describing how his brother was 'assassinated, shot through a window' rather than killed in a fight. A deposition from Tombstone's 1925 mayor was also offered regarding Arizona marriage law and property records.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 10 December 1926 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

TOMBSTONE IS DEFENDED BY AN OLD TIMER

(Continued From Page One)

wasn't sure whether it was a boy or a girl.

See moreSee less

Earp denied that "Doc" Halliday was a notorious character, "outside of this other faction trying to make him notorious," although "of course, he killed a man or two before he went there." There was another little fuss in which "Doc" wounded a man named Joyce and the latter's partner, Earp recalled, and then there was a fight in which Billy Clanton and two of the McLowry boys were killed and two of Earp's brothers and "Doc" were wounded.

"Wasn't one of your brothers killed?" Earp was asked.

"Not in a fight. He was assassinated—shot through the window."

A deposition by O. Gibson, mayor of Tombstone in 1925, was offered to explain common law marriage in Arizona, but was excluded on the ground that the court would take judicial notice of the laws of Arizona and that lawyers could file briefs on the question. Such parts of the deposition as referred to matters of fact were admitted. Gibson testified that assessors' records showed that Mary A. Crabtree, presumably Lotta's mother, was assessed for 14 lots of real estate in Tombstone in 1881.

See the clipping

Imperial Valley Press · El Centro, Calif.

Wyatt Earp, 77, testified by deposition in the will contest over Lotta Crabtree's fortune, confirming he knew the Crabtrees and served as a lawman in Tombstone. He downplayed Tombstone's violent reputation, claiming fewer killings occurred there than legend suggests.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 241 days earlier.

Imperial Valley Press · 10 December 1926 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

OLD DAYS RECALLED BY EARP

s. Carlotta Cockburn of San [Gabr]iel, Cal., is contesting Lotta's [will] which disposes of a $4,000,000 [estat]e on the grounds that she is [the] daughter of Jack Crabtree, [Lotta]'s brother. She charges that [she] was abandoned in Tombstone, [Arizo]na by her parents.

[W]att Earp was deputy sheriff [in To]mbstone in the days when that [now] almost deserted town was a [city] of 25,000 persons and was [know]n as the liveliest mining camps [of th]e west.

See moreSee less

[Tra]dition of Arizona is shot [throu]gh with stories of the Earp [broth]ers and today old timers in [Tomb]stone will take the tenderfoot [to a]bandoned buildings and let [him s]tick his finger in tiny holes-- [tellin]g him, not without pride, that [this h]ole was made by a bullet from [one] of the Earp boy's guns; guns [that] tradition says barked always [on the] side of justice.

Read Disposition

[W]att Earp's disposition was read [in] court in the will contest case [no]w to say that he remembered [Jack] Crabtree and Mrs. Crabtree [when] they lived in Tombstone and [he w]as sheriff and that he knew [they h]ad a child.

[Mrs]. Cockburn maintains that she [is the] child in question. But he [said] that he knew nothing of any [fami]ly relationship between Jack [Crabt]ree and the famous Lotta.

[He] went on in his disposition, [howev]er, to tell the court that [Tombs]tone wasn't as black a place [as it] was painted in its "roarin'

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Wyatt Earp, in a deposition for a Boston probate case over Lotta Crabtree's estate, defended Tombstone's reputation and recounted several killings he witnessed or handled as lawman there in the 1880s. He named victims like Mike Killeen, City Marshal White, McIntyre, and Storms, claiming Tombstone was tamer than reputed and less violent than Los Angeles.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 10 December 1926 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Try at Crabtree Money

Boston, Dec. 9.—(AP)—The good name of Tombstone, Ariz., was defended in a deposition read in Suffolk probate court today by the man who "arrested pretty nearly every man that done any killing there."

See moreSee less

The deponent was Wyatt S. Earp of Los Angeles, deputy sheriff and United State marshal at Tombstone during the '80s, and his testimony was introduced in support of the contention of Mrs. Carlotta Cockburn of San Gabriel, Cal., that she was a niece of the late Lotta Crabtree and entitled to a share in the former actress' $4,000,000 estate.

Looking back on the days when he enforced law on the frontier, Earp declared that witnesses who have described Tombstone as a rought town were all wrong, and that in its wildest days it wasn't "half as bad as Los Angeles." In fact, he asserted he could count all the killings on his fingers.

"The first man killed was Mike Killeen," he began. "Then City Marshal White. He was killed by Curly Bill

See the clipping