The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
A 1918 feature recalls Wyatt Earp's controversial 1896 refereeing of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout, framing him as a gunfighter-turned-bodyguard who entered the ring armed. It describes how he awarded the fight to Sharkey on a disputed foul despite Fitzsimmons clearly winning.
The Milwaukee Leader · 10 October 1918 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
DAYS OF GUN PLAY IN THE ROPED ARENA HAVE ENTIRELY PASSED AWAY
EARP AN OBDURATE REFEREE.
Wyatt Earp, gambier and mankiler, with more than 20 notches on the butt of his gun, was working on the Ingleside race track, near San Francisco. From this position he was taken into the employ of a San Francisco daily newspaper, where he acted as bodyguard for the managing editor, who had been threatened by Dave Nagle, the notorious gun fighter who shot Judge Terry in California. Wyatt Earp was said to be the only man feared by Nagle, and the rumor must have been true, for during Earp's employment Nagle kept out of sight, and the editor enjoyed immunity from his bullets.
See moreSee less
His new position brought Earp into prominence. So when Tom Sharkey was matched with Fitzsimmons he was secured to referee the bout.
On the night of the fight when Earp climbed into the ring the arc lights shone on the butt of a huge six-shooter protruding from beneath his coat tails. Civilized San Francisco had long passed the era of coat tail shooting irons. A policeman followed Earp into the ring and after a long argument induced him to part with his artillery.
The fight went on. Fitzsimmons battled Sharkey to a pulp and finished him with a blow that was unquestionably fair. But Wyatt Earp wasn't in the ring to see Sharkey lose. He immidiately gave the fight, with the $10,000 purse to Sharkey on a "foul."
Fitzsimmons was furious. But immediately after the affair Earp regained his gun and fists were at a discount. Fitz had no chance for personal revenge.
Now comes the odd part of the whole affair.
Fitzsimmons went up to Carson, Nev., to train for his championship battle with James J. Corbett.
Carson became the mecca of the sporting world. Lovers of the fighting