As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

December 1918

2 articles

The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.

This piece marks the 22nd anniversary of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout in San Francisco, where referee Wyatt Earp stopped the fight and awarded victory to Sharkey on a foul. Many spectators disputed that any foul had occurred, but Earp's ruling stood and became the official record of Fitzsimmons' first defeat.

The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 2 December 1918 · page 4

ANNrVERSARY OF FITZSIMMONS' FIRST DEFEAT California fans will never again witness sueh A rnntAOf nf mio-iliatl. &ladiators ag waB staged ln lSan Bran. cisco just 22 years ago today, Dec.

See the clipping

El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.

A 1918 'on this date' column recounts the 1896 Sharkey-Fitzsimmons heavyweight fight, in which Fitzsimmons was dominating until referee Wyatt Earp stopped the bout and awarded victory to Sharkey on a foul. The report notes many spectators believed no foul had occurred, yet the official record still counts it as Fitzsimmons's first defeat.

El Paso Herald · 2 December 1918 · page 9

FITZSIMMONS'S FIRST DEFEAT.

would be forced to meet the victor. Tbe purse was $10,000. and both men were so supremely confident that they agreed to a wtnner-taice-au distribu tion. Freckled Fritz also had an unbro ken string of victories, save for that fake fight In Australia, when he laid i ?-7,n,to-Jlm HalL Later he stopped Hall In four rounds at' New Orleans. After his fight with Dan Creedon. an other Australian, in the Crescent City, in 1S91. Fltx announced his entrance into the heavyweight class, as a com petitor for the title. He started pro ceedings by putting Peter Maber to le.ep in the first round at Lacgtry, Texas, early in 189S.

See moreSee less

Then came the decisive battle with Sharkey and Ruby Bob lost. For eight rounds Fltxslmmona bombarded the big sailor fore and aft. Although Tom was not lacking in cleverness, he was only a punching barfor the nimble Bob. Flti was already doping out schemes for investing that $10.000, ; while sending the sailor sprawling with sledgehammer blows, when the' referee, Wyatt Earp. stopped the! slaughter and awarded the victory to ! Sharkey on a foul. A lot of people 1 present, gifted with good eyesight, openly declared that there wasn't any foul, but the referee said there was, and that settled it. and the records show the result as Fltz's first defeat, although he won fair enough.

See the clipping