As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

June 1918

1 article

The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.

A sportsman reminisces about the 1896 Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout in San Francisco, recalling that Wyatt Earp served as referee while armed with two guns. He describes Earp awarding the fight to Sharkey on a disputed foul claim despite Fitzsimmons dominating the bout.

The Milwaukee Leader · 4 June 1918 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

NATIONAL LEAGUE. Chicago, 5; Boston, 3. Pittsburgh, 3; New York, 2. St. Louis, 15; Brooklyn, 12 (12 innings). Philadelphia-Cincinnati, no game.

NAGER HERE AS LET, THE CHAMPION

See moreSee less

McCoy was fast on his feet, too, but not as shifty as Jim, and besides the Kid was a middle weight and not a heavy weight."

Talk of old fights, etc., brought up the old story about the match between Bob Fitzsimmons and Tom Sharkey at San Francisco.

"It was in December, 1896, that these famous fighters met," said Mr. Flemen, "for I was there and helped handle the affair. Wyatt Earp, well known as a sporting man around the coast, was referee. It was at the old Mechanics' pavilion and when Earp jumped into the ring he had two guns in his hip pockets, which we relieved him of. Poor old Fitz had Sharkey beaten badly, despite the fouls committed by the sailor man, but Earp refused to allow anything. Then when it was seen that Sharkey was about beaten in the eighth round the referee claimed Fitz had fouled Tom, when he went down, and awarded the fight to Sharkey. There was an uproar, but it did poor Fitz no good. They spirited Sharkey away and refused to let a doctor examine him. Fitz sued the club for his money, but never got a cent out of the affair. It was a hard deal to hand a fellow and old Bob got all the worst of it. He proved that later when he knocked Sharkey out in two rounds at Coney Island in August, 1900. I always considered Fitzsimmons one of the greatest fighters that ever lived."

See the clipping