As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

September 1897

7 articles

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The article discusses the Western practice of appointing former outlaws and bandits to law-enforcement positions, citing mining companies and towns that hired notorious criminals as a 'cure' for crime. It cites Tombstone's appointment of one of the 'notorious and feared' Earp brothers as town marshal as an example of this questionable practice.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 4 September 1897 · page 10

Dienst. Stadtgemeinden folgten bald diesem „erbaulichen" Beispiel. So schaffte sich Tombstone als StadtMarschall einen der berüchtigten und gesürchteten Gebrüder Earp an. Ein anderes Städtchen setzte einen der

See the clipping

The Robesonian · Lumberton, N.C.

A Denver dispatch reprinted in a 1897 newspaper claims only Wyatt Earp and Bat Masterson remain alive from a famous group of Old West 'killers,' listing fabricated exploits of Morgan Earp, the Allison brothers, and others in Tombstone and Durango gunfights. The account blends garbled names and invented anecdotes, including a confused story about a marshal called 'Nobo Hyatt' in Durango.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Robesonian · 8 September 1897 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

SHOOTERS OUT WEST NEARLY GONE!

Denver Dispatch. The discovery of gold in the Klondike region may give a new lease of life to the legitimate bad man. In the last decade the ranks of the bad men have become so thinned to-day there are not more than half a dozen representatives of the type made familiar by Bret Harte in his tales of the Argonauts. Of the famous coterie of "killers" who made life lively twelve years ago in the Southwest but two remain—Wyatt Earp and the renowned Bat Masterson. They belong to a widely known group.

See moreSee less

It consisted of Morgan and Wyatt Earp, "Doc" Halliday, Bob, Phil and Jim Allison, Sam Cutts, Nobe Hyatt and Bat Masterson. Each man was responsible for the deaths of more than a score of his fellow beings, yet the killings were all done on the side of law and order or in self defense. Bat Masterson was marshal of Dodge City, Kan.; Morgan Earp of Tombstone, Ariz., and Bob Allison, of Tucson, and twelve years ago it was no sinecure to be marshal of a city in the Southwest The three Allison brothers were famous fighters. Bob Allison lost his life while helping Morgan Earp in his fight

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A Los Angeles Herald feature profiling famous people joining the Klondike gold rush describes Wyatt Earp as the notorious gunfighter who refereed the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight and controversially awarded it to Sharkey on a foul. It claims he will bring money to Dawson City to run gambling games, citing his reputation as an expert faro dealer.

The Herald · 12 September 1897 · page 17 · transcribed from the page image

in front of the police headquarters. WYATT EARP, Tombstone, Arizona. Earp is the best known as the notorious gun fighter who refereed the Sharkey Fitzsimmons fight and gave the fight to Sharkey on an alleged foul. He will carry enough money to Dawson

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report describes motion-picture footage of the March 1897 Corbett–Fitzsimmons heavyweight title fight, detailing the solar plexus punch and Corbett's eventual 14th-round knockout. It notes that after Fitzsimmons won, a riot nearly broke out, quelled by figures including Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson, and Pinkerton agents.

The Indianapolis Journal · 12 September 1897 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

prise which made the perpetuation of the "battle of the century" a possibility, may be gleaned from the fact that these veriscope pictures, and there are 2 1-3 miles of them, show absolutely everything that happened in the ring at Carson City. They are so life-like that the perspiration on the bodies of these two gladiators gleams on shoulders and biceps like Kimberley gems in the southern sun. This begins to be noticeable in the second round. It is rarely that horror is ever depicted so intensely as in the pictures of Corbett, taken after the lanky one from Cornwall found lodgement for his hammer-like fist on Corbett's solar plexus.

See moreSee less

Corbett falls to his knee, with his agonized and pain-racked face full in the focus of the camera. He realizes that in that one left-handed punch, money, glory, fame, adoration and adulation are divorced from him forever. It would have been eminently merciful if that cruel left had forced its way through to a point some twenty-four inches above the place where it landed, for had it gone to the jaw it would have brought with it unconsciousness, and thus would have humanely saved the pompadoured champion the ordeal of hearing himself counted out. The projected pictures show Corbett in agony of despair, conscious of his waning fortunes, but unable to circumvent the condition of affairs. After the solar plexus blow is landed the Californian slowly but surely falls to his hands and knees, and, falling, receives what appears to be a second blow from Fitzsimmons's left, which gave rise and apparent justification to the claim of foul set up by Delany before his principal had yet been counted out. Despite press reports to the contrary, it was Fitzsimmons's fight after the sixth round. The handsome Californian, with a

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

This anecdotal piece describes how mining companies and towns in Arizona hired reputed gunmen and outlaws as guards and marshals for their skill with firearms. It recounts that Tombstone once employed one of the Earp brothers as city marshal, known for his quick-draw technique, alongside a tall tale about another hired gunfighter.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Der Deutsche Correspondent, 4 September 1897, The Robesonian, 8 September 1897.

The Saint Paul Globe · 12 September 1897 · page 18 · transcribed from the page image

Handy With Their Guns. It became the fashion, years ago, for mining companies and other concerns which handle large sums of money in Arizona to employ the worst of the road agents to act as watchmen at high wages. Thus one of the most prosperous copper companies hires, at a very high salary, a fellow who is said to have eighteen murders on his conscience and yet is a most faithful and trustworthy guardian of the property under his charge. Towns followed the example. Tombstone had for a long time in its employ as city marshal one of the brothers Earp, each of whom always fired with his

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A newspaper roundup of notable people heading to the Klondike gold fields includes Wyatt Earp of Tombstone, described as a notorious gunfighter who refereed the controversial Sharkey-Fitzsimmons boxing match. The report claims he plans to run faro and other gambling games in Dawson City, calling him the world's most expert faro dealer.

The Saint Paul Globe · 12 September 1897 · page 25 · transcribed from the page image

among the natives. Mrs. Grace C. Davids, Lexington, Ky.—Mrs. Davids was formerly well known throughout the East as the leader of the New York Band of Mercy. Recently she has turned her attention to seeing that animals are properly treated, becoming a sort of a feminine Henry Berg. She created a sensation at her home in Kentucky, not long ago, by dumping a cartload of dead dogs that the city officials had refused to dispose of in front of police headquarters. Wyatt Earp, Tombstone, Ariz.—Earp is best known as the notorious gun-fighter who refereed the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, and gave the fight to Sharkey on an alleged foul. He will carry enough money to Dawson City

See the clipping

The Pioche Weekly Record · Pioche, Nev.

Boxer Fitzsimmons refuses a bout with Sharkey, saying he already beat him fairly only to be robbed of the decision and purse by a group including Groom, Gibbs, Lynch, Sharkey, and Earp. He declines promoter Groom's new offer, citing distrust of that combination.

The Pioche Weekly Record · 22 September 1897 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Rejected By Fitzsimmons. Ashbury Park. — Fitzsimmons was seen regarding Groom's offer of $17,000 for a fight with Sharkey before the National Athletic Club of San Francisco. The champion said that in the first place he would have nothing to do with Sharkey. He had already beaten him fairly and squarely. He had been robbed of the decision and the purse by Groom, Gibbs, Lynch, Sharkey and Earp, and was done with Sharkey. "I am not sore on San Francisco," continued the

See the clipping