As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

October 1897

8 articles

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

At a 1897 Dixon-Smith boxing match, the crowd hissed and jeered when a future Sharkey bout was announced, recalling the notorious Sharkey-Examiner-Earp affair. This shows the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey referee scandal involving Wyatt Earp was still infamous over a year later.

The San Francisco Call · 5 October 1897 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

through the ropes. The crowd in attendance at this fight was evidently thoroughly on to the matter of fakes, for when the announcement was made that a fight had been arranged between Tom Sharkey and Joe Goddard, to be pulled off in November, there was a recollection of the infamous Sharkey-Examiner-Earp combination, and the hall resounded with hisses. Voices were heard condemning the proposed go, and the name of the yellow journal was frequently mentioned in connection with the past exploit, and each time Sharkey's name was mentioned or whenever he was seen there was a hiss,

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Boxing managers and referees discuss upcoming bouts, including a proposed Goddard-Sharkey fight. Sportswriters sarcastically ask if Earp would referee, alluding to his notorious reputation from an earlier scandal.

The San Francisco Call · 8 October 1897 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

AFTER WALCOTT

terms offered by the club to fight Tom Sharkey in this city in November.

Dan Lynch, who is the manager and backer of Sharkey, was very well pleased with the news and said that he will back Sharkey for any amount to whip Goddard.

See moreSee less

When the sports about town heard the news they smiled and asked "if Earp would referee the match." Of course the only reply to questions of this kind was that if Earp could not be induced to act the third man of the old combination may be asked to select some other one of his friends from Arizona, as a first-class referee must be had to pass judgment on a battle of this kind, and such a man would be hard to find in this city, unless the member who is at present in the East will return in time to appoint one of his body-guard to fill such an important position.

It is thought that the betting will be 5 to 1, with Sharkey on the long end.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Wyatt Earp and his wife, who had traveled north on the Rosalie in September, returned south on the City of Seattle. The report states he intends to make a brief trip to San Francisco before heading back north to build a sawmill at Lake Bennett to produce lumber and boats for the spring Yukon rush.

The San Francisco Call · 11 October 1897 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Wyatt Earp and wife, who went north on the Rosalie September 21, returned on the City of Seattle. Mrs. Earp will make a flying trip to San Francisco and return north as soon as possible.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

A newspaper passenger list reports that the steamer Seattle made a fast trip from Skagway/Alaska, carrying miners returning from the Klondike with gold and money. Among the passengers listed are Wyatt Earp and his wife, who plan to leave for San Francisco, with Earp proposing to establish a sawmill at Lake Lindermann next year.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 11 October 1897 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

$28,000. Among the Seattle's passengers were Wyatt Earp and wife. Mr. Earp will leave today for San Francisco. He proposes to establish a sawmill at Lake Linderman next year.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

A newspaper column reprints a long list of guest or visitor names, among which appear 'Wyatt Earp' and 'Mrs. Earp.' No further detail is given about them; the list is followed by an unrelated human-interest story about a boy named Jimmy Brennan.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 11 October 1897 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

George Boonds.

Mrs. Boonds.

See moreSee less

Wm. Hooper.

Wyatt Earp.

Mrs. Earp.

W. Winn.

Morris Rheinstine.

Pearl Davenport.

B. Dolan.

W. Butler.

R. Thomas.

P. Quirck.

W. H. Ballmon.

C. Woods.

W. W. Wingard.

G. Apstrom.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The passage collects numerous quoted opinions from San Francisco sporting figures harshly criticizing boxer Tom Sharkey, calling him a fraud who faked his loss to Fitzsimmons and predicting his upcoming fight with Goddard will be worthless. One quip references Wyatt Earp as the only referee who could make Sharkey fight honestly, alluding to Earp's controversial refereeing of the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout.

The San Francisco Call · 13 October 1897 · page 5

When President Andy Johnson was swinging around the circle with Secretary ! William H. Seward he was asked in Phil- \ adelphia, 'What about Forney?" "Why," answered Johnson, "should I waste ammunition on dead ducks?" The same pertinent remark applies to ' Sharkey. Why should any ons waste j ammumtiou on such <t "dead duck" as 1 Sha-kej*, particularly people who have bad the experience of the light he gave in i this city witti Fitzsiminons? The general opinion of those who have ', had a chance to properly judge the ex- > sailor's capabilities i* that Sharkey would have considerable difficulty in whipping his own shadow.

See moreSee less

Surne of these opinions are appended. James Markland— Sharkey is a dead knocker. He couldn't whip anything, not even his own reflection. Sharkey in his right with FHzsimmons made a cow ardly exhibition. Tue sailor went to the floor and simulated pain. Mars you, this was done when Miarkev was going. Fight? He is incapable of fighting and he would either run or lie down at the lea^t provocation. Why, that man Shai key is incapable of whit ping anybody. There never was a bigger fraud than SharKey's fight with Fitz*immon§. Ihe sailor went down and out, and now he rolled about ! It was a great fake. Lloyd Eaton — If Shnrkev tiguts there will be notjouy present. Thai man Shar key ia a In. st. l>iiiy Cieary, a permanent member of the San Francisco Atnlefc CJub — Every body is dead against th.s Suariey-God dard tight. Sharkey is too much of a faker. I wouldn't go across the street to »cc Sharkey fight. That man tharkey can't light. He is a faker. Bert Wymnn of San Rafael— l have al ways paid $o for a seat to witness a pu gilistic contest in San Francisco. I wouldn't pay five cents to see Sharkey and Goddard. I beiieve that man 1-narkey to be a faker. He would lie down if he saw any money in it. Juhn Dennis, Postal Telegraph — Shar key i<- a despicable scoundrel so lar as the ring is i o;;C2rned. He couldn't fight a feather unless Wyatt Earp refereed tne conteft. .Sharkev is no good. CKio Hill of J. J. O'Brien— Goddard and Choynski would draw thrfe times the crowd that Godd«r<i and Sharkey could draw. That man S larkey is a f.ker. Pilchard Price — 1 never heard one good word it) favor of Sharkey sines the Fitz timmons light. Kichar<l> Evans of Moraghan oyster dealers — If the Knickerbocker people pull tt<.* fight off they irill starve Jike the poor fellows in the Klondike. Sharkey can't figh . James McEiroy— There would be no naval review in connection with a mill between Sharkey and Goddard. Sharked can't fight He :a a faker. John Wilson of the Fire Department — Goddmrd can lick Sharkey. Sharkey i« a laker. Billy Lewis, exponent of honest sport— Bbarkey in a fake fighter. Charles Deitz of A. C. Deitz <fc Co., Front s.reet— police forctshould stop the ignt witli a gun. It is the only w»y of preventing Kharkey from goin X down. Oeor e Iteese— Sliarkey wiil eet the money, no matter wh.cli way the battle goes. He is an nu:-and*oot faker.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

A newspaper's hotel arrivals column for the Occidental Hotel lists 'Wyatt Earp and wife, San Francisco' among dozens of other guests. The entry is a routine travel notice with no further detail about his activities or purpose.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 14 October 1897 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

HOTEL ARRIVALS.

THE OCCIDENTAL.

See moreSee less

Wyatt Earp and wife, San Francisco.

D. G. Rueane, DeWato.

Mrs. P. P. Ross, San Francisco.

Dr. Wm. H. Chase, New York.

F. H. Brooks, Port Blakeley.

See the clipping

The Owosso Times · Owosso, Mich.

The item reports that boxers Goddard and Sharkey have been matched for a bout, noting public skepticism due to ties between the promoting club and Sharkey's manager. It jokes that if Wyatt Earp served as referee, the odds would be 100 to 1, alluding to his tainted reputation as a boxing official.

The Owosso Times · 29 October 1897 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Sharkey, Goddard and Earp. Goddard and Sharkey are matched, but just how the public will take to the proposition remains to be seen. There will undoubtedly be a lack of confidence, especially as the fight is to come off before a club in which Danny Lynch, the manager of Sharkey, is one of the four partners. Goddard and Sharkey remind one of the two locomotives that were sent crashing into each other recently in an exhibition just to see what the effect would be. It would indeed be a fight between two battering rams, where Sharkey would likely prove the winner. With Wyatt Earp as referee the odds easily would be 100 to 1.—San Francisco Chronicle.

See the clipping