As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

October 1905

7 articles

Washington Standard · Olympia, Wash.

The Cleveland Plain Dealer recalls that Seward's $7,200,000 Alaska purchase was once mocked as a wasteful gamble, but now yields enormous returns through gold production exceeding $21,000,000 this year alone. It also notes Alaskan settlers' frustration at being denied full territorial government, with some even threatening secession to Canada.

Washington Standard · 6 October 1905 · page 1

BIG DIVIDENDS FROM ALASKA. Clcvclttud Plain Dealer. When Secretary Seward paid $7,200,- 000 for what was generally considered the waste Arctic region of Alaska, and had great difficulty in justifying his actiou in thus " buying a pig in a poke," oven far-seeing Americana could have had no idea that in less than forty years tho then lightly regarded bargain would be paying annual divi dends of 300 per cent, on the invest ment. This year Alaska and the Klondike will have a gold output of over sf2l,- 000,000, batwecu three and four mil lions more than last year's product; and, as tho New York Evening Mail, which printß the figures, points out, the Klondike region and all gold fields across the line in British territory are as much a part of the United States " for every purpose of finance or com merce" as if they had been included in the Seward purchase.

See moreSee less

And gold is only one source of Alaska's wealth, the territory having showu possibili ties, even in the way of agriculture, undreamed of ten years ago. This vast and rich territory, with its great and growing permanent popula tion of enterprising and pure-blooded Americans, has been treated in rather shabby fashion by the Washington Government, which has turned a deaf ear to its appeals for recognition in the shape of a full-fledged Territorial government. So resentful are many of Alaska's people that a mass meeting recently demanded secession from the United States and annexation to Can ada. This, of course, was the action of extremists and intended merely for effect, but the next session of Congress should not withhold a Territorial gov ernment from a section of tho country which is better fitted even for State hood than half the existing Territories and at least one State.

See the clipping

The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C.

The paper repeats its earlier claim that Seward's purchase of Alaska was actually a secret way to pay Russia back for staging naval demonstrations during the Civil War. It credits Simon Cameron with suggesting the Alaska sale as a cover story to disguise this diplomatic reimbursement.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The News & Observer · 14 October 1905 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

RUSSIA'S FRIENDSHIP WAS NOT UNSELFISH.

Some weeks ago, referring to the extravagant praise of Russia's unselfishness, made by Colonel George Harvey at a banquet given by him to M. Witte, this paper gave in some detail the story of how the United States came to buy Alaska. The story was, in brief, this: During the War Between the States, Mr. Seward felt the need of making a demonstration to other powers that the Russian Government was in sympathy with Mr. Lincoln's administration. He, therefore, arranged with the Russian Ambassador that the Russian navy should make a demonsration in American waters, on both the Pacific and Atlantic coast, the United States Government agreeing to pay the cost of such demonstration. All the world knows that the Russian navy did make a demonstration in American waters and that it profoundly impressed the whole world and helped to cut off all hope of recognition by other powers of the Southern Confederacy. Who believes that Russia was doing this great service from any altruistic friendship? After the war, Russia presented the bill for making the naval demonstration. It was pretty steep, but the fact did not trouble the administration. The only question was: "How can we pay it?" It would never do to make a direct appropriation of a certain sum "to remimburse Russia for making a naval demonstration to help the United States Government during the War Between the States." Neither country could afford that. The diplomats were in great perplexity and could not find a way to pay the money without exposing the diplomatic secret.

See moreSee less

In that emergency Mr. Simon Cameron was appealed to, and he suggested that, as neither Russia nor the United States cared a fig for Alaska, that the United States buy it from Russia at a price that would reimburse Russia for the money expended and enough more to cover up the transaction. That suggestion was eagerly seized upon by the Russian Ambassador and the Secretary of State, and that course was followed. That publication in The News and Observer seems to have attracted wide attention as the following editorial from the Louisville Courier-Jouranl shows:

"An Open Secret."

"Mistah George Harvey hab suttingly got Mistah Josephus Danl's whar his ha'r am short," or words to that effect. Yet, the subject being historic, perhaps we should approach it with greater dignity. Said the Raleigh, N. C., News and Observer, of which Mr. Daniels is the editor:

"'Mr. Harvey may be right in saying that the mission of the Russian navy that made a demonstration in American waters 'bore no taint of selfishness,' but it is an open secret that Mr. Seward agreed to pay Russia the cost of such naval demonstration, and when no legal way was found to make payment, made the purchase of Alaska--not valued by either country--the pretext for paying Russia the cost of its naval demonstration, which, we are assured, 'bore no taint of selfishness.'"

"This is a serious allegation. If the editor of The News and Observer has not some documentary evidence to support it, the editor of Harper's Weekly has the right to demand it, not as an 'open secret,' as Mr. Daniels described it, but as 'a concealed myth.' Meanwhile, Harper's Weekly recalls this chapter of interesting history:

"'In his 'Life of Seward,' Mr. Bancroft says that the proposal to purchase Alaska was considered by the State Department as early as 1859, and, according to tradition, as far back as President Polk's time. The movement which ultimately resulted in the transfer had its origin on the Pacific slope in 1866, when the Legislature of Washington Territory petitioned President Johnson to obtain such concessions from the Russian Government as would enable American fishing vessels to visit ports and obtain fuel and provisions. Seward directed Cassius M. Clay, our Minister to St. Petersburg, to open negotiations, and in February, 1867, the Archduke Constantine handed to Stoeckl the Russian Minister to Washington, a map with the lines of a cession which the Czar was willing to make. On the evening of March 29 the treaty was made by Seward and Stoeckl at the former's house.

"The price ($7,200,000) was practically fixed by Seward, and was not paid till a year later. It was never regarded as adequate compensation, but rather as an honorarium. That it was not excessive is evidenced by the fact that in a single year our government's receipts from the seal industry alone exceeded $12,000,000. Russia's chief motive undoubtedly was to create an effective counterpoise to Great Britain's Pacific possessions, but the accomplishment was none the less advantageous to us for that reason, and in the business part of the transaction her attitude was eminently high-minded and creditable. The unanimity of sentiment in this country is clearly demonstrated by the fact that only two votes were cast in the Senate against the confirmation of the treaty.

"We make no question that the natural and proper gratitude felt by our people toward Russia at that time because of her refusal to become a party to Napoleon's duplicity and her manifestation of friendliness in dispatching fleets to New York and San Francisco enhanced materially the desire in this country to facilitate the Alaskan negotiations without unseemly haggling, but that is all. If there be any evidence of an explicit agreement on the part of Secretary Seward to pay for the support of those fleets we should like to see it. Even so, it is obvious that Russia was satisfied with very slight security, because she must have recognized the unlikelihood of getting anything, as indeed she did not get anything except the privilege of selling to us a vast territory for a mere pittance. Nor is there record of any demand for her hire or complaint because she did not get it.'"

"Josephus Daniels, the editor of The Raleigh News and Observer, is a gentleman of very high character and

See the clipping

The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C.

The report revives an old controversy claiming Seward's purchase of Alaska was really a disguised way to reimburse Russia for its Civil War-era naval demonstration in American waters, calling it an 'open secret.' Harper's Weekly pushes back, demanding documentary proof and recounting the standard Bancroft account of the 1867 treaty negotiations.

The News & Observer · 14 October 1905 · page 4

UNSELFISH

greater dignity. Said the Raleigh. N. C., News and Observer, of which Mr. Daniels is the editor: " ’Mr. Harvey may be right in saying that the mission of the Russian navy that made a de monstration in American waters ‘bore no taint of selfishness.’ but it is an open secret that Mr. Seward agreed to pay Russia me cost of such naval demonstration, and when no 1 egal way was found to make payment, made the purchase of Alaska—not valued by either country —the pretext for paying Russia the cost of its naval demonstration, which, \fre are as sured, ‘bore no taint of selfish ness.’ ” “This is a serious allegation.

See moreSee less

16 the editor of The News and Observer has not some documentary evidence! to support it, the editor of Harper's Weekly has the right to demand it. not as an ‘open secret.’ as Mr. Daniels described it. but as ‘a concealed myth.' Meanwhile, Harper’s Weekly recalls this chapter of interesting history: “ 'ln his 'Life of Seward,’ Mr. Bancroft says that the proposal to purchase Alaska was consid ered by the State Department as early as 185 ft. and. according to tradition, as far back as President Polk's time. The movement which ultimately resulted in the transfer had its origin on the Pacific slope in 1866, when the Legislature •of Washington Ter ritory petitioned President John son to obtain such concessions from the Russian Government as would enable American fishing vessels to visit ports and obtain fuel and provisions. Seward di- . ‘ rected 'Cassius M. Clay, our Min ister to St. Petersburg, to open '...negotiations, and in February. ' 1867.” the AfeHdvrke Constantine handed to Stoeckl the Russian Minister to Washington, a map with the lines of a cession which the Czar was willing to make. On the evening of March 2ft the treaty was made by Seward and Stoeckl at the former’s house. “The price ($7,200,000) was practically fixed by Seward, and was not paid till a year later. It

See the clipping

The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C.

This piece debates whether Russia's sale of Alaska was motivated by genuine friendship toward the U.S. or strategic calculation against Britain, and questions the unproven claim that Seward secretly agreed to pay for Russian naval fleets sent during the Civil War. It cites near-unanimous Senate approval of the treaty and frames the fleet-payment story as unverified rumor.

The News & Observer · 14 October 1905 · page 4

editor of the Presbyterian Standard, was unanimously elected as mederator. it was a deserved honor. Dr. McKel way has made the organ of the Pres byterian church one of the ablest re ligious journals in the South: he was a pioneer deader in the temperance crusade arid’ lifts' “done the Static some service*’ by his aggressive and affective efforts to lessen drupkenness and the evils of the saloon and saloon politics: and in other ways has come to be one of the most useful leaders for civic righteousness in North Carolina.

See moreSee less

The President will stop at Lexing ton two minutes. Who is to get the glory for getting Teddy to change his mind? The Greensboro Radical sheet says Senator Butler and the Washing ton correspondent of that paper per formed that wonderful feat. The Charlotte Observer gives the glory to Judge Pritchard. Which is right? This important matter should be sub mitted to Spencer Blackburn and G. Sam. Bradshaw as arbitrators in order to prevent unpleasantness. Otherwise it may develop into another case of "Who Struck Billy Patterson?" Mr. Samuel Spencer is up in New treaty. Jersey making sneeches against reg ulating rates by the government When the brag railroad spell-binder has to go to New Jersey to stem the tide against the greed of the transpor tation monopoly it shows that there is a ground-swell for this just legisla tion. When Jerseyites fail to hurrah for the monopolies, there's little ground left for them to do as they please and charge what they please with impunity. That was a high compliment to • 'apt. Matt Manly, of New Bern, in being tendered the position of chief disbursing Officer of the Panama fatal Commission. His acceptance would have been guarantee of ellia civilly and honesty. The Atlantic and North Carolina is to he congratu laled that he remains with it and his many friends will rejoice that he is to stay in North Carolina. great accomplishments. Though yet a young man, he has passed a part of his life at Washington, both as a news paper correspondent and a trusted of ficer of the Government. He may have something up his sleeve as to Seward, Russia and Alaska. If he has \v£ shall be glad to see it. because we have uever taken any stock in the conceit that Russia was an unselfish friend of the United States during the Sectional War. In this, despite how ever the story that Seward agreed to pay the expenses of the Russian naval demonstration, and that the Alaska purchase furnished the way out of it, seems to u§ a little fishy. It is up to you, Brother Daniels, up to you!’’ It is not to be expected that the secrets of the Government find a place in State papers open to the public; and therefore what happened with regard to the purchase of Alaska has been re ferred to as an “open secret,” there being no record of it. It was, per haps, somewhat similar to the in structions of General Jackson that got him into trouble about his Florida action, and which eventually led by his breach with Calhoun. In the same way it is said that General R. M. Saunders had directions from the President of the United States to pur chase Cuba, but the State Department has no record of those instructions, although it suggests that they might have been written by the President with his own hand and not recorded in the Department. Some years ago a member of Con gress from North Carolina, being on the committee that had some matters relating to Alaska under considera tion. was told by a colleague from Pennsylvania of this “open secret.” It was to this effect: that sometime, after the demonstrations made by Rus sia, that country presented a claim for the expenditure. Mr. Seward said that the claim ought to be paid, but could not be for the United States Government had no secret fund that could be used that way; and that this transaction was a matter involving diplomacy and that it would not do to make public, and that therefore appli cation would not be made to Congress for an appropriation to cover the pay ment. Mr. Seward and the other members of the Cabinet were much troubled at Uie situation, when Simon Cameron made the suggestion that as Alaska was of no value to Russia, the United States by purchasing it could reimburse Russia for the expenditure for which she claimed repayment. This proposition was ascertained to be acceptable to the Russian Govern ment. and the purchase was made. The Pennsylvania Congressman being from the same State as Mr. Cameron, was understood to have correct infor mation about the matter he narrated. In a speech delivered by Senator Hoar some years ago, and published in the Springfield Republican, there is reference made to this matter, which seems to us to be confirmatory of what we had previously heard.

See the clipping

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa

An educational item describes Alaska's geography, resources, and history, noting Russia's 1741 discovery under Bering and the 1867 U.S. purchase for $7,200,000. It recalls that Seward and Sumner faced ridicule over 'Seward's Folly,' but says fishery income alone has already exceeded the purchase price within forty years.

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 21 October 1905 · page 3

Virginia to California. Alaska, in area, equals about one sixth of the United States, or one sev enth of Europe. Its largest group of Islands is the Aleution. The island of Attu is a lit tle farther west of San Francisco than San ^rincisco is west of Maine. It is the extreme western point. The Pribylof Islands are the breed ing places of the seal. The seal fur trade of Alaska in 1880 produced over $2,000,000 worth of furs, but the busi ness is now greatly diminished. The St. Ellas Alps are from 1,400 to 20,000 feet high and are the highest mountains north of Mexico.

See moreSee less

There are many huge glaciers and smoking vol canoes. The Russians, under Behrlng, dls covered Alaska in 1741 and it remain ed in their possession until 1867, when the United States bought it for $7,200,000. William H. Seward, secre tary of state and Charles Sumner, sen ator from Massachusetts, in the face Of much ridicule and opposition, were the champions and advocates for the purchase of this "profitless land of im perial dimensions." At the time of the purchase of Alaska, many spoke of it as "Seward's folly," yet in less than forty years the United States have re ceived from its fisheries alone, a sum much in excess of the amount paid, besides its mineral and lumber inter ests which bid fair when developed to exceed any others on the'earth's sur face. The Yukon river is ov$r 2,000 miles long and is navigable in Alaska for 1, 206 miles. It rises in British Colum bia, enters Alaska near the Arctic cir cle and flows in a general southwester ly course across the entire width of the territory emptying in the Behring Sea. It is said, that it discharges one third more water every hour than the Mississippi. The rainfall at Sitka is said to be greater than of any other section out side of the tropics the number of rainy days each year varies from a minimum of 190 to a maximum of 285. Ice fit for consumption scarcely ever forms there.

See the clipping

Douglas Island News · Douglas City, Alaska

The paper disputes the Raleigh Observer's claim that Seward's Alaska purchase was merely a disguised payment for a Russian naval demonstration. It cites Bancroft's biography of Seward to show the purchase was contemplated as early as 1859, originated from Pacific Northwest interests in 1866, and was formally negotiated and signed by Seward and Stoeckl in March 1867 for $7,200,000.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 11 days earlier.

Douglas Island News · 25 October 1905 · page 4

"AN OPEN SECRET" I Mr. Harvey may be right in saying J that the mission of the Russian navy 1 that made a demonstration in AmeriI can waters "bore no taint of selfish9 ness," but it is an open secret that Mr. J Seward agreed to pay Russia the cost / of such naval demonstration, and when C no legal way was found to make payi ment, made the purchase of Alaska? i not valued by either country?the pre- * text for paying Russia the cost of its / naval demonstration, which, we are as- ^ sured, "bore no taint of selfishness."?

See moreSee less

t Raleigh Observer. < We were not aware that it was an i * open secret. In his "Life of Seward," ( Mr. Bancroft says that the proposal to 4 purchase Alaska was considered by the 1

See the clipping

The Columbia Banner · Magnolia, Ark.

The report reflects on Secretary Seward's $7,200,000 purchase of Alaska, once mocked as a wasteful "pig in a poke," now yielding enormous returns through gold production exceeding $21,000,000 this year alone. It also notes grievances among Alaskan residents over the lack of full territorial government recognition from Washington.

The Columbia Banner · 26 October 1905 · page 1

BIO DIVIDDNDS FROM ALASKA. When Secretary Seward paid $7,200,000 for what was generally considered the waste arctic re gion in Alaska, and had great difflenity in justifying the acton in thus “buying a pig in poke.” even far-seeing Americans could have no idea that in lean than forty years the then lightly re garded bargain would be paying annual dividends of 300 percent on the investment. This year Alaska and the Kion

See the clipping