As the Papers Told It

Seward's Folly · The full archive

September 1905

9 articles

The Wenatchee Daily World · Wenatchee, Wash.

The report cites 1905 gold production figures from Nome and Alaska generally, noting the territory's output this year alone nearly covers the original purchase price, with the full year's total covering it twice over. It also notes furs, fisheries, and other resources have added over $200,000,000 to national wealth since purchase.

The Wenatchee Daily World · 9 September 1905 · page 2

[SEPTEMBER 9. 1905 SATURDAY. • ALSAKA'S CONTRIBUTIONS. Woid comes fiom Nome that tiie gold output in that locality for 1906 will be 110,000,00. This breaks all records for that district. Its yield in 11*04, which was the highest up to that time, was $7,000,000. Nome is only one of Alaska's gold producing dis tricts, but it is one of the most pioliiic. For 190") Alaska's entire gold produc tion will be about $15,000,000. And this is only the beginning. The gold field of the Klondike region of the Yukon watershed chanced to he dis covered before any of tie really big produciug carups on the United States siie were staked out.

See moreSee less

Gold bad been picked up in placers iv the lower part of Alaska for many years, and mining had been done there on a considerable «?ale, but the Nome discoveries gave the first reliable indication that gold was plentiful in the Northland. Cana da's experts are saying that there is at least $800,000,000 of gold still in she Klondike field and in the remainder of the Dominion's section of the Yu kon watershed. The United States has the larger end of the valley, how ever, and probably the much richer, end. The gold which comes out of the Nome district this year would pay the purchase price of Alaska, with nearly $3,000,000 left over. The entire ter ritry's gold output for the year would pay the price twice and leave some to spare. Rut the gold is only one of Alaska's resources. Its furs fisheries and gold have contributed much more than $200,000,000 to tie country's wealMi in the past generation, and, ex cept in furs, thes? resources have only just been touched. The territory has a vast wealth of fish timber, coal, iron,and many other things Seward

See the clipping

Seward Gateway · Seward, Alaska

San Francisco capitalist Napoleon Wells describes his trip through the Susitna and Matanuska valleys, praising the climate and soil as superior to California's. He cites a garden at Palmer Station with extraordinary potato yields and says he will invest along the Alaska Central railway route.

Seward Gateway · 16 September 1905 · page 2

Napoleon Wells, A Suh Frahblsbb capitalist, arrived on the stbambfl F.k celsior lAst evening from A radritli'a trip into the Susitna And MAtahUskil Valleys; ant,l is staving at tht IfbtPl Coleman, lie is so well pleased with what he saw in Central Alaska that he has dec idl'd to make large invest ments along the routi of the Alaska

See the clipping

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

The Cleveland Plain Dealer reflects on Secretary Seward's purchase of Alaska, once mocked as a wasteful 'pig in a poke,' noting that the territory now yields over $21,000,000 in gold annually. It also notes Alaskans' frustration at lacking full territorial government, with some threatening annexation to Canada.

The St. Louis Republic · 18 September 1905 · page 6

Rig Illvl4easl Kkm Alaska Cleveland Plain iJealer When Secretary F.-mard paid rr.ii.) for what wa generally considered the waste Arctic ngion of Alaska, nnd had great dllRrulty in Jutifylnc his actlun In thus "liujing a pig In a puke," evm far-eing Americans couM have had no idea that In less than forty year the then lUhtty regarded birciln nouM lw xiylntc annual illildenib1 of T' is-r cent on the Iniestment. Tlds year Alaska and the Klondike will h.ie n gold output of over l21.iMi.ifco. l,t.e.n thteo and four millions mnrv than last jear's roIuct: and.

See moreSee less

a the New York i:enlnc Mall, which print the figures, points out. the Klondike region and all gold fb Ms across the line In ISrltlsh teirl'ory ar as much a -'irt of the t'nlted State "for iery jmrpose of finance or tnmnvrci" a. if they had been Includeil In the ttcnanl purchase And gold Is onl one source of Alaska's wealth, the territory hav ing shown iosibl!itfes even In the wa of agriculture, und-ean.-d of ten jears ago Thl vast and rich terrltor. with Its creat find cm Inn permanent iipulatlnn of enterprising aad puie-hioo-ll Atrerlcans. has wen treated in rsther shabby fashion bv the Wnshmgtni 'Joiernment. which has tu-t!d a deaf e-ar to Its api;il for recognition In the !i.i;- of h full-ttcilgcl territorial "gitiernnient So resentful are msnv of Alaka's pf-pl th.it a ma meeting recently demanded weson from the t'nlted Statiand ann" si.on to f'anada Tbl. of rnut. ns the action f i-x-tfinUn and Intendr-d m-rrlv for elTi-ct. but the next ses sion of tongrs should not withhold a territorUl gov ernment from a e Hon of the rountry which Is 1 ttet fitted len for t.1tetnsl thn half thr exltl!it Terri tories ,md at ln-.-t one S'-jt

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

A new railroad line is being built from Seward into Alaska's interior, intended to eventually reach the Tanana River and Fairbanks, which is producing more gold than any other Alaska camp this year. So far only 45 of the 450 miles to Fairbanks have been completed.

The Minneapolis Journal · 20 September 1905 · page 16

NEW RAILROAD PIERCES INTERIOR OF ALASKA SEWARD ITS TERMINUS ON THE PACIFIC

Seward to the Tanana river and when it is ever complted, will doubtless reach Fairbanks, which camp is pro ducing more gold this year than any other in Alaska. The accompanying illustration is a picture of the new town from which a railroad has been completed for a

See the clipping

Okolona Messenger · Okolona, Miss.

The report describes the USS Katahdin, an expensive naval ram now deemed useless and reduced to rust-prevention duty, as an example of wasted government spending. It then contrasts this with Seward's purchase of Alaska for $7,200,000, once mocked as worthless, now yielding gold output worth 300% annual returns, while criticizing Washington for neglecting the territory's governance needs.

Okolona Messenger · 20 September 1905 · page 1

UC1I1IIU1J - . ' , ,. , . i aotamv. nnvnAoa nr nnnnRH til uuuiiuc&vo iUI f"' f"-" n vKaon innindAd in the Seward purchase And gold is only one source of Alaska's wealth, the iciiiuu. j uo!ijiv"- r . .i o,inii.nra nndrAAmAd of ten vears ago WHY UI OfKI.XiWl V, ' v . " -,.,) .mi riot, rritorv. with its great and JLUIO . . ---- 1 1 1 " a

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

This 1905 report from the Philadelphia Public Ledger notes that Alaska's gold output now exceeds the original $7.2 million purchase price annually. It recalls the 1867 congressional skeptics—including Gen. Butler, Rep. Washburn, and Rep. Doan—who mocked the deal as worthless.

The New Haven Union · 23 September 1905 · page 4

FRIENDLY FEELING FOR RUSSIA. From the Philadelphia Public Ledger. Official estimates place the output of geld in Alaska at about $10,000,000 for 1005. In the last fiscal year the ship ments of Alaskan gold to the United States, as declared at the customs houses, were $0,026,585. Every year the golden yield of this possession exceeds in value the price paid for it. When the sale was negotiated, in 1867, probably a majority of the people of the United States thought that the price, $7,200,000 in gold coin, was ex cessive. This view was reflected in Congress when Gen.

See moreSee less

Butler sarcastical ly proposed that we should pay $7,200, 000 to Russia as a recognition of her friendship and ask her to retain Alaska. He declared that no sane man would favor the purchase of the froz en region on the terms proposed by Secretary Seward. Many other con gressmen agreed with Butler. A New York representative was of the opinion that Alaska was a wretched place, "worth nothing,” and sure to be a bur den upon the United States. Mr.

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

This article recalls the fierce congressional opposition to Seward's 1867 Alaska purchase, quoting skeptics who called it worthless frozen wasteland. It then contrasts this with the territory's actual profitability from fish and fur revenues, and notes that friendship with Russia was a political motive for the sale.

The New Haven Union · 23 September 1905 · page 4

FRIENDLY FEELING FOR RUSSIA.

who are responsible for it. is a confirmation of The Union’s contention, that these children are deliberately being robbed of their full measure of-education. Washburn of Wisconsin thought that the acquisition would be absolutely valueless. Congressman Doan of Mis souri confidently predicted that the In hospitable country would not add a dollar to the wealth of the country. Mr. Blaine records In his "Twenty Tears of Congress" that $7,200,000 In gold represented at the time more than $10,000,000 in the currency of the gov ernment, and many Republicans felt that it was a dangerous political step, when the paper money of the govern ment was at a heavy discount, to en gage "in the speculation of acquiring a vast area of rocks and ice, as Alaska was termed in the derisive description of Mr.

See moreSee less

Seward's purchase.” If Alaska had yielded no gold, it would have been an exceedingly profit able bargain. The fish taken from Alaskan waters within 30 years from the date of the purchase were worth $80,000,000, and in 20 years the fur sales amounted to $3,000,000. The fur traders long sines have paid into the federal treasury much more than the cost of the possession/ Mr. Seward himself did not realize the value of his purchase. It is asserted that he did not consider the transaction from the fin ancial point of view, but believed that Alaska, whatever its intrinsic value might be, was worth more to the Vnited States than to any other coun try. The possibility that some other nation might buy the territory and friendship for Russia, which was much in evidence here in war-time, as the debate in Congress shows, had much to do with the sale.

See the clipping

The Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

A Raleigh newspaper editor alleged that Seward's purchase of Alaska was a disguised way to pay Russia for a naval demonstration, calling it 'an open secret.' Harper's Weekly disputes this, calling it a 'concealed myth' and recounting the documented history of the purchase negotiations from 1854 through the 1867 treaty.

The Courier-Journal · 30 September 1905 · page 6

ters ‘bore no taint of selfishness’ but it Is an open secret that Mr Saward agreed to pay RumiA the cost of such naval dem onstration and whanno legal way was found to maka payment made the pur chase of Alaska— not valued by either oountry-4he pretext for paying Russia the coet of Its naval demonstration which wa are assured ’bora no taint of selflshThls is a serious allegation If the Editor of the Observer lias not dome documentary evidence to support ' it ths Editor of Harper's Weekly has the right to regard It not as “an open secret” as Mr Daniels described It but as "a concealed myth” Meanwhile Harper's Weekly recalls this chapter of Interesting History— "In his 'Life of Seward’ Mr Bancroft aye that the proposal to purchase Alaska was considered by the State Department as early as 18SA and according to tradi tion as far back as President Polk's time Ths movement which ultimately resulted In the transfer had its origin on the Pacific slope in lWt when the Legis lature of Washington Territory petitioned President Johnson to obtain such conces sions from the Russian Government a would enable American fishing vessels to visit ports and obtain fuel and provision Anrul directed Ouelu M Clay our Minister to Bt Petersburg to open nego tiations and In February 187 the Arch duke Constantine handed to Btoeclcl tlie Russian Minister to Washington a map with the lines of a cession which the Caar was willing to make On ths evening of March 29 the treaty was made by Seward and Stoeckl at the former's house The price (87100000) was practically fixed by Seward and waa not paid till a year later It was never regarded aa ads

See the clipping

The Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

The report argues the Alaska purchase price was more an honorarium than fair payment, noting U.S. seal industry profits later vastly exceeded the cost. It disputes claims that Seward secretly agreed to pay for Russian naval support during the Civil War, challenging editor Josephus Daniels to produce evidence.

The Courier-Journal · 30 September 1905 · page 6

of friendliness In dispatching fleets to New York and Ban Francisco enhanced materially the desire In this country to facilitate the Alaskan negotiations with out unseemly haggling but that la all If there be any evidence of an explicit agree ment on the part of Secretary Seward to pay for the support of those fleets wa should like to see It Even so It Is ob vious that Russia wae satisfied with very Might security because she must have recognized the unlikelihood of getting anything as Indeed she did not get any thing except the privilege of selling to us a vast territory for a mere pittance Nor la there record of any demand for her hire or complaint because she did not get It” Josephus Daniels the Editor of the Raleigh ' Observer ie a gentleman of very high character and great accom plishments Though yet a young man he has passed a part of his life at Washington both as a newspaper cor respondent and a trusted officer of the Government He may have something up his sleeve as to Seward Russia end Alaska If he has we shall be glad to bar the pulpit or the medical profes sion The result has been to lift the former neglected callings contributing so largely to the development of our material prosperity to a degree of in telligence and efficiency Immeasurable In its benefit Under this change new fields have been opened for the intelligent youth in useful professions without limiting them to those which were the sole ob you!

See moreSee less

ject of the colleges and universities— fields In all mechanical pursuits and trades and leading to new Inventions and tha greater perfection of all the utilities contributing to the comfort safety and progress of society In this valuable work Kentucky has taken an active part Its Stats Agri left to Kentucky cultural College originally established by a grant of land from the Federal Government has advanced steadily through annual appropriations from the State until it now has a mechan ical and engineering department and from the institution are annually graduated tree at charge scholars re ceived pro rata from the counties well educated ki general studies and also In the several technical departments Aa evidence of the good work dons there It is only necessary to note the result of the past year In lta school of mechanical and electrical engineer ing from which many young men grad uated after a four years! course There were sixty-seven applications awaiting at the following: their services and all th s gradu ates are now engaged profitably in lines of work suited to their tastes and training Seven were called to Penn sylvania and three to Illinois while two each found employment In Ken tucky Indiana Ohio Wisconsin and New York add one each in Connecti cut Georgia Nevada and Tennessee They ' are now filling places in elec

See the clipping