The item reports as 'the day's biggest surprise' that Scopes was found guilty. It is a short aside amid other local news items, not a detailed trial report.
The Washington Times · 22 July 1925 · page 7
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
London newspapers continued front-page coverage of the Scopes trial verdict, with prominent British scientists weighing in. Sir Oliver Lodge said the case wasn't truly a trial of evolution since scientific questions can't be put on trial, while Professor A.M. Low called the verdict a blot on American civilization and an example of childish stupidity.
The Washington Times · 22 July 1925 · page 8
Sir Oliver Lodge Takes Rap At Evolution Verdict
Verdict By International News Service. LONDON, July 22.—J oh n Thomas Scopes and his convic tion for teaching evolution still held the front pages in London newspapers today. Sir Oliver Lodge, famous scientist and psychist, was one of the au thorities to express himself on the Dayton trial. S “I don’t regard this case as the trial of evolution,” Sir Oliver said. “You cannot put scientific questions on trial.” Professor A. M. Low, famous scientist and inventer, was far more narsh. “If the verdict means That it is wicked to teach evolution in America, it is one of the great est blots on American civiliza ton,” he said. “It would be hard to find a worse case of
This is a lighthearted newspaper humor column featuring a limerick about a 'young fellow named Swope' who expected to be convicted over 'evolution dope,' plus a joke about a Chicago zoo chimpanzee fearing being called as a witness at the Dayton trial. The item is part of a miscellany of jokes, verses, and anecdotes unrelated in tone to serious reporting.
The Washington Times · 22 July 1925 · page 13
FOWL TALK
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.
Following Scopes' conviction and $100 fine, defense attorney John R. Neal began preparing the trial record for submission to the Tennessee Supreme Court. He estimated it would take one week to ready the document for the printer, with the case moving to Knoxville for the court's September session.
Americus Times-Recorder · 22 July 1925 · page 1
DEFENSE BUSY WITH RECORD OF CONVICTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.
A syndicated comic panel featuring the character Jiggs reading about the upcoming Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, joking about using a comedian to defend him. It treats the trial as a lighthearted upcoming event rather than reporting actual proceedings.
Americus Times-Recorder · 22 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
Following the close of the Scopes trial, defense counsel John R. Neal began preparing the official trial record for submission to the Tennessee Supreme Court, estimating one week to ready it for the printer. Scopes had been convicted and fined $100, with the case now shifting toward Knoxville where the high court would hear it in September.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 22 July 1925 · page 1
HIGH COURT. DAYTON, Tenn., July 122.-—'l‘he close of the Scopes case brought on ly extra work for John R. Neal, chief counsel for the defense, MHis was the task of preparing the record of conviction of the twenty-four year old school teacher on a charge of teaching evolution theories in the :lpublic schools for submission to the | supreme court. | As he began the work today, he
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
After the trial's conclusion, Dayton quickly reverted to its quiet small-town ways, with notable figures like Darrow and Bryan departing and Scopes arranging his bail in an empty courtroom. The courtroom itself was left in disarray, littered with papers and empty bottles, while jurymen expressed disappointment that they had been excluded from hearing the scientific evidence at the heart of the case.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 22 July 1925 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
DAYTON BACK TO QUIET AFTER WEEK EXCITEMENT
JURYMEN DISAPPOINTED BECAUSE THEY COULD NOT HEAR SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE THAT WAS EXCLUDED.
See moreSee less
DAYTON, Tenn., July 22.—A young negro sat on the steps of the Rhea county courthouse Tuesday afternoon poring over a cheap magazine. Dayton is back to its quiet ways after a climax that jerked it out of its mountain obscurity for a few fleeting days and put it on the lips of the whole civilized world. Most of the notables and visitors will be gone by Wednesday morning. Darrow is going to Knoxville and Bryan to Winchester Tennessee.
Scopes came back to the deserted courtroom after lunch to arrange his $500 bail. There was no one in the county clerk's office except Scopes, his attorney and th bonding agnt..
The famous court room looked as if it had been swept by a storm. Paper was scattered all over the floor. A microphone stand had been knocked down in front of the judge's bench and a heavy chair lay across it. Empty bottles stood around on the deserted counsel tables among the scattered newspapers.
Village Loafers Hang Around
Out on the lawn, until a drizzle began, a few village loafers hung around. Colonel J. R. Thompson, foreman of the jury, and two other jurors sat on a board talking about the trial they had hardly seen. Hot dog stands were being dismantled. Mercants were looking dolefully over the unsold stocks that had been bought in anticipation of a long trial Neither the length of the trial nor the crowds approached even the most conservative expectations.
But the proprietor of the Aqua hotel, who had bunked guests even on the hallway couches and in the bath rooms, has prospered, and E. F. Robinson, the hustling druggist, has made enough out of his soda fountain to retire for life. From 7 a. m. till nearly midnight, his place has been crowded. Tuesday afternoon, visitors were dropping in for a final drink at the table "where it started."
The jurymen were the most disappointed of all. They fought for a place on the jury and then never got to hear the exciting episodes of the trial.
Wanted to Hear Testimony
"We wanted to hear the scientific testimony, most of all," said W. F. Roberson, the one non-church member on the jury, to Darrow after the trial.
R. L. Gentry, the only juror who has read about evolution, went up to meet Clarence Darrow after the trial.
"You've read a bit about evolution, haven't you?" Darrow asked him.
"Quite a bit."
"If you ever come to Chicago, come in and see me. We'll have a long talk," Darrow said. From the day the jury was picked, Darrow has been much interested in this backwoods philosopher-school teacher.
Felt Juror's Sympathy
"I felt you were with us." Darrow continued. "but we didn't want a hang jury and that was why I urged all of you to return a verdict."
"I know what you are driving at," Gentry replied.
After the trial closed, dozens of spectators crowded around Darrow and Bryan. Interest in Darrow seemed to mount perceptibly after his questioning of Bryan. Many here had regarded Bryan as the greatest man of the age and they wondered what kind of a person it was who dared enter the arena to debate religion with their Hercules. Darrow is the first professed agnotistic many in this region ever saw and many have been curious to know what sort of human he is.
Reaction Favorable to Darrow
The reaction has been favorable, for instead of the mean, devil-like peroson they expected, they have found a comfortable old man much like themselves wearing galluses, full of jokes, affable with everyone, and above all, courageous. Shocked as they were when he stood up in the courtroom and protested against the morning prayer, they have come to respect his honesty and courage and they like him for this much as they dispute his agnostic views.
Old Man Abel, who has a real es-
Contrary to the impression that might be given by the Tennessee antate office over Robinson's drug store, expressed the sentiment of the community.
Cross-Section of Views
"If a man is honest and tries to lead a good life as he sees it, that's all anybody can ask," he said. "Every man is entitled to his views. I believe in the Bible, but that is something every man has to decide for himself."
ti-evolution law, that is the way these folks feel about it. They want to be tolerant and they have made a heroic effort to be so in face of the stern religious code pounded into them from infancy.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
After the Scopes trial ended, Dayton's crowds and vendors wind down as hot dog stands are dismantled and merchants sit on unsold stock. Jurors express disappointment at missing the scientific testimony, and Clarence Darrow is shown having a friendly exchange with juror R. L. Gentry after the verdict.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 22 July 1925 · page 7
Roberson, the one non-churci min-: ber on the al'lfi,ng Darrow after tlie the trial. tesk LB} E R. L. Ggniry, ;the only juror w!m{ has read abolt evojution, went up o
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
The report describes Darrow's interactions with jurors after the trial closed, including a juror named Gentry acknowledging sympathy for the defense. It also details how the Dayton community's initial wariness of Darrow as an agnostic softened into respect for his honesty and courage, despite disagreement with his religious views.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 22 July 1925 · page 7
Arlter the trial closed, dozens u‘;l lr',[:('f(lum:‘:! crowded around Larrow and Bryan. Interest i Darrow fieem-i ed o moant pereeptinly arter his questioning cf Bryan. Many here had regarded Bryan as the greatest man ol the age and they woudered what kind of a person it was who dared | enter the arenma to debate :'eligiuu! with their Hercules. Darrow is l.lm]' first professed agnotistic many R this region ever saw and many huvn{
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
Dr. Winterton C. Curtis, a zoologist from the University of Missouri, submitted a written statement on evolution that was admitted to the record of the Scopes trial. He divided evolution into cosmic, geologic, and organic types, and discussed the fact, course, and causes of evolution, emphasizing the strength of the evidence for the historical fact of evolution despite debate over natural selection.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 22 July 1925 · page 8
CURTIS TALKS OF EVOLUTION - ZOOLOGIST OF UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI MADE STATEMENT FOR SCOPES TRIAL
ty view the evidence, The coursé pursued by evolutlon Is“knowh broad ly in/many iostasces . btt im. the nature of the “case is limited and nia’ni of the steps will remain uncer tain, without, however, a calling in question of the historie fact. “In the first place, he established organie evolution.as the only rea-l sonable explapation of the past his tory of living things. Secondly, he of fered in natural selection what then appeared an adequate explanation for the’ origin of theories and hence for the causes of evolution.” (Continufug, he went into a detdlled
The report states that the Dayton, Tennessee 'monkey trial' has concluded, with the teacher fined $100 for teaching human descent from lower animals. It notes his attorneys plan to appeal to a higher court and reflects on the town's sudden fame.
Adams County Witness · 22 July 1925 · page 2
Bible Thought for Today FORSAKE EVIL:—Thus saith the Lord of hosts: Turn ye now from your evil ways, and from your evil doings.—Zechariah 1:4. -o The Commercial-Review of Portland clipped an item from the “Twenty Years Ago” column in the Witness Monday and published it as present day news. The Witness docs not wish to mis-inform anyone and that’s why the date is always given above such items. -o The monkey trial at Dayton, Ten nessee. has come to a close. The teach er who taught that men descended from a lower order of animals was fined $100.
See moreSee less
His attorneys have given notice that the case will be appealed to a higher court. Dayton is a town about the size of Berne and for the past few weeks was the big headliner in nearly all daily papers in this coun try. and even many European papers made mention of it. It is doubtful that the case will attract as much at tention in the higher courts as it did in the small town of Dayton. The whole affair has already accomplished much good in that it leads people to search the Scriptures and seek after truth. -o
John Scopes is convicted of violating Tennessee's anti-evolution law and is fined $100 by the judge. Scopes states that he believes the statute he violated is unjust and that any other course of action would have violated his sense of academic freedom.
Adams County Witness · 22 July 1925 · page 2
TENNESSEE EVOLUTION TEACHER CONVICTED (Continued from page 1) ‘'Have you anything to ‘ay, Mr. Scopes-” asked the judge. “Your honor, I ha\e been convict ed of violating an unjust statute.” replied Scopes. “Any action other than I have pursued would be in violation of niv idea of academic freedom." The judge repeated the fine of
A jury of twelve men took only seven minutes to find John T. Scopes guilty of teaching evolution in Dayton, Tennessee. He was fined $100, the minimum under the law, and his lawyers immediately filed an appeal to send the case toward the U.S. Supreme Court.
Adams County Witness · 22 July 1925 · page 1
SCOPES FOUND GUILTY IN 7-MINUTE DELIBERATION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.
A government clerk filed a test suit in Washington D.C. to stop public schools from teaching evolution and other sciences, citing a congressional funding clause against teaching disrespect for the Bible. The suit names the schools superintendent and science department head, with a hearing set for July 28.
The Indianapolis Times · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Faced With Decision. Bu United Prei<s WASHINGTON, July 22.—A test suit to restrain authorities from teaching evolution and other sci ences in the public schools of the District of Columbia was filed in the District Supreme Court here today by Lauren H. Whittner, Government clerk. Involving all the unheard evi dence of the Scopes trial, the suit seeks to prevent payment of teach
Clarence Darrow, defense attorney in the Scopes evolution trial, publicly reveals his skepticism about miracles and the nature of God. His statements come in response to nine pointed questions posed by prosecutor William Jennings Bryan.
The Indianapolis Times · 22 July 1925 · page 1
HIS DISBELIEFS Doubts Miracles and Nature of God, He Says in Reply to Nine Questions Advanced by Bryan. Bv Times Soecinl DAYTON, Tenn., July 23.—8 y his own words,, Clarence S. Darrow,” evolution, today had 't anded him self a disbeliever in the j Tirades con
Hopes for a series of public debates between Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan on evolution ended when Bryan announced he would not participate. Bryan said he would not invite Christians to meetings where their religion would be mocked.
The Indianapolis Times · 22 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.
This passage presents Clarence Darrow's responses to questions about his religious beliefs, including doubts about the Bible's divine inspiration and supernatural elements like miracles and the virgin birth. He states his belief that the universe operates according to immutable natural laws rather than divine intervention.
The Indianapolis Times · 22 July 1925 · page 5
DARROW DOUBTS BIBLE MIRACLES
BIBLEMIRACLES (Continued From Pago 1) i; and one of them answerd that God jWas made in the image of man. I [do not believe in that kind of God. 5 As to the origin of the universe and what is back of it, I do not pretend I to know. I haven't the intimate acquaintance with it that Mr. Bryan says he has. Q. Do you believe that the Bible is the revealed will of God, inspired and trustworthy? A. I think that there is much of value in the Bible.
See moreSee less
Ido not believe that it was written or inspired by God. I believe it should be taken as every other book, and that the portions in it that are sublime, like such portions otf every other great book, might by a figure of speech be called inspfired. I might even say this of Mr. Bryan’s ‘ln His Im age” if I could find any $ such por
The passage includes Darrow's remarks on belief in an afterlife and his respect for others' religious views, followed by details of a separate taxpayer lawsuit challenging the Tennessee evolution ban's constitutionality by contrasting scientific teachings with biblical accounts. It also notes the Scopes case is heading toward the Supreme Court after the jury's conviction in Dayton.
The Indianapolis Times · 22 July 1925 · page 5
FILE EVOLUTION BAN TEST SUIT
question of when man first believed in life beyond the grave. I am not at all sure tvhether some other an imals have not the same hope of fu ture life. The origin may have arisen in vivid dreams, concerning the return of the dead or front all I know', from actual evidence of the return of the dead. I have never tried to impose my view's of reli gion on any human being that ever lived.” Darrow' added. “I have a right to my own views and would fight as hard to protect every other man’s views as I would my own.”
The jury found John Thomas Scopes guilty, a result that surprised no one who followed the trial. The editorial argues the case will now move to higher courts to test whether Tennessee's anti-evolution law violates the state and federal constitutions.
The Indianapolis Times · 22 July 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
The report describes the final moments of the Scopes evolution trial, including closing remarks from Bryan and Darrow before the judge delivered his final statement about truth and courage. The defendant was fined $100 as the case concluded with reflections on science, religion, and justice.
South Bend News-Times · 22 July 1925 · page 4
FINED $100, AS PRAYER CLOSES EVOLUTION CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
The trial concluded with prayers and courtroom banter as Judge Raulston barred further testimony like Bryan's cross-examination and ordered it struck from the record. Both sides waived closing arguments, and Darrow urged the judge to instruct the jury to find Scopes guilty, after which the judge prepared his charge to the jury.
South Bend News-Times · 22 July 1925 · page 4
EVOLUTION CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
Defense and prosecution agreed to skip closing arguments; Darrow told the jury there was no dispute the law was broken and essentially asked for a guilty verdict to enable appeal. The jury deliberated only seven minutes before returning a guilty verdict.
South Bend News-Times · 22 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
John Thomas Scopes, the convicted defendant, writes that he was not surprised by his conviction given the judge's exclusion of scientific testimony and ruling on the law's constitutionality. He vows to continue the fight in higher courts, up to the U.S. Supreme Court if necessary.
South Bend News-Times · 22 July 1925 · page 2
Scopes Expected Conviction From Court, He States
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
The United Press reports that 'Civic Biology' by George W. Hunter, the textbook used by John Scopes in Tennessee, is also approved and used in Indiana schools. The article quotes passages from the book discussing evolution and man's classification as a vertebrate animal.
South Bend News-Times · 22 July 1925 · page 3
Approved by Indiana Edu cational Board. By United Press: INDIANAPOLIS. July 21. — The same text book which whipped up the evolution tempest in Dayton, Tenn , is in use in Hoosier schools, it was revealed today. John W. Scopes, on trial for vio lating the Tennessee anti-evolution law, used “Civic Biology," by George W. Hunter, in flying in the face of the Tennessee colons who voted to ban tho theory of evolution from the schools of that state. The same book is approved for . Indiana by the state board of edu cation.
See moreSee less
It is not regarded by edu cators as radical in tone and was selected by officials of Manual Training High school as a text book in the science department. "Man Is Animal.” Other schools over the state have also used the book, it was stated. • Hunter’s text discusses the doc trine of evolution in plain terms and refers to Charles Darwin as “the great English scientist.” Darwin was the first scientist to . promulgate the theory of evolu tion. "We have now learned that ani mal forms may be arranged so as to begin with very simple one-celled forms and culminate with a group
A short item reports that John T. Scopes, the Dayton schoolteacher, was found guilty of teaching Darwinian theory in violation of Tennessee law. The notice is terse, appearing amid unrelated stories about a relief fund lawsuit and the Coolidge family's vacation.
South Bend News-Times · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Guilty John T. Scopes, Dayton schoo teacher, was convicted of teachlnj the Darwinian theory In opposit'.ui to the Tennessee law. i DETECTIVES KEEP CLOSE GUARD OVER
After Judge Raulston barred counsel from examining each other further, Bryan submitted nine questions on religion to Darrow through the press, and Darrow answered in kind, expressing skepticism about miracles and the nature of God. The exchange capped the Monday afternoon outdoor session of the Scopes trial.
South Bend News-Times · 22 July 1925 · page 1
United News Staff Correspondent. DAYTON, Tenn., July 21.—Wil liam Jennings Eryan had his chance t«; Examine Clarence Darrow, the counsel for John T. Scopes who mer cilessly exposed the commoner's Ig norance of many facts outside the Eib’e at the al fresco session of Judge Raulston’s court Monday aft ernoon. Bryan put nine questions to Dar row through rtie newspapers and in reply, the brilliant Chicago lawyer expressed a disbelief in miracles and doubts as to the nature of God and otner fundamentals of religion. The court had barred further ex amination of opposing counsel by ea^h other and Bryan had asked per mission to put through the newspa pers the questions he had intended to ask if he had been permitted to call Darrow to the witness stand.
See moreSee less
Darrow promptly agreed to answer in the same way. liie vucsuuiik. Bryan’s nine questions, with Dar row’s answers, follow: 1. Do you believe in the exis tence of God as described In the Bible? Answer—I do not know of any de scription of God in the Bible. If Mr. Bryan would describe what he means by God, I could probably tell whether I believe In his God. The question of what was meant by the word was directly put to counsel for the state and one of them answered j that God was made fn the image of I man. I do not believe in that kind of God. As to the origin of the uni verse. and what is back of it I do not pretend to know. I haven’t the Intimate acquaintance with it that Mr. Bryan says he has. 2. Q.—Do you believe that the Bible is the revealed will of God, inspired and trustworthy? A.—I think that there is much of value in the Bible. I do not believe that it was writen or inspired by God. X believe it should be taken as every other book, and that the por tions in it that are sublime like such portions of every other great book might by a figure of speech be called inspired. I might even say this of Mr. Bryan’s ‘in his image* if I could find any such portion in It. 3. Q.—Do you believe in the su pernatural Christ, foretold in the Old Testament and revealed in the New Testament?
The passage records Bryan's written questions to Darrow about belief in God, the Bible's divine inspiration, and the supernatural Christ, along with Darrow's skeptical answers. Darrow argues the Bible should be read like any other book and rejects literal interpretations of God and Christ's supernatural nature.
Judge Raulston forgave Clarence Darrow for insulting remarks made during trial proceedings, declaring he acted 'even as Christ,' and withdrew the contempt citation that had required Darrow to post a $5,000 bond. The two men shook hands in open court, and due to overcrowding cracking the courthouse ceiling, proceedings moved outdoors.
The Daily Worker · 22 July 1925 · page 1
CONTEMPT WRIT AGAINST DARROW IS WITHDRAWN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.
Clarence Darrow dramatically called William Jennings Bryan as a witness to challenge literal biblical interpretation, and Bryan in turn got permission to question Darrow and Malone. Separately, eight scientists submitted lengthy affidavits defending evolution into the trial record.
The Daily Worker · 22 July 1925 · page 1
DARROW CALLS BRYAN AS WITNESS IN APE TRIAL; BRYAN TO CALL DARROW
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.
Eight scientists prepared roughly 65,000 words of affidavits defending evolution for the Scopes trial record, after Judge Raulston refused to let them testify in open court. The defense planned to use this written record as grounds for appealing Scopes's anticipated conviction to higher courts.
The Daily Worker · 22 July 1925 · page 1
SCIENTISTS' CASE NEARING END
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
After the Dayton trial ended, the Scopes case is expected to go first to the Tennessee Supreme Court and potentially the U.S. Supreme Court, a process that could take up to 18 months. Bryan announces plans for anti-evolution law campaigns in seven more states, while legal opinion is skeptical the law will be overturned.
Paper unidentified · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Le Messager · Lewiston, Me.
The report announces that Professor Scopes has been found guilty of teaching evolution by the court in Dayton, Tennessee, and fined $100, with his lawyer Dudley Field Malone posting $500 bail for appeal. The writer mocks the trial as a farce and vaudeville, criticizes Bryan's defeat and the illiterate jury, then offers readers an explanation of evolutionary theory.
Le Messager · 22 July 1925 · page 4
LE PROCES SCOPES
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
This French-language opinion piece defends Darwin's theory of evolution, arguing it does not deny divine power and that Darwin never claimed man descended from apes. It criticizes William Jennings Bryan for overstepping his authority on religious matters and compares the Scopes trial to the historic persecutions of Socrates and Jesus Christ.
Le Messager · 22 July 1925 · page 4
LE PROCÈS SCOPES
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A philosophical opinion piece reflects on human moral progress across history, arguing humanity has gained little wisdom since ancient Assyria, Greece, and Egypt. The author praises Scopes as a young apostle of science, comparing him to persecuted figures like Servetus, Confucius, and Buddha who suffered for enlightening their contemporaries.
Le Messager · 22 July 1925 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Friends of condemned murderer Russell T. Scott sought to hire Clarence Darrow for a last-minute appeal, raising funds for his defense. Darrow, reached in Dayton, Tennessee where he was working on the Scopes trial, denied being approached but said he had appealed to the governor on Scott's behalf.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 1
SEEK DARROW TO HELP SCOTT IN FIGHT AGAINST GALLOWS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
After being barred from questioning Darrow on religious views directly, Bryan submitted nine written questions which Darrow answered in court, including his skepticism that the Bible was divinely inspired. The report notes Scopes was convicted and mentions plans to appeal the case to the Supreme Court.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 1
MOVE TO CARRY EVOLUTION TEST TO SUPREME COURT AS SCOPES IS CONVICTED - BIBLE GOOD BOOK BUT NOT INSPIRED BY GOD-DARROW
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
The passage records written questions from Bryan about Darrow's beliefs on God, the Bible, Christ's miracles, and immortality of the soul, with Darrow's point-by-point responses. Darrow says he does not believe in miracles or a supernatural Christ, and affirms belief in an immutable natural law governing the universe.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Attorneys for both sides forewent closing arguments and submitted the Scopes case directly to the jury. Judge Raulston expunged William Jennings Bryan's prior testimony from the record, saying it could shed no light on issues before the higher court.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 3
EVOLUTION TEST
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Judge Raulston explains his reasoning for expunging William Jennings Bryan's testimony from the trial record, stating it cannot aid a higher court in determining whether Scopes taught evolution. Clarence Darrow then announces the defense has no further evidence to offer and proposes having the jury instructed to find Scopes guilty, preserving the right to appeal.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Judge Raulston instructed the jury that if they believed Scopes taught human descent from lower animals, they must find him guilty, and the jury complied. Scopes was fined, with both defense and prosecution agreeing the case would now go to the state supreme court.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 3
EVOLUTION TEST
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
The piece comments that the expected verdict in the Scopes case finally arrived, though it could have been reached in half a day. It suggests relief is felt, both by those involved and the public at large.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Ellsworth American · Ellsworth, Me.
A rural news column reports that one citizen caught a sculpin and planned to send it to William Jennings Bryan and Clarence Darrow as an exhibit for the Scopes trial, joking it might help determine the theory of evolution since sculpins don't grow in Tennessee fields. The item is part of a miscellany of local community notes from a small-town correspondent.
Ellsworth American · 22 July 1925 · page 9
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · Grand Rapids, Minn
The piece notes that Scopes's conviction at Dayton, Tennessee was expected since he violated the state law, though the editorial calls the law unwise. It argues science and religion need not conflict, with a dismissive aside on human descent from monkeys.
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · 22 July 1925 · page 6
SCIENCE AND RELIGION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bozeman Courier · Bozeman, Mont.
John Thomas Scopes was found guilty in Rhea county circuit court of teaching evolution in violation of Tennessee law, and fined $100, the statutory minimum. Notice of appeal to the Tennessee Supreme Court was filed, with 30 days granted to perfect it.
The Bozeman Courier · 22 July 1925 · page 1
PROF. SCOPES FOUND GUILTY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
After Scopes's conviction and $100 fine, lead counsel John R. Neal works to prepare the trial record for the state supreme court appeal, a task expected to take about a week. The case may be heard in Knoxville in September, though lawyers worry about delays or sidetracking through the court of appeals, and the legal team may change for the appeal.
The Bismarck Tribune · 22 July 1925 · page 1
LAWYERS WORK ON APPEAL IN SCOPES CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
After the $100 fine, the Scopes case is set to be heard by the Tennessee Supreme Court in Knoxville in September, with lawyers noting it could be sidetracked to the court of appeals first. Defense and prosecution attorneys scatter, with Darrow heading to Knoxville and Bryan touring Tennessee towns.
The Bismarck Tribune · 22 July 1925 · page 1
LONG DELAY FEARED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Mundo · San Juan, P.R.
The judge sentenced Scopes to a $100 fine in the Dayton trial. Darrow announced he would appeal to the state Supreme Court on behalf of the convicted teacher.
El Mundo · 22 July 1925 · page 2
CIEN DOLARES DE MULTA A SCOPES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Mundo · San Juan, P.R.
At Dayton, Darrow apologized to the court for submitting scientific evidence by affidavit against the judge's order, clearing him of contempt, while Bryan, under Darrow's questioning, admitted he did not believe the world was created in six literal days but in six periods. The dispatch also reports that the jury found Scopes guilty, with the fine amount still to be set by the judge.
El Mundo · 22 July 1925 · page 5
BRYAN ADMITE QUE NO CREE EN QUE EL MUNDO FUE CREADO EN SEIS DIAS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Keowee Courier · Pickens Court House, S.C.
Newspaper dispatches report that John Scopes was found guilty by the jury in the Dayton, Tennessee evolution trial and fined $100. The report notes both sides anticipated appealing the case, potentially up to the U.S. Supreme Court, as it was treated as a test case.
Keowee Courier · 22 July 1925 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Keowee Courier · Pickens Court House, S.C.
A humorous, racially mocking letter from 'Cousin Billie Fennell' jokes about being called to testify at the Scopes trial, claiming he will bring a group of people from Oconee to 'prove' evolution claims about human origins. The letter is comedic, referencing earlier mockery of these same individuals in Columbia.
Keowee Courier · 22 July 1925 · page 3
MAY TESTIFY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.
The report explains that education is traditionally a state matter, with the Federal government's role limited mainly to the advisory Bureau of Education. U.S. Commissioner of Education Dr. John J. Tigert, a Tennessean, declines to take a position on the evolution controversy stirred up by the Scopes trial, noting any stance would draw criticism.
Edgefield Advertiser · 22 July 1925 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.
The passage reports that U.S. Commissioner of Education John J. Tigert declined to take a federal stance on the evolution controversy, stating it is a matter for state authorities. The editorial also criticizes Bryan's proposed constitutional amendment as an inappropriate mixing of church and state.
Edgefield Advertiser · 22 July 1925 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.
Judge Raulston ruled that scientific testimony would be excluded from the jury's consideration in the Scopes evolution trial, leading to sharp clashes between the judge and defense attorneys Hayes and Darrow. Court adjourned to allow the defense time to prepare statements of what their excluded expert witnesses would have testified, with Bryan insisting on the right to cross-examine any such statements.
The Watchman and Southron · 22 July 1925 · page 1
SCIENTISTS BARRED FROM SCOPES TRIAL
»\ • Jury is Absent Court Room, Payton, Tenn., July 17 (Associated Press).—After j Judge John T. Raulston today had excluded scientific testimony in the Scopes evolution case court was adjourned until Monday morning until nine o’clock. The interven ing time will be spent by the coun sel for the defence in preparing statements for the records of what their witnesses would have testi fied had they been permitted to ] take the witness stand. Judge Raulston’s decision to exj elude the experts from the witness stand developed sharp clashes be ■ tween Arthor G.
See moreSee less
Hayes of the de fence and Judge Raulston and ; Clarence Darrow also of the de fence. ^ Mr. Darrow asked for the rest I of the day in which to draw up proofs to present. The Judge ask ed if it would take the rest of the day. Mr. Darrow said he did not understand why every request of the. defence was overruled. “I hope you do not mean to re flect upon the' court” said Judge Raulston. “You haye a right to hope.” replied Darrow. “I have the right to do something else,” ■aid Judge Raulston. "All right, all right, then,” said Darrow, ap parently ending the clash. Mr. Bryan insisted on the right of cross examination if the defense placed witnesses on the stand in the absence of the jury. He submitted that no one sided case should be sent along with the, defense documents.
With scientific testimony barred before the jury, defense counsel met with experts to prepare written statements for the court record, to be used in a future appeal. Defense lawyers stated they held no hope for a verdict favorable to Scopes.
The Watchman and Southron · 22 July 1925 · page 1
TO FIX STATEMENTS
Dayton, Tenn., July 18. (By the. Associated fress).—Attorney Gen eral A. TStewart, representing the State of Tennessee in the pros ecution of John T. Scopes, may tell the Stewarts of South Carolina about the Stewarts in Tennessee. Mr. Stewart received today through Doctor and Mrs. H. B. Stewart of Fountain Inn, an invitation to at tend the annual reunion of the clan at Falrview Presbyterian Church of Greenville county. The reunion will be held August 27 and the at torney general said he hoped he would be able to attend.
William Jennings Bryan addressed citizens near the Scopes trial site, defending the Tennessee anti-evolution law and the local culture against claims of bigotry. He alleged a conspiracy by atheists and agnostics against Christianity using evolution as a vehicle.
The Watchman and Southron · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Pikeville, Tenn., July 19 (By the Associated Press).—A brief but vigorous defense of the Tennessee anti-evolution law and of the cul ture of Tennesseeans marked the appearance here today of Wil liam Jennings Bryan. Speaking to several hundred Sequehatchie valley citizens in an open air meeting 20 miles from the scene of the Scopes trial, the fundamentalist.chief began his ad dress by expressing indignation “toward those who have maligned you—those who have come from another state to speak of you as bigots.” He expressed the same feeling toward some of the newspaper men "who have spoken of you as yokels.” • * “I wish that I could have drag ged them here and placed them face to face with a humanity they can not imitate.” he declar ed.
See moreSee less
“The world is discussing the Scopes case,” he said. "It has
Dayton was calm during the Scopes trial recess, with visiting evangelists filling pulpits instead of local pastors. Darrow traveled to Chattanooga for a lecture while other defense attorneys worked on written scientist statements for the court record.
The Watchman and Southron · 22 July 1925 · page 4
DARROW ABSENT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C.
Clarence Darrow left Dayton for a lecture in Chattanooga while other defense attorneys prepared closing statements. The report outlines the upcoming schedule of speeches, the judge's charge, and the likely Tuesday verdict, noting the misdemeanor charge carries only a fine, not imprisonment.
The Watchman and Southron · 22 July 1925 · page 4
DARROW ABSENT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A reader named John Cantey writes to the Manning Times to clarify the evolutionist position regarding the ongoing Scopes trial in Tennessee, explaining that evolutionists see cause-and-effect kinship between species rather than literal descent from apes. He argues evolution is not a religion and should be taught in schools, even suggesting teachers be penalized for refusing to teach it.
Paper unidentified · 22 July 1925 · page 2
JOHN CANTEY WRITES ON EVOLUTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A writer argues that evolution is not a religion and that studying it helps one understand God's design, while contending Tennessee's anti-evolution law violates the Fourteenth Amendment rather than the establishment clause. The author also asserts the Genesis creation story is mythological, predating the Christian era's understanding of the Holy Spirit.
Paper unidentified · 22 July 1925 · page 2
ON EVOLUTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Pageland Journal · Pageland, S.C.
A newspaper column of brief editorial opinions and jokes touches on the Dayton, Tennessee evolution trial, mentioning Scopes and Darrow by name. It notes the defense's objection to opening court with prayer and offers sarcastic commentary on the trial's significance.
The Pageland Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Pageland Journal · Pageland, S.C.
A column of short opinion items mocks Clarence Darrow's stance on evolution, doubts the Dayton trial will settle anything, and criticizes Scopes's lawyers for objecting to opening court with prayer. It also argues scientists have no place as trial witnesses since evolution is 'theory' and the case is about Scopes's guilt, not evolution itself.
The Pageland Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Pageland Journal · Pageland, S.C.
An editorial describes a prospective juror in the Scopes trial being applauded for affirming his belief in the Bible when questioned by Darrow. The writer sides with the juror's simple faith over Darrow's legal reputation, framing the case in religious terms of ultimate judgment.
The Pageland Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 4
RIGHT vs WRONG
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Pageland Journal · Pageland, S.C.
Concession stands set up near the Dayton courthouse during the Scopes trial have largely failed to turn a profit, according to vendors. Judge Raulston's ruling barring expert testimony dashed hopes that the trial would be prolonged long enough for stand owners to break even.
The Pageland Journal · 22 July 1925 · page 7
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
At a Baptist Young People's Union assembly in Mandeville, Louisiana, attendees prayed for the conversion to Christianity of Clarence Darrow, defense attorney in the Scopes trial. The prayer, suggested by state secretary E. D. Solomon, expressed hope Darrow might be converted as the Apostle Paul was, ending with a chorus of 'amens'.
Brownsville Herald · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
Following Scopes's conviction and $100 fine, defense counsel John R. Neal began preparing the trial record for submission to the Tennessee Supreme Court, estimating a week to complete it. The case was expected to be heard in Knoxville in September, with some uncertainty over the lineup of defense lawyers and the possibility of delay via appellate court procedures.
Brownsville Herald · 22 July 1925 · page 1
SCOPES RECORD BEING PREPARED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
The report describes preparations for appealing the Scopes case to Tennessee's supreme court in Knoxville, noting uncertainty over which attorneys would argue the appeal. It also covers a separate federal petition challenging the anti-evolution law and notes the dispersal of trial participants including Darrow, Bryan, and Scopes to various engagements.
Brownsville Herald · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
A mix of newspaper quips and quotes precedes a report on Dean Shailer Mathews of the University of Chicago Divinity School, who compared the Tennessee legislature to Robespierre for trying to enforce belief by law. He argued Christianity need not be restricted by the Bible and that the Dayton trial dramatizes the problem of reconciling faith with intelligence.
Brownsville Herald · 22 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
A satirical 'Home Brew' column jokes that the Tennessee court ruled man is not related to the monkey, thanking Bryan for proving ancestors ate an apple instead of a coconut. The piece is comic commentary following the trial's conclusion, not straight news.
The Seattle Star · 22 July 1925 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Following the verdict, the Scopes case is being prepared for appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court as Dayton returns to normal and visitors depart. Defense attorneys are already at work readying for the next legal battle.
The Seattle Star · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Scopes Case Is on Way to U. S. Supreme Court
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
After the Dayton trial concluded, the Scopes case is set to proceed through the Tennessee supreme court and potentially to the U.S. Supreme Court to test the anti-evolution law's validity. Bryan announces plans for similar anti-evolution legislative drives in at least seven states.
The Seattle Star · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Scopes Case Is on Way to U. S. Supreme Court
- BY WILLIAM J. LOSH (United Press Staff Correspondent) l “PAYTON, Tenn., July 22-=While" Dayton relapsed into {ts normal trun- | quility and its hosts of visitors melt- | ed away, the BEcopes case today | started for the United States supreme court along two broad avenues, . Soonsr or later, probably within 18 months, that tribunal will ‘hand | down a decision on the valklity of the Tennesses anti-evolution law, which nlone wis at stake in the historie proceedings just ended. | Meanwhile, drives for anti-evolu- | tion laws will be started in at least seven states as soon as their legisla tures convene, according to a state ment ziven to the United Press by William Jennings Bryan.
See moreSee less
Upon the ultimate decision of the supreme court will depend.the suc cess or fallure of these laws and of the fundamentalist campaigns to root the evolution theory out of American schools, The Scopes case ttself will go to the Tennessee supreme court at Knoxville for hearing at its Septem. ber session. If this court upholds it, it “will travel thence to Washing ton. If it overturns it, the lssue still will go to Washington thru a yparallel proceeding in the federal court which was started before the trial here began. The attack thru the federal court will travel via the Unied States
Defense attorneys including Darrow, Neal, Hays, and Malone argued to quash the indictment against Scopes, while prosecutors McKenzie and Stewart fought to sustain it. Darrow delivered a fiery speech condemning the anti-evolution law as religious bigotry comparable to the Spanish Inquisition.
Vilas County News · 22 July 1925 · page 8
DARROW WOULD QUASH BILL
Evolution Trial. Dayton, Tenn.—A motion made by the defense to quash the indictment afcuinst John Thomas Scopes, charged with a violation of Tennessee’s anti evolution act, brought forth a flood of oratory. John It. Neal, Arthur G. Hays, Dud ley Field Malone and Clarence Dnr row—all of counsel for accused schoolmaster—argued for the quash ing of the indictment; former Attor ney General Hen G. McKenzie, Attor ney General T. A. Stewart fought to have the indictment sustained. William Jennings Bryan alone of all the learned counsel engaged on this extraordinary case, was silent.
See moreSee less
Clarence Darrow of Chicago was easily the feature of the day. His plea for the quashing of the Scopes’ indict ment. was couched in simple language, but the earnes'tness and the sincerity of the man impressed all who heard him.
A small-town newspaper's humor-and-commentary column makes light references to Tennessee's evolution controversy, including a quip about Scopes' sister losing her teaching job in Paducah, Kentucky, over fears she'd teach similar ideas. It blends this with unrelated jests about weather, politics, beggars, and railroads.
Grant County Herald · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Gosh, watch the corn grwo. ooo LaFollette is dead, Ladd is dead and democracy lost its chance of being the leading progressive party of the country when it refused to nominate McAdoo at New York last summer. A good opening exists for a simon-pure leader. ooo Controversies are far-reaching. Scopes’ sister lost her job as teacher in the Paducah (Ky.) schools because
A Washington D.C. taxpayer, Loren H. Whittner, petitioned the court to withhold the salaries of school officials for permitting the teaching of evolution, which he claims conflicts with the Bible. The District Supreme Court ordered the officials to show cause on July 28 why their pay should not be stopped, while separately Bryan and Darrow had another exchange at the Dayton trial.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 22 July 1925 · page 1
RAISE QUESTION OF EVOLUT'N IN WASHINGTON, D.C. WOULD WITHHOLD SALARIES OF TEACHERS
Bryan Refuses to Engage in De bates “With Anyone.” W. J. and Darrow Have Another Tilt at Dayton. WASHINGTON, July 22.—(jT»>—'Tre usury oHicinls wore1 ordered liy rt local
After Scopes was convicted and fined $100, Clarence Darrow issued a public statement responding to William Jennings Bryan's questions about his views on miracles, the afterlife, and biblical interpretation, after Judge Raulston had struck Darrow's cross-examination of Bryan from the record. The article also notes the trial's unusual features and that Scopes's conviction would be appealed to the Tennessee Supreme Court in September.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 22 July 1925 · page 1
I for proof i f an after life without tind ling "evidenet* on the subject.” lie re piifd yesterday to a series id' question propounded by William Jennings Hr) an as an after math of the Scopes evolutio trial eonvieli: n. Mr. Harrow, described by .Mr. Hry an as oar exhibit of "A finished pro duct of evolution," had subjected the commoner on the witness stand the day before to a close examination on tUa. lit era), interpretation of the Bible and tile Scopes prosecutor had export ed to retaliate in kind.
See moreSee less
lie was forc ed, however, to the medium of a pub lic statement when Judge Raulston struck his testimony from the court record. Harrow declared that he still was seeking evidence on possible life be yond the grave, said lie lmd no know ledge of I lie origin of (lie nniver.se and what is hack of it. locked on the Bible as any other great hook and lielieved "The Christ that was foretold m the old testament was simply a great Jew who should deliver the Jews from phy sical bondage." The lirst act of the Tennessee evolu tb n drama which had a world ns audi ence. closed with the conviction of John T. Scopes. After a brief inter mission there will lie a new scene and new actors as the young biology teach er's conviction and fine of ?I<K) f< r having taught that man descended from a lower life, come before the Ten nessee Supreme Court at Nashville in September on appeal. IVculiar Trial From a legal standpoint. the eight day trial hail many peculiarities. The jury was barred from the court room most of the time. The defense’s pro verbial day ill court, simmered down to exactly two minutes, the brief inter val in which heads the Judge before sentence was passed. Walter White, superintendent of ltliea county schools, and prosecutor of the case, announced la' had drafted an "anti-evolution bill" which he would ask Representative W. I >. t'p shnw. of Georgia, to introduce into Congress. Mr. i pshaw expressed the belief that the question best could be handled by individual states, although he was "open to conviction.” l’uhlie statements by the principles marked the conclusion of (lie trial. Mr. Bryan asserted that Harrow lied "slurred the Bible, insulted the Court, shown his contempt f< r everything Christian and everybody identified with Christianity.” Mr. Harrow, itt replying, declared lie was inclined to think that intelli gent religionists would like to get rid 1 of Mr. Bryan." Dudley Field Malone said the ob ject of defense had liecn fulfilled. "It lias been necessary to expose the ob jects and pretentions of Mr. Bryan’s present leadership. After his examin ation by Clarence Harrow no intelli gent iierson in America can believe that Mr. Bryan is an authority on science, education or the Bilde." No More Debates
The report recaps the end of the Scopes trial, noting Scopes's conviction and $100 fine, and plans to appeal to the Tennessee Supreme Court. It also details public statements by Bryan, Darrow, and Malone, plus Bryan's announcement refusing further debates.
Following John Scopes's conviction and $100 fine for teaching evolution, chief defense counsel John R. Neal began preparing the trial record for submission to the Tennessee Supreme Court. The case's venue shifts from Dayton to Knoxville, where the court will hear the appeal in September.
Paper unidentified · 22 July 1925 · page 1
APPEAL BEING DRAFTED FROM CONVICTION OF EVOLUTION INSTRUCTOR
tioned but will probably be passed (Continued on Page Five) from Dayton to Knoxville With 'Appeal of Scopes Case ready for the printer. teinber. Bethlehem Mines corporation.
Following the trial verdict, defense attorneys were preparing an appeal to be heard in Knoxville, with John R. Neal as senior counsel though other associates might not include those from the trial. Bainbridge Colby, though absent, was reported to remain a member of the defense team despite not yet confirming he would argue before the supreme court.
Paper unidentified · 22 July 1925 · page 1
Jackson and failure to be heard on tho "evolution i®sue" in September would result ir a delay of one year. In connection with the perfection of tho appeal It was pointed out that a new’lineup of lawyers may be found when the case is heard In Knoxville. John 11. Neal, ns senior counsel, was expected to represent the de fense but his associates may not be those who appeared in the trial court. Bainbridge Colby, former secretary of state, an active figure In the case before the trial at Day ton, wa« not present here but his associates jtolntsd out that he had not withdrawn and was a member of defense counsel.
See moreSee less
Asked If Mr. Colby would make an argument be fnre the supreme court. Dr. Neal •aid that while be was nut prepared (Continued on Page Five) COUNTY CERTIFICATES HELD BY
This item presents three photographs of William Jennings Bryan captured during what is called his greatest recent oratorical effort, delivered as a plea to the court in Dayton, Tennessee. The caption identifies the speech as part of his argument defending the state's anti-evolution law.
Paper unidentified · 22 July 1925 · page 1
( wl Here are three pictures of William Jennings Bryan taken during his greatest oratorical effort of recent years—his plea to the court at Day ton, Tenn., that the anti-evolution
Following the end of the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, a Baptist Young People's Union assembly in Mandeville, Louisiana offered a prayer for defense attorney Clarence Darrow's conversion to Christianity. The prayer, suggested by state secretary E.D. Solomano, expressed hope that Darrow might be won to faith as St. Paul was, concluding with a chorus of 'amens'.
Paper unidentified · 22 July 1925 · page 5
PRAYER FOR C. DARROW IS OFFERED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The report describes the aftermath of the Scopes trial, noting that attorneys are drafting an appeal and that a separate federal court challenge to the anti-evolution law may be pursued via a taxpayer petition. It also notes the dispersal of key figures from Dayton, including Darrow, Bryan, and Scopes, with details on their upcoming schedules.
Paper unidentified · 22 July 1925 · page 5
APPEAL BEING DRAFTED TODAY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A Treasury Department employee asked the District of Columbia Supreme Court to stop paying salaries to teachers who instruct evolutionary theory, calling it disrespectful to the Bible. The judge ordered school officials to appear July 28 to explain why such payments should not be halted.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 1
SEATTLE, July 32.—Capt. M. M. Jensen, master Admiral line vessels and Mrs. M. Grace Brumbaugh, widow of former Fairbanks busi ness man were married here today .__ SEATTLE, July 22.—Dan Salt, boxing promoter of the firm of Austin and Salt, died this afternoon following an operation for peri tonitis. -4 WASHINGTON, July 22.—The conflict between religion and science as exemplified in the Scopes anti evolution trial in Tennessee, came squarely before the Federal courts in the District of Columbia. De claring that the children in the national capital are being taught disrespect of the of the Holy Bible.
See moreSee less
Loren H. Wittner asked the Dis trict Supreme Court to enjoin the city's fiscal agents from paying salaries to instructors who teach the evolutionary theory of the origin of man in conflict with Divine creation. Wittn'er is an em ployee in the Treasury department. Justice Siddons ordered the defend ants named by Wittner to appear before the court on July 28 and show cause why payment of salarier to instructors teaching scientific theories in conflict with Bible teachings should not be stopped. ---+- -• -
The article recounts a lesser-known 1884 'evolution trial' of Rev. James Woodrow, uncle of Woodrow Wilson, who was tried for heresy after teaching Darwinian evolution at a Presbyterian seminary in South Carolina. It notes the case drew comparable attention to the Scopes trial and that Woodrow Wilson was indignant at his uncle's conviction.
Seward Daily Gateway · 23 July 1925 · page 4
EVOLUTION TRIAL IN 1884.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A humor column in a Stuttgart, Arkansas newspaper jokes about swimmers resembling creatures that Scopes trial experts testified about regarding human ancestry. The piece is light local commentary mixed with other jokes about town life, unrelated to direct trial reporting.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 7
STUTTGARETTES
We took a swim in White River last Sunday and if some of the experts who gave testimony in the Scopes trial, had been there they
Walter White, Rhea County schools superintendent and Scopes trial prosecutor, announced in Dayton that citizens plan to establish a fundamentalist college there. They intend to invite William Jennings Bryan to serve as its president.
Paris Express · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paris Express · Paris, Ark.
Dr. John Roach Stratton characterized Clarence Darrow as having 'the look of the devil' while comparing William Jennings Bryan to Christ. Bryan telegrammed Stratton asking him to come testify for the prosecution if expert scientific testimony is allowed for the defense.
Paris Express · 23 July 1925 · page 3
DARROW PERSONIFIES DEVIL, PASTOR SAYS
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Paris Express · Paris, Ark. · and 3 other papers
The defense's motion to quash the indictment was overruled by the court, giving Clarence Darrow an opportunity for an extended speech denouncing the anti-evolution law and Bryan. The jury was then sworn in, with Attorney General Stewart opening for the prosecution and Dudley Field Malone giving the defense's opening statement distinguishing evolution from Bryan's version of Christianity.
Paris Express · 23 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Also printed in 3 papers
The Saratoga Sun · Saratoga, Wyo. · 23 July 1925
The Midland Journal · Rising Sun, Md. · 24 July 1925
The Harlem News · Harlem, Mont. · 31 July 1925
Paris Express · Paris, Ark.
Circuit Judge John T. Raulston ruled the Tennessee anti-evolution statute constitutional, overruling the defense's demurrer and denying its motion to quash the indictment. The trial will proceed, with the defense planning an eventual appeal to higher courts regardless of the verdict.
Paris Express · 23 July 1925 · page 6
SCOPES TRIAL JUDGE DENIES QUASH MOTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Forrest City Times and Herald · Forrest City, Ark.
A filler item remarks that 300,000 words were telegraphed in a single day from the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee. It jokes that at this rate the trial might surpass Congress for talking records.
The Forrest City Times and Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Arkansas Echo · Little Rock, Ark.
The piece argues that Tennessee's law, central to the Scopes trial in Dayton, does not ban teaching evolution everywhere but only forbids denying the biblical creation account in state-funded schools. It frames the law as a matter of religious neutrality in public education rather than an attack on evolutionary theory itself.
Arkansas Echo · 23 July 1925 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report states that the trial in Dayton, Tennessee concluded on Monday with teacher Scopes found guilty by the jury of violating the law banning the teaching of evolution in public schools. He was fined $100, and the case will be appealed.
Arkansas Echo · 23 July 1925 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Courier-Index · Marianna, Ark.
An Arkansas newspaper editorial downplays the Scopes trial as a harmless publicity stunt for Dayton, Tennessee, predicting Scopes will be convicted and fined a nominal amount. It also notes Arkansas nearly passed its own anti-evolution law in recent legislative sessions.
The Courier-Index · 23 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Courier-Index · Marianna, Ark.
The article discusses how the Scopes trial in Tennessee is drawing attention to the teaching of evolution in schools, noting that Arkansas narrowly avoided similar legislation in past sessions. It predicts future legislative battles in Arkansas over the issue, especially if the Tennessee law is upheld.
The Courier-Index · 23 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Pocahontas Star Herald · Pocahontas, Ark.
An Arkansas newspaper commentary contrasts the state's industrial cotton-mill ambitions with the ongoing Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee, dismissing it as a harmless publicity stunt. The piece predicts Scopes will be convicted and fined a nominal amount, while teachers and preachers will continue as before regardless of the verdict.
Pocahontas Star Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 7
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Pocahontas Star Herald · Pocahontas, Ark.
An editorial predicts Professor Scopes will be convicted under Tennessee's anti-evolution law and given a nominal fine, which Darwinists will pay for him, while teaching and preaching continue unchanged. It recalls that Arkansas narrowly avoided similar legislation and predicts a hard legislative fight in 1927 if the Tennessee law is upheld.
Pocahontas Star Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 7
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.
The day after the trial concluded, Dayton, Tennessee settled back to its usual quiet pace as carnival stands emptied and crowds dispersed. Scopes planned to return home to Kentucky, Bryan prepared to travel to Winchester for addresses, and Darrow remained briefly before a lecture in Knoxville.
El Dorado Daily News · 23 July 1925 · page 2
DAYTON TAKES STOCK OF SELF
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.
This photo feature shows Clarence Darrow during his impassioned courtroom attack on 'bigotry' at the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, with William Jennings Bryan and his son pictured nearby. It also includes a photo of Judge John T. Raulston reading his ruling upholding Tennessee's anti-evolution law, with a policeman fanning him to keep sweat from his eyes.
El Dorado Daily News · 23 July 1925 · page 8
WORLD NEWS TOLD IN PICTURES
When Darrow Opened Assualt on * This was snapped during Clarence Darrow s impassioned asualt on ‘bigotry" during the 8.opes trial at Dayton, Tenn ounse!— including Willn Jennings Bryan, at the right, and his son at ce left. Bigotry A portion of the defense
A photo shows Mrs. Darrow, wife of attorney Clarence Darrow, sitting in the courtroom during the Scopes evolution trial. The caption notes she shares her husband's agnostic views and supports his defense of John T. Scopes.
El Dorado Daily News · 23 July 1925 · page 8
WORLD NEWS TOLD IN PICTURES
Evolution Trial rence Darrow, wife or the famous lawyer, as she sat in courtrorn watching her hushand help defend John T. the Day Scopes. Sha enthustastically shares Durtow’s "agnostic" views. Up She Goes!
An Arkansas newspaper editorial comments on the ongoing Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee, dismissing it as a harmless publicity stunt for a previously obscure town. It predicts Scopes will be convicted and fined a nominal amount, and notes Arkansas narrowly avoided similar controversy when anti-evolution bills were introduced but failed in its own legislature.
Malvern Times=journal · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Malvern Times=journal · Malvern, Ark.
This editorial discusses how Arkansas narrowly avoided similar controversy when anti-evolution bills in the state legislature failed to pass in recent sessions. It notes evolution is widely taught despite objections, and predicts a renewed legislative fight in 1927, especially if Tennessee's law is upheld.
Malvern Times=journal · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Malvern Times=journal · Malvern, Ark.
The report states that an anti-evolution bill modeled on Tennessee's law is expected to be introduced in the next Congress, possibly by Representative T. Will Taylor or W. D. Upshaw. It credits Rhea County schools superintendent Walter White, the chief prosecution witness against Scopes, as the leader pushing for this federal measure.
Malvern Times=journal · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Evolution Bill in Congress Forecast - Reported Measure Similar to Tennessee's Will Be Up
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Malvern Times=journal · Malvern, Ark.
This editorial opinion piece notes that the Scopes evolution trial has ended, with Scopes convicted and fined $100. The writer argues the trial changed no one's mind about evolution versus the Bible, and mainly served to give Bryan and Darrow publicity.
Malvern Times=journal · 23 July 1925 · page 4
The evolution trial is over—Scopes is convicted and a fine of SIOO has been assessed against him. Those of us who believe in the Bible havn’t changed our minds about the old Book. Those who believe that they descended from apes have the privilege of continuing their belief. After all what has it amounted to except to give Bill Bryan and Clar ence Darrow a lot of publicity. The American people refuse to be excited
Circuit Judge John T. Raulston ruled the Tennessee anti-evolution statute constitutional, overruling the defense's demurrer and denying its motion to quash the indictment against Scopes. The defense plans to appeal to the Tennessee and U.S. Supreme Courts if Scopes is convicted, as the constitutionality question will ultimately need resolution by higher courts.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 2
SCOPES TRIAL JUDGE DENIES QUASH MOTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Bryan responds to Darrow's cross-examination, claiming it was unfair for Darrow to exploit his lack of specialized technical knowledge in fields like paleontology and philology. He argues that no one can be expected to be an expert in every scientific field, citing statistics on the rarity of specialized scientists in America.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 2
DARROW'S CHARGE OF IGNORANCE UNFAIR, BRYAN CLAIMS IN ANSWER
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
The day after the Scopes trial concluded, Dayton, Tennessee settled back into normalcy as the carnival atmosphere faded and concession stands sat empty. Scopes planned to leave for Paducah, Kentucky, uncertain of his future plans, while discussions continued about a possible fundamentalist university and Bryan's upcoming addresses in Winchester.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
A satirical opinion column comments on the Scopes trial wrapping up in Dayton and moving to political debate in Washington, mocking Bryan's views on evolution and noting Scopes received the court's verdict with his coat off. It mixes trial commentary with unrelated humor about Southern politics, smoke, and automobiles.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Will the Vaudeville circuit or the moviea sign up Bryan and Darrow? While the moonlight holds out to bum the wiliest batchelor may be interned. Speaking of unnecessary things, the Florence times mentions Thrift Week in Scotland. Two thirds of the billion, seven hundred million people in the world are in need of a fresh start. John Scopes’s picture shows that he received the court’s lash Tuesday with his coat off. The jawing festival closes in Dayton and opens for an endefinite engagement in Washington. Liberty and prejudice are incompatible, and prejudice is stronger in the land than the love of liberty. Mr. Bryan seems to think it is more re
A letter to the editor endorses Richard H. Edmonds' editorial attacking the American Civil Liberties Union, which was representing Scopes in the Tennessee trial. The letter quotes claims that the ACLU is linked to communism and pacifist groups allegedly tied to wartime German agents.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 4
EDITOR EDMONDS’ CRITICISM OP C|V1I« LIBERTIES UNION Editor The Advertiser: Mr. Richard H. Edmonds, the editor of the Manufacturers’ Record, has performed a noteworthy service in turning: the light upon the “American Civil Liberties Union/' in connection with the Scopes cane in Ten nessee” and he terms that "Union” a “dis reputable organization which has little or nothing to its credit and much to its dis credit.” For space reasons a part of his edi torial will be omitted here, but he says: ‘Through this ‘sensation' |he American Civil Liberties Union is garnering a crop of publicity, or notoriety, which may fur ther delude uninformed, well-meaning per sons into belief that It is a decent organi zation and worthy of confidence and sup port.
See moreSee less
For the enlightenment of such per sons we once again print part of various descriptions of this association by the late R. M. Whitney, an authority on communism and author of ”Reds in Afnerica,” and then quptes Mr. Whitney:
A forum of letters to the editor includes one mocking the founding of 'Bryan University' at Dayton with ironic references to evolutionists' donations, and another criticizing Bryan's reliance on 'majority' opinion during the ongoing Scopes trial. The letters reflect public reaction to the courtroom proceedings as they unfold.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 4
BRYAN UNIVERSITY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A humor column by H. I. Phillips lampoons the endless motions, jury walkouts, and courtroom confusion at the Scopes trial, inventing a mock witness named Amos Q. Pipp who claims to be an evolutionist. It also includes a reader's letter from O. A. Peterson criticizing religious persecution and praising evolution over Bryan's opposition.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A humor piece satirizing the Scopes trial, featuring a fictional 'expert witness' Amos Q. Pipp giving absurd testimony about evolution involving poker hands, vegetables, and baseball. The piece mocks the courtroom atmosphere, the jury's frustration, and the scientific arguments being made by both sides.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 4
LATE RETURNS FROM DAYTON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
After the trial's end, a report describes John Scopes as an intelligent young man wanting to pursue biology as a career, with friends seeking a scholarship for him. It also notes Dayton returning to its quiet routine after the trial's conclusion.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 2
SCOPES ASPIRES TO MAKE BIOLOGY HIS LIFE WORK
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
After the Scopes trial concluded, Dayton quickly resumed its quiet pace while John Scopes made plans to continue his scientific studies and visit family. Despite courtroom hostility, opposing lawyers became friendly, symbolized by a reporters' dance where Darrow and prosecution attorneys mingled warmly.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
The Birmingham Civitan club's Friday luncheon will focus on safety topics with a National Safety Council speaker, but will also feature a prominent visitor from the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tenn. This visitor will respond to an evolution-related attack made by a local pastor at a previous meeting.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 1
SAFETY DAY PROGRAM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Dr. Roy G. Hershey spoke at a Presbyterian prayer service defending Christian evidences including design, adaptation, and order in creation. He criticized evolutionary teaching such as that attributed to Professor Scopes, arguing man is a distinct creation rather than an accident of nature.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 16
BIBLE DEFENDED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A scientific expedition led by Beloit College researchers, accompanied by Count Byron de Prorok and others, plans to explore the Sahara's Haggar peaks seeking evidence of human origins. Friends of the scientists emphasized the expedition was purely scientific and unrelated to the Scopes evolution trial.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 12
GREAT SAHARA
ber 1. Friends of the scientists today empha sized that the expedition was purely scientific and had nothing to do with the Scopes evolution trial. WASHINGTON. July 22 Crop and weather conditions in southern states
Dr. J. R. Hobbs, a Birmingham Baptist pastor, addressed a business club luncheon explaining the legal and scientific issues behind the Scopes trial. He clarified that evolution theory holds humans and apes share a common ancestor, not that man descended from monkeys, then began refuting the theory.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 12
Is About’ Members of the American Business club Wednesday had the opportunity : of hearing a brief but comprehensive discussion of the Scopes trial at Dayton and more particularly the subject of evolution in general, when Dr. J. R. Hobbs, pastor of the First Baptist church of Birmingham, spoke at the weekly luncheon at First Methodist , church, Ensley. Dr. Hobbs, who is considered a capa ble student of evolution and has for many years been a close observer of the subject, chose as his subject, “What’s All This Money Business About.” He at first reviewed briefly the circum stances of the Scopes trial.
See moreSee less
The legal issue at stake in the Day ton trial, said Dr. Hobbs, was, of course. | the question of whether or not the slate of Tennessee has the right to regulate the teachings of its schools. But at the bottom of the whole affair, continued the speaker, is the matter of evolution, which has not been settled at all. He then sought to interpret the meaning of the word "evolution,” as applied to the issue of the moment. Many, said Dr. Hobbs, understand the term to imply growth—growth of any sort along any line. This, he said, is a mistaken impression, for the true defi nition of the word as applied to the issue under debate today is organic evolution, which contends that all aniJ mal life on this earth has come from a common progenitor, and that it has progressed from its least form to its j present state. Man did not descend or ascend, said the speaker, from the monkey; rather, the money and man evolved from the same "grandfather. ’ if we adhere to the generally accepted Idea of evolution. Dr. Hobbs enumerated three points in refuting tbe theory of organic evolu tion. First, he called attention to the fact that defenders of the theory in their books rarely if ever made a state ment as a matter of fact, qualifying their writings, rather, by a succession oi "perhaps's, ’ and using “assumptions" rather than assertions. Again, he as serted, never in the history of mankind j has there been evolution, for, physically, ! men were stronger In older times, while s there has been little if any intelletual j evolution. Dr. Hobbs closed his talk by mentioning the three usual lines of argument advanced by evolutionists— morphology, ontogeny, and palentology —and offering a refutation of each of
The article explains that John Thomas Scopes, a 24-year-old biology teacher in Dayton, violated Tennessee's anti-evolution law by teaching that man descended from lower life forms. It details how William Jennings Bryan championed the law's passage in 1922, which initially drew little global attention but was taken very seriously in Tennessee.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Como se Inició el Famoso Proceso del Profesor Scopes
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The article recounts how Tennessee's anti-evolution law was passed in 1922 with little global attention until Bryan championed it, then describes a meeting at Robinson's Drugstore in Dayton where Scopes told friends he could not teach biology without violating the law. It dramatizes the origin of the test case through dialogue among Scopes, Rappleyea, Haggard, and Hicks.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The passage presents a fictionalized dialogue reconstructing the original conversation in Rappleyea's drugstore where Scopes agreed to test the anti-evolution law, including his arrest the next morning. It also notes a lighter sidebar about Dayton girls carrying toy monkeys as souvenirs now that the case has moved to Washington on appeal.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report recounts how Scopes was charged by Hicks and McKenzie for violating the anti-evolution law, and describes the flood of telegrams that followed. Dudley Field Malone urged him to plead innocent and seek bail, while William Jennings Bryan offered to assist the prosecution to defend Christianity.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes how public interest in the Scopes trial grew after telegrams from supporters and from William Jennings Bryan offering to assist the prosecution. It notes Clarence Darrow joining the defense team, international scientific and literary figures supporting Scopes, and summarizes the opposing positions of Bryan and Darrow as the trial begins.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The article recounts the global attention the Scopes trial drew, including support from figures like Bernard Shaw, and summarizes the opposing positions of Bryan and Darrow. It reports that the jury found Scopes guilty of violating Tennessee's anti-evolution law after only nine minutes of deliberation, with an appeal to the Supreme Court expected to address the law's constitutionality.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Loren H. Wittner, a self-declared atheist and former congressional candidate, filed suit in Washington D.C. to challenge a federal appropriations provision barring teachers from showing 'disrespect' for the Bible. He and his attorneys hope the case will allow direct scientific testimony in court, something the Scopes trial's format did not permit.
New Britain Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 18
PLANS COMPLETE EVOLUTION TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
A separate legal dispute in Washington D.C. concerns a congressional rider restricting school curricula, with officials debating its constitutionality under the First Amendment. Darrow and Bryan, both involved in the Dayton Scopes trial, commented on this unrelated suit, with Darrow calling it bigotry and Bryan welcoming the publicity.
New Britain Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 18
EVOLUTION TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Imperial Valley Press · El Centro, Calif.
The Justice Department will represent District of Columbia authorities in a lawsuit testing whether teaching evolution in public schools is legal, with the Treasury Department involved since it pays teacher salaries. The suit, inspired by issues raised in the Scopes trial, challenges a law banning teaching that shows 'disrespect to the Holy Bible.'
Imperial Valley Press · 23 July 1925 · page 1
U. S. TREASURY IS INVOLVED, NEW EVOLUTION CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A Dayton dispatch reports that Walter White, the local prosecutor in the Scopes case, has drafted a federal anti-evolution bill modeled on Tennessee's statute, which would cut off federal funds from schools and institutions teaching evolution. The report notes this could affect the Smithsonian, National Museum, West Point, Annapolis, and school systems in federal territories.
Evening Star · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Blow to Research Here Is Seen In Federal Evolution Statute Smithsonian and National Museums and Schools Would Be Hit Hard by Bill of Tennessean
Bill of Tennessean. BY ROBERT T. SMALL. DAYTON, Tenn., July 23.—Not only is there to be a real anti-evolution bill introduced In the next session of Con gress at Washington, but it will be'al most Identic with the statute. It will provide that all Fed eral aid and financial support be with held from any school t>r institution which permits the teaching of any theory of evolution denies “the story of the divlnp Creation of man, as taught in the Bible, or which contends that man has descended from a lower order of animals.” If such a* law should pass, it would affect allAhe public school systems of the District of Columbia.
See moreSee less
Hawaii, Alaska. Porto Rico and the Philip pines. to say nothing of the Military Academy at West Point and the Naval Academy at Annapolis. It also would withhold support from the Smithso nian Institution and the National Mu seum at Washington, both of which have been engaged in research work along evolutionary lines. Walter White, superintendent of in struction in this district of Tennessee, who was the official prosecutor of young Scopes, already has drawn up the bill for Introduction in Congress, and told the writer today that he has arranged for Its formal presentation, although it has been published that one or two of Tennessee’s Congress men have declined to stand sponsor for the proposed measure. Mr. White expects that other anti evolution measures wilkjpour Into the of Olives. theory of evolution.
A report describes plans to use the Tennessee anti-evolution statute as a model for proposed federal legislation, with support expected from William Jennings Bryan. Bryan intends to campaign against the 'evolution conspiracy' before leading a pilgrimage to the Holy Land next February.
Evening Star · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Bill of Tennessean. Hawse and Senate before the session is a week old next December, but he believes by that time the appellate courts of this State will have upheld the Tennessee statute, and that it will be taken as a model for the pro posed Federal legislation. Mr. White said he had not consulted William Jen nings Bryan as to his support, but that he expects it. Mr. Bryan purposes to devote a great deal of attention to at tacking the “evolution conspiracy” prior to the time that he leads his pil grimage to the Holy Lands next Feb ruary, to spend Easter on the Mount of Olives.
See moreSee less
Among the anti-evolutionists here the move at Washington to stop sup port of the District of Columbia schools under the existing statute, which withholds payment to any person who “teaches disrespect for the Bible.’’ is regarded as a symptom rather than a forceful step against the “evolutionist propaganda” which is sweeping the country. The clause in the District of Columbia statute is not regarded as comprehensive enough to reach the theory of evolution. The anti-evolutionists place great store by the phrase in the Tennessee law which forbids teaching that “man descended from a lower order of ani mals.” There are many things in the many theories of evolution which the anti’s admit they cannot put a finger on, but they can say that the children of the country shall not be made to believe that “man descended from a (Continued on Page 5, Column 1.l
Dr. Paul Bartsch, curator of mollusks at the National Museum, told a Lions Club luncheon that the Dayton trial was 'an unfortunate affair and no trial at all' regarding evolution, calling William Jennings Bryan a 'quack' for claiming scientific authority. He argued the monkey-ancestry question was only a secondary issue within the larger theory of evolution, and that the trial had stirred up bigotry and distrust reminiscent of the Crusades.
Evening Star · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Dr. Bartsch and Bishop Barnes discuss evolution science, arguing there is no conflict between religion and scientific truth. They criticize Tennessee's attempt to suppress well-established scientific research during the trial.
Evening Star · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
William Jennings Bryan defends himself against the charge that Clarence Darrow exploited his lack of technical scientific knowledge during questioning in the Scopes trial. Bryan argues it is unfair to judge someone for lacking expertise in specialized sciences like paleontology and philology when so few Americans are true specialists in any one field.
Evening Star · 23 July 1925 · page 5
BRYAN CONFESSES LACK OF SCIENCE
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The article discusses the narrow legal scope of the Scopes case as defined by Judge Raulston, focusing on the phrase about descent from a lower order of animals. It explores evolutionists' arguments against anti-evolution laws, including concerns about future legislation and the Smithsonian's view on funding risks.
Evening Star · 23 July 1925 · page 5
BLOW TO U. S. RESEARCH IN STATUTE STRIKING AT EVOLUTION THEORY
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
An editorial discusses a lawsuit filed in Washington D.C. seeking to block school officials' salaries over alleged teaching of 'disrespect for the Holy Bible,' comparing it mockingly to the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee. The writer argues the suit is absurd, particularly objections to teaching the earth is round, and predicts it won't succeed in court.
Evening Star · 23 July 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
An editorial criticizes a quietly-passed D.C. appropriation bill rider barring school funding if staff teach 'disrespect' for the Bible, arguing it could absurdly ban teaching that the earth is round. It references the recent Dayton trial, hoping D.C. does not become another forum for an evolution-versus-Bible courtroom spectacle.
Evening Star · 23 July 1925 · page 6
WASHINGTON, D. C.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The passage is a mix of items: diplomatic sentiments between the US and Australia, a remark that Dayton, Tenn. will be remembered as an intellectual battleground despite no commercial gain, and a report on farm-to-city population movement trends. The Scopes trial is referenced only briefly as a side note about Dayton's lasting notoriety.
Evening Star · 23 July 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
This page features a photograph caption describing William Jennings Bryan, 'the defender of the Bible,' taking the witness stand during the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee. It appears amid a jumble of unrelated wire photo captions on fashion, politics, and inventions.
Evening Star · 23 July 1925 · page 17
WHEN THE DEFENDER OF THE BIBLE TOOK THE STAND AT DAYTON, TENN.
when thr-y appear on the sands the camera men are sure to flock around. row > attorney for the defense in the Scopes case. The photograph was taken after the judge decided to hold the closing session of the trial in J beach at the famous French watering place, Deauville. Many Americans The phiAtrgrspk tells the story. Wide World Photo. 1 the yard of the little Dayton courthouse. United News Pictures. { are spending the Summer at the resort. Wide World Photo.
Newspaper publisher E. W. Scripps, interviewed in Baltimore after a world cruise, predicted anti-evolution sentiment would spread across America like Prohibition did. He said the public misunderstood the Dayton trial as a religious issue and praised both Bryan and Darrow as opposites in knowledge and conviction.
The Washington Daily News · 23 July 1925 · page 3
Scripps Sees Rapid Spread of Bryanism Anti-Evolution Sentiment to Sweep Country Like Prohibition, Publisher Believes
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
A series of captioned photographs recounts the close of the Scopes trial, showing Scopes fined $100 and appealing, and the dramatic courtroom exchange between Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan over biblical literalism. Bryan is pictured on the stand insisting 'The Bible states it, it must be so' under Darrow's questioning.
The Washington Daily News · 23 July 1925 · page 3
LENS RECORDS DAYTON WINDUP
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Doris Stevens, who helped her husband Dudley Field Malone prepare the Scopes defense, comments on a new evolution case pending in Washington D.C. courts. She expresses hope it will thoroughly settle the science-versus-religion debate and elevate the teaching profession nationally.
The Washington Times · 23 July 1925 · page 1
EVOLUTION CASE CALLED BOON
Field Is Broadened. "The fact that not only the teaching of evolution, but the teach ing of geography and physics, in short the whole scientific field,
Following the Dayton trial, a Washington D.C. case was filed by federal employee Loren Wittner against school officials for teaching evolution, calling it disrespectful to the Bible. Corporation counsel Frank Stephens says he found errors in the suit and plans to seek its dismissal, while Scopes trial participant Doris Stevens discusses the broader fight for academic freedom.
The Washington Times · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Asked whether her husband and Clarence Darrow would come co Washington to participate In the local proceedings, Miss Stevens said that the Washington issue had been raised since she left Dayton and she had not been able to speak *to them about it. She said they were exhausted by the strain of the Day toon trial and she did not believe they would be willing to plunge in to another similar ordeal immedi ately. Official in Woman’s Party Miss Stevens, who is a vi<'e presi dent of the National Woman’s Party, will speak ip the garden at the party headquarters, 21 First street northeast, at 8 o’clock to night. She is expected to tell of her experiences and the issues in volved in the Dayton triad. The public is
Monroe Wittner, a self-described atheist, has filed suit in Washington D.C. challenging a congressional law requiring Bible teachings in schools, hoping his case reaches the Supreme Court before the Scopes case. He argues the law unconstitutionally unites church and state and could soon force a court hearing on whether Congress can mandate religious doctrine as science.
The Washington Times · 23 July 1925 · page 2
He has brought suit, he said, in the hope that it will reach the Su preme Court before the Scopes case can come up through the more de vious channels of the State courts.
A separate suit by a self-declared atheist named Wittner challenges Tennessee's anti-evolution statute as unconstitutional, arguing it establishes religion in violation of church-state separation. He sent a telegram to Clarence Darrow seeking advice and hoped Darrow and Bryan might oppose each other locally, while biology teacher W.P. Hay defended his teaching of evolution as theory, not fact.
The Washington Times · 23 July 1925 · page 2
of the ilk of William Jennings Bryan has crept into our schools, halting liberal education.” The remedy for this condition lies in the power of Congress, but first the courts must rule against the mention of religion in legislation, in Wittner’s opinion. "Education." he declared, "must be loosed from the fetters of Intoler ance and placed upon a high plane of liberalism.” It was deemed unlikely today that either Clarence Darrow or William Jennings Bryan will actively par ticipate in the local case.
A Washington social column announces a reception for Doris Stevens, wife of defense attorney Dudley Field Malone, hosted by the National Woman's Party. Stevens, fresh from assisting her husband in Dayton, Tennessee, will address the Scopes trial 'from a woman's angle.'
The Washington Times · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper
Defense attorney Dr. John R. Neal announces plans to bring a new federal court challenge to Tennessee's anti-evolution law within a month, separate from the state appeal of Scopes' conviction. The move, based on an earlier injunction petition, will bring Bainbridge Colby back into the case and may sideline William J. Bryan.
The Washington Times · 23 July 1925 · page 22
SCOPES CASE TO GO TO U.S. COURT Dr. Neal, Chief of Defense Counsel, to Bring New Attack on Law
weeks ago by Federal Judge John J. Gore at Cookeville, Tennessee. In entering Federal jurisdiction without awaiting the decision of the Tennessee State supreme court the Interests of Scopes will be directed ; by Bainbridge Colby, former Secre tary of State, and mark his active return to the case. It also will mark the passing of a majority of the lawyers who held the spotlight at the Scopes trial here. Cm the State’s side, the law will be defend ed by State Attorney General Frank Thompson and any other counsel he Invites to his side.
See moreSee less
This may mean the elimination of William J. Bryan, who ranked as the prosecution’s star counsel here. Win-Right to Hearing Filing of the petition before Judge Gore, it was learned, gave the Scopes defense attorneys the right to a hearing before three Federal judges on the constitutional issue. The defense will take advantage of this legal maneuver within the next month, after serving a required five days’ notice upon the Governor of Tennessee and Attorney General Thompson. At present, defense counsel are awaiting the return of Federal Judge Xen O. Hicks to Chattanooga before settling a def inite date for the hearing. This procedure was agreed upon by defense counsel, it was learned, because the plunge into Federal jurisdiction may result 1n the anti evolution law being held uncon stitutional before the Tennessee State supreme court meets in September to hear the appeal of Scopes’ conviction. In addition, the defense also will provide two direct avenues of approach to the United States Supreme Court even if they lose both battles in the lower courts. Dayton Normal Again Dayton, meanwhile, returned to normalcy. Except for the flaming banner of Evangelist T. T. Martin, announcing “Hell in the High Schools,” the town’s smattering of ••Read Your Bible” signs and the •'Where It Started” advertising at Robinson’s drug store, there are few visual evidences of the trial. The streets have been cleared of the concessionaire stands, which turned the town into a fair grounds midway and the crowds have departed. . I Young John Thomas Scopes, who will return to his Paducah, Ky., home Saturday for a month’s vaca tion, spent the day motoring with his school friends and in visiting the old swimming hole. All de fense attorneys, save Neal, have left for their homes, Clarence Dar row stopping off at Knoxville to night for a public address.
After Scopes' conviction, defense attorneys plan a federal constitutional challenge while awaiting the state supreme court appeal, with Bainbridge Colby potentially replacing Bryan as lead counsel. Dayton has returned to normalcy as Scopes heads home for vacation and most attorneys depart, leaving only Bryan to fulfill a speaking engagement before leaving for Florida.
The Fitzgerald Leader Enterprise and Press · Fitzgerald, Georgia
The article recounts the 1884 heresy trial of Rev. James Woodrow, uncle of Woodrow Wilson, who was convicted for teaching Darwinian evolution at a Presbyterian seminary in South Carolina. It notes his conviction was later reversed by higher church authorities and he went on to serve as college president until retiring in 1897.
The Fitzgerald Leader Enterprise and Press · 23 July 1925 · page 5
NOTHING NEW UNDER THE SUN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Fitzgerald Leader Enterprise and Press · Fitzgerald, Georgia
Following the fundamentalist victory in the Dayton, Tennessee evolution trial, plans emerged to build a monument in the form of Bryan College, with a goal of raising $1,000,000. George F. Washburn of Massachusetts and Florida made the first major donation of $25,000, suggesting the cause could unite Protestants and Catholics against atheism.
The Fitzgerald Leader Enterprise and Press · 23 July 1925 · page 5
BRYAN COLLEGE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.
A Presbyterian minister's sermon, delivered during the Scopes trial, argues that the trial will not settle the truth of evolution or the inspiration of Scripture regardless of the verdict. He criticizes religious controversy as counterproductive and lowering one's standards.
Americus Times-Recorder · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.
An opinion piece argues that neither a guilty nor not-guilty verdict for Scopes will prove or disprove evolution or the inspiration of Scripture. It laments that controversy has already led both sides to apologize for unethical conduct, and urges sympathy rather than scorn for those who disagree on faith.
Americus Times-Recorder · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.
A writer expresses personal religious beliefs, affirming the divinity of Christ and creation by God, while objecting to evolution being taught as fact. The piece follows the trial's conclusion, addressing the broader debate over science and religion sparked by Scopes' defense counsel's arguments.
Americus Times-Recorder · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
The passage quotes Charles Darwin expressing discomfort with the idea of total annihilation after humanity's long evolutionary progress, suggesting he believed in some form of immortality. It then discusses commentary from Arthur Brisbane and others reacting to the Scopes trial, including remarks about Bryan's views on Joshua and the sun.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 23 July 1925 · page 4
DARWIN AND IMMORTALITY
{ tality of the soul, the destruction ~ of our world would not appear so ~ dreadful.—Charles Darwin. Caprer's Weekly, getting into the ciscussion over the Scopes case, takes occasion to say a kind word about Charles Darwin, concluding that he was not what Mr. Bryan would term an “unbeliever,” although, of course, Mr. Bryan would not readily under stand what Darwin really'was. With out being sure of anything nor prov en, Darwin is credited with believing in immortality, as revealed in his words here quoted. Assuming that .Darwiix. Darrow and the monkeys have retired to the shad ow, and that Mr.
See moreSee less
Bryan now holds the limelight as the hero of the occasion, Arthur Brisbane spins this line of thought for his readers: “PDarwin didn't take this little world too seriously, knowing that our sun iz only one among milliohs, and our planet ons of the least imponiant among many millions. “But he didn’'t helieve that a system which preserves forever matter and force would doom the only important thing, consciousness, spirit, or soul, to destruction. “At some other tlme,' when minds are calmer an drage dles. down, it will be interesting to hear Mr. Bryan’'s fuller statement in the Bible about, Joshua stopping the sun is literally true. “Of course Mr. Bryan, as an educat ed man, knows that the sun really does not move around the earth. In Joshua’s' day people thougnt that it
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
A Methodist minister in Dayton invited Rev. Charles Francis Potter, a Unitarian minister from New York who had attended the Scopes trial, to preach in his pulpit. Congregation members objected so strongly that the Methodist minister resigned despite efforts by friends and the bishop to reverse the decision.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 23 July 1925 · page 4
THAT METHODIST PREACHER
Sun two or three years agofi which rovealed Dr. Potter in a role which Dayton never woulg tolerate in any man, living or dead. Here is the role in which Dr. Pot ter played in his New York church, fully the boldest play for modernism that the pastor of any church in re cent times is said to have taken. It easily might upset Methodists in Day ton. It would most likely cause those in New York to shake their heads. Here is Small's story as it appeared
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · Cordele, Georgia
The report details the court costs John T. Scopes would owe if the U.S. Supreme Court upholds his conviction, including fees for the attorney general, witnesses, justice of the peace, sheriff, and state expenses. Total additional costs are listed as $35.25, on top of his $100 fine.
The Cordele Dispatch and Daily Sentinel · 23 July 1925 · page 6
A United Press dispatch from Omaha reports that 17-year-old Mary Bell appeared in public with portraits of Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan painted on her knees. Her parents responded by spanking her and sending her to bed upon her return home.
The Indianapolis Times · 23 July 1925 · page 1
4 Evolution Knees 9 Scoured Bu United Press OMAHA, Neb., July 23.—The first pair of “evolution knees” were wrecked on the rocks of parental discipline# Mary Bell, 17-year-old flapper, W'ho yesterday appeared on the streets with a portrait of Clar ence Darrow p,tinted on her right knee and another of William Jennings Bryan on her left, was spanked and put to bed on her return home from the artist’s day. row’s scowl off her knees.
A friendly lawsuit was filed against the U.S. Treasurer seeking to restrain payment of teacher salaries in schools permitting use of scientific texts, citing a law against teachings disrespectful to the Bible. The suit aims to raise the same issues as John T. Scopes' conviction at Dayton, Tennessee, in hopes of a Supreme Court ruling on the anti-evolution law.
The Indianapolis Times · 23 July 1925 · page 1
6 a. m 58 10 a. m 72 7 a. m...... 63 11 a. m 73 8 ain...... 67 12 (noon) m*. 74 f <i WViiOMAS •• 1 P. m-saaea !• schools were referred to the build* lngs and grounds commltttee. cause it pays salaries of teachers here. The suit seeks to restrain Frank White, treasurer of United States, from paying school authorities who permit the use of scientific texts, 1 citing a law which prevent# teach ings “disrespectful to the Holy Bible.” School authorities will be ar raigned In the suit next Tuesday.
See moreSee less
The suit Is a friendly one. involving the Issues raised in the conviction of John T. Scopes at Dayton, Tenn., for teaching evolution, and having for Us aim a decision by the United State Supreme Court on the antis* subject. __ „.. . ..,
The piece argues that allowing scientists to testify likely would not have swayed the jury or Judge, since Bryan himself was unmoved by their statements. It questions the wisdom of the defense's approach, suggesting the deeper fight against a church-controlled state remained unresolved even if Scopes avoided punishment.
The Indianapolis Times · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.
This editorial argues that the defense attorneys' tactic of proving evolution doesn't conflict with the Bible inadvertently concedes the church's right to control education and the state's right to establish religion. It urges the defense to keep the real issue clear in higher courts: that no legislature should impose church control on education.
The Indianapolis Times · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
A reporter profiles John Scopes near the end of the trial, describing his wish to pursue biology as a life work and efforts to secure him a scholarship. The piece portrays him as intelligent and level-headed, uninterested in commercializing his sudden fame.
South Bend News-Times · 23 July 1925 · page 1
SCOPES TO DEVOTE YEARS TO PURSUIT OF BIOLOGY WORK
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
After the trial, John Scopes is described as a level-headed young man eager to pursue scientific study rather than cash in on his fame, while Dayton quickly reverts to its quiet routine. The piece also recounts a friendly dance thrown by reporters for the lawyers and townspeople, highlighting cordial relations despite courtroom conflict.
South Bend News-Times · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
British newspapers continued to feature the Scopes trial and conviction on their front pages. Scientist Sir Oliver Lodge commented that the case shouldn't be seen as a trial of evolution itself, since scientific questions cannot be put on trial.
South Bend News-Times · 23 July 1925 · page 14
Scopes' Trial End Has Front Page in London
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
A government clerk named Loren Wittner filed suit in D.C. district court seeking an injunction against school officials for teaching evolution, citing a congressional appropriations rider banning 'disrespect of the Holy Bible.' The court ordered the superintendent and a biology professor to appear and show cause why the injunction should not be granted.
South Bend News-Times · 23 July 1925 · page 4
BIBLE-SCIENCE FIGHT OPENS IN CAPITAL; EXAMINE TEACHERS
I. N. S. Staff Correspondent. WASHINGTON. July 22. — The conflict between religion and science, exemplified In the Scopes anti-evo lution trial In Tennessee, today came squarely before the federal courts of the District of Columbia. Declaring that children In the na tional capital were being taught "disrespect of the Holy Bible,” Bo ren H. Wittner of Washington, asked the district supreme court to enjoin the city’s fiscal agents from paying salaries to Instructors who teach the evolutionary theory of the origin of .man In conflict with divine crea tion. Teaching of evolution, Wittner said, was expressly forbidden by con gress in the last district appropria tion bill, 'which provided: “That no part of this sum shall he available for the payment of the salary of any superintendent who permits the teaching of.
See moreSee less
or of any «8iicher who teaches, disrespect of the Holy Bible.”
A Washington man, Boren H. Wittner, filed a test-case injunction in D.C. federal court seeking to stop payment of salaries to teachers who teach evolution, citing a congressional appropriations rider banning 'disrespect of the Holy Bible.' He listed 13 specific instances from textbooks that he claimed contradicted biblical teachings, explicitly modeling the suit on the Scopes trial in Dayton.
An editorial criticizes a Georgia congressman's plan to push federal anti-evolution legislation similar to Tennessee's law, linking the effort to Bryan's influence. It argues that turning biblical interpretation into a political issue betrays constitutional principles of religious freedom and predicts Bryan's followers will be disappointed as they were with his earlier causes.
South Bend News-Times · 23 July 1925 · page 6
A NATIONAL JSSUE? Now cornea a congressman from Georgia, a dem ocrat of course, with the announcement that he will endeavor to secure the passage by congress of a measure almlllar to that of Tennessee In regard to the teaching of evolution. Thia man has been a follower of Bryan In his fac tional devotions, is one of the moat vociferous of the dry forces, and is popularly supposed to wear a night gown and ma.sk. That there would be an attempt to make a politi cal Issue of religious prejudice before the next con gressional campaigns was easily predictable as a result of the last national democratic convention, and that by some means Bryan would be In the forefront of that fight was an ever more patent possibility.
See moreSee less
That quarreling over Interpretations or translations of the Bible could never become a political Issue in this country would not have occurred to the men who wrote Into the constitution what they believed would be a barrier to any alliance between religion and government. That such an Issue would be raised by those who bolong to the creeds whose early members wrote the guaranty of rellgjous freedom because they had rea son to hate any alliance of state and church Is even more amazing. And yet the fervor with which Bryan's steadfast affirmation of belief In not only the most literal In terpretation of the Bible but In translations which are not unanimously endorsed, obtained for him a role greater than when he Insisted that no one should press a crown of gold upon the brow of the downtrodden. The pity of If Is that those who now applaud Bry an will find themselves even more mistaken than those who followed him on his silver dream. Christianity has never changed but there are changes in Interpretation of what are the essentials and what are not In Christianity. If the attitude of Bryan, crusader and powerful as ever, be correct, then every physician Is an emissary ‘of his Satanic Majesty. For In his brief moment of unmasking at this trial, he propounded, not for the court but for the country, the creed that women are condemned to _ suffer pain when repopulating the world because of the sin of the first woman. Against this is the affirmation of science that pain comes because of a highly organized nervous system. The doctor will find ample reasons in the physical body why palp and birth are Joined. But Bryan Insists that there is a curse placed upon all women, because the woman he believes to be the first sinned and because of her sin, all other females born'Into the world are damned for her error. What can be 6aid of the very diligent efforts of doctors, of the hours of study by scientists, of the millions spent for inquiry by philanthropists, to overcome this condition? If Bryan be correct, then there is blasphemy in the discovery of twilight sleep, for man has de stroyed by his intelligence and his ingenuity what was Intended to be punishment Under Bryan’s theory of life every doctor and every midwife becomes a devil and a demon, be cause they use their knowledge and their intelligence to counteract a divine curse. The larger danger is that the eloquence of Bryan, the tradition which hangs about him, may arouse in this nation a sufficient following to make an active issue in American, politics of the demand to put the . leaders pf organized religion in control of the gov ernment. Behind all of this is the effort to make this coun try a theooracy. For the first time In 154 years thers is a serious effort to use the powers of government to control the religious beliefs of citizens and of future citizens. For the first time since the dark ages is science challenged and defied to go as far as it may in the pursuit of truth. For the first time In this country is religion and statescraft made a common cause by a political group. __ This country Is a Christian nation but It has never admitted that It needed the power of law to main
This opinion piece criticizes William Jennings Bryan's trial testimony claiming women's childbirth pain is divine punishment for Eve's sin, contrasting it with scientific explanations. It warns that Bryan's influence could lead to a dangerous national movement to merge religious authority with government control.
A jury in Dayton, Tennessee convicted John Scopes of teaching evolution after deliberating just minutes, following a defense request for a guilty verdict. The $100 fine was upheld when a motion for a new trial was denied, and Darrow announced plans to appeal to a higher court.
The Daily Worker · 23 July 1925 · page 1
SCOPES IS FOUND GUILTY, FINED $100, NEW TRIAL DENIED, DARROW IN APPEAL TO HIGHER COURT
NOT since Henry Ford, the multi millionaire flivver manufacturer, made an ass of himself on the witness ■ stand in the Ford-Tribune libel trial, ' when he referred to history as ‘‘bunk” has a man prominent in public life showed up in so unfavorable a light as the notorious mountebank William ' Jennings Bryan before the grilling examination of Clarence Darrow in the Scopes trial at Dayton, Tennessee. 1 The DAILY WORKER declared that this trial would deal a deadly blow to the church, and this goes for all denominations. If it stopped right now. after William Jennings Bryan exhibited his colossal ignorance un der Darrow's grilling, it is hard to see how any self-respecting person can defend the hocus pocus any longer. * » *
A Daily Worker column by T.J. O'Flaherty gloats over Clarence Darrow's cross-examination of William Jennings Bryan, calling it a devastating blow to religion. The piece ridicules biblical literalism and compares the Catholic Church's past persecution of Galileo and Bruno to the anti-evolution crusade.
The Daily Worker · 23 July 1925 · page 1
By T. J. O'FLAHERTY
PERHAPS a Jesuit might have made a better showing on the witness stand than Bryan. Os course, a Jesuit is too clever to go on the witness stand, but if he did, Darrow would not have such an easy job. The Jesuit god is brought up to date. If the British empire learned a trick or two in the art of managing colonies thru the loss of the United States, the catholic church learned a good deal from its experience in burning here tics. Galileo was persecuted and Bruno burned at the stake because they gave expression to their tfis agieement with the catholic dogma that the earth was fiat and stood still while the sun and the other planets moved around it.
See moreSee less
This was god’s word according to the church. They admit now that god was all wet, in that respect, yet they still expect us to believe in their specially created deity—specially created to frighten us fn giving up our own money.
The jury found Scopes guilty after deliberating only five minutes, and Judge Raulston fined him $100 after barring expert scientific testimony. Scopes then issued his own statement vowing to appeal the anti-evolution law to higher courts.
The Daily Worker · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Rich Landowner Brings In Verdict. The verdict was returned after the jury had been out only five minutes, to take a single ballot on the court house lawn. The conviction was an nounced by Captain Jack Thompson, w hite goateed and the wealthiest land owner in the county. “We find the defendant guilty as charged in the indictment,” were his only words. The court then called Scopes before b!m and asked the young defendant, "Have you anything to say?” “Your honor,” said Scopes, In a nervous tone, but with simple dig nity, “I feel I have been convicted for violating an unjust statute. I shall continue to do all In my power to op pose any law which doesn’t permit the teaching of truth.”
Judge Raulston's rulings excluded the defense's scientific testimony and expunged Bryan's testimony, leading Scopes' attorneys to accept a guilty verdict from the jury. The $100 fine was based on testimony from four state witnesses confirming Scopes taught evolution from Hunter's biology textbook.
The Daily Worker · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Scopes Is Found Guilty; Fined $100
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.
Scopes was found guilty based on testimony from four state witnesses confirming he taught evolution from Hunter's biology textbook. The judge granted the defense 30 days to prepare an appeal, with a Baltimore newspaper backing Scopes' bond, while Harvard's Mather offered to fund further education for Scopes.
The Daily Worker · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.
During the Scopes trial, Judge Raulston commented that the only issue was whether Scopes taught evolution, prompting Darrow to seek an immediate guilty verdict to end the trial and proceed to appeal. The attorneys agreed to waive closing arguments, and the judge expunged Bryan's testimony, stating it could not aid higher courts in deciding the narrow legal question at hand.
The Daily Worker · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
William Jennings Bryan issued a statement responding to Clarence Darrow's accusation of ignorance during the Scopes trial, arguing Christians reject evolution as an unproven hypothesis that undermines spiritual life. He defended his lack of technical scientific knowledge by noting few Americans qualify as specialists in any single scientific field.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 12
in Jennings Bryan, a Issued last night in replyy to Clar ence Darrow’s charge of “ignorance" hurled at him during the Scopes evolution trial, declared that Chris because opposed evolution t ians they refused to “accept an unproven hypothesis when acceptance of it changes the philosophy of life, and tends to chill spiritual enthusiasm.” Bryan said that Darrow attempt ed to take advantage of his luck of technical knowledge in matters of paleontology, archaeology and phil lost I ology, this opportunity was when the court ruled against him. The statement follows: “I am not acquainted with the de tails of any of the sciences to which Darrow referred. My reading on
The Scopes evolution trial ended Tuesday with both defense and prosecution agreeing the defendant should be convicted; the jury returned a guilty verdict in less than 10 minutes. The case will next be heard by the Tennessee Supreme Court starting the first Monday in September.
The Anderson News · 23 July 1925 · page 9
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The twelve jurymen in the Scopes trial have been barred from the courtroom for most of the proceedings, missing both prosecution and defense testimony. They spent their time whittling on the courthouse lawn while awaiting a possible return only for closing arguments.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 5
JURY IN SCOPES CASE HAS TOWN'S SYMPATHY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
John Thomas Scopes was convicted of teaching evolution in violation of Tennessee law, with Judge Raulston imposing the minimum fine of $100. Bryan's testimony was stricken from the record, and the case will move to the Tennessee Supreme Court in Knoxville for appeal.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 5
CONVICTION OF SCOPES ENDS TRIAL AT DAYTON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Affidavits from scientists, educators, and ministers were filed with the Rhea County court, containing the testimony expert witnesses would have given before Judge Raulston barred them. The statements argued evolution is an undeniable fact compatible with religion, describing it as God's method of continuous creation.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 7
Scientists Say Evolution Does Not Conflict With Religious Creation Theory
Method of Continuous Creation” Dayton, Tenn., July 20 —Science fired a broadside into the Tennessee antievolution law today in the form of affidavits by scientists, educators and ministers, filed with the Rhea county court in the Scopes case. The affidavits contained in con dens, d form the testimony which th? expert witnesses for the defense would have given had they not been barred from testifying by Jud re Raulston. That evolution in Nature is an undeniable fact, the proscription of which in public schools would work untold harm, is the tenor of all the statements. That evolution does not conflict with religion, for it is God’s method of con
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Several scientists and scholars submitted sworn affidavits supporting the teaching of evolution, arguing it is essential to biology education and compatible with religious belief. Dr. Maynard Metcalf's statement emphasized that evolution is as established as the earth's revolution around the sun and does not conflict with the Bible.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 7
ity school, University of Chicago, and Rev W. C. Whitaker of Knoxville. Dr Metcalf, zoologist, now doing re search work for Johns Hopkins uni versity, Congregationajist and deacon of church in Oberlin, 0., taught a number of years in Oberlin college, a Methodist institution. In his affidavit he said:— Basis of Biology ‘‘lntelligent teaching of biological science is impossible it the established fact of evolution is omitted. “God's growing revelation of him self to the human soul cannot be realized without recognition of the evolutionary method he has chosen. “Teaching in any field that deals with living things is disgracefully, yes, criminally inadequate if it omits emphasis upon evolution.
See moreSee less
An intelli gent teacher could omit such emphasis only at the expense of his self-respect and of his moral integrity. Such teaching would be criminal malprac tice Just as truly as would be a phy sician’s failure to follow established sound methods of treatment because of fear of persecution by ignorant neighbors. Pivotal Truth of Nature "The fact of evolution—of man, of all living things, of the earth, of the sun, of the stars—is as fully estab lished as the fact that the earth re volves around the sun. Change, growth, evolution is fundamental, a pivotal truth in all nature. ‘There is a great uncertainty as to the method by which evolution has been brought about. None of this has any bearing upon the question of God as a creator of the universe. It is only a matter of the method He has chosen in creation—whether by immediate flat or by gradual growth. This evidence is overwhelmingly that the latter was and is His method. God is just as truly and just as intimately’ acting in the gradual growth of a plant from a seed or of a man from a fertilized egg as he would be in creating in the full grown plant or man all at once in a thousandth part of a second of time. Literalist Interpretation ‘■There is no conflict between the Bible and the fact of evolution. The literal interpretation of the Bible is
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
This editorial discusses the Tuesday conviction of John Thomas Scopes for teaching evolution in violation of Tennessee law, framing it as merely the first step before the real test in higher courts over the law's constitutionality. It argues the true issue is not reconciling science and scripture but whether the Legislature can impose a sectarian test on public school teaching.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 6
The First Battle
’teaching evolution in defiance of the laws of Tennessee clears the way for the real test, which will come in higher courts competent to decide whether or not the law is constitu tional. This is the true issue in volved, although it has sometimes been obscured at Dayton by irrele vant discussion, scientific, theological '■ or crudely personal. That all this was beside the point was recognized '. in the elimination Tuesday of the "testimony” of Mr Bryan along with .all the rest beyond what was needed for formal proof of the fact, not ■denied by the defense, that the ac cused had violated the law’ by teach ing the theory of evolution in the
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A column of brief editorial comments on various topics, including a note that the Scopes trial appears very funny to European observers. It also remarks that the trial has distracted German public attention from the Ruhr crisis.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 6
NOTE AND COMMENT
Devolution was the opposite of evolution in Herbert Spencer’s phi losophy. Bryan might spell it devilution, but he never mentions it and no one knows whether he is agin it or not. The Pittsburg man who has sued , for $200,000 damages because he I was called a “bootlegger” has done । something to help fix popular ideas 1 concerning the moral and social standing of the persons engaged in the bootleg trade. Members of Parliament, declares a British educator, could not pass the tests prescribed for 12-years-old children. But for that matter a test in skipping the rope would find most of them deficient.
See moreSee less
One propaganda that we can all agree not to worry about is that aiming at one-cent letter postage. On the basis of the prewar dollar we are near to having one-cent postage now in all but name. There remains no doubt that the Scopes trial seems to Europe funnier
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A wide-ranging newspaper commentary column jokes that the Scopes trial has become a sensation in Europe, rivaling events since the Civil War era in notoriety. It references Bryan giving Darrow a peach-stone monkey carving and jests that Darrow should reciprocate with an angel statuette, alongside unrelated musings on postage, tires, and Coolidge's vacation.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 6
NOTE AND COMMENT
The Scopes trial has had the good effect in Germany of making every body forget the Ruhr; meanwhile, the French are evacuating it. There’s no cloud without a silver lining. Since Mr Bryan has presented Clarence Darrow with a monkey carved from a peach stone, Mr Dar row might reciprocate with a plaster statuet of an angel. Bishop Oldham of Albany, who startled a London religious gather ing by asking for prayers for the United States, might address his re quest to Dayton, Tenn. When the warlike Moros ask for “more roads and schools” their de sires should be promptly met.
See moreSee less
Both are great civilizing agencies. The alleged European dislike of America has yet to manifest itself in the exclusion of the dollar-bear ing American tourist. Fundamentalists object to the "descent" of man, but "Adam’s fall” is, of course, orthodox.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
This editorial criticizes William Jennings Bryan's statements at the Scopes trial, arguing that his position on protecting the religion of taxpayers contradicts the American principle of separation of church and state. The piece suggests Bryan's logic could justify establishing a state religion, which it finds inconsistent with constitutional protections for all citizens, not just taxpayers.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 1
EDITORIAL COMMENT Bryan’s amazing utterances at Jayton reached a climax in his statement that “the purpose of this ‘trial is merely to prevent attacks on ‘the Bible and the introduction of ir ‘religion or forms of religion an tagonistic to the religion of the tax , ‘payers.” Put more tersely, Bryan apparently meant to say that the re ligion of a majority of the taxpayers . is entitled to special protection from the state in its educational legisla tion. This is the premise upon which one can argue for the estab lishment of a state religion or state church.
See moreSee less
Nothing is more inconsist ent with the American system of the separation of state and church than special privilege for “the religion of the taxpayers” in the shape of sub sidies or legal recognition, or statutory discrimination against other cults or beliefs having re ligious implications. Yet Bryan plumps hard for a form of state preferment in the field of religion in his desire to safeguard the tax payers’ special religious inheritance, whatever it may be. Why he should confine his protective campaign to the taxpayers is a mystery; citizens who are not taxpayers have souls and are recognized by the constitu tion. Bryan’s queer statement may be studied to advantage, however, because the Tennessee evolution law
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A commentary column briefly references the Dayton, Tennessee controversy, noting that James Lane Allen's novel 'The Reign of Law' had anticipated the clash between science and faith decades earlier. It suggests the book is worth revisiting given its timely bearing on the ongoing debate.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 1
George Eastman, the kodak manu facturer and philanthropist, is to de vote the early months of his retire ment to a big game hunting expedi tion in Africa. As Mr Eastman is 70, it is evident tnat a man's retire ment from business may be but a signal for adventure in these strenu ously youthful days. The English bishop of Durham flatters Great Britain overmuch per haps in saying that “American so ciety is at least 90 years behind so ciety in this country in all that makes for religious thought and knowledge.” There must be numer ous people in the British isles who still agree with Bryan.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A brief editorial comment laments that the public missed out on an informal 'university extension course' in biology that could have come from the scientific experts prepared to testify at the Scopes trial. It reflects disappointment that their testimony was never delivered to the court.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 1
There could be no more ideal leader in such a throwback to medievalism than Cole Blease. A great many people will be disap pointed at the failure of opportunity to receive a university extension course in biology, through the news papers, from the eminent scientists who were prepared to testify at the , Scopes trial. The so-called light cruisers which Winston Churchill looks upon as a i menace to the British treasury will be almost as big as the biggest bat tleship which took part in the war with Spain and will cost more.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The piece discusses Judge Raulston's ruling denying the defense's motion to quash the Scopes indictment, noting this was expected given a trial judge's caution on constitutional questions. It anticipates appeals to higher courts that will clarify issues like what constitutes 'teaching' and whether the law bars any mention of evolution.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
This editorial discusses Judge Raulston's rulings on the constitutionality of Tennessee's anti-evolution law and the exclusion of scientific testimony, suggesting these are open to higher legal review. It also addresses Darrow's contempt-of-court apology and comments on the strategic risks of using out-of-state defense lawyers before a Fundamentalist jury.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
This editorial commentary analyzes the legal strategy behind the Scopes trial, suggesting the defense deliberately used out-of-state lawyers to turn the case into a publicity vehicle for educational purposes about evolution. It notes that despite Judge Raulston's exclusion of scientists' testimony from jury consideration, the defense succeeded in getting their affidavits into the public record and printed by newspapers nationwide.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
While the Scopes trial continues in the Dayton courtroom, forty or more teachers from a dozen states have applied for Scopes's biology teaching position. School authorities say they will wait until the trial concludes before taking any action on hiring.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 14
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The piece reviews Richard Swann Lull's book 'The Ways of Life,' noting its scientific, non-controversial treatment of evolutionary theory as public interest surges due to the Scopes trial. It discusses differing scientific views on natural selection and man's history, estimated at under 30,000 years.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 July 1925 · page 12
EVOLUTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
The day after the trial ended, Dayton quieted down with the carnival atmosphere gone, and messenger boy earnings dropped sharply. Scopes said he hadn't decided whether to go on the lecture circuit, preferring to return to college, while Bryan, Darrow, and others made plans to leave or stay in the area.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 23 July 1925 · page 1
CONVICTED SCOPES UNDECIDED ABOUT LECTURE PLATFORM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
This editorial fragment notes that the court ultimately ruled the testimony of Bryan and Darrow about their views on the Bible and evolution had no bearing on the case. It adds that the public had already reached the same conclusion.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 23 July 1925 · page 6
At last the court found that the testimony of Bryan and Darrow, as to their views of the Bible, evolution, not to mention other things about which they have no scientific knowl edge, had nothing to do with the case. The public already had arrived at that conclusion. “London Wants More Drinking Hours”—Headline—And yet we are told that England more than any other country is in need of more working hours at good pay. Will the booze interests pay the doles on ac count of booze and idleness? i —■ i i It will cost the State of Tennessee $26,000 for a flub-dub exposition of wind-jamming because of unwise
A brief commentary remarks that public attention, like evolution itself, will move on from Bryan and Darrow to other topics. It appears amid unrelated economic statistics and local town notes.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 23 July 1925 · page 6
News Interest now will evolute to something else than Bryan and Dar tqw. LITCHFIELD Eugene Purinton, who was seriously hurt by a horse kicking him, is doing nicely.
A Maine local news column reports that the Bangor public library has created a special display of books on evolution, inspired by public interest from the Dayton 'monkey trial.' The item appears amid unrelated local items like ball games and road construction news.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 23 July 1925 · page 6
MAINE GOSSIP
Recognizing the wide spread in terest on evolution generated by the so-called monkey trial in Dayton, Tenn., the Bangor public library has arranged a special display of books on the subject of evolution.
The report describes the Dayton trial's conclusion, stating the jury deliberated only nine minutes before finding teacher John Thomas Scopes guilty of violating the state's anti-evolution law. Scopes was fined, declared he would continue teaching evolution by all means possible, and his defense lawyers hoped for a guilty verdict specifically so the case could be appealed to the state supreme court.
Auttaja · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Scopes jutun juttu vedetään valtion ylioikeuteen
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN
Judge John T. Raulston ruled to exclude scientific testimony from the Scopes trial, prompting sharp exchanges between defense attorneys Arthur Hays and Clarence Darrow and the judge. The defense entered a formal exception and sought to place their intended testimony on record for appeal to a higher court.
The Kanabec County Times · 23 July 1925 · page 3
BAR SCIENTISTS AT SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Farmers Independent · Bagley, Minn.
Judge John T. Raulston ruled to exclude scientific testimony from the Scopes trial, prompting sharp clashes between defense attorneys Arthur Hays and Clarence Darrow with the judge. The defense entered an exception to the ruling and announced intent to place the proposed testimony into the record for appeal to a higher court.
Farmers Independent · 23 July 1925 · page 8
BAR SCIENTISTS AT SCOPES TRIAL
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Der Nordstern · St. Cloud, Minn.
The jury in the Dayton, Tennessee evolution trial returned a guilty verdict against teacher John T. Scopes on Tuesday at 11:29 am. Judge Raulston imposed a $100 fine and set bail at $500 pending appeal, while Scopes declared he would continue fighting the law.
Der Nordstern · 23 July 1925 · page 1
$100 Geldstrafe!
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Der Nordstern · St. Cloud, Minn.
An opinion piece reports that Rev. J. Frank Norris, a Texas fundamentalist evangelist, may join the Scopes trial at Dayton, noting his reputation for pressuring Southern college professors over evolution teaching. The writer sarcastically criticizes Norris's tactics as un-Christian persecution of scholars with inquiring minds.
Der Nordstern · 23 July 1925 · page 10
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Der Nordstern · St. Cloud, Minn.
The report states Judge Raulston has ruled the Tennessee anti-evolution law constitutional, predicting Scopes will be convicted and fined and the case will proceed through appeals to the U.S. Supreme Court. The piece also criticizes Judge Raulston's reaction to a reporter's prediction and comments on the irony of liberals now relying on the Supreme Court they previously criticized.
Der Nordstern · 23 July 1925 · page 10
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Der Nordstern · St. Cloud, Minn.
A newspaper columnist remarks that the Dayton trial will be decided by the time this piece is printed, noting Judge Raulston excluded expert testimony on evolution and upheld the Tennessee anti-evolution law. The writer argues the remaining trial is merely procedural to set up an appeal, since the judge cannot legally direct a guilty verdict despite believing Scopes clearly violated the law.
Der Nordstern · 23 July 1925 · page 12
diversified farming. The reports of the local wheat crop are not as favorable as it was hoped a few weeks ago. The hot wave and excessive rain fall has caused a great deal of rust. The unvarnished trut is that this is no longer a wheat-raising country, and we may as well become reconciled to the situation. It will not do to rely on wheat or other grain corps alone, as they are j too^un certain. The successful farmer must have returns for his labor every year, and not only occasionally.
See moreSee less
The only way to ac complish this is by having other ways of getting returns than by raising grain. We must raise stock, keep cows, hogs and poultry. The trouble about diversification is that it makes farm life a continual daily drudge. In the old wheat-raising days, a few months of hard labor were followed by months of doing chores. But conditions are changing, and we must change with them. Farming is becoming more and more a business, based on business principles, and if conducted along those lines will bring success just as hard work and intelligent management does in other lines. This is being realized thoroughly by the farmers, and the boys and girls are becoming more content to stay on the farm, and there is less defection to the city. An intelligent farming community insures the best chance for real happiness and contentment. The farce at Dayton will be decided when this article ap pears. Now that the judge has excluded expert testimony as to what evolution is and is not, and has also held the anti-evo lution statute of Tennessee valid, the rest of the trial is a mere form to get the record in shape for an appeal through the courts. There is no question that Scopes has violated that law, but inasmuch as he does not plead guilty, his guilt must be de clared by the jury of his peers. The judge has no power to di rect a verdict of guilty or Judge Raulston would have done so promptly. It used to be told among the lawyers of this state many years ago that a young man, who afterwards became a noted jurist, attended his first term as a district judge and on his return related to his lawyer friends that he,had directed a jury in a horse-stealing case to bring in a verdict of guilty. His friends told him in consternation: “Why, you can’t do that!” To which he replied: “But I did, and the cuss is in jail now” If the learned Tennessee jurist had known of this, he might have adopted it as a precedent The many accidents and deaths resulting from negligent driving of the automobile present a very serious situation all over the civilized world, and much thought is given to the so lution of the many problems arising therefrom. One of the outstanding legal problems of the nation is the tremendous number of suits for damages to person or property arising out of these accidents, and the distressingly large number of ver dicts that prove uncollectible after they are obtained, after a great deal of litigation and expense, because of the fact that the debtor is execution-proof. The present laws provinding for fines and jail sentences do not seem to have any material effect on the number of ac cidents, and the injuries and damages for which there is no adequate relief seem to call for the adoption of a social pro gram which would keep step with modern progress. It seems to the writer that there ought to be some system of compulsory insurance by the owners against accidents. Be fore an owner can obtain a license, he should file with his application a duplicate insurance policy providing for the in demnification of anyone whose person or property is injured through the negligence of the operator. This might also have the effect of decreasing the number of irresponsible, inefficient and negligent drivers. Another plan might be the imposing of a larger license fee, a part of which could be used for the creation of a fund to compensate those injured. This is done in some states in the case of workmen’s compensation. It would seem reasonable that the traffic should bear the burden of the damage to person and property, just as under the workmen’s compensation laws the industries bear the cost of personal in juries. The innocent user of our highways needs some better protection just as the workman does. It is reported that Fnace is going right on with its evacua tion of German territory. And it is also reported that the two nations are making a trade and industrial pact that will ser iously affect the industrial life of Great Britain. As to the first we are glad that Germany is at last receiving the consideration that it deserves; as to the second, we are not ready to accept it as true. If it is true, it only goes to show that diplomacy (like politics) makes strange bed-fellows.
An editorial argues that Clarence Darrow's questioning of a prospective juror about being on the 'Bible side' or evolution side creates a false dichotomy, since many Christians reconcile evolution with faith. The piece suggests Darrow's approach may backfire and prejudice public opinion against the defense.
Der Nordstern · 23 July 1925 · page 12
MR. DARROW’S IDEA ' Mr. Clarence Darrow is beyond very much question a very great lawyer, and a clever man. But for all that, he has succeeded in raising in the public mind an issue as respects Christianity and evolution that is calculated to defeat his own purpose in the Scopes case. In questioning a minister, called as a prospective juror, Mr. Darrow asked him “which side” he was on—the Bible side or the other. Now there are a great many people in this world who accept evolution as an explanation of the origin and de velopment of species, who also are very earnest Christians.
See moreSee less
They have no dif ficulty in reconciling the Darwinian hy pothesis with Christianity. They be lieve very firmly in a divine First Cause they believe that, just as all matter is indestructible, so the soul of man is indestructible. Thorough going evolutionists as they are, they find, nevertheless, great comfort in their Bible and in their hope of an im mortal life. It is, thus possible for many earnest Christians to be on both sides and for Mr. Darrow to in{er that such a position is impossible is certain to prejudice his case with a great many who believe that they know as much about such things as he does. When Mr. Darrow was permitted to associate himself with the defense of Scopes we suggested that an unfor tunate choice had been made. It is becoming more and more apparent as the case developes.—Pioneer Press
Judge Raulston ruled to exclude scientific testimony from the Scopes evolution trial after reviewing the legislative intent of the Tennessee anti-evolution statute. He also cited defense attorney Clarence Darrow for contempt of court and set bail at $5,000, while the defense objected and sought to preserve its evidence for appeal.
Askov American · 23 July 1925 · page 8
BAR SCIENTISTS AT SCOPES TRIAL
Courtroom, Dayton, Tenn.—Judge John T. Raulaton excluded scientific testimony from the trial of John T Scopes. The judge's decision was announced after reading a general review of the judge’s conclusions of the intent of the statute as passed by the legislature. The defense at once noted an excep tion to the court's ruling and the judge ordered it placed on record. Judge Raulston’s decision to exclude the experts from the witness stand developed sharp clashes between Ar thur O. Hayes and Judge Raulston and Clarence Darrow in the court. Atlhough court was in session only SO minutes the judge giving his deci sion, it was stormy.
See moreSee less
In reply to a question from Judge Raulston, Hays said the defense had about six branches of science repre sented by witnesses. The defense then announced that it desired to place its proposed testimony into the court for the purpose of plac ing ft before a higher court.
A miscellaneous institutional newsletter column covering camp happenings briefly mentions that Judge Raulston ruled Scopes broke Tennessee law by teaching evolution and upheld the anti-evolution statute as constitutional. The item is surrounded by unrelated jokes and local gossip about mosquitos, band rehearsals, and camp life.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Judge John T. Raulston ruled to exclude scientific testimony from the Scopes trial, upholding the legality of the Tennessee anti-evolution act. The defense, including Arthur Hayes and Clarence Darrow, clashed sharply with the judge and entered a formal exception for appeal to a higher court.
Paper unidentified · 23 July 1925 · page 2
BAR SCIENTISTS AT SCOPES TRIAL
Judge Upholds Legality of Ten nessee Act-Defense En ters Objection. Courtroom, Dayton, Tenu. —Judge John T. Raulston excluded scientific testimony from the trial of John T. Scopes. The Judge’s decision was announced aftor reading a general review of the Judge’s conclusions of the Intent of the statute aB passed by the legislature. The defense at once noted an excep tion to the court's ruling and the judge ordered It placed on record. , Judge Raulston’s decision to exclude the experts from the witness stand developed sharp clashes between Ar thur G.
See moreSee less
Hayes and Judge Raulston and Clarence Darrow In the court. Atlhough court was In session only 30 minutes the judge giving his deci sion, It was stormy. The defense then announced that It desired to place Its proposed testimony Into the court for the purpose of plac ing it before a higher court. In reply to a question from Judge Raulston, Hays said the defense had about six branches of science repre sented by witnesses.
The report states that John T. Scopes was found guilty in the Tennessee evolution trial of teaching a theory contrary to state law and was fined $100. It notes the case will be appealed.
The Wolf Point Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 1
CONVICTED OF EVOLUTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb.
A newspaper photo shows the men who instigated the Scopes evolution test case re-enacting their meeting at Robinson's drug store in Dayton, Tennessee. Pictured are George Rappelyea, who swore out the warrant, prosecutor Walter White, druggist F.E. Robinson, and Clay Green, who brought John Thomas Scopes to the conference.
The Frontier · 23 July 1925 · page 3
Scopes Trial Started Here
Seated at a table In Robinson’s drug store !n Dayton, Tenn., the men who instigated the anti evolution law ’’test” case re-enacted tor camera men the scene where was fired the shot that was “heard •round the world.” They are, left to right, George W. Rappelyea, who swore out the warrant; Walter White, prosecutor; R. £2. Robinson, druggist, and Clay Green, who brought John Thomas Scopes to the conference. New Leader Hoke Donlthen, attorney, Cod idge’s Ohio campaign manager, has In the Day’s News_j
Loren Wittner, an avowed atheist, filed an injunction suit against Washington D.C. school officials to challenge a federal appropriations provision barring teaching deemed disrespectful to the Bible. He hopes the case will allow scientists and fundamentalists to testify directly, achieving what the Scopes trial defense failed to accomplish.
The Bismarck Tribune · 23 July 1925 · page 1
SUIT BROUGHT TO KILL LAWS ON EVOLUTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
A government employee named Wittner filed injunction proceedings against school officials and the federal government to block salary payments, aiming to create a constitutional test case on teaching evolution broader than the Dayton case allowed. He hoped the suit would permit direct courtroom testimony from scientists, while Darrow dismissed the effort as likely bigotry, and Bryan welcomed it as a chance for more debate.
The Bismarck Tribune · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Monitor-Register · Woodstown, N.J.
An editorial discusses rising crime and jury leniency toward murder cases, citing a local prosecutor's complaints about juries excusing serious crimes. It briefly mentions that if Scopes's teachings were offensive to Tennessee officials, it would have been better to quietly dismiss him rather than prosecute.
The Monitor-Register · 23 July 1925 · page 2
LENIENCY OF JURIES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Pickens Sentinel · Pickens, S.C.
A South Carolina weekly newspaper runs humorous commentary on the just-concluded Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, joking about Bryan and Darrow, Judge Raulston, and evolution debates. The editor mixes trial references with unrelated local quips about prohibition, chamber of commerce, and comics.
The Pickens Sentinel · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Pickens ran Dayton a close race for publicity in South Carolina last Week. South Carolina has her problems this summer, but it could be worse. Georgia’s legislature is in session. A visit to the city of Greenville will convince anybody that there is something dead up the branch. We suppose Dayton, Tenn., will hereafter be known rn history as the site of one of early battles of the evolutionary war. The new head of the prohibition enforcement department says too many of the agents have been wink ing at the blind tigers. Social Note.—Messrs. W. J. Bryan, of Miami, and Clarence Darrow, of •. those who at* i!-o .•-••cei-tiilnment at I ay.or. p? ' . v o ■ tii'iivi nd ! by
The piece quotes a scientist's trial testimony about animals developing locomotion to find food, then sarcastically mocks it as flimsy proof of evolution. It suggests fundamentalists should let evolutionists present such weak evidence themselves.
The Pickens Sentinel · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Proving the Theory Of Evolution In explaining the theory of evolu tion at the trial in Dayton, Tennessee, one of the foremost scientists of the country said, on the witness stand: “Animals hustle to Ket their foods and therefore have developed locomo tive organs. Plants have not.” 'His supposition is that if plants did not Ket their food from the air, they, too, in time would develop locomotive organs to aid them to travel about loOkiriK for something to eat. That’s the sort of “proof" handed out iri support of the evolution theory. It seems to The .Sentinel that the best way in the world to cripple ••volu tion is for the fundarnentftlltt* not only to allow the evolutionist* to place '-heir evidence and proof before the
This item is a photo caption identifying the key figures in the Scopes evolution trial: William Jennings Bryan for the prosecution, Judge Raulston presiding, and Clarence Darrow for the defense, with an inset photo of defendant John T. Scopes. It notes the trial has drawn national interest and describes the courtroom scene as informal, with shirt sleeves.
The Pickens Sentinel · 23 July 1925 · page 12
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laurens Advertiser · Laurens, S.C.
John Scopes was found guilty of teaching evolution after prosecution and defense agreed to the verdict once the judge excluded scientific testimony; the jury deliberated less than ten minutes. Judge Raulston imposed the minimum $100 fine, set bail at $500, and the defense immediately moved for a new trial before preparing to appeal to the Tennessee Supreme Court.
The Laurens Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 1
GUILTY VERDICT AGAINST SCOPES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laurens Advertiser · Laurens, S.C.
The jury returned a guilty verdict against John Scopes in under ten minutes after both defense and prosecution agreed he should be convicted, and Judge Raulston imposed the minimum $100 fine with $500 bail pending appeal. The judge also expunged William Jennings Bryan's prior testimony from the record, ruling it irrelevant to the narrow legal question of whether Scopes taught human descent from lower animals.
The Laurens Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 1
VERDICT BY AGREEMENT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laurens Advertiser · Laurens, S.C.
Amid the Scopes trial in Dayton, Rev. Thornton Whaling recounts the 1887 heresy trial of Dr. James Woodrow, uncle of Woodrow Wilson, before the Presbyterian General Assembly in Baltimore. Woodrow was tried for teaching that evolution as a scientific hypothesis was separate from theological questions about creation.
The Laurens Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 3
TELLS OF TRIAL BEFORE PRESBYTERIAN ASSEMBLY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laurens Advertiser · Laurens, S.C.
A speaker at a community gathering references the Dayton evolution trial, drawing parallels to the earlier case of Dr. James Woodrow, who taught evolution's compatibility with Genesis at a Presbyterian seminary in Columbia, S.C. The account details Woodrow's academic background and how his views on evolution evolved over 25 years of study before he was convicted by the Synod.
The Laurens Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laurens Advertiser · Laurens, S.C.
Scopes was asked by the court if he had anything to say before sentencing, and he protested that he was convicted under an unjust law and would continue opposing it. The judge imposed a $100 fine, and after bond was posted the case moved to Knoxville as the next stage.
The Laurens Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 4
GUILTY VERDICT AGAINST SCOPES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laurens Advertiser · Laurens, S.C.
Judge Raulston excluded scientific expert testimony in the Scopes evolution trial, prompting dueling statements from Bryan and Darrow. Bryan defended the ruling as required by Tennessee evidence law, while Darrow accused Bryan of avoiding the issue by hiding behind technicalities.
The Laurens Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 4
LAWYERS CLASH AT DAYTON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laurens Advertiser · Laurens, S.C.
Bryan defends the judge's exclusion of expert scientific testimony as legally correct, while Darrow accuses Bryan of fleeing the evolution debate by hiding behind legal technicalities. The exchange reflects escalating personal conflict between the two lead attorneys at the Scopes trial.
The Laurens Advertiser · 23 July 1925 · page 4
AT DAYTON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Fort Mill Times · Fort Mill, S.C.
John Thomas Scopes was found guilty of teaching evolution in violation of Tennessee law, and fined $100, the minimum penalty. Defense waived closing arguments to expedite an appeal to the Tennessee Supreme Court, with Scopes declaring he would continue opposing the law as unjust.
Fort Mill Times · 23 July 1925 · page 1
JURY CONVICTS SCOPES.
He had explained that the evidence upon which the defense had hoped to bring about the acquittal of Scopes had been excluded by the court and it was the wish of the defense that a verdict of guilty be returned to permit an appeal to the supremo court. Summoned before the bar, Scopes Insisted that he had boon convicted of violating an unjust law. "I will continue to oppose the law in every way in my power,” said the defendant. “I consider it unjust and unconstitutional.’’ Scopes was to appear in court (lur ing the afternoon to file a bond of $100, pending disposition of tlie ap peal.
See moreSee less
The appeal from the circuit court finding will be made to the Tennessee | supreme court, meeting in Knoxville lu ; Septmeber. A formal motion for ai rest of Judgment was made and appli cation for a new trial was made and overruled. The assembly of the tran script 'for use in the appeal will lie the next task for the defense, attor neys said.
The paper defends Judge Raulston's decision to exclude expert scientific testimony on evolution, framing the case as solely about whether Scopes violated Tennessee law. It predicts the jury will soon convict Scopes and dismisses the defense's hope that higher courts will overturn the law as unconstitutional.
Fort Mill Times · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis. · and 1 other paper
William Jennings Bryan declares the trial affirms the Bible's truth and denounces evolution as an organized attack on scripture. He calls Darrow an agnostic who embodies evolution's cruelty and lack of moral foundation, criticizing his courtroom conduct and promising a full reply to Darrow's charges.
The Milwaukee Leader · 23 July 1925 · page 3
IN BIBLE CASE
He embodies all that is cruel, heart less and destructive in evolution. He is our Exhibit A, and proves Ihe criminal folly of intrusting to the tempestuous sea of life an in tellectual ship without a moral rudder and without a compass.
The Watchman and Southron · Sumter, S.C. · 25 July 1925
The County Record · Kingstree, S.C.
Clarence Darrow called William Jennings Bryan as a defense witness and questioned him on Biblical literalism, while Judge Raulston cited Darrow for contempt over earlier remarks before accepting his apology. Overflow crowds forced the court to move proceedings to an outdoor platform.
The County Record · 23 July 1925 · page 1
EVOLUTION CASE COMES TO END BRYAN CALLED TO STAND BY DEFENSE!—DARROW IN CONTEMPT.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The County Record · Kingstree, S.C.
The jury convicted John Scopes in under ten minutes for teaching evolution, immediately clearing the way for an appeal to the Tennessee Supreme Court. The passage also recounts Judge Raulston's statement on a contempt incident involving Darrow from the prior court session.
The County Record · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The County Record · Kingstree, S.C.
John Scopes was convicted in Rhea County court of teaching evolution after the jury deliberated less than ten minutes, with both defense and prosecution having agreed to forgo closing arguments. Judge imposed the minimum $100 fine, and the case was set to be appealed to the Tennessee Supreme Court in Knoxville.
The County Record · 23 July 1925 · page 1
SCOPES CONVICTED; CASE APPEALED JURY RETURNS VERDICT IN LESS THAN TEN MINUTES.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Dillon Herald · Dillon, S.C.
A weekly news digest reports that French scientists, including Madame Curie, passed resolutions condemning the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, as a violation of freedom of thought. The item appears among a roundup of unrelated world news briefs.
The Dillon Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Dillon Herald · Dillon, S.C.
A South Carolina news roundup reports that the Florence Business Men's Christian club sent a telegram to William Jennings Bryan congratulating him on John T. Scopes's conviction for violating the anti-evolution law. The item appears amid a mix of local news briefs about crops, banking, and community events.
The Dillon Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Dillon Herald · Dillon, S.C.
A jury found John T. Scopes guilty of violating Tennessee's law against teaching evolution, and Judge Raulston fined him $100. Scopes told the court he believed the statute unjust and vowed to keep opposing it, with bond set at $500 pending appeal.
The Dillon Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Scopes Declared Guilty
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Dillon Herald · Dillon, S.C.
The report describes William Jennings Bryan as the dominant figure at the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, noting he is certain to benefit regardless of the verdict. It highlights his royalties from book sales in the town and shows an illustration of him reviewing his mail at a bookshop.
The Dillon Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 2
EVOLUTION CASE PROFITABLE FOR BRYAN
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Bamberg Herald · Bamberg, S.C.
The editorial commends William Jennings Bryan's prosecution conduct at the Scopes trial while criticizing Clarence Darrow for boasting of agnosticism and objecting to opening court with prayer. It specifically references Darrow's contempt citation from Judge Raulston the previous Friday, which was later resolved with an apology.
The Bamberg Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 4
BRYAN SCORES.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Bamberg Herald · Bamberg, S.C.
The item reports that a legislative committee found Herrin, Illinois transformed by daily prayer meetings following an evangelistic campaign, with businesses closing at noon for prayer and no recent murders in the once-violent mining town. The writer contrasts this religious revival with Clarence Darrow's disbelief in the Bible as expressed at the Scopes trial, questioning what Darrow could offer to elevate people compared to the Gospel.
The Bamberg Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 4
THE POWER OF THE GOSPEL.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
This editorial discusses news that a bill will be introduced in Congress to ban teaching evolution in public schools nationally, following the Dayton, Tennessee trial. The writer argues such a law would violate the Bill of Rights' guarantee of religious freedom and criticizes William Jennings Bryan for turning the issue into political and religious controversy.
Brownsville Herald · 23 July 1925 · page 4
The Sunday Herald One Year (in advance) .$2.25 Six Months (in advance) .$1.25 Three Months (in advance) .85 Any erroneous reflection upon the character, standing or reputation of any per son, firm or corporation, which may appear in the columns of The Herald, will be glady corrected upon its being brought to the attention of the publishers. National Anti-Evolution Law Proposed OJT of Tennessee, at Dayton, where religious liberty was on trial, comes the news that at the next session of congress a bill will be introduced forbidding the teaching of evolution in the public schools.
See moreSee less
Our guess is that it will not pass, but if it should it would un doubtedly be tested before the United States Supreme Qourt and found unconstitutional. Clearly such a law would be in violation of the bill of rights guaranteeing freedom of thought in religious matters. It isn't a question of whether creation took place as a literal translation of Genesis implies, or whether man has evolved from lowrer orders. It is a question whether, under the constitution, a law will hold that tends in any way to curb men s ideas of the method of creation. We cannot see howr such a law could stand up under the bill of rights. It may be proper that we should discard the bill of rights as was of no moment and may properly be supplanted by some sort of curb on thoughts religious.
A Harrisonburg News-Record column reprinted in the Courier criticizes metropolitan newspapers covering the Scopes evolution trial for mocking rural Tennesseans as 'hill-billies' and misrepresenting their religion and way of life. The writer argues country folk are more honest and hardworking than city dwellers and resent the condescending coverage.
Clarke Courier · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Hill Billies the Best
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
A United News correspondent reports that John T. Scopes wants to devote his life to biology and is seeking a scholarship for post-graduate study. The piece describes him as intelligent and level-headed, uninterested in commercializing his sudden fame from the trial.
The Seattle Star · 23 July 1925 · page 2
Scopes Wants to 'Devote Life to Biology Tennessee School Teacher, Would Study About Fuss He Started
I).\\"l‘U.\, Tenn, July 23.-—Ten nessee’'s most famous criminal wants to devote his life to the cause to which he has thus fu merely loaned his name Young John T, Scopes has Indicated to in.
After the Scopes trial ended, Dayton took down its welcome signs and resumed its quiet routine, though both town and visitors were changed by the experience. Visiting newspaper correspondents, all evolutionists opposed to the law but charmed by local hospitality, hosted a dance where defense and prosecution lawyers mingled as friends, including Clarence Darrow dancing with Dudley Field Malone's wife.
The Seattle Star · 23 July 1925 · page 2
NEWSPAPER MEN GIVE O FAREWLLL DANCE ‘| The friendly atmosphere was fully | manifest at u dance given to the town and the visiting lawyers by | the newspaper men, something quite || vure In the history of reporting. | The newspaper correspondents, ev. | ery ona an evolutionist and opposed |t the Tennesses law personnlly, ) were 80 overpowered by the hospl. | tality of the residents, and their | tolerant apirit, that they felt unable | to leave without some visible recogI nitlon of thelr appreciation. They | hired the village dance hall, brought an orchestra from Chattanocoga, and | had everyone in to dance, | Defonse nnd prosecution lawyers | exchanged dances, cut in on each
A government clerk filed a test suit in Washington D.C. district court seeking to block funding for teachers who teach evolution, invoking unheard evidence from the Scopes trial. The suit cited twelve supposed contradictions between science and the Bible across biology, chemistry, physics, and astronomy.
The Milwaukee Leader · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Unheard Scopes Evi dence Is Involved In Case. WASHINGTON—A test suit to restrain authorities from teaching evolution and other sciences in the public schools of the District of Columbia was filed in the district supreme court here Wednesday by Lauren H. Wittner, government clerk. Involving all the unheard evi dence of the Scopes trial, the suit seeks to prevent payment of teach ers’ salaries under a clause of the district appropriations bill passed by congress which states that no part of the funds should be used for teaching disrepscet of the Holy Bible.
Following the trial's conclusion in Dayton, the Scopes case is set to proceed through the Tennessee Supreme Court and potentially to the U.S. Supreme Court within 18 months. Bryan announces plans for anti-evolution law drives in seven more states, while legal experts express doubt about overturning the law on constitutional grounds, though a technicality might succeed.
The Milwaukee Leader · 23 July 1925 · page 1
SCOPES CASE STARTS FOR HIGH COURT
Urge Ban in Seven States. Meanwhile drives for anti-evolu tion laws will be started in at least seven states, as soon as their legis latures convene, according to a statement given by W. J. Bryan. Upon the ultimate decision of the United States supreme court, will depend the success or failure of these laws and of the fundamental ist campaigns to root the evolution theory out of American schools.
Legal analysts in Dayton assess the odds of overturning Tennessee's anti-evolution law, noting a federal case already pending in Washington. Defense attorneys, with Darrow, Hays, and Neal continuing work, prepare a bill of exceptions and a motion for a new trial to advance the case toward the Tennessee Supreme Court and potentially the U.S. Supreme Court.
The Milwaukee Leader · 23 July 1925 · page 1
BY WILLIAM J. LOSH.
Taken to State Court. The Scopes case itself will go to the Tennessee supreme court at Knoxville, Tenn., for hearing at the September session. If this court upholds it, it will travel thence to Washington. If it overturns it, the issue still will go to Washington through a parallel proceeding in the federal courts which was started be fore the trial here began but which has laid dormant during these sen sational proceedings. Legal opinion here seems to hold that the outlook for a reversal of the anti-evolution law by the United States supreme court is dubious, de spite the professed optimism of the defense staff.
Following Scopes' conviction, Bryan released a written statement declaring the trial proved the Bible's truth and denouncing organized attacks on Scripture under cover of science. Darrow responded with a sharp rejoinder to Bryan's broadside.
The Milwaukee Leader · 23 July 1925 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Bryan's Suppressed Fury Breaks Anew Over Darrow's Head
SAYS COUNSEL IS EXHIBIT A IN BIBLE CASE
See moreSee less
DAYTON, Tenn. — William Jennings Bryan, bubbling over with fury—fury which was suppressed by the sudden jury verdict—burst forth into fresh flame.
Bryan, eager to scorch Clarence Darrow, Scopes attorney, with his burning questions, raised his voice —spoke; and the religious tempest broke over the head of the aged counsel.
Directed At Darrow.
Bryan, whose fiery oratory was quenched by the conviction and closing of the Scopes case here Tuesday, administered his examination of Darrow through the medium of a statement. It was a broadside directed personally at Scopes' counsel. Darrow retaliated in a blistering rejoinder. Bryan's statement follows:
The issue is so large that individuals and localities are relatively unimportant. It dwarfs all other issues now under consideration by the people of the United States and of the world. Is the Bible true, is the question raised by the Tennessee law, and that question is answered in the affirmative as far as this trial can answer it.
Raps Attack On Bible.
Believing as I do in the revealed religion—that is to say, in Christianity built upon the Word of God —I rejoice that the followers of our Lord and Saviour, Jesus Christ, are at last awakened to the insidious attacks which have been made, under cover of a scientific hypothesis, upon the authority of the Bible by unbelieving of every grade and class.
The attack upon the authority of the Bible is organized, deliberate and malignant, and had only to be uncovered to be understood.
Mr. Darrows entrance into the case has been most fortunate for the Christian church. He is the most conspicuous of the outspoken opponents of religion in the nation. He is the finished product of evolution—the most perfect that has yet developed in the United States. He embodies all that is cruel, heartless and destructive in evolution. He is our Exhibit A, and proves the criminal folly of intrusting to the tempestuous sea of life an intellectual ship without a moral rudder and without a compass.
Is Called Agnostic.
He does not believe that there is a God—he is an avowed agnostic, and therefore has no sense of responsibility to God. As love of fellow man has no other foundation than love of God, as set forth in the two commandments, "Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart and thy neighbor as thyself," he has no basis on which to build an unselfish interest in anybody or in anything.
In this trial he has been true to his unbelief from beginning to end. He objected to the customary opening of the court with prayer and insisted on the removal of a sign, "Read Your Bible." He has slurred the Bible, insulted the court, has shown his contempt for everything Christian and everybody identified with Christianity as it is taught in orthodox churches, and "the ruling passion strong in death" closed the after-trial meeting in the courtroom with a sneer when all the other participants had spoken in a spirit appropriate to the occasion.
I shall prepare an answer to Mr. Darrow's charge that I am an ignorant bigot. I am not vain enough to think that this compliment—for, coming from him, it was a compliment—was intended for me alone. While it was addressed to me, it was intended for all who dare differ from him to the exent of believing in the Bible, the God whom it reveals and the supernatural Christ of whom it tells.
Answer Is Planned.
I shall answer for all Christians as well as for myself, but I feel that the answer will receive more consideration if it is separated from the proceedings of today.
When Mr. Darrow summoned me as a witness yesterday I might have refused to testify, but knowing that his purpose was to impose upon the people outside the courtroom rather than to try the case, I consented to testify in order that he might not be able to charge me with unwillingness to face his questions. He did not ask a single question that was proper or that would have been permitted had I objected to it. The judge permitted them to be asked only because I was willing to answer, and later, upon reflection, expunged both questions and answers from the record.
William Jennings Bryan defends himself against Darrow's charge of being an ignorant bigot, saying he will prepare a formal answer on behalf of all Christians who believe in the Bible. A separate item reports the Scopes defense spent roughly $25,000, mostly on expert witnesses who were ultimately barred from testifying.
The Milwaukee Leader · 23 July 1925 · page 3
Darrow’s charge that I am an igno rant bigot. I am not vain enough to think that this compliment—for, coming from him, jt was a compli ment —was intended for me alone. While it was addressed to me, it was intended for all who dare differ from ,him to the exent of believing in the Bible, the God whom it re vc als and the supernatural Christ of whom it tells.
Columnist James Oneal reports on a New York scientist's discovery of a primitive Baptist fundamentalist sect near Dayton, Tennessee, who believe the earth is flat and the sun circles it like a needle on a phonograph disc. The piece suggests this sect is even more literal than William Jennings Bryan in its biblical interpretation.
The Milwaukee Leader · 23 July 1925 · page 14
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
An editorial argues that Bryan, despite opposing evolution in biology, implicitly accepts intellectual evolution since he believes in a round, sun-orbiting earth. It mocks his outdated views on monetary policy as further evidence he resists modern scientific and intellectual progress.
The Milwaukee Leader · 23 July 1925 · page 14
WHAT IS IN YOUR HEAD?
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
A newspaper photo caption identifies the key figures in the Scopes evolution trial at Dayton, Tennessee: William Jennings Bryan for the prosecution, Judge Ralston presiding, and Clarence Darrow for the defense, with an inset photo of defendant John T. Scopes. It describes the courtroom clash as a nationally watched, informal 'shirt-sleeved' affair.
Eagle River Review · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
At the Scopes trial in Dayton, William Jennings Bryan delivered an impassioned speech defending the Bible's account of creation, invoking the Leopold-Loeb case and attacking evolution as corrupting youth. Dudley Field Malone then argued for science and the individual's right to seek truth, receiving even greater applause than Bryan.
Eagle River Review · 23 July 1925 · page 10
BRYAN SCORES ON ORIGIN
Dayton, Tenn.—Dayton heard Wil iam Jennings Bryan plead for revealed religion, for salvation, for the Bible’s account of creation. He “scourged the ■coffers and there was mighty ap plause. Then Dudley Field Maione, Scopes lawyer, arose and stated the case for science—as not being In conflict with real religion. He pleaded for the in dividual s right to search for the (ruth. And, an amazing thing, he won even greater cheers than Bryan. Bryan had .spoken. He had thrown all his prepared arrows a' Darrow. He had singled out the Leopold-Loeb case as the one example of corrupted youth, poisoned by the philosophy of the modern schools, the students of Nietzsche.
See moreSee less
This was only one step from evolu tion, Mr. Bryan had argued. He had offered to call a million witnesses who rejected evolution because It conflicted with ths Bible. He drew a picture of the family tree of the evolutionists, tracing it back to monkey and a “lone ly cell in the bottom of the sea,” and described how it took faith and moral ity and God away from the children and made scoffers of them. He spoke of the “revealed religion" of the Bible, the beautiful story of Christ, the Virgin birth, the atone ment. the resurrection, all the Chris tian faith with its consolations for mankind, claiming that this was elim inated, destroyed, by science and their hypothesis of evolution. ’.e ridiculed the majority of scientists as unbe lievers, the Christian evolutionists as having a vague, far-away God that they could not feel. He spoke for im mortality, for salvation, for all the re ligious doctrine that forms the founda tion ot the faith of the American na tion. But the strange part of it was the other side was with him. They, too, accepted this consolation and this hope and this salvation. But they insisted on their own freedom of interpreta tion, that the Bible must not be used t’s a textbook of science, not taught as a course of science in the schools, not used In that way at all. It was a book for the private conscience. William Jennings Bryan outlined the state’s fight against expert wit nesses on the theory of evolution in a stirring plea as follows: “A Christian believes that man comes from above, but ths evolution ists believe that man comes from be low. “Man is shown as a mammal, scat tered around somewhere inside a cir cle with 3,499 other mammals. Includ ing elephants. “A great game in public schools now is trying to find man. You can’t find him. “Now here we have our glorious pedigree and each child is expected to take It home to his family to be sub stituted for the Bible family tree. “I do not think evolution deserves to be called a theory, it is a hypo thesis. “Every theory has failed and today there is not a scientist who has trreed one species to another, and yet they call us ignoramuses and bigots be cause we don’t throw away our Bible. “This doctrine of evolution disputes the very thought of the virgin birth, eliminates the resurrection and the atonement Evolutionists leave no room for miracles and the Bible teems with miracles. They deny by logic every truth of the Christan reIglon. “Experts cannot be permitted to come into this court and testify that evolution is not a bad doctrine. “If they had half the affection for Tennessee, Indicated by their pres ence here, they would have appeared before the legislature.” Dudley Field Malone of counsel for Scopes, defending the right to introJuce expert testimony, pictured Wll dam Jennings Bryan in a dangerous role. He said: “Whether Mr. Bryan likes it or not,
The passage reports speeches made during the Scopes trial, with William Jennings Bryan arguing against allowing expert scientific testimony on evolution, framing it as incompatible with Christian faith including the virgin birth and resurrection. Dudley Field Malone countered for the defense, beginning to argue for the right to introduce such testimony.
Judge John T. Raulston ruled to exclude expert witness testimony from the Scopes evolution trial, stating that Tennessee's legislature had already settled the question of conflict between evolution and the Bible. Scientists were permitted to submit written statements for consideration by the Appellate court instead.
Eagle River Review · 23 July 1925 · page 10
Tennessee Judge Bars Experts in Scopes Trial Dayton, Tenn. —Tennessee has closed the door against science. Fundamental ism has won. There will be appeals to higher courts, but so far as the decision here is concerned the matter is to all intent and purpose settled now. Tennessee's legislature has decided that evolution and the Bible conflict, and that settles the question, Judge John T. Raulston ruled in barring ex pert witnesses from the trial of John T. Scopes. However, the scientists are writing their views for presentation to the Appellate court. No light cf science or theology is needed, he declared, where the policy of the state has been clearly stated by the legislature.
The report states that after the Dayton trial concluded, the Scopes case is headed to the Tennessee (referred to as U.S.) supreme court to test the validity of the state's anti-evolution law. It also notes planned drives for similar anti-evolution laws in at least seven other states.
Baraboo Weekly News · 23 July 1925 · page 1
HIGH COURTS TO TEST CASE OF EVOLUTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Baraboo Weekly News · Baraboo, Wis.
A Scripps-Howard correspondent, John T. Moutoux, argues the Scopes trial was not started as a publicity stunt, describing how little attention the case initially drew. He recounts Scopes's indifference to the warrant and a reporter not bothering to phone in the story, illustrating the case's slow rise from local obscurity to international attention.
Baraboo Weekly News · 23 July 1925 · page 2
ORIGIN OF EVOLUTION STORY That the Scopes evolution case was “no more started as a publicity stunt to advertise Dayton than was the Santa Barbara earthquake started to advertise Santa Bar bara,” is the declaration of John T. Moutoux, staff correspondent of the Seripps-Howard newspapers, which relieves our spirit not a little. The truth seems to be that this story now agitating the thought of * the civilized world, came out of obscurity very slowly. When the warrant was served on the school teacher, John T. Scopes, so little importance was attached to the in cident that one correspondent did not think a 30 cent telephone call to his Chattanooga newspa per was justified.
See moreSee less
All the newspa per correspondents visiting Dayton have commented on the fact that the principals in the case and tho public in general in Tennessee have been greatly perplexed by the ap pearance of newspaper men from distant cities, sending hundreds of thousands of words by telegraph to the emtropolitan newspapers of the country and the world. When Mr. Moutoux arrived in Dayton, on the night that Scopes was bound to court, he telephoned to the school teacher, asking for an interview, but Scopes, appar ently unappreciating the import ance of the call and disgusted be cause his name was getting into the local papers, hung up the re ceiver. The story of how a drug-store discussion led to the decision to test the anti-evolution law in the courts has been told many times. Here is what happened after the deputy sheriff had come, by Te quest and served the warrant for Scopes’ arrest according to Mr. * Moutoux. “Let’s give the story to the Chattanooga Times,” suggested Attorney Wallace Haggard, who is a friend of the managing editor. “it isn’t worth it,” said E. F. Robinson, who, in addition to op erating the drug store and being president of the school board and a leader in the Progressive Dayton
An Editor & Publisher piece recounts how the Scopes case became national news, describing a reporter's failed attempt to interview Scopes and the drugstore conversation among Dayton locals that led to the story being phoned in to the Chattanooga Times. It traces how a small three-inch item grew into a flood of press inquiries from across the country within a day.
At a Baptist Young People's Union assembly in Mandeville, Louisiana, a prayer was offered for the conversion to Christianity of Clarence Darrow, defense attorney in the just-concluded Scopes trial. The prayer, suggested by state secretary E. D. Solomon, ended with a chorus of 'amens' from attendees.
The Telegraph-Courier · 23 July 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
This is a collection of editorial musings and local commentary from the Kenosha Evening News, touching briefly on Judge Raulston's ruling and the contrasting receptions given to Malone and Bryan. The bulk of the passage covers unrelated local topics like coal strikes, prohibition, and hospital fundraising.
The Telegraph-Courier · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
John Thomas Scopes argues the trial is not really about science versus religion or state control of curriculum, but about the church's recurring need for renewal from intolerance and dogma. He reflects on religious intolerance in society and states that the question of evolution and modernism can only be resolved by scientists and theologians over time, not by court decisions.
The Telegraph-Courier · 23 July 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
John Scopes was found guilty by the jury after only nine minutes of deliberation, with the defense waiving argument to speed an appeal. Judge Raulston fined him $100, set bond at $500, and granted 30 days to file an appeal to the state supreme court.
The Telegraph-Courier · 23 July 1925 · page 7
From Record by Judge. Dayton, Tenn. —• John Thomas Scopes was convicted in Rhea county circuit court at 11:29 o’clock this morning for violating the state statute prohibiting the teaching of theories of evolution in the public schools. He was fined SIOO, the minimum fine under the statute. Notice of inten tion to appeal to the Tennessee su preme court was filed and 30 days giv en in which to perfect the appeal with sn assurance from the court that if additional time should be found nec essary an extension would be granted.
See moreSee less
The case was given to the jury at 11:20, a verdict being returned in nine minutes, after counsel had agreed to waive arguments. A short state ment was made to the jury by Clar ence Darrow of defense coUnsei in which he said, “I don’t see how you can find our client not guilty.” He had explained that the evidence upon which the defense had hoped to bring about the acquittal of Scopes had been excluded by the court and it was the wish of the defense that a verdict of guilty be returned to permit an appeal to the supreme court. Scopes was summoned before the bar. Judge Raulston told him of his con viction by the jury and read a copy of the statement to him. The judge then fixed the fine at SIOO.
The jury deliberated nine minutes and found Scopes guilty, with Darrow urging a guilty verdict to enable appeal. Judge Raulston fined Scopes $100, and the defense announced it would appeal to the Tennessee Supreme Court.
The Telegraph-Courier · 23 July 1925 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
Bryan's Testimony On Monday Is Ordered Expunged From Record by Judge.
Dayton, Tenn. — [illegible] — John Thomas Scopes was convicted in Rhea county circuit court at 11:29 o'clock this morning for violating the state statute prohibiting the teaching of theories of evolution in the public schools.
He was fined $100, the minimum fine under the statute. Notice of intention to appeal to the Tennessee supreme court was filed and 30 days given in which to perfect the appeal with an assurance from the court that if additional time should be found necessary an extension would be granted.
The case was given to the jury at 11:20, a verdict being returned in nine minutes, after counsel had agreed to waive arguments. A short statement was made to the jury by Clarence Darrow of defense counsel in which he said, "I don't see how you can find our client not guilty." He had explained that the evidence upon which the defense had hoped to bring about the acquittal of Scopes had been excluded by the court and it was the wish of the defense that a verdict of guilty be returned to permit an appeal to the supreme court.
Scopes was summoned before the bar.
Judge Raulston told him of his conviction by the jury and read a copy of the statement to him.
The judge then fixed the fine at $100.
Bond was fixed at $500 pending an appeal.
"Have you anything to say, Mr. Scopes," asked the judge.
Scopes Determined to Fight On.
"Your Honor, I have been convicted of violating an unjust statute," replied Scopes, "any action other than I have pursued would be in violation of my idea of academic freedom."
The judge repeated the fine of $100.
Scopes added to the court in his statement that he would continue to oppose the law in every way in his power as he considered it an unjust law and in violation of the constitution.
Dudley Field Malone announced that bond would be arranged at once. Mr. Malone also thanked "the pepole of this community for their hospitality and for the opportunity to try the issues in this case."
Scopes was to appear in court during the afternoon to file a bond of $500, pending disposition of the appeal.
The appeal from the circuit court finding will be made to the Tennessee supreme court meeting in Knoxville in September. A formal motion for arrest of judgment was made on application for a new trial but was overruled. The assembly of the transcript for use in the appeal will be the next task for the defense, attorneys said.
Dramatic Closing Moments.
The scenes attending the close of the eight-day trial were without parallel in the experiences of veteran court observers.
Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Malone, Arthur Garfield Hays and Dr. John R. Neal, of the array of Scopes counsel, delivered farewell messages to the court and to the crowd. The attorneys from northern cities thanked the court and local organizations for hospitable treatment and courtesies.
William Jennings Bryan, of prosecution counsel, and his colleagues, Ben T. McKenzie, and Gordon McKenzie, proclaimed their confidence in the ultimate triumph of right, regardless of human error. The court in a final plea commended the lawyers in the case and declared that true courage was found in the breast of a man who could fight for what he thought to be right, in the face of adverse popular sentiment.
The jury stood and posed for photographers as defense lawyers made final arrangements for their appeal.
Later the meeting was thrown open for general discussion and a half dozen informal speeches were made, thanking the people of Dayton for their hospitality during the period of the trial.
Bryan Loses a Point.
Testimony of William Jennings Bryan, given in the Scopes case yesterday was expunged from the record of the case by Judge Raulston this morning.
The Scopes trial was opened here this morning by a statement from Judge Raulston that the court had had some important matters to pass on.
"I fear I may have committed error yesterday," he said, "In my overzeal to ascertain if there was anything in the proof that was offered to enable the higher courts to ascertain if there was error."
"I feel that the testimony of Mr. Bryan can shed no light on any issue that will be pending before the higher courts," he said.
"The issue is whether Mr. Scopes taught that man descended from a lower order of animals.
"I feel that Mr. Bryan's testimony cannot aid the higher courts," he repeated. "Therefore I am pleased to expunge this testimony from the records of this court."
In discussing the court's ruling, Clarence Darrow said: "We have no proof to offer."
What Might Have Been.
Arthur G. Hayes, for the purposes of perfecting the record in the event of an appeal, read a list of the witnesses the defense would have offered had they been permitted to do so and took a formal exception.
He also asked that the record show that Scopes had a contract to teach in the Rhea county school from September 1 to May 1.
William Jennings Bryan in discussing the expunging of his testimony, suggested that the views of the defense counsel had not been brought out as clearly as might have been. Dudley Field Malone, for the defense, related that members of his side of the cas ewere ready at any time to make their views public when such an issue was germane.
It was explained that the defense's testimony on which it relied to acquit Scopes having been excluded, the defense would state to the jury that it could not ask a verdict of "not guilty" and was satisfied to have a conviction in this court than an appeal might be made to the supreme court of Tennessee and possibly eventually to the United States supreme court.
Clarence Darrow, of defense counsel said that he would make such a statement to the jury.
Heard Only Little Evidence.
The jury had not heard any of the testimony of the defense "test witness" Dr. Maynard M. Metcalf, nor the statements read into the records from scientists and biblical scholars. The only information officially reaching the jury's ears was four state witnesses, two school boys, the superintendent of schools and the chairman of the board of education, and openments from state and defense.
The judge began reading his charge to the jury at 11:04. He opened his charge by reviewing the act under which Scopes was indicted.
"The state must make out its case beyond a reasonable doubt," the court old the jury.
The judge called attention to the wording of the indictment in which it was charged that the defendant taught a theory of evolution, teaching that man descended from a lower order of animals or denied the story of divine creation as taught in the bible.
The judge charged that if the defendant should have violated the law against teaching that man descended from a lower order of animals he should be convicted. The question of denial of the divine story of creation as taught in the bible was not before the jury, the court ruled.
After the judge finished reading his charge, Clarence Darrow said the defense had no requests to make.