John T. Scopes, soon to stand trial in Dayton, Tennessee for teaching evolution, recounts his farewell visit to New York sympathizers, saying he is pleased to be the 'goat' in a fight for freedom of thought. He also describes lawyer Dudley Field Malone joining the defense team and shares lighthearted impressions of New York before heading home.
The Union Daily Times · 11 June 1925 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SCOPES SAYS PLEASURE TO BE THE GOAT
New York June 11—(A P)—Figurative goats, instead of monkeys, have figured largely in the closing hours of the New York visit of John T. Scopes, high school teacher, who goes on trial next month at Dayton, Tenn., for violating the state law against the teaching of evolution.
See moreSee less
In an address last night to New York sympathizers Scopes told of his pleasure of "being the goat" in a fight for freedom of thought.
Dudly Field Malone, New York lawyer, who had been relegated to assist with research work, announced he would not be a "goat" that he would assist actively in the case or not at all. So he was accepted as one of the active counsel.
Scopes, who leaves for home today, was a guest at a dinner of the civic club last night. He said he was embarrassed in addressing the distinguished group of liberals and radicals first because he was young and inexperienced and secondly because while an automobile had been sent to get Clarence Darrow, one of his counsel, he had to walk to the club and got lost.
"Being a goat is not so unpleasant,, he said, "If you are going to be a goat you want to take thought as to whether you are to be a big goat or a little one. I really and truly think this is a fight for freedom of thought. This trial is not to judge whether I am a criminal."
As to sidelights of his New York visit Scopes said: "I found New Yorkers the most lovable people in this country with the most greedy hotels and restaurants and the most selfish people those reporters who wanted to monopplize all my time and not even let me see the follies."
If scopes did get the follies he did find amustment at another theatre in a skirt forecasting the coming evolution trial. There were three characters, William Jennings Bryan, as prosecutor, Scopes and a monkey as a witness.
John Randolph Neal, chief counsel for Scopes, who visited New York wit hhim, has announced a revision in associate counsel. As now planned, they will be Clarence Darrow, Bainbridge Colby, Dudley Field Malone, Arthur Garfield Hayes, eastern manager of the La Follette campaign last fall and Charles W. Thomas, former senator from Colorado.
Malone was reinstated as an active trial associate after he gave notice that he would do mere research work.
"I either stay on an equal basis with other associate counsel or I quit," he said. "If the fact that certain people think I am a Roman Catholic and others know one of my marriages ended in divorce and the fact that my name is Irish is to prove a greater hindrance than help, I must withdraw."
When invited to speak at the dinner to Scopes last night Darrow replied, "I wont come unless you let me make a speech." And speech he did make, bristling with references to "Bryans and bromides" and concluding with this plea for tolerance: "The best way is to try to infere as little as possible with other people, to cultivate a broad spirit of tolerance and charity and let people live their own lives."
Mr. Neal invited everybody down to Tennessee for the trial saying the summer climate was fine and that there are no mosquitoes.
John Scopes attended a dinner at the Civic Club in New York, joking about being the center of attention and describing the trial as a fight for freedom of thought. The report also details the finalized defense counsel roster including Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Malone, and others, plus Darrow's speech on tolerance.
The Union Daily Times · 11 June 1925 · page 1
BE THE GOAT
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Union Daily Times · Union, S.C.
A brief wire item notes that John T. Scopes spoke with his New York-based defenders about the experience of being selected as the defendant in the Tennessee evolution trial. He reportedly expressed amusement at being the test case or 'goat' in the matter.
The Union Daily Times · 11 June 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Chesterfield Advertiser · Chesterfield C.H., S.C.
A newspaper editorial comments on the impending clash between Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan over evolution theory, to take place in Tennessee. It suggests the debate will expose flaws on both sides—poor teaching of evolution and the folly of banning thought by law—and predicts it will become a battle of 'experts' much like the Leopold-Loeb case.
The Chesterfield Advertiser · 11 June 1925 · page 2
WHICH OF THEM KNOW LEAST?
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Chesterfield Advertiser · Chesterfield C.H., S.C.
Clarence Darrow has been selected as defense counsel for John T. Scopes, the Tennessee teacher charged with violating the state's evolution law. The ACLU's Forrest Bailey said the defense hopes to make the trial a dramatic, nationally significant event focusing attention on religion's relation to evolution and education.
The Chesterfield Advertiser · 11 June 1925 · page 4
DARROW DEFENDS JOHN T. SCOPES
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Chesterfield Advertiser · Chesterfield C.H., S.C.
This pre-trial report from New York describes the legal teams assembling for the Scopes case, noting Bainbridge Colby joining the defense alongside Clarence Darrow, while William Jennings Bryan will assist the prosecution. It also mentions that Charles Evans Hughes might be called in only if the case reaches the Supreme Court on constitutional grounds.
The Chesterfield Advertiser · 11 June 1925 · page 4
JOHN T. SCOPES
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
The Westminster Gazette published an editorial condemning William Jennings Bryan's position as prosecution counsel in the upcoming Scopes evolution trial in Tennessee, calling his attitude 'too absurd for serious people to consider.' The paper predicted the case against teacher Scopes was essentially already decided due to Tennessee's anti-evolution law, but urged the law be abandoned as incompatible with scientific progress.
Brownsville Herald · 11 June 1925 · page 1
By ROBERT T. SMALL (Copyright, 1925. by Casper Tribune) DAYTON, Tenn., July B.—The seemingly important discovery has been made here that Clarence Darrow, of Dhicago, heavy gun in the defense of John Thomas Scopes,
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
John Thomas Scopes, after six days of attention in New York, departed for Dayton, Tennessee, accompanied by attorney John R. Neal ahead of his upcoming trial for teaching evolution. A banquet was held in his honor, and he joked about the case starting at a drugstore soda session.
The Seattle Star · 11 June 1925 · page 11
By ROBERT T. SMALL (Copyright, 1925. by Casper Tribune) DAYTON, Tenn., July B.—The seemingly important discovery has been made here that Clarence Darrow, of Dhicago, heavy gun in the defense of John Thomas Scopes,
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
Bainbridge Colby volunteers without pay to join Clarence Darrow and others defending John Thomas Scopes in his upcoming Dayton, Tennessee trial for teaching evolution. Defense team members express hope the trial will heal the rift between science and religion and correct public misconceptions about evolution.
The Milwaukee Leader · 11 June 1925 · page 5
Bainbridge Colby Joins Scopes Defense in Evolution Fight
IS ACCEPTED NEW YORK—Bainbridge Colby, secretary of state in the cabinet of Woodrow Wilson. Clarence Darrow, noted Chicago lawyer, and Dr. Jolin It. Neal, Tennessee, were an nounced late Tuesday as the active trial attorneys who will defend John Thomas Scopes in his forth coming trial at Dayton, Tenn., for teaching evolution in defiance of a State law. M. Colby’s name was added to the array of counsel when he volun teered to help without compensation. Dudley Field Malone, Now York, also is expected to be an associate in the defe A conference of those interested was held Tuesday at the offices of the American Civil Liberties union, nt which plans for the conduct of the defense were discussed.
At a meeting of the American Civil Liberties Union, defense organizers discussed plans to use the Scopes trial's publicity to reconcile science and religion and to counter fundamentalist opposition to evolution. Forrest Bailey said the defense would argue there is no conflict between evolution and the Bible, combining this with a legal argument for freedom of thought and teaching.
Former U.S. Senator Charles W. Thomas of Colorado has been added to the legal team defending John T. Scopes, who faces trial for teaching evolution. Other attorneys include Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Malone, and Bainbridge Colby.
Baraboo Weekly News · 11 June 1925 · page 1
SEN. THOMAS TO AID SCOPES
(CHARACTERISTIC. It is characteristic of the man that Attorney William Jennings Bryan, chief counsel in the prose cution of Prof. Scopes, should open liis case in a speed] at a banquet several days in advance of the beginning of tin* trial. It would only be carrying this characteristic a little nearer its logical end if Mr. Bryan would a k the next Democratic National Convention to clet t. i .: favor of legislation to I outlaw evolution. It is characteristic of Ir. Bryan that he is unable to sec that ttie cause of evolution and its relation to
Clipping to come
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
The report states that Clarence Darrow and Bainbridge Colby have been selected to assist in defending John T. Scopes against charges of teaching evolution in Tennessee. It claims their strategy will be to deliberately lose the case early on to set up appeals to higher courts, with Charles Evans Hughes held in reserve for a potential Supreme Court case.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Telegraph-Courier · 11 June 1925 · page 1
DARROW AND COLBY FOR MONKEY TRIAL Will Endeavor to Lose Scopes Case so They Can Prolong the Talk fest With Bryan. New York City result of various conferences in New York Clarence Darrow, Chicago crim inal lawyer, and Bainbridge Colby, former secretary of state, have been chosen to assist in the defense of John T. Scopes, Dayton, Tenn., high school teacher, charged with violating the Tennessee law prohibiting teach ing of evolution in the schools. Darrow and Colby are expected to lose the case in a spectacular fashion at first, preparatory to the state and United States supreme courts passing on the constitutionality of the law.
See moreSee less
Dudley Field Malone, who with Dar row first volunteered his services, was delegated to keep the home fires burn ing in New York. With Samuel Ros ensohn, of the legal staff of the civil liberties union Malone will engage in research. Malone was not chosen as one of the assistants to John R. Neal, for mer dean of the University of Ten nessee, it was suggested, because he was brought up a Roman Catholic and because he remarried after a divorce. Both of these circumstances, advisers said, might prejudice him with a Ten nessee jury. Charles Evan Hughes, also former secretary of state, will be held in re serve in the event the case reaches the United States supreme court. Mr. Hughes had been suggested by those who feared Darrow’s defense of Leo pold and Loeb, murderers of Bobby Franks, might provide ammunition for William J. Bryan, another former sec retary of state, who is to assist the prosecution. Just in For the Ride. The choice of Darrow and Colby was unanimous after a day of confer ences between the principals of a sub committee of the civil liberties union, which is financing the case. They will serve without pay only at the first trial. Scopes today was suffering from an attack of nerves due to the unusual amount of talking he had done and the resultant publicity. Tonight he will address a dinner at the civic club and then leave for home. Officials of the civil liberties union proclaimed their intention of making the trial the greatest show on earth. Dr. Neal said: “The trial w’ill be used as the occa sion for educating the public on the freedom of teaching in the public schools.” Spokesmen of the union listed the objectg as follows: “To educate the public on evolution. “To show that science and religion are not incompatible. “To demonstrate the necessity of leaving education unhampered by re stricted legislation.”
The civil liberties union selected Darrow and Colby as unpaid defense counsel for Scopes, while Malone was passed over due to his Catholic upbringing and remarriage after divorce, which advisers feared might prejudice a Tennessee jury. Hughes was held in reserve for a possible Supreme Court appeal, while Bryan would assist the prosecution; organizers declared their intent to use the trial to educate the public on evolution and academic freedom.
The Telegraph-Courier · 11 June 1925 · page 1
Just in For the Ride. The choice of Darrow and Colby was unanimous after a day of confer ences between the principals of a sub committee of the civil liberties union, which is financing the case. They will serve without pay only at the first trial. Scopes today was suffering from an attack of nerves due to the unusual amount of talking he had done and the resultant publicity. Tonight he will address a dinner at the civic club and then leave for home. Officials of the civil liberties union proclaimed their intention of making the trial the greatest show on earth. Dr. Neal said:
The Kenosha Evening News announces a series of articles by Dr. Percy W. Cobb explaining the theory of evolution, prompted by the Tennessee indictment of a teacher for teaching it. The series aims to inform readers without taking a side in the controversy.
The Telegraph-Courier · 11 June 1925 · page 1
EVOLUTION Just what is the theory of evo lution we read so much about in the newspapers? In Tennessee a young man is under indictment for having taught it. What did he teach? Just what does evolution imply? The Kenosha Evening News to morrow will present the first of a series of sketches and articles ex plaining just what the famous theory involves. The series was prepared by Dr. Percy W. Cobb, of Cleveland, an authority on the sub ject, and there will be one each day. This, of course, is merely an ex position of the theory, and no at tempt is made to force a decision one way or the other on who ij wrong.
See moreSee less
If you want to be posted on what it is all about, fellow these articles which will begin Thursday.
The item reports that John T. Scopes, the Dayton, Tennessee teacher indicted for teaching evolution, said the case originated from a drug store discussion that spiraled out of control. It frames the legal dispute as having arisen almost casually among local acquaintances.
Torrington Telegram · 11 June 1925 · page 4
cuusiiiuuonai issue was tne main one, has confounded' the opposition by his sudden switch to the science and re ligion conflict. He makes science black and religion Vhite. "You have no Idea what a black and brutal thing this evolution is," he is reported to have said as he leaned across the table at the blushing and embarrassed young defendant, John Scopes. "This anti-evolution law," Mr. Bryan said tonight, “simply prohibits the evolutionists from using the public schools for the purpose of substituting their kind of religion for the religion of the masses."
See moreSee less
While Mr. Bryan is thus bringing religion into the foreground, the de fense, through Prof. John R. Neal, senior counsel, sought today to swing the .constitutional Issue, making re ligion secondary. It was only a short time ago that the defense attorneys were worrying about bringing the religious evolution controversy into the case. Bryan Termed Ambitions Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Ma lone and Arthur Garfield Hayes, de fense lawyers, are supposed to be on their way here, but Mr. Bryan has the fort at present. Mr. Darrow is not of the Christian faith, which militates against his effect upon this situation. Mr. Bryan's challenge was met by Prof. Neal as follows: "We regard Mr. Bryan's speech last night the most remarkable utterance ever made by a lawyer just before his entrance into a trial of a criminal case. His speech comes as a challenge to the defense not to confine the test of the anti-evolution., law to the ex isting limitation of the constitution of Tennessee or even the United States, but instead to put on trial the truth or lack of truth the theory of evolution: the conflict or lack of conflict be tween science and religion, having demonstrated as he apparently ex pects to do, at least to his own satis faction, that evolution Is untrue and that it is destructive to Christianity. He forecasts that he will move rapidly from the lower court, then to the su preme court of Tennessee, then to the supreme court of the United States and having lost his fight on account of the exitsing constitutional guarantee of religious and educational liberties he i
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
John T. Scopes addressed liberals in New York, saying he was glad to be the "goat" in the test case over Tennessee's law against teaching evolution. He is due to stand trial in Dayton, Tennessee the following month.
Paper unidentified · 11 June 1925 · page 1
cuusiiiuuonai issue was tne main one, has confounded' the opposition by his sudden switch to the science and re ligion conflict. He makes science black and religion Vhite. "You have no Idea what a black and brutal thing this evolution is," he is reported to have said as he leaned across the table at the blushing and embarrassed young defendant, John Scopes. "This anti-evolution law," Mr. Bryan said tonight, “simply prohibits the evolutionists from using the public schools for the purpose of substituting their kind of religion for the religion of the masses."
See moreSee less
While Mr. Bryan is thus bringing religion into the foreground, the de fense, through Prof. John R. Neal, senior counsel, sought today to swing the .constitutional Issue, making re ligion secondary. It was only a short time ago that the defense attorneys were worrying about bringing the religious evolution controversy into the case. Bryan Termed Ambitions Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Ma lone and Arthur Garfield Hayes, de fense lawyers, are supposed to be on their way here, but Mr. Bryan has the fort at present. Mr. Darrow is not of the Christian faith, which militates against his effect upon this situation. Mr. Bryan's challenge was met by Prof. Neal as follows: "We regard Mr. Bryan's speech last night the most remarkable utterance ever made by a lawyer just before his entrance into a trial of a criminal case. His speech comes as a challenge to the defense not to confine the test of the anti-evolution., law to the ex isting limitation of the constitution of Tennessee or even the United States, but instead to put on trial the truth or lack of truth the theory of evolution: the conflict or lack of conflict be tween science and religion, having demonstrated as he apparently ex pects to do, at least to his own satis faction, that evolution Is untrue and that it is destructive to Christianity. He forecasts that he will move rapidly from the lower court, then to the su preme court of Tennessee, then to the supreme court of the United States and having lost his fight on account of the exitsing constitutional guarantee of religious and educational liberties he i
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
John Randolph Neal announced the revised defense counsel for John Scopes, including Clarence Darrow, Bainbridge Colby, Dudley Field Malone, and Arthur Garfield Hays. Scopes also spoke in New York about being a willing 'goat' in the fight for freedom of thought.
Paper unidentified · 11 June 1925 · page 1
This utterance, made just on the eve of the trial, Is regarded as forecast ing the return of Bryan to the political limelight, especially 1“ view *ds P'a“ to make a pilgrimage to the Holy Land soon after the case is over. His re turn from that pilgrimage, his friends hone, will rival the return of Roosevelt from Africa and have much the same significance. There la further significance in the fact that Bryan has told friends pri vately here that the next democratic candidate must come from the south and west.
See moreSee less
These are the thoughts that are run ning through the minds of some here during the lull before the trial Friday. Day’s Developments developments today were: 1. Withdrawal of Balnbridge Colby from the Dayton end of the trial. He probably will assist the defense in its appeals to the higher courts but not in the jury trial. . ' . . J 2. Statement by John R. Neal, chief defense counsel, replying to Bryan’s dec laration that if the courts overthrow the Tennessee law, the case will be j appealed directly to the people. 8. Speech by Bryan at Morgan Springs, j 10 miles away, in which he declared | that the majority must r ile in control-; ling the schools as'In all other civic issues. , 4. Appointment of William Jennings Bryan, Jr., a Los Angeles lawyer, to assist his noted father in the prosecu tion. Preparations Complete Dayton’s preparations for the trial are complete. Residents are awaiting the arrival of Clarence Darrow Thursday night as the next big episode. Dud ley Field Malone, of New York, an other defense attorney, also is due Thursday. Some regret was expressed that Baln bridge Colby, the other leading defense attorney, would be detained in New York by conferences on another case. But this will not be a blow to the de fense, as It was planned to reserve Colby chiefly for the constitutional argu ments rather than the Jury trial any way. He has not quit the case and is expected to take part when the argu ments are made before the higher John R. Neal, chief counsel for Scones, took issue with Bryan’s statement be fore the Progressive club of Dayton that the people will decide this case if the courts overturn the anti-evolution law, and that the issue is between evo lution and Christianity. Neal commented especially on Bry an’s forecast of a national fight for a constitutional amendment which will make it possible to bar evolution from the schools. Speech Called Remarkable Neal said Bryan’s previous speech was! the “most remarkable utterance ever1 made by a lawyer Just before his en-1 trance into a trial of a criminal case.” • The speech, he said, is a challenge to put on trial the truth or lack of truth of the theory of evolution. “Having demonstrated as he appar ently expects to do, at least to his satis faction, that evolution is untrue and I destructive of Christianity, he forecast that he will move rapidly from the lower court, then to the supreme court! of Tennessee, then to the supreme court; of the United States, and having lost his fight on account of the existing constitutional guarantee of religious and educational immunities, to gain his point by a new constitutional amendment, a very ambitious program I should say— oven for Mr. Bryan." Neal said he would insist that the treat Issue is whether the law con flicts with the Tennessee constitution and the constitution of the United States in “this attempt to control the mind in its struggle after truth.”
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Attorney Malone objects to being sidelined to mere research work for the Scopes defense, citing his Catholic faith, divorce, and Irish name as possible reasons for marginalization. Darrow agrees to speak at a dinner honoring Scopes, delivering remarks on tolerance and criticizing Bryan.
Paper unidentified · 11 June 1925 · page 7
SCOPES AID TO BE 'GOAT'
This utterance, made just on the eve of the trial, Is regarded as forecast ing the return of Bryan to the political limelight, especially 1“ view *ds P'a“ to make a pilgrimage to the Holy Land soon after the case is over. His re turn from that pilgrimage, his friends hone, will rival the return of Roosevelt from Africa and have much the same significance. There la further significance in the fact that Bryan has told friends pri vately here that the next democratic candidate must come from the south and west.
See moreSee less
These are the thoughts that are run ning through the minds of some here during the lull before the trial Friday. Day’s Developments developments today were: 1. Withdrawal of Balnbridge Colby from the Dayton end of the trial. He probably will assist the defense in its appeals to the higher courts but not in the jury trial. . ' . . J 2. Statement by John R. Neal, chief defense counsel, replying to Bryan’s dec laration that if the courts overthrow the Tennessee law, the case will be j appealed directly to the people. 8. Speech by Bryan at Morgan Springs, j 10 miles away, in which he declared | that the majority must r ile in control-; ling the schools as'In all other civic issues. , 4. Appointment of William Jennings Bryan, Jr., a Los Angeles lawyer, to assist his noted father in the prosecu tion. Preparations Complete Dayton’s preparations for the trial are complete. Residents are awaiting the arrival of Clarence Darrow Thursday night as the next big episode. Dud ley Field Malone, of New York, an other defense attorney, also is due Thursday. Some regret was expressed that Baln bridge Colby, the other leading defense attorney, would be detained in New York by conferences on another case. But this will not be a blow to the de fense, as It was planned to reserve Colby chiefly for the constitutional argu ments rather than the Jury trial any way. He has not quit the case and is expected to take part when the argu ments are made before the higher John R. Neal, chief counsel for Scones, took issue with Bryan’s statement be fore the Progressive club of Dayton that the people will decide this case if the courts overturn the anti-evolution law, and that the issue is between evo lution and Christianity. Neal commented especially on Bry an’s forecast of a national fight for a constitutional amendment which will make it possible to bar evolution from the schools. Speech Called Remarkable Neal said Bryan’s previous speech was! the “most remarkable utterance ever1 made by a lawyer Just before his en-1 trance into a trial of a criminal case.” • The speech, he said, is a challenge to put on trial the truth or lack of truth of the theory of evolution. “Having demonstrated as he appar ently expects to do, at least to his satis faction, that evolution is untrue and I destructive of Christianity, he forecast that he will move rapidly from the lower court, then to the supreme court! of Tennessee, then to the supreme court; of the United States, and having lost his fight on account of the existing constitutional guarantee of religious and educational immunities, to gain his point by a new constitutional amendment, a very ambitious program I should say— oven for Mr. Bryan." Neal said he would insist that the treat Issue is whether the law con flicts with the Tennessee constitution and the constitution of the United States in “this attempt to control the mind in its struggle after truth.”
Clipping to come
Union Labor Bulletin · Little Rock, Ark.
A syndicated editorial piece previews the planned clash between Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan over evolution theory in Tennessee. It criticizes both sides, noting evolution is poorly taught in schools while anti-evolutionists wrongly assume laws can prevent thinking, predicting the case will become a battle of expert witnesses like the Leopold-Loeb trial.
Union Labor Bulletin · 12 June 1925 · page 4
WHICH OF THEM KNOWS LEAST
John R. Neal, chief counsel for Scones, took issue with Bryan’s statement be fore the Progressive club of Dayton that the people will decide this case if the courts overturn the anti-evolution law, and that the issue is between evo lution and Christianity. Neal commented especially on Bry an’s forecast of a national fight for a constitutional amendment which will make it possible to bar evolution from the schools. Speech Called Remarkable Neal said Bryan’s previous speech was! the “most remarkable utterance ever1 made by a lawyer Just before his en-1 trance into a trial of a criminal case.” • The speech, he said, is a challenge to put on trial the truth or lack of truth of the theory of evolution.
See moreSee less
“Having demonstrated as he appar ently expects to do, at least to his satis faction, that evolution is untrue and I destructive of Christianity, he forecast that he will move rapidly from the lower court, then to the supreme court! of Tennessee, then to the supreme court; of the United States, and having lost his fight on account of the existing constitutional guarantee of religious and educational immunities, to gain his point by a new constitutional amendment, a very ambitious program I should say— oven for Mr. Bryan." Neal said he would insist that the treat Issue is whether the law con flicts with the Tennessee constitution and the constitution of the United States in “this attempt to control the mind in its struggle after truth.”
Clipping to come
Union Labor Bulletin · Little Rock, Ark.
The article recounts how the Scopes trial began with a drugstore debate in Dayton, Tennessee, among Scopes, Rappelyea, and local lawyers about the new anti-evolution law. It explains the law's prohibition on teaching evolution and introduces the key figures involved in instigating the test case.
Union Labor Bulletin · 12 June 1925 · page 7
EVOLUTION THEORY.
Kansas City Weekly Star: A Village Debate Grows. “Dayton, Tenn.—One Sunday night about a month ago a group of young men sat in the rear of Robinson’s drug store in Dayton discussing evo lution and religion. It was a sort of Main street gathering in the empo rium of the ‘hustling druggis,’ and might have been duplicated in many small towns. “The particular subject that had started this discussion was the law the Tennessee Legislature recently had passed prohibiting the teaching in the public schools of any theory that denied the story of creation, as re lated in Genesis and which taught that “man has descended fiom a low er order of animal.’ In the group were John Thomas: Scopes, teacher of biology in the town high school; George W.
See moreSee less
Itappelyea.! a chemical engineer of the Cumber land Coal Company, and two young lawyers fresh from college, S. M.
The report recounts the famous drugstore meeting in Dayton where Rappelyea, Scopes, and local lawyers discussed evolution and the new anti-evolution law. Scopes admits he taught evolution using the assigned textbook 'A Civic Biology,' prompting Rappelyea to propose a test case and have him arrested to challenge the law.
Union Labor Bulletin · 12 June 1925 · page 7
Sunday school teacher and Bible stu dent, yet the youngengineer argued that the Bible was a mere history, that it had many errors, that the only book that God ever wrote is read through the spectacles of chemj istry, geology ami biology and on ev-! ery page of this book is the wonder-, ful story of evolution, bringing truth | and grandeur into icligion, not touch-1 ing the teachings of Christ about the kingdom of heaven. “The young lawyers, retaining a f rock-bottom faith in the religion of! their fathers, blinked but were uncon-1 vinced.
See moreSee less
“Finally, young Scopes was drawn into the argument. A red-headed, j good-looking boy, wearing glasses, ■ diffident, unassertive, yet with quiet passionate convictions. He had come from Salem, III., after a year at the University of Illinois through Ken tucky university and finally to this town to teach biology and coach tlte football team a year befoic.
The report recounts the Dayton drugstore meeting where Rappelyea confronted Scopes about teaching evolution from the banned textbook and proposed a test case. It details how Scopes agreed, the ACLU offered defense funding, Bryan joined the prosecution, Darrow joined the defense, and the grand jury indicted Scopes.
Union Labor Bulletin · 12 June 1925 · page 7
Agreed to Be Defendant. “Finally, after more talk, lasting j until midnight, the party broke up; and Scopes had agreed in the inter- ; csts of the teachers of Tennessee to, have the law tested in the courts. “The American Civil Liberties, Union came in with an offer to fij nance the defense. The Christian \ Fundamentalists’ Association wired j William Jennings Bryan, who agreed j at once to accept the role of chief, prosecutor. Clarence Darrow' wired; he would aid the defense. The town j
A humor column by H.I. Phillips satirizes the media circus building around the Scopes trial, joking that boxing promoter Tex Rickard has taken over the event and will stage it like a sporting spectacle with 60,000 seats. The piece invents absurd preliminary 'bouts' between fictional eccentric teachers with nonsensical scientific claims.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 12 June 1925 · page 4
EXTRA! TEX RICKARD TAKES OVER DAYTON EVOLUTION TRIAL
I enn.. tendering the nameof prospective juror* for the monkey rase to Judge J. (*. McKenzie. The trial f Halsey made a thorough inspection of the White House and reported that j are “covering Court. the Summer White House at Swanipscott, Mass., talking with the Chief F.xecuN - opens in Dayton, fenn.. tomorrow. \'id» World Photo. j t| lf > interior was “artistically terrible.” National Photo. J tive regarding matters of interest to the nation. **y Milter Photo Sirrli.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A humor column jokingly frames the upcoming Scopes trial as a prizefight, with absurd 'contestants' and fake training camp reports about Bryan and Scopes. It parodies the public anticipation before the trial begins.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 12 June 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
Scopes' defense attorneys Darrow, Colby, and Malone visited the American Museum of Natural History to study evidence on human evolution, consulting with Professor Henry Fairfield Osborn for scientific witnesses. Scopes himself attended a dinner with supporters in New York while press noted the influx of radicals and activists descending on Dayton for the trial.
a year. ,7ohn S. Elliott Is represent ing the Harriman Interests in Moa-tow. PREPARING CASE Barrow, Colby and Malone Are Hard at Work New Tork, June 12 (4whlla John T. Scopes, high school teacher, ras returning today from New Tork to Dayton, Tenn., his counsel were brushing up on the intricacies of the Ms? of man and there was much dls fcussion of the part radicals are playing in arrangements for the de fense of Scopes on a charge of vio lating the state law against teach ing evolution. Clarence Harrow, Bainbrldge Col ty and Dudley Field Malone, asso ciate defense counsel, visited the American Museum of Natural His tory yesterday.
See moreSee less
They saw in the ball of the age of man specimens show ing the evolution of man and the evolution of the borse. The con ferred with Professor Henry Fair Held Osborn. noted authority on evo lution and president of the museum, who promised aid in lining up sci entific witnesses. When Scopes visited the museum several days ago Professor Osborn warned him not to let radicals run the case, r.aler Scopes, as guest of bonor at a dinner of 300 so-called liberals and radicals, said: "I have met here in New York the most lovable bunch of people T ever knew these who have taken up my case." In this connection the New York Evening Post says: "Greenwich village is on Its way lo Rhea county. There shortly will descend upon Dayton, Tenn., the greatest aggregation of assorted fcranks, including agnostics, atheists, tommunists. syndicalists and new Hawners, ever known in a single procession. "The Scopes ease, teachers, re learch workers, biologists and other nen of science are being smothered In the rush of haired and short -Jiaired women, feminists, neurotics. tree-tliitiWs and free-lovers who fcre determined to shine In reflected glory. The vital issues on the trial In Tennessee are being lost In the Itampede of professional martyrs ,nd a swarm of practicing egotists." Some members of the Civil liber ties union, which Is aiding the de fense, disagree with suggestions that the case be lost in spectacular fashion at the first trial, in order to arouse interest in evolution and to Jet the United States supreme court pass on the constitutionality of the law. These dissenters feel that It would be more beneficial to rout the lo-called powers of darkness right at the start. Arthur F. Hunt of New York, co author of the book "Plology and Human Welfare," from which Scopes taught, has been amazed to learn the part his book was playing In the case. Mr. Hunt said evolu tion was d.-iilt with only superficial ly because the text was intended for elementary students. "Scientists don't speak of the gen eral doctrine of evolution as a the ory any more," he added. "It's a tact." HOMES FARMS
John Scopes was honored at a New York dinner attended by 300 self-described liberals and radicals, praising the people who took up his case. Commentators noted a flood of activists, scientists, and eccentrics descending on Dayton, Tennessee, while a textbook co-author expressed surprise his book was central to the case.
New Britain Herald · 12 June 1925 · page 28
PREPARING CASE
Evening Post says: "Greenwich village is on Its way lo Rhea county. There shortly will descend upon Dayton, Tenn., the greatest aggregation of assorted fcranks, including agnostics, atheists, tommunists. syndicalists and new Hawners, ever known in a single procession. "The Scopes ease, teachers, re learch workers, biologists and other nen of science are being smothered In the rush of haired and short -Jiaired women, feminists, neurotics. tree-tliitiWs and free-lovers who fcre determined to shine In reflected glory. The vital issues on the trial In Tennessee are being lost In the Itampede of professional martyrs ,nd a swarm of practicing egotists."
See moreSee less
Some members of the Civil liber ties union, which Is aiding the de fense, disagree with suggestions that the case be lost in spectacular fashion at the first trial, in order to arouse interest in evolution and to Jet the United States supreme court pass on the constitutionality of the law. These dissenters feel that It would be more beneficial to rout the lo-called powers of darkness right at the start. Arthur F. Hunt of New York, co author of the book "Plology and Human Welfare," from which Scopes taught, has been amazed to learn the part his book was playing In the case. Mr. Hunt said evolu tion was d.-iilt with only superficial ly because the text was intended for elementary students. "Scientists don't speak of the gen eral doctrine of evolution as a the ory any more," he added. "It's a tact."
John T. Scopes, a science teacher, has been indicted by the Rhea County grand jury for teaching evolution in violation of Tennessee law. The trial is scheduled for July 10 in Dayton, based on testimony from his students, and will address whether the state can require teaching based on the Bible versus scientific theory.
Washington Journal · 12 June 1925 · page 4
- Test Case Planned. When Scopes finished, his friend. Doctor George W. Happleyea, a young civil engineer, arose to say: "Any man teaching from that book is. guilty of violating the law. Why, Scopes, you’re Violating the law, and We ought to make a test out of this thing to show the law is unconstitutional.” The other two debaters—Wallace 6. Haggard and Sue K. Hicks, young lawyers—said the same thing. "And we’ll help to prosecute you," they added. Thus waS born the Scopes trial and the test of Tennessee’s anti evolution law.
See moreSee less
Rappleyea swore out a warrant; young Scopes was arrested and released on bis own recognizance to await a preliminary magistrate’s hearing. He obtained the services of Judge John L. God sey, a Dayton lawyer, to represent him. x At the preliminary hearing Scopes was bound oVer for the grand jury under |l,ooo bond. His friend, Rap pleyea, was the plaintiff, and his other two friends. Haggard and Hicks, had prosecuted him. They all thought it was good fun. In the meantime the little fire ignited in the village courtroom had spread across America. William Jennings Bryan, one of the nation’s leading fundamentalists as well as thrice leader of the Democratic party, came to Memphis and, in a. speech, upheld the anti-evolution law. while offering his services to the State in the prosecution of the Scopes case. His ’ offer was ac cepted.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
As Scopes returns to Dayton, his defense counsel including Darrow, Colby, and Malone consult with scientists at the American Museum of Natural History. Commentators warn that the case's scientific merits risk being overshadowed by an influx of radicals, agnostics, and professional activists descending on the trial.
Evening Star · 12 June 1925 · page 2
SCOPES' DEFENSE IMPERILED BY MENACE OF RADICALISM
Natural selection 4e explained as “a continuous adjustment of internal * to external relations.’’ Anti-evolutionists would explain this and all the other theories of evolution gs a continuous injustice of infernal inferences to eternal relations. The populace of Dayton 'mil probably get as much kick out 'of the Scopes trial as the inhabitants of Salem got dut of the witch burning festivals. However, while they won’t be permitted to burn Scopes dt the stajce, his intellectual rights a« a school teacher will be a* stake. ■■■■ ■ • Considering what the Scopes trial is doing for the town of Dayton, it will be an unappre ciative jury that will find Scopes guilty.
See moreSee less
Will Dar-wint That all depends on how successfully Dar-rows against the tide of intolerance backing up in Tennessee. F. J. SCHWAB.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
John Thomas Scopes, soon to stand trial for teaching evolution in Tennessee, visited Annapolis with his attorney John R. Neal to confer with Dr. Jesse W. Sprowls, a professor dismissed from the University of Tennessee on similar grounds. Separately, a co-author of the biology textbook at issue expressed surprise at its role in the case, noting evolution is now treated as fact rather than theory.
Evening Star · 12 June 1925 · page 2
SCOPES IN ANNAPOLIS
However, while they won’t be permitted to burn Scopes dt the stajce, his intellectual rights a« a school teacher will be a* stake. ■■■■ ■ • Considering what the Scopes trial is doing for the town of Dayton, it will be an unappre ciative jury that will find Scopes guilty. Will Dar-wint That all depends on how successfully Dar-rows against the tide of intolerance backing up in Tennessee. F. J. SCHWAB.
Clipping to come
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
While Tennessee moves to prohibit evolution instruction, Chicago's Board of Education approves five new biology textbooks that explain evolution in detail, including diagrams comparing human, ape, and horse skeletons. The report notes that one author, Hunter, wrote the textbook whose use led to John Scopes's indictment in Tennessee.
The Washington Daily News · 12 June 1925 · page 3
Evolution Taught In Chicago
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
This report covers reactions from Washington D.C. school board members to a clause in an appropriations bill about 'disrespect for the Holy Bible,' with most members stating they don't believe teaching evolution violates this clause. The ACLU also weighs in, asserting freedom of science education against legislative interpretation of Bible or science.
The Washington Daily News · 12 June 1925 · page 3
Teaching Evolution Here
Now they have a federal judge in dicted for alleged doing in the wreck ing of a bank in Tennessee. Some thing will have to break in other quarters, else Tennessee will get all the summer advertising. That state ought to be satistied with the Scopes el :
Clipping to come
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
John T. Scopes, en route to his trial in Dayton, Tennessee, stopped in Washington to confer with scientists and his counsel Dr. John R. Neal. He also visited Dr. Jesse Sprowis, a witness in the case who had earlier been dismissed from the University of Tennessee for teaching evolution.
The Washington Daily News · 12 June 1925 · page 1
Scopes Comes to Washington to Confer
Now they have a federal judge in dicted for alleged doing in the wreck ing of a bank in Tennessee. Some thing will have to break in other quarters, else Tennessee will get all the summer advertising. That state ought to be satistied with the Scopes el :
Clipping to come
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
Board of Education president James T. Lloyd says he will study the legislative history of a congressional clause banning funds for teaching 'disrespect for the Holy Bible' to see if D.C. schools violate it by teaching evolution. Lloyd, a self-described fundamentalist, says he doubts the clause would bar use of the same textbook that led to Scopes's indictment in Tennessee, but wants to confirm Congress's intent.
The Washington Daily News · 12 June 1925 · page 1
MEMBERS BACK DOCTRINE
Tins utterance, made just on the Jve of tho trial, is regarded as fore casting the return of B'yan to the political limelight, especially In view of his plan to make a pilgrimage to the Holy land soon after the case is over. His return from that pil grimage, his friends hope, would ri val the return of Roosevelt from Africa and have much the same significance^' Bryan Talks Politics There is further significance in the fact that Bryan h^s told friends privately here that the next deroo .cratic candidate must come from the south and west. These are the thoughts that are running through the minds of some here d-uring the lull before the trial Friday. t • Developments Wednesday were:
Clipping to come
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
A Washington school board member says he will research congressional intent behind a 1921 appropriations clause that might bar paying teachers who use the evolution textbook central to the Scopes indictment. Other board members had varying opinions, and none had known the clause was connected to the book used in Scopes's case.
The Washington Daily News · 12 June 1925 · page 1
MEMBERS BACK DOCTRINE
lawyer, to assist his n.oted father in »he prosecution. . Dayton is Ready Dayton’s preparations for the trial *are complete. Residents are await ing the arrival of Clarence Darrow Thursday night as the next big epi
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
German scientists at the University of Berlin commented on the upcoming Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, saying the issue of teaching evolution is for America to decide. Professor Franz Keibel distinguished between orthodox Darwinism and the broader theory of evolution, expressing regret over Scopes's prosecution while noting he would likely be punished if a law existed against teaching evolution.
The Washington Times · 12 June 1925 · page 2
EVOLUTION LAW UP TO U.S. TO SETTLE
Dayton’s preparations for the trial *are complete. Residents are await ing the arrival of Clarence Darrow Thursday night as the next big epi sode. Dudley Field Malone, of Newr York, another defense attor ney, also is due Thursday. Some regret was expressed that Colby, the other leading defense at torney,. would be defeated in New York by conferences on another case. But this will not be a blow to the defense, as it was planned to reserve Colby chiefly for the consti tutional arguments rather than the jury trial. He has not quit the case and is expected to take part when the arguments are made before the higher courts. John R. Neal, chief counsel for Scopes, took issue with Bryan’s (.Continued on Page Four.)
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
German professors Keibel and Überach comment on the Scopes case, with Keibel distinguishing Darwinism from broader evolutionary theory and Überach calling the law an intolerable infringement on academic freedom. Northwestern University president Walter Dill Scott also issues a statement opposing the anti-evolution law, aligning with the Scopes defense.
The Washington Times · 12 June 1925 · page 2
JUDGE JOHN T. RALSTON Dayton, Tenn., July 8—(AP)—Ar rival of Judge John R. T. Ralston, in Dayton, today to preside at the trial of John T. Scopes, who must answer Friday to a charge of teaching evo lution in the public schools of Tenne see in vilation of a state law, mark ed another step in the progress of events leading to the actual opening of the trial. Clarence Darrow, defense lawyer, will reach Dayton tomorrow after noon about the same time Dudley Field Malone and Arthur Garfield Hayes, other defense attorneys, ar rive in Chattanooga.
See moreSee less
John Randall Neal issued a state ment for defense counsel today in which he said the defense considered Mr. Bryan’s address to the Dayton Progressive Club last night a chal lenge to the defense to "put the truth or lack of truth" or tueory of evolution to the test In the trial. Mr. Bryan made no comment when he read Dr. Neal’s statement. Scopes' Sister Gets Offer Lexington, Ky,., July 8—(AP)—Of fer 'of a position to teach mathe matics and possibly some science at Highland Manor, an exclusive count try boarding school for girls Ht Tarrytown, N. Y., was received today by Miss Lela W. Scopes, University of Kentucky. She failed to get her former position in the Paducah, Ky., public schools because she would not renounce her belief in the evolution ary theory held by her brother, John T. Scopes, of Dayton, Tcnn.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
The Tennessee State Board of Education adopted a new biology textbook that omits any mention of evolution, in compliance with the state's anti-evolution law. This book replaces the one previously used in high schools, including the one used by John Scopes in Dayton.
The Washington Times · 12 June 1925 · page 5
Evolutionless Biology Book Adopted for Tenn. Schools
Scopes Confers with Counsel John T. Scopes (right), the Tennessee high school teacher wh®
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A letter to the editor argues that Tennessee has the legal right to exclude evolution from its public school curriculum, comparing it to a state's right to omit any subject from taxpayer-funded schools. The author notes the law doesn't ban belief in evolution or its discussion elsewhere, only its teaching in public schools, and begins to question whether the theory itself is true.
The Washington Times · 12 June 1925 · page 24
EVOLUTION EXCLUDED
Scopes Confers with Counsel John T. Scopes (right), the Tennessee high school teacher wh®
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
A photograph shows the defense lawyers for John T. Scopes, including Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Malone, and Dr. John R. Neal, conferring with Scopes ahead of his Tennessee trial for teaching evolution. The caption jokes that they plan to 'make a monkey out of Bryan.'
South Bend News-Times · 12 June 1925 · page 1
TODAY BY ARTHUR BRISBANE While this nation discusses Darwin, evolution, William Jennings Bryan, Professor Scopes, science, theology, etc., Mother Nature proves that she has not "theories” and her eternal taws work without fear or favor. On the same evening in New York lightning struck the Museum of Nat ural History, the home of evolution, with stuffed monkeys of all kinds purporting to prove it. The same lightning storm set fire to a hospital and struck and shat tered the great cross on St. Patrick's cathedral.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A roundup of brief national and international news items reports that John T. Scopes, a high school teacher, has been indicted under Tennessee's law prohibiting the teaching of evolution, with his trial set for July 10. The item appears among unrelated news briefs about labor, politics, and disasters.
Paper unidentified · 12 June 1925 · page 4
tel Aqua. “It has been in the past a death grapple in the dark,” said Mr. Bryan, who arrived here today in prepara tion for the trial of John T. Scopes, • who is charged with violating the Tennessee statute against teaching evolution theories in the schools of Tennessee. ■“From this time on it will be a death grapple in the light.” Mr. Bryan, who is associated with counsel for the prosecution of the young high school instructor, was guest of the club which two weeks ago entertained Clarence Darrow of defense counsel in the same dining room The fundamentalist leader was introduced tonight by Wallace Haggard, member of the prosecution counsel.
See moreSee less
A welcome to Dayton was extended by John L. Godsey, local member of the defense counsel. One issue of the coming trial which is scheduled to begin next Friday is whether the people shall rule in the United States, the speaker asser ted. The people are the only source of the power he said, and will in the end control. The dinner ended a day which for Dayton has been one of the busiest since the coming of Darrow, Bain bridge Colby and Dtf&ley Field Ma lone. The arrival of Mr. Bryan short ly afternoon followed the return of John T. Scopes and Dr. John Neal chief defense counsel, from Cooke ville where yesterday they filed • petition for injunction to remove the case from the state to the federal I courts. 1 Mr. Bryan, from the train, was escorted to the home of Richard Rogers where he will make his head-' quarters. During the afternoon, hej held a brief conference with Sue K.! Hicks, Wallace C. Haggard, Judge J. G McKenzie and Herbert Hicks local members of the prosecution staff. He viewed the court room in which, the trial will be held and visited the I newspaper club room. Mr. Bryan' told newspaper men he was “pre pared for the trial.” Mr. Bryan spoke following the din ner which was attended by John T. Scopes, member of counsel for both parties to the suit, leaders iii Day ton’s civic life, and newspapermen. He avoided details of the Scopes case, saying the case would not be tried in the newspapers, but in the: courts. Three points, he said he could discuss with propriety. Referring to the size of Dayton Mr. Bryan said that “some of the city papers” have spoken disparingly of the town “as if it were too small a place in which to hold to great a trial.” "Why should the size of the town be a matter of importance in the trial of a religious case,” asked the speak er, “Christianity began in a small town< whether we date the beginning with the birth of Christ in Bethle hem or with the youth of Christ in Nazareth. Why should not this peace ful community furnish a fitting en vironment for the trial of a case that involves the two greatest sub jects that interest mankind—educa tion and religion. “The newspaper critics who have been making fun of Dayton should
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
At the Illinois Baptist convention, delegates passed a resolution rejecting evolutionary theory and affirming belief in biblical creation. When asked about the Scopes trial in Tennessee, President Pepper said he favored separation of church and state but hadn't followed the case closely.
Paper unidentified · 12 June 1925 · page 2
tel Aqua. “It has been in the past a death grapple in the dark,” said Mr. Bryan, who arrived here today in prepara tion for the trial of John T. Scopes, • who is charged with violating the Tennessee statute against teaching evolution theories in the schools of Tennessee. ■“From this time on it will be a death grapple in the light.” Mr. Bryan, who is associated with counsel for the prosecution of the young high school instructor, was guest of the club which two weeks ago entertained Clarence Darrow of defense counsel in the same dining room The fundamentalist leader was introduced tonight by Wallace Haggard, member of the prosecution counsel.
See moreSee less
A welcome to Dayton was extended by John L. Godsey, local member of the defense counsel. One issue of the coming trial which is scheduled to begin next Friday is whether the people shall rule in the United States, the speaker asser ted. The people are the only source of the power he said, and will in the end control. The dinner ended a day which for Dayton has been one of the busiest since the coming of Darrow, Bain bridge Colby and Dtf&ley Field Ma lone. The arrival of Mr. Bryan short ly afternoon followed the return of John T. Scopes and Dr. John Neal chief defense counsel, from Cooke ville where yesterday they filed • petition for injunction to remove the case from the state to the federal I courts. 1 Mr. Bryan, from the train, was escorted to the home of Richard Rogers where he will make his head-' quarters. During the afternoon, hej held a brief conference with Sue K.! Hicks, Wallace C. Haggard, Judge J. G McKenzie and Herbert Hicks local members of the prosecution staff. He viewed the court room in which, the trial will be held and visited the I newspaper club room. Mr. Bryan' told newspaper men he was “pre pared for the trial.” Mr. Bryan spoke following the din ner which was attended by John T. Scopes, member of counsel for both parties to the suit, leaders iii Day ton’s civic life, and newspapermen. He avoided details of the Scopes case, saying the case would not be tried in the newspapers, but in the: courts. Three points, he said he could discuss with propriety. Referring to the size of Dayton Mr. Bryan said that “some of the city papers” have spoken disparingly of the town “as if it were too small a place in which to hold to great a trial.” "Why should the size of the town be a matter of importance in the trial of a religious case,” asked the speak er, “Christianity began in a small town< whether we date the beginning with the birth of Christ in Bethle hem or with the youth of Christ in Nazareth. Why should not this peace ful community furnish a fitting en vironment for the trial of a case that involves the two greatest sub jects that interest mankind—educa tion and religion. “The newspaper critics who have been making fun of Dayton should
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A brief item mentions that the Scopes trial is about to begin at Dayton, Tennessee, with the evolution question as the central issue. It quotes William Jennings Bryan's remark comparing those who believe in evolution speculating at a monkey cage versus Christians going to church to learn moral perfection.
Paper unidentified · 12 June 1925 · page 6
tel Aqua. “It has been in the past a death grapple in the dark,” said Mr. Bryan, who arrived here today in prepara tion for the trial of John T. Scopes, • who is charged with violating the Tennessee statute against teaching evolution theories in the schools of Tennessee. ■“From this time on it will be a death grapple in the light.” Mr. Bryan, who is associated with counsel for the prosecution of the young high school instructor, was guest of the club which two weeks ago entertained Clarence Darrow of defense counsel in the same dining room The fundamentalist leader was introduced tonight by Wallace Haggard, member of the prosecution counsel.
See moreSee less
A welcome to Dayton was extended by John L. Godsey, local member of the defense counsel. One issue of the coming trial which is scheduled to begin next Friday is whether the people shall rule in the United States, the speaker asser ted. The people are the only source of the power he said, and will in the end control. The dinner ended a day which for Dayton has been one of the busiest since the coming of Darrow, Bain bridge Colby and Dtf&ley Field Ma lone. The arrival of Mr. Bryan short ly afternoon followed the return of John T. Scopes and Dr. John Neal chief defense counsel, from Cooke ville where yesterday they filed • petition for injunction to remove the case from the state to the federal I courts. 1 Mr. Bryan, from the train, was escorted to the home of Richard Rogers where he will make his head-' quarters. During the afternoon, hej held a brief conference with Sue K.! Hicks, Wallace C. Haggard, Judge J. G McKenzie and Herbert Hicks local members of the prosecution staff. He viewed the court room in which, the trial will be held and visited the I newspaper club room. Mr. Bryan' told newspaper men he was “pre pared for the trial.” Mr. Bryan spoke following the din ner which was attended by John T. Scopes, member of counsel for both parties to the suit, leaders iii Day ton’s civic life, and newspapermen. He avoided details of the Scopes case, saying the case would not be tried in the newspapers, but in the: courts. Three points, he said he could discuss with propriety. Referring to the size of Dayton Mr. Bryan said that “some of the city papers” have spoken disparingly of the town “as if it were too small a place in which to hold to great a trial.” "Why should the size of the town be a matter of importance in the trial of a religious case,” asked the speak er, “Christianity began in a small town< whether we date the beginning with the birth of Christ in Bethle hem or with the youth of Christ in Nazareth. Why should not this peace ful community furnish a fitting en vironment for the trial of a case that involves the two greatest sub jects that interest mankind—educa tion and religion. “The newspaper critics who have been making fun of Dayton should read the front page of the book which gave rise to this trial “The biology which the defendant was teaching has as its frontispiece a picture of a crowded city street and just below it the picture of a farm house on a quiet i country road. Beneath the pictures is a suggestion -upon which the city editors might reflect with profit. This is the com ment that the author of the book makes upon the two pictures con trasted: “Compare the unfavorable artificial environment of a crowded city with the most favorable environ ment of the country.” “What is the secret of the world’s interest An this little case?” the speaker asked. “It is found in the feet that this trial uncovers an at tack which for a generation has been
Clipping to come
Telegraf · Baltimore, Md.
The report describes the upcoming trial of John Thomas Scopes in Dayton, Tennessee, for teaching evolution against state law, noting he will be defended for free by Clarence Darrow, John R. Neal, and former Secretary of State Bainbridge Colby. It also notes international reactions, including a German professor calling the case a 'sad sign of reaction' and a California bishop claiming the anti-evolution movement was driven by fear.
Telegraf · 12 June 1925 · page 1
Evoluční boj v Tennessee budí zájem
\\T> JIMMY HENSON. 14Y \LLE\E SUMNER NKA Service Writer Dayton, Tenn., July d. Three Day ton high school boys who will take the witness chair during the ap proaching trial of their science teach er, John T. Scopes, are afraid that they’ll “blubber” when they tell on teacher It’s a funny fix these three lad: find themselves in! They think more of Scopes than most any other boys in Dayton High, and yet they are the very accusers who made him an indict'd criminal, and may either send him to jail or make him pay a si>Ofi fine if li«* is found guilty of teaching evolution.
See moreSee less
“It’s a funny mess,” said serious and bespectacled Jimmy Benson. 17, a senior in Dayton High last year. “We’d be the last ones in the world to do a thing against ‘Prof’ Scopes, and yet they picked on us to testify against him before the grand jury and get him indicted. Wanted to Be Pinched "But he wanted us to do it h» wanted to get pinched!” said Jack Hudson, Hi, and a sophomore. “Well, you can bet your hootin’ nanny they wouldn’t get me to squeal on ‘Prof’ another time!" said How ard Morgan, 11, who, although blit a I-Teshic, has as decided views on the Scopes trial as his senior buddies. Last spring when Scopes consented to be arrested for teaching evolution he needed some expert witnesses from his classrooms. He wanted one from each class his biology class, his physics class, and his general science class. He thought of Jack and Jimmie and Howard. “Come on, buddies, be good scouts and hel|> put me in jail!" he pleaded. Rut Jack and Jimmy and lltoward would n’t!
Clipping to come
The Chapel Hill Weekly · Chapel Hill, N.C.
A newspaper columnist comments on reform organizations and then reprints a poem titled 'Thoughts on Evolution' by J.W. Butler, the Tennessee legislator who authored the state's anti-evolution law. The poem mocks evolutionary theory and defends the biblical creation account.
The Chapel Hill Weekly · 12 June 1925 · page 2
BY HALIFAX JOSES
THE CHAPEL HILL WEEKLY Tell me, now, was your grand dad an ape? If so, have you ever changed your shape? Tell me, did evolution ever fail ■ To rob a monkey of his tail? If a monkey became a man, Tell me now if you think you can I Why all monkeys did not be come men. If they are really man’s nearest kin. If the Bible story of creation Is set aside by investigation, And evolution takes its place, There’s no hope left for Adam’s race. If the body is not raised from out the grave, Then Jesus has no pow’er to save, And modern evolution is the dope Which robs the Christian of his hope.
See moreSee less
If Christ is not raised, your hope is vain, And you will never see yqur loved ones again; If modern evolution is the truth, You will never see the Land of Youth. By evolution all flesh is the same And our ancestors are beasts (Oh what a shame); Will you burn your Bibles with a resolution And adopt the high-brow idea of evolution ? The Bible story of Divine crea tion Is good enough for every nation; From the dust of the earth He made man and beast And every creature from the greatest to the least. The Bible story will ever stand, As the greatest story in every land. Though evolutionists may smart and rage, The Bible remains true, yea, every page. So, by the Bible we will abide, And in its truths always confide; Being content with the ‘Old Old Story,’ Os Divine creation and eternal glory.
A newspaper 'Little Hatchet' commentary notes that John T. Scopes, a Dayton, Tennessee biology teacher, is becoming famous for teaching evolution in defiance of state law. It also mentions Justice Arthur Benson, one of the justices who held Scopes for the grand jury, as likely to share in that notoriety.
The Butler County Press · 12 June 1925 · page 4
A Plea for Religious Tol^ation in Williamsburg. (By William Willis Boddie) Almost every newspaper one may read from now until the Scopes trial ii> Tennessee be determined will con
Clipping to come
The Butler County Press · Hamilton, Ohio
A newspaper opinion column discusses John T. Scopes, a Dayton, Tennessee biology teacher facing trial for teaching evolution in violation of state law. It quotes Justice Arthur Benson's dismissive views on evolution and notes that Bryan may join the prosecution while Darrow and Malone volunteer for the defense.
The Butler County Press · 12 June 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Yorkville Enquirer · Yorkville, S.C.
A roundup of brief news items reports that Clarence Darrow and Bainbridge Colby will serve as principal defense attorneys for John T. Scopes, who faces trial in Dayton, Tennessee for violating the state's anti-evolution law. The item is one of many unrelated short news briefs compiled together.
Yorkville Enquirer · 12 June 1925 · page 8
MERE MENTION
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Union Daily Times · Union, S.C.
John T. Scopes toured the American Museum of Natural History with defense attorneys, viewing evolution exhibits and meeting Professor Henry Fairfield Osborn, who offered to help find expert witnesses. Scopes was later honored at a dinner of 1,500 self-described liberals and radicals, while commentary noted the influx of activists and eccentrics descending on Dayton, Tennessee for the trial.
The Union Daily Times · 12 June 1925 · page 1
Brew T EETTEIITTRRRRRRRRIy»»;;mmmTTT//,/,,,, Howdy, folks! The menkey trial in Tennessee opens tomor row. Friends of the monk are hoping that he won't be con victed of being related to the human race, . . - Clarence Darrow is defending the monkey. He will put 10 alienists on the stand to prove that the monk iy suffering from paranoia, klepto mania and an inferiority complex, - - -
Clipping to come
The Union Daily Times · Union, S.C.
The report describes the influx of agnostics, atheists, communists, and reformers gathering in Dayton ahead of the Scopes trial, along with ACLU members disagreeing over trial strategy. It also notes a textbook co-author's surprise at his book's role in the case.
The Union Daily Times · 12 June 1925 · page 1
ANNOUNCEMENT Home Brew announces that it has engaged Herbert J. Chim panzee, of Wood land Park 1o cover the Tenne. see trial. .\ spe cial trapezr has heen erected in the Dayton court roomt, and he will seng daily com muniques as long as the peaillits’ held out. President Suzzallp. savs the uni versity of the future will be simply a library, Well, that'’s an improvement, any way. The university of the present is simply an athletic stadium. i W e .i - 5
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
Scopes's defense team, including Clarence Darrow and Dudley Field Malone, studied evolution exhibits at the American Museum of Natural History while Scopes traveled back to Dayton, Tennessee. The report notes controversy over 'radicals' and liberal supporters flocking to the case ahead of the trial.
Brownsville Herald · 12 June 1925 · page 2
SCOPES ON WAY TO TENNESSEE
Big Welcome For Bryan At Dayton William Jnnings Bryan was, giv en an enthusiastic welcome on his arrival at Dayton, Tenn., for the evolution trial.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
John T. Scopes, the Tennessee teacher indicted for violating the state's anti-evolution law, traveled to New York with Dr. John R. Neal of Knoxville. They met with attorneys from the American Civil Liberties Union, who agreed to assist in Scopes's defense.
The Milwaukee Leader · 12 June 1925 · page 1
Big Welcome For Bryan At Dayton William Jnnings Bryan was, giv en an enthusiastic welcome on his arrival at Dayton, Tenn., for the evolution trial.
John Thomas Scopes left New York for Dayton, Tennessee, after a farewell banquet, accompanied by defense attorney Dr. John R. Neal, ahead of his upcoming trial for teaching evolution. William Jennings Bryan, in Miami, declined to respond to critics like George Bernard Shaw, saying he would save his arguments for the trial, where he promised to 'make monkeys' of evolution's supporters.
The Milwaukee Leader · 12 June 1925 · page 13 · transcribed from the page image
WE WILL MAKE MONKEYS OF 'EM, BRYAN ASSERTS
BULLETIN. By The United Press.
See moreSee less
NEW YORK—Weary after six days of the center of attraction here, John Thomas Scopes, the country school master who soon must stand trial in Tennessee for teaching evolution, left Thursday for Dayton, Tenn.
Dr. John R. Neal, who, with Bainbridge Colby, Clarence Darrow, Dudley Field Malone and other prominent attorneys will defend him at the approaching trial, accompanied Scopes.
A banquet in Scopes' honor was held Wednesday night at the Civic club.
Referring to evolution case, Scopes said:
"If you are going to be a goat, you want to take thought as to whether you are going to be a big goat or a little one. I really an[d] truly think this is a fight for freedom of thought."
In his speech Clarence Darrow deplored the fact that so many people had tried to improve the world and only succeeded in making it worse.
MIAMI, Fla.—Determined to save his strength for the crucial test at Dayton, Tenn., July 10, William J. Bryan for the first time will not talk in answer to his critics in the prevailing evolution controversy. That is, until the trial. Then he promises to "make monkeys" of Darwin's supporters.
When shown George Bernard Shaw's interview calling him a "blockhead," Bryan "issued a statement," as is his custom. It read:
"Mr. Bryan declines to discuss anybody's criticism of him or anybody's opinion of evolution.
"The case will be tried in the Tennessee court and not in the newspapers."
Mr. Bryan said, however, he was glad to notice that the Tennessee case is "no longer treated as a joke by editors."
"Big Issues at Stake."
"The number and prominence of attorneys engaged by the defense," he said, "would indicate that important issues are at stake."
Prior to the opening of the trial, Mr. Bryan said, he will spend most of his time at his estate near here preparing the case upon which he expects to convict the Tennessee high school teacher, Scopes.
The announcement that Bainbridge Colby, who like Bryan served as secretary of state under Woodrow Wilson, would oppose him in the evolution trial brought no comment from the commoner.
French Lawyer Would Aid.
PARIS—Another great international lawyer Wednesday leaped into the controversy over the Scopes trial when Vincent de Moro-Giafferi declared the Tennessee evolution trial was "the greatest event in law since the trial of Jesus Christ." M. de Moro-Giafferi, whose defense of Henri Landru, the "French Bluebeard," brought him world-wide prominence, asserted he was communicating with Scopes' attorneys, offering his assistance.
Bryan says he will stay quiet until the Dayton trial, saving his strength to 'make monkeys' of evolution supporters, while declining to respond to Shaw's insult. A French lawyer, Vincent de Moro-Giafferi, compares the Scopes trial to the trial of Jesus Christ and offers to assist the defense.
The Milwaukee Leader · 12 June 1925 · page 13
French Lawyer Would Aid. PARIS —Another great interna tional lawyer Wednesday leaped Into the controversy over the Scopes trial when Vincent de Moro-Giafferi declared the Tennessee evolution trial was “the greatest event in law since the trial of Jesus Christ.” M. de Moro-Giafferi, whose defence of Henri Landru, the “French Blue beard,” brought him world-wide prominence, asserted he was com municating with Scopes’ attorneys, offering his assistance.
Scopes's defense attorneys Darrow, Colby, and Malone visited the Field Museum to study evidence on human and horse evolution, consulting with evolution expert Professor Henry Osborn. Meanwhile Scopes himself was traveling back to Dayton, Tennessee to face the trial for teaching evolution.
Paper unidentified · 12 June 1925 · page 2
APES STUDIED BY ATTORNEYS FOR J. SCOPES
1 The iTray of defense counsel was to y* arrive during the day, Clarence I)ar t row coming from Cincinnati late this aflernoi li and Dudley Field Malone and Arthur Garfield Jiayes from Chatta nooga. They were expected to bring with them several witnesses for the de fense. Attorney Genera I A. Thomas Stewart of the ISth judicial circuit arrived yes terday as did .Joint T. Ralston and Tin.mas Scopes, father of tlic defen dant.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The New York Evening Post is quoted criticizing the influx of activists, free-thinkers, and self-styled martyrs overshadowing the real scientific and legal issues of the Scopes trial. Civil liberties union members are also reported disagreeing over trial strategy, with some wanting an early loss to prompt Supreme Court review and others wanting to fight hard from the start.
Paper unidentified · 12 June 1925 · page 2
* iSrWr Jcnwreg* Bryan. W.C. Haggard. Dr. B. K. Loy, mayor of Casper, was elected deputy grand comman der. Other officers of the Grand Commandery elected at yesterday's Masons Convene Today
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
This opinion piece imagines what Thomas Huxley might say if he were alive to testify at the Scopes trial in Tennessee, quoting his writings on evolution and human development from lowly origins. It argues that scientific understanding of man's animal ancestry does not diminish reverence for human nobility, citing his capacity for language and accumulated knowledge.
Paper unidentified · 12 June 1925 · page 6
BEFORE COURT Prof. Scopes Goes on Trial i Today—Reindictment Re turned by Grand Jury. BRYAN GIVEN OVATION AS ENTERS COURTROOM State Will Resist Introduction of Scientific Testimony
Clipping to come
The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska
A brief news item reports that attorney John W. Davis has been asked to assist in defending J. T. Scopes, who was indicted in Dayton, Tennessee for teaching evolution. The note appears among a roundup of unrelated national and international briefs.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 13 June 1925 · page 1
TRIAL OF SCOPES STARTSDAYTON; TEST OF TENNESSEE LAW ON TEACHING EVOLUTION BE MADE BY COURTS DAYTON, Tenn.. July lu (.-?)—The ial of John Thomas Scopes, charged Y. ith violating the new Tennessee law ,y teaching the theories of evolution ; m a public stliool, began here this torning with his reindictment by a -pecial grand jury, after Judge Rauls* - :>n had read the law and the first hapter of Genesis before the court tt. ! 'William dinings Bryan, nni-evolu onist, who volunteered his services > prosecute the aged professor, re ived an ovation when he entered the uirt room.
See moreSee less
Clarence Darrow and ’ mdloy Field Malone, heading the mns 1 for the defense, greeted the; lief prosecutor cordially. Darrow was in his shiii sleeves, and apparent-, ]y suffered from the intense heat. The itorneys conferred together while the -.rand jury was out. Attorney General A. T. Stewart in : >rmed the defense that the State ;ould object to tlie introduction of cientific testimony regarding evolu-. ion. That the case was not to de ^-yrmine the truth of evolution nor of Jhe bible, but rather to try Scopes for violating a state law. Several boys, pupils of Scopes, tes-. lifted before the grand after they re tired that Hunter's Biology was the j text book Scopes used in his teaeli : lgs. _ It wag placed in evidence. Walter White, superintendent of the Rhea County schools and prosecuting witness was also called before the grand jury. The indictment was a1 mere formality to meet with the re-1 quirements of thirty days between i summoning a grand jury and the ini uictment. The previous indictment I was quashed when the second was re turned. Rev. William Cartwight open-1 -d the court with prayer and a squad or blue uniformed policemen from Chattanooga filed in and took the best positions to maintain order. Many Scientists Will Testify. Darrow told the court the defense •expected to call many scientists, who were busy men, and that he would like some indication when he would he ready to hear them. Stewart re marked that it would take but a short lime to select the jury. The court post poned its answer until the jury is ^sworn. Stewart told the court that the prosecution would vigorously re sist any evidence tending to reconcile evolution with the Bible. Stewart proposed to, take the rest of the day off to give visiting lawyers a chance to get acclimated, but Judge Jtaulston ordered an afternoon session for the selection of a jury. Sheriff Draws Names from Hat Jury selection begun by the Sheriff drawing the names from a hat. Both sides accepted W. F. Robinson, a far mer-teacher, who said he had formed an opinion as to the guilt or innocence of Scopes, but could disregard it in his deliberations. J. W. Bagley told Clarence Darrow he knew nothing about evolution and declared his ability to be perfectly fair. He ac . cepted Jim Riley, a farmer Baptist, •who admitted he could not read. Darrow rejected J. T. Massengale, am strictly with the Bible.” The Judge suppressed the tumult of ap plause at these words. W. G. Taylor, a farmer Methodist, said he had some opinions about the case but would de cide fairly. He was accepted.
Clipping to come
El Dorado Daily News · El Dorado, Ark.
The New York Times reports that John Scopes, en route to Dayton for his evolution trial, turned down offers totaling $150,000 from a movie corporation and syndicates. A friend who was with him said Scopes refused because he views the trial as a serious matter.
El Dorado Daily News · 13 June 1925 · page 1
EVOLUTION TEACHER GETS OFFERS WORTH $150,000
MADE BY COURTS DAYTON, Tenn.. July lu (.-?)—The ial of John Thomas Scopes, charged Y. ith violating the new Tennessee law ,y teaching the theories of evolution ; m a public stliool, began here this torning with his reindictment by a -pecial grand jury, after Judge Rauls* - :>n had read the law and the first hapter of Genesis before the court tt. ! 'William dinings Bryan, nni-evolu onist, who volunteered his services > prosecute the aged professor, re ived an ovation when he entered the uirt room. Clarence Darrow and ’ mdloy Field Malone, heading the mns 1 for the defense, greeted the; lief prosecutor cordially.
See moreSee less
Darrow was in his shiii sleeves, and apparent-, ]y suffered from the intense heat. The itorneys conferred together while the -.rand jury was out. Attorney General A. T. Stewart in : >rmed the defense that the State ;ould object to tlie introduction of cientific testimony regarding evolu-. ion. That the case was not to de ^-yrmine the truth of evolution nor of Jhe bible, but rather to try Scopes for violating a state law. Several boys, pupils of Scopes, tes-. lifted before the grand after they re tired that Hunter's Biology was the j text book Scopes used in his teaeli : lgs. _ It wag placed in evidence. Walter White, superintendent of the Rhea County schools and prosecuting witness was also called before the grand jury. The indictment was a1 mere formality to meet with the re-1 quirements of thirty days between i summoning a grand jury and the ini uictment. The previous indictment I was quashed when the second was re
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
John Scopes stopped in Washington to see the Constitution and Supreme Court chamber while traveling back to Dayton for his evolution trial. He reportedly refused over $150,000 in offers from a film company and syndicates, saying he views the trial as a serious matter.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 13 June 1925 · page 1
SCOPES PAYS VISIT TO CAPITAL
Many Scientists Will Testify. Darrow told the court the defense •expected to call many scientists, who were busy men, and that he would like some indication when he would he ready to hear them. Stewart re marked that it would take but a short lime to select the jury. The court post poned its answer until the jury is ^sworn. Stewart told the court that the prosecution would vigorously re sist any evidence tending to reconcile evolution with the Bible. Stewart proposed to, take the rest of the day off to give visiting lawyers a chance to get acclimated, but Judge Jtaulston ordered an afternoon session for the selection of a jury.
See moreSee less
Sheriff Draws Names from Hat Jury selection begun by the Sheriff drawing the names from a hat. Both sides accepted W. F. Robinson, a far mer-teacher, who said he had formed an opinion as to the guilt or innocence of Scopes, but could disregard it in his deliberations. J. W. Bagley told Clarence Darrow he knew nothing about evolution and declared his ability to be perfectly fair. He ac . cepted Jim Riley, a farmer Baptist, •who admitted he could not read. Darrow rejected J. T. Massengale, <4 a Baptist minister, who declared, “I am strictly with the Bible.” The Judge suppressed the tumult of ap plause at these words. W. G. Taylor, a farmer Methodist, said he had some opinions about the case but would de cide fairly. He was accepted.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
John T. Scopes and his attorney Dr. John H. Neal left New York for Dayton, Tennessee, where the evolution law trial will be held. While in New York, they met with American Civil Liberties Union officials sponsoring the defense and discussed plans for a possible appeal all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 13 June 1925 · page 1
Scopes And Counsel Leave For Dayton After Conferences In New York City
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
The editorial argues that the real issues of the Scopes evolution trial are being obscured by a stampede of self-promoting radicals, feminists, and free thinkers who have attached themselves to the case. It suggests the defense team is deliberately provoking Tennessee's hostility to lose dramatically and win on appeal.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 13 June 1925 · page 4
THE MENAGERIE AT DAYTON, TENN.
New York. They went to “the mansion” that had* been prepared for them, a big house on the hill hack of town, where plans were made to meet the prose cution strategy tomorrow. In contrast with the arrival of Wil liam Jennings Bryan, two days ago, the arrival of the evolutionist lawyers created little stir. There were no bands nor parades. Prayers were offered tonight in the courthouse yard for Divine guidance and Judge John T. Raulston, in a statement, gave utterance to his own deep desire for this same spiritual presence during the trial.
See moreSee less
In the view of many deeply religious people, God will speak at this trial in no uncertain voice. To others it is a scoffing matter. Grand Jury to Meet The lawyers see In it chiefly a con stitutional issue of profound impor tance. What the proceeding will be at the start, no one seems to know. “Probably meet and adjourn to have their pictures taken,” said one of the cynical ones in the defense legal staff. The grand jury meets tomorrow, and it ia reported that an effort may be made to strengthen Scopes’ indictment. In that event jury selection would be
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
This opinion piece criticizes the influx of radicals, free thinkers, and publicity seekers descending on Dayton, Tennessee, arguing they are overshadowing the actual legal case. It portrays Scopes as a sidelined figure in his own trial, with the proceedings becoming a sensationalized spectacle rather than a serious judicial hearing.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 13 June 1925 · page 4
THE MENAGERIE AT DAYTON, TENN.
New York. They went to “the mansion” that had* been prepared for them, a big house on the hill hack of town, where plans were made to meet the prose cution strategy tomorrow. In contrast with the arrival of Wil liam Jennings Bryan, two days ago, the arrival of the evolutionist lawyers created little stir. There were no bands nor parades. Prayers were offered tonight in the courthouse yard for Divine guidance and Judge John T. Raulston, in a statement, gave utterance to his own deep desire for this same spiritual presence during the trial.
See moreSee less
In the view of many deeply religious people, God will speak at this trial in no uncertain voice. To others it is a scoffing matter. Grand Jury to Meet The lawyers see In it chiefly a con stitutional issue of profound impor tance. What the proceeding will be at the start, no one seems to know. “Probably meet and adjourn to have their pictures taken,” said one of the cynical ones in the defense legal staff. The grand jury meets tomorrow, and it ia reported that an effort may be made to strengthen Scopes’ indictment. In that event jury selection would be
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A Birmingham church bulletin lists Sunday sermon topics, including one titled 'John Scopes, W. J. Bryan, Clarence Darrow et al., or The Tennessee Evolution Case' to be preached by Rev. J. R. Hobbs at First Baptist. The listing appears among dozens of other unrelated church service announcements and deacon names.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 13 June 1925 · page 14
the preachers who dislike publicity. Banked by photographers, studied by the keen eyes of 75 reporters, cross examined by one of the greatest cross examiners at the bar, Clarence Dar row, facing the efforts of Mr. Bryan to put them in spiritual opposition to the Bible, the witnesses face a situa tion of peculiar unpleasantness, except for the most hardy souls. This will be a shirt-sleeve trial. Everything goes In the courtroom but smoking. The search for the "eternal truth” will be conducted under the spotlights, with a drama that Belasco might have arranged.
See moreSee less
Assistance of Catholics in the Bryan cause was foreshadowed here today by the arrival of Patrick Henry Callahan, of Louisville, one of the outstanding lay figures In the churcff, head of the Knights of Columbus during the war, and Benedict Elder, of Louisville, sec retary of the Catholic Press association of the United States. Mr. Callahan was for three years chairman of the com mittee on religious prejudice, and has been a friend of Mr. Bryan for many yearn. They had a talk with Mr. Bryan, after which Mr. Callahan said: “Respect Due llryan*’ “There is a vast amount of sympathy for Mr. Bryan and the state of Ten nessee among the Catholics of America. A great many of us are highly indig nant at the ribald abuse which has been heaped upon your splendid state by the newspapers and non-religionists of certain sections. “It is a pleasure for me to say that there is no evidence of a desire of a large part of my coreligionists to criti cize the state of Tennessee for having enacted the law, the alleged violation of whidh young Scopes is to be tried. “I would look up<*i the education of the chifld as a matter in which the most scrupulous care should be taken, and the greatest degree of prudence ex ercised. The attacks upon Tennessee from the. outside for seeking to exer cise such, prudent care seem to me-'to be injudicious. “At alt events, the efforts of the great Commoner deserve the Christian faith of tJhe young of Tennessee, and he is entitlled to respect.” Doubts Violation Mr. Elder explained that he thought
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
John Thomas Scopes, accompanied by counsel Dr. John R. Neal and Dr. Jesse W. Sprouls, visited Washington D.C. and conferred with scientists including Dr. Vernon Kellogg before heading to Dayton for his July 10 trial. Scopes said he would ask the school board for his job back after the trial and denied receiving movie offers.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 13 June 1925 · page 14
SCOPES VISITS WASHINGTON
DEFENSE LAWYERS MEET IN (Continued from Paper One) said, “and it has no more to do with* the monkey story than it has with the uftfolding of a belief flower. It neither denies God nor does it teach that man came from monkeys.” A significant incident to many here in connection with the opening of court tomorrow is that the special term of court, under the provisions of the law, automatically brings back the special grand jury. ' Should the prosecution de cide that the pending indictment against Scopes is not strictly accord ing to the letter of the law as has been suggested, he could be reindicted with dispatch tomorrow.
See moreSee less
The defense was expected to move to quash the indictment and refusal ot this motion by Judge John T. Raulston, presiding, would bring the much-dis cussed case finally into court. Teachers Harmed, Says Ilryan In a statement issued today Mr. Bryan charged that the defendant Scopes, as center of the present legal controversy, is working more serious injury to school teachers “than to any other class." He predicted that “this harm" would be ii\creased to an infinite degree by the establishment of the bi tdogy instructor’s alleged views on the independence of the teacher. The fundamentalist leader advocated preserving “the present system" by which, he said, teachers are selected without regard to their views on dis puted subjects. As a rule teachers re spect the opinions of their employers, he believed. “Protestant teachers do not offend Catholic students." Mr. Bryan declared, “and Catholic teachers do not offend Protestant students and neither offend Jews. Republican teachers do not of fend democratic students and demo cratic teachers do not offend repub lican students.” Under the “present system,” he said the personal views of the teacher are left free and the control of what is to be taught is in the hands of those who employ the teachers* He insisted that these employers were “the tax payers and parents acting through legislatures and boards of education.” Mr. Bryan spoke briefly today be fore the members of tbe Rhea county board of education, being introduced by Walter White. superintendent of county schools. Mr. White, a republi can. introduced the Floridan as "the world’s greatest man and first citizen. * Emphasizing the value of education, Mr. Bryan declared in these remarks that religion should be placed yet higher in public esteem. It would be better, he said, for Ten nessee to give up school books than to abandon tbe Bible. He declared his belief in science but urged that it is necessary to know the science of how to live. Would Seek “Eternal Truth.** A devout note was sounded today in a statement issued by Judge Raulston on the eve of the beginning of the court battle. As presiding judge, Mr. Raulston announced that he ap proached his duties in the Scopes case "•with a deep consciousness that the is sues are profound.” "If man without inspiration attempts to delve into the mysteries of God, he finds himself overwhelmed, in per plexities,” the statement said. “Therefore, I am much interested that the unerring hand of Him who is the author of all truth and justice shall direct every official act of mine.” eternal truth.” his own recognizance. for July 10. Kendall. solved.” alive.” recently.
Clipping to come
Arizona State Miner · Wickenburg, Ariz.
A short filler item notes the Tennessee evolution litigation involving William Jennings Bryan for the state and Clarence Darrow and Dudley Field Malone for the defense. The tone is dismissive, calling it 'monkey business' amid other unrelated news items and advertisements.
Arizona State Miner · 13 June 1925 · page 8
DEFENSE LAWYERS MEET IN (Continued from Paper One) said, “and it has no more to do with* the monkey story than it has with the uftfolding of a belief flower. It neither denies God nor does it teach that man came from monkeys.” A significant incident to many here in connection with the opening of court tomorrow is that the special term of court, under the provisions of the law, automatically brings back the special grand jury. ' Should the prosecution de cide that the pending indictment against Scopes is not strictly accord ing to the letter of the law as has been suggested, he could be reindicted with dispatch tomorrow.
See moreSee less
The defense was expected to move to quash the indictment and refusal ot this motion by Judge John T. Raulston, presiding, would bring the much-dis cussed case finally into court. Teachers Harmed, Says Ilryan In a statement issued today Mr. Bryan charged that the defendant Scopes, as center of the present legal controversy, is working more serious injury to school teachers “than to any other class." He predicted that “this harm" would be ii\creased to an infinite degree by the establishment of the bi tdogy instructor’s alleged views on the independence of the teacher. The fundamentalist leader advocated preserving “the present system" by which, he said, teachers are selected without regard to their views on dis puted subjects. As a rule teachers re spect the opinions of their employers, he believed. “Protestant teachers do not offend Catholic students." Mr. Bryan declared, “and Catholic teachers do not offend Protestant students and neither offend Jews. Republican teachers do not of fend democratic students and demo cratic teachers do not offend repub lican students.” Under the “present system,” he said the personal views of the teacher are left free and the control of what is to be taught is in the hands of those who employ the teachers* He insisted that these employers were “the tax payers and parents acting through legislatures and boards of education.” Mr. Bryan spoke briefly today be fore the members of tbe Rhea county board of education, being introduced by Walter White. superintendent of county schools. Mr. White, a republi can. introduced the Floridan as "the world’s greatest man and first citizen. * Emphasizing the value of education, Mr. Bryan declared in these remarks that religion should be placed yet higher in public esteem. It would be better, he said, for Ten nessee to give up school books than to abandon tbe Bible. He declared his belief in science but urged that it is necessary to know the science of how to live. Would Seek “Eternal Truth.** A devout note was sounded today in a statement issued by Judge Raulston on the eve of the beginning of the court battle. As presiding judge, Mr. Raulston announced that he ap proached his duties in the Scopes case "•with a deep consciousness that the is sues are profound.” "If man without inspiration attempts to delve into the mysteries of God, he finds himself overwhelmed, in per plexities,” the statement said. “Therefore, I am much interested that the unerring hand of Him who is the author of all truth and justice shall direct every official act of mine.” eternal truth.” his own recognizance. for July 10. Kendall. solved.” alive.” recently.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
John T. Scopes, the Tennessee teacher on trial for teaching evolution, turned down money offers totaling $160,000, including $60,000 for a motion picture appearance, saying the trial was too serious a matter. He visited Washington D.C. on his way home, viewing the Constitution and the Supreme Court chamber, while preparations for the trial continued in Dayton and William Jennings Bryan spoke on science and religion in Miami.
New Britain Herald · 13 June 1925 · page 3
OFFER MONEY: Evolution Storm Center Declines Movie Contracts
a law ^of the state when Governor Austin Peay approved it March 21. Scopes was arrested on a charge of violating the law’ in his capacity of science teacher of the Rhea county high school. Specific instances of alleged violations were laid to certain biology classes W’here the text, it was charged placed the teacher outside the law. A preliminary hearing was held May 9, and Scopes was bound over to the grand Jury under bond of $1,000, the bail being waived and the school teacher permitted to go his way on his own recognizance. A special grand jury was summoned and an indictment returned. Following the action of the grand jury, Judge John T. Raulston ordered a special term of the Rhea county circuit court for July 10.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
The passage describes preparations underway in Dayton, Tennessee for the Scopes trial, including a telegraph company assigning 10 operators to handle the expected flood of press coverage. William Jennings Bryan, who will assist the prosecution, gave a speech to Miami high school graduates arguing that science without religion is dangerous, and criticized the textbook used by Scopes as contradicting the Bible.
New Britain Herald · 13 June 1925 · page 3
DOWN IN TENNESSEE Undoubtedly the feeling that moat Americans will have on reading the vunous utterances of William Jennings I'.ryan at the now famous evolution trial t Dayton, will he one of vast re lief thut such a mail never reached the \Y hite House. \Y hether or not the Scopes trial turns out to he a national summer joke or not remains to be seen, but Mr. Bryan, at least, should be thor oughly condemned for his frequent assertion that "t hristianity 1* on trial.” This is not true. A young and independent professor of science is on trial for deliberately breaking a law of the State of Tennessee.
See moreSee less
There are higher types of Christians than Mr. Bryan, praise be, whose taith enables them to separate the spir itual growth of the soul from the Darwinian theory of the de velopment of the human body. Mr. Bryan has never taken the trouble to consider this. Hail he done so he would have been deprived of another of his golden opportunities for displaying the "gift of gab” and getting himself into the limelight of th Associated Press. THE CURSE ON CHICAGO
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
Rev. Dr. Percy Stickney Grant, former rector who clashed with Bishop Manning, says the upcoming Tennessee evolution trial will prove a tremendous uplift to the whole country. He attributes Tennessee's anti-evolution law to educational setbacks caused by Southern poverty following the Civil War.
New Britain Herald · 13 June 1925 · page 10
lined weight is 250 pounds, laughed at heat. z i li I'.K lllo A: All.jlitp I n lfpn.l .Tnhn T. Scopes, thp yn'ing high school teacher S charged with trarhing evolution despite Teiinesop law forbidding 5 it. Dudley Field Malone. Arthur
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
John Thomas Scopes, en route home to Tennessee ahead of the Dayton evolution trial, said he chose Clarence Darrow based on his legal career, not his fame from the Loeb-Leopold case. Scopes cited Darrow's defense of 'Big Bill' Haywood in the 1907 Idaho trial, where he won against Senator Borah despite Harry Orchard's testimony implicating the miners' federation in bombings.
Evening Star · 13 June 1925 · page 2
SCOPES EXPLAINS HIS REASON FOR RETAINING LAWYER DARROW
lined weight is 250 pounds, laughed at heat. z i li I'.K lllo A: All.jlitp I n lfpn.l .Tnhn T. Scopes, thp yn'ing high school teacher S charged with trarhing evolution despite Teiinesop law forbidding 5 it. Dudley Field Malone. Arthur
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
John Thomas Scopes, the Tennessee teacher charged with teaching evolution, visited Washington with his attorney Judge John R. Neal on a sightseeing tour. They viewed notable sites including the original draft of the Constitution.
Evening Star · 13 June 1925 · page 2
SCOPES VISITS CAPITAL
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The report surveys newspaper reactions to a U.S. Supreme Court ruling striking down Oregon's law banning private and parochial schools, noting many see it as relevant to the pending Tennessee evolution trial. Editorials from Portland, Chicago, and Savannah papers debate whether the ruling implies limits on states' power to dictate what subjects students may or may not study.
Evening Star · 13 June 1925 · page 6
Oregon School Law Decision Seen Bearing on Scopes' Case
Seen Bearing on Scopes’ Case The whole question of State con trol of education is reviewed in dis cussion which has followed the lic schools as against private or pa rochial ones. But the right of the State to determine what shall be
Newspapers across the country comment on a Supreme Court decision striking down Oregon's law banning private schools, suggesting it may also doom Tennessee's anti-evolution law. A letter to the editor argues the upcoming Scopes trial should not become a staged debate between Darwinism and the Bible, but should focus narrowly on the legal question of whether the teacher violated state law.
Evening Star · 13 June 1925 · page 6
Sees Evolution Trial As Darwin vs. Bible
In the light of this decision “that American children may study what and where they please, we can await with interest the Supreme Court's decision on such evolution legislation as that of Tennessee, should it by any chance come before it,” is the Baltimore Sun’s view.
John T. Scopes traveled toward Tennessee, declining $150,000 in movie and publicity offers including $50,000 for a film appearance, saying the trial was too serious a matter. He stopped in Washington to view the Constitution and Supreme Court chamber, while Bryan continued publicly criticizing evolution teaching.
Evening Star · 13 June 1925 · page 12
SCOPES SHUNS MOVIE AND NEWS OFFERS AGGREGATING $150,000
Quits Defense. By the Associated Press. DAYTON’, Tenn.. July 10.—A new Indictment, based upon the evidence responsible for the old document, was returned against John Thomas Scopes hv a Rhea County grand jury here to day. The Indictment charged viola tion of the recently enacted Tennessee law prohibiting the teaching of evo lution theories in the public schools. The technicality involved was the question of elapsed time between the summoning of the special grand jury In special session and the meeting of the body. Thirty days should have separated the two. Reindictment to day cured this defect, it was said by attorneys.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Scopes toured Washington landmarks and refused lucrative money offers, including $50,000 for a film appearance, saying the trial was too serious. Meanwhile Bryan and others made public statements about evolution and religion as preparations for the Dayton trial proceeded.
Evening Star · 13 June 1925 · page 12
OFFERS AGGREGATING $150,000
First Indictment Quashed. On motion, of the attorney general, the former indictment against Scopes was quashed, having been superseded by the second official document in the case. . The indictment allged that Scopes “did unlawfully and wilfully” teach tn Tennessee schools certain theories that deny the story of the Divine cre ation of man as told in the Bible. It charged that the instructor taught that man was descended from a lower order of animals. This alleged teach ing was "against the peace and dig nity” of the State. Clarence Darrow, speaking for the defense, told the court his side had a number of scientists it expected to call to testify.
See moreSee less
The defense would like to get an Indication when It might be possible to call them as they were busy men. and it was hoped that they would he able to testify with a minimum of effort.
Clipping to come
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
Dr. Charles Wood, a leading Washington Presbyterian minister, comments on the Scopes case and the Tennessee law against teaching evolution, distinguishing between materialistic and theistic evolution. He argues that teaching evolution is only subversive to religion if it fails to acknowledge God as the ultimate cause of life's development.
The Washington Daily News · 13 June 1925 · page 4
SEES DANGER IN TEACHING EVOLUTION
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Dr. Frank Goodchild, editor of the fundamentalist Baptist Watchman Examiner, publicly backs William Jennings Bryan and the Tennessee evolution law ahead of the Scopes trial. He dismisses Scopes as a tool of faddists and argues evolution is unproven and harmful to teach in schools.
The Washington Times · 13 June 1925 · page 1
FUNDAMENTALIST EDITOR BACKS BRYAN
. of God. By the Associated Frees. VIENNA. July 10. —Theology and science can live side by side without conflict, and evolution Is the method of Divine creation of this world. Dr. Carl Veth said in giving to the Asso ciated Press his thoughts regarding the Scopes trial at Dayton. Tenn. , Dr. Veth is an eminent author, pro fessor of .theology at the University of Vienna, and president of the In t ternatlonal Institute of Religious Psy chology. The Scopes trial has aroused in tense interest here and is the sub ject of heated debates in Vienna sqjioiastic circles.
See moreSee less
Dr. Veth said that 20 years ago he began to read the works of Ernst Heinrich Haeckel, the celebrated Ger , man naturalist, who was long re garded as the foremost supporter of Darwinism in Germany. At the time, said Dr. Veth, “the junkers and the conservatives in Germany were tilled with dismay at the theory of evolu tion, as many Americans are today. “1, too, logt my bearings, but I re covered quickly and determined to take nothing on trust. After some years of scientific investigation I con cluded evolution is true and I en tered the field in which during all these years German theology and German science have both continued to labor undeterred for the greater glory of the Christian faith. “I feel for those in America whose < hearts are filled with doubts and who asked themselves ‘Shall we puzzle our youths with the two-fold claims of revealed religion and scientific reve lations?’ “But I love America as the great renewer of civilization and I ask her to anticipate the requirements of her children 30 years hence.”
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
John W. Butler, who authored Tennessee's anti-evolution law, said he cannot afford to attend the Scopes trial in Dayton. The report also notes prominent journalists like Arthur Brisbane have requested press accommodations for the upcoming trial.
The Washington Times · 13 June 1925 · page 1
. of God. By the Associated Frees. VIENNA. July 10. —Theology and science can live side by side without conflict, and evolution Is the method of Divine creation of this world. Dr. Carl Veth said in giving to the Asso ciated Press his thoughts regarding the Scopes trial at Dayton. Tenn. , Dr. Veth is an eminent author, pro fessor of .theology at the University of Vienna, and president of the In t ternatlonal Institute of Religious Psy chology. The Scopes trial has aroused in tense interest here and is the sub ject of heated debates in Vienna sqjioiastic circles.
See moreSee less
Dr. Veth said that 20 years ago he began to read the works of Ernst Heinrich Haeckel, the celebrated Ger , man naturalist, who was long re garded as the foremost supporter of Darwinism in Germany. At the time, said Dr. Veth, “the junkers and the conservatives in Germany were tilled with dismay at the theory of evolu tion, as many Americans are today. “1, too, logt my bearings, but I re covered quickly and determined to take nothing on trust. After some years of scientific investigation I con cluded evolution is true and I en tered the field in which during all these years German theology and German science have both continued to labor undeterred for the greater glory of the Christian faith. “I feel for those in America whose < hearts are filled with doubts and who asked themselves ‘Shall we puzzle our youths with the two-fold claims of revealed religion and scientific reve lations?’ “But I love America as the great renewer of civilization and I ask her to anticipate the requirements of her children 30 years hence.”
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
Clarence Darrow returned to Chicago to begin preparing the defense for the Tennessee evolution test case, planning to consult local biologists and clergymen. He expressed satisfaction with his legal associates and described Scopes as a modest student surprised by the attention.
South Bend News-Times · 13 June 1925 · page 4
DARROW RETURNS TO CHICAGO HOME
Their Side, Too. r BY ROBERT T. SMALL. ■DAYTON, Tenn., July 10. —They are at grips at last—the evolutionists and the anti-evolutionists —and poor old Darwin undoubtedly is turning over In his grave. As the famous battle starts it is perhaps well to take note of the principals to set out a sort of “who's who in Monkeyville,” as the natives are affectionately terming, their town. The line-up shows a | prepoonderance of legal talent on the side of the fundamentalists, numeri cally speaking, but the battle ranks of the evolutionists are close knit and they will give a good account of themselves against the embattled antis.
See moreSee less
Here, then, are the fighting forces: For evolution: John Thomas Scopes, high school teacher and prisoner at the bar, charged with violating the State's new statute forbidlng any one to teach anything which contradicts in an> way the story of the creation of_ man as set forth in the Bible. | Scopes is only 24 and now that he has suddenly discarded his horn-rim med spectacles, he looks Just like anj one of a dozen of the boys around Dayton. The "Professor'’ still is in something of a daze that he should be the center of such a world-curdling controversy.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
Two University of Berlin professors commented on the upcoming Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee, framing it as a matter of academic freedom rather than science. Prof. Franz Keibel expressed regret over the prosecution but noted such controversies between evolutionists and anti-evolutionists barely exist in Germany.
Judge John R. Neal of Rhea Coun ty, chief Tennessee counsel for Scopes; recently a candidate for the Democratic gubernatorial nomination and likely to run again. A brilliant attorney, a man of means, a winning personality, slight of atature, heavy sandy eyebrows and smooth-shaven whenever he happens to think of visiting a barber shop, which isn't often. The judge has almost a studied disregard for matters of but Is held In high esteem. Dudley Field Malone of New York.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
The piece mocks the anticipated grandstanding by prosecutor Bryan and defense attorneys Darrow and Malone in the upcoming Scopes evolution trial in Tennessee. It suggests their competing desire for the spotlight might inadvertently help the defense's case.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 13 June 1925 · page 6
Presumably distinguished orators ^ tike Bryan for the prosecution of B Scopes for teaching evolution ie y Tennessee and Clarence Darrow and Dudley Field Malone for the defense expect to add to their distinction by making speeches. So confident of this are they that there appears to be a vociferous reluctance to "play second fiddle". If they don't look out they will make out a case favor able to the monkey. The case should be, considered important. The ‘‘spouters’’ appear to seek to arro gate to themselves all of the import ance.
See moreSee less
It shouldn't be permitted. . One expert declares it is ridiculous I .to talk about gassing cities in war , fare, that it would be impossible. It J is possible, however, to cause the at mosphere in time of peace to be im \ pure and*unwholesome. It is assum
The piece anticipates the Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, framing it as a clash between science and religion with lawyers, orators, and educators converging on the small town. It speculates about a possible stadium courtroom and radio broadcast, while arguing science and religion are not truly incompatible.
The Watchman and Southron · 13 June 1925 · page 2
TRE BATTLE IN TENNESSEE Famous lawyers, orators and ed ucators will be marshalled at that trial of the high school science teacher at Dayton, Temu, for teach ing, , evolution. Science and relig ion. will Bght it but in the presence of an unprecedented audience, near and Car. That Is, what the scrap pers regard as science and relig ion will fight It out. The scope of the thing—and the defendant’s name is Scopes—grows rapidly. There may be a huge stadium for a court. The’ proceed
The report states that William Jennings Bryan, a longtime opponent of teaching evolution, has pledged his full influence and power to Tennessee's prosecution of Professor Scopes. Scopes, a high school teacher, is charged with teaching Darwinism in his classroom.
Richmond Planet · 13 June 1925 · page 3
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
Dudley Field Malone insists on an active role in defending John Scopes rather than a research-only position, and is accepted as active counsel. The ACLU issues a statement on scientific freedom, while the Georgia Federation of Labor passes a resolution opposing anti-evolution laws.
The Milwaukee Leader · 13 June 1925 · page 8
MALONE JOINS ACTIVE DEFENSE IN SCOPES CASE
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
This item compiles several short dispatches related to the upcoming Scopes trial, including a telegram opposing legislative control of science education, a Georgia labor resolution against anti-evolution laws, Dayton's plan to distribute 'monkey medals' to visitors, and the federal government's declared neutrality on the case. It also includes unrelated brief news items from various towns.
The Milwaukee Leader · 13 June 1925 · page 8
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Paper unidentified
William Jennings Bryan, a longtime opponent of teaching evolution, has pledged his full influence and power to Tennessee's prosecution of Professor Scopes. Scopes, a high school teacher, is charged with teaching Darwinism in his classes.
Paper unidentified · 13 June 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Paper unidentified
John Scopes is studying evolution exhibits, including skulls, at the American Museum of Natural History in New York while awaiting his trial in Dayton, Tennessee. The article notes Bryan has refused to visit the museum exhibit, and museum head Dr. Osborn declined to testify but joined the defense in an advisory role.
Paper unidentified · 13 June 1925 · page 3
PROFESSOR JOHN SCOPES STUDIES SKULLS BEFORE EVOLUTION TRIAL
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Paper unidentified
The report describes preparations before the Scopes trial, including Bryan's refusal to visit a museum exhibit on evolution and Dr. Henry Fairfield Osborn declining to testify as an expert witness but agreeing to advise the defense. It notes the defense's effort to recruit scientific experts from major universities, suggesting the trial is shaping up to be a major spectacle.
Paper unidentified · 13 June 1925 · page 3
It I-peril's! 8 8 £ Hr jj lor fl H H t® „ ,„ , Ji, Irtft n,t,■!> i ~i 11l .I - .,-.,...... * INTERNATIONAL NEWS REE* A general view of Main street, Dayton, Tenn., where evolution trial began today.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The passage describes pre-trial atmosphere in Dayton, noting townspeople initially worried about Clarence Darrow's agnosticism but now eager to see him perform as defense counsel. It also details courtroom logistics like the number of lawyers permitted and discusses Scopes' own religious views, which he describes as agnostic Christian-influenced belief.
Paper unidentified · 13 June 1925 · page 3
International News Service. COURTROOM, DAYTON, Tenn., July 10.—Leaping over its first obstacle in the “legal battle of the century,” the State of Ten nessee this afternoon reindicted JohA Thomas Scopes, twenty-four year-old high school professor, on charges of violating its anti evolution law. • The anticipated clash between religion nad science which focused the eyes of the world upon this mountain town was relegated to the background while the uninter esting technicalities of the law held sway. The new indictment was brought in by a specially summoned grand jury which went into session an hour. after the great evolution trial opened.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A syndicated columnist writing from New York predicts the upcoming Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee will be more of a show than a serious trial, noting the maximum fine is only $500 while the spectacle could draw large crowds. He speculates the trial may be held in a Chautauqua tent rather than a courtroom or baseball field, given Bryan and Darrow's familiarity with such venues.
Paper unidentified · 13 June 1925 · page 8
Scopes Evolution Trial Going to Be Chautauqua Show, Robert Small Says
Here Is Law Scopes Trial Is Putting To Test By International Newt Service. DAYTON, Tenn., July Here is Tennessee’s anti-evolu *x» 3ES 3SI’JKt - ga
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The report describes John Thomas Scopes visiting New York and insisting on final say over his legal defense team, including his preference for Clarence Darrow despite some opposition. It notes tension between Scopes and the ACLU, which some feel has appropriated the case's larger issues beyond the young teacher himself.
Paper unidentified · 13 June 1925 · page 8
CHANCE (Continued from First Page.) firebrand from New York, and Ar* thur Garfield Hayes, famed for hn defense of liberal ideals. Darrow and Hayes jsat in their shirt sleeves, Malone appearing un comfortable in his smart city attire. They sat directly opposite Bryan and his associated local prosecuting counsel. Bryan was in shirt sleeve.*, too, as the heat was unbearable in the courtroom. Once the commoner arose, walked across the courtroom and shook hands with Darrow. Bo;h smiled friendly greetings. With order finally restored, after photographers had laid down their picture barrage.
See moreSee less
Circuit Attorney A. T. Stewart asked for a new in dictment. While Stewart did not announce immediately that the old indictment was abandoned, his purpose was ap parent. Judge Raulston immediately palled prospective jurors from the court room. x When one juror objected lw cause, of the pressure of business, Stewart arose and said: “I don't think we will need the jury more than forty-five minutes.” This move of the prosecution, it was learned, was caused by the fact that the original indictment of Scopes was returned by a grand jury which had been summoned
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The report describes pre-trial maneuvering, noting a dispute over whether Scopes himself or the Civil Liberties Union truly controls the case. It lists the legal teams forming, with Clarence Darrow leading Scopes's defense and William Jennings Bryan heading the state's side, joined by Bainbridge Colby.
Paper unidentified · 13 June 1925 · page 8
fact that the original indictment of Scopes was returned by a grand jury which had been summoned without the required sixty days’ legal notice of their meetings. The prosecution feared this technicality might ultimately be used by the de fense to overturn conviction by an appeal to a higher court. The issues in the case are these: 1. Whether any law limiting pub lic education is a violation of the jealously guarded constitutional guarantees of freedom of speech and freedom of opinion. 2. Whether any State has the right to dictate what shall be taught jn State-aid schools. 3. Whether the courts will de cide that science really does con tradict the Biblical story ot the Creation of Man.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Defense attorneys in the Scopes evolution trial filed a motion to quash the indictment, arguing the Tennessee anti-evolution law violated state and federal constitutions. Jury selection was set to begin July 6, and officials hired extra police to manage the crowds expected in Dayton.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 14 June 1925 · page 1
DEFENSE SEEKS TO QUASH INDICTMENT IN EVOLUTION CASE
Taught Biology Text. And what Scopes taught were lessons from Hunter’s "Civic Biol ogy,” which was approved by the State Board of Education. One of its passages, and the one that was cited to the Grand Jury, which in dicted him, reads as follows: “The great English scientist, Charles Darwin, from this and other evidence, explained the theory of •volution. This is the belief that simple forms of life on the earth , slowly and gradually gave rise to s those more complex and that thus. ' ultimately, the moat complex form (man) came into existence.” A fine legal distinction can He' drawn by the defense as to whether this statement from Hunter's "Civic i Biology” actually denies the Di1 vine Creation of man.
See moreSee less
To find Scopes guilty, the State must prove that this passage, or some otner similar passage in the same text book, contradicts the Biblical story of Adam and Eve. The grand jury thought so. but the jury listened to only one side of the question. The courts may reach a different con-. elusion. On the other hand, if Scope* did I deny the Divine Creation ot man by teaching the text-book theory of biology, then two constitutional is sues will be drawn into the car.e. And this is the most likely 'out come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Judge Neal explains the defense's procedural motion to quash the indictment against Scopes, arguing the anti-evolution law is unconstitutional on multiple grounds under the Tennessee constitution. The motion also challenges the indictment as unconstitutionally vague, potentially delaying the trial's evidentiary phase.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 14 June 1925 · page 1
By ALLENE SUMNER DALTON, Tenn., July 10.—Busi-i ness isn’t as good as usual in the little general clothing store which 1 Jim Darwin has run for 35 years in Dayion, Tennessee! I There’s a reasonj fjome folks who heard about the Darwinian theory that started all the “monkey business’’ in Dayton, got the notion that Jim Darwin was the man who did it'! A couple of lank mountaineers, who had been coming down into the valley to buy socks of Jim every summer, stopped it this year! None of their money should go to a man who said they sprung from monkeys, no siree!
See moreSee less
It’s In the Blood And even the folks who know that Jim. Darwin and Charles Darwin are not one and the same, are a bit leary of Jim’s store—for “this evo lution business” is in the blood! Jim Darwin admits a bit hesi tantly that he’s an evolutionist! It’s a brave thing to say in fundamen talits Dayton. But blood is thick er than water and “a man must stand by his kin folk,” says Dar win. Strangely enough, Dayton, the scene of the celebrated evolution trial, is the very spot where the descendants of Charles Darwin, the greatest scienstist and proponent of evolution, came to settle in Amer ica. Jim Darwin’s gerat-grandfather was a brother of Charles Darwin. He Founded Town It was years and years ago that James figrandfather of Dayton’s merchant, came to Rhea
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
The defense filed a motion arguing the Tennessee anti-evolution law violates multiple constitutional amendments, while Judge Raulston announced jury selection would occur July 6 from a venire of 30 men. Dayton officials also began preparing security measures, including borrowed police from Chattanooga, to handle expected crowds during the trial.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 14 June 1925 · page 2
DEFENSE SEEKS TO QUASH INDICTMENT IN EVOLUTION CASE
By ALLENE SUMNER DALTON, Tenn., July 10.—Busi-i ness isn’t as good as usual in the little general clothing store which 1 Jim Darwin has run for 35 years in Dayion, Tennessee! I There’s a reasonj fjome folks who heard about the Darwinian theory that started all the “monkey business’’ in Dayton, got the notion that Jim Darwin was the man who did it'! A couple of lank mountaineers, who had been coming down into the valley to buy socks of Jim every summer, stopped it this year! None of their money should go to a man who said they sprung from monkeys, no siree!
See moreSee less
It’s In the Blood And even the folks who know that Jim. Darwin and Charles Darwin are not one and the same, are a bit leary of Jim’s store—for “this evo lution business” is in the blood! Jim Darwin admits a bit hesi tantly that he’s an evolutionist! It’s a brave thing to say in fundamen talits Dayton. But blood is thick er than water and “a man must stand by his kin folk,” says Dar win. Strangely enough, Dayton, the scene of the celebrated evolution trial, is the very spot where the descendants of Charles Darwin, the greatest scienstist and proponent of evolution, came to settle in Amer ica. Jim Darwin’s gerat-grandfather was a brother of Charles Darwin. He Founded Town It was years and years ago that James figrandfather of Dayton’s merchant, came to Rhea
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Dayton officials, including Commissioner Frazier, arrange for Chattanooga police, detectives, and a fire engine to help maintain order during the upcoming Scopes trial. The high school will serve as an emergency hospital, and the prosecutor seeks federal legislation against teaching evolution.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 14 June 1925 · page 2
~ COURT IS OPENED o d / By The Assoclated I'ress, - DAYON, July 10. — The case of John T. Scopes, charged violation of f‘tl};e Tennessee law against teaching ~ewdlution in the Public schools, wasTlaced in the hands of the Rhea coun-" “ty grand Jrry for the second time here ‘w today. * } . Wihen court convened for the trial Of .the twenty-four year old School '.'teacher, Attorney General A. T. StewBrt asked that the Grand jury be ; gi;mmbned. Judge Raulston intormedi ':t"l_xe grand jury men that some ques-l‘ Jion had arisen' as to the legality of | the indictment against Scopes and the ;case would be given the grand jur&]
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Dayton officials arrange for ten Chattanooga police officers and a fire department to help manage the upcoming Scopes trial, declining an offer of 100 state militia. The county school superintendent also urges a congressman to push federal legislation cutting funds to schools teaching evolution, while Charles Darwin's daughter-in-law mocks the proceedings.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 14 June 1925 · page 2
IN EVOLUTION CASE
. pDeCßglors growded fato the court I room. - 4 _lt marked the arrival of Bryan to begin his work in connection with the rrosecution of Scopes. ‘ " A last minute change in_counsel for the defense was indicated by the fail ure ‘of John -L. -Godsey, . Dayton - at- : ‘torney, to appear,with the other law yers in.court after his absence from the 'cvo“nte[ence,iin' the case, of defense | attorneys : last “night,” had " been re garded as significant. , . ; . A new indictment based -upon’ the - evidence respensible for, the old docu ment was returned agajtist' Scopes by ‘the grand jury.
See moreSee less
’Soon affer the second ifidictmenit Waß . returned; to: repalc? the' technically of the imperfect first {document, ' Darrow, defense - attorney stated to the ‘cdurt that he and-his _associates regarded scientific testi mony that the théory of evolution _does_not, cotradiet; he ‘divine story of creation as cagditent.’ : " *'Phis was met byMRe statement from ‘the state that the prosecution would contest the introduction of the extra neous evidence and would insist that Eucix scientific ‘evidence in this case fwould-be incompetent. Judge John Rai;lston indicated that ‘e favored the selection of a jury first hefore the matter was argued and ad ‘journed court with inStructions to the _ pherift to have a hundred extra jury '*men present at o'ne-thir\ty.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Defense counsel filed a motion in Dayton, Tennessee circuit court to quash the indictment against teacher John T. Scopes, arguing the Tennessee anti-evolution law violates multiple sections of the state constitution. Jury selection was set for July 6, with plans underway to manage expected crowds including use of the school as an emergency hospital.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 14 June 1925 · page 1
To Be Used As Emer gency Hospital (By Associated Press.) DAYTON, Tenn., June 13.— Judge J. L. Godsey, counsel for the defense, today entered a motion in circuit court here to quash the in dictment against Prof. Jno. T. Scopes, Rhea county high school teacher, charged with violation of the Tennessee anti-evolution law. This action is in line with the rule that all motions of this kind must be filed 20 days after indictment is returned. The text of the motion follows: ’ "State of Tennessee vs. Jb'hn T. Scopes. The defendant moves the court to quash the indictment in this case for
The defense's motion to quash the indictment argues the Tennessee anti-evolution statute is unconstitutionally vague and violates several US constitutional amendments. Meanwhile, Dayton officials prepare for expected crowds at the upcoming trial, arranging medical facilities, police coordination, and a jury venire of 30 men.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 14 June 1925 · page 1
To Summon Panel of 30. Jury to hear the 8copes case will be •elected at the meeting of' Rhea county court July 6, Judge Jno. T. Raulston having announced that a venire of about 30 men will be summoned from which to draw the Jury. Preparations to care for the crowds expected to attend the trial are rapidly going forward. The high school build ing where Scopes teaches will be used as an emergency hospital and a suffi cient corps of physicians and nurses will be on hand to take care of all cases.
See moreSee less
Reservations for newspapermen Of the committee and preparations will be made to accommodate all who come. Commissioner Will Frasier of Dayton today conferred with Commissioner Ed Herron of Chattanooga to assist in maintaining order and directing traffic during the trial of Scopes. One Chatta nooga fire department also is to be brought here. The state militia offered to send 1Q0 men here to preserve order, but the /ffer will not be accepted. Superintendent Walter White of the Rhea bounty schools and prosecutor in ^ the Scopes case, today directed a letter to Congressman J. Will Taylor at KnoxHUe asking him to Introduce In congress a bill refusing aid to schools teaching evolution. His letter says; "I wish to urge you to introduce a bill in the next congress that will-wlth bold financial aid from any college or university that teaches any theory of •volution that denies the Biblical origin of man. You will be serving your coun try well by taking this step.”
Lady Darwin, daughter-in-law of Charles Darwin, commented from New York before sailing to England that men are making monkeys of themselves, referring to the Scopes evolution trial in Tennessee. Her remark was a witty aside rather than a substantive legal report on the trial itself.
Evening Star · 14 June 1925 · page 2
Men Are Making Monkeys of Selves, Lady Darwin Says
_ _ALL DOWN THE AGES We do not know what is to be the outcome of the Scopes trial which is scheduled to start today in the ’llttlc ‘Tennessee town of Dayton, but it isn’t going to end the search for the iruth—nor is it going to nail down the disposition of men to look further into the realms of the unknown. It most likely will not dispose of any of the age old ignorance that prevails in all the persecution which is aimed at those who engage in research. How nature and humankind came to the present wonderful stages of being will not cease to be a charm for the scientists, nor will the unlet tered cease to condemn and ridicule the search for the truth—but what a great day for little Dayton—what a great day!
See moreSee less
” ‘ And coulg Charles Darwin, who was seventy-five years ago giving the world the results of his findings in the greatest life study of organic evo lution that has ever hecome a gift to the scientific world in any form— could that man in his search” for the “reason why” in the world wake up this morning and look in upon the stilted, high-collared, but low-browed, hairy-bodied human set-to that is ‘warming into the old, old fires of per-§
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Judge J. L. Godsey, representing John T. Scopes, filed a motion in Dayton, Tennessee circuit court seeking to quash the indictment against him for teaching evolution, arguing the anti-evolution law is unconstitutionally vague and violates both state and federal constitutional protections. The report also notes that jury selection will occur on July 6, with about 30 men to be summoned as potential jurors.
Evening Star · 14 June 1925 · page 2
SCOPES' ATTORNEY ASKS DISMISSAL
These views were expressed: THE REV. MATTHEW F. SMITH, pastor of the First Presby terian Church: “The Scopes trial will in no way affect the truth or falsity of the evolutionary hypothesis Neither will the decision in the case mean the end of either Christianity
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The defense's motion to dismiss argues the Tennessee anti-evolution law is unconstitutionally vague and violates multiple constitutional amendments. Meanwhile, Dayton officials arrange jury selection, extra police, and facilities to handle the expected crowds for the upcoming Scopes trial.
Evening Star · 14 June 1925 · page 2
ASKS DISMISSAL
highest.” SHE REV. GEORGE S. HEN NINGER, E. Tenth St. M. E. Church: '‘Personally, my position is that of the Bible statement: ‘And God said, “Let us make man in our own image.” * I consider the Dayton trial will prove nothing, and is most un fortunate. I always have had the greatest regard for William Jen nings Bryan, but I believe he is building up a straw man to be knocked down. He has raised an issue that was dead.” • •
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The writer argues that the Scopes evolution case in Dayton, Tennessee is provoking more serious nationwide discussion than any controversy in decades, more so than the 1896 gold-silver debate or America's entry into World War I. The piece notes that unlike those earlier issues, ordinary people seem genuinely engaged in thinking through the evolution question itself.
Evening Star · 14 June 1925 · page 46
BY ROBERT T. SMALL
THE REV. C C. BONNELL, Gar field Ave. M. E. Church: “For more than thirty years I have been a quiescent evolutionist within certain limits. At the time I first gave careful thought to this most dis cussed. but often misunderstood, theory of the perfection of all forms of life, I was able to accept many of its facts without any violence to scriptural accounts. “Man is but an animal; but the highest type, however. I am not greatly concerned whether the Al mighty made man, soul and all, in a period of thirty minutes in our present time, or evolved him from a lower type of animal life through the ages and at a certain time, called creation, endowed him with a JMtl and called this completed
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
This news digest reports that John T. Scopes will be tried on July 10 in Dayton, Tennessee, for violating the state law against teaching evolution, with Clarence Darrow and Bainbridge Colby serving as his defense counsel. The item notes public anticipation of the trial's outcome and references commentary from Bernard Shaw and Henry Fairfield Osborn suggesting Bryan, not Scopes, is really on trial.
Evening Star · 14 June 1925 · page 47
Story Week Has Told: Comprehensive Survey of Latest Events in United States and Abroad
‘The Scopes evolution trial at Dayton, Tenn., is an attempt of a group of people to destroy progress,” today declared the Rev. Clarence A. Mitchell, Cincinnati, Ohio, pastor, who is a delegate to the International B. Y. P. U. con vention here. “Its aim is to cripple the methods of investigation and the result is stagnation. If we stop the unfold ing of truth, creative thinking will ceasee, and deterioratiion will set in,” he said. "The public school is a place for seeking out new truths. Pursuing of scientific methods to find new laws of life adds to our knowledge of life.
See moreSee less
Knowledge is a great asset if used to develop the Christian life. “Therefore, new truths enlarge life and give new r hope that the future has much for us. Our Mas ter put us here to discover truth. Truth will help the church to get its bearing.” he said. The Rev. Mark F. Sanborn of LieI
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
Scopes' defense team filed a motion to quash the indictment against him for teaching evolution in violation of Tennessee law. Judge Raulston, who will preside at the upcoming trial, is expected to overrule the motion.
South Bend News-Times · 14 June 1925 · page 1
SCOPES DEFENSE FORCE WANT CHARGE QUASH
—First Arrival Bu United Press DAYTON, Tenn., July 10.— V. Tuttle, Osceola, Mo., farm er, was the first arrival at the courthouse here today to hear the Scopes trial. He arrived at 6:45 a. m. Tuttle started from his home “hoofing it,” but got rides in automobiles with such success that he was only half a day behind the train.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
John T. Scopes, the young teacher facing trial for teaching evolution, traveled to Dayton, Tennessee after meeting with lawyers and scientists in New York, Baltimore, and Washington. He denied being an agnostic, saying he was raised Presbyterian and held deep religious feelings despite belonging to no church.
South Bend News-Times · 14 June 1925 · page 18
Bv International Nows Service: WASHINGTON, June 13.—John T. Scopes, young high school teacher who goes on trial in less than a month for teaching evolution to his pupils in violation of the Tennessee law, was enroute Saturday to Dayton, Tenn., scene of his troubles, after conferences in New York, Baltimore and Washington with lawyers and scientists who will assist in his de tense. It was Scope's first visit to the nar tional capital and he combined with a business, a sight-seeing trip. Scopes took occasion while here to deny that he is an “agnostic,” de claring that he was reared as a Presbyterian and that he now had a .‘‘deep religious feeling," although llonging to no church.
See moreSee less
He said that his support of the right to teach scientific theories in the public schools was not to be construed as an attack of Christianity or on any religion;
Two University of Berlin scientists, Professor Franz Keibel and Professor O. L. Übersch, discuss the upcoming Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, framing it as an issue of free speech rather than scientific validity. They express disbelief that a teacher could be prosecuted for teaching evolution, noting such controversy barely exists in Germany.
The Daily Worker · 14 June 1925 · page 1
SCIENTISTS IN BERLIN LAUGH AT SCOPES CASE
Discern Two Points. , Out of the confusion of issues two major contentions can he discerned as the trial begins: . * 1. Bryan regards this trial as only tha first step to drive evolution out of the nation’s publicly supported schools. He contemplates a prohi bition amendment for evolution. The people, he declares, have the final control over their schools. If the supreme court decides his way, the task will be simpler and state campaigns for anti-evolution laws will begin everywhere. If the court goes against, then It Is to be an appeal to the people, a great national political campaign on evolu tion and the Bible, the like of which no nation has ever witnessed.
See moreSee less
In this etruggle Bryan will be—at least, he expects to be—the chosen leader. The issue, then, as he sees It, is evo lution versus Christianity to the death. 2. Darrow and the defense de clare the issue is not between evo lution and Christianity. It is, they say, a fight over the constitutional ity of the Tennessee law. They in sist it restricts the right Jo life, lib erty and property without due pro cess of law\ They charge Bryan With befogging the lsssue, appealing to religious prejudice and maneuv ering to make, a black, and white case out of something different.
Clipping to come
The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.
German professors Keibel and Übersch comment that prosecuting evolution teaching is incomprehensible, noting Darwin's theories are now surpassed by newer science but shouldn't be suppressed. Separately, the Georgia Federation of Labor passed a resolution opposing any law banning evolution instruction in public schools.
The Daily Worker · 14 June 1925 · page 1
AT SCOPES CASE
Will Be Struggle. The trial will be a struggle be tween these two views and all of the maneuvering and side excursions will come back in the end to them. All of the testimony from ministers, sci entists and learned men will be di rected to some phase of these issues. They are personified in Bryan and Clarence Darrow, one the veteran lay preacher, the leader of the fun damentalists, the teacher of the great Bible class at Miami, the author of many books on the Bible, a Presbyterian elder of the old school, and the other, the reflective doubter, who has studied everything, pondered the perplexing questions of life and eternity, and who, as he confessed here a few days ago, has found1 no answer.
See moreSee less
Both arc amazing debaters, adept equally with the bludgeon or the rapier. Once Darrow campaigned f*rr Bryan, but now all they have in common are galluses, and even here Bryan wears his concealed, while Darrow flaunts his outside his shirt. Curiously, each has been digging in to the other’s past and strange things have been found. Bryan, for instance, has discovered that when Darrow was defending Bill Haywood in Idaho years ago he said in his plea to the Jury that man was a God-created being, whose soul no state should destroy.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
John T. Scopes discusses his upcoming trial over teaching evolution in Tennessee, saying he expects to lose before a local jury but hopes for a better outcome in a higher court. He explains his views on biology and evolution and mentions fears of future anti-science legislation, including a tract claiming the earth is flat.
Paper unidentified · 14 June 1925 · page 14
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
John Scopes explains how the case began during a discussion at Robinson's drugstore in Dayton, where Dr. Rappleyea suggested testing the anti-evolution law in court. Scopes describes the legal process, local excitement over the case, and his fears about future anti-science legislation in Tennessee.
Paper unidentified · 14 June 1925 · page 14
WILLIAM F. DUNNE f MORITZ J. LOEB Business Manager cago, 111., under the act of March 3, 1°79place as that opeuing at Dayton, Tennessee. of a whole section of the United States. v •
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
John Scopes describes how Dr. Rappleyea proposed taking the evolution law to court and how the case proceeded through magistrate's court to the grand jury. He also notes the town's excitement over publicity and worries that teachers remain vulnerable to lawsuits over teaching evolution.
Paper unidentified · 14 June 1925 · page 14
place as that opeuing at Dayton, Tennessee. That John Scopes, a teacher in a public school, can be brought to trial for teaching evolution as a law of nature, under a law enacted by the Tennessee legislature, is evidence of the retarded development of a whole section of the United States. v • The south is not yet industrialized. It is dominated intelectnally by feudal conceptions which are not found in the great industrial centers where the masses are either irreligious or lukewarm towards orthodox religion. , It is noticeable that the great metropolitan dailies are on tht side of evolution.
See moreSee less
The Scopes case has given them a splendid chance to demonstrate a devotion to scientific truth—truth divorced from the class conflict. It was rising capitalism that brought about the Reformation— the restrictions placed upon independent inquiry by feudal religion made commercial progress difficult and the merchant class broke the power of the Roman church. Insofar as orthodox religion has been of use to capitalism it has been encouraged, but the ethics of Christianity have never been al lowed to interfere with business—the bourgeoisie have two codes as Lafargue explained long ago: One for business and one for their private lives. Retween the two a constant struggle takes place with the result that the best Christian businessmen are the biggest hypocrites. But to get back to Dayton. ' There is much to interest the working class in what is taking place in that little mountain town where feudal reaction is in the saddle. The defenders of Scopes and his prosecutors are of the middle class. It is therefore evident that within that class is a deep division. Darrow is typical of the middle class liberal professional in tellectual —individualistic, a believer in personal liberty, educated and cultured. Bryan represents the agrarian element in the middle class —he is a leader of the well-to-do farmers of the middle west and of the south whose economic interests are opposed to those of big capital ism—the element that at different times has crusaded as Greenback ers. Populists and Free Silverites, rallying always around some chimraerical scheme of currency reform in which was expressed their antagonism to the increasing control of industry and finance by the big capitalists.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Judge Henry Neil of Illinois has asked Dayton authorities to let him appear as a friend of the court in the Tennessee evolution trial. He has offered twelve copies of a religious work by Canon Farrar to be presented to the jurors.
Paper unidentified · 14 June 1925 · page 3
and cultured. Bryan represents the agrarian element in the middle class —he is a leader of the well-to-do farmers of the middle west and of the south whose economic interests are opposed to those of big capital ism—the element that at different times has crusaded as Greenback ers. Populists and Free Silverites, rallying always around some chimraerical scheme of currency reform in which was expressed their antagonism to the increasing control of industry and finance by the big capitalists. The city’ and the town —these are the two forces in opposition to one another in Dayton and it is noticeable that Bryan is calling the attention of the ruralites to the ridicule heaped upon them in the metropolitan press as part of his campaign in defense of the dogma of a creator, a special creation and the first chapter of Genesis.
See moreSee less
In Great Britain this struggle was fought out during the 80’s and 90’s. The complete victory of British capitalism over feudalism symbolized by the huge expansion of industry and the rise of in dustrial capitalism with the proletarianization of the overwhelming majority of the British masses, was accompanied by the spread of rationalism, the printing and distributing of millions of pamphlets on the Darwinian theory; pamphlets by Lyell, Huxley,- McCabe, Allen; the works of Leekie and Haeckel, Lubbock and Romanes. But it was not until the dominant capitalist class had found in the Darwinian theory of the “survival of the fittest” a justification for their oppression of the working class that opposition to the theory of evolution became negligible in England. The jungle law of “tooth and claw” seemed to them to be eminently fitted for their period. Nature itself had placed the seal of approval upon British capital ism and all its works, they claimed, and this distorted Darwinism became the petted darling of the lords of coal and steel. It may be well to say here that capitalism seldom if ever inter feres with the search for abstract truth. Scientific researches in physics, chemistry, biology, anthropology, astronomy, geology and other sciences are encouraged. It is the sociological sciences where the class character of society is shown by every truthful investigator that are frowned upon by the ruling class. Academic freedom is curtailed only when the results of scientific research tend to expose the hypocricy and cruelty of the ruling class and weaken it or strengthen the working class. Modern science is the handmaiden of capitalist production and this valuable servant it is not going to destroy.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
William Jennings Bryan, speaking to a Miami high school graduating class, argued that science without religion is dangerous and claimed the textbook used by Scopes contradicts the Bible. The report also notes Scopes and his attorney John Randolph Neal touring Washington D.C. ahead of the July 10 trial.
The Milwaukee Leader · 14 June 1925 · page 12
Scopes for violating one of the sta tutes of the state in teaching that man has descended from a lower form of life. The book used by him contradicts the Bible and sends the children home believing that the Bible is a lie.”
John T. Scopes, in Washington before heading to Dayton, denied that his textbook claimed man descended from monkeys. He explained that embryology shows humans share lower animal ancestry, citing vestigial organs like the appendix.
In Dayton, Tennessee, defense counsel John Godsey filed a motion to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, who was charged with teaching evolution in violation of state law. The motion was expected to be overruled by Judge John Raulston, with Scopes' trial set to begin July 1.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 14 June 1925 · page 1
MAIN NEWS SECTION I IVouZd Quash Scopes Case DAYTON, Tenn., June 13.—(Unit ed Press)—A motion to quash the in dlctmcnt against John T. Scopes*. Dayton school teacher, who violated the state law by leaching evolution, was filed with the clerk of the Rhea county court today by Judge John Godsey one of the counsel of the defense. The motion will come before Judge John Roulrfon, who is expected to overrule it. WASHINGTON. June 13.—Thom as Scopes, the country school teach -1 cr and storm’center of the evolution controversy, has left for his home 1 town of Dayton, Tennessee.
See moreSee less
Qn July I 1 he will go on trial for famlllarlz ■ Ing his biology class with Darwin ism. Before leaving. Scopes said he hoped to resume teaching In the Dayton school next fall but didn’t expect to get the chance. He was due to arrive In Ashville tonight. Governor Ross Ousts Loomis CHEYENNE, TVyo.. June T“ Governor Nellie Tayloe Ross Satur day announced she had concluded to remove from office Sheriff William i H. Loomis of Park county and had sent a letter of removal to the coun ty commissioners and to Loomis to day. • Tho sheriff was given a hearing before the governor at Cody In April, since which time the governor, hav ing had the matter under advise mentLoomis was charged with hav- ! ing willfully failed, neglected and refused to perform duties Imposed by the law and had been guilty of 1 drunkenness and gross violation of prohibition laws. An appeal to th* courts will probably follow. Aviator Drops 300 Feet Into Sea and Lives , | NEW YORK, June 13.—Dropping ; . 300 feet into the sea after the mu tor of his seaplane had "gone dead ' William Byrne, New York police lieutenant and student aviator, ex tricated himself from the sinking wreckage and kept afloat. The accident occurred off South Beach. Byrne strapped in the cock pit with a safety belt, escaped with out a scratch. He was picked up a few’ minutes later by a passing yacht. HALIFAX N. S.. June 13 —Criss cross trenches and barb wire en tanglements and patrols by soldier* and police, the Cape Breton Colliery district was darkened by the shadow of real war tonight after three days of blood shed and rioting among the 12.000 striking miners. 11 ’‘Don’t worry,” he added. "1 II hr I ..’right." I OnV’ 'hree worker- - > • m
Governor Austin Peay of Tennessee called evolution 'bosh' and predicted the upcoming Scopes trial in Dayton would last no more than thirty minutes. He said evolutionists could do no harm as long as they stuck to the current state textbook.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 15 June 1925 · page 1
EVOLUTION IS JUST BOSH
Taught Biology T^xt. * And what Scopes taught were les sons from Hunter’s "Civic Biology." which was approved by the State Board of Education. and the one that was cited sages. to the grand jury. One of its pas which indicted
Clipping to come
The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska
The piece criticizes William Jennings Bryan's framing of the Scopes case as being about taxpayer control over schools rather than evolution itself. It argues Bryan's position would let those who pay dictate thought and speech, calling this anti-democratic and reactionary.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 15 June 1925 · page 4
THE HUY AN DOCTRINE. Mr. Bryan say;, the ease against Professor Scopes, accused of leaching evolution contrary to the statutes of Tennessee does not involve the theory of evolu tion at ail lint the simple proposition of whether or not ttie people who pay for the support of the schools are to control what is taught in ttyem or whether the scientists are to control. t)f course, Mr. Bryan has missed the meat in the nut (he always does that) but let's accept his conclusion that we of thought and speech.
See moreSee less
Mi. Brayn, then, is not the champion of free thought and free speech. lie stands the confessed advocate of the doctrine that lie who pays should control the thought and speech of the public. Mr. Bryan's position carried to its logical ends would silence the poor man who has nothing with which to pay. It would give the employer the power to decide what his employee should think and say. It would put an immediate end to democracy and re-enthrone feudalism. The Lords would do the think ing and the talking for the vassals. Mr. Bryan Btamps himself, us thinking people have judged hint for a long day, as an undiluted reactionary——as'a Bourbon who never learns and never forgets,
A report describes a proposed resolution at the Tennessee State Bar Association meeting urging the state's attorney general not to prosecute the Scopes evolution case if it reaches the state supreme court, on grounds the case was collusive and moot. It also notes expected legal challenges to the indictment's validity based on how the grand jury was convened by Judge Raulston.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 June 1925 · page 1
WILL SEEK TO END
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Legal circles discuss whether Attorney General Stewart will move to quash the Scopes indictment, arguing Judge Raulston lacked authority to call the special grand jury session. If the motion succeeds, a new indictment would be sought immediately.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 June 1925 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A Baptist pastor in Birmingham preached a sermon lamenting that the evolution controversy in Dayton, Tennessee was overshadowing the teachings of Christ. He outlined the key questions at stake, including state rights and academic freedom, as Bryan and Darrow prepared to clash at the trial.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 June 1925 · page 3
Cause Of Christ Forsaken As Debaters Meet, Is Claim
. somehow he manages to produce a creditable program. On this occasion M. C. S. Noble was, as usual, a splendid master of cere monies. Skits and sketches were put on by groups represent ing the N. C. C. Meredith and Wake Forest jointly, * and the University, and by the Play makers and the music depart ment. The University group burlesqued the Scopes trial in Tennessee. Particularly pleas ing were Theodore Fitch’s songs. * * * When Miss Carrie Moses of Raleigh was in town Sunday she told me an interesting bit of news about my old friend, Jim Cheshire; namely, that his house was recently visited by a ghost.
See moreSee less
In the Army Jim was an expert grenade-thrower. If he brought home any of his gren ades as souvenirs he might try one on the ghost.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Dr. James E. Dillard discusses the Scopes trial controversy as fundamentally a question of interpreting the Bible versus interpreting Nature, noting both have historically contained faulty interpretations. He criticizes both Bryan and Darrow as extremists, stating Bryan fails to see God in nature's laws while Darrow doubts God's role in nature, and declares himself neither evolutionist nor anti-evolutionist.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 June 1925 · page 3
DR. JAMES E. DILLARD
NEW INDICTMENT Dayton, Tenn., July 10.—(4>) —A new indictmeut based on the evidence responsible for the old document was returned against John T. Scopes by Ray county grand jury here today. The indictment charged violation of the recently enacted Tennessee law prohibiting teaching of evolution theories in public schools. The tech nicality involved was the lapse of time in the summoning of the grand jury in special session and the meet ing of that body. Thirty days should have separated the two. Today’s in dictment cured this defect. On the motion of the attorney general, the former indictment against Scopes was quashed, having been superseded by the second official document in the case.
See moreSee less
Boys Testify Several school boys, former stu dents of Scopes, were called before the grand jury to testify. They were followed by the presentation as evi dence of Hunter’s biology, the text book used by the defendant, and the testimony of Walter White, superin tendent of the Ray county schools and prosecutor of the case. As Judge Raulston was convening court, a blind musician stationed his organ on the courthouse lawn and began playing old-fashioned hymns. A crowd assem bled around him and began singing tunes. As the music continued others were attracted to the scene and while the grand jury was being impaneled in the court, the faint sound of old fashioned gospel hymns drifted through the court room windows and during the intermission the crowd poured out on the lawn and discussed developments.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A resolution is said to be planned at the Tennessee Bar Association meeting urging the attorney general not to prosecute the Scopes appeal if it reaches the state supreme court, on grounds the case was collusive. Separately, legal circles discuss a possible motion to quash the indictment due to questions about Judge Raulston's authority to call the special grand jury session.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 June 1925 · page 2
TENNESSEE BAR OPPOSES APPEAL IN SCOPES CASE
New Yorl;, July If). (A 3 > The ago olil effort to define truth will he revived when Professor John T. Scopes, Tennessee evolutionist, has his day in court. His indictment for teaching the Darwinian theory in public schools contrary to the statute has preced ents which reach hack for centuries. In America they date virtually from Plymouth Hock; in the world at large, from the dawn of tlu* Chris tian era. The now nationally known “Scopes ease” is recognizably askin to prevail ing differences between Modernists and Fundamentalists which have in creased with the rise of l>r. Harry Emerson Fosdick.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
The report describes how John T. Scopes turned down large sums from movie producers wanting rights to his trial, including one offer reportedly worth $50,000. It notes that New Yorkers found his refusal puzzling, since he said the trial was meant to be serious, not a money-making venture.
New Yorl;, July If). (A 3 > The ago olil effort to define truth will he revived when Professor John T. Scopes, Tennessee evolutionist, has his day in court. His indictment for teaching the Darwinian theory in public schools contrary to the statute has preced ents which reach hack for centuries. In America they date virtually from Plymouth Hock; in the world at large, from the dawn of tlu* Chris tian era. The now nationally known “Scopes ease” is recognizably askin to prevail ing differences between Modernists and Fundamentalists which have in creased with the rise of l>r. Harry Emerson Fosdick.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
Baccalaureate sermons at Princeton, Yale, Brown and Syracuse addressed evolution, with speakers referencing the Scopes trial. Views ranged from Potter's criticism of Tennessee's ignorance to Hibben's defense of evolution's compatibility with religion and opposition to legislative restrictions on teaching.
New Britain Herald · 15 June 1925 · page 13
EVOLUTION TALKS MADE BY MANY
THE LIMELIGHT Scopes Trial Draws Famous Mon To Tonnesso—\V. ,1. llr.yan On the Job A desire that those concerned with the Scopes evolution case divest themselves of all ambition to estab lish any particular theory for per sonal gratification and that we all constantly inquire for the eternal truth, was expressed by Judge John T. Raulston upon the eve of the trial.: The statement in full follows: "I approach my duties in the trial in the Scopes case with a deep con-! seiousness that the issues are pro-, found. "I am concerned that those con-!
See moreSee less
nected with this investigation shall divest themselves of all ambition to! establish any particular theory for; personal gratification, and that we all constantly inquire for the eternal truth. 11 man, without inspiration, at tempts to delve into the mysteries of God. he finds himself overwhelm ed in perplexities. "Therefore, I am much interested that the unerring hand of Him who is author of all truth and justice shall direct every official act of William Jennings Rryan, Jr., has arrived in Dayton from Los Angeles, joining other prosecution counsel as sembled for the trial of John T. Scopes, beginning there Saturday, on a charge of violating Tennessee anti evolution law. Says Scopes Is Menace William Jennings Bryan believes that John T. Scopes, defendant in the evolution trial is doing more harm to the teachers of the country than to any other class. "This harm,” he declared, “would be indefinitely increased if his (Scopes’) views as to the independ ence of the teacher were estab Religion and education were con trasted in a brief address by Mr.
Clipping to come
Imperial Valley Press · El Centro, Calif.
This editorial anticipates the upcoming Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, framing it as a dramatic clash between science and religion that will draw massive national attention, possibly via radio broadcast. The writer speculates on the outcome, hoping both science and religion emerge chastened but intact, each respecting the other's domain.
Imperial Valley Press · 15 June 1925 · page 4
THE BATTLE IN TENNESSEE
SUBSCRIPTION RATES * THE HA TTLE IX TEWESSEE Famous lawyers, orators and educators will be marshalled at that trial of the high school science teacher at Dayton, Tenn., for teaching evolution. Science and religion will fight it out in the presence cf an unprecedented audience, near and far. That is, what the scrappers regard as science and religion will fight it out. The scope of the thing—and the defendant’s name is Scopes— grows rapidly. There may be a huge stadium for a court. The proceedings may be broad cast by radio.
See moreSee less
They will be wired to the entire press of the nation and a large part of the outer world. Vast audiences will listen to arguments the like of which most of them have never heard or read before. And they will learn something. At least, the open-minded ones will. And will religion kill science off, or will science kill religion off. or will the two eat each other up? Foolish questions! Science is true and eternal, and so is religion. There is reason to hope that when the smoke of battle is over, each will go its own way. as healthy as ever, but possibly a little more chastened, and more ready to keep on its own side of the fence, with a bet ter appreciation of the other's functions and value. There may be new realization of the truth that science and religion belong together, and should get along with each other, complementing and helping and tolerating each other, as man and woman do. PROFIT A RLE A U TOS
This miscellany column briefly notes that whatever the outcome of the Tennessee discussion tracing back to the Garden of Eden, Bryan has elevated Scopes to a prominence that will make him a formidable lecture-circuit competitor. The rest of the passage covers unrelated topics like D.C. water supply, Senator Underwood's political prospects, and weather bureau forecasts.
Evening Star · 15 June 1925 · page 6
TWO TEACHERS The “‘Monkey Trial”’ opens at Dayton, Tenn, That state recent ly enacted a law, making the teaching of evolution in the pub lic schools a crime, and John T. Scopes is alleged to have broken the law by giving instruetion a long the line of the modern evolu tionist. Ile sas arrested and will now be tried by a jury to deter mine his guilt or innocence. On the side of the state is William Jennings Bryan, a pronounced op ponent of the present evolution ary philesophy, who will lead in the prosecution of the school teacher.
See moreSee less
On the other side is an array of brilliant lawyers who will defend Scopes. Among these able men 15 Clarence Darrow of Chi cago. Whether the jury acquits or finds this young man *‘ guilty”
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A reader's letter to the editor questions evolution theory, noting Dayton, Tennessee's sudden fame from the Scopes case and plans to turn it into a summer resort. The writer argues that since monkeys aren't currently evolving into humans, this undermines evolutionary theory.
Evening Star · 15 June 1925 · page 6
No Conflict Seen
VASHON ISLAND NEWS-REC ORD Bryan, and all other fundament alists subscribe to this general be lief. 3, The third class is the Agnos. tie. Literally, it means one who doesn’t know. Taken in its liter al meaning, there are many agnos tics. Scopes isn't one, however. He claims he does know, He claims he can teach the truth about the origin of man. IHe teaches what the modern evolutionist says is!
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
An editorial questions the theory of evolution by asking why monkeys no longer transform into men, and argues true science and true religion cannot conflict. It criticizes both empty religious display and unproven scientific theory, framing the Scopes trial as part of this broader debate.
Evening Star · 15 June 1925 · page 6
4 William Jennings Bryan selling Flo ~rida real estate during his spare ~ moments . . . Clarence Darrow wondering how he will win the case
Clipping to come
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
Board of Education president James T. Lloyd said after reviewing the legislative history that teaching evolution using Scopes' textbook does not violate the 'disrespect for the Holy Bible' clause in the D.C. school funding bill. He stated he would not bring the matter before the Board since he personally sees no violation of the law.
The Washington Daily News · 15 June 1925 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
The article previews the upcoming Scopes evolution trial by noting that attorney Bainbridge Colby will oppose William Jennings Bryan, recalling their earlier clash at the 1920 Democratic National Convention. It recounts an anecdote where Colby's quiet wit won over a crowd eager to hear the famous orator Bryan.
The Washington Daily News · 15 June 1925 · page 8
HISTORY REPEATS: COLBY vs. BRYAN
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
A letter writer complains about misuse of a flag emblem for parking signals at an event. The main item profiles Clarence Darrow, newly selected as defense counsel in the Scopes evolution trial, describing his intellectual depth and prior famous cases like Leopold and Loeb.
The Washington Daily News · 15 June 1925 · page 8
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Yidishes Ṭageblaṭṭ = the Jewish Daily News · New York, N.Y.
A column surveys press opinion on the Tennessee Anti-Evolution Law, quoting a Yiddish-language editorial questioning how evolution should be taught and a Chicago Tribune piece condemning the law as a violation of church-state separation. Both pieces debate the propriety of legislating on scientific and religious matters.
Yidishes Ṭageblaṭṭ = the Jewish Daily News · 15 June 1925 · page 6
A Reader's Impressions of the News of the Day
To everyone's relief the day of the dawned cool and clear. } Dayton “tidied up™ for the greatest “event in its MNstory. The stneul were neatly swept, gay bunting m‘ displayed {n shop windows and store
Clipping to come
Yidishes Ṭageblaṭṭ = the Jewish Daily News · New York, N.Y.
This item compiles editorial commentary from various newspapers reacting to the Scopes case and the Tennessee law banning evolution, including comparisons to the Inquisition's treatment of Galileo. It also includes a Times editorial on the Ku Klux Klan and a note on small Jewish communities in Mississippi.
Yidishes Ṭageblaṭṭ = the Jewish Daily News · 15 June 1925 · page 6
VICTOR L. BERGER Joseph Wood Krutch of KnoxVille, in an article “Tennessee, Where Cowards Rule,” to ap pear in The Nation for July 15, makes a severe criticism of the Tennessee university authorities in connection with the Scopes trial. Writing from Dayton, Tenn., Jie says: ♦ * * “Even those who do not hap pen, like the present writer, to have been born and bred in Ten nessee, should not find it diffi cult to forgive Dayton. A tiny town set in the midst of fruitful strawberry fields, it had never heard of any Darwin, except the one who keeps the local dry goods store, until William Jennings Bryan enlightened it.
See moreSee less
* * * , “While the president of the State University sat in his of €<ce praying that he might be allowed to violate the law in peace; and seeking to retain the friendship of both sides—Day ton was arranging to settle in simple honesty what the repre sentatives of science, education, and enlightenment were anxious only to dodge. ♦ * ♦ “At Dayton no one is afraid
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
The report notes that sixty witnesses have been listed by the state to testify against John Scopes in the upcoming trial. This indicates preparations are underway before the trial formally begins.
The Washington Times · 15 June 1925 · page 1
Sixty on State's List to Testify Against Scopes
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Prosecutors in the Scopes evolution trial announce more than sixty witnesses, including prominent scientists and clergy, will testify for the State. Dayton, Tennessee is making elaborate preparations for the trial, converting local buildings for use by press, visitors, and officials, while William Jennings Bryan coordinates strategy with prosecutors.
The Washington Times · 15 June 1925 · page 1
SCOPES TO FACE 60 FOES
By International Newe Merriee. DAYTON, Tenn., June 15.—More than sixty witnesses will be called by the State in the trial next month of John T. Scopes, charged with teaching evolution in violation of the Tennessee law, it was an nounced here today. These wit nesses, according to H. E. Hicks, of the prosecution, will include some of the greatest divines and scientists in tte wdrld. * Hicks and other State attorneys are to confer tn Atlanta this week with William Jennings Bryan to de fine their plans for the prosecution. Bryan has asked that Senator Thomas J.
See moreSee less
Walsh of Montana and Samuel Untermyer of New York be retained by the State to aid in prosecuting Scopes. Meanwhile. Dayton is preparing feverishly for the greatest event io. her historyThe committee of citizens in charge of arrangements for the trial has decided to turn the grammar school where Scopes taught the theory of evolution into an emer gency hospital; the ball park idll be used as a parking space for auto mobiles and the Dayton tabernacle will be used as a commujiity dining room. , Chattanooga has been asked to supply a fire company and police reserves. Ample arrangements have been made to take care of newspaper men. Press quarters have been ar ranged and special tables set asid?. Representatives of forty-five news papers already have made reserva tions. Arthur Brisbane has been as signed a room in tse same home in which Scopes resides.
A citizens' committee in Dayton has arranged to convert local buildings into an emergency hospital, parking area, and dining hall to accommodate the upcoming Scopes trial, with Chattanooga supplying fire and police support. Reporters from 45 newspapers have reserved press space, and Dr. John Roach Straton condemns evolution as unproven and morally ruinous in a separate statement.
The Washington Times · 15 June 1925 · page 1
BALTIMORE, June 15.—“ Evol ution is all guess work; it hasn’t a leg to stand on and its mor.il ef fects are ruinous,” said tho “Rev erend Doctor John Roach Straton. of New York, when asked to ex press an opinion on the pending trial of John T. Scopes, charged with violating Tennessee law, which forbids teaching of the theory of evolution in public schools. Doctor Straton, who is a well known fundamentalist, delivered two sermons yesterday at the Sev enth Baptist Church, where he was pastor for some years Both sermons dealt* with the fundament alist-modernist controversy.
See moreSee less
' “The evolutionists’ idea Is that there is no revelation from God,” he declared, “and that the Bible is just a plain, ordinary booif much like any other. “The doctrine which Scopes has taught is naturalism as opposed to super-naturalism. It is a terrific doctrine. “What the world wants at pres ent is some old-fashioned religion.” Asked how he accounted for the fact that in England the contro versy has been dead since the be ginning of the twentieth century he replied that in Europe the. evo lutionists and modernists had man aged to have their own way. “Propaganda has done it,” Doctor Straton asserted, “but the prona ganda in this country has been met i by the counter propaganda of those who believe in a supernatural Christ. “The teaching, of the evolution ists has sapped our moral founda tions. Its materialistic philosophy ■ has brought ruin *>n many of the , : younger generation Look at the | ! decay among the student bodies of I the colleges.” I Doctor Straton then went on to i relate how a commission inquiring , into the moral state of a cert.-in New York school had found wide spread moral bankruptcy. This he described to the teaching of the modernists. “Not long ago,” he declared, “I (Continued on Page 2, Column 3J SCOPES TO
William Jennings Bryan recounts a prior debate with an evolutionist, claiming victory by challenging him to produce proof. Senator Thomas J. Walsh announces he will not join the defense team for the upcoming Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee, citing retirement from law practice and summer travel plans.
The Washington Times · 15 June 1925 · page 2
SCOPES TRIAL TO BE BIG
Opponents Are Bitter. Some of Bryan’s opponents bit terly accuse him of attempting to fix in the mind of the nation that the defense wars on religion, in an ticipation of a defeat here and a long struggle for a constitutional amendment banishing evolution from American schools forever. Despite its seriousness, the trial probaldy will have its aspects of in formality and joviality. Judge Raulston said Thursday that while he would not permit smoking, coats would bo shed. Jolly and with a fund of anecdote, Raulston will con tribute a sparkle to the proceedings.
See moreSee less
Darrow is noted as a wit; Bryan has a trick of loosing darts of pun gent sarcasm and Dayton is con tributing her most celebrated legal nmorist to the case —Gen. Ben Mc enzie of the prosecution staff.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A satirical sports column riffs on a rained-out Senators-Nationals game, joking about league rules and baseball 'evolution,' tossing in comedic references to William Jennings Bryan, Clarence Darrow, and Professor Scopes. The piece uses the pending Scopes trial as a punchline for mock-serious baseball controversy rather than reporting on the trial itself.
The Washington Times · 15 June 1925 · page 20
Scopes, Sr. Whereupon Mr. Bryan smiled benevolently and made his. way through the screen door to Main St. Just previous to the introduction Mr. Scopes was telling a reporter he rather admired Mr. Bryan, but thought he .was “a little bit off on the subject of religion.” Mr. Bryan, when the trial is over, is said to be planning a pilgrimage to the Holy Land, then write his memoirs. He is through with the lecture platform, and his .real estate investments in Florida are said to have netted him a fortune.
See moreSee less
He is still' interested in politics, however, and told men in his group at dinner Wednesday night that the next Democratic nominee must come from the south or the west, and frowned, it is said, upon the sug gestion of Al Smith “Civilization on Trial.” CHICAGO —Civilization will be nn trial at Dayton, Tenn., Clarence ’>aj’row declared as he boarded a tfain from Chicago to take a leading pa> for the defense in the Scopes evolution trial. “My sole purpose in participating in this trial,” Darrow said, “is to defend the rights of free speech and honest study. Our very civiliza tion will be on trial. “If Mr. Bryan believes that Ten nessee court or jury is going to have any effect upon the thought and investigations of the world, he’s a very gullible man.” f Miss Scopes Gets Offer. LEXINGTON, Ky.—A position as teacher of mathematics and possi bly some science, at Highland Manor, an exclusive country board school for girls at Tarrytown, N. Y., was
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.
This piece recounts a 1920 Democratic convention debate where Bainbridge Colby cleverly upstaged William Jennings Bryan with a witty remark about speaking loudly versus thinking well. It frames their upcoming opposition in the Scopes evolution trial as a rematch of old rivals.
The Indianapolis Times · 15 June 1925 · page 4
History Repeats Colby vs. Bryan.
County court at Dayton, lean., where John T. Scopes, hhdi school science teacher, will he placed on trial on a charge of teaching evolution in viola tion of the Tennessee law.
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
Clarence Darrow traveled to New York to meet with John T. Scopes, the Tennessee teacher facing trial. Darrow also remarked that he expected Nathan Leopold to follow Richard Loeb's lead regarding an insanity plea.
South Bend News-Times · 15 June 1925 · page 9
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A French-language Maine newspaper reports that Tennessee passed a law banning the teaching of evolution and that Professor Scopes is being prosecuted for teaching it, with Bryan offering to assist the prosecution. The article then digresses into a layman's explanation of Darwin's and Huxley's evolutionary theories, discussing similarities between apes and humans while emphasizing the human soul as the distinguishing feature.
Le Messager · 15 June 1925 · page 4
CHRONIQUE SCIENTIFIQUE
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Reports from Nashville suggest the Tennessee bar association may pass a resolution urging the attorney general to drop the Scopes case if it reaches the state supreme court, arguing the case was a collusive setup rather than genuine law enforcement. Separately, legal circles speculate the district attorney may move to quash the indictment over an allegedly illegal grand jury session, with plans to seek a new indictment if successful.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 June 1925 · page 1
Tennessee Bar Would Call Off Prosecution Scopes
On Over Evolution. Dayton, Term., July 11.—The fight between evolution and ' Christianity “is a duel to the death,*’ William J. Bryan said in an address on his arrival here to aid in the prosecution of Thomas * Scopes, whose trial ou the crim inal charge of tone hi g evolution ' in the school; of Tennessee be jgihs here Friday. Dayton, July 10. — With prayer by the Rev. William M. Cart wright, pastor of the Dayton Methodist Episcopal Church South; the special term of the > Rhea county circuit court con vened this morning for the trial of John Thomas Scopes who is charged wiih violating the anti evolution law of Tennessee.
See moreSee less
The opening of the court was marked by what, was expected to 'be only the first of many demon strations, when the entrance of ' William V ‘r.yan provoked a burst of handcla; ping. Aa the 1 leading member of the prosecut i' ing staff of attorneys walked ' within the bar of the court he was greeted cordially by Clar * enbe Darrow and Dudley Field -VMalone. leaders of the defense •group of lawyers. ' Dayton, July 11 —The /jury selected to try Thomas Scopes was completed ' this morning. The jury is composed of ' - nine farmers, one school teacher, one fruit gaower arid one shipping clerk. * Following completion of tne jury, court '■ adjourned until Monday.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
This Public Ledger editorial argues that defense lawyers and self-promoters are turning the Scopes trial into a spectacle, overshadowing the real constitutional issues of free speech and thought. It worries that John Scopes himself, described as a modest schoolteacher, is being sidelined by radical elements seeking publicity.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 June 1925 · page 6
The Super-Sideshow in Tennessee
On Over Evolution. Dayton, Term., July 11.—The fight between evolution and ' Christianity “is a duel to the death,*’ William J. Bryan said in an address on his arrival here to aid in the prosecution of Thomas * Scopes, whose trial ou the crim inal charge of tone hi g evolution ' in the school; of Tennessee be jgihs here Friday. Dayton, July 10. — With prayer by the Rev. William M. Cart wright, pastor of the Dayton Methodist Episcopal Church South; the special term of the > Rhea county circuit court con vened this morning for the trial of John Thomas Scopes who is charged wiih violating the anti evolution law of Tennessee.
See moreSee less
The opening of the court was marked by what, was expected to 'be only the first of many demon strations, when the entrance of ' William V ‘r.yan provoked a burst of handcla; ping. Aa the 1 leading member of the prosecut i' ing staff of attorneys walked ' within the bar of the court he was greeted cordially by Clar * enbe Darrow and Dudley Field -VMalone. leaders of the defense •group of lawyers. ' Dayton, July 11 —The /jury selected to try Thomas Scopes was completed ' this morning. The jury is composed of ' - nine farmers, one school teacher, one fruit gaower arid one shipping clerk. * Following completion of tne jury, court '■ adjourned until Monday.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
The piece describes how various activists, radicals, and self-promoters are descending on Dayton, Tennessee, overshadowing the actual defendant John Scopes and the legal issue at stake. It portrays Scopes as a modest, obscure figure being trampled by a 'menagerie' of attention-seekers ahead of the trial.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 June 1925 · page 6
Nine Farmers Compose Ma jority of Jurors—Argu ments on Testimony. r . DAYTON, Tenn., July 11. — The jury to hear the charges against l’rof. J. T. Scopes for alleged viola tion of tlie Tennessee State law pro hibiting the teaching of evolution in public schools, was completed late yesterday afternoon. The jury is composed of nine farmers, one farmer-teacher, one fruit grower, and one shipping clerk The question of tlie admission of scientific testimony in regard to evolution, will lie fought out in court on Monday when the court reconvenes.
See moreSee less
No session is being held today to enable the defense to confer on tlie only issue in the case as to whether Scopes taught man descended from the lower order of animals. Attorney General Stewart empha sized that the truth of evolution was not involved in the State's position.
Clipping to come
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.
Religious leaders and university presidents addressed the evolution controversy in baccalaureate sermons and commencement speeches at Yale, Brown, Syracuse, Princeton and elsewhere. Reactions ranged from calling the Scopes trial a national embarrassment to arguing evolution and religious faith were compatible.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 15 June 1925 · page 1
Evolution Theory Widely Discussed
Nine Farmers Compose Ma jority of Jurors—Argu ments on Testimony. r . DAYTON, Tenn., July 11. — The jury to hear the charges against l’rof. J. T. Scopes for alleged viola tion of tlie Tennessee State law pro hibiting the teaching of evolution in public schools, was completed late yesterday afternoon. The jury is composed of nine farmers, one farmer-teacher, one fruit grower, and one shipping clerk The question of tlie admission of scientific testimony in regard to evolution, will lie fought out in court on Monday when the court reconvenes.
See moreSee less
No session is being held today to enable the defense to confer on tlie only issue in the case as to whether Scopes taught man descended from the lower order of animals. Attorney General Stewart empha sized that the truth of evolution was not involved in the State's position.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Reporting from Washington, Prof. John Thomas Scopes explains he chose Clarence Darrow for his defense team based on Darrow's reputation as a skilled trial lawyer, not for the notoriety from the Loeb-Leopold case. The article recounts Darrow's earlier legal career, including his defense of Bill Haywood in the 1907 Idaho trial involving Harry Orchard's testimony about the Cripple Creek riots.
Paper unidentified · 15 June 1925 · page 2
Dudley Field Malone, defence of the profess While tin conferred with CHIEF WAGNER COMING TO NOME ON BOXER WITH MORE SEATTLE. July 10. ./P, Alaska Ilmvnn of Education - '• •.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A feature piece profiles John T. Scopes ahead of his Tennessee trial, noting his belief that any biology teacher must violate the state's anti-evolution law. He also voices fear that future legislation could enshrine a flat-earth doctrine, citing a tract by Rev. M. S. Carlisle, and credits Dr. Rappleyea with instigating the case.
Paper unidentified · 15 June 1925 · page 8
JURY CHOSEN TO TRY SCOPES FOR FALSE TEACHING JURY CONSISTS OF NINE FARM ERS. FRUIT GROWER, CLERK AND FARMER-TEACHER *‘DID SCOPES TEACH EVOLUTION’ All But One Juror belong to Some Evangelical Denomination— “Fundamentalist Jury.’’ DAYTON, Tenn., July 11 (£>)—'The jury to try Professor John A. Scopes the Tennessee professor, for violation of the State law against the teaching of evolution, was secured yesterday afternoon. It consists of nine farmers one teach, one fruit grower, one far mer teacher and one clerk. The ques lion of the admission of scientific tes timony in regard to evolution will be fought in court Monday when it re convenes.
See moreSee less
There will be no session today to enable the defense to confer. The only issue in the case will be “Did Scopes teach that man descend ed from a lower order of animals.’1 €■ ► Attorney General Stewart said today. He said that the theory of evolution was not involved in the State’s posi tion.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The article profiles John T. Scopes and the law's author Butler, describes Scopes's views on evolution being integral to biology, and recounts how Dr. Rappleyea instigated the test case during a discussion at Robinson's drug store in Dayton. It includes a reproduced textbook page from Hunter's 'Civic Biology' that formed the basis of the indictment.
Paper unidentified · 15 June 1925 · page 8
DAYTON, Tenn., July 11 (£>)—'The jury to try Professor John A. Scopes the Tennessee professor, for violation of the State law against the teaching of evolution, was secured yesterday afternoon. It consists of nine farmers one teach, one fruit grower, one far mer teacher and one clerk. The ques lion of the admission of scientific tes timony in regard to evolution will be fought in court Monday when it re convenes. There will be no session today to enable the defense to confer. The only issue in the case will be “Did Scopes teach that man descend ed from a lower order of animals.’1 €■ ► Attorney General Stewart said today. He said that the theory of evolution was not involved in the State’s posi tion. Jury Ail Church Members
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
John Scopes describes how the case began at Robbins' drug store, where Dr. Rappelyea argued no biology teacher could avoid teaching evolution, prompting Scopes to admit he had violated the law. The article also reproduces the textbook page from Hunter's 'Civic Biology' that led to his indictment, and notes how local townspeople later tried to take control of the case for publicity and profit.
Paper unidentified · 15 June 1925 · page 8
A FOOLISH TRIAL. The trial of John T. Scopes, the Tennessee school teacher for viola tion of the state’s anti-evolution law is rapidly developing into a farce—a farce which can do no good to the church members prosecuting Scopes and which can prove nothing for or against evolution. Ministers of the gospel headed by W. J. Bryan have gathered at Dayton, Tennessee, to prosecute the aged professor, and as news dispatches state that court op«ai ed with prayer and the reading of the first chapter of Genesis, there is lit tle doubt but that Mr. Scopes will be
Clipping to come
Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska
In Dayton, Tennessee, counsel for John T. Scopes filed a motion with the circuit clerk seeking to quash the indictment charging him with teaching evolution theories. Scopes is identified as a school principal.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Seward Daily Gateway · 16 June 1925 · page 7
A FOOLISH TRIAL. The trial of John T. Scopes, the Tennessee school teacher for viola tion of the state’s anti-evolution law is rapidly developing into a farce—a farce which can do no good to the church members prosecuting Scopes and which can prove nothing for or against evolution. Ministers of the gospel headed by W. J. Bryan have gathered at Dayton, Tennessee, to prosecute the aged professor, and as news dispatches state that court op«ai ed with prayer and the reading of the first chapter of Genesis, there is lit tle doubt but that Mr. Scopes will be
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Senator John Neal announced that Clarence Darrow would visit Dayton to familiarize himself with the local setting before the Scopes trial begins. Neal also addressed reports about the state bar association and defense strategy, including plans to challenge the statute's constitutionality and the vagueness of the charge.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 June 1925 · page 1
DARROW TO VISIT DAYTON MONDAY
It should confine its efforts to prose cuting the violator of its laws and shunt William J. Bryan and Clarence Harrow into the arbolados, keeping to the subject in hand. If Prof. Scope has been guilty of violating the state Jaws, convict him. If lie has not, free him. If Christianity is pillioried in the Dayton court room, it will be ill for all concerned. It has been found impossible to legislate convictions either into or out of the average man’s head, and some of our greatest sci entists have disagreed with Darwin.
See moreSee less
If man was evolved from an ape, wre are willing to concede that it w^as hard on the apes. If he is as he wras first created, we believe w'e could take some native spruce and a few zeroline cans and put more intelligence into our creation than some jurors exhibit.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Defense counsel previewed their strategy, including attacking the indefiniteness of the charge and the statute's constitutionality, noting ministers called to testify would offer varying views on divine creation. Separately, Governor Peay was formally invited to appear as a prosecution witness, and news emerged of Scopes being served his indictment and a planned conference with William Jennings Bryan.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 16 June 1925 · page 1
PEAY SERVED NOTICE
(Continued From Page One) —Ymms • tear thorough inspection if the case • .s * nigher court, presented a new bill and the defendant was r~ indicted in almost the same lan guage used in the first document. To Explain Evolution A statement by Clarence Darrow of counsel for the defense. show .1 Speakins the first issue at hand. of the expectation of the detense to bring witnesses from a distance, he defense said that the con.erer witnesses in ac rentista competent the case, to explain what evolution is, saying defense counsel consid ered such witnesses comjtent on Luth sides.
See moreSee less
Attney General Stwart, reply. ing to Mr. Darrow’s announeme: that »he defense would insist in mn traducing scientists and Bible stu dents to give their views of the tenuesee aw, sa.d the stale wot., take the position that it was not competent to bring selentsts into the ruse to testify as to what the theuy of evolution is or interpret the Bibl, or ‘anything at taat sort. The brief preliminary strndeu ended the incident for the day. the afternoon session being d-vuted to selection of a jury. The first of the jury panel cailea, W. H. Hobinson, was accepted by the Mate and defense with only a few questions, but Clarence Darrow went into an exhausuve examina tion of the secund prospective juror. followed J. W. Dagley, and this course with the others until the I I The defense lawyer the talismen if they anything of evolution, had discussed it. heard serions or lectures on the subject and read of it in newspapers or He also asked as ‘d magazines. their church membersa.p. familiarity Bible, the with an l kleas, if any, as to the zonsitency Lae tnevry of evolution and the
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Defense attorneys including Clarence Darrow plan to travel to Dayton to set up headquarters and familiarize themselves with the town ahead of the July 10 trial, while prosecution attorneys head to Atlanta to confer with William Jennings Bryan. A related item notes the evolution theory being widely discussed in pulpits and commencement addresses at universities like Princeton and Yale.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 June 1925 · page 18
PLANS ARE LAID FOR INITIAL BOUT IN SCOPES TRIAL
The defense lawyer talismen if they of evolution, had discussed it. heard serions or lectures on the subject and read of it in newspapers or He also asked as ‘d magazines. church membersa.p. familiarity the with kleas, if any, as to the zonsitency Lae tnevry of evolution and the I I the anything their Bible, an l
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Defense and prosecution lawyers, including Bryan and Malone, are organizing travel to Dayton for the upcoming Scopes trial. Meanwhile, university presidents and clergy nationwide discuss evolution in baccalaureate sermons, with reactions ranging from embarrassment over the trial to calls for reconciling science and faith.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 June 1925 · page 18
EVOLUTION IS THEME
talking about the Bible but evolu tion and repeated his question "Dii you preach for or against tion? Mr. Massengale appealed to the court with the question: Is that a fair question?’* Told that it was, he said: "We% I preached against It. of course.” Applause of considerable volune broke out in the crowded court room and Judge Raulston admonished the crowd to preserve order as Mr. Dar row asked: “Why, of course Mr. Darrow was on his feet with a re quest to the court that anyone be excluded who applauded. The cour assured the Chicago man tnat such action would be taken.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
John T. Scopes remains without a teaching contract or summer job due to his pending evolution trial, despite rumors of lucrative offers including a film deal. The indictment has been formally served, Governor Peay is invited as a prosecution witness, and both sides are preparing for the July 10 trial with Bryan and Darrow confirmed as lead counsel.
New Britain Herald · 16 June 1925 · page 18
SCOPES WITHOUT A JOB
Z Br W. O. M'GEEHAJT. (Stuff rorrespondent of The New York Herald-Tribune and The Montgom ery Advertiser.) DAYTON. TENN., July 10.—Special to The Advertiser.—The case of the people vs. John Thomas Scopes, as It is known here, was opened with a prayer for Divine guidance by the Rev. L. M. Cartright, whose fathers be fore him were circuit riders in the Blue Ridge mountains. As the prayer proceeded there were only two heads within the railed enclosure bowed in ostensible reverence, the head of John Thomas Scopes, the meek defendant, and the shinning, half-bar ren pate of William Jennings Bry an.
See moreSee less
Clarence Darrow, who heads coun sel for the defense, stood coatless and twiddled thoughtfully with a pair of lavender suspenders or galluses. It teemed as though these galluses had been designed for effect. The galluses are essential parts of the male costume in this vicinity! It m%y have been that Mr. Darrow Wore them as a nappeal for sympathy to the funda
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
The report describes the formal serving of the indictment on John Scopes and announcements of conferences between prosecution and defense counsel ahead of the trial. It notes plans for Darrow to visit Dayton, Bryan meeting prosecution counsel in Atlanta, and preparations in Dayton for handling crowds including billboard signs.
New Britain Herald · 16 June 1925 · page 18
Date Momentous. j mis date, July lu, nas oeon » mo mentous one 1 rv the life of William Jennings Bryan. It was just 29 years ago to the day that the boy orator of the Flatte burst into ttha impas sioned. "Cross of Gold" speech. Mil lions of words have poured from that golden throat since, campaign speech es. sermons, Chautauqua lectures and Florida realty sales talks. The name of William Jennings Bryan has thinned out, but the voice has not thinned at all In volume, in the transition from ‘ crosses of gold and crosses of silver to crosses of brass through the long rows of the double crosses of poli tics.
See moreSee less
The boy orator of the Flatte, trans formed into the pachyderm of poli tics. and the millionaire realty dealer of Miami, still has a tireless energy and the same tireless voice. Mr. Bryan's entrance was the signal for the first demonstration. The gentler sex among the resident fundamental ists waved their sunbonnets, while the male fundamentalists snapped their galluses as a gesture of approbation. Mr. Bryan smiled that same expan sive smile of which a panoramic pho tograph was taken on the lawn be fore the Rhea county courthouse dur ing the recess. Then Mr. Darrow rose to his feet and revealed the strategic galluses. Mr. Bryan looked just a bit crestfallen There was nothing to do but to remove his neat blue coat. He did this slowly and painfully and stood before the startled fundamen talists of Rhea county and the evolu tionists from far aqd jv*<3e as a man without galluses.
John T. Scopes remains without a teaching contract for next term and his summer car-sales job fell through due to the upcoming July 10 trial. Governor Peay was invited as a prosecution witness, and prosecution counsel will meet Bryan while Darrow plans to visit Dayton before the trial.
Evening Star · 16 June 1925 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image
SCOPES JOBLESS FOR NEXT TERM
Indicted Evolution Teacher Has Received No Contract for Coming Year.
See moreSee less
By the Associated Press.
DAYTON, Tenn.. June 16.—John T. Scopes, indicted for violation of the State anti-evolution laws, still is without a teaching contract for the next term of school. Also, his plans to sell automobiles for a Dayton concern during the Summer months have gone awry because of the opening of his trial July 10. Since his return to Dayton Scopes has made no comment on New York reports that he had received offers totalling $150,000, including a $50,000 contract for a motion picture in which he would appear.
The limelight in which the case has placed the young science teacher continues to be focused upon him. He was complimented yesterday by a large delegation from the town of Coal Creek, headed by the mayor and other city officials.
It was announced today that Gov. Austin Peay had been informed that his presence as a witness for the prosecution at the trial would be welcome. The invitation, extended by Walter White, superintendent of schools and prosecutor: the formal serving of the indictment on Scopes and the announcement of conferences by both defense and prosecution counsel marked the latest developments in the case.
Counsel to Meet Bryan.
Counsel for the prosecution will meet William J. Bryan in Atlanta on Thursday, while the defense announced that Clarence Darrow would visit Dayton next Monday to familiarize himself with the local setting before the trial opens.
John R. Neal, senior counsel for Scopes, said that witnesses representing every branch of scientific thought would be placed on the stand and that it was the plan to have them cross-examined by Mr. Darrow.
Formal service of the indictment on Scopes was a necessary legal formality, although the action of the local justice of the peace giving him his liberty on his own recognizance until court meets still holds. The service was obtained by the sheriff in the same drug store where the test case was proposed.
DR. TIGERT SILENT.
Even though the Government is keenly interested in the outcome of the evolution law trial to be held next month in Tennessee, when the constitutionality of the State law prohibiting teaching of evolution in the schools will be challenged, the Federal agency most concerned is maintaining an attitude of watchful waiting. The policy of the Bureau of Education, the direct link between the Government and the educational system of the Nation, was defined today by Commissioner Tigert as one of "hands off." Dr. Tigert declined absolutely to commit himself or the bureau on a matter which he holds to be one of State sovereignty and one in which the Government can take no part.
Meanwhile, it developed today that a hitherto obscure and little noticed section of the District of Columbia appropriation act for 1925 makes reference to a prohibition against the principles involved in the Tennessee law. In appropriating for salaries for school teachers here, Congress passed a paragraph which providse that no part of the sum appropriated for salaries shall be available for the payment of any superintendent or instructor who permits the teaching of disrespect of the Holy Bible or partisan politics.
The trial of John Scopes, charged with violation of the Tennessee law, will bring in the teachings of the Bible during the testimony next month.
The book, "Civic Biology," which Scopes used in Tennessee, is not used in the public schools here, the only book listed in the high schools on the subject being "Inductive Biology," by Lewanna Wilkins, although other books are said to be used.
Prof. Alfred A. Doolittle, professor of biology at Central High School, said today there is no direct reference to the evolution of man in the books on biology used in the high schools here, although all the references made to the progressive civilization of the human race . support the evolution theory.
The passage reports that Scopes was formally served with the indictment and remains free on his own recognizance, while prosecution and defense counsel announce plans to meet with Bryan and Darrow respectively ahead of the trial. It also notes the Bureau of Education's neutral stance and a related anti-evolution provision in the D.C. appropriations act.
Evening Star · 16 June 1925 · page 12
DR. TIGERT SILENT. Even though the Government is . keenly interested in the outcome of the evolution lawtrial to be held next I month in Tennessee, when the coni stitutionality of the State law pro-; hibiting teaching of evolution in the j schools will be challenged, the Federal . agency most concerned Is maintain ing an attitude of w’atehful waiting. The policy of the Bureau of Educa tion, the direct link between the Gov ernment and the educational system of the Nation, was defined today by Commissioner Tigert as one of “hands | off." Dr. Tigert declined absolutely to commit himself or the bureau on a j matter which he holds to he one of; State soterelgnty and one in which) the Government can take no part. j
Commissioner Tigert of the Bureau of Education refused to take a position on the Tennessee law, calling it a matter of state sovereignty. The report also notes a similar anti-evolution provision tucked into the D.C. appropriations act regarding teaching disrespect of the Bible.
Evening Star · 16 June 1925 · page 12
DR. TIGERT SILENT.
matter which he holds to he one of; State soterelgnty and one in which) the Government can take no part. j Meanwhile, it developed today that j * hitherto obscure and little noticed j section of the District of Columbia ap- ' propriation act for 13-5 makes refer- | ence to a prohibition against the pritij ciples involved in the Tennessee law. j Tn appropriating for salaries for j school teachers here. Congress passed a paragraph which providse that no part of the stint appropriated for sala ries shall he available for the payment of any superintendent or instructor w ho permits the teaching of disrespect of the Holy Bible or partisan politics.
See moreSee less
The trial of Scopes, charged with violation of the Tennessee law. will bring in the teachings of the
While attention focuses on the Scopes trial in Dayton, fundamentalists are organizing a campaign in California, Oregon, and Washington to ban evolution teaching through lectures, sermons, and radio broadcasts. The plan aims to influence 1926 elections, with figures like Aimee Semple McPherson, William Bell Riley, and eventually Billy Sunday and William Jennings Bryan participating.
The Washington Daily News · 16 June 1925 · page 7
West Coast to Have Evolution Battle
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
John Scopes has become a local celebrity in Dayton, Tennessee as his upcoming trial for teaching evolution draws national attention. The report also identifies key figures in the case, including the druggist who hosted the original evolution discussions, the man who swore the warrant, and the presiding judge.
The Washington Times · 16 June 1925 · page 3
IS HERO OF SCOPES
Banquets By lßtern»tion»l News Service. DAYTON, v*enn., June 16.—John T. Scopes, high school professor, who set the tongues of the scientific and religious worlds wagging by the simple act of teaching evolution to his classes in the local high School, has become the most prom inent figure m town. All eyes are focused on him when he makes his appearance In the. streets. When he stops on the sidewalk to converse with some friend or happens into Robinson’s drug store for a soda, he is a veri table human magnet and automat ically collects an audience.
See moreSee less
Dayton Proud of Him. • Residents of Dayton are proud of their young professor, who sud denly has sprung Into nation-wide notoriety, and whose trial here next month for violating the Tennessee anti-evolution law will draw some of the mdst brilliant men of the Na :ion as well ns hundreds of men and women prominent in scientific and educational work. As a token of their respect and admiration for him they are feteIng him with banquets and enter tainments, both private and public. They greet him with a hearty hand shake on the rtreets and inquire as to the progress of the case. They offer their money and their services to the young evolutionist who has elevated their little city to a place of nation-wide prominence. Scopes Works on Case.
The report describes how Scopes has become a local celebrity in Dayton, with residents feting him with banquets and support as his trial approaches. It also notes that both prosecution and defense are preparing their cases, with Bryan and Darrow expected to join the legal teams.
The Washington Times · 16 June 1925 · page 3
ference with Williams Jennings Bryan In Atlanta Friday to place the finishing touches on their plans for prosecuting young Scopes. ' Defense attorneys are eagerly awaiting the arrival here of Clarence E. Darrow, noted criminal lawyer of Chicago, who will assist in defending Scopes. He Is due to arrive about June 22. Dies As She Enters Church
Sir Oliver Lodge, former president of the Society for Psychical Research, gave a speech defending evolution theory and urging people not to fear the word. His remarks were widely seen as a reference to the upcoming Scopes trial in Tennessee.
South Bend News-Times · 16 June 1925 · page 14
Sir Oliver Lodge Staunchly Defends Evolution Theory
Psychical Research. “Don't be '.Tightened by the word evolution.” he counseled in a speech. “The word has frightened the people of America." Those present took this as a ref erence to the forthcoming trial in Tennessee of Prof. John T. Scopes who was indicted for teaching evolu tion in a Tennessee school in viola tion of the state law. "I don't .know what the people of America thing the word evolution means," continued Ix>dge, “but evo lution is the hope or the world. "Evolution means growth, devel opment and progress. The world is a going concern and we do not want it to become stagnant.
See moreSee less
If It is not stagnant then it must be evolving. “We have been on this earth a long time as conscious beings, yet • we have not been intelligent very long. Now that we are intelligent we can help in the process of evolu tion.”
Defense counsel for John T. Scopes filed a motion in circuit court at Dayton, Tennessee, arguing that the state's anti-evolution law is unconstitutional. The motion claims the law, which bars teachers from discussing evolution, violates seven articles of the Tennessee constitution.
The Daily Worker · 16 June 1925 · page 6
Anti-Evolution Law Violates 7 Articles of U.S. Constitution
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
A brief aside buried in an editorial roundup likens the atmosphere surrounding the upcoming Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee to how beer was central to Milwaukee's identity. It is a passing comparison rather than a substantive report on the trial itself.
The Bismarck Tribune · 16 June 1925 · page 4
International News Service.. DAYTON, Tenn., July 11.—The forces of religion, which rallied to help Tennessee convict John Thomas Scopes on a charge of , violating her anti-evolution law, I held a material advantage today in the “legal battle of the cen tury.” Ajury of fundmentalists, all God-fearing farmers of the Cum berland hills and a new indict ment, freed of technical flaws, were the trophies hung at the prosecution’s door. To the de fense was given one boon—a much| sought forty-eight hour delay due to adjournment of the trial until Monday.
Clipping to come
El Mundo · San Juan, P.R.
The article previews the July 10 trial of teacher John Scopes, accused of teaching evolution in violation of Tennessee law, noting intense national interest with radio broadcasts and press wires being installed. It names Clarence Darrow and possibly Bainbridge Colby or Charles Evans Hughes as defense, with William Jennings Bryan as prosecutor, and notes Scopes refused a $60,000 offer from a movie company.
El Mundo · 16 June 1925 · page 2
SE TRATA DE LLEVAR A LA CARCEL A UN PROFESOR POR ENSEÑAR LA TEORIA DE LA EVOLUCION
The forensic battle will revolve s round a simple announcement of defense witnesses. It will unleasn two of the greatest orators of the cay—Clarence Darrow, world fameu agnostic, and William Jennings Bryan, leader of American funda mentalists—in a dramatic clash over evolution and the Bible. It may range over several days before the sir is cleared. To Darrow will fall the duty f;rst of informing the court just what scientific experts have been summoned as witnesses for the de fense. Then he will be permitted to explain what he hopes to prove by them namely, that evolution does not conflict with tne story of the Divine Creation of man.
See moreSee less
Under this leeway. Darrow will launch what he terms his fight to save civilization from the encroachments of religious fanatics. Bryan to Reply To Bryan will be given the prin cipal task of replying and of fight ing the admission of such evidence. It will be the State’s contention that the issue here is solely whether Scopes taught biology and whether his particular textbook of biology violates the Tennessee law. The prosecution will hold that the duty of deciding whether the Scopes Kological lesson dented the Bible storv of creation rests only with the jury and that scientists have {Continued on Page 2. Column 3.1
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
This opinion piece discusses Clarence Darrow's statements during the Scopes trial, quoting his claim that man has made nature worse through intervention. It suggests this remark may create friction between evolutionists and professional scientists on the defense team.
The Seattle Star · 16 June 1925 · page 6
The forensic battle will revolve s round a simple announcement of defense witnesses. It will unleasn two of the greatest orators of the cay—Clarence Darrow, world fameu agnostic, and William Jennings Bryan, leader of American funda mentalists—in a dramatic clash over evolution and the Bible. It may range over several days before the sir is cleared. To Darrow will fall the duty f;rst of informing the court just what scientific experts have been summoned as witnesses for the de fense. Then he will be permitted to explain what he hopes to prove by them namely, that evolution does not conflict with tne story of the Divine Creation of man.
See moreSee less
Under this leeway. Darrow will launch what he terms his fight to save civilization from the encroachments of religious fanatics. Bryan to Reply To Bryan will be given the prin cipal task of replying and of fight ing the admission of such evidence. It will be the State’s contention that the issue here is solely whether Scopes taught biology and whether his particular textbook of biology violates the Tennessee law. The prosecution will hold that the duty of deciding whether the Scopes Kological lesson dented the Bible storv of creation rests only with the jury and that scientists have {Continued on Page 2. Column 3.1
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
This item is a biographical sketch of Clarence Darrow, newly selected as defense counsel in the Scopes evolution case, written by N. D. Cochran. It emphasizes Darrow's intellectual breadth beyond his fame as a criminal lawyer, citing his past cases (Moyer-Haywood-Pettibone, McNamara brothers, Loeb and Leopold) and his wide reading in biology, psychology, history, and philosophy.
The Seattle Star · 16 June 1925 · page 6
Pen Picture of Darrow, Who Will Defend Scopes
DA\TON, July 11.—Prosecution j ‘counsel in the Scopes case will hold that the admission of expert testi mony of scientists and theologians would convert the trail of the Day ton biology teacher into a joint de bate on science and religion. The purpose of the, defense, as announced Friday in the first day of the trial wlpich is testing the Tennessee law against teaching evolution in the public schools, wiii be fought out before Judge Ratils ton, Monday when arguments of the contending sides will be presented to the court. In advance of court session to day, because of the adjournment from Friday afternoon until Mon day, members of the prosecution and attorneys protested that they sought only a decision on Ihe ii-sue alleged to be a violation of the statute.
See moreSee less
The state today is pre paring to oppose the move to put experts on the star,a by every means in its command, acceding to a declaration by Attorney General Stewart.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
A report claims the Tennessee Bar Association plans to adopt a resolution at its Memphis meeting urging the state attorney general not to prosecute Scopes if the case reaches the supreme court. The reasoning given is that the case was allegedly brought about by collusion rather than to address a genuine legal violation.
The Milwaukee Leader · 16 June 1925 · page 7
TENNESSEE BAR TO ASK SCOPES CASE BE OUSTED
DA\TON, July 11.—Prosecution j ‘counsel in the Scopes case will hold that the admission of expert testi mony of scientists and theologians would convert the trail of the Day ton biology teacher into a joint de bate on science and religion. The purpose of the, defense, as announced Friday in the first day of the trial wlpich is testing the Tennessee law against teaching evolution in the public schools, wiii be fought out before Judge Ratils ton, Monday when arguments of the contending sides will be presented to the court. In advance of court session to day, because of the adjournment from Friday afternoon until Mon day, members of the prosecution and attorneys protested that they sought only a decision on Ihe ii-sue alleged to be a violation of the statute.
See moreSee less
The state today is pre paring to oppose the move to put experts on the star,a by every means in its command, acceding to a declaration by Attorney General Stewart.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
Legal observers suggest Attorney General Stewart will move to quash the Scopes indictment at next month's hearing, arguing Judge Raulston lacked authority to call a special grand jury session. If successful, a new indictment is expected to follow immediately.
The Milwaukee Leader · 16 June 1925 · page 7
CASE BE OUSTED
young school teacher criminal ly charged with teaching evolu tion, was thrust forward by de fense attorneys today. Court was in recess until Monday. Clarence Darrow and his staff of legal aslscants defending the theory bf evolut.on and Scopes, took ad vantage of the pause to confer on how best i-o mfcet the unexepected resistance of William J. Bryan and his coprosecutors, to the testimony of expert witnesses. The defense regards the evidence question as the most vital of the whole case and are ready to make a spectacular ha.tie in support of their plan to introduce scientific evidence when court reconvenes Monday. “Clear Cut Question”
Clipping to come
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.
The report describes Dayton, Tennessee preparing for the trial of teacher Scopes, accused of violating the state law against teaching evolution. It notes nationwide commentary from scientists and theologians, and criticizes Bryan's view that one cannot believe in both God and evolution, arguing for freedom to study the question.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 16 June 1925 · page 1
J'x'vn iii 1 >aytoa. Tennessee, it town of iiiMiut I’.ooo inhabitants. great pre patations arc in progress for the trial of a school teaiher hy the name of Scopes wlio is accused of violating the re< ently-euaeted State law prohibiting the touching of the theory of evolution Mi the m lioois of Tennessee. While lia.vtott is preparing for a gala time, educators, physicians, scien tists, professors, anil theologians ill! over the country are voicing their views on evolution. , "You will read about the Scopes trial and the comments of learned tin n mi evolution, and then go about your own business thinking on the ■inestion very much as you did he-, lore.
See moreSee less
for. when it is all ,-aid and done, mail's view on religion and the exisi ence of mankind are mighty hard t> change. u ...lam .Jennings Jlryaii. the eliief j
Dr. George Rappleyea, original prosecutor of Scopes, dismissed reports that William Jennings Bryan had secured attorney Samuel Untermeyer to help prosecute the case. He also noted that Scopes defense plans rested with Dr. John R. Neal, and separately it was reported Scopes applied to keep his teaching job while Edison said he would not attend the trial.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 June 1925 · page 1
RAPPLEYEA SCOFFS AT REPORTS OF AID FROM UNTERMEYER
“Clear Cut Question” t simply settles down fd*a clear question.” said Dudley Field me of Scopes’ counsel, “and that question is whether we are going to be permitted to defend ourselves.” Bryan and Darrow probably will lead their staffs in the fight Mon day. Although Bryan has not prac ticed law for thirty years, he is considered a shrewd practitioner yet, and may engage in debate with the brilliant defense attorneys to ex clude the expert testimony. Announcement by Attorney Gen eral Stewart, during proceedings yesterday that the prosecution will fight admission of such testimony, on the ground that it will not tend to either prove or disprove allega tions of Scopes’ indictment, was a leading development of the monkey trial’s opening session.
See moreSee less
Argue Monday Admissability of such expert testimony may be argued in the absence of the jury Monday. In this contingency, a stellar attraction of the monkey business will be staged, before the trial actually starts. Selection of a jury in two hours and a half came as a hot surprise. The jury picked is composed of ten church members, one man, the youngest on the jury, who is a member of no church and one who did not disclose his affiliations. All are farmers, except two, of whom cne is a shipping clerk and the other ka retired United States marshal. One Bean not read.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A letter from the Dayton entertainment committee notifies newspapers that press tickets are being issued for the upcoming Scopes trial on July 10, 1925. It describes efforts to find lodging for the expected crowds of ministers, lawyers, scientists, and journalists, directing inquiries to W. W. Morgan.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 17 June 1925 · page 4
DAYTON IS GETTING READY
•Really here la something: worth wjiile; the statement of the Polish foreign minister, who remarks: “1 ait not going to America to ask for money. After lecturing at Williams - town I will merely pay courtesy c^lls on President Coolidge and Sec retary Kellogg to thank them for what the United States has done for my young country before and since the armistice, notably In caring for oar children and the spread of epi demics.” That’s refreshing; but Po land Isn’t the only European coun try that owes America their thanks for services rendered, and some seem tq have forgotten all about that in growling because Uncle Sam insists that the regular business debts should be recognized.
See moreSee less
!"I am much interested that the un erring hand of Him who Is author of all truth and justice shall direct etery official act of mine”, says the Jtfdge, who Is to sit in judgment on tHe Scopes case. If Tennessee had felt that way about It why did it not provide that the pupils of the State schools should be taught what are t!)e arguments for evolution, and what some think to be arguments against it? ; The railroads have been accused
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A syndicated columnist reflects on the Tennessee anti-evolution law and the Scopes case, comparing it to an 1858 anti-Darwin crowd reaction in England. He argues for freedom of teaching and learning, satirizing the law by imagining absurd equivalents banning Shakespeare attribution or free verse.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 17 June 1925 · page 4
A MONKEY IN THE WOOD PILE
Howdy, folks! Willlam Jen. nings Bryan threatens (o bar the teaching of evolution thruout the nation. Little Homer Brew Jr. hopes he will bar fractions, too, » - . | Bryan proposes “to put the Bible into the conmstitution.” What's the use? Some lawyer will declare it unconstitutional | - - . ‘ 1t is <lso reported that Bryan wili run for president on an anti cuolution platform. The .inslgnia of the new party, of course, '“"1‘ be & monkey. ‘ - - - . The townspeopie of Dayton are busy sciling hot dogs (o visitors, This ought to show that they believe in evolution. What greatdr example of evolution than that of Fido turn ing into a sausage? . - -
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
John Scopes applied to the Rhea County school board to continue as a teacher next term despite his pending trial. The report also notes Governor Peay's reluctance to testify and Edison's denial of involvement in the defense.
Bible, which Bryan is advocat ing. “Rev. A. Bard, Lutheran clergyman, speaking in Mil waukee, advocates taking the Statue of Liberty from New York harbor and putting up
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
Governor Peay said he would not testify unless compelled, and Thomas Edison denied reports he offered to testify for the defense. Rumors that Bryan had hired attorney Samuel Untermyer for the prosecution were dismissed by prosecutor George Rappleyea, while the ACLU added New York lawyer Charles H. Strong to Scopes's defense team.
New Britain Herald · 17 June 1925 · page 4
VICTOR L. BERGER The Scopes trial in Dayton, Tenn., began today (Friday). According to the Associated Press, William Jennings Bryan, counsel for the prosecution, gave out the following state ment: “The control of what is to be taught in the public schools is in the hands of those who employ the teach ers, the taxpayers and parents acting through the boards of education and legislatures. It would be better for Tennes see to give up school books than to abandon the Bible.” # * * This is exactly what the Span ish rulers and the Holy Inquisi tion stood for in the 15th and 16th centuries.
See moreSee less
And they burned at the stake every Protestant they could lay hands on. They billed and expelled many hun dred thousand Jews and Arabic Marranos. Those Spaniards were absolutely honest in their belief. Only they had the Ro man Catholic Bible—(the Vul gata)—instead of the King James version of the Protestant Bible, which Bryan is advocat ing.
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
Ahead of the July 10 trial of John T. Scopes in Dayton, Tennessee, attorney general A. T. Stewart said the central question would be the constitutionality of the state law banning the teaching of evolution in public schools. He stated the state intends to argue the law is a valid exercise of the legislature's authority.
New Britain Herald · 17 June 1925 · page 16
Now One-Man Town. Formerly a one-industry town, when the people had to depend on a blast furnace concern for their livelihood, Dayton has been trans formed into a one-man town. A. P. Haggard is the man. He is mayor of the town, president of the American National bank, of the * Dayton Veneer & Lumber Mills, of the Dayton Hosiery Mills, secretary treasurer of the Tennessee Valley farms, director of the Dayton Packet Co., and stockholders in nu merous other enterprises.
Clipping to come
Imperial Valley Press · El Centro, Calif.
A photo caption shows John T. Scopes, indicted for teaching evolution in Tennessee, with his defense lawyers Clarence Darrow and Dudley Field Malone during a visit to New York. The image identifies the men left to right as Darrow, Malone, and Scopes.
Imperial Valley Press · 17 June 1925 · page 1
SCOPES AND HIS DEFENDERS
tion. Just wait until Billy gets a constitutional amendment adopted making evolution illegal and unconstitutional. Then you will whisper to a supposedly friendly pal, “Do you know, I really believe man ascended from lower forms of life”—your pal turns out to be an informer and, bingo, the judge commands, “Away with him—2o years at Leav enworth !” And off you go to spend the remainder of your life with the other crooks who carried evolution in their hip pockets. Uncle will have to increase the income tax to build more penitentiaries.
See moreSee less
Is that far-fetched? The present bootleg situation seemed far-fetched a few years ago. They have to boot leg evolution in Tennessee now, so far as public educa tional institutions are concerned. At any rate, Billy B, right before the opening of the trial, has emitted the threat of a constitutional amend ment. If adopted, the amendment would either be a prime joke or the opening of a new session of the dark ages. There are more wonders in the universe than Bryan’s mind is able to take in. He is lacking in vision and imagi nation, as well as positive knowledge. He actually believes that it is a duel between religion and evolution. Religion will suffer infinitely more if Bryan wins than if he loses. Darrow is not a typical evolutionist, and he could be made a good target by the antis. Evolutionists as a rule believe that things are evolving upward. Darrow believes things are going to the devil. He takes the negative in public debates on the question, “Is Life worth Living?” Opinion is pretty well divided as to the importance or unimportance of the trial. Some say it will be an epoch maker. Others say it is a farce. We cannot believe the wheels of progress will be turned back, no matter what the outcome of the trial may be. Science will be studied by all who are capable of comprehending it anyhow. INSISTS ON BEING SUCCESSFUL The usual happened. The plute papers printed a re port that the Detroit publicly-owned street railway was in terrible financial shape—and when the truth came along, it was found to be the opposite. The utility had made im provements without issuing bonds and creating an addi tional burden of interest for the public to pay. A private company would have issued bonds and increased its burden of debt. Had it proved to be a fact that the Detroit utility had accumulated a debt, it might not have been surprising in view of the fact that it carries passengers for an average fare of six and one-tenth cents, which is one of the low est rates in the entire country. It also pays the platform men wages which are the highest paid to street railway em ployes anywhere in the country except Chicago where the cost of living is higher.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
John Scopes, the Tennessee teacher charged under the state's anti-evolution law, has formally applied to return to his teaching job at Rhea County High School next term. Also noted: Governor Austin Peay says he will not testify at the trial unless compelled by legal process.
Evening Star · 17 June 1925 · page 3
SCOPES IS SEEKING FORMER POSITION
Darrow is not a typical evolutionist, and he could be made a good target by the antis. Evolutionists as a rule believe that things are evolving upward. Darrow believes things are going to the devil. He takes the negative in public debates on the question, “Is Life worth Living?” Opinion is pretty well divided as to the importance or unimportance of the trial. Some say it will be an epoch maker. Others say it is a farce. We cannot believe the wheels of progress will be turned back, no matter what the outcome of the trial may be.
See moreSee less
Science will be studied by all who are capable of comprehending it anyhow. INSISTS ON BEING SUCCESSFUL The usual happened. The plute papers printed a re port that the Detroit publicly-owned street railway was in terrible financial shape—and when the truth came along, it was found to be the opposite. The utility had made im provements without issuing bonds and creating an addi tional burden of interest for the public to pay. A private company would have issued bonds and increased its burden of debt. Had it proved to be a fact that the Detroit utility had accumulated a debt, it might not have been surprising in view of the fact that it carries passengers for an average fare of six and one-tenth cents, which is one of the low est rates in the entire country. It also pays the platform men wages which are the highest paid to street railway em ployes anywhere in the country except Chicago where the cost of living is higher. The utility has rebuilt 17 miles of track, built 19 miles of track into new territory, and established bus extensions of 42 miles. It has built 50 new cars in its own shops and bought 378 elsewhere. It has renewed about two-thirds of the overhead structure. All of which costs money. It was on May 15, 1922, when the city took over the lines and began to operate them. This experiment in municipal ownership is so successful that it shocks the sensitive nerves of plutes who are financially interested in having all public ownership experiments fail. Even under a hostile mayor the experiment insists on being successful. STATE INSURANCE Due to the activity of the Socialists in the state legis lature, the law relating to state life insurance has been changed so that the one thousand dollar limit has been taken off. The new provision is to the effect that a policy on one risk may be as high as one-half of one per cent of the total amount of insurance in force.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The report denies rumors that Edison would testify for the defense or that Bryan had hired Untermyer for the prosecution, and notes the ACLU added Charles H. Strong as an observer. It also mentions DeKalb County schools requiring teachers to state views on evolution before hiring.
Evening Star · 17 June 1925 · page 3
LAW VALIDITY MAIN POINT
DAYTON,TENN. Cbntlnued Frotf Page One. the Judge’s desk, drew slips from a hat and the sheriff summoned the men so picked from the first pane waiting in the room. When 13 men were drawn, Judge Raulston excused two who had served on a regular jury in the past two years and two more names were drawn from the hat. The new jury was assembled to re-indict Scopes, because, as Judge Raulston explained, there was some question as to the legality of the original indictment.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Attorney General A. T. Stewart said the constitutional question would be central to the upcoming trial of John T. Scopes in Dayton, set for July 10. He stated the State would argue the anti-evolution law is constitutional and within the legislature's authority.
Evening Star · 17 June 1925 · page 3
original indictment. Await New Indictment. Raulston then read the first chap ter of Genesis from a battered old Bible he brought to the courtroom. When he finished Raulston told the jury the question for them to decide was whether Scopes had vio lated the Tennessee anti-evolution law. He explained the separation of state and federal functions. He said he regarded the Scopes’ case as a “high misdemeanor and excep tionally serious because of its ex ample of law violation on the part *of a teacher. “It breeds a spirit of disrespect for law in our body politic,” he said.
See moreSee less
The charge was identical with that made to the grand jury on May 25 when Scopes was indicted. The judge then ordered the jury to retire to deliberate and at 10 a. m., ordered the court recessed until 11 o’clock. The room then exploded into noisy commotion as the audience stretched in their seats, got up to walk around, chattered and lit their pipes.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A gossip column notes that Kentucky newspapers are claiming John Scopes as 'our fellow citizen of Paducah,' comparing him to fellow Paducah native Irvin Cobb. The item reflects pre-trial anticipation of the Tennessee evolution case as a major news event.
Evening Star · 17 June 1925 · page 6
Take Second Adjournment. Atty. Gen. Stewart asked that the oid indictment be quashed and the judge so ordered it. Darrow addressed the court to In quire concerning prosecution plans, saying that he did not want to get defense witnesses here too early. Discussion ensued between Darrow, Stewart and Raulston as to how long it would take to pick the jury. Darrow said he expected it would take some time as he desired to get the impartial jury the law as sured them. The upshot of the colloqy was that Raulston ordered the sheriff to round up 100 veniremen and whacked his gavel down, adjourning court until 1:30 p. m., (Central standard time) when selection of the trial jury will start.
Clipping to come
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
The Rhea County Board of Education, meeting next week to select teachers for fall term, will temporarily set aside John Thomas Scopes's application to reclaim his old science teaching position. The report suggests his job status is uncertain pending the board's decision.
The Washington Daily News · 17 June 1925 · page 1
(Continued From Page sine) "f scientists tending I,. thill there is no eonlliel between ev>. hiti'm nml tlie Iiil.lt*. I think ii hut ri^lil Hint our position should aK,. l„. definitely stated iini] lli.-’t it might he understood that we intend to hack our liosithii us vigorously ns we Know how." t’ontiliuilig. he deelnred it to he hi understanding that Scopes would not
Clipping to come
The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.
Dayton's Progressive Club announces fixed room and board rates of $4 per day to prevent profiteering during the upcoming Scopes trial, with city commissioners regulating food prices. The courthouse is being expanded to seat 13,000 people, with outdoor loudspeakers and lawn seating for 5,000 more, and about 500 press credentials are being issued.
The Washington Daily News · 17 June 1925 · page 8
Dayton Ready for Crowd at Trial Rooms and Meals Available at Four Dollars a Day—Profiteering to Be Forbidden
which to base their contentions. Prosecution attorneys on the other hand consider tho case one in which only the question of whether or not John Thomas Scopes taught that, man descended from a lower form' of animal was Involved. Basing ’ their contention upon this view*, they have announced their Intention of making a supreme effort to prevent the trial from leaving the purely legal course and trailing into a re ligious and scientific controversy. The only Issue. Attorney General Stewart said last night, is whether or not Scopes taught that man de scended from a lower form of ani mal.
See moreSee less
Th? administration of oath to the jury* Monday, followed by the read ing of the indictment and the ar raignment of the defendant will ' bring the opposing counsel together , for their first real clash In the trial. Symptoms of such a clash were rathe objections of Mr Stewart to the Clarence Darrow In examining nroa
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
John T. Scopes is described as a local celebrity in Dayton, Tennessee, feted with banquets as he awaits his trial for teaching evolution. The article notes no signs of the case being dropped, with prosecution and defense preparing for the upcoming proceedings.
South Bend News-Times · 17 June 1925 · page 4
SCOPES POPULAR WITH TOWNSFOLK
„WKSTMAN STREET ilincie"te elalenge th* SU'S people tt Teanessss t* ----- —= they please and accordins to their own nense or responelhility and their own judgment as to what h harm ful and what is objectionable frem a Bible standpoint “The people of Tennessse have a right to protect the Bible an they understand it. They are not com palled to consider the interpreta tions placed upon it by people at other atates, whether Christians or scientists or both." Newspaper Is Heot After a day In which defense at torney. aa Dr. Neal described them, were “lawyers, with a poreibility of being orators Monday." the array of reprtsentatives of Scopes’ legal in terests, picnicked with newspaper
Clipping to come
The Daily Worker · Chicago, Ill.
The Tennessee bar association plans to ask the state's attorney general to refuse to prosecute the Scopes case if it reaches the supreme court, claiming Scopes was indicted by collusion. The report also notes Scopes was traveling from New York to Dayton and explained his choice of Clarence Darrow as attorney.
The Daily Worker · 17 June 1925 · page 1
35 Beyna is Wrong : " DAYTON, Tean., July 11— <1. N. 8.-John T. Scopes, youthful de fendant In the Tennomnes evolution kane, i not a hero in his father • eyes, but just a “food worthy boy. . The parental analysis was river the 24y ear-old school teacher by dad, Thomas. Scopes, a union la man of Padukah, Ky., in an ex claive interview today withInte national News Service. The r£e Reartily endorsed hla son’s position the tamous evotution controfers na
Clipping to come
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · Grand Rapids, Minn
The piece jokes that sensational figures like Clara Smith Hamon, Floyd Collins, and now J.T. Scopes get lucrative movie offers after notoriety. It claims Scopes was offered tens of thousands of dollars to appear in films but says he will decline.
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · 17 June 1925 · page 4
GET INTO THE MOVIES
JON T. SCOPES hr a fundamentalist to trial in Dayton, Tenn., on July 0 for 1 awim alone either. Sant Sang. her pareuts week-end with I at
Clipping to come
Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.
William Jennings Bryan, speaking to high school graduates in Miami, discussed science and religion and previewed themes he may use in prosecuting the Scopes evolution trial. He emphasized that education without religion can create moral menace, citing the Leopold-Loeb (Franks) case, and noted the upcoming July 10 trial date.
Edgefield Advertiser · 17 June 1925 · page 6
Bryan Discusses Evolution Case.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Pageland Journal · Pageland, S.C.
This is a mix of filler editorial items including jokes, postage complaints, and a brief snide comment on John T. Scopes facing trial for teaching evolution in Tennessee. It notes the irony that evolution is banned while the Bible is excluded from schools too, and predicts Scopes will gain notoriety regardless of the trial's outcome.
The Pageland Journal · 17 June 1925 · page 2
BY W. O. M’GEEHAN (Staff Correspondent of The 1V>1? York Herald-Tribune and The Mont gomery Advertiser) DAYTON, TENN., July 11.—Special to The Advertiser.—The crime wave hit Dayton today. It started with the ar rest of Loping Charlie, a local charac ter, so named because he always trav els at that gait. Loping Charlie was arrested for speeding as he passed Rob inson's Drug Store on Main street. It was his first offense and it Is attrib uted to the insidious poison of Evolu tion. The boldest and most desperate of the day’s crimes was the one committed by Asa Winn, a free thinker who had come down from the mountains lured by the prospect of^ mingling In the sat v urnalia predicted as a result of the evolution test.
See moreSee less
Asa Wells was caught thinking below' the deadline. The deadline for thought was estab lished here at the opening of the pro ceedings by agreement between the local sheriff and the visiting police from Chattanooga. The prohibited area starts from and includes the cottage w'here William Jennings Bryan resides. Even the free thinkers have respected the restricted area, where no thought is indulged in excepting in Scriptural terms. Crime Before BryaiTu House Of course, it was expected, that with an assemblage of lawless characters such as Clarence Darrow. Dudley Field Malone, Mencken and occasional sport i writers that a certain amount of think- ; lng would be going on. It would bo j impossible for the constabulary of Day ton, even though reinforced by Captain Marion Spencer’s men from Chatta- !
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
The article recounts a 1920 Democratic convention incident where Bainbridge Colby, soon to oppose Bryan at the Scopes trial, cleverly deflated Bryan's oratorical reputation before a restless crowd. It frames this as a historical precedent to Colby facing Bryan again in the Dayton evolution case.
The Seattle Star · 17 June 1925 · page 8
COLBY VS. BRYAN.
BY W. O. M’GEEHAN (Staff Correspondent of The 1V>1? York Herald-Tribune and The Mont gomery Advertiser) DAYTON, TENN., July 11.—Special to The Advertiser.—The crime wave hit Dayton today. It started with the ar rest of Loping Charlie, a local charac ter, so named because he always trav els at that gait. Loping Charlie was arrested for speeding as he passed Rob inson's Drug Store on Main street. It was his first offense and it Is attrib uted to the insidious poison of Evolu tion. The boldest and most desperate of the day’s crimes was the one committed by Asa Winn, a free thinker who had come down from the mountains lured by the prospect of^ mingling In the sat v urnalia predicted as a result of the evolution test.
See moreSee less
Asa Wells was caught thinking below' the deadline. The deadline for thought was estab lished here at the opening of the pro ceedings by agreement between the local sheriff and the visiting police from Chattanooga. The prohibited area starts from and includes the cottage w'here William Jennings Bryan resides. Even the free thinkers have respected the restricted area, where no thought is indulged in excepting in Scriptural terms. Crime Before BryaiTu House Of course, it was expected, that with an assemblage of lawless characters such as Clarence Darrow. Dudley Field Malone, Mencken and occasional sport i writers that a certain amount of think- ; lng would be going on. It would bo j impossible for the constabulary of Day ton, even though reinforced by Captain Marion Spencer’s men from Chatta- !
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
A farmer-like man near Seattle offers a homespun commentary on the Scopes evolution trial controversy in Tennessee, musing on Darwinism versus the Adam and Eve story. He frames the real issue as whether elected legislators or trained teachers should decide school curriculum.
The Seattle Star · 17 June 1925 · page 8
The leader of the mob was out spoken. ,JIt is the fault of Scopes. It is the first time there was any think ink going on below the deadline. Ho ought to be made an example of.” Only by making a show of force by waving their sticks did the police manage to convey the desperate thinker to the town jail. The united constabulary is now working on a plan to create a special thinking squad made up of veteran po licemen familiar with the tricks and devices of free thinkers.
See moreSee less
This squad will be on duty day and night for the duration of the evolution trial. There will be no saturnalia of thought ir Rhea county, Tennessee, if the authori ties can stop it by using every human endeavor possible. In an attempt to check the wave of lawlessness, Deck Carter, who claims ♦ he title of chapipion Bible reader of the world, was taken to the town limits and ordered not to come back. Of course, these proceedings were extra legal, as the boys would say, but they were deemed necessary for the. com munity. Deck Carter had showed a disposition to heckle Mr. William Jen nings Bryan and to challenge him to Bible demonstrations.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
An unnamed local man gives a rambling first-person opinion on the Scopes evolution controversy, arguing that teachers, not legislators or voters, should decide what is taught in schools. He reflects on trusting educated teachers over politicians like Bryan, while a separate unrelated insurance-policy item appears mixed into the same clipping.
The Seattle Star · 17 June 1925 · page 8
1 MR. McGEEHAN’S DAYTON LETTERS £ \V. O. McGeehan, the newspaper corre ' ^ spondent, whose stories are among the fea tures appearing in The Advertiser in con t* nection with the Dayton trial, is one of the <5 most brilliant newspaper writers on the * American press. He was sent to' Dayton by the New York Herald Tribune, of which 2 paper he is sports editor, to which position
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
John Scopes has returned to Dayton after visiting New York, saying his trial will benefit both churches and science. Darrow and other defense attorneys plan to arrive soon, while prosecutors consult Bryan about possibly adding Untermyer and Walsh, and the town prepares facilities for the expected crowds.
The Milwaukee Leader · 17 June 1925 · page 3
UNTERMYER AND WALSH MAY JOIN FIGHT ON SCOPES
1 MR. McGEEHAN’S DAYTON LETTERS £ \V. O. McGeehan, the newspaper corre ' ^ spondent, whose stories are among the fea tures appearing in The Advertiser in con t* nection with the Dayton trial, is one of the <5 most brilliant newspaper writers on the * American press. He was sent to' Dayton by the New York Herald Tribune, of which 2 paper he is sports editor, to which position
Clipping to come
The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska
John T. Scopes told reporters in Chattanooga that he is a Christian who believes in the Bible's divine inspiration and Jesus Christ's existence, while maintaining his belief in evolution. He noted the superintendent would only recommend a Fundamentalist for his teaching reinstatement.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 18 June 1925 · page 1
CHRISTIAN CHATTANOOGA, Tenn., June 18. —John T. Scopes, who goes on trial July 10, told reporters today: “I am a Christian and believe the Bible was Divinely inspired and that Jesus Chjist did exist.” He reiterated his belief that man evolved from lower animals anil pointed to the Bihle saying God created man in his own image but not exactly. Scopes ap plied yesterday for reinstatement. School Superintendent White an nounced he would recommend none but a Fundamentalist.
A brief news digest mentions Professor George Gilbert Murray of Oxford University condemning the prosecution of Professor J.T. Scopes in Tennessee for teaching evolution, calling it the most serious setback to civilization in history. The item appears alongside other unrelated news mentions of public figures.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 18 June 1925 · page 2
Mentioned in the News
(By Associated Press) DAYTON, Tenn., July 11.— Clarence Darrow, of counsel for John T. Scopes, in a statement late today accused the state’s legal rep resentatives in the prosecution of the Tennessee evolution case of making an effort to “run away from the facts” in their fight to prevent the introduction of expert testimony on science and religion. He charged that this effort is doubtless on account of their inabil * ity to “get any scientific man in the world to deny the facts that prove the correctness of evolu tion.
See moreSee less
1 The Chicago lawyer, associated with local attorneys who are defending the young Dayton biology teacher, directed his attack particularly against Wil liam Jennings Bryan, assisting the state in the prosecution, who has held that evolution and Christianity are Irreconcilable. "Millions of the ablest men in the • world, including a large proportion of students of religion, are both Christians and evolutionists,” Darrow asserted. "And among these are the ablests scien tists of the world.” The visiting counsel for Scopes further declared that the fact that any theory or scientific view may be con trary to any religious idea furnishes no right for a state to prohibit it. “If this were true," he said, "then most of astormomy and geology would fall under the ban.” Darro'w’s statement follows: s Questions Of Fact "There are two things necessary to crime under the Tennessee statue: One teaching the theory of creation conI trary to the divine account as recorded in Genesis, and one teaching that man evolved from the lower form of animal j life. These are purely questions of fact. ' “With one or two exceptions every j Juror in this case has stated he knows ! little or nothing about evolution. The < came thing could be said about almost any jury that would be assembled in any state in the union. As there are some thousand different religions and tome 50Q secta of Christians, naturally there is some difference of opinion on the divine account as taught in the j Bible. • "More than one account is given of ! the creation of man in the Bible and j these do not agree. Men have debated i a long time as to the meaning of much j in the Bible, and especially of the ! aocount of creation, and yet a Tennesj see Jury that has given no attention to evolution is supposed to know, first, ' what evolution is, and, sceondly, what : the Bible te&chea with reference to the j creation of man, and, third whether ' these theories and the account in the j Bible are in conflict. f Vvlil.nr. llal.l X’ "And Mr. Bryan says they ahould de- ! cide all this without evidence. It is i obvloua that no jury can accomplish 1 any such thing. "The effort to keep the defense from j offering evidence in this case is a plain j effort to run away from the facts and 1 ji is doubtless on account of their inabil I ity to get any scientific man in the t world to deny the facta that prove the f correctness of evolution. "This is further shown by the fact (Continued on Page Two)
Clipping to come
Seward Daily Gateway · Seward, Alaska
Correspondence pouring into Judge Raulston's desk expresses wishes the Bible be burned and never taught, ahead of the Scopes trial set for July 10. Attorney General Stewart's office is swamped with applications from lawyers nationwide seeking to join either side of the case.
Seward Daily Gateway · 18 June 1925 · page 1
WINCHESTER, Tenn., June IS. (/p) —Letters expressing the wish that the Bible be burned and never taught, were received in a mass of unsolicit ed correspondence coming to the desk of Judge Raulston, who presides at the trial of Scopes on July tenth. Attorney General Stewart’s mailbox is overloaded with applications from lawyers all over the country, asking permission to appear on one side or the other.
The report describes the Scopes defense team, including Dudley Malone and John Neal, and speculates that Charles Evans Hughes might assist, with a strategy to show no conflict between evolution and Genesis. It predicts Scopes will be convicted at Dayton but that the case will have lasting significance, with Bryan leading the prosecution.
Paris Express · 18 June 1925 · page 2
(By Associated Press) DAYTON, Tenn., July 11.— Clarence Darrow, of counsel for John T. Scopes, in a statement late today accused the state’s legal rep resentatives in the prosecution of the Tennessee evolution case of making an effort to “run away from the facts” in their fight to prevent the introduction of expert testimony on science and religion. He charged that this effort is doubtless on account of their inabil * ity to “get any scientific man in the world to deny the facts that prove the correctness of evolu tion.
See moreSee less
1 The Chicago lawyer, associated with local attorneys who are defending the young Dayton biology teacher, directed his attack particularly against Wil liam Jennings Bryan, assisting the state in the prosecution, who has held that evolution and Christianity are Irreconcilable. "Millions of the ablest men in the • world, including a large proportion of students of religion, are both Christians and evolutionists,” Darrow asserted. "And among these are the ablests scien tists of the world.” The visiting counsel for Scopes further declared that the fact that any theory or scientific view may be con trary to any religious idea furnishes no right for a state to prohibit it. “If this were true," he said, "then most of astormomy and geology would fall under the ban.” Darro'w’s statement follows: s Questions Of Fact "There are two things necessary to crime under the Tennessee statue: One teaching the theory of creation conI trary to the divine account as recorded in Genesis, and one teaching that man evolved from the lower form of animal j life. These are purely questions of fact. ' “With one or two exceptions every j Juror in this case has stated he knows ! little or nothing about evolution. The < came thing could be said about almost any jury that would be assembled in any state in the union. As there are some thousand different religions and tome 50Q secta of Christians, naturally there is some difference of opinion on the divine account as taught in the j Bible. • "More than one account is given of ! the creation of man in the Bible and j these do not agree. Men have debated i a long time as to the meaning of much j in the Bible, and especially of the ! aocount of creation, and yet a Tennesj see Jury that has given no attention to evolution is supposed to know, first, ' what evolution is, and, sceondly, what : the Bible te&chea with reference to the j creation of man, and, third whether ' these theories and the account in the j Bible are in conflict. f Vvlil.nr. llal.l X’ "And Mr. Bryan says they ahould de- ! cide all this without evidence. It is i obvloua that no jury can accomplish 1 any such thing. "The effort to keep the defense from j offering evidence in this case is a plain j effort to run away from the facts and 1 ji is doubtless on account of their inabil I ity to get any scientific man in the t world to deny the facta that prove the f correctness of evolution. "This is further shown by the fact (Continued on Page Two)
Clipping to come
Also printed in 2 papers
The Midland Journal · Rising Sun, Md. · 19 June 1925
The Harlem News · Harlem, Mont. · 26 June 1925
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A letter to the editor argues that Tennessee's law does not ban teaching evolution outright, but merely declines to fund instruction denying the Biblical creation account. The writer frames opposition to the law as "propaganda" and cites scripture to support distinctions between kinds of flesh.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 18 June 1925 · page 4
AS TO EVOLUTION "PROPAGANDA"
The eyes of the Nation rested on Dayton, Tenn., last week, and watched with interest as the preliminaries were completed and the trial of John Thomas Scopes, high school teacher, accused of teaching evolution, got un der way. William Jennings Bryan was on the stage for the prosecution, while Clarence Darrow of Chicago and Dudley Kield Malone of New York were playing leading parts in the de fense. The trial opened with the . quashing of an indictment against Scopes because of a technicality and his immediate reindictment by the grand jury.
See moreSee less
This delayed things for about an hour. The jury was then chosen, after its members emphati cally declared they either knew noth ing of evolution or that they had not' formed an opinion concerning its merits. Scopes is accused of having violated e law passed by the last Tennessee Legislature which prohibits the teach ing of evolution in the public schools. The trial is designed as a test case. There is little likelihood that it will result in a victory or defeat, as far as the theory of evolution is concerned. The only case in point is whether the
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A letter to the editor from Ed D. Rauner of Attalla, Alabama argues that if teaching evolution is unconstitutional, so too is mandating what must be taught, making uniform textbook laws equally suspect. He warns that forcing children to learn facts contrary to their parents' religious beliefs risks igniting a dangerous spread of secular propaganda.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 18 June 1925 · page 4
The eyes of the Nation rested on Dayton, Tenn., last week, and watched with interest as the preliminaries were completed and the trial of John Thomas Scopes, high school teacher, accused of teaching evolution, got un der way. William Jennings Bryan was on the stage for the prosecution, while Clarence Darrow of Chicago and Dudley Kield Malone of New York were playing leading parts in the de fense. The trial opened with the . quashing of an indictment against Scopes because of a technicality and his immediate reindictment by the grand jury.
See moreSee less
This delayed things for about an hour. The jury was then chosen, after its members emphati cally declared they either knew noth ing of evolution or that they had not' formed an opinion concerning its merits. Scopes is accused of having violated e law passed by the last Tennessee Legislature which prohibits the teach ing of evolution in the public schools. The trial is designed as a test case. There is little likelihood that it will result in a victory or defeat, as far as the theory of evolution is concerned. The only case in point is whether the
Clipping to come
New Britain Herald · New Britain, Conn.
Judge Raulston and Attorney General Stewart report being flooded with unsolicited mail, including lawyers seeking to join the case, ahead of the Dayton trial set for July 10. Scopes himself states he believes in both evolution and Christianity, seeing no conflict between them.
New Britain Herald · 18 June 1925 · page 13
MORE LOVE NOTES GIVEN LAWYERS
"leht of. explaining that the question Involved was the validity of the Ten nessee law prohibiting the teaching of evolution. . f ' '. ' "The questions Involve such', a case will be presented in the Scopes lyiralr.1' be declared, "are manifestly for thinkers and sane, sincere and loyal Americans. The line-np rertain I Iv has the color of 'fanaticism vs. tolerance.' " n a statement to newspapermen yesterday at ClinttanoogaV John'T." Scopes, the defendant, declared that while he was a believer In evolution, he also was a Christian and believed that the bible was dlvitily Inspired.
See moreSee less
He expressed the. opinion that there. -was no conruci oemii-u 1.... .... religion. ! Scopes' application for his old 'position as tcoclic-r in the Khea I county High school next term will ! not be acted upon until after the ! trial, it was stated. At tho same time, I Walter White, superintendent of schools, and prosecutor of the case, I said that he wouhl not recommend j any one as a teacher who was not tt fundamentalist.
A report claims that the spirit of Charles Darwin, communicating through a medium named Miss Louise Owen in London, has renounced evolutionary theory and now agrees mankind is of divine origin. The story frames this supposed spiritual message as arriving conveniently on the eve of the Scopes trial in Tennessee.
Evening Star · 18 June 1925 · page 10
lution and Decides That Bryan Is Right . On the eve of the Scopes trial in Tennessee, the spirit of Charles Dar win has entered the evolution con troversy which is about to challenge the attention of the world. Darwin "recants.” He takes it all back. He says man is not descended from the ape. Darwin is sorry that he spoke. He asks his followers to scrap the theory of evolution and accept the affirmation that mankind is of divine origin. The renunciation of the author of “The Origin of Species” appropriately reaches the United States byway of Great Britain, where Darwin was born.
See moreSee less
It arrived there by the spirit route. The recipient of his remorse ful communications is an English woman, Miss Louise Owen, who is now attracting widespread notice in London as the transmitter of regular spirit messages from the late Lord Northcliffe. Miss Owen was for 20 Winter of 1921-1922. country.
Judge Raulston and Attorney General Stewart report being swamped with unsolicited mail, many from cranks, ahead of the Dayton evolution trial. Scopes himself states he believes in both evolution and Christianity, seeing no conflict between science and religion.
Evening Star · 18 June 1925 · page 34
34 LETTERS BOMBARD EVOLUTION JUDGE
that he feared that the legal phase of the case was about to be lost sight of. explaining that the question involved was the validity of the Tennessee law prohibiting the teaching of evolution.
Fundamentalist attorneys met in Atlanta to prepare the prosecution of John T. Scopes, who faces trial in Dayton, Tennessee on July 10 for violating the state's anti-evolution law. William Jennings Bryan was set to meet with the attorneys to help outline the case.
.\ g ot | " “The, Dayton Ministers’, Association, sponsor of -the occasion, expects .a great throngs to attend the address tomorrow. of Bryan. “who . will speak ‘ at _the open air auditorium arranged op the_court house lawn. ° ‘
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Dayton, Tennessee expects up to 10,000 visitors including attorneys, scientists, and curiosity seekers for the upcoming trial of John T. Scopes over teaching evolution. The town is arranging special trains, buses, lodging at nearby resorts, and meals through churches and the high school cafeteria to accommodate the crowds.
The Washington Times · 18 June 1925 · page 1
10,000 Are Expected At Scopes Trial
By International News Service. This was made known today by ; the entertainment committee, which be utilized. is composed of Whitney Morgan and W. C. Wilbur. Five thousand people is all that Dayton can take care of at one time, it was pointed out, but the city is depending on nearby resorts to come to her as sistance.
Dayton, Tennessee residents are organizing housing and meals for the influx of visitors expected for the Scopes evolution trial, with churches and the high school cafeteria serving lunches. Meanwhile prosecution and defense attorneys continue preparations, with prosecution lawyers traveling to Atlanta to confer with William Jennings Bryan.
The Washington Times · 18 June 1925 · page 1
hold a conference with William Jennings Bryan tomorrow morning. ADVERTISEMENT Endless Caverns ■excursion, Sunday, June 21. >2.60 round trip. Southern Railway, 15rl0 H St. N. W. Adv.
Charles H. Strong, president of the Unitarian Laymen's League and secretary of the Association of the Bar of the City of New York, has been appointed to observe the upcoming trial of John T. Scopes. Scopes, a Dayton, Tennessee high school science teacher, faces prosecution on July 10 for teaching evolution.
The Washington Times · 18 June 1925 · page 8
CHURCH MEN GET BEHIND SCOPES
NEW YORK, June 18.—Charles H. Strong, president of the Uni tarian Laymen’s League, has been appointed by the executive com mittee of that organization to act as an observer at the trial of J. T. Scopes, the Dayton,, Tenn., high school instructor in science, who faces prosecution on July 10 for teaching evolution. Mr. Strong is secretary of the Association of the Bar of the City of New York.
The Fitzgerald Leader Enterprise and Press · Fitzgerald, Georgia
The article reports that the Unitarian Laymen's League, led by Charles H. Strong, will back John Scopes at his upcoming trial and may seek to intervene on his behalf. It notes that Scopes' attorneys are withholding details pending further strategy conferences, and that many religious groups intervening care less about science than about the state's right to dictate religious teaching.
The Fitzgerald Leader Enterprise and Press · 18 June 1925 · page 1
UNITARIANS FIGHT FOR FREE THOUGHT
Matthew Smith, Presbyterian pastor. “What is done at Dayton will have little effect either on Christianity or evolution.” “The Tennesse law against teach ing of evolution in my judgment is not only foolish but will also prove to be unconstitutional,” said Rev. Joseph Armistead, of the Christian denomination. "The Bible itself from the begin ning to Christ, was an evolution, and development from the lowest, to the highest.” Rev. Paul Judgon Morris, Baptist
Clipping to come
The Savannah Tribune · Savannah, Ga.
This opinion piece describes a Rollin Kirby cartoon mocking Bryan's anti-evolution stance, depicting a cave school with a 'no evolution' sign. It also criticizes Bryan's qualifications as prosecutor in the upcoming Scopes trial, calling him ignorant of evolutionary theory and pedagogy.
The Savannah Tribune · 18 June 1925 · page 3
THIS WEEK
Matthew Smith, Presbyterian pastor. “What is done at Dayton will have little effect either on Christianity or evolution.” “The Tennesse law against teach ing of evolution in my judgment is not only foolish but will also prove to be unconstitutional,” said Rev. Joseph Armistead, of the Christian denomination. "The Bible itself from the begin ning to Christ, was an evolution, and development from the lowest, to the highest.” Rev. Paul Judgon Morris, Baptist
Clipping to come
The Savannah Tribune · Savannah, Ga.
An opinion piece argues that Scopes clearly broke Tennessee's anti-evolution law and should be found guilty, but criticizes William Jennings Bryan for opposing evolution and intellectual freedom. The writer frames the case as a battle between scientific progress and ignorance.
The Savannah Tribune · 18 June 1925 · page 3
By ALLENE StTMNER XEA Service Writer. Tenn., July 11.—“The older a man gets and the more he sees of life the more he sees that only one thing in life counts—and that's Folks.” When Clarence Darrow. famous criminal lawyer, came down to Day ton to loo If the ground over where he will wage a war against William Jennings Bryan in defense of John T. Scopes, Indicted science teacher. he turned genial philosopher and lawyer." For a day and a night Darrow poked about the little town, baring his 'soul to whomsoever willed, and consenting to expound his theories f of life as learned for the past 68 years. « And through his every sentence runs his creed of “folks are all that counts."
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
Judge Godsey, counsel for John T. Scopes, presented a motion to quash the indictment charging violation of Tennessee's anti-evolution law, citing constitutional guarantees of religious freedom and vague wording. The item also notes that Bainbridge Colby, former Secretary of State, will join the defense team for Scopes.
John T. Scopes, set to stand trial in Dayton, Tennessee for teaching evolution in violation of state law, returned from New York. He stated his lead attorney Clarence Darrow would arrive in Dayton with his family later in the month.
The Daily Worker · 18 June 1925 · page 2
DAYTON, Tena., June 16,—John T. Soopee, who will go on trial here next month charged with violating the state anti-evolution law by teaohing evolution to his biology class in the Rhea oounty high school, returned hare from New York. Scopes declared that his chief attorney, Clarence Darrow, will arrive in Dayton on June
This article frames the upcoming Scopes trial as a national test case on the right to teach evolution, not merely a Tennessee legal dispute. It quotes Judge John Randolph Neal on the issue of free inquiry and notes that legislatures cannot legislate scientific truth, while introducing Judge John T. Raulston who will preside.
The Anderson News · 18 June 1925 · page 6
Scopes Trial for Teaching Theory of Evolution Is a Test Case for Our Nation
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Anderson News · Lawrenceburg, Ky.
This report discusses the broader implications of the Scopes trial, framing it as a national issue about the limits of legislative power over scientific truth. It presents multiple newspaper editorials and opinions on the constitutionality and wisdom of Tennessee's anti-evolution law, contrasting views from the New York World, Louisville Courier, Norfolk Virginian Pilot, and others.
The Anderson News · 18 June 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Anderson News · Lawrenceburg, Ky.
This item compiles editorial opinions from several newspapers—including the Norfolk Virginian Pilot and Philadelphia North American—criticizing or analyzing Tennessee's anti-evolution statute ahead of the Scopes trial. The pieces debate whether the law improperly mixes church and state and whether it violates individuals' right to seek truth and education.
The Anderson News · 18 June 1925 · page 6
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Reports indicate the Tennessee Bar Association may pass a resolution urging the attorney general to refuse prosecution of John Scopes, viewing the case as collusive and moot. Separately, the defense filed a motion to quash the indictment on constitutional grounds as legal maneuvering begins ahead of the Dayton trial.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 18 June 1925 · page 13
TENNESSEE LAWYERS OPPOSE SCOPES CASE
While nation-wide notables in law, science and religion do battle in the Scopes anti-evolution trial in Dayton, Tenn., street venders hope to reap a harvest selling souvenirs and trinkets. Upper photo shows salesman about to sell the crowd a gold plated fountain pen or something. At lower right Walter White, prosecutor, is looking up the law and cooling off between sessions. At left is the type of Daytonian from which the jury is chosen. T. Edgar Benson, the man shown, was pick* ing peaches when called for jury duty. T. SUBWAY LOCAL BANKERS
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Scopes' defense team filed a motion arguing the Tennessee law banning evolution instruction violates federal constitutional provisions, requiring Judge Raulston to first rule on constitutionality before any evidence is introduced. Dayton officials also prepared extra police and fire support from Chattanooga to handle the influx of visitors during the trial.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 18 June 1925 · page 13
IMPORTANT STEP
EVOLUTION # " (Continued from Page One'* would be absurd for Tennessee experts to advise the people of New York and Illinois as to what is helpful or harm- , ful, why is it not absurd to call experts from New York and Illinoisto chal lenge the right of the people of Ten nessee to legislate as they please and according to their own sense of respon sibility and their own judgment as to what is harmful and what is objection able from a Bible standpoint.” The airay of representatives for Scopes’ legal interests, pinicked with newspaper men in the afternoon, join ing a boat ride down the Tennessee liver in which the Chattanooga News was host to the visiting reporters.
See moreSee less
Members of prosecution counsel mot ored to a mountain resort near Dayton j in the late afternoon. Mr. Bryan has two engagements to- | moirow, the first to teach a Bible class i at Sunday school in the Methodist Epis copal church, South. In the afternoon he will conduct a union service in which all the Dayton churches are joining, speaking from the band stand in the yard of the court house. Members of the jury, evidently faith fully observed Judge Raulston’s in structions to avoid assembles, meet ings, or services where any discussion of the case might take place. Ten of the twelve who will decide the case live in the country, far removed frcm Dayton and they were at home. The two town representatives were follow ing their daily pursuits as if they were not to become famous Monday.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
John T. Scopes spoke to a New York audience, nervously explaining that his prosecution began as a casual 'soda water session' at Robinson's drug store in Dayton, Tennessee. He described being persuaded to let his biology teaching serve as a test case against the state's antievolution law, framing it as a fight for freedom of thought.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 18 June 1925 · page 5
SCOPES EXPLAINS HIS PART IN CASE
Darrow, Neal Satisfied. Clarence Darrow and John R. Neal expressed themselves as sat isfied with the jury. They knew they could not obtain 12 highly ed ucated men so they contented them selves with approving the 12 ear nest citizens of Rhea county, who declared they had an open mind on the evolution question. The crux of the trial will come in the argument over the admissi bility of ..scientific evidence con cerning evolution and religion. This is vital to the defense, for upon this testimony it hopes to prove that evolution must be regard ed as a subject that cannot, under the constitution of either Tennes see or the United States, be barred from the schools and hence the law which Scopes is accused of vio lating is invalid.
See moreSee less
Upon it, incidentally, depends the length of the trial. As one of the defense counsel put It, “if we are permitted to defend ourselves,” it will last three weeks or more; if the scientific testimonyof the 25 witnesses the defense has secured is barred, the trial will end quick ly after the prosecution introduces its evidence and arguments are heard.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
John Scopes described how the case began during a casual drugstore discussion in Dayton, Tennessee, where he agreed to let his teaching become a test case for the anti-evolution law. The defense team announced that Dudley Field Malone would have equal standing with Clarence Darrow, and former Senator Charles W. Thomas also offered his services.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 18 June 1925 · page 5
Bryan Changes Front. The defense was somewhat indig nant over what it termed Bryan’s change of front. In his address at the Acqua hotel Tuesday night he expressed a desire that the “mon ster” evolution, which has been fighting religion in the dark, be dragged at this trial into the light. It was construed by John R. Neal to mean that Bryan would in terpose no objection to the introduc tion of scientific testimony. They credit Bryan with the announce ment of Stewart that the prosecu tion will fight “determinedly" this evidence as irrelevant and incompe tent.
See moreSee less
Judge Raulston has asked both sides for opening statements as to how they intend to conduct their cases and what they hope to prove. Both sides were busy Saturday pre paring these statements, which will reveal the issue sharply and are certain to precipitate the;fight over scientific testimony.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The item reports that John T. Scopes turned down offers totaling over $150,000 from movie companies and newspaper syndicates. It praises his restraint as helping preserve the dignity of the upcoming Tennessee evolution trial.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 18 June 1925 · page 1
Bryan Changes Front. The defense was somewhat indig nant over what it termed Bryan’s change of front. In his address at the Acqua hotel Tuesday night he expressed a desire that the “mon ster” evolution, which has been fighting religion in the dark, be dragged at this trial into the light. It was construed by John R. Neal to mean that Bryan would in terpose no objection to the introduc tion of scientific testimony. They credit Bryan with the announce ment of Stewart that the prosecu tion will fight “determinedly" this evidence as irrelevant and incompe tent.
See moreSee less
Judge Raulston has asked both sides for opening statements as to how they intend to conduct their cases and what they hope to prove. Both sides were busy Saturday pre paring these statements, which will reveal the issue sharply and are certain to precipitate the;fight over scientific testimony.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The passage notes that the Dayton trial technically concerns only the constitutionality of a law, but Scopes' counsel may use it to either antagonize religious traditionalists or ease their distrust of science. It reports that the defense plans to argue evolution does not necessarily conflict with biblical teachings.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 18 June 1925 · page 1
Darrow. CHINESE STRIFE BEING TAKEN IIP IN CONFERENCE President and Secretary Kellogg in Week-end Meet. BY DALE VAN EVERY (United Press Correspondent) SWAMPSCOTT, MUi.-A week end conference, expected to have
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The piece discusses a motion by Judge J. F. Godsey to quash the indictment against John Scopes, arguing the Tennessee anti-evolution law is unconstitutional. It analyzes the legislature's power over public school curricula and predicts Scopes will likely be fined $100 unless the law is found to violate religious liberty guarantees.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 18 June 1925 · page 6
SPRINGFIELD, THURSDAY. JUNE IT, 1925 The Main Point in Tennessee No New York or Chicago lawyer is needed in the Scopes case, if the trial is to be a lawsuit. Judge J. F. Godsey of Tennessee, in entering a motion in the circuit court to quash the indictment, goes straight to the point of the legal controversy. “The ‘act, which is the basis of the in " ‘dictment and which the defendant is ‘charged with violating,” says the motion, “is unconstitutional and void ‘in that it violates the constitution ‘of Tennessee.” The motion raises other points .with the view to an appeal to the federal courts in case the evolution law is sustained by the state courts.
See moreSee less
But the legal battle is obviously to be fought over the question whether the Tennessee constitution warrants a statute penalizing anyone who ex pounds a theory in the public schools that is contrary to the teaching of Genesis concerning the origin of man. Unless it can be shown that the evolution statute infringes on theconstitutional guaranty of re ligious liberty and establishes a re straint on teaching in the interest of a certain religious belief, which enjoys no special constitutional priv ilege, the chances would seem to place Mr Scopes eventually under the necessity of paying SIOO fine. , A legislature has large powers over education, especially in the pub lic schools. In this state the Legisla ture enacted not long ago that in ■struction concerning the constitution should be given in the schools. Obviously it may dictate to that ex tent. If it may require that certain subjects shall be taught, it may re quire that certain subjects shall not . be taught. But in all such legisla tion, constitutional guaranties must be respected. The Tennessee evolu tion law is vulnerable in that it essays to establish belief in the biblical story of the creation of man as a kind of state religion and to stigmatize the theory of evolution as necessarily antireligious and therefore contrary to public policy. That the theory of evolution is in no degree antagonistic to true re ligion will now be affirmed by a host of respected and eminent religious 5 teachers. One of the most striking ■ testimonies of this character comes . -from the distinguished editor of the Catholic Encyclopedia, who says that the Roman church, while not re garding the evolution theory as
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
An editorial argues the Tennessee evolution statute may violate religious liberty guarantees by establishing biblical creation as a quasi-state religion. It cites religious authorities, including a Catholic Encyclopedia editor, who argue evolution is not inherently antireligious.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 18 June 1925 · page 6
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A New York Times report describes a 1924 Nebraska case where teacher David S. Domer sued Lutheran congregation members for defamation after they accused him of teaching evolution and being unfit to teach. The jury awarded him $5,675 in damages, ruling that belief in evolution did not prove moral or mental unfitness.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 18 June 1925 · page 12
A NEBRASKA EVOLUTION CASE
Robinson’s drug store (right), town forum of Dayton, Tenn., witnessed the beginning of the Scopes case. 4 Above are * the "conspirators” just as they were the afternoon Scopes’ indictment was "framed.” Seated: H. E.
Clipping to come
The Carbon County News · Red Lodge, Mont.
This article, published weeks before the trial began, frames the Scopes case as a national test of human freedom to inquire into truth, not merely a Tennessee matter. It includes commentary from William Jennings Bryan and opposition figures like Judge John Randolph Neal on the legal and philosophical stakes of legislating against teaching evolution.
The Carbon County News · 18 June 1925 · page 1
SCOPES TRIAL FOR TEACHING THEORY OF EVOLUTION IS A TEST CASE FOR NATION
ancestor of man. Evolution goes much farther back than Charles Darwin. That all living organisms have been derived by gradual evolution from simpler forms was an idea pro posed by the ancient Greeks. In the thousands of years that have followed many have conjectured at the mechanism that might have pro duced this evolution. But not until the later years of the ■eighteenth century and the beginning of the nineteenth century did any thinkers base their explanations of evolution on actual observations. Among these early thinkers there stand out the names of Buffon.
See moreSee less
Erasmus Darwin, grandfather of Charles, Lamarck and Goethe, who was a great biolo gist as well as a great poet. Charles Darwin's name le asso ciated with evolution more strongly than any other because he popular ized it, and because he was the cen-, ter of an evolution controversy sim ilar in some respects to tho Scopes ( case, that was stirred up in England half a century ago. Since Darwin’s time his 1 ’eas have been modified and much has been added to them. His greatness as a scientist remains unqual'ied. As one scientist says: "Science always Is changing as new researches are made. It is no more to be expected that Darwin should have been en tirely right than that the ancient Greeks should have been entirely right, nor Is it to be expected that modern science is entirely right." From .Main Stem, Branches.
Clipping to come
The Carbon County News · Red Lodge, Mont.
This item compiles editorial opinions from various newspapers and public figures like George Bernard Shaw and William Jennings Bryan on the Tennessee anti-evolution law. It presents multiple viewpoints on academic freedom, taxpayer rights over school curricula, and the relationship between compulsory education and individual rights to seek truth.
The Carbon County News · 18 June 1925 · page 1
Quash Indictments in Evolution Trial. } _ DAYTON. Tenn.. July 13.—Tlu evolution trial, the case against Prof John T. Scopes, resumed this forenoon over arguments. The Court overruled the defense I motion to quash the indictment. The defense cited fourteen reason? for quashing, largely alleging un constitutionality of the law against evolution and errors in the indict ment Tile attorneys referred at length to sections of the constitution re specting religious freedom. The defense announced 20 prom inent scientists and educators were enroutc here or expected as wit nesses. These witnesses include Shealor Matthews, Dean of the Di vinity School of the University oi Chicago.
Clipping to come
The Carbon County News · Red Lodge, Mont.
The article presents arguments between Fundamentalists and their opponents over whether taxpayers have the right to dictate curriculum, including teaching of evolution, and distinguishes atheism from agnosticism. It also introduces Judge John T. Raulston, who will preside over the upcoming Scopes trial, with Bryan for the prosecution and Darrow for the defense.
The Carbon County News · 18 June 1925 · page 1
Makes Protest. DAYTON, Tenn., July 13.—Rev. Howard Gale Byrd, yesterday with drew from the pastorate of the Methodist Episcopal Church, when the large congregation protested aaginst Rev. Charles Francis Pot ter, Modernist minister of New York, taking the pulpit. Dr. Potter proposed an evolution sermon. Rev. Byrd called off three regular Sunday preaching services and announced: “I have quit. I have not resigned. I have quit.”
Clipping to come
The Carbon County News · Red Lodge, Mont.
This fragment discusses arguments around the Scopes Trial, including claims that private and parochial schools would remain free to teach evolution regardless of the ruling. It frames the core issue as whether individuals have a natural right to seek truth and form their own judgments on topics like evolution, economics, religion, and history.
The Carbon County News · 18 June 1925 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Lambertville Record · Lambertville, N.J.
The piece discusses the upcoming Dayton, Tennessee trial of a teacher who taught evolution, using it as a springboard to question biblical literalism by asking who Cain's wife could have been. It concludes that evolution and Christianity are compatible, citing a scientist's claim that man descended from apes.
The Lambertville Record · 18 June 1925 · page 2
WHO WAS CAIN’S WIFE? The present controversy over the approaching trial in Dayton, Tenn. of the teacher who supports the theory of the evolution of man
The report notes that John T. Scopes plans to file a motion to quash his indictment, arguing that Tennessee's anti-evolution statute violates both state and federal constitutions. This is one of many brief items in a roundup of world news.
The Weekly Exponent · 18 June 1925 · page 7
EVOLUTION TO THE FRONT. We presume there is about as much interest in the trial of John T. Scopes the Tennessee school teacher, which started last Friday, as in any case be fore the public or courts for many years. But as we stated heretofore, it does not seem possible that the ends aimed at by both the prosecutor and the defenders—the determination of whether it is right to teach evolution in the public schools—can be reached. Possibly those lawyers who are bent on gaining immense publicity as oppo nents or proponents of evolution can
Clipping to come
The Pickens Sentinel · Pickens, S.C.
A photo caption identifies Judge John T. Raulston of Rhea County, Tennessee, who is presiding over the trial of Professor Scopes for teaching evolution in Dayton's high school. It notes William Jennings Bryan is assisting the prosecution while Clarence Darrow leads the defense.
The Pickens Sentinel · 18 June 1925 · page 4
EVOLUTION TO THE FRONT. We presume there is about as much interest in the trial of John T. Scopes the Tennessee school teacher, which started last Friday, as in any case be fore the public or courts for many years. But as we stated heretofore, it does not seem possible that the ends aimed at by both the prosecutor and the defenders—the determination of whether it is right to teach evolution in the public schools—can be reached. Possibly those lawyers who are bent on gaining immense publicity as oppo nents or proponents of evolution can
Clipping to come
The Pickens Sentinel · Pickens, S.C.
A small-town South Carolina newspaper's humor column makes a passing joke about Tennessee teacher Scopes believing he descended from an ape. The rest of the item is unrelated local jokes about chickens, legislature, and Wall Street.
The Pickens Sentinel · 18 June 1925 · page 2
Prof. Scopes, a Tennessee school teacher, thinks he descended from a will discover that there are some mighty fine people in the newspaper business. Speaking of the bow-legged
An editorial reprinted from another paper discusses Bryan's argument that taxpayers who fund schools have the right to dictate what is taught, including banning evolution. It argues the anti-evolution law may be hard to overturn in court, citing a recent Supreme Court ruling on parental rights over schooling as analogous support for state control of curriculum.
The Pickens Sentinel · 18 June 1925 · page 2
“If the people and the legislature saw fit to prohibit the teaching of music in public schools, or geogra phy or physiology or any other sub ject, it is hard to see how they could ae denied such a right of self-de termination. From this standpoint, t appears to some that the effort to ight the anti-evolution law through fie courts has a fine chance of fail ire. “The Supreme Court has just held n the Oregon case that parents have fie undisputed right to send their fiildren to schools whose corriculum ind courses of study please them.
See moreSee less
A ornollary of this view would seem o be that people who own and main ain schools may specify subjects of tudy. A contrary decision might ,ave far-reaching consequences. Who rill control schools if the owners annot ? How else could we secure he stability of corruculums and chool policies upon which parents ase their choice of schools? “Rather than resort to a doubtful »gal test, the advocates of liberal iews in the teaching of science hould carry their case directly to the i eople in Tennessee. They should j Lrive to convince them by regular lental processes of the value of leir teachings in the scientific study.
John T. Scopes, a biology teacher at Dayton, Tennessee high school, is on trial for violating the state's 'monkey law' by teaching evolution. The report notes the case is being watched nationally as a test case.
The Pickens Sentinel · 18 June 1925 · page 1
John ,-T. Scopes, professor of biology at Dayton, Tenn. high school, on trial there for viQlating the "monkey-law” — or, charged with teaching the theory of evolu tion. It is a test case watched with a great deal of interest throughout the country.
The piece reflects on the Scopes evolution trial in Dayton, Tennessee, suggesting it began as a local joke that newspapers blew out of proportion into a worldwide sensation. It argues the jury's verdict will be meaningless since most jurymen won't understand evolution, framing the whole affair as public diversion.
The Chesterfield Advertiser · Chesterfield C.H., S.C.
This editorial discusses the Tennessee Scopes trial over teaching evolution, framing it as a national issue touching on human freedom and the conflict between evolutionary theory and the Genesis creation story. It quotes Judge John Randolph Neal opposing restrictions on inquiry and William Jennings Bryan defending fundamentalist views against evolutionary theory.
The Chesterfield Advertiser · 18 June 1925 · page 1
SCOPES TRIAL A TEST CASE FOR THE NATION
possible to prove by legislative en. actment the truth or falsity of evo lution as it would be to pass a law that would definitely establish th£ truth or falsity of gravitation. What is, is, and no legal pronouncements cat make otherwise. The question raised involves the right of the human being to try to learn the truth re garding the origin of life. Of course ia so far as inquiry presupposes doubt, the issue embracesJthe ques tion of agnosticism, in that the theory of evolution necessarily runs Counter to the Genesis story of the creation.
See moreSee less
Judge John Randolph Neml, of KnokvOle, Teon., states hia posi tion in the controversy in this way: “We regard it as equally un-Ameri <U and therefore unconstitutional, 'whether it is kingly or ecclesiastical autherty or legislative power that would attempt to limit the human 'And in its enquiry after truth.” On the other side of the fence stands the statement of William Jen* ulngs Bryan, arch fo0 of tho evolu tionary theory. “This” says Mr. Bryan “is one of the greatest ques , rioas ever raised—the question of the people who created them. If not they, then who? The Fundamentalists are trying to establish the doctrine that the taxpayer her a right to say what shall be tapgSt—the taxpayers and not the scientist* -rCan a.handful of scientists rob your chi? l»*n of religion and turn them out atheists?” Rebuttal then advances this argu ment :Even though the theory of evolution be true and be finally ac cepted by the people as against the Story of the Genesis those who might accept the truth could not be con sidered atheists. They point, too, to the wide divergence between-s. athe-1
The Chesterfield Advertiser · Chesterfield C.H., S.C.
The passage presents competing viewpoints on evolution, agnosticism, and compulsory education, featuring statements from Judge John Randolph Neal and William Jennings Bryan on opposite sides of the controversy. It also identifies Judge John T. Raulston as presiding over the Scopes trial, with Bryan aiding prosecution and Clarence Darrow leading the defense.
The Chesterfield Advertiser · 18 June 1925 · page 1
Story of the Genesis those who might accept the truth could not be con sidered atheists. They point, too, to the wide divergence between-s. athe-1 ism and agnosticism. | Another viewpoint: there does not appear to be any particular quarrel with Mr. Bryan* basic theory that the taxpayers have a right to set up schools, and to govern the school curriculum. It is only when this is coupled with'legislation making edu cation compulsory that the right of the individual to seek truth becomes abridged. On the one hand it i* said compulsory education does not neces sarily involve study only in public schools. Parochial and sectarian and
The Chesterfield Advertiser · Chesterfield C.H., S.C.
The report describes the ongoing trial of John T. Scopes, a Dayton, Tennessee teacher charged with violating the state law against teaching evolution. It notes Judge Raulston presiding, with William Jennings Bryan assisting the prosecution and Clarence Darrow leading the defense, and discusses the broader argument over the right to knowledge and truth.
The Chesterfield Advertiser · 18 June 1925 · page 1
I The crux of the argument appears to hang on the natural right of the human species to seek the truth, to be informed on the thpqght of {he i world and be given th< <bfrty then to exercise their awn judgment*)* the forming of opinions, and whether ’the Tennessee statute pilaws that right. This applies to economic a, to retigfcn, to history, indeed to all bases of human knowledge, including' the Vheory of evolution. ’ ________ .
An advertisement promotes a Washington Bureau bulletin covering arguments for and against evolutionary theory, timed to the upcoming Tennessee trial. It invites readers to send five cents for a copy covering both the pro and con sides of the debate.
The Seattle Star · 18 June 1925 · page 8
Evolution—Pro and Con ] P THE subject that Is uppermost in the news today: what do we know about 1t? TDoes the evolutionist say woe are descended from mon keya? If not, what does he say? Does the 'hnory of evolution precludo a bellef In creation by CGod? What are the arguments that will bae used In the big trial In Tennessee? What does Willlam J, Bryan have . to say on the subject? | 'Eu-r-Wnnhlnglon bureau has ready for you a bulletin on the subject, glving BOTH SIDES of the question, Tt gives briefly and simply the - main arguments for and agalnst the theory of evolution and especially the theory that man evolved from lower forms of life.
See moreSee less
Whichever slde of the argument you may personally take, this bulletin glves YOUR gide and the OTHER side. il out the coupon below and mall to Washington, D, C,, as directed,
A letter to the editor discusses the Scopes anti-evolution law alongside other quirky Tennessee legal provisions, such as a near-miss bill barring Jews from teaching and constitutional bars on ministers and atheists holding office. The writer speculates Tennessee will have plenty of legal controversies to resolve even after the Scopes case concludes.
The Seattle Star · 18 June 1925 · page 8
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The article explains that England experienced its own evolution controversy 65 years before the Scopes trial, beginning with Darwin's 1859 publication of 'Origin of Species'. It notes that Cambridge and Oxford were particularly opposed to teaching evolution, and clarifies that Darwin did not claim man descended from monkeys but that life evolved from simpler forms.
The Seattle Star · 18 June 1925 · page 8
England Beat Us by 65 Years to Evolution Row
BY WILLIAM PHILIP SIMMS MOH'!‘ of us have an ides Ten. nikdbe I pulling & new one on us when she objects to evolution being taught in her
The piece argues the Tennessee anti-evolution law matters to the Labor movement because it sets a precedent for state-dictated dogma beyond religion and science, potentially extending to unionism, art, and socialism. It calls the law worse than medieval or Puritan religious statutes.
The Milwaukee Leader · 18 June 1925 · page 14
Shows Different Inter pretations. J.y 7h9 Asm-Mated Pi ess, Court Room, Dayton, Tenn., July 13. Discussion of a motion by the defense to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, charged with violating the Tennessee law against inc teaching of evolution theories in the public schouls occupied the iorenoon session of court today, Presenting the motion, John P..
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
This editorial argues that the Tennessee law and prosecution of John T. Scopes represent a dangerous return to medieval-era suppression of free inquiry. It invokes scientific pioneers like Newton and Edison to argue that legislating truth is a repudiation of human progress, urging the labor movement to fight this 'revival of medievalism.'
The Milwaukee Leader · 18 June 1925 · page 14
oped between the attorney general. A. T Stewart, and Clarence Darrow and again between Ben G. McKn ie and Dudley Field Malone. Neither seriously ruffled the calm ot the court.
Clipping to come
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
This item introduces John T. Scopes, a Dayton, Tennessee biology teacher facing trial for violating the state's 'monkey law' against teaching evolution. It includes editorial opinions from several newspapers debating the constitutionality and implications of the law for academic and religious freedom.
Eagle River Review · 18 June 1925 · page 1
AFTER TRUTH By Edward Percy Howard Tennessee’s battle over the right to teach the theory of evolution in the public schools has now engaged the serious attention of all civilized thinking peoples. It is contended in some quarters that the whole ques tion of human freedom and develop ment is wrapped up in the issue. The question is of importance not only ip Tennessee or Florida or Oklahoma or
This item compiles editorial opinions from various newspapers and public figures on the Tennessee anti-evolution law ahead of the Scopes trial. It includes views from the Norfolk Virginian Pilot, Philadelphia North American, George Bernard Shaw, Judge John Randolph Neal, and William Jennings Bryan on the constitutionality and implications of regulating evolution teaching.
Eagle River Review · 18 June 1925 · page 1
OPINIONS
1 origin of life. Of course in so far as inquiry presupposes doubt, the issue embraces the question of agnosticism in that the theory of evolution neces, sarily runs counter to the Genesis story of the creation. Judge John Randolph Neal, of Knox ville, Tenn., states his position in thq controversy in this way: “We regard it as equally un-American and there fore unconstitutional, whether it is kingly or ecclesiastical authority or legislative power that would attempt to limit the human mind in its enquiry after truth.” On the other side of the fenca stands the statement of William Jem nings Bryan, arch foe of the evolution ary theory.“ This” says Mr. Bryan “is
The passage presents competing viewpoints on the Tennessee anti-evolution statute, contrasting arguments about free inquiry versus taxpayer control of school curricula. It explores Bryan's position that taxpayers should control what is taught, countered by arguments about the right to seek truth and inconsistencies in compulsory education enforcement.
Eagle River Review · 18 June 1925 · page 1
Another viewpoint: There does not appear to be any particular quarrel with Mr. Bryan’s basic theory that the taxpayers have a right to set up schools, and to govern the school cur riculum. It is only when this is coup led with legislation making education compulsory that the right of the in dividual to seek truth becomes abridge ed. On the one hand it is said com pulsory education does not necessarily § involve study only in public schools. Parochial and sectarian and private schools are still left as the unhamper, ed media through which evolution or any other theory of life or conduct be taught.
See moreSee less
Other controversalists say this is not a practicable answer in that it would create a monetary stan dard of education. Were evolution demonstrated or accepted as the true principle of life, then such knowledge would be barred to the poor: Indeed they) would be compelled to learn only the story of Genesis, correct or incorrect. The crux of the argument appears hang on the natural right of the
John T. Scopes is being flooded with advice from New York liberals about who should defend him in his upcoming trial for teaching evolution. Debate centers on whether to accept Clarence Darrow and Dudley Field Malone, or instead choose a more religiously neutral figure like Charles Evans Hughes, with Scopes himself appearing undecided.
Pinedale Roundup · 18 June 1925 · page 4
TOO MANY COOKS MAY SPOIL BROTH - TENNESSEE LAW VIOLATOR IS RECEIVING ADVICE FROM ALL PARTS OF NATION
IBs PTtlc & Atl.wtil Wouldn't this fl-year-old hairy chap, an inhabitant of the Zulu islands, make an impressive stir iBsRinfipnthnu if he. were introduced as an ex- "Read your Bible!" says the sign in Dayton, pointed out by F. E. hibit in the evolution trial at. Robinson, Police Chief Frazicr and B. L. Morgan (1. to r.),
Clipping to come
Pinedale Roundup · Pinedale, Wyo.
A report on a Civil Liberties Union luncheon where John Scopes and backers debated whether to accept Clarence Darrow and Dudley Field Malone as defense counsel, amid concerns about Darrow's atheism and the Leopold-Loeb case. Scopes expressed hope that outside help would be approved, and scientist Henry Fairfield Osborn declined to testify but agreed to advise the defense.
Pinedale Roundup · 18 June 1925 · page 4
fly thp Associated Press. COURTROOM, DAYTON, Tenn.. July 13. —Discussion of a motion by the defense to quash the indictment against John T. Scopes, charged with violating the Tennessee law against the teaching of evolution theories in the public schools, occupied the morn ing session of court today. . Presenting the motion, John R. j Neal spoke first for the defense, folj lowed by Arthur (5. Hays, presenting ! the same contention. Former Attor- ! ney General B. G. McKenzie spoke in i opposition to the motion, with Sue j K. Hicks, also of the State counsel, i making the last argument before the j
Clipping to come
The Saratoga Sun · Saratoga, Wyo.
A brief news item reports that Clarence Darrow, Chicago criminal lawyer, and Bainbridge Colby, former secretary of state, have been chosen to assist in the defense of John T. Scopes, the Dayton, Tennessee teacher charged with violating the state law against teaching evolution. This appears amid a roundup of unrelated general news items.
The Saratoga Sun · 18 June 1925 · page 6
Other than reading of the indict-1 nient and questioning of a juror as j to whether he had expressed an opin ion as to the guilt or innocence of the defendant, the first hours of the day’s first session were uneventful. A mild clash of attorneys developed between the attorney general, A. T. Stewart, and Clarence Darrow, and again between Ben G. McKenzie and Dudley Field Malone. Neither seri ously ruffled the calm of the court. Mr, Neal, submitting the motion to quash, cited 14 reasons selected by the defense on which to base the motion. The contentions were nearly all re-1 lated to the constitutionality of the i
Clipping to come
The Midland Journal · Rising Sun, Md. · and 1 other paper
A newspaper photo caption describes the courthouse in Dayton, Tennessee, where the Scopes evolution trial will be held in July. It appears alongside images of the new solicitor general and President Coolidge's trip to St. Paul.
The Midland Journal · 19 June 1925 · page 2
Other than reading of the indict-1 nient and questioning of a juror as j to whether he had expressed an opin ion as to the guilt or innocence of the defendant, the first hours of the day’s first session were uneventful. A mild clash of attorneys developed between the attorney general, A. T. Stewart, and Clarence Darrow, and again between Ben G. McKenzie and Dudley Field Malone. Neither seri ously ruffled the calm of the court. Mr, Neal, submitting the motion to quash, cited 14 reasons selected by the defense on which to base the motion. The contentions were nearly all re-1 lated to the constitutionality of the i
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Paris Express · Paris, Ark. · 18 June 1925
The Midland Journal · Rising Sun, Md. · and 1 other paper
The passage describes plans for the upcoming Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee, noting the defense team including Clarence Darrow, Bainbridge Colby, and Dudley Malone, with a possible role for Charles Evans Hughes. It outlines the defense's strategy to argue no conflict between evolution and the Bible, while predicting Scopes will likely be convicted at trial before a larger legal battle ensues.
The Midland Journal · 19 June 1925 · page 2
cies working toward his upiift. ‘‘lf, in the processes of millions of years we have come to the point in evolution where man may reach out and grasp immortality, or may reject and refuse immortality, it is indeed true that we are dwelling between two eternities, past and future. “There is one clear call in Christ’s message—it is a call to hear, to see, to know, to advance, to reach out, to seek God. In His message I find no call to close the eyes or shut the ears to the things that reason may discern.
See moreSee less
“When scientists have solved all the problems of life, when they are able to take the protoplasm and de velop it into a full-grown man, it will be time enough for the scientists to begin dogmatizing instructions in the ways of life. When they can form the protoplasm from which life springs, then it will be time enough for them to deny that God was needed in crea tion.”
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Paris Express · Paris, Ark. · 18 June 1925
The Alaska Daily Empire · Juneau, Alaska
John T. Scopes, the Tennessee teacher indicted for violating the anti-evolution law, traveled to New York with Dr. John R. Neal of Knoxville. There they consulted with attorneys from the American Civil Liberties Union, who would assist in his defense.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 19 June 1925 · page 8
Who Scopes Confers with Counsel
* John T. Scopes fright), the Tennessee high school teacher who was indicted for violation of the anti evolution law, and Dr. John Ri Neal, of Knoxville, Tenn.. went, to New York to consult with attorneys! for the American Civil Liberties Union, who will aid in the profe c, ^ defense. To Wed At last NAVAL RESERVE TEAM AND CITY SQUAD TO PLAY i Sailor Ball Team lo Play