As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

February 1911

15 articles

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

An article decrying the slaughter of herons and egrets for the plume trade notes that wild pigeons, once abundant in Pennsylvania and other Northern states twenty-five years earlier, are now never seen at all. The passenger pigeon's disappearance is invoked as a cautionary parallel to warn against the extinction of egrets through unchecked plume hunting.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 1 February 1911 · page 3

South again they r.r. to be killed vvli'd. sale as In tb-vrgia and tin t'arolin.:.-. Twenty-live years ago wild pigeons wen abundant in Penn sylvania. as well as in other Northern States: today the; are never sia-n. Northern visitors, whose opinions are influential In Kloiida, nn put a st-'p to the slaughter of the heron and tile egret by merely declining to pur-j i-haso or to wear the plumage whose i|iiest nu-ans the annual sacrifice of | thousands of these beautiful birds and the eventual extinction of their spe ed ".—Philadelphia Public Ijeilger.

See the clipping

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

An Audubon society agent argues that America's patchwork of state game laws failed to protect migratory species like the passenger pigeon and Eskimo curlew until too late. He calls for centralized federal control over migratory bird protection as the best solution going forward.

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 1 February 1911 · page 7

MIGRATORY BIRDS.

he recognize in the sum of SIOOO for his tor at the college this morning. He eamo The tickets are selling well and no appearance m April term of court to to Durham for a consultation in regard doubt a full house will be in attendance. be held at ter. At last reports the to a proposed publication of a new jourSelections will be furnished by the high to protect theém. The framers of the con stitution showed no forethought regarding the protection of our natural resources but left the matters to posterity.

See moreSee less

Our game laws were evolved at haphazard by the people of the different states, and so there came about a heretogenous jumble of confiicting statutes, continually juggles, and arranged not so much te protect the game and birds as to x})lrotect the righés of certain classes In unting then. This hodge-podge of game laws, applied to states on to counties, towns, streams, lakes, bays or shqres only gave real pro tectian to certain kinds of resident game untll recent years. The people never see the necessity of protecting a migratory pird unti}l’ the species is nearly extinct, and some:imes not even then. Real pro tective laws for the passenger pigeon and the wild turkey were enacted in a few states after the birds were practically gone. The great flocks of the Eskimo curlew have passed away, and when they were nearly extinct a few states gave them a little protection. These birds were extirpated before the people realized the danger and no public sentiment was arous e,dngor their protection until it was too

See the clipping

The Bridgeport Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.

An Audubon Society writer argues U.S. game laws were a disorganized, state-by-state patchwork that failed to protect migratory species until too late, citing the passenger pigeon and Eskimo curlew as birds driven to extinction before real protection laws existed. He credits recent federal involvement, like the Biological Survey, hunting licenses, and anti-spring-shooting laws, with finally moving toward more uniform conservation policy.

The Bridgeport Evening Farmer · 2 February 1911 · page 7

MIGRATORY BIRDS

He would have compelled us to pro tect them. The framers of the con stitution showed no forethought re garding the protection of our nation al resources, but left such matters to posterity. Our game laws were evolved at haphazard by the people of the different states and so there came about a heterogeneous jumble of con flicting statutes, continually juggled and arranged not so much to protect the game and birds as to protect the rights of certain classes In hunting them. This hodgepodge of game laws applied to states or to counties, towns, streams, lakes, bays or shores only gave real protection to certain kinds' of resident game.

See moreSee less

'until recent years. The, people never see the ne cessity of protecting a migratory bird until the species is nearly extinct and sometimes not even then. Real pro tective laws for the passenger pigeon

See the clipping

In the story →

Belding Banner · Belding, Mich. · and 8 other papers

Chief Game Protector Joseph Kalbfus states there are no wild passenger pigeons left in Pennsylvania or anywhere else, despite persistent rumors to the contrary. He cites correspondence with researcher C. F. Hodge of Clark University, who has investigated hundreds of claimed sightings but failed to confirm any surviving birds.

Belding Banner · 2 February 1911 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

PIGEON IS EXTINCT

So Declares Game Commissioner of Pennsylvania.

See moreSee less

Dr. Kalbfus Asserts That Those Who Claim to Have Seen Wild Birds Are Merely Careless Observers.

Harrisburg, Pa.—To the ever recurrent question, "Are there any wild pigeons in Pennsylvania?" Chief Game Protector Joseph Kalbfus once more answers an emphatic "no."

Dr. Kalbfus has been investigating this subject on his own hook, and in co-operation with other seekers after knowledge for years, but feels that the wild pigeon, or passenger pigeon, is extinct, not only in Pennsylvania, but throughout the world, notwithstanding reports to the contrary.

The cause for the disappearance of this bird, which existed in flocks of millions a generation ago, can only be conjectured, but it seems that other causes beside wanton destruction by man are found. Dr. Kalbfus sums up the general situation in a letter on the subject, which he wrote to a group of local sportsmen who asked him for information on the subject. He wrote:

"So many inquiries are coming to me regarding the presence of wild pigeons in the United States that I think it best to write you this short letter explanatory of our understanding of this matter. For some years past certain individuals have been attempting to collect data that would prove the presence of the wild pigeon somewhere in the United States or in the world.

"In the Forest and Stream issue of September 3 will be found an article by C. F. Hodge, who is connected with the Clark university, Worcester, Mass., who has been for some years past investigating this matter. This gentleman writes that he has received several hundred communications relative to this matter, but that up to this time he has failed to prove the presence of a passenger pigeon anywhere in the United States.

"Many people write him that they are certain of their identification, that they know what wild pigeons are and are sure the birds are passenger pigeons. Investigation has invariably proved them to be turtle doves or the band tail pigeon, or some bird other than our passenger pigeon. Mr. Hodge says in concluding his article that while his investigation is not encouraging, it does not prove beyond the question of a doubt that passenger pigeons may not yet be found and he proposes to continue his investigation for another year. This, it seems to me, covers the ground absolutely, no difference what reports may be printed in the newspapers; no single instance of the existence in the United States of the presence of the wild pigeon has been proved.

Many reasons for the disappearance of the pigeon have been made; the one that seems to be the most plausible to me is that during the time when these birds were everywhere, there was a horde of predatory birds and animals living upon them, following them up and down in their passage through the country. For some reason during the year 1879 vast numbers of these birds were destroyed either by geese or by being blown to sea in the Pacific, sailors reporting that they sailed for many hours through floating dead pigeons. This, it seems to me, depleted the supply to such an extent that those remaining were not able to withstand the attacks of their many enemies and gradually fell a prey to those enemies until they became extinct."

See the clipping

Also printed in 8 papers
  • Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · 10 November 1910
  • The Fulton County News · McConnellsburg, Pa. · 10 November 1910
  • The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis. · 10 November 1910
  • The Elbert County Tribune · Elbert, Colo. · 11 November 1910
  • The Lusk Herald · Lusk, Wyo. · 17 November 1910
  • The Washburn Times · Washburn, Wis. · 24 November 1910
  • Holbrook Argus · Holbrook, Ariz. · 6 December 1910
  • The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo. · 8 December 1910

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

In an interview about restocking trout and protecting game birds, a state official notes that the wild (passenger) pigeon was ruthlessly slaughtered during spring migrations and is now extinct in the state, and nearly so nationwide, prompting a reward for a surviving pair. He uses this as evidence for the need for proper game law enforcement, citing the successful protection of wild ducks as a contrasting success.

The Mirror and Farmer · 2 February 1911 · page 6

state. "The native game girds of the state cannot be reared in captivity; at least it has never been successfully done up to the -present time; so, of necessity, the work of the commission must be con fined to the enforcement of the laws for the protection of the wild birds, a work which unfortunately began too late to prevent the utter extinction of some of them. The wild pigeon, which was ruth

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

The article reports on the sole surviving passenger pigeon, an 18-year-old bird living at the Cincinnati Zoological Garden, whose death will mark the end of the species. It recounts how the once-billions-strong population was wiped out through merciless hunting with nets, decoys, clubs, and sulphur smoke, and notes the extinction has spurred efforts to protect other bird species.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Wood County Reporter · 2 February 1911 · page 4

THE LAST WILD PIGEON One lone passenger pigeon. Urn last survivor of the species, so far as is known, lives at the zoological garden m Cincinnati. She is eighteen years o and With her death will end the la>t chapter of a tale of human greed and desire to kill which has no parallel and which is almost incredible. Less than tilt.: years ago ttie num ber of passenger or wild pigeons was estimated in billions. Ail eas'ern North America abounded in these beautiful and harmless birds. The Hocks were so large that, when in flight, they extended as tar as the eye could reach in every direction.

See moreSee less

So great was their number that it took several hours for a flock to fly pist a given point. The bud hosts were often of such density as to obscure, the sun. The shot-gun and other common implements that have made havoc in bird life were not murderous enough in this pitiless butchery. .Vet and decoys, poles, clubs, and potsnf sulphur beneath the roosting places hastened the extermination. The carcasses were left to decay upon the ground or to be food for hogs. There are few if any more lament able instances of man’s destroving power and utter disregard of life in the animal or bird world than this. But there is one comp nsation. The extermination of the wild pigeon has served to arouse many to lire grave necessity of protecting and restoring other birds before it is too late. The gulls, terns, gredes. egrets, clucks must be saved from the fate of the wild pigeon.—The Dumb Animals.

See the clipping

Las Vegas Optic · East Las Vegas, N.M.

This 1911 piece catalogs animals driven to extinction by human slaughter, listing the passenger pigeon alongside the buffalo, quagga, and great auk as already gone. It uses these losses to argue for banning automatic shotguns, citing sportsmen who boasted of killing hundreds of geese in a day.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Las Vegas Optic · 6 February 1911 · page 3

GAME HOGS TO BLAME

In our own country the wild buf falo is no more. The species has been saved from entire extinction by tihe labors of a few men, but there are none left exoept in neias ana parka. The passenger pigeon, which

See the clipping

Willmar Tribune · Willmar, Minn. · and 7 other papers

The report describes Big Lake, Arkansas, as the last major legal shooting ground for wild ducks, where market hunters kill and ship hundreds of thousands annually despite club efforts to stop them. It warns that without federal protection, ducks may face extinction like the buffalo and passenger pigeon.

Willmar Tribune · 8 February 1911 · page 3

LOCATION OF BIG LAKE

"swamp angels," the members are bar red from hunting on their own grounds. A move is now on foot to have the club deed its property to the United States government as a na tional game preserve. This would re sult in its being policed by federal rangers and ducks protected. Many sportsmen believe that .unless this Is done another generation will see the total extermination of the wild duck, as the last few generations saw the extermination of the buffalo and' the passenger pigeons which once were to

See the clipping

Also printed in 7 papers
  • Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C. · 1 February 1911
  • The Hope Pioneer · Hope, N.D. · 2 February 1911
  • · · 3 February 1911
  • The Ordway New Era · Ordway, Colo. · 3 February 1911
  • The Prince George's Enquirer and Southern Maryland Advertiser · Upper Marlborough, Md. · 10 February 1911
  • Tensas Gazette · St. Joseph, La. · 17 February 1911
  • Bonners Ferry Herald · Bonners Ferry, Idaho · 27 May 1911

Saint Mary's Beacon · Leonard Town, Md.

The article describes the last known passenger pigeon, a female living at the Cincinnati Zoological Garden, said to be eighteen years old. It recounts how the species, once numbering in the billions and darkening the sky in flight, was wiped out through relentless hunting with guns, nets, and sulphur fires.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Saint Mary's Beacon · 9 February 1911 · page 1

The Last Wild Pigeon

_ Morning Prayer. Ob, may i be strong and ban, today, Aad may I a* kiad and true. And groat all men la a way, W'tUi tkaak good ehaar in tha tatny 1 *ay. Andkwalritkadeeds Ido. May tha kmpto heart of a chad ba mlaa. And tha gras or a roaatn bioom; Lot mo Oil the day with a bop* dtrlaa A nd t -rn my fac* to tho sky's glad shins, With writ a cloud of gloom. With tha guidon lever* oTI to and light 1 would lift tho world, aad whoa.

See moreSee less

Through a path with kindly dosda outdo bright I com to tho calm or thoataiilt night. Lot mo raM la peace. Amen. - Nrzojf Wat skua ir. In Momoriam. D*nt*l*d tbl-lire. Jan. ft. I**ll-, Cronos U. Ratos*, { n the 78 I. year i f i g agt. Rn tjn a tru • Übrttb . a gned rf. V** *- fio-bc**- •*. hoiiti Itltrd by u I #r,o s<‘V*’ nun He leaves a brother and sister and six children tu u> urn hie baa But remember. dear fri*-nd*, that our loss in hi* < t(<-nal gain a r d the los* is only b tho-c who remain ba bind to mourn hi* departure, Ada, be forever rest in peace I Wli.i hta wife and tour Mitts ones. He la now beneath the cold rod. And together their route aro reeling In the I’a rad ton of Uod. rohuman handa trl-d hard <o aaro Mm, Tmu and prayer* wo* a all In vain. For an angel came ard bota him Swiftly from thla world of pain. Yet again we hope to meet him Whan -be day of lira is fled. And in Heaven with all to greet h‘m * here no farewell tears are (bed. Long he lingered weak with pain Which never could he cures. But now unto eternal rest. Ho has been called hy the Hleaeed Lord. —by hla grand-daughter. C. B. Tha Last Wild Plgaon. One lone passenger pigeon, the l ist s-rvivor of the specie*, so far a* i* iTD'-wn. 1 res at the s o’ogical garden in Cincinnati She is eigh teen years o’d._ With herdealb will end 'act chapter of a tale of human greed and desire to kill which ba* no paraded and wbeb is almost In credible Less than fifty years ago the Dum ber of passenger or wild pigeons was esMmated In biilipns AM east -rn North America abounded in these beautiful and harmless birds The cks were so Urge that, when in lliJht, tb-y ezieaded g far as The eve coui3*f©acT?Tb CYei'y -Ac tion i S'i great was their number that * took several hours for a flock to fly past a given point. The bird hosts were often of such density as to obscure tb-* sun. The shut gun and other common that have made havoc in bird life were not murderous enough in ibis pitiless butchery Nets and decoys, poles, clubs, and oots of sulphur benea'h the nx*at irg-p'ace* Las'.e> ed the extermina ti n. The carcasses wnrg to de cay upon the ground or to be food f..r hogs There are few if any more lament able instances of man’s destoving power and utter disregard of life in the animal or bird world than this But there is one compensat ; on. The extermination of the wild pigeon has served to arouse many to the grave necessity of protecting and restoring other b ; rds before it is too late. The gulls, terns, grobe*. egrets, ducks must ba saved frog tie fte of the wild pigeon.—Our Dumb Animals Saved From Awful Peril. “I never felt so near my grave,” writes L *wis Chimblln.of Manches ter, Ohio. R R No 3. “as when a frightful cough and lung trouble pulled me down to 115 pounds in spite of many remedies and the blsl doctors. And that lam alive today is due solely to Dr. King’s New Dis covery, which cnmolntaly cured me. N>w I weigh 160 pounds ard can work hard. It also cured my four children of crouo. ’’ Infallible for Coughs and Colds, its the most cer tain remedy for L.Grippe, Asthma, desperate lung trouble and ail bronchial affections, 6*c and tl. A trial bottie free. Guaranteed by J J Norris, Lecnardlown, Md. Planning Tha House ‘ Weil,” said 6 fford Herrington, cheerfully. ‘Tve got the plans for my new house on the lake shore all finished.” “Finished to suit you?” “N ro But the architect is sat isfi d and tbit’s the best I ran ex pect ” *Ht ba! How about Mrs. Ber ringiou?” “It’s all right with her too. In fact, she got that fixed before we started. You see. she 'aid out toe cupboards and wardrobes, end al' the architect bad to do was to build a bouse around them. ” —Cleveland Rain Dealer.

See the clipping

Monroe City Democrat · Monroe City, Mo.

The report describes a lone surviving passenger pigeon living at the Cincinnati zoological garden, said to be the last of a species once numbering in the billions across eastern North America. It recounts the mass slaughter by nets, clubs, and sulphur fires that wiped out the species, framing it as a cautionary tale for bird conservation.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Monroe City Democrat · 9 February 1911 · page 7

The Last Wild Pigeon

m,I0?8 of associate industries. F .J ".. I 1" 1 UOH 1 Deueve 1110 owners oi railroads and great industrial enternew enisrpnses. maia oecause thev are lightened. Capital is timid Until the owners are sure .u1. 1 1 1 . : 1 1 . luc u,li; ai,u "'"aiora W1" 1101 ! harass them they will continue to conserve and refrain from new en terprises. "We now have the freight rate problem to solve. There will be few new enterprises until that is settled. As the ruilroaiis pro. ,u r th general .

See moreSee less

. . . 1 : . ,1 . , . : I : . l . .1. puDiu: uous likewise, i mean ine industrial part of th' ; jblu-, not sj much the agricultural, ihe public and business generally would fare much better with a freight rate higher than at present, with its sub sequent railroad prosperity than they would Willi a lower freight ; rate that would cause the railroads to curtail expenditures on improve ments and new enterprises, fuoberly Monitor. The Last Wild Pigeon. One lone passenger pigeon, the last survivor of the species, so far as is known, lives at the zoological garden in Cincinnati. She is eigh teen years old. With her death will end the last, chapter of a tale of human greed and desire to kill which has no parallel and which is almost incredible. T acc thnn fCtr troarc o 1r trii nnm , . ?. , ber of passenger or wild pigejns . . .. . was estimated in billions. All eastXT , . , , , .

See the clipping

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

A bird protection appeal notes that wild pigeons, once numbering in the millions, are now nearly extinct, with searches for nests turning up nothing. The passenger pigeon's fate is used to urge action against the slaughter of other birds like egrets and robins in the South.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 18 February 1911 · page 8

KILLING OF BIRDS

Wild Pigeons Extinct. " 'There are millions of them,' re marked a noted robin trapper. That was the language used by the hunters who trailed the wild pigeons twenty five years ago in Pennsylvania, New York and other northern states. To day wild pigeons are as near extinc

See the clipping

Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.

At a Massachusetts legislative hearing on bird protection and spring shooting laws, ornithologist William Brewster recalled testifying years earlier for protection of the wild pigeon, using the same arguments now made against coots that failed to prevent the pigeon's extinction. The hearing featured competing testimony from naturalists, sportsmen, and landowners debating the merits of the current protective law.

Springfield Weekly Republican · 23 February 1911 · page 4

hayhrook. 111. February 11, 1011. ogiats. formerly editor of the Auk. and ! president of. the American ornithological union. It is found by Dr Brewster that I the scarcity of birds at (’oncom ns <oto ; pared with Thoreau's time, is not due to । lack of food or growing population gener ■ .illy, because since the protection from I spring shooting afforded by the present law the birds are returning in encourag ing numbers. Mr Brewster uippea rod before ! a committee years ago for protection of the । wild pigeon anti the same arguments used j against the coot and other birds now were used against the wild pigeon which is now I extinct. Oue thing Dr Lewis would eui

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.

An article advocating protection for swans, gulls, and prairie chickens invokes the passenger pigeon as a cautionary tale of extinction. It notes that only one passenger pigeon remains, kept at the Cincinnati zoological garden, with a $400 reward offered for finding even a nest of the species in the wild.

The Evening Times · 23 February 1911 · page 5

PLEA FOR BIRD PROTECTION

at :20 p. m. Park River Institute. Mo. 4W—'Via Mod Lake Valla, arrives In Orand Forks at 4:16 p. a* Park River is making extensive Tuesday, Thursday and Sat* preparations for a two-days' farmers' urday. No. 440—Via Red Uln Vails, Isavss institute ,which opens there tomorrow. Orand Forks at 7:S0 m_ Several prominent speakers and in Monday. Wsdnosday. Friday, stitute' workers will be In attendance. farmers have as they live almost alto gether on insects and are scavenger birds fs well. Last summer it was no unusual sight to see large flooka of these birds flying over the fields and more than one farmer has told the Journal that after a visit of one of these flocks of sea gulls he could, no tice a great difference In the amount of grasshoppers on their farms.

See moreSee less

It has been suggested that as many as possible write to our representa tives in Bismarck and especially to Bernt Anderson who is on the game and fish committee, asking them to use all the Influence they can to have the bill pass the house. It does not seem so very long since we had the passenger pigeons with us. We have seen them fly past In such flocks that for hours at a time they would obscure the sun. Today In all this great big country, we have only one passenger pigeon, and that one Is In the zoologi cal garden at Cincinnati. The Ornithological society of Brown's university offers a regard of $400 to anyone who can find even a nest of a passenger pigeon. They have gone forever. A beautiful bird, much more beautiful than our domestic pigeon. Our cormorants, our trumpet ing swans, our gulls, terns, prairie chickens and wild ducks, all bid fair to meet the same sad fate if some thing is not done soon to protect and care for them. Mr. Barr, the dairy

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

A North Dakota newspaper article urges readers to support a bird protection bill before the state legislature, citing the passenger pigeon's extinction as a warning of what could happen to other species. It notes that only one passenger pigeon remains alive, in the Cincinnati zoo, and that a $400 reward is offered for anyone who can find even a nest of the species.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 23 February 1911 · page 2

URGES SUPPORT

^Bernt Anderson, who is on the game and fish committee, asking them to use all the influence they can to have the bill pass the houseIt does not saei so very long since the passenger pig eons would pass in such flocks that for hours at a time they would obscure the sun. Today in all this great coun try we have only one passenger pigeon, and that one is in the zoological gar dens at Cincinnati. The ornithological society of Browns university offers a reward of $400 to anyone who can find even a nest of a passenger pigeon. They have gone forever. A beautiful bird, much more beautiful than our domestic pigeons. Our cormorant^,

See the clipping

The Mirror and Farmer · Manchester, N.H.

The National Audubon Society reports that only one passenger pigeon remains alive, housed at the Cincinnati zoological garden, with a reward still unclaimed for finding an inhabited nest. The article recalls New Hampshire's once-thriving pigeon-netting trade and mourns the species' destruction by hunters and plume sellers, urging protection for other threatened birds.

The Mirror and Farmer · 23 February 1911 · page 2

ACCORDING to the National Audu bon society, only one survivor of the vast flocks of passenger pig eons that not so many years ago used to traverse the continent in billions is known to exist today. That solitary, beautiful bird is in the zoological garden at Cincinnati, a gentle reproach to man's inhumanity to the feathered tribe. A large prize has been and still is offered for the discovery of a single inhabited nest of this species, but no one has pre sented any valid claim for the reward. When the bird at Cincinnati, now 18 years old, dies, the passenger pigeon will probably have become extinct.

See moreSee less

There are men living in New Hamp shire who recall the days when wild pig eons were netted in this state annually by the thousands. Men made a business of capturing them for the market, and when they forsook New England for the great grain fields of the West, some of the Yankee pigeon catchers followed them there. The late James Thompson of Hooksett, David Sprague of Bedford and "Pigeon" Parker of Merrimack were famous pigeon snarers when the birds roamed the 'woods of southern New Hampshire in countless numbers, and they made the business of snaring very profitable. An old-time pigeon house, where pigeons were fattened for the mar ket, limy still be seen adjoining the old Sprague farmhouse on the Pulpit road, known as the "Four Corners." It is a sad thing to see an exquisite creature like the beautiful passenger pig eon slaughtered from the face of the earth by pot-hunters and the sellers of plumage. Now that the pigeon is gone the public should resolve to do all in

See the clipping