As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

March 1911

14 articles

The Dawson News · Dawson, Ga.

A Savannah News item notes that robins, once abundant in Georgia winters, are now scarce, comparing their decline to the wild pigeon, once so numerous it broke tree branches but now believed extinct. It blames deforestation, game laws, and pump-guns for declining bird populations generally.

The Dawson News · 1 March 1911 · page 2

The Destruction of Birds. From the Savannah News. What has become of the robins? The Sandersville Georgian recalls that in former years the woods in winter were literally full of the red breasts. But, it says, ‘‘comparative ly few have been seen this winter. The robins have doubtless gone the way of the wild pigeons, once so numerous that they would break the branches of a tree in which they roosted, but are now thought to be extinet.”” The question is a very large one. It involves deforesta tion, game laws, pump-guns and other things.

See moreSee less

But it is a pity that the wild pigeons have gone and the robins are going. And it might be mentioned that summer ducks, partridges and doves are not as nu merous as they used to be. Buzzard Chesterfieldan Gentleman,,

See the clipping

Atlanta Semi-Weekly Journal · Atlanta, Ga.

A newspaper correspondent argues for stronger enforcement of bird protection laws, citing the near-total slaughter of doves and partridges as mirroring the earlier fate of the passenger pigeon. The writer notes only one known wild pigeon remains, using this as a cautionary tale for current conservation efforts.

Atlanta Semi-Weekly Journal · 17 March 1911 · page 4

stroying insects that damage the crops. The investigators have lately given to the world the fact that the partridge is the greatest known enemy of the boll weevil, and here we are threatened with this pest to the cotton crop and yet al lowing one agency of its destruction ex terminated. It is not hard to find men in this state whose fathers remember when the wild pigeons came by the mil lions. That has not beeh long, and to day there is said to be but one known live wild pigeon in this country. The senseless slaughter* of the birds has done

See the clipping

Devils Lake Inter-Ocean · Devils Lake, N.D.

A children's Junior Audubon Society meeting included a program with various bird-related presentations, including one titled 'The Last Passenger Pigeon' by Beta Thompson. The meeting also referenced author Marshall Saunders, known for animal-themed children's books.

Devils Lake Inter-Ocean · 17 March 1911 · page 5

Birds," Herman Naugel. "The Last Passenger Pigeon," vv ... Beta Thompson. Mrs. Marshall Saunders, author of 'Beautiful Joe* and Tilda Jane," the Friend of Children, Animals and

See the clipping

The Enterprise · Harlem, Mont. · and 21 other papers

The article reports a standing $400 reward for anyone who finds a wild passenger pigeon nest with nestlings and can prove it without disturbing them. It notes that rumors the birds had relocated to Mexico or South America were investigated and found to be completely false, while watchers across the country continued searching in vain.

The Enterprise · 23 March 1911 · page 6

PA'S RESUMIABLY everybody knows by this time that there Is a standing offer of $400 in cash for the man, woman, boy or girl who ,jfinds the nest of a wild pig eon (ectopistes migratorl us), otherwise known as the passenger pigeon, and finds with it the nestling birds. In order to get the reward the person who makes the dis covery must leave the nest and the birds unmolested and prove the truth of it by making a report adid giving the sci entists an opportunity to verify the case.

See moreSee less

a Magazine and newspaper articles lit-", it erally by the thousands have been writ- - ten about the disappearance of the wild pigeons which once, as it is al w ways put, "darkened the sun with their flights." -The members of the biologi fii cal survey in Washington are specially interested in the subject of the disap pearance of this bird of passage from its wild haunts. For years it has been hoped that nesting pairs might be found it in some part of the country and that with proper protection the bird might in be restored in part at least to its place in nature. Recently there was a story published to the effect that the birds, wearied of in the constant persecution, which met them in the United States, had changed the course of their flight and had gone into Mexico and there were living peace fully and happily. This story proved to be absolutely without foundation. Still another tale was to the effect that the pigeons had gone into the heart of South America and there finding conditions pleasant were leading a non-migratory life. This tale also proved to be en tirely fictitious. In nll parts of the southern states in the winter seasons there are people watching sharp-eyed for a glimpse of the bird that once was a common sight. In the summer sharp eyes of the north are constantly on the alert for the same purpose, but as yet no authentic report has been received that the bird of mys terious disappearance has revisited the scenes familiar through the centuries to Its ancestors. One of the scientists most interested in the search for the wild pigeon is Ruthven Deane, fellow of the American Ornithologists' union and president of the Illinois Audubon Society for the Protection of Wild Birds. Mr. Deane virtually has given up all hope that any living specimen of the passenger pigeon ever will be found, but he is as tireless today as ever in tracing reports of the bird's reappearance to their sources. The offer of $400 for the discovery of a nesting pair of the pigeons and their undisturbed nest comes from Clifton R. I-odge of Clark university, but $100 ad ditional will be paid for the discovery of a pair of birds and their nest if found in the state of Illinois. The additional reward is the joint offer of Mr. Deane and, as I remember it, of Professor Whitman of the-University of Chicago. One of the most curious features of the search for the wild pigeon is the mistakes which are made constantly by men who years ago trapped the pigeons and were as familiar with their appearance as they were, and are today for thnt matter, with the appearance of the com mon robin of the dooryard. Reports have come in from all sections of the country of the reap pearance of the pigeon, but on investigation it invariably has been found that the discoverers had seen nothing more nor less than the com mon wild dove (venaidura macroura), or mourn log dove, which is so familiar a bird that it seems almost impossible that any man of the countryside could have failed to overlook It as his constant neighbor, and could confuse it with its much larger cousin, the passenger pigeon of other days. To give an example of how the search is con ducted for the wild pigeon and how conscientious are the scientists in attempting to verify reports of its reappearance this one instance, taken from a hundred instances, may be noted. Recently a report from northern Michigan reached the presi dent of the Illinois Audubon society that the passenger pigeon In very truth had reappeared in the vicinity of a club house frequented by fishermen and gunners, many of whom had known the pigeon well in the old days and who were certain that in this case they could not be mistaken. as to the identity of the bird via itors. It was a long journey to the northern Michi gan club house, but an ornithologist undertook the trip believing in his heart that finally the passenger pigeon had been found, for he knew that the men who had made the report had been familiar with the bird in the old days and sup posedly knew the appearance of Its every feather. At the end of the journey he was told that the pigeons wvere there and he was led out to see them. They proved to be mourning doves, a bird common in nearly all parts of Michigan and~in most of the states of the Union. The dis appointment was keen, and keener in this case because this was one report which seemed to have about it every mark of truth. When I was a boy I knew the wild pigeon fairly well. It was nothing like as abundant as it had been in the years gone lly, but occa slcnal~y emal floecas were seen in the vicinity of miy hi I l~place in tlho foothills of the Adirondack mountains in central New York. I am sorry to say that I shot some of the birds before I fully realized the value of giving protection to a van ishing race. The mourning dove I know as well as I know the English sparrow, and I think that there is no chance of confusion in my mind re specting the identity of the dove and Its bigger relative, the pigeon. It is possible, though I am not sure that such Is a fact, that I saw the last wild pigeon reported In Illinois. Others may have been seen since that time within the bor der's of the state, but If so I have not seen their appearance reported. At five o'clock on the morning of a late April 'lay, fifteen years ago. I went into Lincoln nark.

See the clipping

Also printed 22 more times, in 21 papers
  • The Lamar Register · Lamar, Colo. · 22 March 1911
  • Torrington Telegram · Torrington, Wyo. · 23 March 1911
  • The Green Forest Tribune · Green Forest, Ark. · 24 March 1911
  • Rocky Ford Enterprise · Rocky Ford, Colo. · 24 March 1911
  • The Rice Belt Journal · Welsh, La. · 24 March 1911
  • The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · 24 March 1911
  • The Citizen · Frederick City, Md. · 24 March 1911
  • The Midland Journal · Rising Sun, Md. · 24 March 1911
  • Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio · 24 March 1911
  • Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis. · 24 March 1911
  • Jerome News · Jerome, Ariz. · 25 March 1911
  • The Idaho Springs Siftings-News · Idaho Springs, Colo. · 25 March 1911
  • Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan. · 25 March 1911
  • The Semi-Weekly Leader · Brookhaven, Miss. · 25 March 1911
  • The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb. · 29 March 1911
  • The New Era · Walden, Colo. · 30 March 1911
  • The Brandon News · Brandon, Miss. · 30 March 1911
  • Mrs. Grundy · Tracy City, Tenn. · 30 March 1911
  • Torrington Telegram · Torrington, Wyo. · 30 March 1911
  • The Pioche Record · Pioche, Nev. · 1 April 1911
  • The Alamogordo News · Alamogordo, N.M. · 13 April 1911
  • The Colfax Chronicle · Colfax, La. · 15 April 1911

The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · North Platte, Neb.

A $1500 reward is offered for anyone who finds a passenger pigeon nest with live nestlings, verified by scientists, as the Biological Survey hopes to find surviving wild pairs. Rumors that the pigeons had relocated to Mexico or South America are reported as thoroughly debunked.

The North Platte Semi-Weekly Tribune · 24 March 1911 · page 7

RESUM ABLY ovoryoouy H knows by this time that thero is a standing offer of MOO In caflh for" the man, I B woman, boy or girl who I 1W I finds the neat of a -wild pig I RmU I eon fectoDlstcs mlgratorlus), othcrwiso known &b tho pasBcngor pigeon, and finds with It tho nestling birds. In order to get tho reward tho porson who makes tho dis covery must leavo tho nest and tho birds unmolested and provo tho truth of It by making. a report and giving tho sci entists an opportunity to verify tho caso.

See moreSee less

Magazlno and nowspapor articles lit erally by tho thousands hnvo been writ ten about tho disappearance of tho wild pigeons which once, as It 1b al ways put, "darkened tho sun with their flights." Tho members of tho biologi cal survey In Washington are specially Interested In tho subject of tho disap pearance of this bird of passage from its wild haunts. For years It has been hoped that nesting pairs might bo found in somo part of tho country and that with proper protection tho bird might bo restored in part at least to lto ploco In nature. Recently thero was a story published to tho effect that tho birds, wearied of tho constant persecution which mot them in tho United States, had changed tho courso of their flight and had gon6 into Mexico and thero woro living peace fully and happily, This story proved to bo absolutely without foundation. Still another tnto was to tho effect that, tho pigeons hntfgono Into tho heart of South America and thero finding conditions pleasant wero leading a non-migratory life. This talo also proved to be en tirely fictitious. In all parts of tho southern states In the winter seasons thero aro peoplo watching" sharp-eyed for a gllmpso of tho bird that onco was a common sight. In tho summer sharp eyes of tho north aro constantly on tho alert for tho same purpose, but as yet no authentic report hns been received that the bird of mys terious disappearance has revisited tho scenes familiar through tho centuries to its ancestors. 1 Ono of tho scientists most interested in tho search for tho wild pigeon is Ruthvcn Deane, fellow of tho American Ornithologists' union and president of tho Illinois Audubon Society for tho Protection of Wild Birds. Mr. Deano virtually has given up all hopo that any living specimen of the passenger pigeon ever will be found, but ho ,1s as tireless today as over In traolne rcnortn of tho bird's reappearance to their sources. The offer of $400 for tho discovery of a nesting pAlr of tho pigeons and their undisturbed nest comes from Clifton R. Hodge of Clark university, but $100 ad ditional will bo paid for tho disepvery of a pair of birds and their nest if found in tho stato of Illinois. Tho additional reward is tho Joint offer of Mr. Deano and, as I remember it, of Prorcssor Whitman of th,o University of Chicago. Ono of tho most curious features of tho searoh for tho wild pigeon is tho mistakes' which aro mado constantly by men who years ago trapped tho pigeons and were as familiar with their nppearanco as they woro, and nro today for that matter, with tho appearance of tho com mon robin of tho dooryard. Reports lmvo como in from all sections of tho country of tho reap pearanco of tho pigeon, but on Investigation it Invariably has been found that thp discoverers had seen nothing moro nor less than tho com mon wild dovo (venaidura macroura), or mourn ing dove, which is bo familiar a bird that It, seems almost impossible that any man of tho countrysido could havo failed to overlook it as his constant neighbor and could confuse it with its much larger cousin, tho passenger pigeon of other days. To give an example of how tho search Is con . ducted for tho wild pigeon nnd how conscientious aro tho scientists In attempting to verify reportB of its reappcaranco this ono instance, taken from n hundred instances, may bo noted. Recently a report from northern Michigan reached tho presi dent of tho Illinois Audubon society that tho passenger pigeon In very truth had reappeared in tho vicinity of a club liouso frequented by fishermen and gunners, many of whom had known tho pigeon well In tho old days and who wero certain that In this case they could not bo mistaken as to tho identity of the bird vis

See the clipping

Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio

The article reports a standing $400 reward from the biological survey for anyone who finds a nesting pair of passenger pigeons with young, requiring proof and scientific verification. It also debunks two circulating rumors claiming the pigeons had relocated to Mexico or South America, stating both stories were fictitious.

Perrysburg Journal · 24 March 1911 · page 6

4 UESUMAHLY everybody knows by this tlmo that there is a standing offer of $400 In cash for tho man, woman, boy or girl who finds tho nest of a wild pig con (ectoplstcs mlgratorl ub), otherwise lenown as the passenger pigeon, and finds with It the nestling birds. In order to get tho reward the person who makes tho dis covery must leavo tho nest and tho birds unmolested and prove the truth of it by making a report and giving tho sci entists an opportunity to verify tho case.

See moreSee less

Jlagazlno and newspaper articles lit erally by tho thousands have been writ ten about the disappearance of tho wild pigeons which onco, as it Is al ways put, "darkened the sun with their flights." Tho members of tho biologi cal ourvey In Washington are specially Interested In tho subject of tho disap pearance of this bird of passage from Us wild haunts. For years It has been hoped that nesting pairs might bo found in some part of tho country and that with 'proper protection tho bird might bo restored in part at least to Its place In nature. Recently there was a story published to the effect that the birds, wearied of tho constant persecution which mot them in tho United States, had changed tho course of their flight and had gone into Mexico and there were living peace fully and happily. This story proved to bo absolutely without foundation. Still another tale was to the effect that tho pigeons had gone into tho heart of South America and there finding conditions pleasant wero leading a non-migratory life. This talo also proved to bo en tirely fictitious. In all parts of the southern states In tho winter seasons there are people watching sharp-eyed for a glimpse of tho bird that once was a common sight. In tho summer sharp eyes of tho north are constantly on tho alert for tho same purpose, but as yet no authentic report has been received that the bird of mys terious disappearance has revisited the scenes familiar through the centuries to Its ancestors. One of tho scientists most Interested In tho search for the wild pigeon 1b Ruthven Deane, fellow of the American Ornithologists' union and president of tho Illinois Audubon Society for tho Protection of Wild Birds. Mr. Deane virtually has given up all hope that any living specimen of the passenger pigeon ever will bo found, but ho is as tireless today as ever in tracing reports of tho bird's reappearance to their sources. The offer of $400 for tho discovery of a nesting pair of tho pigeons and their undisturbed nest comes from Clifton R. Hodge of Claik university, but $100 ad ditional will be paid for tho discovery of a pair of birds and their nest if found in tho state of Illinois. Tho additional reward Is tho Joint offer of Mr. Deane and. as I remember it, of Professor Whitman of the University of Chicago. One of the most curious features of tho search for the wild pigeon is tho mistakes which are made constantly by men who years ago trapped the pigeons and were as familiar with their appearance as they were, and are today for that matter, with tho appearance of tho com mon robin of tho dooryard. Reports have come in from all sections of the country of tho reap pearance of tho pigeon, but on investigation It invariably has been found that tho discoverers had seen nothing more nor less than the com mon wild dovo (venaldura macroura), or mourn ing dove, which is so familiar a bird that It. seems almost impossible that any man of tho countryside could havo failed to oyerlook it as his constant neighbor and could confuse it with Its much larger cousin, tho passenger pigeon of other days. To give an example of how tho search is con ducted for tho wild pigeon and how conscientious are tho scientists in attempting to verify reports of its reappearance this one instance, taken from a hundred Instances, may be noted. Recently a report from northern Michigan .reached the presU dent of tho Illinois Audubon society that tho passenger pigeon in very truth had reappeared in tho vicinity of a club house frequented by flBhermen and gunners, many of whom had known the pigeon well In the old days and who wero certain that in this case they could not bo mistaken as to tho identity of tho bird vis

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

A $400 reward remains standing for anyone who finds a nesting pair of wild passenger pigeons and reports it to scientists without disturbing the nest. The article debunks earlier rumors that the pigeons had relocated to Mexico or South America, noting these stories proved entirely fictitious, while watchers in both southern and northern states continue to search for authentic sightings.

Eagle River Review · 24 March 1911 · page 5

4 m.;s[jMABLY gverybody pnows by this time that mere is a standing offer of ¢4OO in cash for the man, ;voma.n, boy or girl W¥l° | finds the nest of a wild pig , con (ectopistes migratori . ug), otherwise known as ‘ne passenger pigeon, and finds with it the mnestling pirds. In order to get the 3 ri the person who makes the disP must leavé the mnest and the o molested and prove the truth of

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

The article recounts and debunks earlier fictitious stories that passenger pigeons had relocated to Mexico or South America, noting ornithologists like Ruthven Deane have abandoned hope of finding survivors. It describes ongoing but fruitless searches, cash rewards offered for proof of a nesting pair, and explains that many 'sightings' are actually mourning doves mistaken for the extinct bird.

Eagle River Review · 24 March 1911 · page 5

One of the scientists most interested "te scarch for the wild pigeon is - Jiviver Deane, fellow of the American P g (nitolu’sts’ anion and president of ‘ e llinois audubon Society for the Bl ocetion of Wild Birds. Mr. Deane - i 'ruelly has given up all hope that any i "z specimen of the passenger pigeon ¢ vill be found, but he is as tireless il a 7 as ever in tracing reports of the

See the clipping

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

This report describes how scientists carefully investigate claims of passenger pigeon sightings, noting a Michigan case where supposed pigeons turned out to be mourning doves. It includes a personal first-person account from a man recalling a possible genuine sighting of a male passenger pigeon in Chicago's Lincoln Park years earlier.

Eagle River Review · 24 March 1911 · page 5

%, . Vas a boy I knew the wild pigeon w., “ Tt was nothing like as abundant ..~ “Cen In the years gone by, but occa v Small focks were seen in the vicinity of Y. . ein the foothills of the Adirondack w., L 0 central New York. I am sorry to %, . ©'ot some of the birds before I fully ko '© value of giving protection to a van !s"kt.,\ % The mourning dove I know as well tere . 'lie English sparrow, and I think that Yoo, 0 chance of confusion in my mind reWy, O ldentity of the dove and its bigger w .

See moreSee less

0 Digeon. It is possible, though lam Wy .. 40 such is a faet, that I saw the last W, O 0 reported in Illinois. Others may fog .. | Sten since that time within the borY., | S‘ate, but if so I have not seen their

See the clipping

Jerome News · Jerome, Ariz.

This is merely a table-of-contents listing noting that page 8 of the paper's second section contains a piece titled 'Passing of the Passenger Pigeon,' described as illustrated. No actual content of that article is given here, only the index reference amid other unrelated listings about manufacturing statistics and other features.

Jerome News · 25 March 1911 · page 2

Practical Hints For Ranchmen. Miscellaneous. Page 8 — Passing of the Passenger Pigeon. Illustrated. The Kitchen Cabinet. Miscellaneous. When in Prescott if you wish to get the best meal obtainable

See the clipping

The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb.

A $400 reward is offered for anyone who finds a passenger pigeon nest with nestlings and reports it to scientists without disturbing it. The article debunks rumors that surviving pigeons had relocated to Mexico or South America, calling both stories fictitious.

The Columbus Journal · 29 March 1911 · page 6

Ihe constant persecution which met them in the United States, had changed tins course of their (light and had gone into Mexico and there were living peace fully and happily. This story proved to in: absolutely without foundation. Still another tale was to the effect that the pigeons had gone into the heart of South America and there finding conditions pleasant were leading a non-migratory l:te. This tale also proved to be en tirely fictitious. In all partB of the southern states in the winter seasons there are people witching sharp-eyed for a glimpse of I'ij bird that once was a common sight.

See moreSee less

In Hie summer sharp eyes of the north are constantly on tho alert for the same purpose, but as 3'et no authentic report .' s been received that the bird of mys-K-iious disappearance has revisited the scenes familiar through the centuries to its ancestors. One of the scientists most interested in the search for the wild pigeon Is ftuthveu Deane, fellow of the American Uniilhologists union and president of Ihc Illinois Audubon Society for the Protection of Wild Birds. Mr. Deane ttrJually has given up all hope that any living specimen of the passenger pigeon rver will be found, but he is as tireless otlay as ever in tracing reports of tho Iiird's reappearance to their sources. The offer of $400 for the discovery of a nesting pair of the pigeons and their undisturbed nest comes from Clifton R. Hodge of Clark university, but $100 ad ditional will be paid for the discovery nf a pair of birds and their nest if found in the state of Illinois. The additional reward is the joint offer of Mr. Deane and. as I remember it, of Professor Whitman of lue University of Chicago. Ono of the most curious features of the search for the wild pigeon is the mistakes which

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

This 1911 nostalgia column reprints local news items from 40, 50, 25, and 15 years prior, including a brief 1871 note that hunters returning from pigeon hunts reported wild pigeons 'few and far between.' The item is embedded among unrelated historical trivia like marriages, deaths, and local business news.

Mineral Point Tribune · 30 March 1911 · page 5

FROM THE TRIBUNE FILES

March 27th, hy Rev. Dr. Jackson, Mr. John Vickerman and Miss H. Dolphin, both of Linden. The U. S. Hotel of this city will re turn to the proprietorship of Mr. Hugh Phillips on the Ist of May. Parties we have seen returning from weary tramps after wild pigeons report them “few and far between.” A coroner’s inquest was held overj the body of Mr. George Mulks, found dead in Diamond Grove last week, and a verdict rendered that "he came to his death by exposure while laboring under temporary insanity.”

See the clipping

The Coalville Times · Coalville, Utah

A $1,500 reward is offered for anyone who finds a living passenger pigeon nest with nestlings, provided it is left undisturbed and verified by scientists. The report also debunks recent rumors that surviving pigeons had relocated to Mexico or South America, calling both stories fictitious.

The Coalville Times · 31 March 1911 · page 7

I I tho winter season Hum ors pexipto I watching tliarper l for n glimpse of I his constant neighbor I and could confuse t with I 1 III SIM VIIIA orerybody knows by tills limo that there la n standing otter of I 100 In cash for tin man woman boy or Url who nude Ito next of a wild pig con lectoplslc mlnrntorl ull otherwlso Known an Iho pnsscnger pigeon anti find with It Ito nestling bird In order to net the reward tho croon who make thus dls covery oust leave Ito nest ami his birds unmolested and prose the truth or It by making a report and gulag tits lei enlists an opportunity to verify too cane MnMiiInu iiiul newspaper article lit erally by the thousands have been writ ten about the disappearance or tho wild pigeons which once nil It In nl way put darkened the nun with their nights Tho member or Ito blologl cal survey In nshlngton nro specially Interested In the subject or the disap pearance or tlili bird or lltlllO from III wild hnunti Kor yrani It has been hoped that nesting pair might tic round In soma part or Ito country and that wllh proper protection the bird might bn restored In part nt trout to Us pia co In nature Itccently there was a story published to the enYct Hint Ibo birds wearied or the constant persecution which met them In the United KlHlv had changed llio course or their night and had hone Into Mexico and there were IKIiiK peace fully and happily This tory protest to ho nbsolutrly without foundntlon 81111 another tnlp a to the iduct that the pigeon hul n e Into tlmheartof South America ni etc finding condition plenwint were IradliiK II non migratory life Till halo oleo pros lil to be en tirely llclllloui In nil parts of the southern slate In thus bird that ono won n common night In Ibo Bummer ahnrp eye of Iho north are constantly on Iho alert for tin namei purpose but ns yet no nuthentlo report hnl been recehcd that Ito bird or mill Itrlou dltappenrancn tan rotlslled the scene familiar through the centuries to Its ancestors One or the scientists most Interested In ho Hearth for the wild pigeon li IlmhMMi Deane fellow of tho American Ornithologists union anti president or tha Illinois Audubon Society for tho 1rotectlon of WillI lllrelj Mr UIII virtually lion given up alt liopo thnt an > living specimen of tho passenger pigeon ever will ho found but ho li I a > tireless today ns ever In tracing rrporli of tho birds reappearance to their sources Tho offer of 100 for the discovery of n netting pair of lint pigeons and their undisturbed nest come from Clifton II lodge of Clark university but = 100 ad dltlonat will bo paid for tits discovery of n pair or birds and their nest If found In tin Into of Illinois Tho additional reward IIIIO Joint j offer of Mr Dennn and as I remember II of Professor hitman of the Unherslly of Chicago Ono of tho most curious feature of the search for tho wild pigeon Is tho mistakes which nro loathe constantly by men Mho year ago trapped the pigeons and were as familiar with their appearance nn they were and are today tor that matter with thin appenrnnco of tho common mon nblll of this doornrd 1IlloreA have come In from nil sections or Iho country or thin reap Iornnlo or the pigeon bill 011 IIlIeallllnlloll It Invariably tins beets found mat Ilia ellseo > crci had seen nothing more nor less than Hut com mon wild data unaldurn matrnura or mourn Ing line which II I ro fnmlllnr n bird that It teems almost Impossible that nay man of the county I I slde could have failed I to overlook It I as f III

See the clipping

The Coalville Times · Coalville, Utah

A report on the ongoing search for the believed-vanishing passenger pigeon, including cash rewards from the Audubon Society and a University of Chicago professor for finding a nest or pair. It describes repeated false identifications by experienced former pigeon hunters, who mistake common mourning doves for the much larger passenger pigeon, including one detailed account of an ornithologist's disappointing trip to Michigan.

The Coalville Times · 31 March 1911 · page 7

mon wild data unaldurn matrnura or mourn Ing line which II I ro fnmlllnr n bird that It teems almost Impossible that nay man of the county I I slde could have failed I to overlook It I as f III Its much larger cousin lie I passenger pigeon of other da > i To glue an example of how tho iieirch Is I con ducted for tho wild pigeon unit how ronnclrntlou are tha scientists In attempting to verify report of Its rcapptnrancn this one Instance token from a hundred Instiincr may bn noted Itenntly a report from northern Mlehlgun reached hiss presl dent of tie Illinois Audubon society that Ihs passenger plgron In very truth had reappeared In Iho lclnlty of n cluli IIOUDO freiiicntrd by llshrrmen l and Runners many of whom hud known the pigeon well In thn old days and who were certain that In this ease they eoutd not ho mistaken ns to tho Identity of the bird vi l Horn gun club haul but nn ornithologist undertook Iho trip bcllcUng In his heart that finally thin passcnhcr plgeim hud been found for ho knew that tho men who had mode thus report had been familiar with tits bird In the old days and sup posedly know the appearnncoof Its every feather At thin end of the Journey ho was told that tho pigeons were hero and ho was led out to sea them They proved to ba mourning dove u bird common In nearly nil parts of Michigan and In moat of the state or thin Union The ill appointment was keen and keener In thl cat because this was ono report which seemed to have about It every mark or truth When I was a boy I know tho wild pigeon fairly well It was nothing Ilka as abundant as It had been In the years gonn b > but occa ilonally imall nocks were seen In the vicinity of my birthplace In the foothills of tha Adirondack mountain In central Now York 1 am sorry to nay that I eliot some of tho birds before I fully rcallted Iho value of giving protection to a van Ishlng race Tho mourning dove I know an well as I know thin lnRllili sparrow and I tljlnk that there Is no chanco of confusion In my mind re specting thin Identity of Uio dovo and Itl bigger relative the pigeon It Is possible though I am not sure that such is I n fact that I saw the last wild pigeon reported In Illinois Other may have been seen since that time within the bor ders of tho state but If so I have not seen their appearance reported At Ova oclock on the morning of a late April by fifteen rears ago I went Into Lincoln park

See the clipping