As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

January 1899

11 articles

The Middleburgh Post · Middleburgh, Pa.

The Smithsonian Institution reports that despite a liberal reward and extensive correspondence, no live passenger pigeon could be found, leading to the conclusion that the species is now extinct. The article contrasts this with earlier decades when passenger pigeons flew in flocks so vast they blotted out the sun, citing Audubon's observations of flights numbering in the hundreds of millions.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.

Wrong

The Middleburgh Post · 5 January 1899 · page 3

THE EXTINCT WILD riGEQN. Liberal Reward Offered Has Palled m Prod see n Uncle . The Smithaonian Institution has an nounccd that nil efforts on its part to obtain a Ihe specimen of the wild or passenger plgi on have n Milled in fail nn-. Nothwithstanding a liberal re ward was offered by the Institution, uml much correspondence uml inquiry carried on. no live passenger pigeon has been produced. That thii native American bird la ex tinct w ill no doubt astonish many per sons, for but a few years ago they wwr.

See moreSee less

so numerous an net aally to seem to out number the leaves on tlie trees through which they drove their amaiingly rapid flight, Persona yd in middle life can remember the vast tlights of pi geons that could be seen nnj day in the tall after the middle of Oetobi r. The birds in these flights were I j numerous that they stretched across the sky from horizon to horizon, and were so closely packed together that the sun was hidden for hours at n time. Audubon, America's greatest oral thologist, observed n flight of pigeons in Kentucky that extended as far as i the eye could reach, and was more than live hours in passing, lie attempted to compute the number of individual birds in the flight, and found that beyond queation there were more than joo.iMiO. i uii. Further, he estimated that there could not have been less than that num ber in the smaller tlights which were observed passing northward in great numbers early in the day. living very swiftly and unusually high. The first (lights appeared In lie the vangUBVd of an immense army patrolling' the blue Meld of heaven, tlie advance unherald ed by banner or bugle, yet possessing the dignity of overwhelming numbers. Audubon observed with the utmost wonder that the number of flights vis ible early in the day Increased and multiplied until the earth was fully canopied with the feathered hosts, through which only glimpses of the SUn could be seen. When the main body of the rank and lile had passed, there were yet detached regiments of guards to cover the rear tif the ilceing army. These stragglers continued to pass until dnrkness rendered them In 1 visible. This wonderful flight is well authenticated by many persons who were then living in the section of tho country the birds flew over Indian apolis News. Siberian Exiles. In 15 years Rus&ia has sent (124,000 persons to Siberia, fully 100,000 rela tivel of prisoners having accompanied i the exiles of their own free will. N. . World. Flaring Card Tax. Mosaow'a orphan asylum, founded by Catharine IL, it supported1 by a tax on flaying cards. Cincinnati Enquirer.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A veteran Pennsylvania resident reminisces about the closing of the Delaware canal and the end of the century-old lumber rafting trade, noting both expired together. He recalls the vast pigeon flights that once helped save the Delaware Valley from hunger, now part of a vanished era.

The Sun · 8 January 1899 · page 19

DELAWARE'S FINAL RAFT.

Beginning in 1701 of nn Imlnstry Thnt Drought Fortunes to aiany-The Great Flight of Pigeons Thnt flaved the Dela ware Volley from Hunger Olrt Iron aldes'a Mast Cut Out nt Miut Hope.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A reminiscence describes the hard winter of 1837 in the upper Delaware Valley, when crop failure and depressed lumber prices caused distress until vast flocks of wild pigeons arrived to nest and feed on beech mast. Residents slaughtered and sold the birds in huge quantities, with some shippers earning large profits, providing relief that the writer credits with saving the local population.

The Sun · 8 January 1899 · page 19

iy svttlod localities of thn Delaware alloy Lumber did not commnud enough to cover tho cost of rafting it. and It wns dlfllcult to obtain pay for what was sold Tho crops were ex tremely short, too, to add to the distress. It happened, how uv or, that beech nuta were un usually abundant the year befoie, and Sullivan and Wayne counties had extensive beoch forest. Wild pigeons then exlstod In this country In enormous numbers, nnd tho spring of 1837 brought them in countless thousands to the hteeh woods of tho upper Delaware, to nest nnd food on the mast that had lain under tho snow all winter. To sny there were thousands of them does not get

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

An aging local recounts a massive passenger pigeon roost that once arrived in the upper Delaware valley, where people of all ages shot, clubbed, and netted pigeons by the thousands to sell at markets via rafts. He credits the windfall with saving the local economy during a lumber slump, while noting the species has since gone unaccountably extinct.

The Sun · 8 January 1899 · page 19

I ,m5' V "y Plaintively that they ought to have V Wvrii.l,n I wish It wasn't argued on that rcadr nnd profltablo snlo. hot a few specula tors In pigeons cleared as much as J 1.000 enoli on soma trips, and before tho great pigeon roost broke up and tho birds took, tholr depar ture then, was moro money brought into the valley from tho sale of wild pigeons thnn all the lumber sont to market that spring returned to Its owners, and the lumbor country was saved. Some of tho solid mon of Sullivan, Delaware nnd Wnyno counties got their start In that pigeon yenr, nil owing to beech nuta nnd rafting. The Sway I camo to be hero at the death of

See the clipping

In the story →

The Black Hills Union · Rapid City, S.D. · and 4 other papers

Responding to a reader inquiry about the disappearance of the once-abundant wild pigeon, the piece explains that wholesale slaughter by market hunters at nesting grounds nearly exterminated the species, killing old birds and squabs indiscriminately for shipment to cities. It also notes trap-shooting clubs received live-netted birds, making sportsmen accessories to the market hunters' greed-driven destruction.

The Black Hills Union · 13 January 1899 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Where Are the Wild Pigeons. In response to an inquiry as to the cause of the disappearance of the once abundant wild pigeon, the information is here given that the wholesale butchery of these birds resulted in almost exterminating the species, says Wisconsin Agriculturalist. The market hunters followed the birds to their nesting grounds, where countless thousands of wild pigeons congregated to breed, and a merciless slaughter was indulged in, year after year, until few of the species remain. The larger portion of the pigeons (old birds and young squabs, indiscriminately) were killed on the roosting grounds, and shipped to the larger cities.

See moreSee less

A smaller percentage was netted or trapped and sent alive in crates to sportsmen's clubs and associations for trap-shooting purposes. The trap-shooting sportsmen of America are therefore "accessories" in the nefarious work of destroying the wild pigeons of the country, though the greed of the market hunter is mainly responsible for "the deep damnation of their taking off."

See the clipping

Also printed in 4 papers
  • Grand Rapids Herald-Review · Grand Rapids, Minn · 10 December 1898
  • The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D. · 15 December 1898
  • Blackfoot News · Blackfoot, Idaho · 7 January 1899
  • The Dupuyer Acantha · Dupuyer, Mont. · 16 March 1899

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This 1899 newspaper article reports that the passenger pigeon, once abundant across Pennsylvania and other eastern states, is now nearly extinct, with its breeding range shrunk to remote northern wilderness areas. It compares the bird's rapid decline to that of the American bison, noting that only small isolated colonies remained by the late 1880s.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 10 days earlier.

The Sun · 15 January 1899 · page 25

?rr.n viaRoss almost uoxk. The Historic Ilonsts Mnny Ynnrs Ako-DIi-npiienrnnce J.lko Thnt ot tlio Iluftnlo. Tlio passenger pigeon JCcloptetetMioratorlua of tho ornithologist, tho wild pigeon of tho siKiitsmnn onco so plontltul within tho bo rdors of Pomi8lrnnla and othor Hustoni States, Is doomed. Llko tho buffalo, its extinction Is only tho mnttor of a few years. Kvcn now thoro nro fow of theso birds frequenting places closo to our largo cities, whore a score of rears ngo millions nested nnd reared tholr joung. Tho breeding rnngo of tbo pissongor pigeon to-day Is nlmost wholly In tho sparsely settled wooded regions thnt form our extreme northern border, from northern Malno westward to northern Minnesota; nlong the Michigan pe ninsula, in tho central patts nt tho Domin ion ot Cnnndn nnd ns far north ns tho shores ot Hudson's liny.

See moreSee less

If they hato been breeding extensively In thoso rcmoto corners of the country In recent years, man litis no know ledge of It Isolated nnd scattering pairs still llnd a homo in tho New Lngland States, in northorn Now York and Pennsylvania, New Jersey. Michigan. Wisconsin, Minnesota and, furthor south, in Kentucky and eastern Tcn ncssoo. The onormous pigoon roosts of by gono yonrs. If thoy exist, nro In tho impene trable w lldorncss of tho north Tho extermination of the pnssongor pigeon has nrogrcssod oven moro rnpldl than did thit of tho American bison Tho Inttor's doud were counted by tho tens of thousands: tho wild pigeons by tho millions. Eight or ten years ngo, small colonics of wild pigeons frequented tho bocch woods in tho northern counties of Pennsylvania nnd southern counties of Now York. In tho Bprlng of 1888 n colony of 100 pairs were found breeding along tho shores ot n small crook In tho upper end of Pottor coun ty. Pa. This was tho last roost roportod from tho Stat. Slnclo pairs, howovor, breed In Pot ter, Plko and Monroe counties, Ta., ovon yet. In the counties ot Cumborland, Cnpo May nijd Atlantic, In southern Now Jersoj, a fow scattering pairs havo boon brooding In rccont years. Tho stories told by old sottlors In tho sparsoly sc tiled counties of rennsj It aula of tho big wild pigeon roosts they havo ivltncssed aro interesting Tho early spring of 1800 brought whnt wns probably tho largest nesting that ctcr took placo within tho bordotsot thntStato. Mchoopany Creek, Wyoming county, was tho scono of tho roost, which wns sot-en miles long nnd three miles wido. Of the thou sands of trees ndjacont to tho shores ol tho crcok. thoro wns scarcoly ono which did not contain nt least ono nest, while somo of thorn held halt n dozen nests. .A cotiBorvntlto cstimnto placed tho number of pigeons In this roost nt not less than half u million. Thou sands of the blrdsworo killed bypot liunters nnd nottors, wno shipped them to tho maikots of tho Eastern cities by tho carload This Pennsylvania nesting, howovor, wns a pigmy compared to that which took placo on tho southern peninsula of Michigan, about fif teen miles south of the Straits of Mackinac, in tho early Bpriue of 1870. Lato one afternoon tho wild pigeons began to arrive near Petosky. It was a dismal March day. The birds camo In tvv o bodies, ono directly from tho south by land, tho other following th east const of Wisconsin, until they renchod Manltou Island, whon tlio creat nrm y of birds chanced tholr course and flew straight across Lake Michigan. This lat ter body of pigeons came In from tho lake just before dark, and those who saw it say that It was a compact mnss of birds fully six mllos long nnd two miles wldo. The llrst Hock to nrrivo In the woods adjacent to Petosky was almost as large. With u foot of snow covering tho ground In the woods. w'cro the sun could not reach It, but with the I. dds hire, this monstrous body of birds began building their nests The colony extruded Its boundaries so rapidly that It soon spread oter a tast territory This nest ing wns twcntv-iilne miles long nnd Iioni three tollve miles, wide I'rom Petosky for nine miles through hardwood timber, then across n river swamp, nnd then on through tvventv miles of k white pine belt, did this throng settle livery treo of ant sue through this stretch of ivvonty uine miles contained a nest: many of thorn a dozen nests Tho nolso made by this count less mass of wild pigeons was deafening, their combined clamor being easily distinguished three miles away l'or six weeks tho birds remained nt tho Totoiky nesting. During this time several million birds were slain Nearly a thousand men waged a warlareor extermination against tho pigeons. The shipments of dead birds to tho distant city markets from Petosky nnd smaller towns along tho penlnsuln averaged two carloads each day for fully ono mouth, but with nil tills slaughter it is estimated that not ono bird in a thousand was taken. Owls and hawks pre cd upon both thoold blrdsnndtho squabs that occupied tho lasts to an alarming extent. '1 his Petosky nesting covered something llko 100,000 ncies of land. Tho number of (had birds oent by rail each day was counted at 14. fJOO. while an equal number wns shlpi ed by water Thlsdoes not Include l'Jo.OOOIIvobirds sent away by uctters In forty dujs more than l,r()0,000 were slaughtered A man vvhowas an oc-vvitnessof this great noiting declares that thousands of squabs were loft dead In tbo nests and thousands of dead uud wounded old blids were not secured, lleroughl estlmntfd that no les nu astound ing number than fn.(Mio,ooO pigeons were oaorillccd during the nesting The uettcrs who havo dnno so much to ex terminate the American wild pigeon are be coming almost ns scarce an nrtiele as tho birds themselves Tlio netters' excuse foi tho non appearance of tlnv birds In their formergreat numbers i that they hato been drlten Into tho uninhabited regions north or the gro it hikes. Into Hrltish North America This theory may in part be true, hut surely the Intense cold of the winters would causo them to Hock to warmer climes In tho warmer Southern States tew of these birds nro now to bo seen Tho migratory seusons como .111111 go, but tho I wild pigeon Is not counted nmoiig the birds that take flight, north or south The last big flight known to naturalists was that which took plni 0 in Michigan in the spring of 1KMH At cording tn men who witnessed tho fl ing of the pigeons that year, fully a quarter of n million birds wore on tho wing Tho netters wein on the alert on that occasion tolcaiuof the Inige nesting place these biids must hato rnaile, but ever effort tn llnd tho Hock proved futile The trackless woods of Hritisli North Amerien.no doubt, pioved to bo the pigeons' haven of safety The methods pursued by tho potters In cap turing the birds are tailed, the morn (ommou w.u being to hnto a doen or innio lito pigeons Willi thulrejellds sewed shut These blidsiire east into the space Inclosed by the net There they fluttcrn bout and decoy nrouml them thou sands or pigeons The neltur. hidden nttny be hind a ban lei of hemlock boughs, pulls bis Hi Ing nnil the net closi s over his pie) 'Iho nets often become so lull that tho struggling birds te ir it loose from the pegs to v. Inch it Is fastened, aiid ii, that vvav mail) esiapu '1 he wild pigeon bcinmis easllj bewildered tin one oceus on an immense flock of young birds became lo-t tv Idle noising Crooked Lake. Mlihignu. In 11 heavy fug linlend ol II) ing stia'ght ahead the) begnn In circle about I'l nallvtbe descended when iieui lug the shore, ami thousands or them stnn k 1 he water uud were di owned The shoi e of the lake for sev end miles was entered u foot or mmo deep with tlii'in. Thoold birds following cloudy behind lose nbovo the fog and none perished The il.ijs when wild pigeon sin 1 it Ing was .1 lending pastime among sputsiueii tun now but n lemembinnce 'Iho passenger pigeon, like the great auk 01 the Lu .Northland, is doomed to extlni tiou in this country

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A subscriber from Buffalo Lithia Springs asks the Dispatch what became of the wild pigeons that were so numerous before the Civil War, since none are seen in the area now. The paper replies that they have been nearly exterminated.

Richmond Dispatch · 15 January 1899 · page 3

Wild Pigeons, wo the Editor of the Dispatch: .. answer in your Query column v . become of the wild. pigeons 42.1 wore so numerous in this country ! ‘he civil war, and oblige

See the clipping

The Nebraska Independent · Lincoln, Nebraska

A writer reminisces about simple country pleasures of youth, including fishing, hunting, and trapping. He describes in detail how wild pigeons were caught using a large net rigged with ropes and stakes, hidden by a brush blind.

The Nebraska Independent · 19 January 1899 · page 8

rich and harmless, The fish rod, the. gun, the steel trap and the pigeon net afforded plenty of sport, Fishing brook trout Js one of the most excit

See the clipping

The Nebraska Independent · Lincoln, Nebraska

A reminiscence of camping in Pennsylvania mountains, trapping fur animals, and netting wild pigeons using a blinded decoy ('stool pigeon') tied to a board to lure flocks. The writer notes that such netting sport is now largely over, as wild pigeons have become scarce compared to the vast flocks of earlier decades.

The Nebraska Independent · 19 January 1899 · page 8

rich and harmless, The fish rod, the. gun, the steel trap and the pigeon net afforded plenty of sport, Fishing brook trout Js one of the most excit ing sports, requiring themist s-.ience and caution possible. A sudden wave of the pole or swing of the line puts the speckled beauty on his guard and at once his appetite for the tempting bait is gone lie will not bite Yen must keep out of sltfht yourself, he line must drop Into thewater neur the bunk or by the side of an old log with out splurge or racket.

See moreSee less

In a strange brook we preferred to flub up stream to explore, tlnn turn and fish, down for trout. The gun was a source of great sport, Woodehucks, squirrels, hawks and foxes were the near-by game, but a hundred miles away, among the mountain of Pennsylva nia, we found deer, wolves, and for once wa found a bear. A mountain camp, twenty miles from a honw or road, nothing to live on only what we carried in on our backs or killed with our guns or caught with a hook, hud a wild charm full of free Joy. Trap ping for mink, martin, muskrat, otter ami beaver, weekly visiting our traps, with gun Jn bornd, was romantic sport, and somewhat profitable withal, Hlx dollars for a mink or' mart In is no small wad and we have sold them for more, The cap of 'the climax, how ever, was netting wild pigeons, Our net was about ten by twenty, fastened one side to the middle of a long rope This rope in turn was fastened each etui to a stake driven into the ground. A brush bouse was built over one of the si iikes to hide us from sight of the birds, The other side of the net was fastened to the ground. Then the long rope, with the net, was drawn back and slipped under a hook and the ground or lied covered with wheat and while the pigeons were eating :he net was slid over them To call the pigeons to the Isiit we had a rtxd pigeon. We fastened bis f-et to ft strip of thin lwsird, then tb-d a long string to the board and carried the other end back to the brush house. J Jut before tying the pigeon to the stool we bad to sew his eyes op 'I'M was done by pushing the needle hrough the center of the under eye lids, then twUting the thread into a kink on top of the head, thus drawing the lids up over the eye. This seemed a little cruel at first, but ladies thrust needles through their ears The eye lid soon henle, leaving the hole for fu ture use. When we saw a Hock of pigon flying within a mile or so we would mine our stool pigeon fo;ir or five feet from the ground, Jet l' the string and he would nutter slowly to the ground, just as he would when lighting. The wild bird would see him atid down they would come by the dozen and some times by hundreds. Hut that sport is done with, there are but few wild pigeon now 'ihey used to fly over in the spring by ihe millions; the air would be full for days. They were fond of beech nuts and onk acorn and would turn over the leaves and pick up almost every nut. In the summer and fall they would do much damage in Ihe -sheaf fields. Young pigeon made the best if eating and were called squiilm. They I'l'iiernlly nested north of 'he lukes. sometimes In western New York. I'hey would till the trees with nests n thouMimd of seres and when tie yonn gplgeons began to fly they werv easily captured. Parents would) dd v - t . s well to buy the l'.vs guns -Mien I hey want ihein, rather than that they fre quent place of evil influence,

See the clipping

The Van Buren Press · Van Buren, Ark.

The Smithsonian Institution reported that all its efforts to acquire a live wild or passenger pigeon had failed, despite offering a reward and conducting extensive correspondence and inquiry. No live specimen could be produced.

The Van Buren Press · 21 January 1899 · page 3

obtain a live specimen of the wild or [ passenger pigeon have resulted in fail ure. Notwithstanding a liberal reward was offered by the institutionand much correspondence and inquiry carried on no live passenger pigeon has been pro duced. 1 Senator Douglass has introduced a bill

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The article describes the passenger pigeon as nearly extinct, with its once-vast roosts near large cities now gone. It notes that remaining birds are scattered in sparse numbers across northern border regions, with no confirmed large breeding grounds remaining.

The Times · 22 January 1899 · page 9

Almost Unknown. © The passing of the pigeon—Ectopistes migra torious of the ornithologist, the wild pigeon of the sportsman—once so plentiful within the borders of Pennsyl vania and other Eastern States, is doom ed, says the New Yorg Sun. Like the buffalo, its extinction is only the matter of a few years. Even now there. aré few of these birds frequenting places close to our large cities, where a score of years ago millions nested and reared their Young. The breeding range of the passen. gor pigeon to-day is almost wholly In the sparsely settled wooded regions that form our extreme northern border, from northern Malne westward to northern Minnesota; along the Michigan peninsula, in tho central parts of the Dominion of Canada and as far north as the shores of Hudson's Bay.

See moreSee less

If they have been breeding extensively in these remote cor ners of the country in recent years, man has no konwledge of it. Isolated and scat tered pairs still find a home in in the New England States, in northern New York and Pennsylvania, New Jersey,, Michigan, Wisconsin, Minnesota, and further south, in Kentucky and eastern Tennessee. The enormous pigeon roosts of by-gone years, if they exist, are in the impenetrable wilderness of the north. The extermination of the passenger pigeon has progressed even more rap idly than did that of the American bison. The latter's dead were counted by the | tens of thousands; the wild pigeons by the millions. Elght or ten years ago small colonies of wild pigeons frequented the beech woods in the northern coune ties of Pennsvivania and southern coun ties of New York. In the spring of 1888 & colony of 10 pairs were found breeding along the shores of a small creek in the 3 upper end of Potter county, Pa. This was the last roost reported from the State, Single pairs, however, breed in Potter, ! Pike and Monroe counties, Pa., even yet. IN OLD TIMES. 000 were slaughtered.

See the clipping