The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas · and 2 other papers
The report recounts a huge passenger pigeon nesting near Petoskey, Michigan, covering 29 miles and 100,000 acres, where hunters killed over a million birds in forty days. It notes conflicting estimates of the slaughter, up to 50,000,000 birds, and offers netters' theory that survivors fled north into Canada.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Topeka State Journal · 2 February 1899 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
FEW WILD PIGEONS LEFT.
[From the New York Sun.]
See moreSee less
The passenger pigeon—Ectopistes migratorius of the ornithologist, the wild pigeon of the sportsman—once so plentiful within the borders of Pennsylvania and other eastern states, is doomed. Like the buffalo, its extinction is only the matter of a few years. Even now there are a few of these birds frequenting places close to our large cities, where a score of years ago millions nested and reared their young. The breeding range of the passenger pigeon today is almost wholly in the sparsely settled wooded regions that form our extreme northern border, from northern Maine westward to northern Minnesota, along the Michigan peninsula, in the central parts of the Dominion of Canada and as far north as the shores of Hudson's bay. If they have been breeding extensively in these remote corners of the country in recent years man has no knowledge of it. Isolated and scattered pairs still find a home in the New England states, in northern New York and Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Michigan, Wisconsin, Minnesota and, further south, in Kentucky and eastern Tennessee. The enormous pigeon roosts of bygone days, if they exist, are in the impenetrable wilderness of the north.
The extermination of the passenger pigeon has progressed even more rapidly than did that of the American bison. The latter's dead were counted by the tens of thousands; the wild pigeons by the millions. Eight or ten years ago small colonies of wild pigeons frequented the beech woods in the northern counties of Pennsylvania and southern counties of New York. In the spring of 1888 a colony of 100 pairs were found breeding along the shores of a small creek in the upper end of Potter county, Pa. This was the last roost reported from the state. Single pairs, however, breed in Potter, Pike and Monroe counties, Pa., even yet. In the counties of Cumberland, Cape May and Atlantic, in southern New Jersey, a few scattered pairs have been breeding in recent years. The stories told by old settlers in the sparsely settled counties of Pennsylvania of the big wild pigeon roosts they have witnessed are interesting. The early spring of 1869 brought what was probably the largest nesting that ever took place within the borders of that state. Mehoopany creek, Wyoming county, was the scene of the roost, which was seven miles long and three miles wide. Of the thousands of trees adjacent to the shores of the creek, there was scarcely one which did not contain at least one nest, while some of them held half a dozen nests. A conservative estimate placed the number of pigeons in this roost at not less than half a million. Thousands of the birds were killed by pot hunters and netters, who shipped them to the markets of the eastern cities by the carload. This Pennsylvania nesting, however, was a pigmy compared to that which took place on the southern peninsula of Michigan, about fifteen miles south of the Straits of Mackinac, in the early spring of 1876. Late one afternoon the wild pigeons began to arrive near Petosky. It was a dismal March day. The birds came in two bodies, one directly from the south by land, the other following the east coast of Wisconsin, until they reached Manitou island, when the great army of birds changed their course and flew straight across Lake Michigan. This latter body of pigeons came in from the lake just be- their course and flew straight across Lake Michigan. This latter body of pigeons came in from the lake just before dark, and those who saw it say that it was a compact mass of birds fully six miles long and two miles wide. The first flock to arrive in the woods adjacent to Petosky was almost as large.
With a foot of snow covering the ground in the woods, where the sun could not reach it, but with the fields bare, this monstrous body of birds began building their nests. The colony extended its boundaries so rapidly that it soon spread over a vast territory. This nesting was twenty-nine miles long and from three to five miles wide. From Petosky for nine miles through hardwood timber, then across a river swamp, and then on through twenty miles of a white pine belt, did this throng settle. Every tree of any size through this stretch of twenty-nine miles contained a nest; many of them a dozen nests. The noise made by this countless mass of wild pigeons was deafening, their combined clamor being easily distinguished three miles away.
For six weeks the birds remained at the Petosky nesting. During this time several million birds were slain. Nearly a thousand men waged a warfare of extermination against the pigeons. The shipments of dead birds to the distant city markets from Petosky and smaller towns along the peninsula averaged two carloads each day for fully one month, but with all this slaughter it is estimated that not one bird in a thousand was taken. Owls and haws preyed upon both the old birds and the squabs that occupied the nests to an alarming extent.
This Petosky nesting covered something like 100,000 acres of land. The number of dead birds sent by rail each day was counted at 14,500, while an thing like 100,000 acres of land. The number of dead birds sent by rail each day was counted at 14,500, while an equal number was shipped by water. This does not include 125,000 live birds sent away by netters. In 40 days more than 1,500,000 were slaughtered.
A man who was an eye-witness of this great nesting declares that thousands of squabs were left dead in the nests and thousands of dead and wounded old birds were not secured. He roughly estimated that no less an astounding number than 50,000,000 pigeons were sacrificed during the nesting.
The netters who have done so much to exterminate the American wild pigeon are becoming almost as scarce an article as the birds themselves. The netters' excuse for the non-appearance of the birds in their former great numbers is that they have been driven into the uninhabited regions north of the great lakes, into British America. This theory may in part be true, but surely the intense cold of the winters would cause them to flock to warmer climes. In the warmer southern states few of these birds are now to be seen. The migratory seasons come and go, but the wild pigeon is not counted among the birds that take flight, north or south. The last big flight known to naturalists was that which took place in Michigan in the spring of 1888.
According to men who witnessed the flying of the pigeons that year, fully a quarter of a million birds were on the wing. The netters were on the alert on that occasion to learn of the large nesting place these birds must have made, but every effort to find the flock proved futile. The trackless woods of British North America, no doubt, proved to be the pigeons' haven of safety.
The methods pursued by the netters in capturing the birds are varied, the more common way being to have a doz- The methods pursued by the netters in capturing the birds are varied, the more common way being to have a dozen or more live pigeons with their eyelids sewed shut. The birds are cast into the space inclosed by the net. There they flutter about and decoy around them thousands of pigeons. The netter, hidden away behind a barrier of hemlock boughs, pulls his string and the net closes over his prey. The nets often become so full that the struggling birds tear it lose from the pegs to which it is fastened, and in that way many escape.
The wild pigeon becomes easily bewildered. On one occasion an immense flock of young birds became lost while crossing Crooked Lake, Michigan, in a heavy fog. Instead of flying straight ahead they began to circle about. Fi-
FEW WILD PIGEONS LEFT.
[From the New York Sun.]
The passenger pigeon—Ectopistes migratorius of the ornithologist, the wild pigeon of the sportsman—once so plentiful within the borders of Pennsylvania and other eastern states, is doomed. Like the buffalo, its extinction is only the matter of a few years. Even now there are a few of these birds frequenting places close to our large cities, where a score of years ago millions nested and reared their young. The breeding range of the passenger pigeon today is almost wholly in the sparsely settled wooded regions that form our extreme northern border, from northern Maine westward to northern Minnesota, along the Michigan peninsula, in the central parts of the Dominion of Canada and as far north as the shores of Hudson's bay. If they have been breeding extensively in these remote corners of the country in recent years man has no knowledge of it. Isolated and scat- ing extensively in these remote corners of the country in recent years man has no knowledge of it. Isolated and scattered pairs still find a home in the New England states, in northern New York and Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Michigan, Wisconsin, Minnesota and, further south, in Kentucky and eastern Tennessee. The enormous pigeon roosts of bygone days, if they exist, are in the impenetrable wilderness of the north. The extermination of the passenger pigeon has progressed even more rapidly than did that of the American bison. The latter's dead were counted by the tens of thousands; the wild pigeons by the millions. Eight or ten years ago small colonies of wild pigeons frequented the beech woods in the northern counties of Pennsylvania and southern counties of New York. In the spring of 1888 a colony of 100 pairs were found breeding along the shores of a small creek in the upper end of Potter county, Pa. This was the last roost reported from the state. Single pairs, however, breed in Potter, Pike and Monroe counties, Pa., even yet. In the counties of Cumberland, Cape May and Atlantic, in southern New Jersey, a few scattered pairs have been breeding in recent years. The stories told by old settlers in the sparsely settled counties of Pennsylvania of the big wild pigeon roosts they have witnessed are interesting. The early spring of 1869 brought what was probably the largest nesting that ever took place within the borders of that state. Mehoopany creek, Wyoming county, was the scene of the roost, which was seven miles long and three miles wide. Of the thousands of trees adjacent to the shores of the creek, there was scarcely one which did not contain at least one nest, while some of them held half a dozen nests. A conservative estimate placed the number of pigeons in this roost at not less than half a million. Thousands of the birds were killed by pot hunters and netters, who shipped them to the markets of the eastern cities by the carload. This Pennsylvania nesting, however, was a pigmy compared to that which took place on the southern peninsula of Michigan, about fifteen miles south of the Straits of Mackinac, in the early spring of 1876. Late one afternoon the wild pigeons began to arrive near Petosky. It was a dismal March day. The birds came in two bodies, one directly from the south by land, the other following the east coast of Wisconsin, until they reached Manitou island, when the great army of birds changed their course and flew straight across Lake Michigan. This latter body of pigeons came in from the lake just before dark, and those who saw it say that it was a compact mass of birds fully six miles long and two miles wide. The first flock to arrive in the woods adjacent to Petosky was almost as large. With a foot of snow covering the ground in the woods, where the sun could not reach it, but with the fields bare, this monstrous body of birds began building their nests. The colony extended its boundaries so rapidly that it soon spread over a vast territory. This nesting was twenty-nine miles long and from three to five miles wide. From Petosky for nine miles through hardwood timber, then across a river swamp, and then on through twenty miles of a white pine belt, did this throng settle. Every tree of any size through this stretch of twenty-nine miles contained a nest; many of them a dozen nests. The noise made by this countless mass of wild pigeons was deafening, their combined 6 lbs Dried Grap[es] 3 lbs Country A[pricots?] Fancy Evaporate[d] 3 lbs Silver Prun[es] 2 lbs Pitted Plum[s] 3 lbs Evaporated 2 lbs Evaporated Pitted Cherries, Fancy Apricots, 3 1-lb packages Fancy Peaches, [ 2 lbs Pears ..... 3 packages Seed[less] CE[REALS] Columbia Oats, [ 4 packages Scotc[h] 4 packages Quail 10 lbs bulk Scotc[h] Pillsbury's Vitos 3 packages Amer[ican] 3 packages Quail 5 lbs good clean 3 lbs fancy Japa[n] 10 lbs fancy H[ Beans .......... 5 lbs new Lima [ 10 lbs new green 7 lbs Split Peas 7 lbs Pearl Barle[y] 18 lbs Pearl Hom[iny] Mail O[rders] shore, and thousa[nds] water and were [ the lake for seve[ral] a foot or more de[ep] birds following [ above the fog a[nd] Sold in Although at th[e] may be much de[ and their propri[ verely because o[f] many of them a dozen nests. The noise made by this countless mass of wild pigeons was deafening, their combined clamor being easily distinguished three miles away.
For six weeks the birds remained at the Petosky nesting. During this time several million birds were slain. Nearly a thousand men waged a warfare of extermination against the pigeons. The shipments of dead birds to the distant city markets from Petosky and smaller towns along the peninsula averaged two carloads each day for fully one month, but with all this slaughter it is estimated that not one bird in a thousand was taken. Owls and haws preyed upon both the old birds and the squabs that occupied the nests to an alarming extent.
This Petosky nesting covered something like 100,000 acres of land. The number of dead birds sent by rail each day was counted at 14,500, while an equal number was shipped by water. This does not include 125,000 live birds sent away by netters. In 40 days more than 1,500,000 were slaughtered.
A man who was an eye-witness of this great nesting declares that thousands of squabs were left dead in the nests and thousands of dead and wounded old birds were not secured. He roughly estimated that no less an astounding number than 50,000,000 pigeons were sacrificed during the nesting.
The netters who have done so much to exterminate the American wild pigeon are becoming almost as scarce an article as the birds themselves. The netters' excuse for the non-appearance of the birds in their former great numbers is that they have been driven into the uninhabited regions north of the great lakes, into British America. This theory may in part be true, but surely the intense cold of the winters would cause them to flock to warmer climes. In the warmer southern states few of these birds are now to be seen. The migratory seasons come and go, but the wild pigeon is not counted among the birds that take flight, north or south. The last big flight known to naturalists was that which took place in Michigan in the spring of 1888. According to men who witnessed the flying of the pigeons that year, fully a quarter of a million birds were on the wing. The netters were on the alert on that occasion to learn of the large nesting place these birds must have made, but every effort to find the flock proved futile. The trackless woods of British North America, no doubt, proved to be the pigeons' haven of safety. The methods pursued by the netters in capturing the birds are varied, the more common way being to have a doz
Also printed in 2 papers
- The Times · Richmond, Va. · 22 January 1899
- The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont. · 5 February 1899