As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

November 1893

15 articles

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A mother and daughter died after drinking poisoned porter, and the shock killed the husband upon hearing the news; three siblings were arrested though evidence was weaker than in the Borden case. The report predicts this new murder mystery will become as notorious as the Borden case.

Alexandria Gazette · 10 November 1893 · page 2

A Dourle Murder Mtstery.? South Boston, Mass., has a murder mystery which is as fiendish in its de? tain as the famous Borden case, and which bears a remorkable resemblance to that case, except in the form of death, poison being used instead of a hatchet. A mother and daughter drank from a bottle of porter ana dropped dead al? most instantly. A post-mortem exami? nation revealed the fact that they had swallowed enough cyanide of potas? sium to have killed ten persons. Two sons and a daughter have been arrest?

See moreSee less

ed, charged with the murder, but the evidence which the police have thus far secured against them is not as strong as that arrayed against Lizzie Borden. This case bids fair to became equally celebrated in the annals of crime. The awful results of the crime did not end in the death of the two victims who drank the poison. Last night the husband and father learned for the first time of the tragic death of his wife and daughter, and in a few minutes he, too, was a corpse. The shock had killed him. Another daughter is lying at death's door aud the chances are against her recovery.

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

Lizzie Borden and her sister Emma have moved to a better house in Fall River after inheriting their parents' fortune, but critics continue to scrutinize her behavior. The report corrects sensational claims about her refusing mourning attire, noting neither sister ever wore mourning, even at the funeral or during the trial.

Iowa County Democrat · 10 November 1893 · page 3

THE BORDEN HOME. NOT THE SCENE OF THE GREAT MURDERS. CHEAP CRITICS STILL CARP AT HER CONDUCT.

If Lizzie Borden ever tried to live so as to satisfy her critics she has given it up as a hopeless task. They found no end of fault with her as long as

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

The New York Sun corrects false reports about Lizzie Borden's clothing, clarifying she hired a livery team rather than using her own horse, and that neither she nor Emma ever wore mourning attire. It also addresses misconceptions about their former home's furnishings and describes their new house and finances.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 18 days earlier.

Iowa County Democrat · 10 November 1893 · page 3

CHEAP CR TICS STILL CARP AT HER CONDUCT. Silt* ami Her Sister Have Purchased a House in a More Pretentious Street, Haring Come Into a Handsome Fortune —Suil Objects of Idle Cur iosity. If Lizzie Borden ever tried to live so as to satisfy her critics she has given it up as a hopeless task. They found no end of fault with her as long as she lived in the old house on Second street, Fall River, where the murders were committed, and now that she has moved into another dwelling in a bet ter part, of the city they say that she has come into the money of her mur dered parents and is making it fly.

See moreSee less

Among the sensational stuff that has been published about her recently is the news that she refuses to wear mourning and goes tearing through the streets in a buggy beside her sis ter Emma in a very light dress, while Emma dresses in deep mourning. Ac cording to the Now York Sun, the fact is that she inis on two occasions hired a livery team and gone out for a ride, her own and only horse being busied by the work on the farm, beyond the city limits. She has, indeed, worn a light gown—one of her old ones that the detectives pulled over as they nung in the girls’ closet in the old house after the murder. But Emma lias not accompanied her in deep or any other kind of mourning, for the simple rea son that neither of these original and interesting women believes in wearing mourning. They never have worn mourning. They did not go to the burial of the elder Bordens iu that attire. They did not wear mourning in court when Lizzie was tried for the murders. Liz zie wore a crepe dress part of tin* time, but. had a purple feather in her hat. The rest of the time she wore her black lace dress, with the same hat — but, according to the rulings of fashion, lace would not have been considered mourning, even had the hat been differ ut. Miss Emma Borden has recently had anew dress made, the lirst not able purchase of the kind made by eith er of flic women since the murders, j Their neighbors watch them pretty closely, and know all that they do. This new gown is decidedly not mourn ing. Feminine readers will know what sort of a dress it is when they are told that the name of its stuff sounds like “shallee do lane.” It is black with a green tigure iu it. The light gown that Lizzie is criticised for wearing is a light drab with blue threads iu it. The neighbors—both the friendly and the unfriendly—say that the testimony at the murder triad created a false im pression as to the way the Borden girls dressed. They never made any show, but always dressed very well indeed, in clothes of good material and plenty of them. They had their own means, iu money and mill stocks, and they made good use of them. There is equal misconception, not as to how they lived, but as to the style of their home. The parlor was newly and stylishly furnished for the use of the young women, and the rest of the house was set with substantial but not new fur niture. There will not be much to call the stepmother to mind in the new house, as Miss Emma gave all Mrs. Borden’s things to that lady’s sister, Mrs. Fish, of Hartford. This is the elder sister. Mrs. Whitehead, the younger one, wno lives in Fall River, is yet almost, a girl and would have found less use for them. In the new house in the select resi dence parr of the town the young wo men will live as they never were able to live in their old home, because their former home had practically none of the modern improvements. The old couple were satisfied without them and the girls were far more anxious to leave that neighborhood of stores and tenements than to have the old house modernized. As soon as they moved into their new home workmen took pos session of their old home and began to make it fit for rental. It would scarcely be thought that any one would be found who would wish to live in that house of horrors, but the women have already had ap plicants for it and can easily keep it rented. They will only rent it to per sons suitable to the neighborhood, that is to say, satisfactory to their old neighbors with whom they Jived twen ty years. There is never a day that sightseers do not linger around the old house, staring at it as if. by watching, they may be able to solve the mystery it once enveloped. Usually they stare at the right house, easily picking it out because of the barn behind it, but once iu a while a man or a woman will stand for half a day studying the wrong house and the people who go iu and out of it. When Lizzie was dis charged by the court and came back there to live she seemed to bear no grudges against those who had been obliged to testify during the trial With the exception of Miss Russell, her old companion, all the old friends were taken up again. Miss Russell is the girl who told about the burning of the Bedford cord dress. She is much to be pitied, for she was rudely dealt with in the Massachusetts press at the time, although she only told the truth. One other incident in the old house was the visit of Bridget Sullivan, who was murders. She called on the day that the family servant at the time of the Lizzie reached home. It was a short call, and has never been repeated. Very much that is utter nonsense has been published about the fortunes that the sisters have oome into. The “fortune” of the stepmother consisted of about $1,700 in cash and half of a tenement of the value of, possibly, $2,000. This property the Borden girls gave to the sisters of thefir step mother, Mrs. Fish and Mrs. White head. It will be remembered that this tenement was referred to in the testi mony at the murder trial Mr. Bor den had given the property to Mrs.

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's life after her acquittal, noting she resumed friendships except with Alice Russell, and details the modest inheritance from Abby Borden's estate given to her sisters. It explains the legal reasoning that because Abby was murdered first, her property passed to Andrew Borden's estate, which then went to his daughters, dispelling rumors of a lawsuit by Abby's relatives.

Iowa County Democrat · 10 November 1893 · page 3

Borden, and as it was apparently to the advantage of Mrs. Borden’s rela tives, tiic sisters were vexed with their father and his wife, bin particularly with her. It was after this that Liz zie ceased to address Airs. Burden as "'mother.” Emma had never called her anything but Abby. It is not true that the sisters of Mrs. Borden throat - ■ eued to sue for more than, has been j given them, or for any part of the es i late. The method of the murderer of j the old couple rid them of all title as !

See moreSee less

heirs, because it was proved that Mrs. | Borden was murdered first. Her pro perty, therefore, went to his heirs, and, when he was mtu-dered next, his pro perty went to his daughtrs. Mrs. Bor den’s sisters bad this explained to ■them, and had no intent ion to bring suit for a share iu the estate. The gift to them for their dead sister's little belongings was an unforced kindness on the part of the Borden girls. They have taken their father’s estate, which is commonly sjiokeu of its of the value of $lOO,OOO. it is probably less than' that, but is of a nature to increase greatly' as time goes on. On Aug. 5 Emma Burden filed a petition with the j clerk of the probate court iu Taunton i and qualitu-d, with a bond of $50,000, to act as administratrix of her father’s estate. The bond filed with the court ! by* Lawyer Wood, ;is administrator of All’s. Borden’s estate, was one of $5OO only. Alias Emma Borden is now in control of the estate fur her own bene- \ lit and that of her sister Lizzie. She 1 has uot yet filed a schedule of the

See the clipping

Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J.

A proposed Massachusetts legislature bill would require release on bail after six months of pretrial imprisonment unless witnesses are unavailable. The note explicitly ties this reform to Lizzie Borden's lengthy imprisonment before her trial.

Passaic City Record · 11 November 1893 · page 3

Bhall be released six months on bail, unless the government can prove that material witnesses have been enticed away or are unable to attend on ac count of sickness. This will prevent such long and unjust imprisonment as that undergone by Lizzie Borden.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The item notes that since her acquittal, Lizzie Borden has been socially ostracized and remains an object of public attention wherever she goes. It mentions she recently visited the World's Fair and enjoyed it because she drew little notice there.

The Morning News · 14 November 1893 · page 4

PERSONAL.

Ever since Miss Lizzie Borden was acquit ted of murder by the jury, she has been soci ally ostia:ised. She is still an object of at tention, whether it be on the street, in the cars or at church. The church people, it is said, would rather that she would not make her appearance in the sanctuary. Recently Miss Borden visited tho world's fair, but as she attracted little attention she enjoyed the

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A routine court report lists Supreme Court cases argued, including 'In re lost will of Julia C. Holt' with Georgiana Needham as respondent and a Lizzie Borden among the contestants and appellants. This appears to be an unrelated legal matter, not the Fall River murder case, and no further details are given.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 15 November 1893 · page 5

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Howard Times · Howard, R.I.

The report describes the Borden sisters' new home on French Street, a modest yellow and brown frame house in a fashionable neighborhood, reportedly purchased for $11,000. It notes Lizzie appears healthy and even improved, while her sister Emma's health has suffered greatly from the strain of the murders and trial.

Howard Times · 18 November 1893 · page 1

LIZZIE BORDEN'S HOME. It Is Now Near the Fashionable Avenue of the City.

French street is a modern thoroughfare set with prettf' villas, generally wooden, in o})en grounds with a showing of neat lawns, a few vases and tlowers and plenty of shade trees, The houses are small and of the type of dwell ings with which most of the smaller subrubs of this ¢ity are built up, The new Borden dwell ingis a yellow and brown frame house, with u little pointed tower on one corner of the roof and a porch in front and partly on one side. IThe house might have cost $3,000 or $4,000 to build.

See moreSee less

It is not as tine as several neighboring cottages, It is said that the sisters employ only one servant, as they did in the old house down town. Lizzie bears up extremely well after her re markable experience; indeed she appears to be as well as she ever was and stouter and better looking. The case 1s different with the older sister, The famiiy amliciion, the horrors of the murders and the long strain during Lizzie's trial were more than her nerves could endure, and she is nothing like the woman she was. Her health is far from robust, and she fre

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The report states that since her acquittal, Lizzie Borden has been socially ostracised by her community. She still draws attention in public, including at church, where congregants reportedly wish she would not attend.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 20 November 1893 · page 2

Ever since Miss Lizzie Borden was ac quitted of murder by the jury she has been socially ostracised. She is still an object of attention, v. ra ther it !»<• • n the hirer t. in the cars or at church. The church people. It is said, would rather that she would not make her appearance in the sanctuary. ( Jail Hamilton has published a pamphlet history of the cast* of Mrs. Maybrick of England, who is in prison under a life sen tence for poisoning her husband. Miss Dodge in it describes in detail the efforts she and others have made ineffectually to secure the release of the woman whom she believes to have been unjustly convicted.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The report describes Lizzie Borden living quietly with her sister Emma and servant Bridget Sullivan in a new home away from the murder scene, while the old homestead has been divided into two families' residences. It notes she is largely ostracized by the community, attends church irregularly, and wishes to return to charitable work she abandoned since the tragedy.

The Helena Independent · 21 November 1893 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

PURSUES A DARKENED PATHWAY.

Lizzie Borden's Life Clouded by the Shadow of Her Parents' Murder.

See moreSee less

The notorious Borden murders are still shrouded in mystery and continue to furnish a theme for conversation and speculation among the gossips of Fall River, Mass. Lizzie Borden, the younger daughter of the victims, the only known person who last saw her father alive, is living in a neat and comfortable home on French street, a mile or more from the scene of the tragedy and in the center of an aristocratic neighborhood. Her sister Emma and a servant—not Bridget Sullivan—live with her.

The interior of the old homestead has been remodeled, and two families have moved into it. One is that of A. C. Peckham, a grocer; the other that of L. L. Hall, a horse trader. The heads of the two families do business within two blocks of the gloomy house, and they smile derisively when their customers question them about ghosts.

MISS BORDEN'S NEW HOME.

Not since Lizzie Borden left her old home has she been near it. Mrs. Churchill and Miss Russell, her old time friends, still live in the vicinity, but she never visits them. She is practically ostracized, and when she appears on the streets she attracts no especial attention. She goes to church, but not regularly. Her presence is not welcomed by more than half her church friends, and after her occasional appearances it is not uncommon to hear many bitter statements regarding her. She has not taken up the church work she dropped many months ago, but one of her very few intimates recently said that she had expressed a wish that she might be enabled to enter into some of the work she "used to do before her pathway in life was darkened."

Her three firmest friends are the daughters of Charles J. Holmes and her sister Emma. They are very kind to her. Her new house is far more attractive than the one in which she formerly lived. Her reception room and parlor will compare favorably with those of any refined young woman, and the domestic facilities are as good as can be procured anywhere.

She recently visited the World's fair with Miss Caroline Borden, a maiden lady, who is much interested in her, though not a relative. She attracted little or no attention while on her way to and from the exhibition, and she told a friend on her return that she enjoyed every minute of her visit.

An inquiry at police headquarters by a New York World correspondent elicited the interesting information that five persons known to the police could clear up the mystery if they would tell the truth. Who these five persons are cannot be learned at present, but eventually they will speak if the police surmises are correct.

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The report describes Lizzie Borden's social isolation since the trial, noting she rarely visits old friends and faces mixed reception at church, though she maintains close ties with the Holmes daughters and her sister Emma. It also mentions her new house and an uneventful visit to the World's Fair, plus a claim that five people known to police could clarify the mystery if they spoke.

The Helena Independent · 21 November 1893 · page 6

MISS BORDEN'S NEW HOME

She recently visited the World's fair with Miss Caroline Borden, a maiden lady, who is much interested in her, though not a relative. She attracted little or no atten tion while on her way to and from the ex hibition, and she told a friend on her re turn that she enjoyed every minute of her visit. An inquiry at police headquarters by a' New York World correspondent elicited the interesting information that five per sons known to the police could clear up the mystery if they would tell the truth. Who these five persons are cannot be learned at present, bUt eventually they will speak if the police surmises are correct.

See the clipping

The State Rights Democrat · Albany, Oregon

A short item recalls that Lizzie Borden was tried in Massachusetts for the murder of her father and stepmother and was acquitted. It then mentions she has since come into some new situation, though the text is cut off before details are given.

The State Rights Democrat · 24 November 1893 · page 3

non-political Oregon grangers were solid- ,s p'ayedat Corvallis. ly for free silver; that thev were in favor ; Lizzie Borden, who was triej in Mass of legislation for lowering passenger rates ; c!.usetts for 'he murder of her father and

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The report notes that since Lizzie Borden's acquittal of murder, she has been socially ostracized. It states she remains an object of public attention wherever she goes—on the street, in streetcars, or at church—and that churchgoers reportedly wish she would not attend services.

Pawtucket Tribune · 27 November 1893 · page 1

Fver since Miss Lizzie Borden was nc quitted of murder by the jury she has veen socially ostracsed. She s still an otjeet of attention, whether it be on the

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A dispatch notes that Hosea Knowlton, who prosecuted Lizzie Borden, led his ticket in the recent Massachusetts election, outpolling the winning gubernatorial candidate. The report suggests his belief in Borden's guilt did not harm his public standing, despite facing a respected opponent later elevated to the bench.

Evening Star · 30 November 1893 · page 2

Asmounts to Over a Million Yen. SAN FRANCISCO, Nov. 30.-The steamer Peru arrived from Hong Kong via Yoko hama shortly after 1 o'clock yesterday af ternoon. Among her passengers were Rev, and Mrs. Wmn. H. Chalfant, board, of Presby terian missions, who have been at work in north Qhina for nine years. The Peru brings the following adivices from the orIent: In a fire which recently destroyed 247 houses in the French con cession at Shanghai two children lost their lives. Estimates have been made of the gov ernent grants necessary for repairing the damage caused by the late floods in Japan. the total amounts to over one millIon yen. a - BORDEN CASE RECALLED. Knowlton. Who Prosecuted Lissie. Led il Ticket in Masechusettm.

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The item reports that since her acquittal Lizzie Borden has been socially shunned, drawing attention wherever she appears, whether on the street, in cars, or at church. It notes that churchgoers reportedly would prefer she not attend services.

The Helena Independent · 30 November 1893 · page 3

know that she marrying a nobleman. The mother of Marie Bashkirteeff said in a recent interview that she still had much of her daughtea's diary that had not yet been published, and that the journal would not appear in its entirety until she herself was dead. MIse Mary Reed of Cincinnatit, who has contracted the malady herself while acting as a nurse among lepers in India, sent home asking that $50 be withheld from her mod est salary and devoted to the relief of the recent flood apfferers in thesoutlh Ever since Miss Lizzie Borden ws ac quitted of murder by the jury she has been socially ostri~lied. She is still an object of attention, ,wslether it be on the atre~t, in

See the clipping