As the Papers Told It

Lizzie Borden · The full archive

October 1893

13 articles

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A Providence man recounts spotting Lizzie Borden, recently acquitted in her sensational trial, enjoying the Chicago World's Fair with a female companion. He describes her as appearing free and content, though her face showed signs of the mental strain from her imprisonment, and reaffirms his belief in her innocence.

The Providence News · 4 October 1893 · page 3

A Providence man who has been visitin - the Worlds fair says: 1 was much as tonished one day to flud myself face to face with & woman who receutly had atiracted the attention of the entire country, and whose name was on every lip buta few weeks ago. It was Miss Lizzie Borden of Fall River. I was curl

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

This editorial argues that newspapers perform a public service by reporting crimes like those of Carlyle Harris and Lizzie Borden, rather than suppressing news to protect the guilty. It contrasts the public's right to know with the wishes of criminals who would pay for silence.

Evening Journal · 5 October 1893 · page 2

THE RIGHT NEWSPAPERS

In the jiotorious esses of Carlyle Harris aud Lizzie Borden, for instance, what would they not have given if they could have gone through the pre limlnary trials without publicity? How easily Harris could have proceeded in

See the clipping

Wood River Times · Hailey, Idaho

A newspaper item reflects on how Lizzie Borden's deportment during suspicion and trial influenced public judgment of her case. It notes the popular belief that innocent people often appear guiltier than the truly guilty, expressing surprise she endured the ordeal at all.

Wood River Times · 5 October 1893 · page 2

INTERESTING ITEMS

The loss of the Victoria is a fresh reminder of the worthlessness of life saving devices which are not kept constantly in older and ready for use. The ill-fated ship was provided with water-tight compartments and if the-e had been closed the hole made by the Campcrdown, terrible as it was, would not have resulted so ca lumitously. But the bulkheads were open and when the effort was made to close them it was too !ate. Eternal vigilance is the price of ,, , ,.. . safety as well as of liberty.

See moreSee less

• .........- - The deportment of Lizzie Borden at various times while under suspi cion had much to do with the trial of the lady. Now the innocent per son in that situation shows more guilt, according to popular judgment, than the guilty oue. An adept crime acts and looks innocent, while the innocent is overwhelmed with the shame involved in suspicion. This is not news to most persons, but it cer tainly is to a number who have their abiding-places in and aboutir all River and New Bedford. The wonder is that Miss Borden survived her ordeal

See the clipping

The Philipsburg Mail · Philipsburg, Mont.

The piece reflects on Lizzie Borden's life after her acquittal, suggesting her Puritan ancestry gave her the strength to endure the trial. It expresses hope that society will not hold the accusation against her, given she was found not guilty by a unanimous jury verdict.

The Philipsburg Mail · 5 October 1893 · page 2

The lot of Lizzie Borden for the rest of her life cannot be an enviable one. The recollection of the fiery ordeal through which she has passed will try the iron self control of even this woman with the

See the clipping

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo. · and 2 other papers

The report describes the Borden sisters' new home on French Street in Fall River, a modest yellow and brown frame house in a fashionable neighborhood, reportedly purchased for $11,000 though likely worth less. It also notes Lizzie appears to be in good health after her trial, while her older sister Emma has been visibly worn down by the ordeal.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 8 October 1893 · page 4

LIZZIE BORDEN'S HOME

It la Now Near the Fashionable Avenue ot Fall River. Tho new home of the Borden girls on French street is not on the best street in the town, but it is in a good neighbor hood and near the most fashionable ave nue. It was occupied by a man of means and good social position, who sold it be cause he wished to live where he could enjoy the fine prospect that is to be had from another point on the same hill. It is said that the sisters paid SII,OOO for the place, and that may be the fact, though the house scarcely warrants a belief that such was a true figure.

See moreSee less

French street is a modern thoroughfare set with pretty villas, generally wooden, in open grounds with a showing of neat lawns, a few vases and flowers and plen ty of shade trees. The houses are small and of the type of dwellings with which most of the smaller suburbs of this city are built up. The new Borden dwelling is a yellow and brown frame house, with a little pointed tower on one corner of the roof and a porch in front and partly on one side. The house might have cost S3,(XX) or $4,000 to build. It is not as fine as several neighboring cottages. It is said that the sisters employ only one servant, as they did in tho old house down town. Lizzie bears up extremely well after her remarkable experience; indeed she appears to be as well as she ever was and stouter and better looking. The case is different with the older sister. The family affliction, the horrors of the murders and the long strain during Liz zie’s trial were more than her nerves could endure, and she is nothing like the woman she was. Her health is far from robust, and she frequently has to give up. or rather to break down.—New York Sun.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo. · 10 October 1893
  • The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · 19 October 1893
  • The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · 20 October 1893

The Mt. Sterling Advocate · Mt. Sterling, Ky.

A Boston newspaper's popularity contest offering a free World's Fair ticket included Lizzie Borden as a contestant, and she garnered about 90,000 votes. When she appeared close to winning, her attorney Mr. Jennings asked that the prize go to the next-highest candidate, and a final push secured the ticket for someone else.

The Mt. Sterling Advocate · 10 October 1893 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Wood River Times · Hailey, Idaho · and 2 other papers

The item notes that criminals often imitate notorious crimes, citing two recent murders resembling the Fall River Borden case. One occurred in Indiana, where a man sleeping at home was fatally hacked with a hatchet despite many people being nearby, with no clues found.

Wood River Times · 11 October 1893 · page 2

When some bold law-breaker makes a departure from the worn ruts of crime there are always those who follow in hiscourse. Since the mvsteri ous Borden tragedy at Fall River there

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D. · 22 September 1893
  • The Baptist Headlight · Topeka, Kan. · 1 October 1893

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn.

The report describes the Borden sisters' new home on French Street in Fall River, a modest yellow and brown frame house reportedly bought for $11,000 though seemingly worth less. It notes Lizzie appears to be thriving physically after the ordeal, while her sister Emma has been worn down by the strain of the murders and trial.

Mower County Transcript · 11 October 1893 · page 5

It Is Now Near .the Fashionable Avenue of Fall River. The new home of the Borden girls on French street is not on the best street in the town, but tt is in a good neighbor hood and near the most fashionable ave nue. It was occupied by a man of means and good social position, who sold it be-* cause he wished to live Where he could. enjoy the fine prospect that is to be had from another point on the same hill. It is said that the sisters paid $11,000 for the place, and that may be the fact, though the house scarcely warrants a belief that such was a true figure.

See moreSee less

French street is a modern thoroughfare set with pretty villas, generally wooden, in open grounds with a showing of neat lawns, a few vases and flowers and plen ty of shade trees. The houses are small and of the type of dwellings with which most of the smaller suburbs of this city are built up. The new Borden dwelling

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

The report describes the Borden sisters' new house on French Street in Fall River, noting its modest size and cost despite being near a fashionable area. It also notes Lizzie appears to be in good health after the trial, while her sister Emma has been worn down by the ordeal.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 11 October 1893 · page 1

It Is Now Near the Fashionable Avenue of Fall Illver. Tlio new homo of the Borden girls on French street is not on the best street in tho town, bnt it is in a good neighbor hood and near tho most fashionable ave nue. It was occupied by a man of means and good social position, who sold it be cause ho wished to live where ho could enjoy the fine prospect that is to be had from another pjint on the same hill. It is said that the sisters paid $11,000 for tho place, and that may be the fact, though the house scarcely warrants a belief that such was a true figure.

See moreSee less

French street is a modern thoroughfare set with pretty villas, generally wooden, ill open grounds with a showing of neat lawns, a few vases and flowers and plen ty of shade trees. Tho houses are small and of the type of dwellings with which most of tho smaller suburbs of this city are built up. The new Borden dwelling

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A satirical news-in-brief column notes that Lizzie Borden's appearance at the World's Fair caused great excitement, contrasting it with Adlai Stevenson's unnoticed visit. The item mocks the public's fascination with Borden's celebrity after her trial.

The Providence News · 11 October 1893 · page 6

GREAT excitement has been caused by the ;“a of Miss Lizzie Borden at the World's fair. When Adlai Steven son was there noone knew of it except Adlai himself. Such is fame. - George Fraxcis TraiN wants to perpetuate the Worlds fair indefinitely. It this were it is just possible that George Francis might be in duced to transfer his bench from Cen

See the clipping

The Silver State · Unionville, Nev.

The report describes the Borden sisters' new house on French Street, noting its modest size, yellow and brown frame construction, and reported $11,000 price. It also notes Lizzie appears healthy and stouter after her trial, while Emma's nerves have suffered from the ordeal.

The Silver State · 12 October 1893 · page 3

Tlw houses are small and of a type of dwellings w ith which most of the sub urbs of this city are built up. The new Borden dwelling is a yellow and brown frame house, with a little pointed tower on on one corner of the roof and a porch in front and partly on one side. The house might have (■list ■j.'JOOO or $1000 to build. It is not as line as several neighboring cottages. It is said that the sisters only em ploy one servant, as they did in the old house down town.

See moreSee less

Lizzie bears up extremely well after her remarkable experience; in A deed she appears to be as w ell as she ever was and stouter and Ijetter look ing. The case is different with the older sister. The family] affliction, the horrors of the murders and the long strain during Lizzie’s trial were more than her nerves could endure. Her health is far from robust, and •he frequently has to give up, or rather to break down.—A . Y. Sun. »•«

See the clipping

The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I.

The report describes the Borden sisters' new home on French Street in Fall River, noting it is modest but in a fashionable neighborhood, possibly costing $11,000. It also notes Lizzie appears to be in good health after her ordeal, while her older sister Emma has suffered greatly from the strain of the murders and trial.

The Olneyville Times · 13 October 1893 · page 3

Fall River. The new home of the Borden girls ou French street is not on the best street in the town, but itis in a good neighbor hood and near the most fashionable ave nue. It was occupied by a man of means and good social position, who sold it be cause he wished to live where he could enjoy the fine prospect that is to be had from another point on the same hill. It is said that the sisters paid $ll,OOO for the place, and that may be the fact, though the house scarcely warrants a belief that such was a true figure.

See moreSee less

French street is a modern thoroughfare set with pretty villas, generally wooden, in open grounds with a showing of neat lawns, a few vases and flowers and plen ty of shade trees. The houses are small and of the ty_e of dwellings with which most of the smaller suburbs of this city are built up. The new Borden dwelling is a yellow and brown frame house, with a little pointed tower on one corner of the roof and a porch in front and partly on one side. The house might have cost $3,000 or $4,000 to build. It isnot asfine as several neighboring cottages. Itis said that the sisters employ only one servant, as they did in the old house down town. Lizzie bears up extremely well after her remarkable experience; indeed she appears to be as well as she ever was and stouter and better looking. The case is different with the older sister. The family affliction, the horrors of the murders and the long strain during Liz zie's trial were more than her nerves could endure, and she is nothing like the woman she was. Her health is far from robust, and she frequently has to give up, or rather to break down.—New

See the clipping

Orleans County Monitor · Barton, Vt.

A women's temperance column praises good men who help women, citing Governor Robinson's personal visit to Lizzie Borden before taking her case as an example of noble male support. The author claims his belief in her innocence, formed through private conversation, helped secure her acquittal.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 18 days later.

Wrong

Orleans County Monitor · 23 October 1893 · page 3

THE GOOD IN MEN. Miss Lorena Ellis, in a recent num ?r of Womankind, says: "It has been my pleasure to hear ated by some of the most progress e and gifted of women that the noest and purest of friendships were ose existing between men and wo en. The service a good and wise id honest man can render a woman - a good, uplifting comradeship can t be measured by mere words. Any pman wno proposes so race me rid, i. e., be in the thick of the conht for bread or fame, needs to be Id some things, kindly, but severe and truthfully.

See moreSee less

The man knows e pitfalls because he is a man. He bks at his feet; women's vision is ually straight out, often upward, e is apt to stumble where he avoids. Ilf I ever feel like praying, it is len I recall what some men have ne lor women, 1 ieei iiKe praying tit more men would arise like these. In the trial of Lizzie Borden, fresh the minds of all, she was upheld d carried through by the belief (in r innocence) of Governor Robinson. fore he would take the case, he Int to her alone and talked to her. ose two hours made him her friend d defender. He was as rain in the bert to her. She clung to his words d believed in his ability. Mutually

See the clipping