A 1905 promotional article about the city of Billings touts its modern amenities and includes a photo caption identifying Curly as General Custer's scout. The caption describes him as the sole survivor of the Little Bighorn battle.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
The Billings Gazette · 1 April 1905 · page 41
3Ï wm Curly—Scout for General Custer and Only m Survivor of Massacre.
Manchester Democrat · Manchester, Iowa · and 1 other paper
Citing Capt. Jack Crawford's account in Munsey's Magazine, the article claims Sitting Bull was a self-promoting medicine man rather than a warrior, and that he was not present during the actual Custer fight at Little Bighorn. It describes him as profiting enormously from his false reputation as the mastermind of Custer's defeat.
Manchester Democrat · 5 April 1905 · page 6
Sitting Bull, the Mncb Advertised Sioux Warrior, Wa» Coward. According to Capt. Jn«»k Crawford, formerly chief of scouts with the Unit ed States forces In the West, and who writes entertainingly in Munsey's Mag azine on "The Last of the Indian Chiefs." Sitting Bull, the once famous Sioux and reputed a mighty warrior, was a monumental fraud. He was a mere medicine man, and tecame noto rious Rimply because, with a few fol lowers, he refused to come in au«t accept the rations offered by I'ncle Sam. This put him Into the outlaw class, and he was regarded as an en emy to the government.
See moreSee less
In 187o he took to the hills and adopted the tac tics of the renegade. In the Little Big Horn fight, where Custer, the greatest of all Indian fight ers, fell with his gallant 300 scattered on the field of massacre, it was sup posed that Sitting Bull led the victo rious Indians, and the world long point ed to him as the inspiring spirit of Sioux vengeance. The truth is that Sitting Bull was not in the Custer fight at all. He was looking for one of his youngsters who had strayed awsy from camp, and he did not put in an appear ance until the historic fight was over. Nevertheless, the tremendous and sen sational self-advertiser was hauled all over the United States and Europe,
John Thomas of Minneapolis claims to have been part of Custer's expedition up the Little Bighorn, disputing another man's claim to be the last white survivor of the massacre. He describes serving as a saddler under Custer and says he avoided the massacre by accident when his horse was reassigned just before the battle.
ONE OF CUSTER'S MEN. sele Survivor of the Expedition Tell of His Escape. John Thomas. the sole survivor of General Custer's expedition up Big Horn, which was completely annihilat ed by the Indians. is a resident of Minneapolis. He is fifty-eight years old and lives at 2501 Aldrich avenue. After reading a dispatch in the Trib une stating that William McKee of that city claimed the hcnor of being the last white survivor of the massacre Mr. Thomas talked interestingly of the events leading up to the massacre and those which followed.
See moreSee less
"I knew McKee well," said Mr. Thom as. "He was not a member of General Custer's expedition, but was in Gen eral Reno's detachment. There was but one person who escaped alive, and that was an Indian of the name of Curley, who is now with the Buffalo Bill show. While I was in the expedi tion under command of General (`us ter, I was not in the massacre. It was only by accident, however, that I was not. When a young man I JMned the Indian fighters under command of Gen eral Terry. "My duty was that of a saddler. I cared for all of the harness, saddles and sometimes made myself-4andy as a shoemaker. With the other warriors, I was supplied with a horse. About a week before the massacre the entire expedition was camped on Tongue riv er. General Terry decided that the forces were to be divided, and 666 men were placed under the command of General Reno. General Gibbs of Mon tana was in command of a much small er detachment. "I was placed under General Custer, and everything was in readiness for the party to start when General Custer came to me and said: "'John, who Is using this horse?' "I replied that I intended to use the horse, to which he said that he wanted the horse fof a Chicago newspaper re porter. I Insisted on using the horse. when the general declared that he would consider his men a poor lot if they would not know enough to take care of their own saddles and harness for five or six days. These were the last words he spoke to me. I gave up the horse to the reporter and was sent to the boat under one of the captains of General Gibbs' army of scouts. "The reporter did not return; neither did any of the men under General Cus
The report describes the table used for writing the terms of Confederate surrender at Appomattox, now being loaned by Mrs. Elizabeth Custer to the War Department. It notes that her late husband, General George A. Custer, died in 1876 at the Little Bighorn massacre.
Daily Public Ledger · 7 April 1905 · page 2
partment, and will send with it, as its creden tials, as it were, letters from Colonel Marshall of General Lee's staff, the only Confederate eilicer present at the signing of the articles, and a plan of the old McLean house, with the posi tion of the table in the room properly indicated. Secretary Taft has written Mrs. Custer he will be glad te accept the table, as a lean, and will have it placed in the reception-room at the Department, the largest room in the State, War and Navy Building. He mentions that the War Museum has long been abolished, and
John Thomas, claiming to be a survivor connected to Custer's 1876 expedition, recounts how he was reassigned away from Custer's command just before the final battle. He disputes a rival claimant's survivor story and names Curley, a Crow scout now with Buffalo Bill's show, as the lone escapee from the massacre.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Virginia Citizen · 7 April 1905 · page 4
ONE OF CUSTER'S MEN. ???? ??r*l??r ?f the Ez??*maa T?-Ila> ?f Ul. K.ra,r. John Thomas, tbe sole survivor of General Custer* cxjiedition up Blg Ilorn, which was completely annlhllat ad by the Indlans. Is a resldeut of Minneai?olis. He ls ttfty elght yeara old and Ilves at 2501 Aldrlch avenue. After readlng n dlspatch in the Trib ane stnting that WIMInm McKee of that city clalmed tbe bonor of being the last wblte survivor of the massacre Mr. Thomas talked Intcre^tingly of the events leading up to the massacre and tbose which followod.
See moreSee less
"I knew McKee well," said Mr. Thom? as. "He was uot a member of General Custer'8 expeuitfon. but was ln (Jou eral Reno'a detacfameut. There was but one person who escaped allve, and that was an Indlan of tbe name of Curley. who is uow with the Buffalo BIU sbow. While I was iu the expedl tlou under command of General Cus ter, I was not in the massacre. lt was only by accident. however, that I was not. When a young man I joined tbe Indtan flgbters uuder command of Gen? eral Terry. "My duty was tbat of a saddler. I cared for all of the harness. saddles and sometimeaimade tuyself handy aa a shoemaker. With the other warrlors, I was supplied with a horse. About a week before tbe massacre tbe entire expedltlon was camped on Tongue rlv? er. General Terry decided that the forces were to be dlvided. and 600 meu were plnccd under the commaud of General Iteno. General Gibbs of Mon tana was In command of a much small er detachment. "I was placed under General Custer, and everything was in readiness for tha party to start when Oeneral Custer eame to me and said: M 'John, who ia uslng this horaeY "l replled that I intended to uae tbe horse, to which he said tbat he wanted the horae for a Cbicago newspaper re porter. I insisted on uslng the horse. when the general declared that be would consider his men a poor lot If tbey would not know enough to take cara of their own saddles and harness for flve or six days. These were the laat worda he spoke to me. I gave up the horse to the reporter and was sent to the boat under one of the captnins of General Gibbs' army of scouts. "Tbe reporter dld not return; neitber dld any of tbe men under General Cus? ter. All were kllled in tbe massacre. and with the exceptlon of the newspa? per man and General Custer the men were all scalped. Tlie Indlans had great love for Oeneral Custer, and for that reason It ls believed that they they dld not scalp him. As for the reporter. they found tbe papers on bis body nnd were eivilired enough to know tbat he was not tbelr enemy, but was a courier of news. "The Fall West. the name of tbe boat, made Its way up Big Horn nnd then up the Little Big Horu until ttie water became so shallow that it was dangerous to attempt to go fartber. The l>oat was run on to a sand bar. nnd we camped tbere for several dsys. We had nothing to eat but dry bread nnd meat. and all of the men were growing hungry. Before the captain was up one morning I took down my gun nnd started out for n hunt. I had Just ahot three elk when I heard two reporta from guns in dlfferent directlons. I made my way back to tbe boat, and the men were almost panic stricken. The news of the massacre had been recelv ed from some of Oenernl Iteuo's men. "I would hnve been In the massacre had it not l>een for Oeneral Custer tak? lng my horse and giving it to tbe re? porter. After the massnere I was uu? der Oeneral Oibbs. t'cncral Mllea was then aaatgaM to ?aaeaai Qaaaral Ter ry. Whlle I was out huntlng oue day I met Oeneral Mlles, en route to Ter? ry *s cainj| He was lost. nnd I directcd him. X& nftcrward l>ecnnie well ne quainted., Almost tbe flrst worda spo ken to me by Oeneral Mlles nfter we were en route to Terry** camp was to request me to 11 x his boots. He aald: 'My great toe is sticklag out of my boot. Can you fix lt? Sew It up with any kind of leather. I am not partlc ulsr.* I flxed tbe gcneral's boots with red calf leather. "There is one remarkable occurrence which happeued that I shall alwnys re member. One of the Indlans was shot flfteen, times, and all of tbe bullets re maincd in bls body. Flve days nfter the massacre he Jumned upou the bnck of n horse nnd with the flfteen l>ul' *ts ln his body rode to bls home. a dlsti..n??? of 200 mlles."?Mlnneapolls Trlbun-v
A man recalls that he was pulled from General Custer's detachment at the last moment when Custer gave his horse to a Chicago newspaper reporter instead, sparing him from the massacre. He also describes the chaotic aftermath, including the steamboat Far West's journey and meeting General Miles.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Democratic Messenger · Snow Hill, Md. · and 8 other papers
A veteran recounts how General Custer took his horse to give to a Chicago newspaper reporter just before the final march, sparing the narrator from the massacre. He describes the aftermath, including news reaching the steamboat Far West and his later service under Generals Gibbon and Miles.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Democratic Messenger · 8 April 1905 · page 6
ONE OF CUSTER’S MEN. |>l Survivor of tkr (expedition Tells of His Ksespe. John Thomas, tin* sole survivor of General Custer’s expedition up Big Horn, which was completely annihilat ed by the Indians, is a resident of Minneapolis, lie is fifty-eight years old and lives at 2501 Aldrich avenue. After reading a dispatch in the Trib une stating that William McKee of that city claimed the honor of being the last white survivor of the massacre Mr. Thomas tulked interestingly of the events leading up to the massacre aud those which followed.
See moreSee less
“I knew McKee well.” said Mr. Thom as. “lie was not a member of (Jeucral Custer's expedition, but was in Gen eral Iteno’s detachment. There wus but one person who escaped alive, aud that wus an Indian of the uume of Curley, who is now with the Buffalo Bill show. While 1 was in the expedi tion under commund of General Cus ter, I was not in the massacre. It was only by accident, however, that I was not When a young man I Joined the Indian fighters under command of Gen eral Terry. “My duty was that of a saddler. I cared for all of the harness, saddles and sometimes made myself handy as a shoemaker. With the other warriors, I was supplied with a horse. About a week before the massacre the entire ex]>edition was camped on Tongue riv er. General Terry decided that the forces were to be divided, and tJOd men were placed under the command of General Meno. General Gibbs of Mon tana was in command of a much small er detachment **l was pluced under General Custer, and everything was in readiness for the party to start when General Custer came to me and said: “ 'John, who is using this horse?’ “I replied that I intended to use the horse, to which he said that he wanted the horse for a Chicago newspaper re porter. I insisted on using the horse, when the general declared that he would consider his men a poor lot if they would not know enough to take care of their own suddles aud harness for five or six days. These were the last words he spoke to me. I gave up the horse to the reporter and was sent to the lxrnt under one of the captains of General Gibbs’ army of scouts. “The rei*orter did not return; neither did any of the men UDder General Cus ter. All were killed in the massacre, and with the exception of the newspa per man and General Custer the men were all scalped. The Indians had great love for General Custer, and for that reason it Is believed that they they did not scalp him. As for the reporter, they found the papers on his body uud were civilized enough to know that he was not their enemy, but was n courier of news. “The Fall West, the name of the boat, made Its way up Big Horn and then up the Little Big Horn until the water became so shallow that it was dangerous to attempt to go farther. The boat was run on to a sand bar, and we camped there for several days. We had nothing to cat but dry bread and meat, and all of the men were growing hungry. Before the captain was up one morning I took down my gun and started out for a bunt. I had just shot three elk when I heard two reports from guns in different directions. I made my way back to the boat, and the men were almost panic stricken. The news of the massacre had been receiv ed from some of General Iteuo’s men. “I would have been In the massacre had it not been for General Custer tak ing my horse and giving it to the re porter. After the massacre I was un der General Gibbs. General Miles was then assigned to succeed General Ter ry. While I was out hunting one day I met General Miles, eu route to Ter ry’s camp. He was lost, and I directed him. We afterward became well ac quainted. Almost the first words spo ken to me by General Miles after we were en route to Terry’s camp was to request me to fix his boots. He said: ‘My great toe is sticking out of my boot. Can you fix it? Sew It up wltb any kind of leather. lam not partic ular.’ I fixed the general's boots with red calf leather. “There is one remarkable occurrence which hap|>eued that I shall always re member. One of the Indians was shot fifteen times, and all of the bullets re mained in his body. Five days after the massacre he juuq>ed upou the back of a horse and with the fifteen bullets In his body rode to his home, a distance of 200 miles.”—Minneapolis Tribune. A Dos Hltrhlnis Post. Every one has seen the dog that rides behind Ills master ou horseback, and the dog that leads the old blind mnu, and the one that carries his master’s caue nr paper, and the dog that can do tricks, but It has Ihhmi left to an uptown expressman to utilize his little spaniel as a hitching post. Almost ev ery day he may la* seen seated by his master's side, with a strap attnch<*d to the collar he wears. When the team sto|>B and the expressman has to go Into the house the dog Jumps down, and his master fastens the strap to the horse's bridle. The dog will then sit down and look up into the horse's face and remain in tliut position till the ex prcßsman releases him. At this lie leups into the wagon, and they drive away.—Philadelphia Press. A Wonderful (Escape. An Italian of the name of Robarto was painting some of the Iran work of the bridge that spans the great gorge at Victoria falls, Africa, the other day. The plank on which he was standing tilted and precipitated him down the side of the gorge. He struck the rock three times, turning a half somersnult on each occasion, and eventually land ed among the foundations a hundred feet lielow. Beyond three sculp wounds and a severe shuking uud bruising he was none the worse for his adveuture. RUSSIAN PRISONS. fulelde or Madnoc the l'unl Kate of Their Victims. An Englishman writes in the St. Janies’ Budget of St. Petersburg pris ons: “Yet more horrible than the fate of the workers murdered in the streets of St. Petersburg is the doom of those hapless men whom the tender mercies of the triumphant bureaucracy have consigned to the dark fortress of St. Peter aud St. Paul and the inferno of the Schlusselburg. 'in Lake Ladoga. Well may the inhabitants of St. Peters burg shudder as they glance beyond the Neva at the dark fortress whence each hour the north wind brings across the river the discordant sound of its melancholy bells melancholy, indeed, for nothing but memories of suffering aud oppression sits upon Its granite walls. Here Peter I. tortured uud mu tilated his enemies. Here he slew his own son. Alexis, aud to this dungeon, during the reigns of the empresses, om nipotent favorites consigned aspiring rivals. Aud since then whole genera tions of men and women for no other crime than love of their oppressed country have entered these gates, often to leave them no more. “A special refinement of the Rus sian prison system in the ease of po litical prisoners and suspects is con tinued solitury confinement until, as in the case of that splendid intellectual reformer. IHuittri Passu re IT. they can be rejKirted as •harmless.’ Some pris oners here were relieved of tlieir senses quite gently aud almost politely. They were shut up in comfortable cells well lit by electric light, uud for mental pabulum they were supplied with only religious aud technical works. When insanity or suicide supervened the ap pointed end hail been secured. But the doom of others presents even great er feature's of horror. Imagine a dark, damp cell, measuring 10 by 0 feet, beneath the level of the surrounding waters, in whieli the chained man or woman is condemned to lie in absolute idleness, studiously Isolated from any intercourse with huinau beings. “For ten minutes every second day the miserable wretch is allowi*d to see the light and breathe the air in the pris on yard. For the rest Intolerable lone liness. absolute silence, occupation of not the smallest kind; no Itooks, no writing materials, no instruments of nianuul labor. Madness comes to such gradually with the passing yeurs. In the majority of cases the mind rots slowly in the eufoebling body. Suicide and madness are the two great weap ons in which Russian autocracy puls its trust.” The Man Behind the Gan. In a speech ou the naval appropria tion bill during its consideration by the house at Washington Mr. Spark mun of Florida brought out incidental ly the fact that the phrase "the man be hind the gun” cau be traced back to Napoleon aud very probably originat ed with him. Mr. Spurkman said: “It has been said that Napoleon upou hear ing of the victory of Jackson at New Orleans, with his handful of American soldiers, over the veterans of the Brit ish army who had conquered him, sent to America for the purpose of obtaining samples of the guns that hud wrought snch havoc among General Pakenhum’s forces in that great battle, but when his messenger returned, stating that the weaiion used was the ordinary flint steel hunting rifle of the American frontiersmen, he exclaimed: T sec how it is. It was not the guns, but the men behind the guns. Had I such sol diers as these I could couquer the world.’ ” A Railroad Incident. Rudyard Kipling has, of course, done more to familiarize the world with In dia than any one else. Here is an inci dent which Mr. Kipling tells ns an ac tual event, which has somehow es caped finding Its way Into any of his plans. books: A few years ago the native sta tion master of an Indian railway sta tion many miles from any city was at tacked by a tiger made bold by hun ger. His assistant instantly took ref uge in the office, barricaded the doors and wired for instructions to the near est town. Imagine the amazement of the operator at the other eud of the line to receive the following dispatch: "Ti ger on platform eating station muster. Pleuse wire Instructions.”
The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I. · 14 April 1905
East Providence Eagle · East Providence, R.I. · 15 April 1905
· · 28 April 1905
The Savannah Tribune · Savannah, Ga. · 13 May 1905
Holbrook Argus · Holbrook, Ariz. · 29 July 1905
Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D. · 6 October 1905
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A Minneapolis man named John Thomas claims to have been part of Custer's expedition and disputes another man's claim to be the last surviving white participant. He recounts a confused story of hunting near a boat on the Little Big Horn and narrowly avoiding the massacre.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 8 April 1905 · page 7
Jobson—Miss Blank looks awfully friv olous to me; what makes you think she has so much hard sense? Robson—I just heard her refuse an Invi tation to a card party because she couldn't play cards. at Ghe K. ® G. Store ONE OF CUSTER'S MEN. Sole Survivor of the Expedition Tells of His Escape. From the Minneapolis Tribune. John Thomas, the sole survivor of Gen eral Custer’s expedition up Big Horn, which was completely annihilated by the Indians, is a resident of Minneapolis. He is 58 years old and lives at 2501 Aldrich avenue.
See moreSee less
After reading a dispatch in the Tribune stating that William McKee of that city claimed the honor of being the last white survivor of the massacre, Mr. Thomas Reno's men. talked interestingly of the events leading op to the massacre and those winch fol lowed. "I knew McKee well.” said Mr. Thomp as. “lie was not a member of General Custer's expedition, but wys in General Reno’s detachment. There was but one person who escaped alive, and that was an Indian of the name of Curley, who Is now with the Buffalo Bill show. While I was in the expedition under command of General Custer. I was not in the mas sacre. It was only by accident, however, that 1 was not. When a young man 1 joined the Indian lighters under command leather. of General Terry. “My duty was tlint of a gaudier, l cared for all of the harness, saddles and sometimes made myself handy as a shoe maker. With the other warriors, 1 was supplied with a horse. About a week before the massacre the entire expedi tion was capiped on Tongue river. Gen miles.” eral Terry decided that the forces were to bee divided, and (106 men were placed under the command of General Reno. General Gibbs of Montana was in com From Hucress. mand of a much smaller detachment. “I was placed under General Custer, and everything was in readiness for the party to start when General Custer came to me and said: “ ‘John, who Is using this horse?’ “1 replied that I Intended to use the horse, to which he said that he wanted the horse for a Chicago newspaper re porter. I insisted on using the horse, when the geenral declared that he would consider his men a poor lot If they would not know enough to take care of their own saddles and harness for five or six days. These were the last words he spoke to me. I gave up the horse to the re porter and was sent to the boat under one of the captains of General Gibbs' army of scouts. “The reporter did pot return: neither did any of the men under General Custer. All were killed in the massacre, and with tinexception of the newspaper mail and General Custer, the men were all sculped. The Indians had great love for General Custer, and for that reason It is lndleved that they did not scalp him. As for the reporter, they found the papers on his body and were civilized enough to know that he was not their enemy, hut was a courier of news. plain Bill.” “The Fall West, the name of the boat,
A man identifying himself as a camp helper under Custer recounts personal anecdotes from the Little Bighorn campaign, including fixing General Miles's boots and losing his horse to a reporter just before the battle. He claims all of Custer's men died and were scalped except Custer and a journalist, and tells of a wounded Indian who rode 200 miles with fifteen bullets still in his body.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
An elderly Minneapolis man, John Thomas, claims to have been part of Custer's 1876 expedition as a saddler, disputing another man's claim to be the last survivor. He states only the Crow scout Curley survived the massacre, while recounting how a last-minute horse mix-up may have spared him from Custer's doomed detachment.
John Thomas of Minneapolis claims a connection to Custer's 1876 expedition, disputing another man's claim to be the last white survivor. He explains he served under Custer as a saddler but was reassigned away from Custer's final column before the massacre, crediting the scout Curley as the only true survivor.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
Peninsula Enterprise · 8 April 1905 · page 1
ONE OF CUSTER'S MEN.
those which followed, 4 “I knew McKee well,” sai Ms Thoid- + ~~ as. “He was not & member of General Custer's expedition, but was ju Gens’ eral Reno's detachment. There was but ene person who escaped alive, and that was an Indian of the name of Curley, who is now with the Buffalo. Bill show, £ d ter, I was not in the massacre. It was only by accident, however, that I was not. When a young man I joined the Indian fighters under command of Gen eral Terry. “My duty was that of a saddler, I cared for all .of the harness, saddles and sometimes made myself handy as a shoemaker.
See moreSee less
With the other warriors, I was supplied with a horse. About a week before the massacre the entire expedition was camped on Tongue riv er. General Terry decided that the forces were to be divided, and 666 men were placed under the command of General Reno. General Gibbs of Mon tana was in command of a much small er detachment. “I was placed under General Custer, and everything was in readiness for the party to start when General Custer came to me and sald: “John, who is using this horse? “1 replied that I intended to use the horse, to which he said that he wanted the horse for a Chicago newspaper re porter. I insisted on using the horse, when the general declared that he would consider his men a poor lot if they would not know enough to take care of their own saddles and harness for five or six days. These were the last words he spoke to me. I gave up the horse to the reporter and was sent to the boat under one of the captains of General Gibbs’ army of scouts. “The reporter did not return; neither did any of the men under General Cus ter. All were killed in the massacre, and with the exception of the newspa per man and General Custer the men were all scalped. The Indians had great love for General Custer, and for that reason it is belleved that they they did not scalp him. As for the reporter, they found the papers on his body and | were civilized enough to know that he | was not their enemy, but was a courler of news. | “The Fall West, the name of the | boat, made its way up Big Horn and | then up the Little Big Horn until the | water became so shallow that it was | dangerous to attempt to go farther. | The boat was run on to a sand bar, and | we camped there for several days. We || had nothing to eat but dry bread and | meat, and all of the men were growing “| hungry. Before the captain was up - | one morning I took down my gun and ) | started out for a hunt. I had just sho | three elk when I heard two reports | from guns in different directions. 1 | made my way back to the boat, and the f | men were almost panic stricken. The “| news of the massacre had been recelv {| ed from some of General Reno’s men. 2{ “I would have been in the massacre t | had it not been for General Custer tak -| ing my horse and giving it to the re y | porter. After the massacre I was un 1 | der General Gibbs, General Miles wa 1 | then assigned to succeed General Ter ¢| ry. While I was out hunting one da; o| I met General Milgs, en route to Ter "| ry's camp. He was lost, and I directe him. We afterward became well ac quainted. Almost the first words spc ken to me by General Miles after w y | were en route to Terry's camp was t 1 | request me to fix his boots. He said a | ‘My great toe is sticking out of m o | boot. Can you fix it? Sew it up wit . | any kind of leather. I am not parti 1 | ular, I fixed the general's boots wit 1 | red calf leather. d “There is one remarkable occurrenc , | which happened that I shall always r , | member. One of the Indians was she r | fifteen times, and all of the bullets 1 . | mained in his body. Five days afte d | the massacre he jumped upon the bac e | of a horse and with the fifteen bulle k | in his body rode to his home, a distanc , | of 200 miles.” —Minneapolis Tribune. n ————————— i The Man Behind the Gun. In a speech on the naval appropria tion bill during its consideration by the house at Washington Mr. Spark man of Florida brought out incidental ly the fact that the phrase “the man be hind the gun” can be traced back to Napoleon and very probably originat ed with him, Mr, Sparkman sald: “It ‘has been said that Napoleon upon hear ing of the victory of Jackson at New Orleans, with his handful of American soldiers, over the veterans of the Brit ish army who had conquered him, sent to America for the purpose of obtaining samples of the guns that had wrought such havoc among General Pakenham's forces in that great battle, but when his messenger returned, stating that the weapon used was the ordinary flint steel hunting rifle of the American trontiersmen, he exclaimed: ‘I see how it is. It was not the guns, but the men behind the guns. Had I such sol dlers as these I could conquer the world” tndecw Johnson's Workbench, A. Anderson, a tailor in this place, 18 now using one of the wost historic tai lor benches in Alabama, if not in Amer fea. It is a bench used by Andrew Johnson when he was a young man and worked in this county for a Mr. Sloss, who in that day was one of the leading tailors. Andy came here as a journey man and spent some time working for ‘Mr. Sloss, and the old tailor bench he ‘used to sit upon has been preserved un tll this day. It was discovered in the country many years ago by the late Captain R. B. Mason, who bought it as a relic and has kept it in his home until the recent fire destroyed the tailor shop of Mr, Anderson, when he was tendered the use of the table by Messrs. Greer and Robert Mason, sons of the late Captain R. B. Mason, and he has it now in his shop.—Athens Cor, Nashville Banner, 5
A Minneapolis man named John Thomas claims to be connected to Custer's annihilated expedition after reading of another man's survivor claim. His own account reveals he was reassigned away from Custer's detachment just before the battle and so was not actually present at the massacre.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
A Paris correspondent reports that a flag said to have been picked up from the Little Bighorn battlefield, belonging to Custer, is now in the possession of an American from Wyoming living in Paris. The item was prompted by Buffalo Bill's Wild West show reenacting the battle in Paris.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 10 April 1905 · page 3
Taken to Paris. Paris, April 9.—"Buffalo Bill's’’ repro duction of the battle of the Little Big Horn and Custer's last stand recalls tc a correspondent the fa;t that the flag of Gen. Custer, which was pic ked up on
A 1905 review of a minstrel show describes its opening segment closing with a tableau representing Custer's last stand at the Little Big Horn. The rest of the article details other performance acts including comedians, vocalists, dancers, and a band.
The Washington Times · 11 April 1905 · page 5
After the first part, which closed with a tableau representing Custer's last stand at the battle of the Little Big Horn, came a funny skit entitled “The I:cubator Ward,” with Morse and Gib son as the principals, assisted by Su-~ bers, Mocre, and Reed. Several cf the dusky babes put on exhibition were la beled with the names of well-known Shriners, causing much amusement. ! i Next came George Primrose, in ‘a num ber of his characteristic dances, which i showed that age has not deprived him
The report states that Mrs. Custer, widow of General Custer who died at Little Bighorn, is donating to the War Department the table on which General Grant wrote the terms of Lee's surrender at Appomattox. The item notes this as a kindness from her, marking the historic restoration of the union in 1865.
The Laramie Republican · 12 April 1905 · page 1
TABLE ON WHICH SURRENDER WAS WRITTEN. Through the kindness of Mrs. Cus ' ter, widow of General Custer, the dis . tinguished cavalry leader who lost his s life in the Little Big Horn fight, the » war department is about to receive i the table on which General Grant wrote I the terms of surrender of General - Lee’s army at Appomattox court house, r April 9, 1865, which marks the restor ation of the union of states.
A former army scout claims Sitting Bull was a fraudulent 'medicine man' who was not even present at the Little Bighorn battle, having been off looking for a lost child. The article says Sitting Bull later exploited his false reputation for profit before starting the Ghost Dance movement.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Aberdeen Herald · 13 April 1905 · page 3
AN INDIAN FRAUD.
Inning the time Sitting Bull wax set ting the stage and rehearsing his ghost dancers for the grand climax, he was no much afraid to show his face at the Indian agency that he sent one of tils sons to gather in the lii weekly rations supplied by Vncle Sam. The govern tnent authorities saw trouble ahead, and, knowing the Sioux tendency to maswacre, gave orders for the arrest of the old medicine man. Thirty-nine In dian police and four volunteers went to the home of the gruat maker of sig natures, anil found him In the midst of elaborate preparations for flight, lie submitted quietly to arrest, however, until one of his sons, doubtless famil iar with his father's cowardly nature, began to jeer and Jibe him.
See moreSee less
Sitting Bull, true to his reputation, called In a loud voice for rescue. A general melee was precipitated, in
The article, citing Capt. Jack Crawford's writing in Munsey's Magazine, claims Sitting Bull was never a true warrior but a 'medicine man' who gained notoriety only by refusing government rations. It further claims he was supposed to have led the Little Bighorn fight against Custer and was later killed along with his braves in a clash with Indian police.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Corvallis Gazette · 14 April 1905 · page 7
AN INDIAN FRAUD. SittingBull, the Much Advertised Sioux Warrior, Was a Coward. According to Capt Jack Crawford, formerly chief of scouts with the Unit ed States forces In the West, and who writes entertainingly In Munsey's Mag azine on "The Last of the Indian Chiefs," Sitting Bull, the once famous Sioux and reputed a mighty warrior, was a monumental fraud. He was a mere medicine man, and became noto rious simply because, with a few fol lowers, he refused to come In and accept the rations offered by Uncle Sam. This fit him into .the outlaw class, and he was regarded as en en emy to the government.
See moreSee less
In 1875 he took to the hills and adopted the tac tics of the renegade. In the Little Big Horn fight, where Custer, the greatest of all Indian fight ers, fell with his gallant 300 scattered on the field of massacre. It was sup nosed that Sitting Bull led the vlcto-
Corvallis Gazette · Corvallis, Or. · and 1 other paper
This report claims Sitting Bull was not actually present during the Custer fight, having been away searching for a lost child, despite his later self-promotion as the mastermind of Custer's defeat. It also describes how he later raised money by selling autographs and eventually started the Ghost Dance Messiah movement among the Sioux.
EITT1KO BUIX. rlous" Indians, and the world long point ed to him as the Inspiring spirit of Sioux vengeance. The truth Is that Sitting Bull was not In the Custer fight at all. He was looking for one of his youngsters who had strayed away from camp, and he did not put in am appear ance until the historic fight was over. Nevertheless, the tremendous and sen sational self-advertiser was hauled all over the United States and Europe, lionized and paraded as the greatest Indian general on earth. To be pointed, to as "the chief who wiped out Custer's command" meant something to an Indian, and Sitting Bull showed no reluctance about reap ing the profits.:.
See moreSee less
He raised the price of Sioux signatures from 10 cents to $1, and nearly got writer's cramp at that. But he discovered, like other American heroes, "that popularity is short-lived. His association with the palefaces had taught him the importance" of being earnest Therefore he Inaugurated the famous Messiah craze among his peo ple. He told them, with much beating of the tomtom, that their forefathers would soon return to earth, properly decked in war paint, and would pro ceed to wipe out the palefaces, yank out the barbed wire fences, burn the government posts, drive the United States troops into the tall timber, and return once again to the ' tepees and the watch-fires of the old regime. During the time Sitting Bull was set ting the stage and rehearsing his ghost dancers for the grand climax, he was so much afraid to show his face at the Indian agency that he sent one of his sons to gather in the bi-weekly rations supplied by Uncle Sam. The govern ment authorities saw trouble ahead, and, knowing the Sioux tendencyto massdere, gave orders for the arrest of rthe old medicine man. Thirty-nine In dian police and four volunteers went to the home of the great maker of sig natures, and found him In the midst of elaborate "preparations for flight He submitted quietly to arrest, however, until one of his sons, doubtless famil iar with bis father's cowardly nature, began to Jeer and Jibe him.. . Sitting Bull,, true to his reputation, called la aloud voioe torrescue. . A general meleewas , precipitated. In TTHEl SWEE 1 ' VOJCfSOF j P,RING. jj ! 1 . ' J V i pre405, Cincinnati Post which six Indian police and eight of AN INDIAN FRAUD.
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis. · 31 March 1905
East Providence Eagle · East Providence, R.I. · and 3 other papers
A Minneapolis man, John Thomas, claims to have served as a saddler in Custer's expedition but escaped death only because his horse was taken by a reporter days before the battle. He recounts that Curley, an Indian scout, was the sole survivor of the massacre itself, and that Custer and the reporter were the only ones not scalped.
-0 J O ter's expedition up Big ‘ ; Horn, which was completeSO Iv aununibilated by the In dians, is a resident of Minnespolis. He is fifty-eight years old and lives at 2501 Aldrich avenue. After reading a dispateh in the Tri bune stating that William MeKee, of that city, claimed the honor of being the last white survivor of the massa cre, Mr. Thomas talked interestingly of the events leading up to the massa cre and those which followed. “I know McKee well,” said Mr. Thomas. *“He was not a member of General Cuaster's expedition, but was in General Reno's detachment.
See moreSee less
There was but one person who escaped alive, and that was an Indian by the name of ‘Curley,” who is now with the Buffalo Bill show. While I was in the expedi tion under command of General Custer I was not in the massacre. It was only by accident, however, that I was not. When a young man I joined the Indian fighter, under command of General Terry. “My duty was that of a saddler. 1 cared for all of the harness, saddles, and sometimes made myself handy as a shoemaker. With the other warriors I was supplied with a horse. About a week before the massacre the entire expedition was cawmped on Tongue River. General Terry decided that the forces were to be divided, and GGG men were placed under command of General Reno. General Gibbs, of Mon tana, was in command of a much smaller detachment. “1 was placed under General Custer, and everything was in readiness for the party to start when General Cus ter came to me and said: *“John, who is using this horse? “I replied that I intended to use the horse, to which he said that he wanted the horse for a Chicago newspaper re porter. I insisted on using the horse, when the General declared that he would consider his men a poor lot if they would not know enough to take care of their own saddles and harness for five or six days. These were the last words he spoke to me. [ gave up the horse to tke reporter and was sent to the boat under one of the captains of General Gibbs’ army of scouts, “The reporter did not return, neither did any of the men under General Cus ter. All were killed in the massacre, and with the exception of thie news paper man and General Custer the men were all scalped. T®e Indians had great love for General Caster, and for that reason it is believed that they did not scalp him. As for the reporter, they found the papers on his body, and were civilized enough to know that he was not their enemy, but was a cour ier of news, “The Fall West (the name of the boat) made its way up Big Horn and then up the Little Big Horn until the water became so shallow that it was dangerous to attempt to go further. The boat was run onto a sand bar, and we camped there for several days. We Lad nothing to eat but dry bread and meat, aud all of the men were growing hungry. Before the captain was up one morning I took down my gun and started out for a hunt. I had just shot three elk when I heard two re ports from guns in different directions, I made my way back to the boat, and the men were almost panic-stricken. The news of the massacre had been received from some of General Reno's men, “I would have been in the massacre had it not been for General Custer tak ing my horse and giving it to the re porter. After the massacre I was un der General Gibbs, General Miles was ‘then assigned to succeed General Terry. While I was out hunting one day I met General Miles en route 1o Terry's camp; he was lost and I di rected him. We afterward became well acquainted. Almost the first words spoken to me by General Miles after we were en route to Terry’'s camp was to request me to fix his boots, He said, ‘My great toe is sticking out of my boots. Can you fix it? Sew it up with any kind of leather: I am not par ticular.” I fixed the General’s boots with red calf leather. “There is one remarkable occurrence which happened that I shall always re mewmber. One of the Indians was shot fifteen times and all of the bhullets re mained in his body, Five days after the massacre he jumped upon the back of a horse, and with the fifteen bullets in his body rode to his home, a distance of 200 miles.” —Minneapolis Tribune,
The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I. · 14 April 1905
· · 28 April 1905
The Savannah Tribune · Savannah, Ga. · 13 May 1905
The Star · Reynoldsville, Pa.
The article reports that Elizabeth Custer, widow of Gen. George A. Custer, donated the table on which Grant wrote the terms of Lee's surrender at Appomattox to the War Department. It notes Custer was killed in the Indian fight at Little Bighorn in 1876.
The Star · 19 April 1905 · page 7
Historlo Table Presented. Tlie table on wiueii G-:n. C,-nnt wrote tne. terms ot surrender of ucn. Robert E. Let's surrender at Appo mattox, April 9, JSfiG, has been pre sented to the Wnr Department by Elizabctii B. Custer, of Bronxvllle, N. Y widow of the late Gen. Gaorge H. Custer, who was killed In the Indian fight at Little Big Horn in 187G. The table was presented to Mrs. Custer the day after the sur render by Gen "Phil" Sheridan, and since that time has been In a fire proof storage house.
A woman's letter to the Houston Post recounts the story of Comanche, Capt. Keogh's horse, found wounded as the only living creature on the Little Bighorn battlefield after the massacre. It describes his rescue by litter, recovery, and later honored status in the 7th Cavalry at Fort Meade.
Evening Star · 23 April 1905 · page 49
COMANCHE.
Custer Massacre. Letter In the Houston X'ost. Some time ago I read in the Post a notice of a visit to a friend in Houston of Billy MacGee?a survivor of Custer's old com mand. Mention is made in this article of a horse, the only survivor of the Custer mas sacre. A perusal of this article freshens the memory of an old "army woman," and I send you the story. Perhaps you may care to print it. When Col. Reno's command reached the Custer battlefield on the Little Big Horn the only living thing in all that silent sol diery was the magnificent horse of tho martyred and lamented Capt.
See moreSee less
Keough?Co manche. He was grievously wounded many times, but not fatally, and the grief stricken soldiers were determined he should live: so they made a litter of the boughs ot trees, covered with "army blankets," and with many tender hands lifted Comanche on it and carried him "to camp," a few miles away, where the army surgeons and veterinarians soon had him on the "con valescent list," and later on. he was "dis charged from the hospital" well! Recov ered! Almost a miracle! Subsequently?In the winter of 1878 and 187U? my husband, a captain of Infantry, United States army, served with the re habilitated 7th Cavalry at Fort Meade, S. D., where Comanche also was "stationed." An order from the War Department had been received and read to the immortal 7th that henceforth Comanche was to have special care, a padded stall, an "orderly, especially detailed," to care for him, and that never again should he be ridden, but panoplied in "boots, saddle and saber." He was to be led at the head of the 7th Regi inent of davalry when on parade, in com memoration of those heroes who died with Custer. Comanche was a magnificent, powerful horse, in color a claybank or buckskin, with long, full or waving dark brown mflIM and tail. His coat was like yellow satin; his scars scarcely discernible, and lie would rear, kick and squeal like a veri table colt out on a frolic. One (lay Gen. Sturgus. the then colonel of the 7th. and commanding officer of the garrison, was on the steps of our "quar ters" when the orderly with Comanche came sweeping down "officers' row." t said: "Oh, general. I do want to put my arms around his neck." "Well, you shall,'' ?aid he. "Orderly, bring Comanche Urn
A newspaper theater listing announces that the Imperial Theatre Stock Company will stage 'Northern Lights,' a drama featuring actor William Courtleigh as an educated Sioux Indian. The play depicts an Indian uprising near Fort Terry, Montana, said to occur shortly before the Custer massacre.
The Providence News · 26 April 1905 · page 3
In response to numerous requests Mr. Willlam Courtleigh and the Imperial The atre Stock Company will produce at that house next week Harkins and Barbour's great drama, ‘““Northern Lighta™ This is the play In which ns an educated Sioux Indian Mf. Courtlelgh made one of his Featest successes, The play has to do with the Incidents attending and Indian uprising near Fort Terry, Montana, gliortly before the Custer massacre, ~An important feature of May Irwin's rerformances {8 the rendering of her “coon” ditties which have been syncopa ted for her exclusive use.
See moreSee less
The things she sings about this season are ‘‘Tennessee,” ‘Bible Stories,” “Can't you Guess?"' “In the Shadow of the Pyramids,” “I'm Wor ried to Death about That,” * ’'Tain't No fenee In Loving That Way,” “Expotenti tus"” and others, She will appear at the Providence Opera House the last three rights of the present week.
A newspaper review of a stage play titled 'Northern Lights' describes its plot, which fictionalizes the Sioux uprising and the destruction of Custer's Seventh Cavalry at Little Bighorn. The review focuses on actor William Courtleigh's performance as a Yale-educated Indian character named John Swiftwind.
The Providence News · 29 April 1905 · page 3
IMPERIAL THEATRE
| of this uprising during which QGeneral ! Custer and his Seventh Cavalry Regiment | went down to their swift ard awful ex | termination in the Little Big Horn Valley [ at the hands of the comßined Sioux tries
A 1905 reminiscence of the West Point class of 1861 discusses classmates' academic standings, contrasting Custer's poor scholastic performance with his battlefield fame. It notes Custer was killed, along with seven hundred of his troopers, at the Little Big Horn in Montana, alongside other reflections on deceased classmates like O'Rourke and Dennis Michie.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Daily Press · 30 April 1905 · page 7
I Point, a clnss whose members In after j years were among tho most brilliant j men of their time in the milllnry service. Brig.-Gen. E. I'. Alexander, C. S. A., class 1S57, stales that. "In i conversation with Colonel Ives, of I President Davis' staff, during a ride j along the lines, 1 asked his estimate [of Robert E. Lee. His reply was In* | presslve; stopping his horse and turn l ing Iiis face to me, ho snid: 'Lee Is I the most audacious officer in either ar | my.
See moreSee less
Confederate or Federal; he will fight quicker and longer and take more desperate chances than any general this country has ever scon and you will live to see it.' " Tho truth was?as still Is?Fitz Lee was a man of action rather than a student and in hnrscmnnsbip nnd all physical exercises be greatly excelled. U. S. Grant and Jefferson Davis, graduates of exactly the same grading and in classes of ncnrly the same strength, furnish good illustrations of the capabilities of the "middle-man" of the class. Longstrcet, Lee's lieutenant and corps commander, who as a scholar was considerably below the average. Is another instance of the middle-man of a class. To lliose of us who were closo ob? servers (as cadets ever are) of our officer-instructors at the academy? men who In carlcr years had led the columns of assault up the Heights of Chapultcpec, and drawn swords on the field of Ucuna Vista, and Palo Alto?evidence of (heir distress was not wanting In Hie hour of our coun? try's peril. The class of 1801, which reported at the. Academy in 1857, one hundred and eight strong, musters on the army list today bul five. Of the missing through forty years or more, the record Is in? complete; of the others wo here shall speak. O'Roukc, the leader of the class, and Custer, the last of scholastic file-clos? ers, each was hilled at the head of hfs regiment upon the field of battle?the former cut down In early youth at Gettysburg, and the latter massacred, together with seven hundred of his white-horse troopers, at ' Little Big Horn river, Montana. "Custer, ever at the head of his regi? ment," and Custer I without disparage? ment) "ever at th<y foot of his: class." Of O'Roukc, more anon. But. let ns fov a moment cxnmlno Into this pheno? menal scholastic performance of Cadet Cuslcr, leading tho "immortals" in a class of piio hundred?ngaln of eighty, of sixty, then fifty, and finally marker of n class graduating with but thirty, four members. Glorious old boy! Dnro-dovll of tho class! How well did yon h?ng on to the (tail-end?nlways ahead of tho de? ficient?foot of a class of thirty-four Vol. x.. no. 100. _new: