As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

March 1905

51 articles

Weekly Arizona Journal-Miner · Prescott, Ariz.

A New York dispatch reports that William McGree, said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, was found guilty of first-degree manslaughter for fatally stabbing Frank Mitchell. He was remanded for sentencing.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Weekly Arizona Journal-Miner · 1 March 1905 · page 7

NEW YORK, Feb.24. Wm. McGree, said to bo the last white survivor of tho Custer massacre, was found guilt; tonight of manslaughter in the first degree and was remanded for sentence. He was accused of fatally stabbing Frank Mitchell.

See the clipping

Potosi Journal · Potosi, Mo. · and 1 other paper

William McOe, claimed to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn, was found guilty of manslaughter in the first degree in New York. The brief report gives no further detail on the circumstances of the crime.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Potosi Journal · 1 March 1905 · page 2

William McOe. said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn river, was founi guilty of manslaughter in the first degree

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 2 March 1905

Fergus County Argus · Lewistown, Mont.

William McGee, claimed to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, was found guilty of first-degree manslaughter in New York for fatally stabbing his roommate Frank Mitchell in a December quarrel. McGee claimed self-defense; the report notes he later served with General Miles in the Nez Perce campaign after recovering from his Custer battle wounds.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Fergus County Argus · 1 March 1905 · page 1

Custer Massacre Survivor Arrested. New York, Feb. 24 —Win. McGee, said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, was found guilty of manslaughter in the first degree last night and was remanded for sen tence. He was accused of fatally stab bing FYank Mitchell, his room mate, on December 10, after a quarrel. Me Gee alleged that the stabbing was In self-defense. After recovering from wounds received in the Custer massa cre, McGee served with General Miles in the Nez Perce campaign.

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

A retrospective article profiles banker J.W. Raymond, noting that after the June 26, 1876 Custer massacre, Mrs. Custer and grieving relatives of the slain officers came to Bismarck, where the Raymonds hosted them. It then traces Raymond's later banking career in Jamestown and Minneapolis.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 1 March 1905 · page 7

i-i &, his wife that if she could endure such a life in ten years they would move back east. "On June 26, i376. occurred the Cus ter massacre and to Bistmarck came Mrs. Custer, and the grief stricken rela

See the clipping

The Forest Republican · Tionesta, Pa.

William McGee, reportedly the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, was found guilty of first-degree manslaughter in New York for fatally stabbing his roommate during a quarrel. He claimed self-defense and was remanded for sentencing.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Forest Republican · 1 March 1905 · page 1

Man Who Was With Custer Convicted

a motion for the appointment of a commission to take testimony from Minister Merou, at Washington, to substantiate the defendant's claim. Hot Springs Conflagration. The first estimates of damage done by tho great conflagration Saturday at Hot Springs, Ark., were not ex aggerated. More than 40 city blocks were destroyed by the flames, and the most conservative estimates place the loss at a million and a half dollars, while several insurance men say the figures will reach two million. Three unknown bodies rucove.-pd are the only known fatalities. $3,0OC,OCO Fire at New Orleans.

See moreSee less

The Stuyvesant docks, the exten sion terminal of the Illinois Central op. the river front at New Orleans, were swept by fire Sunday night. The two large grain elevators,',holding about a million bushels, were des troyed early, and tho other yards were attacked. It is Bald the loss will reach fully $3",000,000. Operation on Dr. Harper. Dr. William R. Harper, president of Uie University of Chicago, underwent a serious surgical operation In the Presbyterian hospital In that city. He Is afflicted with cancer. The condition of - President W. R. Harper of the University of Chicago, who was operated on last week for cancer, is said to be improv ing. In a bulletin Issued by attend ing physicians It was stated that Dr. Harper was making satisfactory pro gress toward recovery, all nausea hay ing disappeared. The patient took fluid nourishment and slept restfully. Man Who Was With Custer Convicted. William McGee, said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn river, was found guilty in New York city of manslaughter In the first degree Friday night In the criminal branch of the supreme court. He was ac cused of fatally stabbing Frank... Mit chell, his roommate, on Dec. 10, after a quarrel. After recovering from his wounds In the Custer massacre, Mc Gee served with General Miles In the Nez Perces campaign. McGee al leged that the stabbing was In jel defense. Ha was remanded for-"Sentence. Piatt Suit Dismissed. The suit of John R. Piatt, the oc togenarian millionaire of New York city, to compel Hannah Elias, negress, to return to him $085,000 which he alleges he gave to her dur ing a period extending over 25 years, was dismissed by Justice 0"Corman In the supreme court. Justice O'Gorman said the case was absolutely without evidence to sustain Piatt's allegation that the money was obtained from hlra by means of threats of bodily harm and exposure of their relations. Double Tragedy at Corning. Edward Keating, a wellknown mln Btrel man who has traveled with vari ous companies, shot and killed James Fulford on the streets of Corning, N. Y., Thursday night and. then commit ted suicide by taking carbolic acid. Fulford recently married Mabel Preston, and Keating accused him of stealing his girl. They had had trouble previously over the affair and had engaged in personal encounters. Bothwere young men, well known In Corning and in Elmlra. Investigation Will Be Thorough. President Roosevelt assure! Mr. Campbell of Kansas that all of the power of his administration necessary would be used In the Investigation he is undertaking through the bureau, of corporations Into the affairs of the Standard Oil company, to the end that tho small producer, dealer and con sumer alike shall have fair treatment, and that at the same time no Injustice shall be done the Standard Oil com pany or any other concern. Electrocuted at Telephone. Charles Holton, aged 28, night fore man at "Woodward avenue car house bf the ..Detroit United railway, was electrocuted ' while using the railway company's private telephone line. It was evident that the 'phone current had become "crossed with the current used for operating the cars. The telephone burned for three minutes after Holton had staggered away from it to fall dead. Preparing For Inauguration. Washington is assuming holiday at tire in honor of tho approaching inau guration ceremonies. Flags and bunt ing are being flung from tho fronts of buildings especially .along historic Pennsylvania avenue, over which the parade is to pass. Reviewing stands rapidly are rising along tho avenue, covering tho entire line of march from Seventeenth street to the Capitol. Senate Called In Special Session. President Roosevelt has Issued a proclamation convening the United States senate in special session at 12 o'clock noon on March 4 next to "re ceive such communications as may be made by the executive." . 1 ' House Passed Naval Bill. The house, after a seven-hour ses sion, passed the naval appropriation bill, carrying a total of $99,914,359. The provision for two battleships, as reported by the committeo on naval affairs, was retained. Richard Croker Sails For England.- Richard Croker, accompanied by his youngest son, Herbert, sailed for Eng land Saturday morning on the Cunard liner C'ampuuiu a motion for the appointment of a commission to take testimony from Minister Merou, at Washington, to substantiate the defendant's claim. Hot Springs Conflagration. The first estimates of damage done by tho great conflagration Saturday at Hot Springs, Ark., were not ex aggerated. More than 40 city blocks were destroyed by the flames, and the most conservative estimates place the loss at a million and a half dollars, while several insurance men say the figures will reach two million. Three unknown bodies rucove.-pd are the only known fatalities. $3,0OC,OCO Fire at New Orleans. The Stuyvesant docks, the exten sion terminal of the Illinois Central op. the river front at New Orleans, were swept by fire Sunday night. The two large grain elevators,',holding about a million bushels, were des one child. troyed early, and tho other yards were attacked. It is Bald the loss will reach fully $3",000,000. Operation on Dr. Harper. Dr. William R. Harper, president of Uie University of Chicago, underwent a serious surgical operation In the Presbyterian hospital In that city. He Is afflicted with cancer. The condition of - President W. R. Harper of the University of Chicago, who was operated on last week for cancer, is said to be improv ing. In a bulletin Issued by attend ing physicians It was stated that Dr. Harper was making satisfactory pro gress toward recovery, all nausea hay ing disappeared. The patient took fluid nourishment and slept restfully. Man Who Was With Custer Convicted. William McGee, said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn river, was found guilty in New York city of manslaughter In the first degree Friday night In the criminal branch of the supreme court. He was ac cused of fatally stabbing Frank... Mit chell, his roommate, on Dec. 10, after a quarrel. After recovering from his wounds In the Custer massacre, Mc Gee served with General Miles In the Nez Perces campaign. McGee al leged that the stabbing was In jel serious injuries. defense. Ha was remanded for-"Sentence. Piatt Suit Dismissed. The suit of John R. Piatt, the oc togenarian millionaire of New York city, to compel Hannah Elias, negress, to return to him $085,000 which he alleges he gave to her dur ing a period extending over 25 years, was dismissed by Justice 0"Corman In the supreme court. Justice O'Gorman said the case was absolutely without evidence to sustain Piatt's allegation that the money was obtained from hlra by means of threats of bodily harm and exposure of their relations. Double Tragedy at Corning. Edward Keating, a wellknown mln Btrel man who has traveled with vari ous companies, shot and killed James Fulford on the streets of Corning, N. Y., Thursday night and. then commit ted suicide by taking carbolic acid. Fulford recently married Mabel Preston, and Keating accused him of stealing his girl. They had had man. trouble previously over the affair and had engaged in personal encounters. Bothwere young men, well known In Corning and in Elmlra. Investigation Will Be Thorough. President Roosevelt assure! Mr. Campbell of Kansas that all of the power of his administration necessary would be used In the Investigation he is undertaking through the bureau, of corporations Into the affairs of the Standard Oil company, to the end that tho small producer, dealer and con sumer alike shall have fair treatment, and that at the same time no Injustice shall be done the Standard Oil com pany or any other concern. Electrocuted at Telephone. Charles Holton, aged 28, night fore man at "Woodward avenue car house bf the ..Detroit United railway, was electrocuted ' while using the railway company's private telephone line. It was evident that the 'phone current had become "crossed with the current used for operating the cars. The telephone burned for three minutes after Holton had staggered away from it to fall dead. Preparing For Inauguration. Washington is assuming holiday at tire in honor of tho approaching inau guration ceremonies. Flags and bunt ing are being flung from tho fronts of buildings especially .along historic Pennsylvania avenue, over which the parade is to pass. Reviewing stands rapidly are rising along tho avenue, covering tho entire line of march from Seventeenth street to the Capitol. Senate Called In Special Session. President Roosevelt has Issued a proclamation convening the United States senate in special session at 12 o'clock noon on March 4 next to "re ceive such communications as may be made by the executive." . 1 ' House Passed Naval Bill. The house, after a seven-hour ses sion, passed the naval appropriation bill, carrying a total of $99,914,359. The provision for two battleships, as reported by the committeo on naval affairs, was retained. Richard Croker Sails For England.- Richard Croker, accompanied by his youngest son, Herbert, sailed for Eng land Saturday morning on the Cunard liner C'ampuuiu sale. Forest Republican.

See the clipping

The Wisconsin Weekly Advocate · Milwaukee, Wis. · and 1 other paper

William McGee, who claims to be the only survivor of Custer's command at the Little Bighorn, is being tried for the killing of Frank Mitchell. The two had quarreled over cooking a kidney stew, and Mitchell was fatally stabbed with a kitchen knife.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

The Wisconsin Weekly Advocate · 2 March 1905 · page 2

William McGee, an ex soldier and for me; - resident of Texas, who claims io be the only member of Custer's force to escape the massacre of the command on the Little Big Horn, has been placed on tr'al hero on the charge of killing Frank Mitchell, last December.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • · · 4 March 1905

Rosebud County News · Forsyth, Mont.

William McGee, an ex-soldier claiming to be the only member of Custer's command to escape the Little Bighorn massacre, is reported to be on trial in New York for killing Frank Mitchell in December. The brief item notes his sensational claim alongside the murder charge.

Rosebud County News · 2 March 1905 · page 6

Claims to Be Cestcr Survivor. New York, Fob. 27. — William Mc Gee. an ex-soldier and former resident of Texas, who claims to be the only member of Custer's force to escape the massacre of the command on the Little Big Horn, is on trial here on the charge of killing Frank Mitchell last December.

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

A 1905 feature recalls the early life of J.W. Raymond and his wife in Bismarck, Dakota Territory, including the arrival of Mrs. Custer and grieving families after the 1876 Custer massacre. It traces Raymond's later banking career in Jamestown and Minneapolis.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 2 March 1905 · page 6

SS-TP-V "On the 26th cf June, 1876 occurred the Custer massacre and to Bismaick came Mrs. Custer, and the grief stricken relatives of the massacred officers. Mr. and Mrs. Raymond were noted for their hospitality and enter tainment. They at once extended the hospitality of their home to the stricken ones, which home became a haven of rest and quiet until their departure for the east. "Mr. Raymond started a good busi ness, having establised the Bank of Bismarck and in connection ran a wholesale grocery and supply store. In the meantime Eber H. Bly built the Sheridan House where the mag nificent new depot stands. 'On the 30tli of June 1880, J. W.

See the clipping

Pierre Weekly Free Press · Pierre, S.D. · and 2 other papers

William McGee, a former Texas resident and ex-soldier, claims to be the only member of Custer's command to escape the Little Bighorn massacre. He is now on trial in New York for killing Frank Mitchell the previous December.

Pierre Weekly Free Press · 2 March 1905 · page 3

Claims to Be Custer Survivor. ..... New York, Feb. 27. William Mc Gee, an ex-soldier and former resident of Texas, who claims to be the only

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D. · 2 March 1905
  • The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D. · 3 March 1905

The Brookings Register · Brookings, S.D.

William McGee, an ex-soldier claiming to be the sole survivor of Custer's command at the Little Big Horn, is on trial in New York for the December murder of Frank Mitchell. The brief item notes his dramatic claim alongside his current murder charge.

The Brookings Register · 2 March 1905 · page 2

Claims to Be Custer Survivor. New York, Feb. 27. William Mr Gee, an ex-soldier and former resident of Texas, who claims to bo the only member of Custer’s force to escape the massacre of the command on th< Little Big Horn, is on trial here or. the charge of killing Frank Mitchell last December.

See the clipping

The Bon Homme County Independent · Tabor, S.D.

The column reports that William McGee, said to be the last survivor of the Custer massacre, fatally stabbed a roommate and was arrested. The writer sarcastically notes his 'fighting blood' and that he now seeks release.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Bon Homme County Independent · 2 March 1905 · page 4

|. D. Rockefeller and the Rus sian Czar have troubles of their own. The people ot S juth Dakota see the necessity of a new capitol building at Pierre, but Senator Kittredge views the situation dif ferently. In Sacramento, Cal., two sena tors were expelled from the sen ate lor excepting bribes. That these two boodlers regard this humiliation as the lesser evil than being inprisoned is evident: es pecially if the bribe was fatter than a senator’s salary. William McGee who is said to be the last survivor of the Custer

See the clipping

The Evening Statesman · Walla Walla, Wash.

This article revisits the Little Bighorn battle nearly 30 years later, asserting that a scout named Curley was the only person to escape before the fighting began. It also recounts an unverified story about Lieutenant Harrington's death by suicide to avoid capture, based on secondhand testimony from a pursuer.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Potosi Journal, 1 March 1905, Fergus County Argus, 1 March 1905.

The Evening Statesman · 2 March 1905 · page 1

FORT YATES. N. D.. March 2.—lt is about time'for some alleged survivor of the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn in 1576 to turn up in some eastern city with stories of his escape. As a matter of fact, a half-breed named Curley, who escaped before the fighting began, was the only man who ever got away. This is well known to the In dians here, who certainly ought to know. Lieutenant Harrington"s body was never recovered, and the reason was always a mystery until the story was told some years ago.

See moreSee less

To this day many of the Indians who pa; ?;i in the fight do not know how he be came separated from his comrades and died some distance from the battle field. ' Lieutenant Harrington was pursued by the Indians for miles until all but two had given up the chase. Just as they had also about decided to give up, they saw a puff of smake and Har rington fell from his horse, dying by his own hand rather than to fall into the clutches of the Indians. The place where he died, so one of his pursuers says, is a muddy alkali flat, and it may be that his body was covered with mud. Anyway it was neved recovered. At the request of Lieutenant Harring ton's mother the writer has endeavored to find if any Indians ever had his Ma sonic charm or watch or other jewelry, which it is believed he wore at the time of his death, but without success. Mrs. Harrington wrote that "she bore no ill will against the Indians; it was war, each fighting for what they thought was right." Most of the trinkets and jewelry which the Indians took from the bodies or the dead were buried in a landslide some distance from the battlefield, where they had cached the plunder, and they themselves were never able to identify the place, owing to the change in the topography. A portion of the plunder was taken to the Wood mountains in Canada, where the In dians fled after the battle, and doubt less disposed of there. A story current is that Rain-in-theFace killed Custer. "Old Rain," as he is familiarly called, is still living here, but has used crutches many years. He did not kill Custer. None of the Indians knows who killed "Long Hair," as they call him. He fell in the general massacre. The days of boasting of the killing of white men have long been gone among the Indians, though they love to tell of their old hunting and fighting prowness among themselves. Of the Custer massacre they tell but little, and it is only after urging that you can get some old fellow, after much smoking of his long pipe, to tell with dramatic gesture the story of that fatal day in 1876. In a few years it will be im possible to hear the story first hand, as the old warriors are fast passing away. Mad Bear and John Grass, are noted chiefs who are still living. The for mer, who is over 70, is still a fine, up right Indian, and comparatively rich, having a big herd of cattle and horses and a beautiful ranch on the banks of the Missouri river. Grass is ailing this winter, but is still the leading spirit among his people.

See the clipping

The Evening Statesman · Walla Walla, Wash.

The report describes Lieutenant Harrington's unrecovered death and his mother's search for his effects, noting looted items were lost in a landslide or taken to Canada. It also debunks the popular legend that Rain-in-the-Face killed Custer, stating no Indian knows who killed him, while describing surviving chiefs like Mad Bear and John Grass.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Evening Statesman · 2 March 1905 · page 1

FORT YATES. N. D.. March 2.—lt is about time'for some alleged survivor of the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn in 1576 to turn up in some eastern city with stories of his escape. As a matter of fact, a half-breed named Curley, who escaped before the fighting began, was the only man who ever got away. This is well known to the In dians here, who certainly ought to know. Lieutenant Harrington"s body was never recovered, and the reason was always a mystery until the story was told some years ago.

See moreSee less

To this day many of the Indians who pa; ?;i in the fight do not know how he be came separated from his comrades and died some distance from the battle field. ' Lieutenant Harrington was pursued by the Indians for miles until all but two had given up the chase. Just as they had also about decided to give up, they saw a puff of smake and Har rington fell from his horse, dying by his own hand rather than to fall into the clutches of the Indians. The place where he died, so one of his pursuers says, is a muddy alkali flat, and it may be that his body was covered with mud. Anyway it was neved recovered. At the request of Lieutenant Harring ton's mother the writer has endeavored to find if any Indians ever had his Ma sonic charm or watch or other jewelry, which it is believed he wore at the time of his death, but without success. Mrs. Harrington wrote that "she bore no ill will against the Indians; it was war, each fighting for what they thought was right." Most of the trinkets and jewelry which the Indians took from the bodies or the dead were buried in a landslide some distance from the battlefield, where they had cached the plunder, and they themselves were never able to identify the place, owing to the change in the topography. A portion of the plunder was taken to the Wood mountains in Canada, where the In dians fled after the battle, and doubt less disposed of there. A story current is that Rain-in-theFace killed Custer. "Old Rain," as he is familiarly called, is still living here, but has used crutches many years. He did not kill Custer. None of the Indians knows who killed "Long Hair," as they call him. He fell in the general massacre. The days of boasting of the killing of white men have long been gone among the Indians, though they love to tell of their old hunting and fighting prowness among themselves. Of the Custer massacre they tell but little, and it is only after urging that you can get some old fellow, after much smoking of his long pipe, to tell with dramatic gesture the story of that fatal day in 1876. In a few years it will be im possible to hear the story first hand, as the old warriors are fast passing away. Mad Bear and John Grass, are noted chiefs who are still living. The for mer, who is over 70, is still a fine, up right Indian, and comparatively rich, having a big herd of cattle and horses and a beautiful ranch on the banks of the Missouri river. Grass is ailing this winter, but is still the leading spirit among his people.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

A New York dispatch reports that William McGee, who claims to be the only member of Custer's command to escape the Little Bighorn massacre, has been placed on trial for killing Frank Mitchell in a December quarrel. The men reportedly fought over cooking a meal, and Mitchell was stabbed with a kitchen knife before McGee surrendered.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 2 March 1905 · page 2

■ I The Washington lea is lain re has prsaed a bill to submit to apo ular ; vote the question of the rcmovul of the stste capital front Ofympla to Tacoma. ( M*v” I bey an Atherly to repeal the bill {/ the result of the election should t Aot praaa aat'afaclory? li- . 9 , Kansas. {Fast Virginia, Washing ton, Nebraskaajfcj Coloradoan* all en- । g"^ j# a fight against the Standard OH xxgßiany, wbits |s resisting the develupOMMH ms th" resources of the | states named, and ttaU'rfejJcr and hl* fellow “magnauw” bald a m»M*ung at । N» w York last week m wbtcb it was determined U> lake the field against । the figbl^ru If hoth side* arc h« much in earnest na a^tn to be we rm»t | prepare to wita«^ (Jut hattla of ^Armageddon.

See moreSee less

if 1 ■■ । A New York dispatch says: “IVIL 'II am McGee. an ex-soldier and a fowier t /^addeul of Trias, who claims to Ite the only member of Custer's force to escape , the masaaerr of his command on the Little Big Horn, has been placed on ( »lr|gl here on a charge of killing Prank MM*tLell last Decemispr. McGee boardt rd with K«V'brll ,«od the men quarreled over the gmupcr way of COnOOCting n v Aldor y slow Miu-brll was subbed t with a kitchen moj/c arid Metier surI rendered UUie pufuw w/xio kwraing of t =?=i.' . j The state hoHrd of sheep rommlaAionm re organised at s meeting held j; At Douglas last week, electing Dr. J M. Wilson president and Gemgn 8. Wah i

See the clipping

The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN

William McGee, who claimed to be the last white survivor of Custer's defeat at the Little Big Horn, was found guilty of manslaughter in the first degree in New York. The report notes his purported connection to the famous battle alongside details of his conviction.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Kanabec County Times · 3 March 1905 · page 6

William McGee, said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn river, was found guilty of manslaughter in the first degree

See the clipping

The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn.

William McGee, claimed to be the last white survivor of Custer's Little Bighorn massacre, was found guilty of first-degree manslaughter in New York for fatally stabbing his roommate. He awaits sentencing for the December killing.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Ely Miner · 3 March 1905 · page 3

New York, Feb. 25. —William McGee, said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre on the Little Big Horn river, was found guilty of man slaughter in the first degree here Fri day night and w'as remanded for sen tence. He was accused of fatally stab bing Frank Mitchell, his room mate, on December 10, after a quarrel. Fatally Shoots Sister. Muncie, Ind., Feb. 23—Rudyard Foust, the four-year-old sonoi Mr. and Mrs. Fred Foust, fatally shot his sister, three years old, through the head with a revolver.

See the clipping

The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn.

William McGee, claimed to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn, was found guilty of first-degree manslaughter in New York. He was accused of fatally stabbing his roommate Frank Mitchell after a quarrel on December 10.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Worthington Advance · 3 March 1905 · page 7

New York, Feb 25.—"WHIiamMcGee, said to be the last white survivor of the" Custer masdacre on the Little Big Horn river, was found guilty of man­ slaughter in the first degree here Fri­ day night and was remanded for sen­ tence. He was accused of fatally stab­ bing Frank Mitchell, his room mate, on December 10, after a quarrel. Fatally Shoots Sister. Muncie, Ind., Feb. 23.—Rudyard Foust, the four-year-old son of Mr. and Mrs. Fred Foust, fatally shot his sister, three years old. through the head with a revolver.

See the clipping

The Montgomery Tribune · Montgomery City, Mo.

A brief news item reports that William Medea, described as the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, has been convicted of first-degree manslaughter in New York for stabbing Frank Mitchell to death after a quarrel. The item appears amid a roundup of miscellaneous national and international news briefs.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Montgomery Tribune · 3 March 1905 · page 2

William Medea, said lo be th last white survivor of the Custer massacre, who stabbed Frank Mitchell faulty la New York, after a quarrel, has been contlcted of manslaughter In the first

See the clipping

Lincoln County Record · Pioche, Nev.

William McGee, described as the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, was found guilty of first-degree manslaughter in New York City for fatally stabbing his roommate Frank Mitchell after a quarrel. McGee claimed self-defense, and the report notes he later served with General Miles in the Nez Perce campaign after recovering from wounds at Little Bighorn.

Lincoln County Record · 3 March 1905 · page 3

Killed In a Saloon Row. News has reached Ukiah, Cal that Antone Maessi was shot, and killed during a bar room row in a saloon In Fort Bragg. Serfraflno Necclarl, who had stopped in front of the place to light a cigarette before hostilltes com menced, received a charge of shot in the neck and shoulder, and is hovering between life and death at the hospital. The inmates of the saloon have not yet told who did the shooting or what the row was about. About a dozen shots were fired.

See moreSee less

Survivor of Custer Massacre Convipted of Manslaughter. William McGeo, said to be the last; white survivor of the Custer massacre, was found guilty of manslaughter in he first degree In New York City aad was remanded for sentence. He was! accused of fatally stabbing Frank1 Mitchell, his room mate, on December' 10, after a quarrel. Mcfiee alleged that the stabbing was In self-defense. After recovering from the wounds recvived ia the Custer massacre, Mi-Gee served with General Miles in the Nez Peres campaign.

See the clipping

The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D.

William McGee, described as the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, was convicted of manslaughter in the first degree for fatally stabbing his roommate Frank Mitchell. He was remanded for sentencing.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Mitchell Capital · 3 March 1905 · page 2

THE LAST SUfiViVOR. "Hiis Time the Sote Living Member o» Custer's Force Is Convicted of Manslaughter. New York, Feb. 1'T. WiULun McCce. said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, was convict cd of manslaughter mate, on December Hi after a quarrel. Mc1 lee alleged that the stabbing was in self-' highly defense. After recovering from the wound? re ooived in the Custer massacre. McGee {served with General Mlks in the Nea Perces campaign.

See the clipping

The Sisseton Weekly Standard · Sisseton, S.D.

William McGee, an ex-soldier claiming to be the only member of Custer's command to survive the Little Big Horn massacre, is on trial in New York for killing Frank Mitchell last December. The report notes his claimed survivor status alongside the murder charge.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.

Wrong

The Sisseton Weekly Standard · 3 March 1905 · page 6

doesn't hare to shovel eration from San Francisco to Salt confessed. been signed between Great Britain Lake in two and a half years d«re to write that. and the other interested powers. 'e. -A 1v", "The whole record of tho Stamdarc. f. Oil company in Kansas has been record of broken promises, of treach ery to every interest which is making for the material prosperity of the state, of duplicity, deception and wrong. There is not a single instance where they have kept faith with any body. "It is a record from start to finish oof oppression, of favoritism, ot dis crimination and of lawbreaking."

See moreSee less

Compel Trusts to Br Decent. Tupeka, Ian., Feb. 2G—"I do not know what plans tbe Standard Of! trust made at its meeting yesterday, but I can rely that Kansas is going to stand on its rights as & sovereign state, protect its people and compel trusts to be decent," said Gov. Hoch yesterday. The trust hunting fever has abated in the legislature and the members are busy fighting over patronage aurl Senator Smith's resolution to investi gate all trusts has not been acted upon, and when it is, will be killed. Standard's Hands Idle. New York, Feb. 2G.—It was learned yesterday that at Thursday's meeting of the Standard Oil company the ques tion bearing on the investigation of the methods of the corporation was discussed and it was agreed to allow it to take its course. Tlio matter is now in the bauds of the company's counsel, who, contrary to reports, is conducting no campaign against tlio investigation movomeut. Claims to Be Custer Survivor. New York, Fell. 27. William Mr Gee, an ex-soldier and former resident of Texas, who claims to be the onlv mcmber of Custer's force to oecap" t.he massacre of the command on the Little Big Horn, is on trial here on the charge of lulling Frank Mitcheli last December. Falling Elevator Kills. Davenport, Iowa, Feb 2fi.—A fa!Hn? elevator in the Rock Island arsenal killed Edward O'Toole and injured Leon W. Hunt and August Abed. The three were workrpen in the g*n car riage department. Knatvold Gets Plum. Washington, Fob. 2G—Former State Senator Knatvold of Albert Lea, Minn., yesterday was n^rpoiwted a bank examiner on the reoaenmoada

See the clipping

Lawrence Democrat · Lawrenceburg, Tenn.

William McGee, described as the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, was convicted of first-degree manslaughter in New York for fatally stabbing Frank Mitchell after a quarrel. The report notes his purported connection to the 1876 Little Bighorn battle.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.

Wrong

Lawrence Democrat · 3 March 1905 · page 6

GENERAL NEWS ITEMS.

I 'V William McGee. said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, who stabbed Frank Mitchell fatally la New York, after a quarrel, has been

See the clipping

The Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

A review of Warren K. Moorehead's novel 'Tonda' about a Sioux girl educated in the East, noting the book depicts corrupt agents and adventurers whose deceptions provoked the Indian troubles leading to the Custer fight. The reviewer notes the book portrays the clash as 'in reality a bravely fought battle' rather than a massacre, though criticizes the writing quality.

The Courier-Journal · 4 March 1905 · page 5

Rain-In-the-Face her life In the wig wam of her father aqd of her husband are recounted with a knowledge of In dian customs habits and ceremonies that makes them Interesting The story shows the deceptions' that were practiced upon the Indians by unscrup ulous agents horse thieves and adven turers whose rascality finally precipi tated the Indian troubles and led up to the Custer "Massacre which was In reality a bravely fought battle There la a wealth of material in the volume but it has not been used to the beet advantage the style Is often poor and the dialect of the white men unreal '

See the clipping

The Leader · Brookhaven, Miss.

William McGee, described as the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, was convicted of first-degree manslaughter in New York for fatally stabbing Frank Mitchell after a quarrel. The brief item appears amid a digest of unrelated news items from around the country.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

The Leader · 4 March 1905 · page 2

William McGee, said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, who stabbed Frank Mitchell fatally in New York, after a quarrel, has been

See the clipping

Macon Beacon · Macon, Miss.

William McGee, described as the last white survivor of the Custer massacre, was convicted of manslaughter in the first degree for fatally stabbing Frank Mitchell in New York after a quarrel. The brief item ties his notoriety to his supposed survival of the famous battle.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

Macon Beacon · 4 March 1905 · page 1

A plant for the manufacture of conn loss. j-n,ooo, William Mcfiee, said to he the last while survivor of the Custer massacre, who stabbed Frank .Mitchell fatally in New York, after a quarrel, has been convicted of manslaughter in the first degree. United States Minister Dawson at San Domingo City has nodded the

See the clipping

The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.

William McGee, said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn, has been found guilty of first-degree manslaughter in an unrelated case. The report appears in a roundup of miscellaneous crime news from March 1905.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.

Wrong

The Washburn Leader · 4 March 1905 · page 7

William McGee, said to be the last white survivor of the Custer massacre on the LJttle Big Horn river, has been found guilty of manslaughter in the rst degree. Former City Treasurer George Hoi comb is nnder arrest charged with embezzlement from the city of Ever ett, Wash* while treasurer of the sum of $11,600. Muncle, Ind., Rudyard Foust, the At four-year-old son of Mr. and Mrs. Fred Foust, shot his sister, three years old, through the head with a revolver.

See the clipping

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

William McGee, who claimed to be the white survivor of the Custer massacre, was sentenced in New York to seven years and ten months for manslaughter after stabbing a man during a quarrel. The judge acknowledged his claimed military service but said even soldiers cannot take the law into their own hands.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

Bisbee Daily Review · 7 March 1905 · page 2

o SURVIVOR OF CUSTER MASSACRE Sentenced to Prison for Manslaughter in New York. New York. March C William Mc Gee, who claims to be the white sur vivor of the Custer massacre, was be fore Justice Keneficke for sentence. He was convicted of manslaughter In having stabbed Frank Mitchell, after a quarrel over the qualities of beef stew. McGee, who is 55 years old. said he had acted only in self defense. thing about it is the fact that the men most interested, who can least afford such an innovation, do not seem to realize that such a law would be vi cious in Its operation, for, no matter how excellent the motive of the fram- ' er of the bill might be, its first and only effective would be to produce paralysis In sections where it can least be afforded.

See moreSee less

Any law that per mits the employment of armies of men at excellent wages, and builds up cities in the wilderness or in the desert, is a good law, and to change it is to sport with the prosperity of a people. The difference between ten per cenL copper ore in Jerome, and three per cenL ore in Clifton or Morenci, as pointed out by the Bisbee Review, is great, and represents a difference in earning power which the legislators must take into account. Failing to recognle the difference, such a law would occupy the position of a dere lict upon the high seas a. menace to the safety -and prosperity";- of F commerce.

See the clipping

The Arrow · Carlisle, Pa.

At a school event, a Native American man (Y) tells students through his son to abandon traditional dress and live like civilized people. Hollow Horn Bear, mentioning his return from the Custer Massacre, also speaks of adapting to white ways and praises the school's military training.

The Arrow · 9 March 1905 · page 3

I Speech of Hollow Horn Bear | interpreted by Thos. Flood. Ladies and Gentlemen, and I will also i say my children: You have heard my career which has been read to you. When my father came to his end he told me it was time now for me to stop and take a rest. । This was soon after I came home from 1 the Custer Massacre. My father took me

See the clipping

The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D. · and 1 other paper

A 1905 Sioux City Tribune piece recalls Captain Seth Bullock's 1876 journey from Helena to the Black Hills, undertaken while the plains were still dangerous following Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn. It also recounts an anecdote about Bullock later telegraphing Theodore Roosevelt using a frontier greeting.

The Mitchell Capital · 10 March 1905 · page 10

"tenderfeet" waiting to go In with the Montanans to the new El Dorado. It was the time when the plains were In fested with Indians fresh from the bloody massacre of General Custer and his brave Seventh cavalry. The party of 125 which left Bismarck on a July day with its heavy train of wagons •was none too safe from the depreda tions of the savages. The trip across

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb. · 9 March 1905

The Caucasian · Shreveport, La.

The article recounts the story of Comanche, the gray horse ridden into the Battle of Little Bighorn, said to be the only survivor found alive on the battlefield after Custer's defeat in 1876. It describes his later life of honored retirement at Fort Riley until his death, and notes Sioux commemorations of the battle's anniversaries.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Sisseton Weekly Standard, 3 March 1905, Lawrence Democrat, 3 March 1905, Macon Beacon, 4 March 1905.

The Caucasian · 12 March 1905 · page 8

CELEBRATED BATTLE CHARGER

te . ahxout sixteen hands high, was tl charger on which Custer appeared tile head of one-half of the Sevent United States Cavalry in his last batt n at Little Big Horn, June 25. 1876. "Comanche" was the only living thin e that escaped the massacre when Gener: Custer and his men were massacred 1 the Sioux. When found he was mar miles from the bloody battlefield, an almost dead from loss of blood flowin e from seven wounds. Major Reno command cared for him as if he ha

See the clipping

The Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

William H. McGee, described as the sole survivor of the Custer massacre, was sentenced to nearly eight years for manslaughter after stabbing a fellow old soldier during an argument over kidney stew. The judge credited McGee's war record but said even a brave soldier must be held accountable for taking a life.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.

Wrong

The Courier-Journal · 13 March 1905 · page 3

SOLE SURVIVOR OF CUSTER MASSACRE W M McGee Ssntencsd To Prison For Nearly Eight Years For Manslaughter ' William H McGee sole survivor of the Custer massacre was sentenced to seven years and ten months in prison by Justice Keneflck to-day for killing Frank Mitchell December 9 eaye a New York telegram to the Baltimore American McGee's record saved him from a longer term He served with Custer and waa with the General at the famous battle with Sitting Bull Later McGee served ae a scout with General Miles with whom he went through many Indian campaigns He has 'scare of bullets snd knife wounds all over hie body McGee and Frank Mitchell both old warriors quarreled in a room at 300 East Forty-first street over their re spective ability to make a kidney stew" McGee stabbed hie old friend and Mitchell died a few days later McGee was tried In the Criminal Branch of the Supreme Court and found guilty of manslaughter in the first degree The Jury however recommended mercy In sentencing McGee Justice Kene flck eald: “The records show you have been a great soldier Your character generally has been good I have taken that into consideration and I would be easier with you only it must be shown that even a brave soldier cannot take life with impunity”

See the clipping

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · Fargo, N.D.

A local newspaper feature praises Mandan, North Dakota as a treasure trove of historical and literary material, citing the Mandan Indians, Lewis and Clark, and Custer's departure from Fort Abraham Lincoln to fight Sitting Bull's forces. It also reprints a Munsey's Magazine story about a lost treasure of gold dust sunk in the Missouri River in 1865.

The Fargo Forum and Daily Republican · 16 March 1905 · page 5

MANDAN IS A TREASURE HOUSE FOR NOVELIST

Columbus of the Lewis Clark ex pedition which camped one winter near the site of Mandan of Custer and his departure from Fort Abraham Lin

See the clipping

The Sea Coast Echo · Bay Saint Louis, Miss.

John D. Martin, the Italian-born bugler who survived Little Bighorn by being sent off with dispatches, recounts the battle decades later while running a food stand at Fort McHenry. He describes being sent by Custer to carry orders to Reno and Benteen before returning to witness the massacre's aftermath.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The Leader, 4 March 1905, The Washburn Leader, 4 March 1905, Bisbee Daily Review, 7 March 1905.

The Sea Coast Echo · 18 March 1905 · page 3

HE SAW CUSTER'S FALL. BUGLER WHO ESCAPED MASSACRE TELLS HIS EXPERIENCES.

Institution —hangs by its red cord upon the wall of his lunchroom, says the San Francisco Chronicle. John D. Martin, or Giovanni Martin, as he was known in Rome, the city of his birth, owed his escape on that summer day, June 25, 1876, when Cus ter’s command was cut to pieces, to the fact that he had been sent with a despatch to a point three miles away. He returned with the troopers just in time to witness the close of the mas sacre. At fourteen he was a drummer with Garibaldi’s patriots.

See moreSee less

When he came to this country, at the ago of twenty three, he enlisted again. He v. r as as signed to Custer’s command, and when Custer crept upon the peaceful look ing Sioux village on that day in June he selected Martin to carry despatch es to Major Marcus A. Rono and Capt* F. W. Benteen, commanding the two other divisions of the troop. The des jatches ordered them to join Custer it once. This is Martin’s story of the lay: : “We came upon the banks of the Little Big Korn at 11.30 o’clock in the morning, and across the waters we saw a village of several hundred te pees. Custer called a halt. “ ‘Men/ he said, pointing to the vil lage, the streets of which were de serted save for an occasional stray cur, half naked child, or bent old wo man, ‘we have ccme upon the Sioux village while the warriors are away hunting buffaloes. We will go down there, take possession of the camp, and fall upon the men when they re turn tired with hunting.’ “The men all waved their caps, and gave three cheers. Custer had a con sultation with his officers. Then call ing me he borrowed paper and none*! from Adjt. Cook, and wro e this mes sage: ‘Join mo at once, bringing the pack trains.’ He told me to find Reno and Benteen, and deliver the paper to them. “It was a hard ride of three miles, and my horse was wounded in the hip by a bullet from an Indian in ambush, but 1 pushed on until 1 reached Capt. Benteen. Soon after 1 got to him Ma jor Reno came dashing up, calling to the captain that he had been ambush ed, and had left fifteen men and two officers dead upon the field, beside a number of wounded. When we reach ed the scene of this engagement the Indians had fled. “The two divisions joined and pressed on to Custer. We arrived at about 12 o’clock upon a bluff at the head of a narrow ravine down which Custer had gone to see the river bank simply swarming with the naked, painted forms of Sitting Bull’s braves. The end was just in our view, and I remember well how close the forces were to each other. “The Indians had by that time en tirely surrounded Custer’s men and closed in upon them, fighting hand to hand. I remember the hideous ap pearance of the braves in their war paint, with the skins of wolves and antelopes in their hands, which they shook in the faces of our troop ers’ horses, rendering them unman ageable. “You have often seen the paintings iv Custer’s last fight. Well, they are not exaggerated in their detail, and with the terrible din the Indians kept up you can well imagine that it was an awful scene. ‘I do not remember seeing Custer

See the clipping

The Sea Coast Echo · Bay Saint Louis, Miss.

An elderly veteran, identified as Custer's messenger, recounts his personal story of riding to deliver orders to Reno and Benteen at Little Bighorn. He describes witnessing Custer's forces surrounded and overwhelmed by Sioux warriors from a nearby bluff.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Sea Coast Echo · 18 March 1905 · page 3

...CRE TELLS HIS EXPERIENCES.

Institution —hangs by its red cord upon the wall of his lunchroom, says the San Francisco Chronicle. John D. Martin, or Giovanni Martin, as he was known in Rome, the city of his birth, owed his escape on that summer day, June 25, 1876, when Cus ter’s command was cut to pieces, to the fact that he had been sent with a despatch to a point three miles away. He returned with the troopers just in time to witness the close of the mas sacre. At fourteen he was a drummer with Garibaldi’s patriots.

See moreSee less

When he came to this country, at the ago of twenty three, he enlisted again. He v. r as as signed to Custer’s command, and when Custer crept upon the peaceful look ing Sioux village on that day in June he selected Martin to carry despatch es to Major Marcus A. Rono and Capt* F. W. Benteen, commanding the two other divisions of the troop. The des jatches ordered them to join Custer it once. This is Martin’s story of the lay: : “We came upon the banks of the Little Big Korn at 11.30 o’clock in the morning, and across the waters we saw a village of several hundred te pees. Custer called a halt. “ ‘Men/ he said, pointing to the vil lage, the streets of which were de serted save for an occasional stray cur, half naked child, or bent old wo man, ‘we have ccme upon the Sioux village while the warriors are away hunting buffaloes. We will go down there, take possession of the camp, and fall upon the men when they re turn tired with hunting.’ “The men all waved their caps, and gave three cheers. Custer had a con sultation with his officers. Then call ing me he borrowed paper and none*! from Adjt. Cook, and wro e this mes sage: ‘Join mo at once, bringing the pack trains.’ He told me to find Reno and Benteen, and deliver the paper to them. “It was a hard ride of three miles, and my horse was wounded in the hip by a bullet from an Indian in ambush, but 1 pushed on until 1 reached Capt. Benteen. Soon after 1 got to him Ma jor Reno came dashing up, calling to the captain that he had been ambush ed, and had left fifteen men and two officers dead upon the field, beside a number of wounded. When we reach ed the scene of this engagement the Indians had fled. “The two divisions joined and pressed on to Custer. We arrived at about 12 o’clock upon a bluff at the head of a narrow ravine down which Custer had gone to see the river bank simply swarming with the naked, painted forms of Sitting Bull’s braves. The end was just in our view, and I remember well how close the forces were to each other. “The Indians had by that time en tirely surrounded Custer’s men and closed in upon them, fighting hand to hand. I remember the hideous ap pearance of the braves in their war paint, with the skins of wolves and antelopes in their hands, which they shook in the faces of our troop ers’ horses, rendering them unman ageable. “You have often seen the paintings iv Custer’s last fight. Well, they are not exaggerated in their detail, and with the terrible din the Indians kept up you can well imagine that it was an awful scene. ‘I do not remember seeing Custer

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Sea Coast Echo · Bay Saint Louis, Miss.

A surviving cavalryman named Martin recounts the chaos of the Little Bighorn fight, describing the two-day siege, the arrival of Terry and Gibbon's relief force, and finding Custer's body with two bullet wounds but not mutilated. The account closes with biographical details of his later military career and family life.

The Sea Coast Echo · 18 March 1905 · page 3

“We found Custer lying partly cov ered by two horses, just as if the men had tried to form a breastwork with the animals. There were two bullet holes in his body, but it was not muti lated. The Indians refrained from doing this cut of respect for bis fight ing qualities, but the other mem were fearfully mutilated —hacked to pieces with knives—a ghastly scene.” Martin was in several brushes,- both before and after this. Through his thirty years’ service and seven enlist ments he was never wounded, and to day is the same compact little Roman, that he was when he enlisted in the Hudson street enlisting office in New York in 1874. ’ After his first enlistment expired he

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A veteran who served in multiple Indian campaigns writes to dispute a man named McGee's claim of being Custer's scout who carried the last dispatch to Reno, calling it fraudulent. He instead praises Charley Reynolds as one of the best scouts he knew, recalling an 1875 Yellowstone expedition where Reynolds kept the party supplied with meat.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Courier-Journal, 13 March 1905, The Sea Coast Echo, 18 March 1905.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 22 March 1905 · page 1

Named McGee Is a Fraud Editor Tribune: In a recent issue of the Tribune I noticed a letter from Capt. Foley in reference to qn article which has appeared dn several papers about one McGee, who claims he was a scout under General Custer and car­ ried the last dispatch to Reno. Capt. Foley speaks my sentiments when he says that McGee is a fraud. I had the honor to be with every Indian expedition from General Sully's In 1864, wihen Fort Rice was built, until 1882 when General Miles had whip­ ped the whole Sioux nation and had located them on agencies.

See moreSee less

I served under Generals Sully, Stanley, Custer, Tully and last under General Miles. While I never knew much as to the members of the army, I was in a posi­ tion to know the duties of a scout as I would often have to take them up and down the river with their horses and to cross them In their business of locating the hostile Indians. I bad an article In the Tribune last summer stating that I had known only two genuine scouts any they were Yellowstone Kelley and Buffalo Bill. My excuse in writing you now is about one of the best men in that business that I ever met. I over­ looked this at the time I wrote you. This was Charley Reynolds, Custer's favorite scout. My reason no doubt for not mentioning his name with the other two was that while Charley was a famous scout, he was also the best hunter that I ever saw and when we explored the Yellowstone in i875 to see if it was navigable in order to supply the army by water, General Custer sent Charley with us and he kept us with two companies of sol­ diers, supplied with all the meat we could use on the trip. On that trip we went to a point now called Hunt­ ley, 90 miles above the Big Horn

See the clipping

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Steamboat captain Grant Marsh recalls scout Charley Reynolds, who had an injured hand but refused to stay behind from the Little Bighorn campaign. Dr. Porter told Marsh that Reynolds was shot and killed instantly while the doctor was amputating a wounded soldier's leg.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 22 March 1905 · page 1

INDIAN SCOUTS IN EARLY DAYS

Named McGee Is a Fraud river. General J. W. Forsythe was in military command. In his report of that trip, the Custer expedition was arranged for the next summer and no doubt all of your readers are familiar with the results. To go back to Charley Reynolds: When we joined the army wihdch had marched across from Fort Lincoln, Dr. Porter and Charley came on board of the boat. Charley had a felon on his left hand, which was giving him lotB of trouble. Dr. Porter had him stay with me on the boat but his Jiand got no better and when we separated at the mouth of the Rosebud river, the cavalry to go on its march to the Little Big Horn,

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut

A review describes the stage production 'John Ermine of the Yellowstone,' playing at Poli's theater, which is set in northern Wyoming just after the Custer massacre. The plot follows a half-white, half-Indian scout caught between his loyalty to native life and his love for a white officer's daughter, culminating in a fatal duel with her West Point suitor.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 23 March 1905 · page 7

POLI'S "JOHN ERMINE." The scenes of "John, Ermine of the Yellowstone." James K. Hackett's sue i-ess of Inst season. In which Franklin Woodruff will be seen at Poll's to night, are laid In northern Wyoming, just after the Custer massacre. The

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Mrs. George A. Custer, widow of the general killed at Little Bighorn in 1876, offers to loan the government the table on which Grant wrote the terms of Lee's surrender at Appomattox. Secretary Taft is considering placing the historic relic in the Secretary's room at the War Department.

Evening Star · 24 March 1905 · page 1

Mrs. George B. Custer, widow of Gen. eorge H. Custer, the distinguished cavalry ader of the civil war, who lost his life the Indian fight at'Little Big Horn, in me, 1876, the War Department is about receive possession of one of the most In ,resting relics of the war-of the rebellion. is the table on which Gen. Grant wrote Le terms of the surrender of Gen. Lee's rmy at Appomattox Court House, April 9, 65, which marked the restoration of the nion of states. The story of the historic table and how comes into the possession of the United ates government at this late date is told the subjoined correspondence: Mrs. Custer's Offer. I

See the clipping

The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.

In this 1905 reminiscence, retired steamboat captain Grant Marsh recounts ferrying supplies for the Custer expedition and describes how scout Charley Reynolds, despite a painfully infected hand, insisted on joining the campaign rather than stay behind. Marsh also recalls learning from Dr. Porter about events after Reno's wounded were brought back to his steamboat.

The Washburn Leader · 25 March 1905 · page 3

Gen. Custer sent Charley with us and he kept us with two companies .of soldiers supplied with all the meat we could use on the trip. On Named McGee Is a Fraud.

See the clipping

The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.

Grant Marsh, the steamboat captain from the Little Bighorn campaign, gives his reminiscences defending the reputation of scout Charley Reynolds and recounting secondhand details of his death from Dr. Porter. He also disputes a claim by one 'McGee' to have been a Custer scout who carried the last dispatch to Reno.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Washburn Leader · 25 March 1905 · page 3

INDIAN SCOUTS OF THE EARLY DAY

Steamboat Captain of the Caster Massacre. Named McGee Is a Fraud. are-familiar with the his left hand which was was that they bad I men EDITOR TRIBUNE: In a recent issue of the Tribune, I noticed a letter from Capt. Foley in reference to an article which has appeared in several papers about one McGee, who claims he was a scout under Gen. Custer and carried the last dispatch to Reno. Capt. Foley speaks my sentiments when he says that McGee is a fraud. I had the honor to be with every Indian ex pedition from Gen.

See moreSee less

Sully's in 1864 when Ft. Rice was built, until 1882 when Gen. Miles had whipped the whole Sioux nation and had located them on agencies. I served und6r Generals Sully, Stanley, Custer, Tully and last under Gen. Miles. While I never knew much as to the members of the members of the army, I was in the position to know the duties of a scout 21s I would often have to take them up and down the river with their horses and to cross them in their business of locating the hostile Iudians. I had an article in the l^ribune last summer stating that I had known only two genuine scouts and they were Yellowstone Kelly and Buffalo Bill. My excuse in writ ing you now is about one of the best men in that business that I ever met,. This was Charley Rey nolds, Custer's favorite scout. My reason* doubt, for not mention* 110 ing -his name .with the other two was that, while Charley was a fa mousscout, he was also the best hufitei* that I-evw saw, and when we explored the Yellowstone in 1875 to see if it was naVagable in order to supply the army by waterway. r* i. W

See the clipping

The Fairmont West Virginian · Fairmont, W. Va.

Elizabeth B. Custer, widow of General George A. Custer who died at Little Big Horn in 1876, donated to the War Department the table on which Grant wrote the terms of Lee's surrender at Appomattox. The relic, given to her by General Phil Sheridan after the surrender, will be displayed in the Secretary of War's reception room alongside other Civil War artifacts.

The Fairmont West Virginian · 25 March 1905 · page 5

WROTE TERMS OF LEE'S SURRENDER ON TABLE RECENTLY PRESENTED TO WAR DEPARTMENT BY MRS. CUSTER

Mrs. Custer the day after the surrender, by General Phil. Sheridan, and has Blnce that time been In a fireproof storage liouBe. Mrs. Custer wrote recently to the Secretary of War offering the historic

See the clipping

The Times Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Elizabeth Custer, widow of General Custer who died at Little Bighorn in 1876, is lending the government the small table on which the Confederate surrender terms were written at Appomattox. The relic, sent to her by General Sheridan in 1865, will be displayed in the War Department's reception room alongside other Civil War memorabilia.

The Times Dispatch · 26 March 1905 · page 15

HISTORIC TABLE FOR GOVERNMENT GOES TO WAR DEPARTMENT

(From Our Regular Correspondent.) WASHINGTON, D. C, March Jffi.-J'rob .?bly the most Interesting relic of the war between the Slates I* about to come Into the possession of the War Depart? ment, This Is nothing more nor less thnn tho table on which wero written the terms of surrender r/f the Army of North? ern Virginia -lo Gcnenil Orant at Appo? mattox. The table has been kept stored In a fireproof bulbil' for'years, but It t? about to come i the War Depart? ment, nnd will probably occupy-a place In tho reception room at the Departr merit, where are many' reminders of the great struggle of 1RC1-'65.

See moreSee less

The bible Is the property ot Mrs. Eliza? beth B. Custer, widow of General George B. Custer, who lost his life In 1870 nt the massacre of the I.lttlo Big Horn. On the 10th of April. 18(15. the day nfler.the sur? render of General Lee, General Sheridan wrolo Mrs. Custer that he wns sending her tho small writing table on whichtlio articles of surrender, were -wiltt.cn. Mra. Custer lias preserved the t-thlo all Ihtac 'years, but says she wishes to lend It to the Deportment, nnd will semi with It. as Its credentials, as It .wore, letter:* from Colonel "Marshall, of General lice's ?tafr. tho only Confederate officer pres? ent at tho signing of the articles, and r plan of. the old-McLean, house,, with tho position of llie'table In the room properly indicated. .Secretary Taft has written-Mrs. Custer he will be glad to accept the table, as p loan, and will have It placed'iri the re? ception room nt the Department^ the largest room In th*S State, War and Navy building. - He mentions that the war museum has long been abollsHed, and the articles contained therein sent to the arsenals at Governor's Island, Water vllet and Springfield, and n. few to the National Museum. In this city. Among other articles displayed In tho reception room at the Department Is the flag which enveloped the coffin containing the re? mains ofPresident Lllcoln on the trip from Washington to Springfield, 111.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A miscellany column item notes that Mrs. Custer, widow of General Custer who died at the Little Bighorn, is arranging for the War Department to receive the table on which Grant wrote the terms of Lee's surrender. The item is a brief aside among various unrelated news notes.

New-York Tribune · 27 March 1905 · page 8

Haining of school teachers in the sum of from $2,000, to $4,000,000. Through the kindness of Mrs. Custer, widow of General Custer, the distinguished cavalry leader who lost his life In the Little Big Horn fight, the ‘War Department is about to receive the table on which General Grant wrote the terms of surrender of General lLee's army at Appomattox Court

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

The item notes that Mrs. Custer, widow of General Custer who died at the Little Big Horn fight, is donating to the War Department the table on which Grant wrote the terms of Lee's surrender at Appomattox. It briefly references Custer's death in passing while focusing on the historical artifact.

Evening Times-Republican · 29 March 1905 · page 4

Thru the kindness of Mrs. Custer, widow of Gen. Custer, the distinguish ed cavalry leader who lost bis life in the Little Big Horn fight, the war de partment is about to receive the table on which (ion. Grant wrote the terms of surrender of Gen. l-ee's army at Appomattox court bouse, April !), 1SC5.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The widow of General Custer, who died at Little Bighorn, is donating to the War Department the table on which Grant wrote the terms of Lee's surrender at Appomattox in 1865. The item notes this marks the restoration of the Union.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 29 March 1905 · page 6

Through the kindness of Mrs. Custer, widow of General Custer, the distin guished cavalry leader who lost his life in the Little Big Horn tight, the War Department is about to receive the ta ble on which General Grant wrote the terms of surrender of General Lee's army

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Decades after Little Bighorn, General Custer's widow arranges to give the War Department the table on which Grant wrote the terms of Lee's surrender at Appomattox. The note briefly identifies Custer as the cavalry leader who died at the Little Big Horn fight.

Omaha Daily Bee · 30 March 1905 · page 6

PERSONAL NOTES

Through the kindness of Mrs. Custer, widow of General Custer, the distinguished cavalry leader who lost his life In the Little Big Horn fight, the War depart ment In about to receive the table on which ' General Grant wrote the terms of surrender of General Lee's army at Appo mattox Court House, April 9. 1865. which

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

A trapper named J. L. Peters, encountered near Evanston, Wyoming, claims to be a white survivor of the Custer massacre at Little Bighorn. He reportedly explains how he escaped the fate of his companions, apparently unaware that other men elsewhere have made similar claims to being the 'only' survivor.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Salt Lake Tribune · 30 March 1905 · page 1

ANOTHER ONLY SURVIVOR, One of Custer's Men Discovered Near Fvnuston. Special to Thc Tribune. t KVAXSTON. Wyo March 23. Another only whlto survivor of tho Custer mas sacre has been discovered near this place. IIo Is J. L,. Peters, an old-time trapper, who during the pnflt winter mado his headquarters at tho Chambers ranch. Po ters was ln town a few days ago. bring ing with him several packhorso lpads of skins of mountain Hons, wildcats, wolves and coyotes which ho trapped during the cold months. Ho talks In an interesting manner of the battle of the Little Big Horn, and logically explains how he es caped tho fate which overtook "all" of hia white companions.

See moreSee less

Peters knows nothing of thc claims of other persons ln various parts of tho country to tho title of tho "only" white survivor of tho Custer massacre.

See the clipping

The Berne Witness · Berne, Ind. · and 3 other papers

A 1905 newspaper article derides Sitting Bull as a self-promoting fraud who profited from his fame after Little Bighorn, then recounts his instigation of the Ghost Dance movement and his death during a botched arrest by Indian police in 1890. The piece is sharply editorializing, casting him as cowardly and manipulative throughout.

The Berne Witness · 31 March 1905 · page 7

During the time Sitting Bull was set ting the stage and rehearsing his ghost dancers for the grand climax, he was so much afraid to show his face at the Indian agency that he sent one of his sons to gather in the bi-weekly rations supplied by Uncle Sam. The govern ment authorities saw trouble ahead, and, knowing the Sioux tendency to massacre, gave orders for the arrest of the old medicine man. Thirty-nine In dian police and four volunteers went to the home of the great maker of sig natures, and found him in the midst of elaborate preparations for flight.

See moreSee less

He submitted quietly to arrest, however, until one of his sons, dovbtless famil iar with his father’s cowardly nature, began to jeer and jibe him. ; Sitting Bull, true to his reputation, called iu a loud voice for rescue. A general melee was precipitated, In which six Indian police and eight of Sitting Bullls braves .were killed, him

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis. · 31 March 1905
  • Manchester Democrat · Manchester, Iowa · 5 April 1905
  • Aberdeen Herald · Aberdeen, W.T. · 13 April 1905

Bismarck Daily Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Mrs. George A. Custer, widow of the cavalry general killed at Little Bighorn in 1876, offers the War Department the table on which Grant wrote the terms of Lee's surrender at Appomattox. Secretary Taft suggests the relic be kept in the War Department's possession.

Bismarck Daily Tribune · 31 March 1905 · page 3

MRS. CUSTER OFFERS TAFT A RARE RELIC TABLE ON WHICH GRANT WROTE TERMS OF LEE'S SURRENDER, SECRETARY TAFT SUGGESTS THAT INTERESTING RELIC BE IN WAR DEPARTMENT

George B. Custer, widow of Gen. George A. Custer, the distinguished cavalry leiader of the civil war, Who lost his life in the Iidlan fight at Little Big Horn, in June, 1876, the war department Is alb out to receive possession of one of the most inter­ esting feiics of the war of the rebel­ lion. It is the table on which Gen. Grant wrote the terms of the sur­ render of Gen. Lee's army at Appo­ mattox court house, April 9, 1865, which marked) the restoration of the union of states.

See the clipping

The Bottineau Courant · Bottineau, N.D.

This is a roundup of brief local news items from various North Dakota towns, including a passing mention that the Bismarck Tribune printed reminiscences of 'Custer massacre times.' The bulk of the text concerns unrelated local affairs like weddings, schools, and politics.

The Bottineau Courant · 31 March 1905 · page 4

•I' The Bismarck Tribune prints some interesting reminiscences of Custer massacre times. The Mohall Independent' and the Sherwood Journal are quarreling. Quit it fellows. The Starkweather Times man has to borrow a Devils Lake Journal and wants an exchange.

See the clipping