As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

May 1905

14 articles

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A painting by Astley D. M. Cooper titled 'The Burning Arrow,' valued at $25,000, is on exhibition at Howe & Stetson Co., depicting Indians using fire-signaling arrows during the 1876 Custer campaign. The artist, who covered the Indian war for Frank Leslie's Weekly, based the scene on something he witnessed firsthand in the Black Hills.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 1 May 1905 · page 8

THE BURNING ARROW

Custer campaign of 1876, which culmin ated -in the Custer massacre. A group ofi warring Indians are assembled, In the moonlight behind a clump of rocks

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Star · Honolulu Oahu

The article reports that the transport Sherman left San Francisco carrying the Seventh Cavalry, described as Custer's old regiment, bound for Honolulu, Guam, and Manila. It notes this was the regiment massacred at Little Big Horn by Sitting Bull's Sioux Indians in the 1870s.

The Hawaiian Star · 1 May 1905 · page 8

CUSTER'S OLD REGIMENT COMING The transport Sherman left San Francisco yesterday for Honolulu, Guam and Manila. The Seventh Cav alry, Custer's -old regiment, Is under stood to be aboard. It was the Seventh that was massacred at Little Big Horn by Sitting Bull's Sioux Indians, in the Seventies.

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

A promotional review describes a Northern Pacific railway guidebook's new chapters, including one on 'The Sepulchre of Lame Deer,' a chief said to have fought in the Custer massacre before being killed by General Miles. The chapter recounts the legend of his burial in a sealed cave above the Rosebud valley, later pointed out by his daughter.

The Minneapolis Journal · 11 May 1905 · page 6

ATTRACTIVELY PRESENTED

is entitled "The Sepulchre of Lame Deer," one of the chiefs who took part the Custer massacre and was pur sued and killed in a fight with General Miles. He is supposed to have been laid awav in a natural cave overlook ing the Rosebud valley, which was sealed up and has since ,been pointed out by the daughter of the old chief. The usual chapter on Yellowstone park is featured by splendid photo graphs of the geyser region, and atten tion is called in another chapter to beautiful Lake Kachess, nestling high among the crags of the Cascades.

See moreSee less

The Lewis and Clark exposition at Portland is illustrated and described at length. Other picturesque points along the Northern Pacific line are shown in striking half-tone illustrations. The book as a whole is a worthy successor to the notable series of this railroad's publications. It is sent to any address on receipt of 6 cents for postage.

See the clipping

East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.

A newspaper article describes a cavalry officer's sabre, reportedly worn at the Little Bighorn battle, now displayed in Major Moorhouse's office window after being presented to him by Col. Edward S. Godfrey. The piece recounts Godfrey's presence near the battle as a lieutenant under Major Reno and describes how Native scouts used sticks to depict Custer's defeat to Reno's men.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.

Wrong

East Oregonian : E.O · 11 May 1905 · page 3

SABRE WHICH WAS WORN AT LITTLE BIG HOItX. Was Prcsr-Mctl to Major Moorhouse by Col. K. S. Godfrey, Who Took it From uu Indian in Wlioso Posncssion it Whs a.s a Trophy of the Fa iion Mnasiicre of 1870 Godfrey Was In the Immediate Vicinity of Die Rattle nt the Time. Xow shown In the window of Major Moorhouee's office Is a cavalry off! cer s sabre which, if it could only (peak, might tell the story of the fiercest and bloodiest struggle record ed in the annals of the West the battle of the Little Big Horn, of which no adequate account has ever been given and never will be, unless by the spirits of the dead.

See moreSee less

The sabre, which almost beyond a doubt, was worn Into the fatal canyon by an officer of the Seventh cavalry, was presented to Major Moorhouse by Col. Edward S. Godfrey, now conv mander of the Ninth cavalry. The colonel was a first lieutenant In the famous Seventh when the greater part of that regiment and General Custer were slain by the Sioux on June 25, 1878. At the time of the battle of Little Big Horn, Lieutenant Godfrey was at another place with a portion of the regiment under com mand of Major Reno. Some deeper ate fighting with the Sioux was also had by this detachment, but with less disastrous results than befell Custer and his men. Shortly after the Custer massacre an Indian scout reached the force under Major Reno, and to describe that terrible struggle placed a lot of little sticks In a circle with one In the center to designate the com mander. Then the scout cast the sticks, the center one last, Into the Big Horn river, thus showing how the entire force had been swept down. For some time following the mas sacre the Sioux warriors went adorned 350 20a 40c 100 25o 20c SOc 250 20c 200 SOo 90c 20a

See the clipping

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

This retrospective piece describes the Sun Dance torture ritual undergone by Rain-in-the-Face, then recounts his alleged murder of two men near Fort Lincoln years before Little Bighorn. It details his arrest by Tom Custer and his later confession to General Custer, boasting of tomahawking and scalping his victims.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The St. Louis Republic · 14 May 1905 · page 28

"". flttlnr evldencest of M ftolci'm. MASSACRE OK CfSTEH. It U through hi connection with the marsiere of General Custer and men that Italn-in-the-K.ice l principally known. UN role in that historic drama, noes back soir.; three yeir pravloii. to the fljrht, when a s-urjtt-on In the army and a civilian I tradt-r attached to General D. 8. Stanley i rT-.llilo!i .were murdered aa thay .topped to ftnl and water their lioraea on the Red i Klver. Some eighteen month. IntW Charley

See the clipping

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

The report recounts Rain-in-the-Face's harsh imprisonment, his escape, and his vow of revenge against Custer and his brother Tom. It then recounts the famous but contested legend that he cut out Tom Custer's heart, noting the warrior's own contradictory account that he did not recognize the Custers during the battle.

The St. Louis Republic · 14 May 1905 · page 28

HIS PRISON EXPERIENCE.

In the spring ofliW fUln.ln-tfce.Fare Joined fflfllng iralfs band of hostile, open iv prte'Iaimln? that he woulf "cut th heart out vf Tom Cu.t.r and eat ti.'". Nothing further of hlir. a lieard tintlt the memorable masscr. of Custer and

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

This 1905 article discusses a Cossack horse's long-distance journey to St. Petersburg, comparing it to various feats of equine endurance including American frontier horses. It references scouts from Custer's 1876 campaign who reportedly covered 150-280 miles, mistakenly describing the campaign's end as the 'massacre on the Rosebud.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 18 May 1905 · page 10

jhe appetite of the beast increased Wjta the distance traveled. At the start it required 8 pounds of oats and 14 nnunds of hav a dav to keeo it up. anj for water it took the snow alongside the road, as well or spring water was not obtainable. When two-thirds of the Journey was completed the horse was eating 30 pounds of oats and 14 pounds of hay each day. An English or American horse, aside from the plains breed of the latter country would havo surrendered quickly. Tho West ern American horse has made some wonderful long distance Journeys inr quick time.

See moreSee less

During Custer's campaign of 1876,- which ended in the massacre on the Rosebud, some of the scouts for the army covered ISO to 280 miles In hours on three feeds and three chances to water lor their horses. In Grierson's wild ride during the Civil War to cut the Confederate lines, tho rido which eventually gave birth to Sherman's march to the sea, one Chicago cavalryman was in the saddle for 170 miles and that without dis mounting. He lives now as a mail car rier for the Post office. One November day in the Goose River County of Dakota a cowboy named Ivorson was called to a ranch cleaning. ' cured for his employer's daughter, who had heen taken suddenly ill - with croup. The nearest doctor was 38 miles away, the temperature was 18 dogres below, tho wind was scurrying

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A 1905 feature profiles the aging Sioux leader Rain-in-the-Face, describing his life and reproducing picture-writings he made depicting events including the Little Bighorn battle, courtship, a killing, and the sun dance. The drawings show symbolic details such as five horses shot from under him during the Custer fight.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The St. Louis Republic, 14 May 1905, The Daily Morning Journal and Courier, 18 May 1905.

Los Angeles Herald · 21 May 1905 · page 41

PROBABLY the most interesting If not the most famous Indian ,ln the annals of the Sioux is Raln-in-the-Face. For many years he was a war chief of note, and later an 'exile In Canada. At present he passes his days on the Standing Rock reservation in North liakota, the last of the great Sioux leaders. He is a full blooded Unkpapa Sioux and was born some sixty years ago in the northern part of South Dakota, one of a family of six brothers, the most celebrated of whom, excepting him self, was Iron Horße.

See moreSee less

Physically he Is of splendid propor tions and remarkably striking in ap pearance, although a wound in the right leg necessitates the use of crutches. Time has dealt kindly with him, and he shows but few traces of his years. His career has been a strenuous one from the time of his birth until our last trouble with the Indians at Pine Ridge. With the hope of adding something new and certainly at first hand to fiction and fact relating to him, tho writer asked Rain-ln-the-Face some years ago to chronicle in his own way by means of Indian picture writings a few of the most interesting events in his life. The results was a collec tion of rare drawings, five of which are given herewith. Indian hierogly phics in general are scarce today, and more so those executed by so famous a chief. In one picture he Is shown In the battle of the Little Big Horn, the bat tle In which Custer fell. The five marks on the horse's neck, body and legs denote In Indian writing that he had five horses shot from under him. In another he goes courting and wooes end wins his first wife. He takes with him his finest spotted horse, to make as -great an. impression as possible up or. the Indian maiden he has chosen to wed. One picture Is supposedly a large camp. On the right is Rain-ln-theFace's tepee and on the left a medi cine lodge, In front of which Is Sitting Dull, making "medicine" for the suc cess of the Indians In the Custer fight then in progress. In still another pic ture he kills an enemy, a Crow Indian of note, who stole a horse belonging tc the - chief. He has drawn In this picture one of the magnificent war bonnets used by the Sioux of the early days, which sometimes measured twelve feet In length. The 'last of these la an unusual pic ture, and not often seen, even among the Indians. It represents the sun dance, a ceremony of extreme torture, and It is the only drawing of the dance the writer ever saw executed by an Indian, as this subject is sacred. The dance was performed by the bucks of old to show their bravery and indiffer ence to pain. A brief description of this dance would perhaps be of Inter est. The Indian about to undergo the torture is suspended from a long pole by rawhide thongs fastened to skew ers, which. In turn are run through muscles exposed by Incision In the right and left ) breasts. The Indian bangs In the air by these thongs until either completely prostrated or the fessed to the general that he was thfi murderer, and boasted of It and of the brutal manner In which it was done. That he had shot the elder of the two first but not fatally, and that he beat out his victims' brains with a tomahawk and then shot their bodies full of arrows and finally scalped both men. Neither of the murdered men was armed. The chief was confined to the guard house until further disposition could be made of his case. A fellow prisoner was a citizen who had been Imprisoned for some minor offense. The guard house was poorly built and without necessary furniture, and for several months Raln-in-the-Face and his com panion lay in chains, with the floor for their bed. Winter came, with its piercing blasts from the north, and Raln-ln-the-Fuce lay upon the floor without as much as

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

This 1905 article describes the Sioux sun dance torture ritual and recounts how Rain-in-the-Face was arrested by Colonel Tom Custer for killing two men years before Little Bighorn. It frames Rain-in-the-Face's fame as stemming primarily from his role in the Custer massacre.

Los Angeles Herald · 21 May 1905 · page 41

muscles tear loose, thereby releasing the skewers. Should the brave thus qualifying for the warpath faint or surrender to the excruciating pain he Is considered a squaw and prerogatives of a warrior are denied him. Rain-in the-Face, in order to show unusual bravery, underwent this torture a sec ond time by tearing the muscles in the right and left shoulder. The brave who hung Rain-in-theFace to the sun pole was the cele brated Long Soldier, seven feet tall, who placed him as high as he could reach. Raln-in-the-Faro carries upon hit body numberless scars .

See moreSee less

received in hlsi first sun dance many years ago, fitting evidences of his stoicism. It is through his connection with the massacre of General Custer nnd men that Raln-in-the-Face is principally known. His role In that historic drama goes back some three years previous to the fight, when a surgeon In the army and a civilian trader attached to General D. S. Stanley's expedition were murderod as they stopped to feed end water their horses on the Red river. Some eighteen months later Charley Reynolds, a government scout, subse quently killed at the battle of the Little P.lk Horn, brought in informa tion to General Ouster, at Fort Lin coln, that the Indian who had mur dered both men was Rain-ln-theFace, then at the Standing Rock res ervation drawing government rations. General Custer Immediately detailed his brother. Colonel Tom Custer, and a cavalry captain rfnd escort to ar rest the murderer. Raln-in-the-Face was found in the trader's store at the agency and personally arrested by Colonel Tom Custer. • When the prisoner and his captors returned he was brought before Gen eral Custer. The general questioned the prisoner closely, but to no pur pose. The Indian remained Imperturb able. The next day, however, he con

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The passage recounts how Rain-in-the-Face was imprisoned by Tom Custer, escaped after filing through chains, and joined Sitting Bull's hostiles, vowing revenge. It claims he fulfilled this vow by killing and symbolically eating the heart of Tom Custer during the Little Bighorn fight in 1876.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Los Angeles Herald · 21 May 1905 · page 41

brother and which suggested that re | venge so amply fulfilled upon the banks of the Little Big Horn. Raln-ln-the-Face's companion re ceived from outside sources a black smith's file, and one night, when the vijrljance of the guards was relaxed, both prisoners filed through their chains, cut a hole in the guardhouse wall and made good their escape. In the spring of 1874 Rain-in-theFace joined Sitting Bull's band of hos-' tiles, openly proclaiming that he would "cut the heart out of Tom Custer and eat it." Nothing further of him was heard until the memorable massacre of Custer and troopers, June 26, 1876.

See moreSee less

In this fight he distinguished himself farmers to meet the malefactors with shotguns on the highway. A fanner's wife on a rural telephone which had been in operation only a few months was asked how she liked the telephone. She naively answered: "Well, we liked it a lot at first, and do yet,' only spring work Is coming on so heavy now that we don't hardly have time to listen now."

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The first squadron of the Seventh Cavalry, Custer's old command, left Fort Myer bound for San Francisco and then the Philippines, with the band playing 'Garryowen,' the tune played during the 1876 Little Big Horn campaign. The report lists the regimental officers who departed with the troops.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 10 days earlier.

The Washington Times · 21 May 1905 · page 2

SEVENTH CAVALRY LEAVES FORT MYER

station tggether with the band and the regimental non-commissioned staff. The regimental headquarters were also on the train. i As the train pulled out the band played ‘‘Garryowen,” music to which the Seventh Regiment marched out for the Little Big Horn campaign in 1876. Custer’s Old Command. The Seventh is Custer's old com mand. During the stay in Washington officers and men of this regiment have been received with more than usual cordiality. ~The first squadron came to Fort Myer in September last to relieve the second squadron of the Fifteenth Cavalry.

See moreSee less

The transfer was made immediately after ithe maneuvers at Manassas. The four troops were encamped on the parade ground at the post for two months after their arrival The of ficers of the regiment took a prominent part in the sccial festivities of the cap ital, Regimental Officers, ~The officers who left with the regi ment were Col. Charles Morton, Major William J. Nicholson, Capts. Nathan K. Averill, Thomas H. Reberts, and Rob ert Wallach, First [deuts, Evan IH. Humphrey, Charlies H, Boice, Daniel H.

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

A review of Cyrus Townsend Brady's book 'Indian Fights and Fighters' notes its discussion of whether Custer caused the Little Big Horn disaster by disobeying orders. The book presents letters from army officers on both sides of the question, aiming for impartiality rather than a definitive conclusion.

The Laramie Republican · 26 May 1905 · page 1

DR. CYRUS BRADY ON THE CUSTER MASSACRE. Cyrus Townsend Brady’s latest book, "Indian Fights and Fighters,” the fourth in the "American Fights and Fighters” Series, (McClure-Phillips), is notable because it, contains an ex haustive discussion of the mooted ques tion as to whether Custer caused the disaster on the Little Big Horn creek by disobeying orders. Thia discussion is in the form of letters from a number of distinguished officers of the army who are in a position to know the facte. The whole subject la gone over thoroughly, and evidence is presented which may assist the reader in arriv ing at hie own conclusion. The evi dent impartiality And fairness of the writer is seen. In that he presents both sides of the case. This matter Is con

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

A 1905 review discusses Cyrus Townsend Brady's book arguing Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn resulted from his disobedience of General Terry's orders. The reviewer finds Brady's case compelling though notes it has drawn criticism, while praising the broader book series on American military history.

The Minneapolis Journal · 31 May 1905 · page 4

WAS GENERAL CUSTER JUSTIFIED IN DISOBEYING GENERAL TERRY'S ORDERS?-Cyrus Townsend Brady's view, unequivocally expressed in Indian Fights and Fighters, that Custer's slaugh ter on the Little Big Horn in 1876, was due first of all to his own disobedience to his chief's orders, has been seriously ques tioned and has brought upon Mr. Brady severe criticism. While the orders of General Terry gave Custer a good deal of latitude, there is no question that Mr. Brady's position is a strong one. To read his story of Custer's last fight is to be well niffh convinced.

See moreSee less

The story is only one of many, alike in convincingness, in Mr. Brady's latest ad dition to the series bearing the title, "American Fights and Fighters," which includes "American Fights and Fighters, Colonial." "American Fights and Fight ers, Revolutionary1812," and "Ameri can Fights and Fighters, Border," in ad dition to the volume in hand. The book is profusely illustrated by men who have made reputations as illustrators, especially of such subject-matter as this book contains. The arrangement of the material is good and is indexed in a way to make the book valuable for reference. McClure, Phillips & Co., New York.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

On Decoration Day 1905, Crow and Cheyenne Indians placed wildflowers on the graves of soldiers killed at Little Bighorn, with Custer's grave receiving the largest share of offerings. The article notes the Crows were not involved in the battle, while the Cheyenne had fought against Custer's forces, yet both tribes now honor his memory annually.

The Sun · 31 May 1905 · page 2

INDIANS TRIBUTE TO CUSTER

They T Place parf Flowers FoWfrA nn onlils Ills Jls Grave Grf iraveand and Those Thosenfllls Tole ToleoC Thoseor ills Men MenCnow MenCnow nfllls oC Is Ifn IfnCROW Cnow INDIAN AGENcY AoF cY Mon on May f03 30 30The 3 30The The To Crow Cow and Cheyenne Che nne Indians Incln today todaycelebrated toayrlebroted todaycelebrated celebrated rlebroted Decoration Decortlon Day by b placing placng wild wildflowers wid widower wildfiower flowers ower on the graven jr v of It tho soldiers oldler killed killedIn kied kiedIn killedIn In the th Custer Cttr massacre rnAcr Every 1ery grave grve had hada hd hda a few flowers 01 placed IAd on it itGen itOn itGen Gen Custers s grave grm came cme in I for the thelargest th thelargest On Cltr largest share shar of Mowers lowor the th mound being beingIndians bing bingentrly beingentirely entrly entirely largst cord covemei with ofering offerings from the theIndll tileIndians

See the clipping