As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

December 1886

19 articles

The Weekly Sentinel · Winston-Salem, N.C. · and 2 other papers

An 1886 Washington dispatch profiles a bugler named Martin, described as the sole survivor of Custer's command, who is seeking a government messenger job with Gen. Sheridan's endorsement. Martin recounts being sent to hurry up Reno and Benteen and also tells of the scout 'Curly' escaping by disguising himself as a Sioux.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The Weekly Sentinel · 2 December 1886 · page 2

Louisville Courier-Journal. Sole Survivor of Custer's Command. The sole survivor of the Custer massacre, a bugler named Martin, is in the city an appli cant for a messengership in one of the de partments. He is indorsed by Gen. Sheridan, and will probably get a place in the war de partment. Martin said to-day he was with Custer when he spied the Indian village, and was sent with, an order hurrying up Maj. Reno and Capt Benteon. To this circum stance Martin probably owes his life, as when he returned the other 265 men of Custer's command were dead upon the ground.

See moreSee less

"I was the only soldier survival-," Said Martin. "There was an Indian scout named 'Curly' who made his escape. Before the I tattle com menced he saw that it would be a massacre, so he loosened his hair, snatched a piece of red trimming from his clothes to tie it with, tore a black blanket in two and wrapped it around his legs, as if ho wore leggings, and then throwing a blanket over his shoulders he looked not unlike a hostile Sioux. He dashed into their midst and w as not detected, and thus made his escape." Washington Cor.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Clarion · Jackson, Miss. · 17 November 1886
  • The Asheville Citizen · Asheville, N.C. · 17 November 1886

The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.

A decade after Little Bighorn, this report refutes popular claims that Rain-in-the-face was a chief who killed Custer and mutilated his heart, stating he was 50 miles away during the battle. It asserts Custer's body was not mutilated and that it is unknown who actually killed him, as the Indians did not realize they had killed Custer until days later.

The New North-West · 3 December 1886 · page 2

The Iconoclast Gets His Work in, on the Man of Humid Countenance. TAYLoR, Dak., Nov. 20.-Iteomagajo, or Rain-in-the-face, has been much talked about, and he is the subject of periodical newspaper notices which have appeared about every six months, ever since the bat tie of the Little-big-horn. Every one of these notices and alleged interviews has has mls. represented the man and entirely disregarded facts. It has been said that he is a chief, that he took an active part in the battle of the Little-big-horn, that he is the Indian who killed Custer, and that he cut Custer's heart out and ate a piece of it.

See moreSee less

All of these state ments are absolutely false. Rain-In-the-face is not a chief. (He has a brother, Iron-horn, who is chief of a small band of Unkapapa Sioux residing at the Standing Rock agency). He took no part in the battle of the Little big-horn. At the time that battle took place Rain-in-nth-face, with 16 other braves, was 50 miles distant from the scene of action, waitcing the movement of troops who were advancing under General Crook, and did .ap return to 81ttlngBulI's camp until It hadd l from the Little-big-horn upon the sarrfviuj v u. Tonry. Therefore he could adh L*e killed Custer; and as to him or any other-Indian cuttiag out end eating a piece of Costr's heart, nothing of the kind was done. Custer's body was not mutilated, and the Indians did not know they had killed Custer until they learned It from outside parties several days after the fight; therefore it is not and never will be known who killed Custer. The -lndias supposed t was Custer's men they were fighting, and looked among the dead for a long-haired hbler, but inding none, they concluded that Custer wms not among the slain. General Custer bau bl hair eat Just bebrns going on that expedition. Rain-ta-theface mzkes no effort to correct these statements, lh3ing that they brtghi.m into notle, and through them be bomaes a pereso of some consequence and reeidve attentions that would not otherweis be be stowed. 2. H. Ar.4aow, 8eoat and laterprer,

See the clipping

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Scout E. H. Allison writes to correct newspaper claims that Rain-in-the-Face was a chief who killed Custer and ate his heart. He states Rain-in-the-Face was fifty miles away during the battle and that Custer's body was never mutilated.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 3 December 1886 · page 2

HISTORY CORRECTED.

A 'Modest Indian.' v." MINNEAPOLIS NOV. 26.—E. H. Allison, scout and interpreter, writes the Evening Journal from Taylor, Dakota, to correct certain newspaper misstatements concern­ ing the Indian, Rainin-the-Face. It has been said that he is a chief that he toon an active part in the battle of. the Little Big Horn that he is the Indian who killed Custer, and that he cut Custer's heart out and ate apiece of it. All of these state­ ments are absolutely false., Rain-in-tlie Face is not a chief, and took no part in the battle of the Little Big Horn.

See moreSee less

At the time the battle took place, Rain-iu-the-Face with sixteen otner braves was fifty miles distant from the scene of action, watching the movement of the troops who were advanc­ ing under General Crook, and did not re­ turn to Sitting Bull's camp until it hlid fled from the Little Big Horn upon the arrival of GeneraJ Terry. Hecould nothavekilled Custer, and as to him or any other Indian cutting out and eating a piece of Custer's heart, nothing of the kind was done, Custer's body was not mutilated, and the Indians did not know that they had killed Custer until they learned it from outside parties several days after the fight. The Indians looked among the dead for a long-haired chief, but finding none, they concluded that Custer was not among the slain. Gen. Custer had his hair cut just before going on that expedition. Had Rain-in-the face been there he would cer­ tainly have recognized Custer, as his face had become familiar to him when he was in the guard house at Fort Lincoln two years before under a charge of murder. Kain-in-the-Face is a cripple, having been injured by the accidental discharge of a gun. Long before the Custer massacre he was distinguished among his people for bravery and intense hatred of tne whites. This, together with the fact that he was arrested and held a prisoner at Fort Lin­ coln by Gen. Custer, has led to all the ab­ surd stories about him and he himself makes no effort to correct these statements, finding that they brini him into notice.

See the clipping

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · Butte, Mont.

A presidential proclamation will establish a military reservation and a national cemetery on the exact ground at the Little Bighorn where Custer and his men died in 1876. The report notes Fort Custer was built in 1877, six months after the battle, mainly to help keep the peace.

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · 4 December 1886 · page 3

CUSTER'S BATTLE GROUND.

New Military Reservation and Ceme tery to be Established Upon the Historic Spot. It will interest the people of Montana at large and the men who rode with and against General Custer—the Murat of the Union cavalry—to know that a proclamation will soon be issued by Mr. Cleveland for the establishment of a thirty-six-mile square, one township, military reservation about Fort Custer on the Big Horn River, in the Crow Reservation in this Territory in This proclamation will also reserve three ana a naît square miles ol land for National cemetery upon the precise grounds on which CuBter and his brave men fell in on 1876.

See moreSee less

Fort Custer was established in 1877, six mouths after the massacre of the Gen eral and bis command, and was probably established more for the preservation of peace than because of any strategic advan tages it offered. It has, since its comple tion, been heavily garrisoned, and there are two companies of infantry and three of cavalry there ilow.

See the clipping

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · Bozeman, Mont.

The article refutes popular rumors that Rain-in-the-Face was a chief who killed Custer and ate his heart, explaining he was 50 miles away during the battle. It states Custer's body was not mutilated and that no one can truly know who killed him.

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · 8 December 1886 · page 4

Rain-in-the-face, with 16 other braves, ! was 50 miles distant from the scene of | action, watching the movement.of troops • who were advancing under Gen. Crook, and did not return to Sitting Bull's camp | until it lias fled from the Little-big-horn j upon the arrival of Gen. Terry. There- ! fore'he could not have killed Custer; and ! as to him or any other Indian cutting j out and eating a piece of Custer's heart • nothing of the kind was done. Custer's body was not mutilated, and the Indians j did not know that thay had killed f 'us t-r until they learned it from outside ! parties several days after the fight, there

See the clipping

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · Bozeman, Mont.

Scout E.H. Allison states Custer's body was not mutilated and no Indian ate his heart, contrary to popular rumor. He explains the Indians never identified Custer's corpse because his hair was cut short, and that Rain-in-the-Face's fame stems from earlier imprisonment at Fort Lincoln, not from killing Custer.

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · 8 December 1886 · page 4

RAIN-IN-THE-FACE.

Long before the Custer massacre he was | distinguised among his peopl e for bravery and intense hatred ofttie whites. This, ; together with the fact that he was arresti ed and held a prisoner at Fort Lincoln 1 be Gen. Custer has led to all the absurd i stories about him; and he himself makes no effort to correct these statements, finding that they bring him into notice, j and through them he becomes a person of some consequence and receives atten tions that would not otherwise be bestow ed. E. H. Allison,

See the clipping

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

Howard C. Scott travels to Fort Yates to marry Roma DeRudio, daughter of Captain DeRudio of the Seventh Cavalry. The article recounts how Captain DeRudio survived the Little Bighorn battle by hiding in a thicket for 36 hours after his horse was shot from under him during Reno's retreat.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 8 days earlier.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 10 December 1886 · page 8

will be Wedded with Miss Roma Derudlo, daughter of Captain Derudio of the Seventh cavalry. Mr. Scott was formerly stationed here and for several years was a clerk at Lincoln. He is well'known, in the North­ west and is -a worthy young man. The soon-to-be bride is the daughter of one of the best known officers in the regular army, and one who witnessed the battle of the Little Big Horn in which Custer and his men were killed. Captain Derudio was with Reno and his horse was shot froin un­ der him while he was in the woods on the bank of the river.

See moreSee less

Without attempting to get back to his command—as the attempt would be snicidalr-he hid himself in a thicket and there renflttned without food or water tor thirty-six hours. He is an inter­ esting talker and can give a very vivid ac­ count of the battle as he saw it from his hiding place. The wedding of the captain's daughter with Mr. Scott will be celebrated at the post on Thursday evening. Not the 8alntlon Army. As the train from the east stopped at the depot Tuesday, loud and enthusiastic singing was heard, and the report was circulated that a company of the salvation tony was in the car. The notes that shot through the key holes and windows of the car were of more than ordinary musical harmony and the scribe made a dash for the car to enjoy the entertainment As he eng' hemence and eccentricity of a drum major. No sooner had the reporter closed the door than an intelligent appearing gentleman exclaimed very earnestly: "This is a private car, sir." "Excuse me, sir, but are newspaper men 'barred' "Are you a newspaper man 7" "Yes sir. Are you the captain of this army?" "What army "Why. the salvation army, of course." At this the singers ceased their warbling, the director dropped his baton and fell limp and weak into a seat and the intelligent genius who announced that the car was private, handed the scribe the following card: UN. A. Thompson, Manager Thompson

See the clipping

The Lusk Herald · Lusk, Wyo.

The president is expected to proclaim a 36-square-mile military reservation around Fort Custer on the Big Horn River in the Crow reservation, Montana. He will also set aside 3.5 square miles as a national cemetery on the site of the Custer battlefield.

The Lusk Herald · 10 December 1886 · page 1

। give the town a good name, and his es forts should be encouraged by every one who has the good of Lusk at heart. To Be Enlarged Washington Special: The president will soon declare by proclamation the es tablishment of a military reservation.con taining thirty-six square miles, or one township ol land surrounding Fort Custer on the Big Horn riv< r in the Crow Indian reservation. Montana. He will at the same lune make ’declaration of the reser vation of three ami one half square miles of land for the establishment of a national cemetery upon the site of the Custer bat tie field.

See moreSee less

Fort Custer was established in 1877, six months after the massacre of Custer’s command, and although not con sidered a strategic point, was considered necessary to the preservation of peace. It has been pretty heavily gnirisoned, nnd has at present five companies of infantry and three of cavalry in its garrisons. Early in July last the war department asked the Indian bureau for 4>><) square miles for the Fort ( uster reservation, but the request was considered exorbitant.

See the clipping

Springfield Globe-Republic · Springfield, Ohio · and 1 other paper

This report describes the structure of the Dakotah (Sioux) nation, listing its seven council fires or principal bands, including the Teton band from which Sitting Bull originated. It also details the Sun Dance ceremony, a ritual involving self-piercing performed to interpret dreams or avert misfortune.

Springfield Globe-Republic · 12 December 1886 · page 2

MORE ABOUT THE DAKOTAHS.

this band the Asslnaboines are sprung. Seventh The Tstonwans, or Village of the Prairie; about one-half of the entire Da kotah jieople. numbering about 113, MX) souls. Sitting Bull, the leader of the Custer massa cre, is from this band, and they are con sidered the finest body of men among the

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va. · 17 December 1886

Lancaster Daily Intelligencer · Lancaster, Pa.

The Secretary of the Interior's annual report describes progress in Indian affairs, citing reduced hostilities, increased school attendance, and more Indians living on individual land allotments. It also references the Custer massacre as an example of past mismanagement and urges creation of a commission to improve Indian agent quality and advance citizenship policy.

Lancaster Daily Intelligencer · 14 December 1886 · page 2

1 under the control of an able and honest man there need be llttle fear of a repeti tion et the scenes that preceded the Custer massacre, when ammunition trains were pissed through te Iudians already en the war path. The secretary says that llm nr.,. .i...

See the clipping

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

E.H. Allison, the scout who brought in Sitting Bull and helped secure the Indians' surrender after the Custer massacre, is passing through the city en route to a lecture tour. He has angered both Indians like Rain-in-the-Face and army personnel with recent published letters, and will now deliver paid lectures on his experiences in Brooklyn, New York, and other eastern cities.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 17 December 1886 · page 6

The Scout Will Lecture. E. H. Allison, the well-known scout, who brought Sitting Bull into camp and who was instrumental in securing the surren­ der of the Indians at the close of the war which was made memorable by the Custer massacre, is now in the city, and will leave in a few days for Brooklyn and New York. Allison has brought down upon his head the wrath of the Indians by certain letters which he has published of late, and Iiain-in-the-Face is particularly chagrinned. He has also gained the en­ mity of many of the regular army and whites upon the reservations, but as to who is In the wrong the TRIBUNE cannot say.

See moreSee less

Allison's mission in the east is to fill a number of engagements in the lecture field. He lias been offered ana accepted $1,500 for three months' service, and will deliver his first lecture in Brooklyn. Thence he will go to New York, Philadel­ phia, Boston and other citieii The subject of his lecture will be the Indians, and he will attempt to give an accurate account of his experiences as a scdut.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A traveler recounts touring the Sioux reservation in Dakota Territory a decade after the Custer massacre, meeting the warrior American Horse who had once chased him. The piece also describes preparations for the wedding of the last hereditary Sioux royal heir, with legendary background on the chief 'Old Smoke.'

St. Paul Daily Globe · 25 December 1886 · page 24

TERRITORY OF DAKOTA

extending his hand: "How. kolah. how." It was American Horse, whom 1 had not seen since a few weeks after the Custer I massacre, when he did me the honor of ' chasing me several miles, interspersing his ' attempt to catch up with several leaden in- • vitations to halt. But now "bis heart was good," he drew rations and was being

See the clipping

The Southern Herald · Liberty, Miss.

The War Department issued an order setting aside Fort Custer as a military reservation, describing its boundaries. The notice states the fort is located on the site of the Custer massacre.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Southern Herald · 25 December 1886 · page 4

, aueciionaie ouci nigs miiicu io ineir t acainst the measure. ages, sexes and conditions, and to The Commissioner of the Gener-' mingle in social intercourse one al Land Office has notified the local; with another, and to strengthen land offices in California and Now friendships by a more intimate re Mexico that the lands of the Atlan-Ration with each other. To our tic and Pacific Railroad Company j friends and readers of the Herald which were forfeited by the act of what can wc say more than to wish July 6, 1886, have been restored to 'you a happy Christmas and con the public domain, and are open to !

See moreSee less

tinued prosperity? We have long settlement at $2 ,50 and $1 25 per : been accustomed to send our greetcrcing to the people of beloved old An order has been issued from j Amite, freighted with the best the War Department setting aside wishes of our hearts for their hap Fort Custer, Arizona, as a military P'"ess and annual holiday enjoy reservation, and describing its j mcnt.and hope to continue thus to metes and bounds. Frfrt Custer is ! visit .vou whilu The Herald holds on the site of the Custer massacre. a Place amon8 thc Press of Missis It has been a military post for some ! siPP. aHd to be ablc to furnlsh -vou time, but the department now takes !such information at all times as iM Ant ,..v, it will bo protitahlc as well as a . . B 111 U, .HI U W 1 V . ' 1 V. .V II V. 111, -

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A theater news item reports that Steele Mackaye is adding a new feature to Buffalo Bill's Wild West show: a dramatic representation of the Battle of Little Big Horn, also known as the Custer Massacre. About $12,000 was spent on preparations, with Buffalo Bill himself playing Custer and actual Native Americans performing as the Indians.

New-York Tribune · 26 December 1886 · page 11

Bellaw will of course ob Charles, r1ervert Keleey Joseph , Mr. Henlay Orablree, Harry Edwards sr Oliver, Mr. Hambiton ~ir Benjamin, Charles Groves Moses, Aunle Robe Lady Teazle, Mme. Ponist Mrs. Candour, Miss Carrie Coote Maria, and Miss Sadie Bigelow Lady sneerwell. ‘The scenery by Philip Goalober is ull new. Lawrence Barrett's production of “ Rienzi” in Washington was one of the evenis of tue season there. Mr. Barrett was tiken out to Ked Top by the President and Mrs. Cleveland and was entertained by wany leading politicians. To-morrow tienzi” will receive its second performanes in Providence.

See moreSee less

Steele Mackaye having recovered from the fatigus in. cident to his stage management of “Rienzi ” is once more at work upon the Wild West. Another leature 1s to be added to the entertainment which, it is promised, will be even wore *thriliing” (han apy of those that have already been seen. This novelty will be a representation of the ba’ le of the Little Big Hor, generally kuown as the Custer Massacre. Some $12,000 is said to have been spent on tho preparations. Buflalp Bil hklwsel! will impersonate Custer and the Indians will be the genuire imported article. An important part of the audiences are made up of people from out of town.. These arrive ners by special excursions from places as far away aa Boston, Philadelphia, and Provideace, ana wake the Wile Wes: the culef object of thelr visit. On Thursday last, a contract was signed bLetween David Belasco and Clay Greene of the one part and Miss Lotta or the other. By the terms of (lis Belasco and Greene agres to furnish the actress wilk a new comedy for next season. A check for $1,000 was handed to the dramatists and when the play is compisted avd produced they will receive £4,000 more. The play is said to be o: rather a higher order of comedy than those in which Lotta has been aceustomed to appear. Belasco 13 also at'work on a play he is writing with Mr. ae Mille for the Lyceum Theatrs vext season.

See the clipping

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A humor item mocks an English traveler duped into buying a supposed arrow that killed Custer for $20 in Montana. It then notes that historical fact contradicts such fiction, stating Custer's body was found unmutilated by the Sioux and untouched by any arrow.

Rock Island Daily Argus · 29 December 1886 · page 3

beside him. and not a soul else in tho vehicle. Boston Traveler. FMita and Fiction. In Montana there ia still a tendener to crash high hats and prcy on the pocketbook and entimeiit of too tenderfoot. To cito a single instance of umuitifrated gall triumphing over credulity in that section, an English traveler on our train purchased for 93) the arrow that killed Custer. As far an the frstimony of history is coneomed relative to tho dreadful battle scene that lay silent overlooking the banks of the Little Big Horn, the body of the dashing, golilen-liuired Custer was found un mutilated by the lmnd of the savago Hioux, undcfilod by the touch of an arrow. Thus fact triumph.- over fiction. Cor. Chicago lu-ter-Oceau.

See the clipping

New Ulm Weekly Review · New Ulm, Minn.

The War Department has set aside Fort Custer as a permanent military reservation, located on the site of the Custer massacre. The decision to preserve the historical spot is described as commendable.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

New Ulm Weekly Review · 29 December 1886 · page 4

The war department has issued an order setting aside Fort Custer, Arizo na, as a permanent military reserva tion. The Fort is located upon the site of the Custer massacre, and the deci.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This is a theater advertisement for Buffalo Bill's Wild West show at Madison Square Garden, announcing holiday performances and new additions to the program. It specifically promotes the first staged representation of the Battle of Little Big Horn and the death of General Custer as part of the entertainment.

New-York Tribune · 30 December 1886 · page 7

Visit the Camp and Indian Village after the perfor nance. Spectral imducements offered to schools and tn -titutions. h oplay, first representation of the famous battle Big Horn and death eof the brave Gene the Little Custer.

See the clipping

Canton Register · Canton, Ill.

A man describes a hunting trip with Crow Indians through the mountains, including a scene of communal deer-eating around a campfire. Upon returning, he finds Sitting Bull and ninety followers dancing with the Crows around the monument marking Custer's 1876 defeat, which he describes with bitterness as celebrating a massacre.

Canton Register · 30 December 1886 · page 7

THE SAVAGE SIOUX.

lields as we were riding over the country. When 1 returned 1 found Sitting Bull here with ninety of his followers, having a dance with the Crows. They danced around the monument of General Custer and his three hundred dead companions, whom they slew in lS7t>. It made the white blood a little warm to see the brutes thus celebrating this massacre, but they were too many for us. and we had to keop quiet, just as a saloon-keeper does when a gang of cowboys shoot the necks off his bottles, tire through his mirrors, etc. When the ceremony was through they de parted for Boplar Kiver, D. T., their home.’*

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This is an advertisement for Buffalo Bill's Wild West show at Madison Square Garden, announcing a new attraction debuting Monday: a theatrical representation of the Battle of the Little Big Horn and the death of General Custer. The ad also lists show times, prices, and other attractions like the Indian village and Mexican restaurant.

New-York Tribune · 31 December 1886 · page 7

Women and Children tn the MOST STUPENDOUS EXHIBITION OF THE AGE, Branch ticket office. Pond’s music stora, 25 Union Square. Doors open at 1 and 7p. m. Genuine Mexican R stanrant, Visit the Camp and [ndian Village after the psriormaace. Special inducements offered to schools and institutions. Monday, first representation of the famous battle on the Little Big Horn and death of the brave General Custer.

See the clipping