As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

January 1887

15 articles

The Morning Star · Carlisle, Pa.

A newspaper reports that Buffalo Bill Cody's Wild West show features a reenactment of the 'Battle on the Little Big Horn,' popularly called the Custer Massacre, performed by Sioux, Cheyenne, and Pawnee Indians. It also includes criticism that touring with the show exposes Native performers to alcohol, vice, and disease, undermining reservation civilizing efforts.

The Morning Star · 1 January 1887 · page 4

“The Custer Massacre,” as Big Horn,” or it is popularly called. One of our young | _ _ _ 1.1.. g * men who visited his father in Buffalo Bill’s employ tells us that while sleeping in his father’s lodge there, he was waked up by partly intoxicated Indian showmen three times in one night and urged to drink whiskey with them, and they pressed him to go to the brothels of the city with like testimony Other them, 0011108 to us. The false notions and vile habits carried back to the reservations by these one hundred showmen will go a great way toward nullifying the heat agent’s efforts

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Buffalo Bill's Wild West show at Madison Square Garden draws large nightly crowds, with its reenactment of the Battle of Little Big Horn proving especially popular. Buffalo Bill himself plays General Custer to great applause, and the show will soon depart for London after a successful season.

New-York Tribune · 9 January 1887 · page 4

————— E . — CROWDS AT THE WILD WEST SHOW. Buffalo Bill's Wild West tn the Madison Square Garden is nore prosperous than ever, judging from the great orowds of people who visit it nightly and at the Tuesday, Tharsday and Saturday matineos, Tho representation of the famous battle of tho Little Big Horn has given the exhibition a new lease of Life and has proved an emphatic success. Buffalo Bill us General Custer is greatly applauded as every performance, Many military men have visited the garlen to see the Custer battle and among the most enthusiastic of them, soem ingly, was General Sherman, The Wild West must scon deputt for an early opening in London, hence the season here, which has (n many respects been a remarkable one, must be brought (oa close in u fow weeks.

See moreSee less

Iu Lio meantime other eon oh will bo introduced from time to tie and everything will be done by the management 10 Keep alive public interest Lore has bool al AVOrage dally attendance of over 7,000

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

During a Wild West show performance of the Custer Massacre, Buffalo Bill slipped and accidentally struck Sergeant Bates with his sword, cutting his brow. The next day, Sergeant Bates and some of the show's Indians visited a school to watch the children's opening exercises.

New-York Tribune · 13 January 1887 · page 5

SERGEANT BATES WOUNDED AND * BUFFALO BILL'S” REIN BARKED—INDIANS AT A SCHOOL, There was a little real bloodshed at ** Buffalo Bill's representation of the Custer Massacre on Tuesday afterpoon. The United States Cavalry, nuder thelr yellow. wigged chief, had charged as usual on the Sionx camp, and had been caught in the ambush and mussacred. o puttalo BIL” with sword drawn afd empty pistols, was still keeping Sitting Bull's braves off from the vantage ground of a little platforin, painted like a manned, As he brandished his sabre for the last time, however, his foot slipped and ho fell from the wooden stand, barking his skin against the rongh boards.

See moreSee less

In the sharpness of the pain he let his sword fall to one side. The blade struck sergeant Bates, who was lying flat at the base of the mound, across the brow. The curtain wns rong down before the spectators eonld notlee what had happened, serceant Bates has been wearing a big piece of court

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Inspector-General Baird traveled to Fort Duchesne, Utah to investigate conditions there under orders from General Sheridan, following an earlier inspection that blamed Major Benteen of the 9th Cavalry. Benteen, who served under Reno at the time of the Custer massacre, is to be court-martialed at Fort Duchesne in February on charges of drunkenness.

New-York Tribune · 13 January 1887 · page 2

AN OFFICER TO BE TEIED FOR DRUNKENNESS, WASHISOTON, Jan, 12.—~Inspector-General Baird left Washington to-day for Port Duchesne, Utah, to make a thorough iuvestigation of affairs at that post under speelal structions from General Sheridan. A previous inspection of the post by direction of General Crook Jiowed an unsatisfactory condition of affairs, particularly with regard to the protection of the troops durmg the winter, and resulted in throwing the blame upon Major Benteen, of the 9th Cavalry, stationed there. An order has been {issued at Fort leavrth for the trial of Major Benteen on charges of enw tolonel Charles A, Kanbe is to be president drankenness which 1s to meet at Fort Duchesne, February we court nieen ts a welbknown Army othicer and has Major | (Cant record as a fighter, He belonged to Major a bri o's command at the time of the Custer massacre, Ie jmnior major of cavalry, having been promoted a short ting wgo, — i —

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Inspector General Baird is sent to Fort Duchesne, Utah to investigate unsatisfactory conditions blamed on Major Benteen, including poor winter troop protection. An order has been issued for Benteen's court-martial on drunkenness charges, with the trial set for February 7th under Col. Eaube.

Evening Star · 13 January 1887 · page 1

Major Benteen to be Court Martialed

UNSATISFACTORY CONDITION OF AFFAIRS AT FORT DUCHESNE. Inspector General Balrd left Washington yester day for Fort Duchesne, Utah, to make a thorough Investigation of affairs at that post, under special instructions from Gen. Sheridan. A previous In spection of the post by direction of Gen. crook showed a very unsatisfactory condition of affairs, particularly with regard to the protection of troops during the winter, and resulted in throw ing the blame upon Major Benteen, of the 91 h cavalry, ^rationed there. Gen. Balrd!s inspection Is to be complete and show exactly who is respon sible.

See moreSee less

It is learned that an order has been Issued at Fort Leavenworth for the trial of Major Benteen on charges of drunkenness. CoL Charles A. Eaube is to be president of the court, which is to meet at Fort Duchesne, February 7th. Major Benteen is a well-known army officer, and has a brilliant record as a fighter. He belonged to Major Reno's command at the time of the Custer massa cre. He is the junior major of cavalry, having been promoted a short time ago. ?? Monument to IVefpro Soldier* and Sailor*

See the clipping

New York Dispatch · New York, N.Y.

A newspaper entertainment listing describes Madison Square Garden's 'Great Wild West' spectacle, which includes a dramatic reenactment titled 'The Battle of the Little Big Horn' featuring Custer's last rally and his death scene. The item notes the show continues to draw large nightly audiences.

New York Dispatch · 16 January 1887 · page 5

Globe Museum.—Proprietors Meehan and Wilson announce as their chief attraction for this present week the appearance of Mr. A. O. Babel, the cowboy pianist, who, it will be remembered, gave his first performance in thia city last season at Steinway Hall. He is said to be a “natural-born” musicfan. He will appear at each recital—every hour—in the ordinary costume worn by the cow boys of Texas. All the great collection of animate and Inanimate ourios and freaks of nature will be seen on exhibi tion as usual. Perfoi m inces will be given every hour in the theatorium.

See moreSee less

Madison Square Garden.-The new and realistic dramatic addition to the “Great Wild West” apectaole—“The Battle of the Little Big Horn,” With Custer’s last rally and the representation of the scenes attending his deatn—finds no abatement as yet in its attractiveness, and therefore it is that the vast amphitheatre of the Garden is nightly thronged With large audiences. The usual matinees will be given on Tuesday,

See the clipping

The River Press · Fort Benton, Mont.

Buffalo Bill's Wild West show is performing at Madison Square Garden in New York, including a daily reenactment of General Custer's death at the Little Big Horn, with Buffalo Bill playing Custer. Forest and Stream magazine criticizes the exhibition as a disrespectful burlesque of dead soldiers' memory.

The River Press · 19 January 1887 · page 4

Big Horn. Buffalo Bill takes the part of the hero, wears an auburn wig and other wise makes up to represent Custer. The Forest and Stream protests against the ex

See the clipping

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper personal item reports that Major Benteen, who served under Reno at the time of the Custer massacre, is being investigated for drunkenness while on duty at Fort Duchesne, Utah. It also recounts his military career history, including his later transfer to the 7th U.S. Cavalry as captain in 1866.

The National Tribune · 20 January 1887 · page 4

PERSONAL. Ex-Senator Dorsey hns gone to Europe. MuJ. Ben teen, who belonged to Reno's command at the time of tho Custer massacre, and who has a brilliant record as a daring cavalry officer, is to bo investigated for drunkenness whileon duty at Fort Duchesne, Utah. He entered the army as a Lieutenant in the 10th Mo. Car. Sept. llS6I,bccamo

See the clipping

The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn.

A court-martial has been ordered at Fort Duchesne, Utah, to try a field officer, reportedly Maj. Frederick Benteen of the Ninth Cavalry, on charges of drunkenness. The report notes Benteen's distinguished record in Custer's last campaign and that an inspector general has been sent to oversee the proceedings.

The Worthington Advance · 20 January 1887 · page 2

It}. Veiteei to ba Tried. Omaha Special.—An order Issued from military headquarters ill this city recently calls for a court-martial at Fort Duchesne, Utah Feb. 7. The fact that two colonel's three lieutenant colonels and six majors are to compose the court shows that a field officer is to be triod. It is an open secret that that officer is Maj. Fred­ erick Benteen, ot the Ninth cavalry lately in command ot Fort Duchesne and who was suddenly relieved by Col. Edward F. Hatch. The charge is stated to be drunk' enness.

See moreSee less

Benteen made a brilliant record in Custer's last campaign. The announce* ment that Li^ut, Col, Absalom Baird, in­ spector general, has been ordered to pro­ ceed from Wellington to Duchesne is tak­ en as evidence here that the army head q"urtcrs at Washington will not permit the ease to con:o to trial unless thecircum stances are so flagrant as to prevent it be­ ing arranged otherwise without detriment to tho service.

See the clipping

Little Falls Transcript · Little Falls, Minn.

A military order calls for a court-martial of Maj. Frederick Benteen, formerly of Custer's command, at Fort Duchesne, Utah, on charges of drunkenness. The report notes his noted record during Custer's last campaign and suggests army officials may try to resolve the matter without a full trial.

Little Falls Transcript · 21 January 1887 · page 2

Kaj. Benteen to be Triad.' Omaha Special.—An onler issued from military headquarters in this city recently calls for a court-martial at ForUDuchesne, Utah, Feb. 7. Tlie fact that two colonel's three lieutenant colonels and six majorB are to compose the court shows that a field officer is to be tried. It is an open secret that that officer is Maj. Fred­ erick Benteen, of the Ninth cavalry lately in command of Fort Duchesne and who was suddenly relieved by Col. Edward F. Hatch. The charge i.s stated to be drunk­ enness.

See moreSee less

Benteen made a brilliantrecordin Custer's last campaign. The announce­ ment that Lieut. Col. Absalom Baird, in­ spector general, has been ordered to pro­ ceed from Washington to Duchesne is tak­ en as evidence here that the army head­ quarters at Washington will not permit the case to come to trial unlesB the circum­ stances are so flagrant as,to prevent it be­ ing arranged otherwise without detriment to the service.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A New York Star item recounts club-dinner gossip attributing views to General Sherman that blamed a subordinate commander's retreat for Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn. It further claims some believed Custer shot himself to avoid capture and ransom by the Indians.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Indianapolis Journal · 23 January 1887 · page 11

Did General Custer Commit Suicide? New York Star,, A gentleman wa3 relating the other night at a club dinner soma remarks which General Sher man lately made in conversation about the death of Custer and tho causes which led to it la army circles, it seems, the" opinion has long pre vailed that the massacre of General Custer and his command at the Little Big Horn was due to the misconduct of the commander of one of the detachments of United States troops. Tho force was jn three divisions, and two of these one be ing under the direct leadership of Custer were to close in noon the flanks of the Indian camp.

See moreSee less

The second division, without engaging , the In dians at all, retreated; and although the third division met the retreating troops and tried to force them back to the scene of operations, ifc was too late. Custer's men were overpowered. In the same conversation the belief was ex pressed that, seeing the situation, the gallant commander shot himself in order to avoid the horrors of capture and prevent the advantage which the Indians would have gained if thoy could have held him for a ransom.

See the clipping

Alpena Weekly Argus · Alpena, Mich.

This is a humor/wit column from 1887 containing a brief pun referencing Custer's death at Little Big Horn as a joke about failure. It is not a news report but a later passing reference used for comedic effect.

Alpena Weekly Argus · 26 January 1887 · page 1

WIT AND HUMOR

The Lick glass cost $50,000. A liquor glass is oftentimes more expen sive" Boston Transcript. Many a man besides brave Custer has fallen at the Little Big Horn.

See the clipping

The Hope Pioneer · Hope, N.D.

The report recounts how Bismarck was founded in 1872 by railroad speculators and grew due to military supply traffic and Black Hills gold rush activity. It notes that Custer's 1871 expedition to the Black Hills sparked gold rumors, leading to the 1876 Indian war and Custer's death.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Hope Pioneer · 28 January 1887 · page 1

DAKOTA'S CAPITAL

1871, Geu. Custer, then In charge of Fort Lin coln, fitted out an expedition to the Black Hills with a view to set at rest the question as to whether there was gold there or not The scientific authorites who accompanied Custer reported that they saw no gold, and that the rock found there was not a gold-bearing rock but soon, miners who had explored the Hills, brought back a number of specimens tbat set tled the matter. The papers throughout the country were filled with these reports, Iu 1876 there was a Btampede made for tlie Hills, notwithstanding that several parties who had reached there the year before were removed by the government troops.

See moreSee less

Iu 1879 more than one thousand teams were engaged iu freight ing between Bismarck and the Hills. The occupation of the Hills led to the Indian war of 1876, the massacre of Custer and his com

See the clipping

Lincoln County Tribune · North Platte, Neb.

A local social gossip report describes a party where Mrs. W. M. Evans displayed her collection of Indian relics gathered during her residence in Dakota. Some items reportedly belonged to Sitting Bull, and several were picked up from the Custer massacre battlefield.

Lincoln County Tribune · 29 January 1887 · page 3

tion of Indian relics gathered by Mrs. E. during a residence in Dakota. A number of these formerly belonged to Sitting Bull and several were picked up on the field of the Custer massacre. Before the strik

See the clipping

The Big Horn Sentinel · Big Horn, Wyo.

The Wild West show troupe, featuring Buffalo Bill playing Custer, performs nightly reenactments of the Battle of Little Bighorn at Madison Square Garden. The article describes the theatrical battle sequence and criticizes the show as inappropriate given that Custer's widow reportedly lives in the area and the event remains too recent for such spectacle.

The Big Horn Sentinel · 29 January 1887 · page 1

The IJ.tlr Ul* U«rM. i The Wild W»\.» ithow troupe of cow (•oiaand Indiana, now performing at the Madpton Square Garden. New York, angiving ilaily exhibition* of how (trneral UuMer win killed in the tattle of the Little Big Horn. Buffalo Bill, uho taken the part of the hero, w turn an auburn wig and othrnUM makes lup to represent Uunter. The perform ance h thus desenlted by the Times: “In the first scene is show n the camp of the troops cuminundtwl by General CuMtcr. The tn«o|«s and msuilm march out of camp.

See moreSee less

One of the scouts dts covem the Sioux village. Sitting Bull an<l his warriors arc ap|>arrntly en gaged in the innocent pastinws of prairie life. The se»»ut retires and in forms Custer that the enemy is at hand and in fair condition to ta wi|axl off the face of the earth. The sound of the bugle is hrard. The Indians in slantly prepare an ambush. Custer and his men dash Into the open space from the Madison avenue end of the garden. The bugler sounds tbocharge. Custer waves his sword, puts spurs to his charger ami. followisl by his men. rides down u|mhi the Indian village like a cyclone Instantly the troo|is arc surrounded by w hooping Indians, and a "tiTTinr hand-to-hand comtat" en sues. In an extremely short s|m<-o of tune the Indians gain a complete victo ry. Custer Is the last man killtsl. and he dies after performing prisHgn-s of \alor. Then the survhon« i»«d men indulge in a war whoop and u shrieking match, and the curtain falls to slow music,’’ The tattle of the Little Big Horn was fought in the summer of IN7<k The death of gallant Custer, ten years ago, has not yet livroine an incident of his ' tory so remote as legitimately to Is* made the nubj««ct of a circus show. If we are not mistaken Mrs. Custer Is

See the clipping