As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

November 1886

24 articles

The Emporia Weekly News · Emporia, Kan.

The report describes a visit to Washington by a man identified as a survivor of Custer's command, who delivered Custer's final order to Major Reno before the battle. It recounts how this order saved his life, as he was away from the battlefield when the rest of the command was killed.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: The McCook Tribune, 28 October 1886, The Anderson Intelligencer, 28 October 1886, The New North-West, 29 October 1886.

The Emporia Weekly News · 4 November 1886 · page 2

and at tbe war department the past week r? n nlup V.HLn. an I A n wi,. with the exception of one Indian scout, of the Custer massacre. He was by the side of Custer when tbe latter spied the camp of the hostile Sioux, and Coster, without lesving tbe spot, tore a leaf from his diary and wrote npon it bis order for Msor lie no to hurry op with his command, and gave it to Mart'ne to deliver. That order saved tbe life of Mar tine, for when be got back to the some there was not another member ot tbe com mand ol 206 men aliye.

See moreSee less

Martina is here to secure a .messengershtD in the war de partment, as be is tired of a soldier's border life, and says that he has had his share of a soldier's hardship. General ShertoaD is espousing the survivor's causr, and he will doubtless hereafter be comfortably lodgi d In the palatial butldingof the war department. Instead ot exposed to tbe verities of winter in the western wilds. H.

See the clipping

Phillipsburg Herald · Phillipsburg, Kan.

In this 1886 interview, Buffalo Bill Cody recounts frontier adventures including meeting Kit Carson, then describes how news of Custer's massacre at Little Big Horn reached General Merritt's column in 1876. He goes on to narrate the pursuit of Cheyenne warriors and the skirmish leading to his famous duel with Yellow Hand.

Phillipsburg Herald · 6 November 1886 · page 4

General Custer was slain on the 25th of June, when I was acting aa scout for the Fifth cavalry, under General Merritt We were on our way to Fort Laramie when the news reached us thut Custer and Lis gallant troops Lad been massa cred on the Little Big Horn. We started back to loin General Crook in the Big Horn country, when we received word thut 800 Cheyenne warrioua had that day left the lied Cloud agency to join Sitting Bull's forces. General Merritt resolved to inteicept the Cheyennea. He

See the clipping

Phillipsburg Herald · Phillipsburg, Kan.

Buffalo Bill Cody narrates in his own words a duel with a Cheyenne chief, Yellow Hand, whom he shoots and scalps after their horses fall, declaring it 'the first scalp for Custer.' He describes the chief's father, Cut-Nose, later offering mules to buy back his son's scalp and regalia.

Phillipsburg Herald · 6 November 1886 · page 4

titij and bhot Lis horsa dead in Lis tracts. At the same instance my Lorse stepped into a hole and fell. I was not injured by my horse's fall and f prang upon my feet. The Indian arose as quickly as I did and faced me not twen ty steps distant. We both raised our rilles and fired at the same time. He missed me and my bullet entered Lis breast. In a second I was on Liiu and drove the knife to the Lilt Li Lis Leart. Then I pulled off )us w ar bonnet aud scalped Lini in the rnuet approved In diuu style.

See moreSee less

TLe Indians, seeing their chief siuin, charged upon me. Colonel Mason, with Company K., came to my assistance and drove the enemy back. As the soldiers galloped up I held up the scalp and the war Laonnet and shout ed: 'The first scalp for Custer!' The chief killed w.is Yelio Hand, son of old

See the clipping

Great Falls Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

Ten years after Little Bighorn, Sitting Bull and sixty warriors reportedly planned a war dance at the Custer battleground but were talked out of it. En route, Sitting Bull bullied a Cheyenne agency into giving him rations meant for another band.

Great Falls Tribune · 6 November 1886 · page 4

* Sitting Bull Bluffs the Agent. .Ib,lemston~ Journal: Sitting Bull and a band of sixty warriors were, a short time ago, bound to hold a war dance at the Custer battle ground, which project, however, Mr. Bull was persuaded to re linquish. In their progress across coun try they took in Upshaw's Ceyenne agen cy. Sitting Bull was aware of a scarcity of provisions in the forage department of his expedition, and called upon Agent Lpshaw for a replenishment. The agent had heard many blood-curdling rumors of the savage chieftain, and when ai proached by the haughty warrior attempt ed to talk him out of the scheme the wily Sioux had hit upon to gain a supply of hog, hominy and chicory, but the old chief became more dictatorial in his man ner and would not accept "No" for an answer.

See moreSee less

At last Mr. Upshaw said, "These are not my rations, they belong to Black Wolf's band. Old Bull laughed in his sleeve at the impression he was making of "Observer," that bulldozing was be ing practiced by influential citizens of Great Falls upon the laboring-men is a malicious falsehood, and "Obser ver" knows it.

See the clipping

The Livingston Enterprise · Livingston, Mont.

A decade after Little Bighorn, Sitting Bull and warriors reportedly planned a war dance at the old battlefield before visiting Cheyenne Agency. There he intimidated agent Upshaw into handing over rations meant for another band.

The Livingston Enterprise · 6 November 1886 · page 1

Sitting Dull ItluflT« the Agent. Yellowstone Journal: Sitting Bull and a band of sixty warriors were, a short time ago, bounit to hold a war dance at the Custer battle ground, which project, however, Mr. Bull was persuaded torelin* quisli. In their progress across country they took in Upshaw's Cheyenne agency. Sitting Bull was aware of a scarcity of

See the clipping

New York Dispatch · New York, N.Y.

Madison Square Garden's 'Wild West' exhibition announces a new winter attraction featuring one hundred warriors from the Sioux, Crow, Pawnee, Comanche, Wichita and Cheyenne tribes. They will reenact the battle and massacre at Little Big Horn where General Custer was killed.

New York Dispatch · 7 November 1886 · page 5

Madison Square Garden. — New in herent is to be given to the -Wild West ” exhibition at tho Madison Square Garden this Winter, by the engagement of one hundred warriors from the Sioux, Crow, Pawnee, Comanche, Wichita and Chey enne tribes, to take part in the representation of the memorable battle and massacre on the Little Big Horn, in which Gen. Custer was killed. These hos tiles, some of whom have been upon the war-path ■©ver since their tribes had an existence, are to bury the hatchet in Madison Square Garden and go into the peace:ul business of instructing the white man.

See the clipping

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · Bozeman, Mont.

The report describes Sitting Bull and sixty warriors reportedly planning a war dance at the old Custer battleground a decade after Little Bighorn, before being talked out of it. It also recounts a tense exchange with Indian agent Upshaw over rations during the band's travels.

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · 10 November 1886 · page 2

1329 1455 1201 1255 1245 13891 019 660 sal Tbe Mctiibeny's. Of the celebrated McGib&ny family, who will give a concert this evening, the Boston Daily Globe says : "It i« pleasant to see the McGibeny family on the stage. There is an agreeable absence of con ventionalism in their grouping, as well as in the way in which they carry out their concert programme; and if the fif teen great and small McGibenrs do not from a very happv as well as *h uncom monly talented household, all signs and indications are wonderfully at fault.

See moreSee less

The McGibeny 's were greeted last night by a large audience. Their sppcarance in the Dahlgren cours? last week was very successful; and their entertainment yesterdBy evening met with every mark of popular faver." From The Husbandman. The farmers of Montana need have no no fears of a tumble in oats this season since he speculators that supply our markets are buying in Salt Lake, Pocatello, Ida ho, and (laying $1.35 per hundred there, and we think the same figure in Dakota. Oats at Townsend rensuin firm at $1,50 to $1.50 per cwt., delivered.on board the cars. At these figures farmers make some money and should be happy. We do not anticipate that prices will be low er for a number of years, as consumption is increasing much more than the amount produced. The barley crop grown by Thomas Neild, of the Missouri valley, this year, only yielded about 800 bushels. Had it it not been for a hail storm of a few min utes duration the yield would have been much more. He estimates the loss by by the hail at not less than 2,000 bushels The quality of the gram raised is must excellent. mol«» Bull m«g i tta Sitting Bull and a band of sixty war

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

An advertisement for a Wild West theatrical extravaganza promotes a dramatic recreation of frontier life, featuring Buffalo Bill, Chief Gall, and performers including Dick Curley, billed as 'the sole survivor of the Custer massacre.' The show promises hundreds of performers, elaborate painted scenery, and a parade through the streets.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 14 November 1886 · page 7

BUFFALO BILL HIMSELF. DICK CURLEY, the sole survivor of the Custer massacre, and CHIEF GAUL, the Indian warrior who led the hostile savages In that terrible conttiet, will appear.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A theatrical production is described featuring elaborate scenery by Matt Morgan depicting the civilization of the West, culminating in a staged reenactment of the Custer massacre. The performance will include Dick Carley, billed as the sole survivor of Custer's band, and Chief Gall, who led the Indians in the battle.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 14 November 1886 · page 11

[he gray Light ot dawn gradually ereeps on the scene and makes vaguely visible its dim isla and e¢avern. ons recesses, and the magnitude of the torces against which man had to fight is revealed, Through all its steps and gradral development we then trace the eivtization of the West, The sturdy pioneer with axe and rifle, his sole links to cirilization, is seen maintaining lis war with barbarian natare and barbarian man. Ihe lite of the plains is shown as well as the lite of the forest, and I am making a yrave mistake if the educational aspect ot this entertainment is not as marked as the merely interest ng and amusing.” It was learned that a representation of the celebrated Custer massacre will form a chiet episode of the performane-, the interest in this being heightened by the

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A theatrical gossip column reports that Native American performers from several Plains tribes are traveling to New York to stage a representation of the battle and massacre of the Little Big Horn, in which Custer was killed. The item appears amid unrelated theater and actor news of the day.

The Indianapolis Journal · 14 November 1886 · page 12

sentation of the battle and massacre of the Little Big Horn, in which Custer was killed. Colonel Mapleson, with Nordiea. Fohstrom, Has treiter and Dotti is at Glasgow, Scotland, giving suc cessful operatic performances. Mr. .1. I\. Emmet, jr., is now managing his father’s business. To see “Fritz" on the stage one would not think he was old enough to have a son capable of managing anything, but the young Emmet, has proven to be a capable business man. It is now stated that Mr. Irving will come to Amer ica next season.

See moreSee less

There was at one time some talk to the effect that Mr. Irving’s next tour of the United .States would be conducted by the Messrs. Nixon & Zimmerman, of Philadelphia, but that plan, if it had ever had any real existence in fact, has now been abandoned, and Mr. Irving will manage himself. It is the intention to produce nothing but “Faust,’’ which has been a tremendous success at the Lycuom, in London. Air. Irving will open at the Star Theater, in New York.

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

A Bismarck contractor named Gallagher visited the Little Bighorn battlefield and found a decayed soldier's boot containing human foot bones under sagebrush near the Custer monument. The relic appeared undisturbed since the 1876 massacre.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 18 November 1886 · page 8

a famous Custer battle field on the Little Big Horn. While looking about there, he found a curiou3 relic of the massacie, which he brought to that city. About half a mile from the Custer monument,

See the clipping

The Pulaski Citizen · Pulaski, Tenn.

A man identified as bugler Martin, claiming to be the sole survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, is in Washington seeking a government job with Sheridan's endorsement. He recounts being sent with orders to Reno and Benteen before the battle, and describes scout Curly's disguise-based escape among the Sioux.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Pulaski Citizen · 18 November 1886 · page 1

Sole Survivor of Custe, o Command. Tbe sole survivor of tbe t uster massacre, 0 bugler named Martin, is in the city an appli cant for a messenger-ship in ono of the de partments. He is indorsed by Gen. Sheridan, and will probably got a place in the war de partment Martin said to-day lie was with Custer when he spied the Indian village, and was sent with an order hurrying up Maj. Reno and Capt Benteen. To this circum stanco Martin probably owes his life, as when he returned the other 265 men of Custer's command were dead upon tho ground.

See moreSee less

"I was the only soldier survivor," said Martin. "There was an Indian scout named 'Curly' who made his escape. Before tho battfe com menced ho saw that it would be a massacre, so he loosened his hair, snatched a piece of red trimming from his clothes to tie it with, tore a black blanket iu two and wrapped it around his legs, as if he wore leggings, and then throwing a blanket over his shoulders ho looked not unlike a hostile Sioux. Ho dashed into their midst and was not detected, and thus made his escape." Washington Cor.

See the clipping

West Virginia Argus · Kingwood, W. Va.

A satirical item mocks the growing number of people claiming to be the lone survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn, joking that this figure will soon outnumber the original troops. It suggests he'll eventually hold conventions and nominate himself for office.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: New-York Tribune, 14 November 1886, New-York Tribune, 14 November 1886.

West Virginia Argus · 18 November 1886 · page 2

Iiie Washington monument is 656 feet high, which is the highest 1 artificial structure in the world, and the statue of Liberty is over 300 feet high, and is the tallect statue the world has ever seen. America is getting up in the world. __ The only surviver of the Custer massacre is becoming so roultitudij nous that unless some of him dies oH soon he wlil be holding conventions and nominating himself for all the offices in this land. Already he out- ' numbers the troops in Gen. Custer’s i command.

See moreSee less

1 he amount of land in the Indian ierritory is sufficient to give every i Indian 2603 acres ; but if the land grabbers who are trying to get hold of it are succeasful the Indian may regard himself lucky jf he saves the three quarters of an acre after the other fellows have got the 266.

See the clipping

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A. D. Gallagher visited the Little Big Horn battlefield and found a soldier's boot containing a human foot bone, undisturbed since the 1876 massacre, which he donated to the Tribune. He also recounted witnessing a separate Sioux-Crow killing during his Montana trip.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 19 November 1886 · page 6

A Relic of the Custer Massacre. A. D. Gallagher, of this city, who is the contractor for the brick work on the court house at Dickinson, was in the city Friday. He has recently made a trip into Montana, visiting the famous Custer battle field on the Little Big Horn. While looking about there, he found a curious relic of the massacre, which he brought to the city and kindly presented to the TRIBUNE. About half a mile from the Custer monument, under a

See the clipping

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

A reporter interviews Sergeant Louis Rolt, a former Custer cavalryman now a New York policeman injured in a streetcar accident, about his memories of the 1876 Little Bighorn fight. Rolt recounts the march up the Rosebud, the Crow scouts, and the discovery of the large Sioux encampment before the battle began.

Shenandoah Herald · 19 November 1886 · page 1

A NEVER TO BE FORGOTTEN DAY

FORGOTTEN DAY. IN. Y. Mail and Express. | There Bellevoe limped out of days ago a man, Hospital a few Louis Rolt by name, the story of fifteen years the past whose life rarely would make a narrative eqaaled in exciting interest. Heis a policeman of thecity,attached tothe Fifth street station house. In 1870 he enlisted in the army and joined General Custer’s Seventh United States cavalry in Kansas. He be | | came first sergeant in Company K of that command and was with Cus. ter through all his Indian cam: | paigus, including that against the ‘Sioux led by Sitting Bull.

See moreSee less

Escap ling in many close and hot fights | with Indians it was reserved for | him to become a subject of hospital [ : treatment through chasing some ‘boys on Avenue A, where he slip

See the clipping

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

A cavalry survivor interviewed in 1886 recounts his firsthand experience of the June 1876 Little Bighorn fight, describing the march up the Rosebud, the division of Custer's command into three battalions, and Reno's and Benteen's repulses. He says Custer's fate became clear only after their own retreat across the river, with no way to send him help.

Shenandoah Herald · 19 November 1886 · page 1

FORGOTTEN DAY

| of the 25th the scouts reported hav ing discovered the Sioux in the valley of the Little Big Horn. We were then twelve to sixteen miles | } from them. General Custer called a council of war and then sounded boots and saddles and ordered us to advance at once. When we got within two miles of the Indians the command was halted and divided into three parts. General Custer took five companies, General Reno three and General Benteen three. General Reno was ordered to cross

See the clipping

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

A veteran recounts Reno's repulsed attack, Benteen's arrival, and the besieged soldiers' ordeal until Terry's relief force arrived on June 27. He describes finding Custer's and his men's mutilated bodies three miles down the river and hastily burying them.

Shenandoah Herald · 19 November 1886 · page 1

dead men and horses lay almost in company order in some places. “The bodies of General Custer and his staft we found on a kuoll of ground farthest from the river and at the highest point. Nearly every body was mutilated, cat in different ways by the Indians, and had been stripped of clothing. — General Custer’s and that ot a newspaper correspondent were the ouly ones antouched. We brought just one horse out alive. Of course we could not bury them, but we put earth over them and marked General Custer’s grave as best we could.

See moreSee less

The sight of that field of the dead was something fearful, and I can’t describe it to you. In my opinion the trouble was in di viding the force in making the at tack. Evidently General Caster had no idea of how far down he would have to go when he ordered General Reno to charge at once.” Mr. Rolt received the award of a medal of honor for bravery during the fight. In the fight at Bear "aw mountain, September, 1577, against Nez Perces, he was the only oflicer not killed or wounded, and being ordered to take charge of the com pany by Colonel Miles, did so and kept the Indians at bay. — —

See the clipping

Great Falls Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

The President will proclaim a military reservation around Fort Custer in Montana and set aside land for a national cemetery at the site of the Custer battle. The report reviews the history of Fort Custer's founding in 1877 and the dispute between the War Department and Indian Bureau over the reservation's size.

Great Falls Tribune · 20 November 1886 · page 4

-e was considered necessary to tue preservala( though not considered a strategic point, vtion of peace. It has been pretty heavily it fl garrisoned, and has at present five comf panies of infantry and three of cavalry in wI its garrison. Early in July last the war ed Ydepartment asked the Indian bureau for ta: u400 square miles for the Fort Custer resla: is ervation, but this request was considered 1)1 exhorbitant. The bureau suggested that

See the clipping

The Livingston Enterprise · Livingston, Mont.

The report describes a presidential proclamation establishing a military reservation around Fort Custer and a national cemetery at the site of the Custer battle field. It also notes Fort Custer was established in 1877, six months after the massacre, and describes its current garrison strength.

The Livingston Enterprise · 20 November 1886 · page 2

= = (J 'OoUAU square miles of land for the establish ment of a national cemetery upon the site of the Custer battle field. Fort Custer was established in 1877, six months after the massacre of Custer's command, and although not considered a strategic point, was considered nec essary to the preservation of peace. It has been pretty heavily gariisoned, and has at present five companies of infant ry and three of cavalry in its garrison. Early in July last the war department asked the Indian bureau for 400 square miles for the Fort Custer reservation, but their request was considered exor bitant.

See moreSee less

The bureau suggested that a township was sufficient and the war de partment insisted that it ought to have at least sixty-four square miles. Its de sire for so large a reservation was chiefly to reduce intemperance among the soldiers, and to place whisky sellers so far away that theelisted men would be greatly inconvenienced to get liquor. Gen. Sheridan has concluded, however, that the township granted will be suffi cient, and the secretary of the interior

See the clipping

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · Bozeman, Mont.

The President will proclaim a military reservation of one township around Fort Custer and a national cemetery of three and a half square miles on the Custer battlefield site. The report details disputes between the War Department and Indian Bureau over the land's size, and notes legal questions about taking treaty-protected Crow land without Congressional action.

The Bozeman Weekly Chronicle · 24 November 1886 · page 1

New Military Reservation. The President will soon declare by proclamation the establishment of a military reservation, containing thirty six square miles, or one township of land surrounding Fort Custer on the Big Horn river in the Crow Indian reservation, Mont. He will at the same time make declaration of the reservatton of three and one-half square miles of land for the establishment ef a national cemetery upon the site of the Custer hattlefield ( Fort Custer was established in 1877, six months after the massacre of Custer's command, and although not considered a strategic point was considered neces sary to the preservation of peace.

See moreSee less

It baa been pretty heavily garrisoned and has at present five companies of Infantry and three of cavalry in its garrison. Early in July, last the war department asked the Indian bureau for 400 square miles of land for the Fort Custer Reservation

See the clipping

The Livingston Enterprise · Livingston, Mont.

A. D. Gallagher, visiting the Little Big Horn battlefield, found a hardened leather boot remnant still containing human foot bones in a sock, apparently undisturbed since the 1876 massacre. He donated the relic to the Bismarck Tribune, which now holds two similar boots believed to be from the same pair.

The Livingston Enterprise · 27 November 1886 · page 4

A Relic of the Custer Massacre. Bismarck Tribune: A. D. Gallagher, of this city, who is the contractor for the brick work on the court house at Dickin son. has returned to the city to remain over to-morrow. He has recently made a trip into Montana, visiting the famous Custer battle-field on the Little Big Horn. While looking about the field he found a curious reiic of the massacre, which he brought to the city and has very kindly presented to the Tribune. About half a mile from the Custer monument, under a

See the clipping

New York Dispatch · New York, N.Y.

This is a theater/entertainment review describing Buffalo Bill's Wild West show, which includes a historical tableau depicting the Little Big Horn tragedy and General Custer's death as one of its performance segments. The piece also covers other theatrical offerings at Poole's Theatre, noting large audiences and upcoming productions.

New York Dispatch · 28 November 1886 · page 4

—The Mountain Village again—The Cyclone. With this there is an historical picture of frontier fort life in which is illustrated the tragedy of tho Little Big Horn and the death of General Custer.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Major North and Pawnee scouts captured Swift Bear's entire band of warriors and families without a fight, seizing horses and arms. The report notes fears that peaceable Sioux at Red Cloud agency, aware of the Custer massacre, might join the warpath.

Omaha Daily Bee · 28 November 1886 · page 10

agency between eight and nine thousand peaceable Sioux Indians , of different bands , all of whom wore being fed anil otherwise provided for by the govern ment. Heil Cloud was then the acknowl edged head chief of all these Indian ! ! , but ho had became inoioso and obstinate and had gone off with his ou n little band , Those Indians knew all about the war that was going on. Tliov had learned of the Custer massacre , and it was greatly feared that something might occur to bring the peaceable Indians out upon the warpath.

See moreSee less

Great care and precaution had to ho exorcised to prevent any thing of the kind The warriors who had been brought in with Hed Cloud were placed under guard in n strong building , and the squaws were allowed to go down on the creek , near the agency , and make a camp tor themselves. The captured her < es wore sent in charge of Major North to Fort Laramie. General McKen/.te with his command soon after marched to Fort Lara ink * , and wa followed by General Crook who came alone in an ambulance. [ TO HI : cox < : i.ri ii : > xu.vr SUNDAY. ]

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

At Madison Square Garden, the Wild West show's cowboys and Indians spent a quiet Sunday resting, playing cards, and wrestling. The report notes a new Custer Massacre scene would be rehearsed and likely performed the next day.

New-York Tribune · 29 November 1886 · page 8

A QUIET SUNDAY IN THE WII'D WEST. Everything was quict yesterday about the Madison Snare Garden, a tramp soldier or two did duty as usual on the cor ners outside, but all the doors of the big building were tightly closed, Inside the cowboys and Indians of the Wild West lounged on the benches or in the tan-barked arena. The cow boys played games with cards and indulged in athletics, wrestling and jumping, more particularly. The Indians have a summer camp in the big hall on the Madison ave, side of the Garden and spent the greater part of thelr time in the tents there. The new Custer Massacre scene will be rehearsed this morning and will probably be put oa at one of the per formaonces o-1oITOwW, >

See the clipping