As the Papers Told It

King Tut's Tomb · As the Papers Told It

Act Seven

The Curse Keeps Count

March 1927 – October 1930

The work went on, case after case of restored treasure travelling down the Nile to Cairo, and so did the list. In 1927 a paper counted six dead. In 1929 another reported, wrongly, that Carter himself had died; Carter’s former secretary Richard Bethell did die, ‘the eighth victim,’ and in 1930 his father, Lord Westbury, threw himself from a window. That spring the King and Queen of the Belgians toured the tomb with Carter and ‘defied’ the curse, and when a British Museum keeper died that autumn a paper put the toll at some thirty.

Six dead, and Egyptologists scarce

Charles B. Driscoll, in the Brownsville Herald, counts six leading tomb-hunters dead: Carnarvon first, then George J. Gould, Wolfe Joel and Sir Douglas Reid, then Professor Casanova of the College of France and, within days, Dr. Georges Benedite of the Louvre. A few more such deaths may halt the work, he writes, for Egyptologists are scarce. He suspects age, overwork, excitement and climate, but the threat of a curse is ‘still dreadful to men who love life.’

Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.

Brownsville Herald · 21 March 1927 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

CHARLES B. DRISCOLL: EGYPTIAN MYSTERY

Six of the leaders of the tomb-hunters in Egypt have died since the tomb of Tutankhamen was discovered in the Valley of the Kings. Lord Carnarvon himself, backer of the scientific expedition, was the first victim. He died of a disease which the superstitious called mysterious. The English doctors said it was merely an unfortunate infection.

See moreSee less

George J. Gould, Wolfe Joel and Sir Douglas Reid, all financially and otherwise interested in the job of taking the ancient pharaohs out of their graves, died successively. It was said that each of their maladies was mysterious. But in each case the doctors found a name for the fatal illness.

Later Professor Casanova, of the College of France, a noted Egyptologist, who had been active in the work of looting the tombs of the kings for the benefit of modern science, died suddenly and, some said, mysteriously. Then, within a few days, Dr. Georges Benedite, director of the Egyption antiques section of the Louvre Museum, died. He had been one of the foremost workers in the great undertaking that has been under way since Tutankhamen's long rest was disturbed by the professors and financiers of Europe and America.

* * * *

A few more such deaths may halt the work of digging up dead Egyptians. Learned Egyptologists are scarce, and among those who remain alive, life is held to be very dear. There is a belief (call it superstition if you will) that the ancient Egyptions, who thought that undisturbed rest for the corpses of kings was most important, may have concentrated around the tombs of their rulers some sort of mysterious forces which strike with strange maladies those who venture to take these monarchs out of their resting places and place them on show for the multitudes to stare at.

As a matter of sober fact, it is probably that advanced age, overwork, excitement, and the terrible Egyptian climate are the chief forces depleting the ranks of the learned doctors of Egyptology. But the threat of an ancient curse is still dreadful to men who love life, be they ever so learned.

See the clipping

Lady Carnarvon dies, and the curse is revived

The British Embassy in Washington goes into mourning for Lady Carnarvon, and the paper recalls the curse said to be carved over the tomb’s entrance. It also reports that Howard Carter ‘died soon after Carnarvon.’ He had not: a year later the papers were reporting his plans for the next season.

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Washington Daily News · 2 February 1929 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Tales of King Tut's Curse Is Revived as British Mourn Lady Carnarvon Embassy Here in Official Mourning for Victim of Mysterious Malady Which Has Claimed Two Who Opened Tomb

The British Embassy is in official mourning for Lady Elizabeth Carnarvon, widow of the man who first opened the tomb of King Tut-Ankh-Amen.

See moreSee less

Lady Carnarvon's death recalls the superstition that the curse of King Tut would be fatal to desecrators of his tomb and their families.

An inscription carved over its entrance warned that death would punish any one who violated its sanctity.

Lord Carnarvon died from the bite of an insect after discovering the tomb. Howard Carter, an American who was head of the Carnarvon expedition, died soon after Carnarvon, from a mysterious malady. Now Lady Carnarvon is dead, likewise mysteriously.

See the clipping

Ninety cases from Luxor to Cairo

Quoting the Daily Mail, a United Press dispatch reports that ninety cases of treasures from the tomb, the fruit of two years of restoration work, have reached Cairo from Luxor. Among them are a gold bed, a gaming board with two large boxes of games and what the paper calls the first real sickle sword.

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 96 days later.

Wrong

The Washington Daily News · 18 March 1929 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Ninety Cases of King Tut's Treasures Arrive at Cairo By United Press

LONDON—Ninety cases of treasures from the tomb of Tutankhamen, representing two years of restoration work, have arrived at Cairo from Luxor, a dispatch to the Daily Mail said.

See moreSee less

The treasures from the $20,000,000 tomb of the Pharoah who lived 3000 years ago, excavated by Howard Carter in 1925, inc[lud]ed a gold bed, the first real sicle sword ever [illegible], a ga[illegible]ing board with two large boxes of games, and other rare articles.

See the clipping

The eighth victim

When Richard Bethell, Carter’s secretary, dies at 46, an Associated Press writer in London counts the dead: Carnarvon; his half-brother Aubrey Herbert; a radiologist who was to X-ray the mummy; a Canadian professor; an Egyptologist who killed himself, writing ‘I knew there was a curse on me’; and two more who had dug in the Valley. Eight in six years.

The Daily Alaska Empire · Juneau, Alaska

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Daily Alaska Empire · 19 December 1929 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Blames Curse of Ancient Tomb for Eighth Death

By PHILIP HEWITT-MYRING (A.P. Staff Writer)

See moreSee less

LONDON, Dec. 19.—There has just died at the early age of 46 Captain the Hon. Richard Bethell, son and heir of Lord Westbury and there are those who say that he was the eighth victim of the curse of Tut-Ankh-Amen.

Six years ago the tomb of that Pharaoh was opened in Egypt by a British archaeological expedition headed by Lord Carnarvon, who had had for his chief assistant Howard Carter.

Within a year Lord Carnarvon died in Cairo from an illness which developed from a mosquito bite on the face. A month or two later Colonel Aubrey Herbert, Lord Carnarvon's half-brother who had also entered the tomb and was stated to have had a premonition of impending disaster, also died.

Howard Carter succeeded Lord Carnarvon in command of the expedition, and Mr. Bethell acted as his secretary.

In 1924 there died in Switzerland Sir Archibald Douglas Reid, a famous radiologist who had agreed to make an X-ray examination of the body of the dead king.

A little later, an eminent Canadian, Professor Laffleur of McGill University, died at Luxor while on a visit to the tomb.

H. G. Evelyn-White, scholar and Egyptologist, committed suicide towards the end of the same year and left a letter containing the words:

"I knew there was a curse on me."

Two sudden deaths connected with the tomb took place in 1926. They were those of M. Benedite, a French archaeologist attached to the Department of Antiquities at Cairo, and M. Pasanova. Both had taken part in the excavations in the Valley of the Kings.

Thus eight men of the comparatively few who took leading parts in the Drama of the Tomb, have died within the last few years.

One inscription is commonly found on various Egyptian tombs. It varies in its actual wording but its sense is this:

"Here lies the Great King. And whoso disturbs this tomb, on him may the curse of Pharaoh rest."

See the clipping

Next, the tomb of Alexander?

Planning the last season’s work at the tomb, Carter (the paper calls him Harold) speaks of looking for the tomb of Alexander the Great in the city named for him. Egyptians answer that Egypt might well make that search itself.

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 53 days earlier.

The Washington Daily News · 11 February 1930 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Search for Alexander Tomb May Be Started Next Year

CAIRO—A search for the tomb of Alexander the Great is likely to be conducted at last in his namesake city. Harold Carter, explaining his plans for the coming season's final work at the tomb of Tutankhamen, expressed interest in seeking the tomb of Alexander after his excavations at the Valley of the Kings are ended.

See moreSee less

Residents of Egypt have countered with the suggestion that Egypt might well undertake this important search, and at present the need for locating Alexander's tomb is a much discussed topic.

See the clipping

‘I cannot stand any more horrors’

A Washington editorial finds the curse revived by Lord Westbury, seventy-eight, who leapt from a high window leaving a note: ‘I cannot stand any more horrors.’ It counts at least nine deaths, twelve by one reckoning, among them, it says, a tourist who killed herself in Chicago and a mysteriously shot Egyptian prince. Carter says there is ‘no place more free of risk than a tomb.’ Westbury, it thinks, brooded himself into melancholy; he had named a daughter Nefertiti.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 27 February 1930 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

The Curse of Pharaoh.

"Death shall come on swift wings to him that toucheth the tomb of a Pharaoh." So runs the legendary warning in Egypt that was revived when six years ago Howard Carter opened the tomb of Tut-ankh-Amen in the Valley of the Kings. This sinister portent is revived by the death of Lord Westbury, seventy-eight-year-old peer of England, who, last week, plunged to his death by a leap from a high window. Lord Westbury's connection with the opening of Tut-ankh-Amen's tomb was remote. His son, Richard Bethell, who was secretary of Howard Carter during the excavation, was found dead in a London club last year in mysterious circumstances. His death brought the "curse" back to memory. Lord Westbury had evidently been brooding over the loss of his son, for he left a note which read, in part: "I cannot stand any more horrors."

See moreSee less

There have now been at least nine and by one reckoning twelve deaths fairly closely associated with the opening of the tomb. First, the Earl of Carnarvon, who financed the expedition, died, a few weeks after the tomb was opened, from the effects of the bite of a poisonous insect. Then Sir Archibald Douglass Reid, who X-rayed the mummy, passed. Col. Aubrey Herbert, Carnarvon's half-brother, who was present at the opening of the tomb, next died. Jay Gould, American millionaire, died of pneumonia after visiting the tomb. Mrs. Evelyn Greely, American tourist, killed herself in Chicago after a visit to the Valley of the Kings. Prof. Laffleur of Montreal died after inspecting the sarcophagus. H. G. Evelyn-White killed himself because he thought the curse had reached him. Prince Ali Fahmy Bey of Egypt was mysteriously shot soon after a visit to the valley. Dr. Jonathan W. Carver was killed in an automobile crash after assisting Howard Carter in his work. In addition, two French archeologists, MM. Benedite and Pasanova, both of whom had taken part in the excavations in the valley, died suddenly in 1926.

Howard Carter, who conducted the exploration, found the tomb, opened it and supervised the removal of its contents, is of all persons the one who if the curse is effective should long since have succumbed. But on the contrary he is alive and flourishing. He ridicules the superstition of the vengeance of the Pharaoh, which he says all sane people should dismiss with contempt. "There is," he declares, "no place more free of risk than a tomb."

It is altogether in the course of nature that a number of persons involved in the exploration in Egypt should have died in the course of six years, but it is somewhat significant that so many should have met violent deaths so soon after the exhumation of Tut-ankh-Amen. The psychological effect of the tradition, repeated and stressed whenever any member of the Carnarvon party passed away, has undoubtedly been malevolent. It is easy to see how Lord Westbury, who had no association with the enterprise but was interested in it because of his son's participation, might brood himself into a noxious melancholy. He had surrounded himself with souvenirs of Egyptian enterprises. He had long prior to the expedition named one of his daughters Nefertiti, after Tut-ankh-Amen's queen. Thus saturated in Egyptian lore, the "curse" marked him as a victim.

See the clipping

Belgian royalty brave the curse

King Albert and Queen Elizabeth of the Belgians visit the tomb with Carter, the Associated Press reports, and neither shows any fear of bad luck. The dispatch recalls how the superstition was revived last month by the suicide of Lord Westbury, whose son had been connected with the excavation, by the small boy killed by his hearse, and by the death of a British Museum employee.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 25 March 1930 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

BELGIAN ROYALTY VISITS LUXOR TOMB

King and Queen Defy Reputed Curse of Pharaohs, Entering Tomb of King Tut.

See moreSee less

By the Associated Press.

LUXOR, Egypt, March 25.—The King and Queen of the Belgians yesterday defied the reputed curse of the pharaohs.

With Howard Carter, excavator of the tomb of Tut-ankh-Amen, King Albert and Queen Elizabeth visited the tomb in the Valley of the Kings and neither indicated any bad luck was expected. Thereafter the King walked nearly two miles from his yacht into Karnak. He will go to Cario Wednesday.

The alleged curse of the Pharaohs is a popular superstition in England, where many persons believe that anyone who touches the tomb of an ancient Egyptian ruler will suffer a quick violent death.

The superstition was recalled last monh in the suicide of Lord Westbury, an elderly Brtish peer, whose son had been connected with the Tut-ankh-Amen excavation and himself had died the year before. As Lord Westbury's funeral was in progress, the hearse struck and killed a small boy, thus causing a renewal of the speculation. At about the same time one of the employes of the Egyptian section of the British Museum died, and that was added to the list.

See the clipping

Dr. Hall’s death revives the curse

Dr. Harry R. H. Hall, 57, keeper of Egyptian and Assyrian antiquities at the British Museum, whose charge included the Tutankhamen relics, dies in London after a short illness. The United Press says his death revives the old superstition and counts some 30 deaths since Carnarvon’s among people connected with the expedition, ‘some of them extremely remote’.

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

South Bend News-Times · 14 October 1930 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

FAMOUS EXPLORER IS DEAD IN LONDON By United Press: LONDON, Oct. 13.—Dr. Harry R. H. Hall, 57, famed archaeologist and keeper of Egyptian and Assyrian antiquities in the British museum, including the Tutankhamen relics, died Monday after a short illnes. His death revived again the old superstition about the "curse of King Tutankhamen" which was supposed to descend on those connected with the disturbing of his tomb. After the death of Lord Carnarvon, who sponsored the excavation of the tomb several years ago, some 30 deaths have occured of persons connected directly or indirectly—some of them extremely remote—with the expedition.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Six: The Boy King