Cleopatra’s mummy and a warning from Paris
From Paris, Sterling Heilig warns that it will take courage to linger over a king who was ‘priest as well as Pharaoh’. His chief case is Cleopatra’s mummy, which he says came to Paris among Napoleon’s loot and was buried under a lilac bush in the national library’s garden; an aged former guard, Aristide Duval, tells how all who touched her sickened, died or lost their reason.
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Evening Star · 18 March 1923 · page 75 · transcribed from the page image
Experience With Cleopatra's Mummy Inspires French Fears About New Find
Incidents Surrounding Napoleonic Looting and Subsequent Course of Events Cause Rumors of Strange Poisons and Malignant Influences Clinging to Some Egyptian Royalties Who Were High in Ancient Priestly Favor—Lid of Gorgeous Mummy Case Remains in Cabinet of Medals at French National Library—What Happened When Prussians Were at Gates of Paris.
See moreSee less
BY STERLING HEILIG.
PARIS, March 8.
Lord Carnarvon and Howard Carter are tranquilly emptying Tutankhamen's rock tomb of his couch of gold, his gilded chariots and all the mass of treasure so great that it is not told of—and nothing at all happens. They crowbar the sealed door to the inner sanctuary and violate the stone sarcophagus—yet nothing happens. But it will take courage in those men who know to linger over the remains of Tutankhamen, who was priest as well as Pharaoh!
It is no new story (although talked of everywhere today) that occult poisons and malignant influences were loaded into certain august mummy cases thousands of years ago and are still claimed to cling to them as a protection and revenge against violation! In particular, the thing is claimed for royalties who were high in the ancient priestly favor.
Yet the excavators will risk it—as will, in a lesser degree, the staff of the New York Museum of Art, Mr. Lythgoe of the New York Metropolitan Museum, Mr. Wemlock, head of the American excavation mission; Dr. Alan Gardiner, greatest English authority; Prof. Breasted of the University of Chicago, Capt. Engelbach, M. Lacau and a dozen other Egyptologists who can find their way close enough to the body, but it is Lord Carnarvon and Howard Carter who run the most risk, being primarily responsible for the tomb's violation.
* * * *
All these men recognize, in their hearts, what Arthur Weigall openly calls "the malevolence supposed to linger around the bones of these ancient dead!" And Weigall, kindly remember, was up to recently inspector general of antiquities under the Egyptian government!
The risk has been often taken. Some day a partial list of learned men and common porters who participated in great "finds" at the cost of paralysis, hallucinations and other strange ills (not to mention death itself) will astonish the public. But the excavating clan has sacred ardor, and is silent, secretive, pigheaded. Until high-placed confession breaks the ban of silence we shall know but isolated stories, wrung by surprise from victims and eyewitnesses, as in the great discoveries just before the war.
At that time, Cario and London were really excited over the malign emanations of Tcheser Ka Ra, high priestess of the sun. To the disturbing of her rest, they traced seven deaths and a long train of accidents, sickness and minor strokes of ill-fortune!
Physical contact seemed the chief danger from that yellow mummy—since locked in a small private room of the British museum, which few employes ever penetrate.
Not only the archaeologists who violated her tomb; but Arab laborers, innocent sailors, railway porters, expressmen, house servants and the English family which gave Tcheser Ka Ra an honored place in the hall of their manor house were poisoned, physically, mentally, morally!
Some lost their health, some money, some their lives and some their reason!
Physical contact? We naturally seek a "natural" explanation. It is known that radium activity persists through thousands of years. Could priestly masters of forgotten knowledge have charged their illustrious dead with yet more powerful, subtle substances, which even spread and seep, although, being long exposed, they weaken—as with Cleopatra's mummy, brought to Paris?
* * * *
Few know, indeed, that great Cleopatra—Egypt's last, most famous queen, the Cleopatra of Shakespeare and of history—moulders under the lilac bushes of a Paris garden! Yet such is the astonishing fact.
Octavius Caesar, in the piece by Shakespeare, said:
"She shall be buried by her Antony. No tomb upon earth shall clip in it a pair so famous"!
As a fact, for fifteen centuries, to Shakespeare's time, the two reposed in Egypt, royal mummies, redolent of nameless drugs and spices, shining with untarnished gold, were the last priestly adepts of a disappearing science laid them.
Two centuries after Shakespeare, she was still beside her Antony. Then came a greater than Octavius Caesar, a lean, sallow young French general—who laid hands on the spoil of Egypt!
Did Napoleon know that he was stealing great Cleopatra's body? Surely, he would not have touched it. But the conqueror, in those days, gathered up, pell-mell, the treasures of all Europe, for the benefit of Paris. What would today represent hundreds of millions in paintings, marbles, bronzes, tapestries, art objects and antiquities, were ruthlessly picked up wherever the imperial armies passed and freighted to the capital.
After the fall of Napoleon millions worth were returned to the governments which originally owned them, but there were strange compromises, errors and neglectful executions of an honest French decree. A renaissance frame would be kept and the painting itself sent back, or a carved Venetian bed would be returned—without its magnificent old brocade hangings!
In this way, among fifty tons of Egyptian antiquities, an obscure mummy case was returned empty, while its contents and lid remained in Paris. The case itself, splendidly decorated in the interior, makes handsome effect today. It is in the Gizeh Museum, Cairo. Empty!
Obscure mummy case and obscure mummy? Ah, no—anything but that, in light of modern knowledge. But they knew nothing at the fall of Napoleon. The Rosetta stone, part of the same loot, strayed into the hands of the English, and Champollion, French savant, was not to unlock Egyptian hieroglyphics with its aid until 1831. Nobody, even years after that date, could read the "cartouche" of Cleopatra. Yet there it was, unmistakable, for all to read when the time came.
* * * *
These astonishing facts are known so little they may seem incredible, at first glance, but there is no doubt about them among the specialists of the Louvre's Egyptian department and the French national library.
No guide book mentions Cleopatra's presence in Paris. Later, as will be seen, they were ashamed of what they did to her; and many high officials were abjectly frightened at the things which happened—when they happened. Yet if you visit the cabinet of medals, in the national library, you will still see there the lid of that gorgeous mummy case—which was returned to Egypt, empty!
Lid and mummy stayed on, in Paris, long, obscure years after the return of the empty case to Gizeh. In some neglected corner, a swath form lay beneath that lid—a royal mummy, untouched. Cleopatra slept well, perhaps on the principle of the one only British museum guard who can get on with the priestess of the sun, Tcheser Ka Ra:
"Treat her civil, and don't touch her. That's what I say. Treat her civil, and she will behave as a lady should. That's my belief, and I acts upon it."
Now, comes the part which the French authorities gloss over.
Trouble followed!
In 1871, when the Prussians were at the gates of Paris, the museums and galleries were the scenes of feverish activity.
Paintings came down from the walls, to be hidden in garrets. Those of great size were cut from their frames and rolled. Antique marbles were boxed and buried. Precious art objects were conveyed in trunks and packing cases to the private apartments of curators and simple museum guards. To the credit of French patriotism, every object was finally returned to its place, in good condition—all but Cleopatra!
At that moment of terror and confusion (repeated in 1918, just before the American masses were thrown in between Paris and the Teutonic onrush) this mummy and two others of no consequence were hurried to the same cellar where they had hidden the coin collections.
Through a bad winter and early thaw, the Seine waters rose to this cellar—and nobody paid attention. All its hidden treasures soaked without harm—all except these Egyptian mummies!
Alas! When taken up to daylight, Cleopatra had finally met the fate of common mortals! She who had slept in gold and spices for 1,800 years was now become an object of greater repulsion than a mummy ought to be.
The coins went back to the national library. The mummies, being in the party, accompanied them; but the library officials held their noses and declared that the queen, in particular, had lost all quality to figure among the treasures of a medal cabinet!
* * * *
It was then or never that Cleopatra, fully recognized but still kept secret, should have been returned with honors to Egypt. But the Prussians were at St. Denis (as the French are in the Ruhr today) and the French republic was barely established.
Newspapers were full of other matters. It was really nobody's business; and the learned men and officials who knew that it was Cleopatra felt no need to call attention to her bad condition.
Also it was doubtful if she could stand a sea voyage in any case.
So they buried her in haste, with nothing but a lilac bush to mark the spot.
And phenomena began to happen.
If you pass down the Rue Vivienne, in Paris, glance through the grilled gateway of the library's high wall.
There you will see the little garden where they planted Egypt's queen like a dead poodle.
Learned men who read all the afternoon in the library shudder, tremble and fairly run at twilight as they pass the little garden to the streets.
They feel their souls attacked. One dry student of middle age economics feels an interior urge to "flee to Egypt." Another sat, rapt and vacant, on a garden bench, until removed by a policeman. Oftenest, they dash off in panic fright and get knocked down by taxi cabs.
Neighbors tell of "dust-whirls" in the garden. The proprietor of an adjoining hat store has seen them light up with a pale rose phosphorescence.
Minor phenomena, all these. They have been weakening through the years. None in authority at the national library dates from 1871. None feels responsibility. None fears the "feeling." But it was different in 1872:
* * * *
Today, one sole survivor, aged man of Meudon, trembles at the name of Cleopatra.
He is Aristide Duval, left, in his own opinion, as "a horrible example and a warning." Already, in 1872, he was the sole survivor of four museum guards who bore Cleopatra from the Seine-soaked cellar to the little garden of the lilacs.
"She caused sickness, death, loss of property, friends and reason to all who touched her on the day she was buried," says Aristide Duval. "Monsieur Hervet, the curator, died of a lingering fever two months later. He had touched the body. Also Monsieur Boislutin, his adjoint of the coin cabinet, who preceded him, by apoplexy.
"Equally, Monsieur Fauno, assistant librarian, lost all his family fortune in one month of speculation on the bourse, and died demented and forsaken. One other learned man, whose name I shall not tell, fell by a footpad's knife at midnight, outside the Mabille gardens."
The aged, broken man lowers his voice.
"We were only four poor guards, obeying orders. Yet she struck us! When Lavigne committed suicide I resigned, because we were all panic-stricken after Monsieur Hervet and his adjoint. I retired to Meudon and got off with what the doctors called malignant typhoid, but it wasn't. My hair fell out. I lost my teeth, sores came to me and my left leg was paralyzed. As you see, I drag it.
"With these ills she let me linger as example! Brunin and Tremglay, the two other guards, well, I'll not talk of them. They went wrong in their heads and died, with blood—. Of course, the Queen of Egypt felt the ignominy of our touch. She did not want to moulder in the earth. But it was ill to touch her, in the first place."