As the Papers Told It

Jesse James · As the Papers Told It

Act Seven

Frank James Surrenders

May – November 1882

After the killing, the papers followed the money made from it. Bob Ford lectured in western Missouri, and the Fords were shown at a museum on Broadway; splinters from the floor of the St. Joseph house sold at 55 cents each, and an embalming firm offered Mrs. Samuels $10,000 for the body. That autumn Frank James walked into the governor’s office, unbuckled his belt and handed over his arms, delivering himself, he said, to the governor and the law; a Kentucky report said he would answer all the charges against him in the courts.

Ten thousand dollars for the body

Weeks after Jesse James was buried in the yard of the old homestead near Kearney, an Idaho paper passes on word that a Cincinnati embalming firm has offered his mother, Mrs. Samuels, $10,000 for the body, with a share of exhibition proceeds the firm puts at $100,000. The paper’s advice: ‘Better take it.’ An April report thought Bob Ford had probably arranged with Governor Crittenden to produce the corpse for the same sum.

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory

Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 2 May 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A Cincinnati body-embalmer firm offers Mrs. Samuels $10,000 for the body of her son, the outlaw, Jesse James, with a share in the proceeds of the exhibition, which they estimate at $100,000. Better take it.

See the clipping

Bob Ford lectures on the killing

A Texas paper reprints the Dallas Herald on a Kansas City report that Bob Ford is lecturing in western Missouri on the killing. In April the Ford brothers had pleaded guilty to murder, been sentenced to hang on 19 May, and been pardoned by Governor Crittenden. The Herald marvels at how profitable murder has become, and says the same listeners would be as keen to see Ford hanged: ‘a mere morbid sentiment of curiosity.’

Brenham Weekly Banner · Brenham, Tex.

Brenham Weekly Banner · 25 May 1882 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE DALLAS HERALD SAYS: As will be seen from our special from Kansas City this morning, Bob Ford, the murderer of Jesse James is lecturing in western Msisouri: It is antonishing to see how profitable murder is in these degenerate days, and how mercurial the populace. The same people who are listening with curiosity to Ford's description of the homicide would be equally keen to see him if he were being hung. The country is full of a mere morbid sentiment of curiosity.

See the clipping

Talk of a pardon for Frank James

A St. Louis dispatch of 29 May relays the Post-Dispatch's story that Governor Crittenden has been negotiating with Frank James for ten days and will pardon him within a week; the hold-up is his friends' demand for pardons from Minnesota and Texas too. Frank did surrender in October, but promised to answer the charges in court, and said he had not been in Missouri for over a year; this report puts him in St. Louis in May.

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Butler Weekly Times · 7 June 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

WILL SURRENDER.

Negotiations Pending Regarding the Surrender of Frank James.

See moreSee less

St. Louis, Mo., May 29.—The Post-Dispatch will publish a statement this afternoon showing that Gov. Crittenden has been negotiating with Frank James for the past ten days for his surrender and that the noted outlaw will be

PARDONED WITHIN A WEEK.

Sheriff Timberlake and Police Commissioner Craig, of Kansas City, and an attorney representing the Jameses, accompanied by Frank James and three of his friends were in St. Louis Friday and Saturday last.

It is stated that Frank James

HAS NOMINALLY SURRENDERED

to Sheriff Timberlake under a flag of truce, and that Gov. Crittenden has promised a full and unconditional pardon to the famous outlaw.

Sheriff Timberlake was registered here at the hotel under an assumed name, but was recognized by a Post-Dispatch reporter, and both he, Police Commissioner Craig and the attorney admitted that

NEGOTIATIONS WERE PENDING

for Frank James' pardon. They were in St. Louis for the express purpose of meeting Gov. Crittenden on his return from New York, but the latter passed right through to Jefferson City. They further stated that the delay in negotiations is

OCCASIONED BY FRIENDS

of Frank James insisting that full pardons should also be secured from the governors of Minnesota and Texas, where the outlaw is under the ban of the law, and steps are now being taken to that end.

THESE PARDONS

are necessary for tear Crittenden's successor might deliver up Frank James on requisitions from either of said states. There is scarcely a doubt that the negotiations will be successfully consummated.

See the clipping

Mrs. James's lectures draw little

A Texas editorial note reports that the lecturing tour of Mrs. Jesse James ‘does not seem to be a success’: one night in St. Louis took in only ten dollars. In April the widow had told a Kansas City reporter that only a few hundred dollars were left to her, and that what she knew of Jesse would never be made public.

Brenham Weekly Banner · Brenham, Tex.

Brenham Weekly Banner · 22 June 1882 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

EDITORIAL NOTES

The lecturing tour of Mrs. Jesse James does not seem to be a success. The receipts for one night in St. Louis were only ten dollars.

See the clipping

Backstage with the Ford brothers in Chicago

A Montana paper reprints a Chicago Times interview with Bob and Charley Ford, found backstage at a State street variety theatre. Bob, a ‘slim, smooth-faced boy of 20’, says Jesse was standing on a chair and turned his head at the click of the pistol, and that Governor Crittenden kept his promise: ‘What I did was done by his directions’. An April dispatch had reported that the governor knew of the Fords' plan and approved it.

The River Press · Fort Benton, Mont.

The River Press · 23 August 1882 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE FORD BOYS. A Times Reporter Interviews Them at Chicago.

"Want to see the Ford boys? Why, of course; just follow me." And the Times reporter picked his way along a narrow passage and stood behind the scenes of a State street variety theatre.

See moreSee less

Bob, whose pistol-shot rang through the United States a few months ago, has been described before, and by the descriptions recently telegraphed to the papers; no one would fail to recognize him. A slim, smooth-faced boy of 20, with short, dark hair, gray eyes and regular features, he hardly realizes in his appearance the beau ideal of the dime-novel reader. Quiet and reserved in his manner, he impresses one favorably, but it was the very

SARCASM OF FATE

permitted a lad like that to send a bullet through the brain of Missouri's outlaw.

"You felt pretty nervous when you got the drop on Jesse?"

"Well, I couldn't miss him. He was standing on a chair almost as close to me as I am to you. He turned his head when my pistol clicked, and the bullet struck him just behind the ear and came out over the eye. He fell stone dead. There wasn't much fuss after that. When Mrs. James ran in and took his head in her lap she accused me of killing him, but I never answered her. Charlie and I picked up our hats and walked out of the house."

"What have you been doing since?"

"Scarcely anything. We went out to visit our folks near Richmond, in Ray county, for a few weeks, but most of the time we spent at a boarding house in Kansas City. No, I was never afraid that the gang would try to get even with me. You see, Frank James would not attempt

TO KILL ME

in a crowded city, for he would stand no show of escaping. If he ever does try that dodge he will do it when I am visiting the old folks in the country."

"It is said that he is very feeble and broken down."

"Well, when I saw him a few months ago he was healthy enough. But one thing is certain and that is that Governor Crittenden has fixed the gang for good, and Frank will never try to reorganize it. Crittenden has done more than any other man ever did for the State of Missouri, no matter what his enemies say about him."

"He stood by you pretty well."

"Yes, he kept his promise. What I did was done by his directions, and I think I had as much right to do it as if I was one of Pinkerton's detectives."

"What sort of a man was Jesse James in private life?"

"A very good man, I should say. He was devoted to his wife, and always pleasant and agreeable about the house. You would rather like him at first, but you would change your opinion when you began to see into his real character. Treacherous? Well, I should say so. Why, he shot one of his own gang, when the poor devil was fast asleep. If my hand had trembled there would have been a lively time in that sitting-room."

"Jesse would have made a corpse of me in about two seconds," said Charley, who had been a quiet listener to the conversation.

"You ought to call on Allan Pinkerton," suggested the reporter; "he ought to feel somewhat indebted to you."

"Yes," said Bob, musingly. "Jesse was pretty anxious to get even with the Pinkertons. If he had ever got a chance he would have made short work of the old man, or of Billy either, for that matter. By the way, I wonder if Pinkerton has many men as brave as the one he sent to capture Jesse. Why, that detective expected to take Frank and Jesse alive. He located their house and walked in and asked for a job as a farm-hand. They suspected him, and before he knew they had him covered with their revolvers. Then they searched him, found his weapons and the game was up. They

TIED HIM HAND-AND-FOOT, threw him over a horse, and took him with them across the Missouri river into the next county. Then they put three bullets into him, and left him by the roadside. His name was Wicher, I think, but he was a brave fellow. The people up that way must have thought that one man could handle a gun as well as another. They were mistaken though, and it took them a long time to find out how desperate the James boys were."

"You are a practiced shot yourself," remarked the visitor, timidly.

"Yes, said Bob, in an off-hand abstracted manner, and he took out his long 45-caliber weapon, and whirled it round in a beautifully familiar way, and in dangerous proximity to the reporter.

"Is it loaded?" inquired the latter.

"Well, I wouldn't have much use for it if it wasn't." He cocked it, twisted it round in the air, and the hilt dropped in his palm. The visitor moved nervously to one side, just in time to come within range of Charley's two revolvers, one of which was describing circles in the air, while he was trying how many times he could cock the other within the space of a second. Even curiosity, however, has some limit under certain circumstances, and the visitor

GENEROUSLY HINTED

that the boys should relax their hospitable efforts to amuse him."

"We are going to stay here a week," said Bob, "and will then go to Cincinnati. I understand that some people don't believe we are the Ford boys. If these papers are not evidence enough," he said, producing a bundle of letters and telegrams, "I refer you to Detective Thorp, of the Central station. He saw us in Kansas City, shortly after the shooting, and we had a visit from him to-day."

See the clipping

The Fords on show in New York

By late September the Ford brothers are on show at Bunnell's Broadway museum in New York, on a two-weeks engagement as ‘mild-mannered murderers’. A showman at the door tells the story of the killing; inside, among the museum's monstrosities, visitors find two slender young men with downy faces and go away thinking it all humbug. The Missouri paper ends: ‘But it is a big thing for Bunnell.’

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

The Butler Weekly Times · 27 September 1882 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

The Ford brothers—Charles and Robert—are making a show of themselves for money at Bunnell's Broadway museum, New York. They are playing a two-weeks engagement as "mild-mannered murderers." They attract crowds, and mingle with the spectators, and the papers say it is hard to tell which are the murderers and which the peaceable people satisfying curiosity in a museum. The eloquent showman stands at the door giving a blood-curdling history of the taking-off of Jesse James and other daring and death-dealing doings of the Ford brothers, who are on exhibition among the monstrosities within.

See moreSee less

The people buy tickets and walk in, and are immeasurably disappointed when they look upon the young, downy faces and slender forms of the Fords. They cannot reconcile the quiet and retiring presence of the youths with the showman's story, and go away believing that the Ford brothers business is all humbug. But it is a big thing for Bunnell.

See the clipping

Frank James gives himself up

A short Kentucky report: Frank James has surrendered to the governor of Missouri. He gives as his reasons his wife and children and a wish to lead an honest life, and he will answer all the charges against him in the courts. The pardon said on 29 May to be a week away is not mentioned; the surrender comes four months after those first reports of a deal.

Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

Evening Bulletin · 7 October 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

FRANK JAMES, the notorious Missouri outlaw, and brother of Jesse 'James, has surrendered to the governor of that state. He says he is prompted to this act by considerations for his wife and children, and a desire to lead hereafter, an honest life. He will appear before the courts and answer all of the charges against him.

See the clipping

Frank hands his arms to the governor

In the Louisville Post, Frank says he lived near Nashville from 1877 as B. J. Woodson, and calls George Shepherd’s 1879 claim to have killed Jesse ‘a great hoax’: Jesse was in Nashville at the time. The St. Louis Globe-Democrat then describes the surrender in the governor’s office: Frank unbuckles his belt, hands over arms he says have not left his possession since 1864, and delivers himself ‘to you and the law.’

Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

Evening Bulletin · 11 October 1882 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

FRANK'S STORY. His Residence in Nashville and in Louisville, and his fun With Bligh.

FULL ACCOUNT OF HIS SURRENDER.

See moreSee less

Louisville Post.

Frank James, in telling his own story, claimed first that he meant to reform and become a law-abiding resident of Missouri. He said that for twenty-one years he had been outlawed and hunted from state to state like a wild animal, He had learned to suspect his dearest friends, and day and night it was a constant watch with him. In August, 1877, he went to Nashville with his wife in the character of an emigrant. He went under the name of B. J. Woodson. He soon effected the rental of a piece of land from Josiah Walton, on White creek, a few miles from Nashville. For a year he worked ten hours a day on this farm. Then he engaged to a team for a year for the Indiana Lumber Company, on Jeff Hyde's place, driving a four-mule team and taking his meals in the woods with darkies. His boss was T. J. Jefferson, of Ohio, and Frank, like his boss, was a Republican. At the end of this year he rented a farm from Felix Smith, on White

Creek, eight miles from Nashville. He remained there till April, 1881. Among his intimate friends there were Charles

Eastman, county clerk; J. W. Shute, member of the legislature; Dr. Jordan, Dr.

Manlove, Dr. Wm. Hamilton, Sheriff Tim

Johnson, Rev. D. Wall, Clint Cantwell,

Wm. Bryan, Jr., and others. He said these men would be greatly amazed to hear now that he was Frank James in disguise.

The only trouble he ever had there was with a man who took him for a Yankee.

It ended in a friendship between the two. He was intimate with detectives

Fletch, Horn and Watson, of Nashville, who little dreamed who he was. He accidentally met his brother Jesse in Nashville.

He found that Jesse was living near Waverly, Humphreys county, West Tennessee. Jesse was farming and much interested in horses. A year and a half after Jesse moved to North Nashville. Jesse owned the horse Jim Malone at the time. In the fall of 1880, Dick Liddel and Jim Cummings found the James boys in Nashville. Frank does know where either is now. One day Jim ran away, and fearing he was going to give them up they got under arms. It turned out that Jim got frightened by his surroundings and simply ran away for better security. Just as the boys had got settled once more Jack Ryan was arrested in the neighborhood and taken to Missouri. This broke up the homes ot the brothers and they once more became wanderers. He claimed that during their residence near Nashville no one knew their identity.

FRANK IN LOUISVILLE. We reproduce Frank's very comical ac count of his experiences in Louisville, and his experience with one of our detectives. He says:

"Do you remember the sensation of a little over a year ago when Captain Bligh, of Louisville, endeavored to trap you near Bloomfield, Ky., by a decoy pay train?"

"Yes, I read the Republican's article on that, it being copied in Courier-Journal. I laughed a good deal over it, especially over the pay train scheme. The article, if I remember right, was not published until about three months after the attempt was made, I can't determine just where I was on the date of Bligh's ingenious enterprise. It is not improbable I was in Louisville, however, as I certainly was not down in the woods hunting for a pay train. You might remark in this immediate connection that if Captain Bligh will go to Rufer's Hotel and examine the register between the dates of the 10th and the 15th of last October he will find that Fred. Thorn, of Virginia, stayed there over night. I was in the city a week that time, but arrived there late at night, and not caring to wake up my friends I put up at

Rufer's till morning. To tell you the truth I never entertained any fear of capture by the detectives. Now I knew that George Hunter was working all the time to get a chance to bag us, and when that negro was killed in the woods down there, and Hunter and Larry Hagen made that midnight raid on a hut in the hope of capturing some of us, I was not surprised. I felt certain that the killing of the negro would be charged to us, although I was the only man in that section, so far as I know, and I was not within a hundred miles of the place. Being aware that Hunter was on the qui vive I felt confident that some place or other would be raided soon, just for the chances of finding somebody. It is a practice of mine, when I am being hunted for, to sit down and figure what course the detectives will take in their search, and then I take the other one. I have never to my knowledge misjudged them in my guesses. No, the only danger we had to apprehend was from give-aways or traitors in our households."

"By the way, what was the true story about George Shepherd's pretended killing of Jesse some years ago?" "I am sure I

DON'T KNOW THE DETAILS.

All I know is that it was a great hoax. Jesse was down at Nashville at the time and my wife read him a telegraphic account of it from the newspapers the morn after it occurred. We laughed a good deal over it, but never learned what it all meant. George Shepherd, by the way, is entitled to distinction as being the only outlaw Detective Bligh ever caught. George, you know, has only one eye, and Bligh came in on his blind side and nabbed him,"

The prisoner in further conversation said that in no case did the publications place the locality of the boys correctly. While in Denison, Texas, once he was put down for a train robbery in Muncie, Ks. He said they never spent their time in lonesome, retired places, but mostly in cities. They never wore disguises and traveled mostly by rail. He carried usually two large Remingtons and a Winchester rifle. He said he was a good shot with pistol or rifle. He finally declared himself to be without means, and if allowed desired to go to farming. He has a wife and little son.

THE SURRENDER.

The story of the surrender is thus graphically told by the St. Louis Globe-Democrat:

"It having become known throughout the capitol building shortly before 5 o'clock that Frank James would at that hour put in an appearance and surrender himself, the heads of the departments and their clerks, with others who were in and about the building, assembled in the executive office to await the arrival of the noted outlaw. Among those present beside the governor were Judge Henry, of the Supreme Court; Phil. E. Chappell, State treasurer; John Walker, State auditor; Adjutant Gen. Waddell, Major T. O. Towles and others, besides the representatives of the press.

The hands of the clock on the south wall of the office were close upon the hour of 5 when the expectant ears of those present heard the sound of footsteps entering the rotunda of the building. A moment later the well-known form of Major John W. Edwards appeared in the open doorway. As he advanced into the room he was followed by a man nearly six feet in height, of slender, neat and trim build, who walked erect, and with a quiet, easy and self-possessed gait, to the middle of the room. Stopping in front of the governor, Major Edwards said:

"Governor and gentlemen, this is Frank James. He is here to give himself up." This brief introduction brought face to face the executive of Missouri and the noted outlaw, whose name has been a terror in this state and is familiar throughout our land, if not the whole world. It was a scene without a precedent in the annals, of the state, and to all present was intensely interesting and dramatic. To all appearances Frank James was the coolest and least moved man in the room. While Major Edwards was introducing him his countenance was as quiet and calm in its expression as if the business in hand were no concern of his. He advanced a step toward the governor, and by a dexterous movement unbuckled a belt from around his lithe body and, holding it toward the governor, said:

"Governor, I am Frank James. I surrender my arms to you. I have removed the loads from them; they are not loaded. They have not been out of my possession since 1864. No other man has ever used them since then. I now give them to you personally. I deliver myself to you and the law."

Governor Crittenden received the proffered belt, pistol and cartridges, and with characteristic courtesy requested Frank James to be seated, saying that he was very glad to meet him, particularly in this manner.

Frank James answered that he had come in and surrendered himself because he desired to do as he had done for years—that is, live the life of a law-abiding citizen. He hoped to be able to prove that he was not so bad as he had been painted. Although he had been living the life of a quiet, orderly and law-abiding citizen for four years he well knew that everything criminal that had been committed of late years had been credited to him. To the governor he said, with more earnestness in his tone than he had hitherto shown. "If some one were to assassinate you, although I might be able to prove myself entirely innocent, I would not be able to conv'nce people that I was guiltless of the crime. They have been in the habit of attributing all manner of crimes to me, and are ready to believe anything they hear."

Reference being made to the time he had been to the State, Frank James said he had not been in Missouri for over a year previous to the Sunday, September 24, when he reached St. Louis.

Governor Crittenden said: "I have received over half a bushel of letters from you, or from those professing to be you. I have received them from not only three or four different men on the same day, but from several different States."

"Yes," answered the outlaw; "this proves that any crime, no matter by whom committed, is likely to be laid to me. I

have surrendered because I wished this to end, and to prove, as I can that for four years I have been a law-abiding citizen, and that I have been painted blacker than

I am. I do it for my wife and child's sake.

I am in your hands, to do with me as you see best."

Indeed, no one would take the quiet calm man, with, the wide, open and frank looking eyes, for the outlaw who had held sway over Missouri for so long. His clear complexion indicated habits of temperance and there was not an ounce of superfluous flesh upon his frame. He showed himself to be a man who could patiently undergo great hardship, while his eyes, though in no wise, restless, saw and closely observed everything about him. They may or may not have noticed a pile of papers near the wall, back of the door through which he had entered. Those were the remaining copies, printed posters, of the famous proclamation issued by the governor last year, offering rewards for the capture and conviction of Frank and Jesse James. His letter above published, which Governor Crittenden had taken from the safe and given your correspondent to copy but a few moments before Major Edwards and himself arrived, was handed about among those present and read with interest. It was not long before the news of Frank James surrender spread to every part of the city. It created more excitement than anything that has taken place here for many years, and a stream of curious people set toward the McCarty House, where, until nearly 11 o'clock, the great surrendered held a levee. Even from the "Kingdom of Calaway" there came a delegation, all solid for Frank James, and considering it an honor to be allowed to take him by the hand.

See the clipping

Splinters of the floor where Jesse fell

Seven months after the shooting, splinters from the floor where Jesse James fell are sold at the St. Joseph house for 55 cents each. A Minnesota paper adds that, according to ‘the keeper of the sacred place’, Jay Gould paid a dollar for a piece he cut out himself, meaning to have it made into a watch charm.

New Ulm Weekly Review · New Ulm, Minn.

New Ulm Weekly Review · 1 November 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Splinters from the floor whereon Jesse James fell when he was shot, are sold on the premises for 55 cents each. Mr. Jay Gould, according to the keeper of the sacred place, paid a dollar for a piece which he cut out himself, and which proposed to have made into a watch charm. Where's Mr. Vanderbilt?

See the clipping

Bob Ford cleared in the Hite case

Bob Ford, tried in Ray county for the killing of Wood Hite, is acquitted after the jury is out a few hours. The set says little more of Hite: an April dispatch put the Fords' home near Richmond, in Ray county, not far from the farmhouse where, it said, Dick Little killed Wood Hite in a bedroom fight the January before. The clippings do not settle who killed him.

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

The Butler Weekly Times · 1 November 1882 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Robert Ford, the slayer of Jesse James, who has been on trial in Ray county for the killing of Wood Hite, was acquitted by the jury after being out a few hours.

See the clipping

Chicago boys under ten take his name

Chicago police have found a band of twenty boys, all under 10, who call themselves ‘The Young Jesse James Gang.’ Most come from good families, the Salt Lake paper says, but all are skilled thieves, and the penalty for informing on one another was to have the right thumb nail torn out. In March a Cheyenne paper had warned that making a hero of an outlaw leads boys to become desperadoes.

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The Salt Lake Herald · 26 November 1882 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

THE CHICAGO police have discovered an organization of twenty boys, all under 10 years of age, who style themselves "The Young Jesse James Gang." Most of the lads are of excellent parentage, but all are proficient thieves and criminals. The penalty prescribed for squealing on each other was to have the right thumb nail torn out.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Six: Jesse James Assassinated