As the Papers Told It

Jesse James · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

Death of an Outlaw

February 1875 – August 1876

In January 1875 men believed to be detectives raided the Samuels farm, the home of the brothers’ mother, at night. A bomb thrown into the house killed a boy and maimed Mrs. Samuels, who said her sons were not there. In September 1875 Jesse was reported killed at Pine Hill, Kentucky, after a bank robbery at Huntington, but the dead robber was Thompson McDaniels. In August 1876 Hobbs Kerry, a captured train robber promised clemency, named the James brothers among his partners.

The night raid on the Samuels farm

A Jefferson City paper gathers the Kansas City reports: men supposed to be detectives came by special train to the Samuels house near Kearney, and an ‘infernal machine’ thrown into the kitchen killed a boy and badly wounded Mrs. Samuels. Men at Brookfield boasted they had captured one of the James boys. She said her sons were not there; The Sun said in 1881 that they were, in 1882 that they were not.

Paper unidentified

Paper unidentified · 5 February 1875 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SOME KNOWN FACTS.

THE JAMES BOYS

The Latest and Most Authentic Report of their Attempted Capture.

See moreSee less

The Detectives Have Vanished Mysteriously.

The Real Results of the Raid as Yet Unknown.

Were the James Boys Captured?

The all-absorbing question in newspaper circles is the recent mysterious, night attack, by a party of known men, on the home of the James is Clay county last Monday night, or Tuesday morning We glean from Kansas City Journal and Times all there is now bearing upon the affair which has not heretofore appeared in the columns of the JOURNAL. The Kansas City Journal says:

Of one thing there is no doubt, and that is, that a party of men did visit the house of the James boys' mother, Sunday night and that a desperate fight ensued, and that somebody engaged in the fight was hurt, as the spots of blood found about the premises fully showed.

SAD INDICATIONS

of the visit are also found in the death of a lad, the step-brother of the outlaws, and the serious wounding of the mother by the explosion of an infernal machine, which was thrown into the kitchen by parties from the outside. While we certainly deprecate the act by whomsoever committed of using means which endanger the lives of innocent parties, especially women and children, and feel a sympathy for the parties injured by the explosion of this infernal arnangement, we have charity enough to believe that no such result was calculated.

WHO THEY WERE.

There has yet been no satisfactory explanation of the character of the men composing the party which made this raid yet the supposition, based upon the character of the James boys, leaves no doubt but that they were detectives, and that they paid with the intention of killing and being killed. The reticence of the railroad officials as well as the vague answers to questions given by the members of the Samuels family, leave the

MATTER SHROUDED IN MYSTERY,

It is a well known fact that since the death of Wicher, the detective, who is supposed to have been murdered by the James boys some months ago, that parties have been working secretly to capture them.

THE RECKLESS DARING

of the boys has made the undertaking one of a hazardous nature, and served to hold in check those who wished to achieve fame in that direction, and the struggle which occurred Sunday night certainly seemed to show the would-be captors that they had met foemen worthy of their steel.

At present, we are unable to give anything authentic as to the success attending the efforts of the detectives. They came, we learn with requisitions in their pockets from Iowa, and armed with United Stats warrants, and, as they passed east Monday, we presume they are either in Chicago, or, somewhere in Iowa, with whatever and whomsoever they may have captured, and until their story is told, we presume the tacts will not be made known.

To return

TO THE THEORY OF RESULT

of the battle raging outside, we are left to the field of conjecture solely. If the boys made their escape, it must have been that they succeeded in getting their horses from the stable. In proof of this, the plain marks of horses feet as if ridden at great speed, coming from the barn toward the East gate in the pasture lot and suddenly turning, approached the bars and were not traceable further. Taking into account the character of the boys as

DARING RIDERS.

It is easy to believe they might, if once mounted, easily leap this very ordinary fence, and following a farm road passing South along the West line of the yard fence, succeed in reaching the timbered pasture lot and eventually the Kearney road.

The line of retreat of the detectives is plainly visible across the wheatfield West of the barn, the long paces and deep indentations showing that the return march was rapid until they had traveled some distance.

DROPS OF BLOOD

near the stable, and on this trail would indicate that some one was hurt of this party. Blood in the pasture lot South of the house leads to the same conclusion as to some one there.

Immediately after the accident to Mrs. Samuels and the lad, medical assistance was summoned. Drs. Yates and Scruggs, of Kearney, went at once, arriving at the house about half an hour before the boy breathed his last, which was at half past four a. m About half past five the horse ridden by Dr. Scruggs was taken away by some one, and has not since been heard of, thus adding another link to the theory of the boys' escape. Thus we have theories on theories, all of them weak at some points. We have also

SOME KNOWN FACTS.

That the mail train let off some parties East of Kearney.

That a special from Kansas City took four men, and gathered up others at Liberty, delivered them near the same point where the first party got off the train.

That an attack was made on the house of Mr. Samuels, the step-father of the James boys; that the wounding of Mrs. Samuels and the killing of the boy resulted; that the house was fired; that the attacking party retired hastily, and were taken up by the special train; that no one can really say if their party was augmented or lessened when they reached the railroad again.

As to the further results of their venture, no one except the actors in the tragedy can truly tell.

To oppose the theory of capture, Mrs. Samuels states that the James boys were not at her house that hight, and that she had not seen them since May last; further, they

NEVER GO AFOOT.

If captured, their horses must have been left somewhere, but only one animal, viz: Jesse's sorrel mare could be found in the morning on the Samuels farm. No strays have been found in the vicinity—the detectives could not carry captives forcibly at the rapid pace traveled

WERE THE JAMES BOYS CAPTURED?

That is the all-absorbing question. One side of the story has been given. A mother who is probably on her death-bed at this moment has stated firmly that Jesse and Frank were not at home. The statement is the property of the reader. It is not the province of the news-gatherer on such occasions to give opinions of his own where there is doubt. The one side having been given, let the other be as impartially considered.

On the night of the 26th an engne and caboose left this city, going in the direction of Kearney. Of this there is no longer any doubt It contained seven or eight unknown men.—Persons in Kearney know this "train" passed that station. That night a fight occurred at the

HOUSE OF THE JAMES BOYS.

Sombody, as has been stated previously, was hurt. Of this there is no doubt; this is corroborated by nearly all who have examined the premises. Did the attacking parties know that their booty was on the ground—if they were not positive, why the determined efforts to cut off all possible escape? If they had been intent only upon destruction, why the battle that certainly ensued? Again, a gentleman who is reliable states that the

WIFE OF JESSE JAMES

was in that vicinity not a week ago. This same gentleman gives another important link. He was in Cameron the next day after the affray. He was told by parties whom he knows to be reliable that the caboose and engine referred to stopped at Brookfield, on the Hannibal & St. Joe line, the morning after the affair, and eight men got out and breakfasted. They told parties at Brookfield the exact report of what occurred at the house of Mr. Samuel just as it has been given in these columns. They said they were the parties who did it; that they had

CAPTURED ONE OF THE JAMES BOYS, and had him in the caboose, and that the other was thought to be one of the Younger boys. A third had escaped. How came these men to tell the story so correctly so soon after the occurrences unless they had been witnesses to it? There is another theory: About a year ago one of Pinkerton's detectives went to Liberty and conversed with the Sheriff about capturing the James boys. A few days afterward he was found below this city, dead, with a rope around his neck, and a

BULLET-HOLE IN HIS HEAD.

Last spring three men on this side of the river, at some station, name now forgotten, went to the river and called the ferryman over to this side. They got into his boat and had a fourth man tied who was silent. The next day the three returned; the day following a man was found dead not far from the landing. It is said he was one of Pinkerton's detectives. Not long ago another of Pinkerton's men went to St. Clair county and asked the deputy Sheriff to assist him in capturing the Younger boys. They started out and stopped at a house where the Younger's were. Going on they were overtaken by three men, the Youngers, who halted them. The detective drew a derringer and shot one of the Youngers, killing him.

THE OTHER TWO

fired in return, killing the deputy sheriff and wounding the detective, who died soon after.—Has Pinkerton undertaken to avenge the death of these men by an attempt to destroy the family of Mr. Samuel? The reader can form his own conclusions. The link is given as it happens to arise amid a multiplicity of surmises.

When the reporter left Kearney he was informed that a posse of twenty men had been summoned by the sheriff for service last night. That it was surmised that one of the James boys was wounded on the 26th and was concealed in the vicinity of his home, and an attempt would be made to find him.

In the mean time mystery still abounds, and the case is left for further developements.

See the clipping

Dinner with a rifle across his lap

From the Kansas City News: a few days before the Kearney raid, Jesse James rode up to a house near the city and asked a man he knew for dinner. He opened the back door to find a way of retreat and ate with a Henry rifle across his lap; when he took off his greatcoat, five Remington revolvers showed. The paper counts ‘forty-six missiles of death’.

Martinsburg Weekly Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

Martinsburg Weekly Independent · 27 February 1875 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

JESSIE JAMES.

How He Dined with Forty-six Missiles of Death About His Person.

See moreSee less

[From the Kansas City News, 5th.]

At this time anything connected with the James boys is of interest to the people of this section especially, and we give the following account of how Jesse James appeared at a house not many miles from this city about the 18th of last month, only a few days prior to the affair near Kearney. He rode up in front of the house about noon, and asked the proprietor, whom he knew, if he could get dinner.

Being replied to in the affirmative, he asked if there were any dangerous people around, and, the answer being satisfactory, he looked carefully in all directions and then dismounted. He entered the house, and, walking to a back door, opened it and looked around, quietly remarking that he wanted to know a way to retreat if it became necessary. He carried a fine Henry rifle with him, and after removing his great coat, the butts of five large six shooting Remington revolvers were disclosed, showing that, with the rifle, he had forty-six missiles of death ready for any one coming to interfere with his liberty.

When his dinner was announced he again look out at the doors, and then seating himself at the table, with the rifle across his lap, dispatched his meal with a hearty relish and in the most unconcerned manner possible, save with an occasional glance through the windows, keeping up, meanwhile, a pleasant conversation with his host. What two or three or four men would have relished the task of appearing in the doorway and interrupting that outlaw's dinner with a demand to surrender? Their only hope to save their lives, or at least the life of one or more of them, would be to get the first shot and that an unerring and fatal one.

See the clipping

Jesse James reported dead in Kentucky

A short item: a dispatch from Pine Hill, Kentucky, says Jesse James has died of wounds received there with the gang that robbed the bank at Huntington, West Virginia. The report was false: ten days later the Kenosha Telegraph had him alive in St. Louis and named the dead robber as Thompson McDaniels. The Sun in 1881 put Frank James, not Jesse, among the Huntington robbers.

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Alexandria Gazette · 20 September 1875 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A dispatch from Pine Hill, Ky., reports the death of Jesse James, wounded there several days ago when with the gang who robbed the Huntington, W. Va., Bank. James is well known throughout the country as a notorious Missouri outlaw, whose depredations produced much excitement some time ago.

See the clipping

Not Jesse: the dead robber was McDaniels

The correction to the Pine Hill story: the paper says Jesse James is living quietly among friends in St. Louis and denies he was killed. The dead Huntington robber was Thompson McDaniels, whose brother Bill, it says, was shot trying to break jail at Kansas City while held for the Muncie train robbery. The Sun in 1881 calls that brother Bud and puts the jailbreak at Lawrence.

The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Kenosha Telegraph · 30 September 1875 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Jesse James is living quietly in St. Louis, among friends, and denies that he was killed at Pine Hilil Ky. It has been ascertained that the name of the dead robber of the Huntington bank was Thompson McDaniels, a Western Missouri desperado, whose brother Bill was shot while endeavoring to break jail at Kansas City a few months ago, where he was held for complicity in the robbery of the Kansas Pacific train at Muncie last December.

See the clipping

Hobbs Kerry turns state’s evidence

A St. Louis Times correspondent follows Hobbs Kerry, taken from the Boonville jail at 3 a.m., to Sedalia, where on a promise of ‘unconditional clemency’ he names his partners in the train robbery: Cole and Bud Younger, Frank and Jesse James, Clel Miller, Chadwell and Pitts. Despite the promise, The Sun reported in 1881 that Kerry was serving seven years for the Otterville robbery.

Paper unidentified

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 11 August 1876 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

KERRY'S SQUEAL

The Captured train Robber Barters State's Evidence for Unconditional Clemency.

See moreSee less

His confession Encompasses Clel Miller. Chadwell. Pitts, the James Boys

An Expedition to the Place of "the "Divide," and of the Buried Papers.

[Special to the St. Louis Times.]

SEDALIA, MO., Aug. 8.—Your correspondent was in Boonville last night and telegraphed to the Times of an effort being made to force Hobbs Kerry, the suspected train robber, or at least to induce him to turn State's evidence. Hazen left during the day and went to Sedalia. All that the Times correspondent could learn by the most diligent and patient seeking was that Kerry had

REFUSED TO "SQUEAL"

except under certain conditions, and that these had not been agreed to as yet. The officers after Hazen's departure appeared to be waiting for something but refused to answer any questions. Their sense of the importance of coming events was very plainly expressed in their actions and communicated itself to the town people. Somebody started the story that a raid on the jail was to be effected by the friends of Kerry. All combined to create unusual excitement. A visit was paid to the Advertiser office, where everybody looked knowing but had

NOTHING TO COMMUNICATE.

Your correspondent returned to his vigils with Captain Rogers, the Sheriff of Cooper county, who showed no disposition to go to bed. Mindful of his instructions to spare no pains to ascertain what Kerry knew, the correspondent was equally wakeful,

About 1 o'clock this morning Captain Rogers received a telegram from Sedalia which apparently afforded him great satisfaction. He got together a small posse of men, and had frequent reference to his watch. The correspondent followed all these movements and about 3 a. m. saw Kerry

TAKEN FROM THE JAIL

by Rogers and three deputies and hurriedly escorted to the depot of the Missouri, Kansas and Texas Railroad.

At the last moment, just before the departure of the train for Sedalia, it was ascertained that the mysterious telegram was from Larry Hazen, the Cincinnati detective who has been representing the express companies in the pursuit of the train robbers. Kerry had agreed to turn State's evidence on a promise of unconditional clemency. Hazen could not promise this till he had consulted the express authorities and he had gone to Sedalia for this purpose The offer of Kerry had been accepted by those authorized to speak. This news Hazen had telegraphed with instructors to bring Kerry to Sedalia at once and there he was going.

THE CONFESSION.

Rogers and his party by the train for Sedalia and the Times correspondent went by the branch to Tipton, there took the Missouri Pacific and reached Sedalia in time to secure the confession of Kerry. Upon the promise of entire clemency he told Hazen and the others that Cole and Bud Younger, Frank and Jesse James, Clel Miller, Chadwell, Pitts and himself did the robbery, He said that Miller got the jewelry. He also implicated the same parties in other primes.

THE PROOF.

It seems that Kerry, in order to convince them that his story was true, told them if they go with him he would show them the place where the money was divided and the papers left, They agreed to his proposition, hence his being brought to this point.

The detectives, with a strong guard, left here this morning before day for a point fifteen or eighteen miles south of Sedalia, near Florence, in Morgan county,

NO DOUBT EXISTS

as to the truth of the story, and if Pitts and Chadwell are captured, as has been reported, none but the old regulars are left.

News from truthful sources here to-day is that the Youngers and James boys were seen in Clay county yesterday. The detectives have little hope of getting them without killing them,

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: The Brigands of Missouri