As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

December 1901

5 articles

In the story →

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

A case involving members of the Hatfield family, made notorious by the Hatfield-McCoy feud, is pending before the U.S. Supreme Court concerning title to about 800,000 acres of land in West Virginia, Kentucky, and Virginia. The appeal also raises questions about the constitutionality of West Virginia's land laws and involves disbarment proceedings against two attorneys.

The Evening Times · 3 December 1901 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

SUIT INVOLVING 800,000 ACRES.

Important West Virginia Case Appealed.

See moreSee less

BITTERLY FOUGHT FOR MANY YEARS

Appellants Members of Notorious Hatfield Family — Attorneys Fired Upon, One Shot, and One Assailant Killed.

Under the title "S. D. Hatfield and Nancy C. Rutherford vs. Henry C. King," an appeal now pending before the Supreme Court of the United States, is concealed what in many respects is one of the most remarkable cases ever brought before that court for adjudication. The appellants in the case are members of the family made notorious by the Hatfield-McCoy feud.

Involved in it is not only the title to about 800,000 acres of valuable agricultural timber and mineral land in West Virginia, Kentucky, and Virginia, together with the constitutionality of the land laws of the State first named, but also the question of disbarring from practice before the Supreme Court of two attorneys against whom have been filed charges of fixing up a fictitious and fraudulent suit to be used for the purpose of obtaining a judgment against the 400 and odd settlers now in possession of that part of the land in West Virginia.

Old Morris and Clinton Tracts.

One tract of this land known as the Robert Morris survey, consisting of 500,000 acres, lying in the three States mentioned, was granted to Robert Morris, of Philadelphia, by the Commonwealth of Virginia, under patent dated June 23, 1795.

The other tract, embracing 142,000 acres, was granted by Virginia to DeWitt Clinton as assignee of William Duval, February 19, 1796. This lies entirely within the State of West Virginia, and it is claimed, overlaps in part the Morris grant.

In 1894 the West Virginia authorities, acting under a State law providing for the forfeiture of lands not entered in the land registry or upon which taxes had not been paid for a period of five years, brought suit against that portion of the Morris tract within Wyoming, Logan, Mingo, and McDowell counties. The period in this instance was at least eleven years, and upon some parts of the tract it was shown that the holders themselves had paid the taxes for more than twenty years.

Origin of Present Litigation.

Acting upon a decree in its favor the State sold the lands to about four hundred individuals and corporations who are now in possession and against whom suits of ejectment have been filed by Henry C. King, of New York, who claims ownership of the entire tract under conveyance from Robert Morris.

This litigation for possession, instituted by King in 1895, has been going on ever since in the chancery, county, State, and United States circuit courts of West Virginia, and has previously been before the Supreme Court of the United States in one form or another on three or four occasions.

King, in addition to innumerable suits for ejectment, has sued out many injunctions to restrain the occupants of the lands claimed by him from disposing of the timber or coal thereon.

Attorneys Repeatedly Fired on.

The feeling against attorneys in that part of the State was so intense that they have been fired on repeatedly. One of them, Stiles, was wounded, and one of his assistants was killed.

In the original action King set up the claim that there had been no forfeiture of the lands, alleging a decree patenting the lands under the State law had been obtained by his predecessors in 1883, but he offered, if that decree were deemed invalid, to pay all back taxes due.

Before the chancery suit was decided, however, King brought an action in the United States Circuit Court to eject the various holders of the land, and from the adverse judgment of that court he appealed to the Supreme Court of the United States. Pending the hearing of this appeal an agreement was made by King's attorneys and filed in court that no action should be had in the chancery case or the proceedings before the commissioner of school lands in Wyoming county.

King's Alleged Breach of Faith.

Notwithstanding, and in violation of this agreement, King, it is alleged, obtained in 1897 a report from the commissioner, and, without notice to the parties concerned, they claim, obtained from the Circuit Court of Wyoming county a decree of redemption for that portion of the 500,000 acres in West Virginia.

The decree fixed the boundaries as claimed by King, a large part of the DeWitt Clinton tracts and other lands shown by other records to be outside the limits of the grant, being included.

King then paid the back taxes on the land together with interest and costs, and renewed proceedings in ejectment against the alleged "squatters." He was, however, enjoined from taking any advantage of the decree by an injunction, which also restrained the commissioner from paying out any of the money received from King. That injunction is still in force.

While the constitutionality of the law of West Virginia forfeiting title to lands for non-registry and non-payment of taxes during a period of five years, is the real basis of the appeal to the Supreme Court, and that State is represented in the case by special act of the West Virginia Legislature, which also appropriated $1,000 for prosecuting it, yet that question is not even touched upon in the motion filed by counsel for the Commonwealth.

Neither is it mentioned in the various petitions filed by the numerous parties interested.

Serious Charges Made.

Former Attorney General Rucker, of West Virginia, in his brief in behalf of the State, asks the Supreme Court first to declare null and void all proceedings in the case, both in this court and in the court below, for the reason that it is a fictitious proceeding, entirely under the control of Henry C. King and his counsel, feigned for the purpose of obtaining in the absence of any real opposition an opinion and decrees for use against the present holders of the lands in question, and that the pendency of the suit has so far as possible been concealed from the numerous persons whose interests it was intended should be affected by its result.

Second, that the decrees in the courts below be declared void on the ground of collusion, and, third, that Maynard F. Stiles and Henry C. Plesher, King's attorneys, be disbarred and proceeded against for contempt of court for bringing a ridiculous case before it and for other alleged unprofessional practices.

Grounds for the Action.

The grounds upon which this unusual action is based are set out at some length in the various petitions and affidavits presented on behalf of the appellants and those who ask the court for the privilege of intervening in the present action. Stuart Wood and thirty-five other holders of the land, including water, mining, and lumber companies, claiming bona fide ownership of the land, charge King, Flesher, and Stiles with bringing and carrying on this fictitious suit in the Circuit Court without the knowledge of the rural defendants; that it does not appear from the records of the Circuit Court that it was ever regularly and formally instituted; that no process was ever issued against either S. D. Hatfield or Nancy C. Rutherford; that the alleged orders and decrees made in that case were not entered in the order book of the court, and that no record of the pendency of this suit in that court is shown until application was made for a certification of the record for the purpose of appealing the case.

They further charge that S. D. Hatfield and Nancy Rutherford did not authorize Flesher to appear for them in the case or appeal it, and that neither of them knew of the suit until it had been appealed to the Supreme Court, their affidavits to that effect being attached.

Missing From the Records.

Flesher, it is also charged, filed, as attorney for Mrs. Hatfield, Mrs. Rutherford and William Claypool, a statement of fact in an ejectment suit against them, although all three of them in their affidavits deny signing it, which statement, it is alleged, has mysteriously disappeared from the court records.

The petition further avers that Flesher had been suspended from practice by the circuit court of Jackson county, for not paying over money collected as attorney.

As to Stiles, the petitioners charge him with falsely stating in the original bill that King was in possession of the lands of Mrs. Hatfield, as he had for years known of her occupancy. They also cite the record of the circuit court of Wyoming county showing Stiles' name stricken from the roll of attorneys before that court for unprofessional conduct in the King contest, although this action was afterward reversed by the higher court.

Family of Feud Fame.

It is also alleged that the name "Nancy C. Rutherford," one of the alleged appellants, is false, as she since 1895 has been Nancy C. Browning by reason of her marriage, and that that marriage was known to King's attorney.

Mrs. Browning, it appears from her affidavit, is the daughter of Sarah D. and Joseph Hatfield, and the granddaughter of Aby Hatfield, all members of the family concerned in the famous Hatfield-McCoy feud. Mrs. Hatfield claims unbroken possession of her land for thirty-two years, and a deed by Aby Hatfield to his daughter Martha Toler, dated 1861, shows the latter had since that date been in possession of that portion of the Hatfield tract.

The record of the latter deed in the clerk's office of Logan county has, however, been mutilated. Other affidavits show the land had been in possession of the Hatfields for at least since 1858.

Stiles' Alleged Promises.

Mrs. Hatfield deposes regarding the arrangement between her and Stiles regarding the suit that the latter had proposed to defend her title to the lands in an ejectment suit promising to pay all expenses and to reconvey her lands to her if King won the suit.

Her affidavit further declares that Stiles suggested Flesher, one of King's attorneys, to act for her, and consulting her own lawyer, H. K. Shumate, she had consented. Flesher afterward called on her, and she gave him power to act for her in the ejectment suit only.

Denies Alleged Agreement.

She denies all knowledge of the agreed statement of facts used in the present suit, and swears she never knew of the pendency of the suit until the appeal had been filed in the Supreme Court.

Holmes Conrad, formerly Solicitor General of the United States, heads the list of attorneys for the petitioners in their brief asking dismissal of the suit and disbarment of Stiles and Flesher. The latter have been given until Tuesday to file replies to the charges and the motions.

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

Thirty-five landholders seek to intervene in a court case, charging that King, Flesher, and Stiles brought a fictitious suit without the knowledge of defendants S.D. Hatfield and Nancy Rutherford. They allege no process was ever issued, no proper court record exists, and that Flesher was never authorized to appear on the defendants' behalf.

The Evening Times · 3 December 1901 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

A petition challenges an ejectment suit, alleging that attorneys Flesher and Stiles engaged in misconduct, including a mysteriously disappeared affidavit and false claims about land possession. It also alleges that one petitioner, Nancy C. Rutherford, used a false name, as she had actually been Nancy C. Browning since her 1885 marriage, and that she is descended from the Hatfield family of feud fame.

The Evening Times · 3 December 1901 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Arizona Silver Belt · Globe City, Ariz.

A man named Hatfield was shot and killed by officer Devine in Troy after resisting arrest and running toward his house; a coroner's jury exonerated Devine. The report claims the victim was the last surviving member of the Hatfield family of the famous Kentucky feud with the McCoys.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Arizona Silver Belt · 26 December 1901 · page 1

A KILLING AT TROY.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A deputy sheriff named Devine shot and killed Robert H. Hatfield, described as one of the last of the notorious Kentucky feuding clan, at a mining camp in Arizona's Pinal Mountains. Hatfield had refused to surrender on a wife-beating warrant and threatened to kill anyone who tried to arrest him.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The San Francisco Call · 30 December 1901 · page 1

SHERIFF'S GUN ENDS THE LIFE OF A HATFIELD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come