As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

April 1901

23 articles

Paper unidentified

West Virginia's State Board of Pardons recommended pardon for Elias Hatfield, of Hatfield-McCoy feud fame, who is serving 12 years for the murder of Doc Hills in Mingo county. He is reported to be dying from consumption.

Paper unidentified · 4 April 1901 · page 2

PARDON Has Been Recommended For Elias Hatfield

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

The Huntington Advertiser · Huntington, W. Va.

The board of pardons at Moundsville penitentiary decided to recommend a pardon for Elias Hatfield, who was serving a 12-year sentence for killing 'Doc' Ellis, citing that he was dying of consumption. His attorneys had pleaded his case the previous day.

The Huntington Advertiser · 4 April 1901 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

HATFIELD TO BE PARDONED

THE SLAYER OF "DOC" ELLIS SAID TO BE DYING AT MOUNDSVILLE.

See moreSee less

WHEELING, W. Va, Apr. 4—The board of pardons which is in session at the Moundsville penitentiary this afternoon decided to recommend a pardon for Elias Hatfield, of Hatfield-McCoy feud fame, who is serving a 12 year sentence. They will give as a reason the fact that Hatfield is dying of consumption. Attorney Charles J. Schuck and Captain Ewing had Hatfield's case and pleaded for his pardon yesterday.

See the clipping

Daily New Dominion · Morgantown, W. Va.

Attorneys argued before the West Virginia State Board of Pardons for clemency for Elias Hatfield, citing his ill health and alleged trial errors. Hatfield, about 25, was serving a 15-year sentence for killing Dr. Ellis in Mingo County, an act said to have ended the Hatfield-McCoy feud.

Daily New Dominion · 4 April 1901 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

The West Virginia state board of pardons has recommended a pardon for Elias Hatfield, imprisoned for 12 years for the murder of Doc Bills in Mingo County, connected to the Hatfield-McCoy feud. The brief dispatch notes his anticipated release.

The Stark County Democrat · 5 April 1901 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article recounts the fearsome reputation of the Hatfield family across four states and credits Deputy U.S. Marshal Daniel W. Cunningham with capturing four clan members and sending one to the gallows. It frames the ongoing law enforcement campaign as a dangerous pursuit against a family long immune from justice.

Evening Star · 6 April 1901 · page 24 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

HUNTING HATFIELDS

The Dangerous Pursuit of a Deputy United States Marshal.

See moreSee less

HAS CAPTURED FOUR OF THE CLAN

Deeds of Daring in the Mountains of West Virginia.

AT THE RIFLE'S POINT

Written for The Evening Star.

Throughout the northern spurs of the Alleghanies the name of Hatfield is a name of terror. Devil Anse and his clan have for years and almost with impunity ravaged the mountain region of four states—Virginia, West Virginia, Kentucky and Tennessee—with murder, arson and all other crimes of violence. The murders perpetrated by them in the Hatfield-McCoy feud are only a small part of their crimes. Nowhere in criminal annals is there another family with so bloody a record.

In their own home region of southern West Virginia their dominance is complete. There is a saying there, backed by a long and grim record, that to offend a Hatfield is the surest form of suicide. Even the officers of the law seldom interfere with them, and though the aggregate of indictments against the clan mounts up into the hundreds, its members, armed to the teeth, not only ride free in their own mountains, but even visit the cities unmolested when they choose. If they take a grudge against a man they hunt him to his death, and their list of victims was a long one before any man, except the McCoys, raiding in reprisal from across the border of Kentucky, dared interfere with them. But now they are being hunted in their own state by a man who has already captured four of them and sent one to the gallows. This is Deputy United States Marshal Daniel W. Cunningham of the district of West Virginia.

His First Capture.

Originally Cunningham was a partisan of the Hatfields. He had been a recipient of the surly and dangerous hospitality of Devil Anse and had heard his side of the Hatfield-McCoy history. Shortly after that he stayed at the house of Jim Vance, one of the Hatfield leaders, who had been killed while raiding in Kentucky, and heard from Vance's widow the story of the butchery of three defenseless McCoy children by a force of Hatfields, the first act in carrying out the declaration of extermination against the McCoys. Once convinced of the truth of this the marshal made a resolve to capture and turn over to justice every participant in that crime who should cross his path, and within a month he had made his first capture.

This was the taking of Charles Gillespie, who, after the murders, went to his aunt's home in Tazewell county, Virginia, just across the line. The house stands on a remote mountain, reached by a horse trail. Thither Cunningham made his way, pretending to be a friend of Gillespie's. At the house he learned that Gillespie spent his days in the mountain forest, coming in only at night. In a clearing of the woods he found the young desperado, carrying the inevitable rifle. Whistling a cheerful tune, the marshal walked along the trail until he met Gillespie, whose suspicions were disarmed, for he never supposed that a man hunter would be whistling on the trail. As they came face to face Cunningham caught the young fellow by the wrists. Gillespie struggled, but the marshal's muscles are scarcely less hard than the steel handcuffs which he snapped upon the desperado's wrists, ending the fight. Gillespie confessed to his part in the murders, substantiating the story told by Mrs. Vance. Cunningham took him to Kentucky, where he was tried and convicted, but afterward broke jail and escaped.

A Daring Enterprise.

While in Pike county, Kentucky, Cunningham learned of a plot to bushwhack and murder Frank Phillips, a partisan of the McCoy family. Ellison Hatfield, Black Elliott Hatfield and Tom Mitchell, murderers of the McCoy children, and also of Miss Allenham and Calvin McCoy in the attack Allaphare and Colvin McCoy, in the attack on old Randall McCoy's house, had planned to go from Jim Vance's house, which is a few miles within the West Virginia line, over the border into Pike county, and lay for Phillips there. Cunningham planned a counter ambush, in which he enlisted Bill Napper, an experienced hunter, and a young man named Gibson, of less experience, but equal gameness. The marshal knew that any one of the Hatfield gang would kill him on sight, but that if he killed any of them he must stand trial for it, as the state administration of West Virginia was, for reasons of its own, friendly to the Hatfields. It looked like a dubious proposition, for the three Hatfield men had Winchesters, but Cunningham determined to have a try at it. He picked out Ellison, the biggest and most dangerous of the trio, for himself, assigning Black Elliott to Napper and Mitchell to Gibson. Concealing themselves behind trees, they waited for their men near a creek bottom, along which the bushwhackers were sure to come.

When they came Ellison was in the lead, walking along the bank. Cunningham stood close behind his tree with a rock in one hand and his rifle in the other. The other two Hatfields were a distance behind, while Cunningham's aids were farther up the bank. When Ellison was within a few yards of Cunningham, the marshal, moving slowly around his tree to keep out of sight, stepped on a crackling twig. Instantly the rifle of the desperado was leveled, but before he could fire the rock took him on the chin and he wavered for a second. In that second Cunningham was upon him. At the same moment Gibson opened fire and Mitchell and Black Elliott fled back along the creek bed, pursued by Cunningham's assistants, who left him in full confidence that he could handle Ellison.

A Fight for Life.

This proved to be a big contract, however. The marshal had wrenched away Ellison's gun, by which time the outlaw had recovered from his surprise and began to put up a furious fight. The rock had struck him only a glancing blow, and had not impaired his powers. He was as big a man as his antagonist and almost as strong. At the first wrench after they had clinched both went over the bank. In the rocky creek bed they struggled, now in the water, now out of it, never on their feet, the Hatfield tearing and biting at his captor like a wild beast, the marshal striving to get the handcuffs on his man. Endurance and condition won the battle. Moon- rance shine whisky is bad for the wind, and when Napper and Mitchell returned empty-handed Ellison was tied and handcuffed, while Cunningham was washing his bruised and bloody face in the creek. Cunningham took Ellison across the river to Kentucky, where they found Bud McCoy waiting with twelve men. The McCoys called on Cunningham to give up Ellison Hatfield to them, and at that Ellison broke down, cried and begged, and confessed the murder of Allaphare McCoy. Cunningham asked Bud McCoy what he intended to do with Ellison. "Kill him and cut him up into inch pieces." "Then you'll kill me first," said Cunningham, lifting his rifle. Gave Them Another Chance. After a consultation, McCoy promised to land Ellison Hatfield in jail without maltreatment, a promise which he kept. Ellison was tried, convicted and hanged. The Hatfields swore that they would have Cunningham's life if he ever again came into their country. Within a short time he gave them the chance, by going after Ellick Messer, another member of the child-mur-

dering expedition. Young Gibson went with him. They found Messer near the Hatfield settlement sitting on a log with his rifle across his knees, and captured him without a fight. At the station, where they took the train for Kentucky, they encountered a dozen of the Hatfield clan, fully armed, who had heard of the capture, and had liquored up and declared their intention of blowing Cunningham to bits. The worst they did after contemplating the obvious readiness of Cunningham's and Gibson's rifles was to curse compendiously, and assure the captive that they would derail the train and get him out. He was taken to Kentucky, confessed and got a life sentence. It was afterward discovered that before joining the Hatfield gang he had murdered the three children of a man against whom he had a grudge. Recovered the Boy. Thereafter whenever Cunningham was in the southwestern part of the state the Hatfields followed him. That they never succeeded in catching up to him would seem to indicate lack of zeal on their part, difficult to reconcile with the fervor of their threats. Three years ago the marshal gave them an excellent chance to get him, had they been on the alert. In a drunken revel, one night, they had instituted a little sport with a poor woodchopper named Duffy, which ended characteristically in their driving him into a pond, where he was drowned. His nine-year boy they took to bring up in their clan. The boy's uncle learned of it, and advertised a reward for the recovery of the child. Nobody came forward to apply for the job until a friend suggested that Mr. Duffy write to Dan Cunningham. That official took three days off, rode alone into the Hatfield settlement, found the boy at a house within half a mile of Devil Anse's homestead, grabbed him up on his horse, and galloped away. If the Hatfields followed, he did not know it. Thus was spoiled an outlaw in the making. In Gilbert, W. Va., lives Doc Ellis, a well-to-do timber owner. Against him the notorious Jonce Hatfield had sworn a grudge, for some fancied grievance, and sent word that he would kill him on sight. As it was a great detriment to Ellis' business to have a Hatfield gunning for him, he hired a crack shot named Hopkins to keep watch for Jonce and shoot first. Neither Hopkins nor Jonce had had any luck in their shooting, when Dan Cunningham came to Gilbert and put up at Ellis' house. Ellis told him of Jonce's threat. "I've got a little business with Jonce myself," said Cunningham. "Reckon I'll hang around for a few days." Two evenings later Hopkins came in and said that two men with Winchesters were lying out in a ragweed patch near the house. One of them, he thought, was Jonce Hatfield. "We'll go out and get them," said Cunningham. Hopkins was willing, and a lumberman who had dropped in volunteered to go

Daniel W. Cunningham, Deputy U. S. Marshal.

along. Counting in Ellis, the party was four strong, all around. But Jonce had a reputation as a dead shot, had killed a dozen men, and he and his companion had all the advantage of the position. Cunningham led his forces out of the house by a rear exit, and around by a gully to a spot near the ragweed patch. He had made a study of the ground about the house previously, and knew just how to go ahead. With Ellis close behind him, he crept up close to where Jonce crouched. The outlaw had his gun pointed at a lighted window of the Ellis house, waiting for a figure to show. The curtain was down. It always was in that house, for just such a reason.

"Don't reckon we'll get him tonight," the attacking party heard Jonce mutter to his companion.

"Shall I shoot the d—d murderer?" whispered Ellis.

"No," replied Cunningham. "I want him alive."

Then he broke cover and went straight for Jonce. Hatfield wheeled, but Cunningham's rifle pointed straight between his eyes. The other man dropped on all fours and scuttled away through the weeds. Jonce stood paralyzed.

"Hands up," commanded Cunningham.

The outlaw hesitated.

"Reach for the stars! Quick!" came the sharp order.

Threaten His Life.

The outlaw's rifle fell and his hands went up. Cunningham took from him a 44-caliber revolver and a fine English dirk, and left him in charge of Ellis while he went after the other man. The man was soon found and captured. He was Auk Dameron, and as Cunningham knew nothing at that time against him he was released. This proved to be an error, for it was afterward found that Dameron had broken jail under sentence of death for the murder of a deputy sheriff in Virginia. Cunningham took Jonce Hatfield to Kentucky, where he broke down and confessed. He is now serving a life sentence for the murder of the McCoy children. Naturally that made the Hatfields more savage than ever against Cunningham, and they redoubled their threats. Now, whenever he is in that country he gets warning that bands of mounted Hatfields are following him. But, as before, they don't catch up. He holds the clan in contempt.

"If they can get you foul they'll kill you," he says. "But in the open they're all cowards."

It is not part of Cunningham's duty as a federal officer to hunt Hatfields. He does it as he would hunt rattlesnakes, and as his warrants for "moonshine" whisky distillers often take him to the Hatfield country, he is likely to get more of them. Cunningham is not the sort of man that one would care to have on his trail. He is more than six feet tall, broad in proportion, beautifully muscled, possessed of catlike agility and as swift as he is sure with a rifle or revolver, and in that country swiftness is a necessary accompaniment of sureness. He is always in the hardest of training, as he neither drinks, smokes nor chews. In manner and appearance he is quiet and unostentatious, and when going about the country is commonly taken for an itinerant clergyman. THE CAPTURE OF ELLISON HATFIELD. "REACH FOR THE STARS. QUICK!"

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This sensationalized 1901 account describes detective Cunningham capturing outlaw Gillespie, who confesses to murders, then recounts a planned counter-ambush against Ellison Hatfield, Black Elliott Hatfield, and Tom Mitchell near the Kentucky-West Virginia border. The dramatic narrative depicts a tense standoff in the woods as Cunningham and his men lie in wait to kill the approaching Hatfield gang before being bushwhacked themselves.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Evening Star · 6 April 1901 · page 24

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This 1901 account recounts lawman Dan Cunningham's pursuit and capture of Hatfield associates, including a gang member named Messer who later confessed to murder and received a life sentence. It also describes an earlier episode where Hatfields drowned a woodchopper named Duffy and took his young son, whom Cunningham later recovered.

Evening Star · 6 April 1901 · page 24

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A 1901 report describes Deputy U.S. Marshal Daniel Cunningham hunting down and capturing members of the Hatfield clan in West Virginia, including one Hatfield caught lying in ambush and two men accused of helping murder McCoy children. The piece frames the Hatfields as a lawless, feared family finally being brought to justice years after the original feud.

The Savannah Morning News · 8 April 1901 · page 2

HUNTING THE HATFIELDS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This retrospective article profiles Deputy U.S. Marshal Daniel Cunningham, who turned against the Hatfields after hearing of a massacre of McCoy children and began capturing clan members. It details his capture of Charles Gillespie through disguise and ambush, with Gillespie confessing and corroborating earlier accounts.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.

Wrong

The Savannah Morning News · 8 April 1901 · page 2

REACH FOR THE STARS! QUICK! CAME THE SHARP ORDER.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The report recounts how Marshal Cunningham tricked and captured young Gillespie, who confessed to the McCoy murders, then describes Cunningham learning of a Hatfield plot to ambush Frank Phillips and his counter-ambush plan. The account is written in a dramatic, novelistic style typical of later feud retrospectives.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Savannah Morning News · 8 April 1901 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Ceredo Advance · Ceredo, W. Va.

The Board of Pardons at Moundsville penitentiary voted to recommend a pardon for Elias Hatfield, who is serving a 12-year sentence for murder stemming from the Hatfield-McCoy feud. The board cited reports that Hatfield is dying of consumption.

Ceredo Advance · 10 April 1901 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Chicago Eagle · Chicago, Ill.

A civil engineer recounts a tale from his surveying days in the Tug River country, describing how two railroad detectives evaded an ambush set by the Hatfields by seeking hospitality directly at Devil Anse Hatfield's fortified home. Having eaten under his roof, the detectives were protected by mountain custom, and Devil Anse reluctantly hosted them before guiding them safely out of the territory.

Chicago Eagle · 13 April 1901 · page 8

HOW DEVIL ANSE WAS FOOLED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Marietta Daily Leader · Marietta, Ohio

The article describes the notorious Hatfield clan's reputation for violence across four states, noting their general immunity from law enforcement. It highlights Deputy U.S. Marshal Daniel W. Cunningham, a former Hatfield associate, who has turned against them and already captured four clan members, sending one to the gallows.

Marietta Daily Leader · 17 April 1901 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Marietta Daily Leader · Marietta, Ohio

The report narrates how lawman Cunningham tracked down and captured a Hatfield associate named Gillespie, who confessed to the murders. It continues with an elaborate story of a counter-ambush plot against Hatfield gang members including Ellison Hatfield, organized by Cunningham in Pike County.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Marietta Daily Leader · 17 April 1901 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Marietta Daily Leader · Marietta, Ohio

The passage narrates a violent struggle between a marshal named Cunningham and an outlaw called Ellison Hatfield, ending in Ellison's capture and handover to Bud McCoy's men. It claims Ellison was later tried, convicted, and hanged for the murder of Allaphare McCoy, and recounts a follow-up manhunt for another Hatfield associate.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 9 days earlier.

Wrong

Marietta Daily Leader · 17 April 1901 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

This retrospective account describes the Hatfield clan's long reign of terror and violence across four states, noting their near-total impunity from law enforcement. It highlights Deputy U.S. Marshal Daniel Cunningham's ongoing campaign to capture Hatfield gang members, having already caught four and sent one to the gallows.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 April 1901 · page 27

DESPERATE TASK OF FEDERAL OFFICERS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

This 1901 account describes Deputy U.S. Marshal Daniel Cunningham's campaign to capture Hatfield clan members years after the feud, including his capture of Charles Gillespie through disguise and trickery. It frames his motivation as revenge for Hatfields' killing of three McCoy children, as told to him by Jim Vance's widow.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 April 1901 · page 27 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

FINISH OF A BLOODY FEUD Hatfield Clan of Murderers Run to Cover and Captured.

DESPERATE TASK OF FEDERAL OFFICERS

See moreSee less

Killers Bagged in the Mountain Fastnesses of West Virginia—Worst Feared Ruffians in the Country.

Throughout the northern spurs of the Alleghanies the name of Hatfield is a name of terror. Devil Anse and his clan have for years and almost with impunity ravaged the mountain region of four states—Virginia, West Virginia, Kentucky and Tennessee—with murder, arson, and all other crimes of violence. The murders perpetrated by them in the Hatfield-McCoy feud are only a small part of their crimes.

petrated Nowhere in criminal annals is there another family with so foul and bloody a record.

In their own home region of southern West Virginia their dominance is complete. There is a saying there, backed by a long and grim record, that to offend a Hatfield is the surest form of suicide. Even the officers of the law seldom interfere with them and though the aggregate of indictments against the clan mounts up into the hundreds, its members, armed to the teeth, not only ride free in their own mountains, but even visit the cities unmolested when they choose. If they take a grudge against a man they hunt him to his death, and their list of victims was a long one before any man, except the McCoys, raiding in reprisal from across the border of Kentucky, dared interfere with them. But now they are being hunted in their own state by a man who has already captured four of them and sent one to the gallows. This is Deputy United States Marshal Daniel W. Cunningham of the district of West Virginia. Originally Cunningham was a partisan of the Hatfields. He had been a recipient of the surly and dangerous hospitality of Devil Anse and had heard his side of the Hatfield-McCoy history. Shortly after that he stayed at the house of Jim Vance, one of the Hatfield leaders, who had been killed while raiding in Kentucky, and heard from Vance's widow the story of the butchery of three defenseless McCoy children by a force of Hatfields, the first act in carrying out the declaration of extermination against the McCoys. Once convinced of the truth of this the marshal made a resolve to capture and turn over to justice every participant in that crime who should cross his path, and within a month he had made his first capture.

This was the taking of Charles Gillespie, who, after the murders, went to his aunt's home in Tazewell county, Virginia, just across the line. The house stands on a remote mountain, reached by a horse trail. Thither Cunningham made his way, pretending to be a friend of Gillespie's. At the house he learned that Gillespie spent his days in the mountain forest, coming in only at night. In a clearing of the woods he found the young desperado, carrying the inevitable rifle. Whistling a cheerful tune, the marshal walked along the trail until he met Gillespie, whose suspicions were disarmed, for he never supposed that a man hunter would be whistling on the trail. As they came face to face, Cunningham caught the young fellow by the wrists. Gillespie struggled, but the marshal's muscles are scarcely less hard than the steel handcuffs which he snapped upon the desperado's wrists, ending the fight. Gillespie confessed to his part in the murders, substantiating the story told by Mrs. Vance. Cunningham took him to Kentucky, where he was tried and convicted, but afterwards broke jail and escaped.

In the Haunts of the Clan.

While in Pike county, Kentucky, Cunningham learned of a plot to bushwhack and murder Frank Phillips, a partisan of the McCoy family. Ellison Hatfield, Black Elliot Hatfield and Tom Mitchell, murderers of the McCoy children and also of Miss Allaphare and Colvin McCoy, in the attack on old Randall McCoy's house, had planned to go from Jim Vance's house, which is a few miles within the West Virginia line, over the border into Pike county, and lay for Phillips there. Cunningham planned a counter ambush, in which he enlisted Bill Napper, an experienced hunter, and a young man named Gibson of less experience, but equal gameness. The marshal knew that any one of the Hatfield gang would kill him on sight, but that if he killed any of them he must stand trial for it, as the state administration of Virginia was, for reasons of its own, friendly to the Hatfields. It looked like a dubious proposition, for the three Hatfield men had Winchesters, but Cunningham determined to have a try at it. He picked out Ellison, the biggest and most dangerous of the trio, for himself, assigning Black Elliott to Napper and Mitchell to Gibson. Concealing themselves behind trees they waited for their men near a creek bottom, along which the bushwhackers were sure to come.

When they came Ellison was in the lead, walking along the bank. Cunningham stood close behind his tree, with a rock in one hand and his rifle in the other. The other two Hatfields were a distance behind, while Cunningham's aides were further up the bank. When Ellison was within a few yards of Cunningham the marshal moving slowly around his tree to keep out of sight, stepped on a crackling twig. Instantly the rifle of the desperado was leveled, but before he could fire the rock took him on the chin and he wavered for a second. In that second Cunningham was upon him. At the same moment Gibson opened fire and Mitchell and Black Elliott fled back along the creek bed, pursued by Cunningham's assistants, who left him in full confidence that he could handle Ellison.

This proved to be a big contract, however. The marshal had wrenched away Ellison's gun, by which time the outlaw had recovered from his surprise, and began to put up a furious fight. The rock had struck him only a glancing blow, and had not impaired his powers. He was as big a man as his antagonist, and almost as strong. At the first wrench, after they had clinched, both went over the bank. In the rocky creek bed they struggled, now in the water, now out of it; never on their feet; the Hatfield tearing and biting at his captor like a wild beast; the marshal striving to get the handcuffs on his man. Endurance and condition won the battle. Moonshine whisky is bad for the wind and when Napper and Mitchell returned, empty-handed, Ellison was tied and handcuffed while Cunningham was washing his bruised and bloody face in the creek. Cunningham took Ellison across the river to Kentucky, where they found Bud McCoy waiting with twelve men. The McCoys called on Cunningham to give up Ellison Hatfield to them; and at that Ellison broke down, cried and begged, and confessed the murder of Allaphare McCoy. Cunningham asked Bud McCoy what he intended to do with Ellison. "Kill him and cut him up into inch pieces."

"Then you'll kill me first," said Cunningham, lifting his rifle.

Again on the Trail.

After a consultation, McCoy promised to land Ellison Hatfield in jail without maltreatment, a promise which he kept. Ellison was tried, convicted and hanged. The Hatfields swore that they would have Cunningham's life if he ever again came into their country. Within a short time he gave them the chance, by going after Ellick Messer, another member of the child-murdering expedition. Young Gibson went with him. They found Messer near the Hatfield settlement sitting on a log with his rifle across his knees, and captured him without a fight. At the station, where they took the train for Kentucky, they encountered a dozen of the Hatfield clan, fully armed, who had heard of the capture, and had liquored up and declared their intention of blowing Cunningham to bits. The worst they did after contemplating tention the obvious readiness of Cunningham's and Gibson's rifles, was to curse compendiously, and assure the captive that they would derail the train and get him out. He was taken to Kentucky, confessed and got a life sentence. It was afterward discovered that before joining the Hatfield gang he had murdered the three children of a man against whom he had a grudge.

Thereafter whenever Cunningham was in the southwestern part of the state the Hatfields followed him. That they never succeeded in catching up to him would seem to indicate lack of zeal on their part, difficult to reconcile with the fervor of their threats. Three years ago the marshal gave them an excellent chance to get him, had they been on the alert. In a drunken revel, one night, they had instituted a little sport with a poor woodchopper, named Duffy, which ended characteristically in their driving him into a pond, where he was drowned. His 9-year boy they took to bring up in their clan. The boy's uncle learned of it and advertised a reward for the recovery of the child. Nobody came forward to apply for the job until a friend suggested that Mr. Duffy write to Dan Cunningham. That official took three days off, rode alone into the Hatfield settlement, found the boy at a house within a half mile of Devil Anse's homestead, grabbed him up on his horse and galloped away. If the Hatfields followed he did not know it. Thus was spoiled an outlaw in the making.

In Gilbert, W. Va., lives Doc Ellis, a well-to-do timber owner. Against him the notorious Jonce Hatfield had sworn a grudge, for some fancied grievance, and sent word that he would kill him on sight. As it was a great detriment to Ellis' business to have a Hatfield gunning for him he hired a crack shot named Hopkins to keep watch for Jonce and shoot first. Neither Hopkins nor Jonce had any luck in their shooting when Dan Cunningham came to Gilbert and put up at Ellis' house. Ellis told him of Jonce's threat.

"I've got a little business with Jonce myself," said Cunningham. "Reckon I'll hang around for a few days."

Two evenings later Hopkins came in and said that two men with Winchesters were lying out in a ragweed patch near the house. One of them he thought was Jonce Hatfield.

"We'll go out and get them," said Cunningham.

Caught Red Handed.

Hopkins was willing and a lumberman who had dropped in volunteered to go along. Counting in Ellis the party was four strong, all armed. But Jonce had a reputation as a dead shot, had killed a dozen men, and he and his companion had all the advantage of the position. Cunningham led his forces out of the house by a rear exit, and around by a gully to a spot near the ragweed patch. He had made a study of the ground about the house, previously, and knew just how to go ahead. With Ellis close behind him he crept up close to where Jonce crouched. The outlaw had his gun pointed at a lighted window of the Ellis house, waiting for a figure to show. The curtain was down. It alawys was in that house, for just such a reason.

"Don't reckon we'll get him tonight," the attacking party heard Jonce mutter to his companion.

"Shall I shoot the d—n murderer?" whispered Ellis.

"No," replied Cunningham. "I want him alive."

Then he broke cover and went straight for Jonce. The Hatfield wheeled, but Cunningham's rifle pointed straight between his eyes. The other man dropped on all fours and scuttled away through the weeds. Jonce stood paralyzed.

"Hands up," commanded Cunningham.

The outlaw hesitated.

"Reach for the stars! Quick!" came the sharp order.

The outlaw's rifle fell and his hands went up. Cunningham took from him a forty-four caliber revolver and a fine English dirk and left him in charge of Ellis while he went after the other man. The man was soon found and captured. He was Auk Dameron and as Cunningham knew nothing at that time against him he was released. This proved to be an error, for it was afterward found that Dameron had broken jail under sentence of death for the murder of a deputy sheriff in Virginia. Cunningham took Jonce Hatfield to Kentucky, where he broke down and confessed. He is now serving a life sentence for the murder of the McCoy children. Naturally, that made the Hatfields more savage than ever against Cunningham and they redoubled their threats. Now whenever he is in that country he gets warnings that bands of mounted Hatfields are following him. But, as before, they don't catch up. He holds the clan in contempt.

"If they can get you foul they'll kill you," he says. "But in the open they're all cowards."

It is not part of Cunningham's duty as a federal officer to hunt Hatfields. He does it as he would hunt rattlesnakes and as his warrants for "moonshine" whisky distillers often take him to the Hatfield country he is likely to get more of them. Cunningham is not the sort of man that one would care to have on his trail. He is more than six feet tall, broad in proportion, beautifully muscled, possessed of catlike agility and as swift as he is sure with a rifle or revolver, and in that country swiftness is a necessary accompaniment of sureness. He is always in the hardest of training, as he neither drinks, smokes nor chews. In manner and appearance he is quiet and unostentatious and when going about the country is commonly taken for an itinerant clergyman.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The report recounts how Marshal Cunningham tricked and captured fugitive Gillespie, who confessed and corroborated Mrs. Vance's account of the murders. It also describes Cunningham later organizing a counter-ambush in Kentucky against Hatfield gang members plotting to kill McCoy partisan Frank Phillips.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Omaha Daily Bee · 21 April 1901 · page 27

DESPERATE TASK OF FEDERAL OFFICERS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The article profiles Deputy U.S. Marshal Daniel Cunningham, who hunts members of the Hatfield family in West Virginia despite their fearsome reputation. It recounts a planned ambush involving Ellison Hatfield, Black Elliott Hatfield, and Tom Mitchell, described as participants in the deadly attack on Randall McCoy's house.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Jersey City News · 27 April 1901 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The report recounts a fictionalized-sounding struggle between Marshal Dan Cunningham and an outlaw called Ellison Hatfield, including a brutal hand-to-hand fight and eventual capture. It also recounts an earlier tale of Cunningham rescuing a kidnapped boy from the Hatfield clan after they drowned his father.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 10 days earlier.

The Jersey City News · 27 April 1901 · page 7

CAPTURE OF ELLISON HATFIELD.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The passage recounts two tales of detective Dan Cunningham's bravery against the Hatfield clan: rescuing a kidnapped boy from the Hatfield settlement, and confronting the gunman Jonce Hatfield who had been hired to kill timber owner Ellis. Cunningham organizes an ambush party and corners Jonce Hatfield while he lies in wait to shoot Ellis.

The Jersey City News · 27 April 1901 · page 7

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Times · Washington, D.C.

The report describes a shooting match near Davy, West Virginia, where Captain Hatfield, reputed a top marksman, was beaten by his cousin Mrs. Simon Kline. Hatfield graciously credited her skill to shared Hatfield blood.

The Times · 28 April 1901 · page 1

SHE OUTSHOT HATFIELD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A dispatch from Bluefield, West Virginia recounts how Captain Hatfield, feud leader reputed to be the best shot in the state, was beaten in an impromptu shooting match by his cousin Mrs. Simon Kline, a Hatfield by birth. Hatfield graciously conceded defeat, remarking that the marksmanship was 'in the blood' of the Hatfield family.

Alexandria Gazette · 29 April 1901 · page 1

SHE OUTSHOT HATFIELD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come