ONLY HATFIELD PICTURE.
PHOTOGRAPH OF THE FAMOUS WEST VIRGINIA OUTLAWS.
See moreSee less
In a Careless Moment Devil Anse Allowed It to Be Taken—The Hatfields Wrecked the Photographer's Establishment the Next Day, and Only One Proof Was Saved.
When the famous feud between the Hatfield and McCoy families, which cost many lives in the mountain country of West Virginia and Kentucky, was declared at an end in April, 1897, the families of old Randolph McCoy and the descendants of old Deacon Ellison Hatfield, led by the notorious Devil Anse, gathered on the banks of the Big Sandy River to sanction the wedding of Mary McCoy and young Aaron Hatfield. There are rumors now that this peace protocol is over and talk of a fresh outbreak. Whether there is any ground for the belief that the feud is to be reopened it is hard to tell, for fighting, not talking, is what both families engage in when the ill-feeling comes to the top and there are scores to be settled.
Four times the Hatfields and the McCoys gathered to declare off the feud that has been passed down through three generations, and three times out of the four blood was shed before the negotiations were concluded. Moonshine whiskey, which both families make and drink in large quantities, has been responsible mainly for the breaking of these compacts, and if the families go at each other again it will probably be because of the evil effects of the product of the illicit distilleries in the West Virginia mountains. It is almost incredible that such a feud could start up again and continue with the same freedom that it did twenty years ago, but it is possible, for the authorities of that State are as powerless to stop it to-day as they were years ago, when Parish and Sam McCoy shot and killed young Bill Stayton from ambush, thereby shedding the first blood of the feud.
The picture that accompanies this story is particularly interesting for two reasons. First, it is the only group picture ever taken of the Hatfields and the only picture ever taken of any of the leaders of that family with their consent. Secondly, having been taken in times of peace, it illustrates the caution with which these outlaws are observing the truce. There are four revolvers and four rifles in sight. How many small weapons there are in concealment it is impossible to tell, but the reader can be pretty certain that Mrs. Devil Anse and Mrs. Cap, in the background, and the two youngsters in the foreground are as well prepared for emergencies as their relatives. It was only a short time after this picture was taken that one of these youngsters tried to murder a deputy sheriff who had cornered his father, Cap Hatfield, who was a fugitive from justice, having escaped from the jail at Williamson. The youngster came pretty near succeeding in his purpose.
After Cap Hatfield escaped from jail in July, 1897, he made for Devil Anse's old home on Tug River, near the mouth of Peter Creek, where he was joined by the others who are shown in the picture. Some fifteen miles away, at a small settlement, a photographer had set up an establishment and he drove out to the Tug River cabin to get a picture of the Hatfields. The Hatfields received him decently enough, but refused to allow him to take a picture at first. Cap was particularly vehement in his objections, but Devil Anse was good-natured about the matter. He knew that he and Cap and other members of the family had had cameras snapped at them during visits to West Virginia towns time and again, and he finally got the whole crowd together and told the photographer to fire away.
The result was the picture here shown. The photographer took the plate away, promising to send back a set of the pictures. The next day Cap Hatfield was in an ugly mood. He cursed Devil Anse, himself and everybody else for sitting for a photograph, particularly at a time when officers were on his track, and, armed to the teeth, he set out for the settlement to do things to the photographer and his outfit. Now, of all the Hatfields, Cap is the most reckless and murderous. He, more than any other member of the family, with the possible exception of Ellison Mounts, is responsible for the killing and maltreating of women in the feud now supposed to be closed, and he is a scoundrel without morals or mercy. Killing is his pleasure, and there is no doubt in the world that he would have murdered that photographer if he'd ever caught him.
But Devil Anse looked out for that. With Elias, Trav and Joe he headed Cap off and sent him back to the cabin. All Hatfields have a way of doing what Devil Anse tells them to do, and even the bloodthirsty Cap is subservient to him. The old man told Cap that he'd see that none of the pictures were printed, and with his three younger sons he set out to keep his word.
The photographer declared on his solemn oath that he had sent the plate away to be developed. He was lying when he said it, and it was a good thing for him that it was Devil Anse and not Cap that he tried to fool. Anse and his boys found the plate and destroyed it. Then, as a lesson to the photographer, they smashed his cameras and wrecked his entire establishment. Then they went back to the cabin on Tug River.
But the photographer had struck off a proof before Devil Anse arrived. He toned this proof and made the picture shown here. It fell into the hands of the McCoys and one of them gave it to a travelling man who went through that region a short time ago. The cabin which is the background of the picture is deserted now and was practically deserted then. It was being used when the picture was taken as a hiding place for the fugitive Cap. It is over the fireplace in this cabin that the following, done in gaudy colors, has hung for years:
THERE IS NO PLACE LIKE OUR HOME.
Under this motto some wag wrote some years ago:
"Leastwise, not this side of hell."
Although the McCoys shed the first blood in the famous feud, the history of the affair shows no such atrocities credited to them as to the Hatfields. Anything more horrible than the revenge of Devil Anse and his sons for the murder of old Deacon Ellison Hatfield could not be imagined. The murder of Miss Allaphare McCoy by Ellison Mounts, who only committed the deed because he was quicker with his gun than Cap Hatfield, was the most dastardly crime of the whole feud and roused the whole country at the time. The McCoys have shot and killed, too, but there are no such terrible crimes against them as against the Hatfields, unless it be the murder of Deacon Ellison Hatfield, who was stabbed twenty-seven times in a claspknife duel with Talbot McCoy, and was beating his man when Farmer McCoy shot him in the back. And these two bewhiskered individuals in the picture, who would look like peaceful mountain farmers if it wasn't for their weapons, have been the chief actors in the crimes of the Hatfields. Deacon Ellison was always a peacemaker up to the time of that fight with Talbot McCoy.
In the language of a writer who has compiled some interesting facts about the feud, "the trouble all began over two long-nosed, razorbacked, elm-peeler hogs." Old Randolph McCoy lived on Pond Creek, in Pike county, Ky., and Deacon Ellison, Devil Anse and the rest of the Hatfields on the Logan county side of Tug River, West Virginia. Floyd Hatfield, a brother of Devil Anse, lived in Kentucky near Randolph McCoy. The McCoys accused Floyd Hatfield of stealing these two hogs, and the case came up for trial before Matthew Hatfield, who was a Justice of the Peace. Floyd Hatfield won the case and the hogs because he had the best witnesses.
Floyd's principal witness was old Bill Stayton, his brother-in-law. Stayton, with his son, young Bill, and several of the Hatfields were fishing in Tug River shortly after the trial when Randolph McCoy and two of his sons came along. Randolph opened up the hog question and finally called old man Stayton a perjurer, whereupon young Bill, who was only 18 years old, hit Randolph on the head with a stone. A few months later Parish and Sam McCoy murdered young Bill from ambush, but they were acquitted in a Kentucky court. The Hatfields were getting ready to do some killing themselves, when election day rolled around and the two families, being interested in the same candidate, patched up a peace which was kept for several years.
Johnson Hatfield, known as Jonce, was an outlaw in Kentucky at this time, and he opened up the bad feeling again by ruining Rose Ann McCoy, a daughter of Randolph McCoy. Then when Talbot and Farmer McCoy took advantage of their sister's intimacy with Jonce Hatfield to follow her to the outlaw's lair and arrest him in order to get the rewards offered for his capture, there was more trouble. Devil Anse, Cap, and the rest of the Hatfields, warned by Rose Ann, rescued Jonce from the McCoys, but the feeling was not allayed, and there would have been a heap of killing but for another election in which both families happened to be interested in the same candidate. The candidate was Thomas Stafford, a blood relation of the Hatfields and related by marriage to the McCoys, and on that election day the families declared peace once more, and sent down for buckets of moonshine in which to seal the compact.
It was on that day that Deacon Ellison was murdered, and only a few days later that Devil Anse and his sons took their revenge, that revenge being the most fearful tragedy of the feud. The McCoys and Hatfields drank moonshine to each other until they got to feeling ugly. Then Talbot McCoy remembered that young Elias, who is No. 2 in the picture, had once borrowed $1.75 from him and had failed to return it. Elias, who was a mere boy then, called Talbot a liar, and Talbot started to beat him. The sight of great, burly Talbot McCoy beating little Elias Hatfield was more than peaceful Deacon Ellison could stand. He drew a revolver and with Elias Hatfield, the youngster's uncle, went for Talbot. Farmer McCoy drew a pistol, and two constables, seeing trouble ahead, arrested Talbot and young Elias for fighting. All might have been well but for Deacon Ellison Hatfield. Too frequent indulgence in moonshine had changed him from a peacemaker to a troublemaker, and he denounced all the McCoys as scoundrels for pretending to make peace when they were really looking for fight. He called Talbot McCoy a coward for pitching into a boy and made a lunge at him with his knife. The constable who was holding McCoy let him go, and Talbot drew a knife, while the members of both families made a ring for the two men to fight it out.
Talbot McCoy sprang at the Deacon and plunged his knife into his side. The Deacon cut open his opponent's head and then the men fell apart. Ellison accidentally cut his own hand and dropping his knife he sailed into McCoy with his fists. Talbot stabbed him twenty-six times and then slipped and fell, with Deacon Ellison on top of him. The Deacon grabbed a heavy stone and in another moment would have crushed McCoy's head to a jelly, but at that moment Farmer McCoy shot him in the back, and then dropping his revolver ran up the road.
Then the constables asserted themselves, placing Farmer, who had been captured by Elias Hatfield and Talbot, under arrest. They also arrested Randolph McCoy, Jr., a mere boy, who was accused of stabbing Deacon Ellison in the legs during the fight. The prisoners were taken to John Hatfield's house, while the wounded man was taken care of by a neighbor. The news of the shooting of Deacon Hatfield brought a dozen Hatfields to John Hatfield's house, but the McCoys disappeared and made no attempt to rescue the prisoners.
The next day, while the constables were taking the prisoners to the Pikesville jail, they were met by Devil Anse and a lot of other Hatfields, who ordered the constables to take the prisoners to Blackberry Creek. On the way there Devil Anse took the prisoners away from the constables, tied them together with ropes, and drove them into West Virginia, where they were placed in a schoolhouse for safekeeping.
There Devil Anse told the prisoners that if Deacon Ellison died of his injuries they would be put to death. A lot of the McCoy women folks came and pleaded for mercy, but Devil Anse drove them all away. The prisoners suffered torture while in the schoolhouse, for the ropes that bound them were on so tight that the blood could not circulate.
When the news of Deacon Hatfield's death was brought to Devil Anse he conveyed it to the prisoners, and they broke down and wept. That night the Hatfields drove them down the road, still bound with ropes, and over the line into Kentucky. Farmer McCoy, who had fainted, was restored to consciousness, and then the march was resumed until the spot selected by Devil Anse was reached. Here the prisoners were thrown to the ground, then raised on their knees and tied in that position to some bushes. Talbot McCoy, who had asked to be allowed to face his executioners, was turned the other way, while Farmer was made to look into the weapons of his murderers. The boy Randolph was tied facing the others, and then Devil Anse yelled to Wall Hatfield that all was ready and that he was to give the word when to fire.
"Take aim. Fire!" yelled Wall, and every man discharged his weapon. Talbot and Farmer were killed instantly. No shot was fired at the boy. His punishment was to see his relatives die.
After the shooting the Hatfields started back for West Virginia, but they hadn't gone far when one of them objected to leaving the boy Randolph alive. It was dangerous, he said, as the boy knew every one of them and might send them all to the gallows.
"Go back, then," said Devil Anse, and this man went back and blew the top of the lad's head off with a shotgun. Back in West Virginia Devil Anse gathered his men around him and made them all swear a solemn oath never to reveal the night's doings under penalty of death.
It was some time after this that Cap Hatfield and Tom Wallace went to the cabin of Bill Daniels and horsewhipped Mrs. Daniels and her daughter, who was Wallace's wife, until they were insensible because they suspected them of having informed the McCoys of an intended raid into Kentucky. Mrs. Daniels died some time after as the result of this beating. Mrs. Wallace recovered. There were a number of killings between this affair and the murder of Allaphare McCoy, the most notable one being the murder of Jeff McCoy, one of the most peaceable of the McCoys, who was lured to his death by Devil Anse through base treachery.
The McCoys made a determined effort to bring some of the Hatfields to justice for their crimes and came pretty near succeeding. This infuriated the Hatfields and their revenge was the raid in which Allaphare McCoy was so brutally murdered. It was on a New Year's night that the Hatfields went to old Randolph McCoy's house and called upon him to surrender. In the house were Randolph and his wife, his son Calvin, Rose Ann, Cap Hatfield's former mistress and her little boy Melvin, of whom Cap was the father. They were in the west end of the house. In the east end were Allaphare, Addie and Fanny McCoy, daughters of Randolph, and Cora McCoy, the orphan daughter of Talbot.
Failing to get any response from Randolph, Cap Hatfield, Ellison Mounts and some of the others broke open the door at the other end of the house. Allaphare McCoy came out in her night dress and protested that there were no men in that part of the house.
"Light the fire or I'll shoot you," yelled Cap.
"Cap, I can't," cried the girl, putting her hands to her face. "I have no light. Don't kill me, Cap, I never done you any harm."
"Kill her," said Jim Vance, Devil Anse's brother-in-law.
Cap raised his gun, but before he could shoot Ellison Mounts fired, and the girl fell dead with a bullet in her heart. In the fight that followed a few minutes later Calvin McCoy was killed and all of the McCoy women were injured. Old Randolph escaped, however.
There were raids innumerable after that, some by the McCoys, some by officers of the law, but most of them by the Hatfields. The feud went on despite the efforts of the authorities to stop it, until March 1891, when it was declared off. Peace lasted until February, 1895, when a Hatfield adherent named Culler killed Henry Chafflin of the McCoy clan with a chunk of coal. That reopened the feud, and it raged up to the time of the wedding of Mary McCoy and Aaron Hatfield.
The last big row occurred on election day, 1896. Cap Hatfield came into Matewan with a rifle, a shotgun, and two pistols. He cast his vote, imbibed a lot of moonshine whiskey, then went out in the street, and, running across Rutherford McCoy, shot him dead. Walking up the street he ran across Henderson Chambers, a McCoy man, and mortally wounded him. Then with his 12-year-old boy he cleared out, closely pursued by Rutherford McCoy, Jr. The latter took a shot at Cap as he ran, and the bullet grazed Hatfield's hand. Wheeling around, Cap dropped to his knee, took careful aim, and put a bullet through young Rutherford's heart.
Cap was captured a few days later and put in the Williamson jail. He was convicted of manslaughter and served three months. Then he escaped from the jail and is to-day a free man. The most remarkable thing about the feud as it stands to-day is the unwillingness of the West Virginia authorities to punish any of the Hatfields for their crimes. They are afraid of reopening the feud. For just as sure as a Hatfield is arrested and prosecuted the rest of the Hatfields will blame it on the McCoys and a raid will follow. The McCoys have repeatedly sought for revenge through the courts, while the Hatfields have always settled differences with their guns. The Hatfields always regard the McCoys with suspicion, and if there is fresh trouble it will be because some of the McCoys are caught trying to set the machinery of justice going.
1. —— Dameron, a relative of the Hatfields and an "outlaw." 2. Elias Hatfield, son of "Devil Anse." 3. Son of "Cap" Hatfield. 4. Troy Hatfield, son of "Devil Anse." 5. "Devil Anse" Hatfield. 6. Mrs. "Devil Anse." 7. Mrs. "Cap" Hatfield. 8. Joe Hatfield, son of "Devil Anse." 9. Son of "Cap" Hatfield. 10. "Cap" Hatfield. 11. Supposed to be Ellison Mounts.