As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

July 1893

6 articles

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A 1893 Pikeville letter reprinted in the New York Press claims the long Hatfield-McCoy feud was permanently settled by the secret marriage of Frank Hatfield and Hattie McCoy, two years after they began corresponding without their families' knowledge. It recaps the feud's origins, from a dispute over hogs to the romance between Johnson Hatfield and Rose Ann McCoy, and mentions the earlier execution of Ellison Mounts.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Richmond Dispatch · 9 July 1893 · page 2

END OF A GREAT FEUD THE HATFIELDS AND McCOYS MADE FRIENDS BY A MARRIAGE.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Published after the feud's declared end, this long retrospective narrates its mythic origins—hog disputes, a forbidden romance between Johnson Hatfield and Rose Anna McCoy, and escalating bloodshed culminating in the killing of three McCoy brothers. It frames the violence as rooted in clashing notions of family honor across two warring mountain clans.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 9 July 1893 · page 2

SHE BLINDLY BETRAYED HER LOVER

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The report retells older feud legends, including a torture-killing of a McCoy relative, then describes the New Year's Night 1888 raid on Randolph McCoy's home, in which Ellaphare (Alifair) McCoy was shot dead and the house burned. It claims Mrs. McCoy was also shot during the attack.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 38 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 133 days earlier.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 9 July 1893 · page 2

A SUCCESSION OF MURDERS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

The Breckenridge News · Cloverport, Ky.

The report claims the Hatfield-McCoy feud was permanently settled by the marriage of Frank Hatfield and a McCoy woman, arranged secretly over two years by the younger generation. It also recaps the feud's origins, from a dispute over hogs to the Johnson Hatfield-Roseanna McCoy affair and the capture of outlaw 'Jonce' Hatfield.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Breckenridge News · 19 July 1893 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

END OF THE GREAT FUED. HATFIELDS AND M'COYS MADE FRIENDS BY A MARRIAGE.

The True Story of the Quarrel is Herewith Given in Detail.

See moreSee less

The Execution of Ellison Mounts in Kentucky.

The McCoy-Hatfield fued, which for years has drenched the mountains of Kentucky and West Virginia with blood, has been permanently settled. Several times during the existence of the terrible strife reports of a similar nature have been circulated, only to be followed by outbreaks more bitter than before, until each faction has looked upon advances of friendly character as merely a part of a concerted plan to secure an advantage in the mountain war. Peace was the result of the marriage of Frank Hatfield and Hattie McCoy, representatives of the younger element of both factions. They met in a log schoolhouse in the wilds of the Kentucky mountains several weeks ago. The place was selected owing to its isolated location and because it was an equal distance removed from the homes of the two factions. About a dozen representatives of both families were present. For two years the young couple had been corresponding without the knowledge of their families and through their advances and the efforts of mutual friends the mountain fued is ended forever.

BUT THE FRIENDLY

arrangements came after years of fierce warfare, in which many lives have been sacrificed by both factions in order that their peculiar ideas of family honor might be maintained with becoming dignity. The first quarrel between the families was about two hogs. This was amicably settled after only one man had been killed. The second trouble was caused by a wayward girl. Pretty Rose Ann McCoy, daughter of old Rand'l, loved stalwart Johnson Hatfield, a son of Bad Anse. They did not bother with a marriage ceremony. "Jonce" was an outlaw in Kentucky. He had at that time been indicted twenty-seven times. The crimes, however, were not venal in Kentucky or West Virginia eyes He had merely made a practice of bringing moonshine whisky across the border. Talbot McCoy, Rose's brother, was made a deputy and set out to catch Jonce. He captured him by following his sister on one of her visits to her lover. She slipped away and gave the alarm. Then Bad Anse Hatfield gathered a posse and rescued the prisoner. After that Rose Ann lived with her lover at war with her family, until the lover kicked her out and her family took her back. In 1882 a political rally made the two factions friends again until too much whisky got into the politics. Deacon Ellison Hatfield and Talbot McCoy fought a duel with knives. It was

A HORRIBLE AFFAIR.

Claims of foul play were made by both sides. Finally a McCoy onlooker shot and badly wounded Ellison Hatfield during the duel. Three McCoys were arrested. The Hatfields took them away from the officers and carried them (among the prisoners was a little boy) into West Virginia. Bad Anse Hatfield led the gang. Talbot McCoy's young wife, with a baby in her arms, went on her knees to Anse to plead for her husband's life; but the Hatfield leader could not be moved. He sat with his revolver in his hand waiting for news from Ellison. If Ellison died then he would kill the McCoys. Ellison died the next day. The McCoys were taken into the woods and tied to trees by their throats. Then the two men were shot down. The little boy was at first spared. Afterward a Hatfield went back and killed him. While the McCoy faction was in a way cowed by the triple murder the Hatfields appear to have been incited to further deeds of violence.

A SUCCESSION OF MURDERS.

Until 1884 no one was killed. Then Anse Hatfield planned a surprise on three McCoys whom he knew would pass along a certain road about dusk. Three men appeared, and they were fired on, one being killed and two badly hurt, but they were not the McCoys. Anse was angry at having been deceiven into killing the wrong men. He thought that a Mrs. Daniel and her daughter had warned the McCoys- Several nights later, Bad Anse Hatfield and Tom Wallace suddenly ter. [illegible] the Daniels cabin. Bill Dan compelled to[o]k into a cocked Winches[ter] dragged by their [s]leep quiet. He was their night clothes and b[a]nd daughter sible. The beating was done beds in bone end of a cow's tail, which Cap [illegible] cut from the animal in the stable of his victims. A year later "one of the women" died from the terrible beating, and the other is a cripple for life. After that

Bill Daniels joined Rand'l's men in revenge. A brother of Mrs. Daniels was tied with a rope to a saddle a few days afterward, and driven like a hog down

Grapevine creek toward the Daniels home

[whe]re he was to be killed in sight of his [door]. As they neared the point the

[th]ought he saw a chance to slip [a rope] around his neck. The Hat[field learned] great satisfaction, that [the] [illegible]an. [illegible]OOK [illegible]g, plunged [h]igh into shore. Then the Hatfields kneeled down and deliberately began firing with their Winchesters at his head. The fugitive was permitted to reach the opposite bank. Just as he thought himself safe, Anse cried, "Now." The next moment the fugitive dropped back into the river with three Winchester balls in his head. The Hatfields had been playing with him. They could have killed him the first fire, but there was more fun in waiting. This is one of the stories much enjoyed to this day in Hatfield circles. Then some Hatfield sympathizers were captured and taken to the Pike county (Ky.) jail. This made the Hatfields "right mad" and incited that faction to a sort of revenge that horrified the people of both states. On the New Year's night following there were at Randolph McCoy's home besides himself and wife their son, Calvin and Rosa Ann's seven-year-old boy, Melvin, and Allaphare, Addie and Fanny McCoy, Old Rand'l's daughters. About midnight the inmates were roused by a

GANG OF HATFIELDS.

Old Rand'l made no reply to the Hatfields' order to surrender. The door was first shot full of holes, then five men of the Hatfield gang used a log as a battering ram and tore the door from its hinges. Miss Allaphare, hearing Cap Hatfield's voice, and remembering that they had been sweethearts once, sprang to the door in her night clothes to appeal to him. As the girl appeared, Cap, from behind a tree ten yards distant, raised his rifle to fire. "You wouldn't shoot me, Cap," observed the girl calmly, but without attempting to retreat. Then Ellison Mounts shot the girl down while she continued to plead for her mother and sisters. In the meantime the house has been fired in several places, and the women told to run out and try to escape to the woods. Mrs. McCoy was shot ten feet from the house. As she was supposed to be dead she was not shot again. An effort was made to have the perpetrators of this out- rage extradited. It failed, and a proba- bly illegal posse crossed the border in search of them. They killed old Uncle Jim Vance; captured Wall Hatfield and Doc and Sam Mayhorn; killed Andy Var- ney and Bill Dempsey, and finally cap- tured Ellison Mounts. THE EXECUTION OF ELLISON MOUNTS.

The prisoners were taken into Kentucky and lodged in the Pike county jail. All went to the penitentiary for long terms except Ellison Mounts. He was convicted of the murder of the McCoy girl. Feb- 18, 1890, was the date fixed for the exe- cution. The Hatfields swore that Mounts should never hang. One hundred of the McCoy faction assembled and escorted the prisoner to a small valley surrounded by mountain peaks near the scene of his crime. A desperate fight was expected, and, with cocked rifle in the hands of his executioners, Ellison Mounts was swung off. Bad Anse explained that the proposed rescue failed because the boys were kinder tired of killing McCoys, "and if I could just shoot that —— Phillip and Ole Rand'l, I'd go to the gallows just as peert as I ever went to dinner," he observed.

A year ago Frank Philip was shot at a dozen times by the Hatfields while he was on West Virginia soil in one of his daring attempts to arrest members of the gang single-handed. The last victim of the fued was Cap Hatfield. The circumstances surrounding his death have never been made clear. He was shot during last Christmas week, near Tug river. Anse says it was the result of a quarrel with some of his friends over a game of cards, but others assert that the murder was indirectly due to the terrible mountain fued.

See the clipping

The Breckenridge News · Cloverport, Ky.

This 1893 article retells the feud's history from the hog dispute through the Johnson Hatfield–Roseanna McCoy affair to the 1882 election-day killings of Ellison Hatfield and three McCoys. It claims a young boy was among those captured, spared, then later killed by a Hatfield.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 28 days later.

Wrong

The Breckenridge News · 19 July 1893 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Breckenridge News · Cloverport, Ky.

This report recounts earlier atrocities including a tortured killing by cow's-tail whipping and the taunting river execution of a fugitive, framed explicitly as a tale 'enjoyed in Hatfield circles.' It then describes the New Year's Night raid on Randolph McCoy's home, including the shooting of Alifair McCoy, the burning of the house, and the posse's cross-border manhunt that killed Jim Vance and captured Wall Hatfield and the Mahon brothers.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 10 days earlier.

The Breckenridge News · 19 July 1893 · page 1

A SUCCESSION OF MURDERS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come