Weekly Courier-Journal · 24 February 1890 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
DEATH BY LAW.
The Murder of Alla-phare McCoy To Be Expiated.
See moreSee less
A Dramatic Story of a Midnight Raid and the Slaughter of a De-fenseless Girl.
DEEDS OF MOUNTAIN BANDITTI.
ELLISON MOUNTS, ALIAS HATFIELD. (From a photograph taken in the jail.) Pikeville, Ky., Feb. 17.--(Special.)--This morning everything was as quiet in this little mountain city as could be expected, considering that on to-morrow will take place the first hanging that has occurred in this county for perhaps forty years.
To-morrow a procession consisting of the guard, officers and Ellison Mounts will leave the jail of Pike county for the scaffold, which has been erected about half a mile from the jail and court-house where Ellison Mounts will be executed for the murder of Miss Allaphare McCoy, on the night of January 1, 1888, at the humble home of her father, Randolph McCoy, on Blackberry creek, about thirty miles from this place.
The story of the crimes of the gang of which Ellison Mounts was a member would fill a volume. The atrocities of the aboriginal savage, with whom Boone and his contemporaries contended in these same mountains more than one hundred years ago, do not surpass the crimes of "Devil Anse" Hatfield and his gang. Frequently the public has been furnished with descriptions of the McCoy-Hatfield feud, and it is not necessary here to give a full detail of all the actions of this mountain banditti. It will suffice to give a brief history of the life and crimes of Ellison Mounts, who is on to-morrow, according to his statement, is going to change a state of sorrow and grief for one of unending joy in the Paradise of God.
On every afternoon for more than a week services have been held in the jail. Rev. J. W. Glover, pastor of the M. E. church, South, at this place, and who is also the jail physician, is standing nobly by the condemned man, and will accompany him to the scaffold and there will sing a song and offer prayer. The other services, consisting of the reading of a portion of the Scriptures and perhaps a short discourse by Dr. Glover, will be held at the jail. Mounts says he is prepared to die.
Mounts has been ill for several days. He refuses to talk to anyone about his case or his past history, although your correspondent has gained sufficient facts from reliable sources to warrant the following statement concerning his life and crimes:
A man about six feet, or perhaps an inch over in height, weighing when in health, perhaps 185 pounds; with very light hair and dull gray eyes. Such is Ellison Mounts as he appears to a casual observer. Nothing very striking in his appearance, is the first decision; but on closer inspection of features you will find the traits of a very fiend plainly discernable. A high, narrow forehead, prominent cheek-bones, broad, vulgar mouth, a nervous, twiching chin, all marks of a character bereft of the finer sensibilities.
Ellison Mounts is now about twenty-five years of age, and is the illegitimate son of the good Deacon Ellison Hatfield, who was the first victim of the feud proper, who was killed on August election day in 1882. Mounts' early boyhood was spent in the usual pursuits of a rude, unrully boy, in fishing, hunting, roving about the neighborhood and engaging with boon companions in Sabbath-breaking, petty pilfering, and all the multifarious pursuits known to the average ungoverned country boy. His father was a "Hard-shell" Baptist preacher. His training in "book-learning" was very limited. He can read, and write a little, which constitutes his stock of education. His education in vice seems to have been very thorough; and when at the age of seventeen he saw his father killed he was ripe for bloodshed. His first participation in murder was on the night following the death of Deacon Ellison Hatfield, his father, who died from the effects of the wounds received on August election day, 1882, at the hands of Talbot, Farmer and "Little Bud" McCoy. Immediately after the fight in which Deacon Hatfield received his wounds, the three McCoys were arrested—young Randolph McCoy, however, being taken for "Little Bud"—and, early the next morning, the guard with the prisoners started for Pikeville, a distance of about thirty miles. They had not proceeded very far, when they were intercepted by "Old Devil Ance" Hatfield, a brother of the wounded man, who relieved the guard—being accompanied by Ellison Mounts and about ten others—and took the McCoys back to West Virginia, to a place near where the wounded man had been carried. On Wednesday afternoon, Deacon Hatfield
CAPT. HATFIELD.
died, and, shortly after dusk, "Devil Ance," with his crowd, took the three McCoy boys across to the Kentucky side, tied them to paw-paw bushes and there, in the darkness of night, brutally murdered them. Mounts confesses that he was in the crowd, and assisted in the shooting.
The next murder in which Mounts participated occurred in June, 1884. It will be remembered that when the McCoy boys were murdered in 1882, Talbot McCoy was a man of some property, and married. Of course, an administrator must be appointed, and who so well-fitted to settle up the estate as his brother Calvin? In order to do this work it was necessary to bring some suits, and the cases were der were to be tried before a Justice of the Peace on the Tug river, near the scenes of the bloody massacree of 1882. The Hatfield gang, of which Ellison Mounts was still an active member, formed a plan to murder Randolph McCoy, the father of the murdered boys, and Calvin, the administrator, as they should return from the trial. By a mistake they fired on some innocent and unconcerned parties, slightly wounding one and seriously injuring the other.
The most heinous crime of the series, and the one for which Mounts is to hang, is the murdering in cold blood of a defenseless girl.
On New Year's night of 1888 there were at Randolph McCoy's house, besides himself and wife, his son Calvin and Rose Ann's little boy Melvin, all of whom were in the westerly end of the house. In the other end were Allaphare, Addie and Fanny McCoy, daughters of Randolph, and young women grown, besides little Cora, the orphan daughter of Talbot.
Shortly after midnight they were awakened by a gang of Hatfields, who called on old Rand'l' to surrender or they would burn his house over his head. The gang was headed by Uncle Jim Vance, who had hitherto kept out of the trouble and was got into it by a circumstance which illustrates the morals of these mountaineers very well. Uncle Jim's sister was the wife of Bad Anse.
With Vance were Cap Hatfield, Jonce Hatfield, Bob Hatfield, a younger son of Cap; Elliott Hatfield, son of Ellison; Ellison Mounts, French Ellis, Tom Gillespie and Tom Mitchell.
Gillespie and Elliott Hatfield were posted as sentinels up and down the road. The other seven attacked the house.
Old Rand'l' made no answer to the demand to surrender, and an effort was made to break in his door. The door was barred. Then the gang attacked the other end, where the girls were, and broke in their door, and jumped back lest a man should be inside and shoot out.
Allaphare, the oldest girl, went to the door and told them no man was in there.
"Stir a light," ordered Jim Vance, and Allaphare went to the fireplace and tried to build a fire. But the coal was out, and there was neither wood nor match to light a fire. Allaphare returned the men why she could make no fire. The men broke out in a tor- rent of profanity, and Cap Hatfield
ALLAPHARE M'COY. swore he would shoot her if she did not at once make a fire in the fireplace. She recognized his voice, and said, holding up her hands and bursting into tears: "Cap, I can't; I would, indeed, I would, if I could. You wouldn't shoot a woman who never did you any harm, would you?" "What the hell are you parleying with her for?" yelled Uncle Jim. "God—— her, make no more account of her than you would of a man. Shoot her, —— her." Cap raised his gun, but Ellison Mounts had his gun already at his shoulder, and shot the girl down as she stood there in her nightgown. The ball entered just over the left breast, and she fell back dead with only a moan.
JUDGE RICE. Then one of the gang, who had found a bag of cotton between the two houses, brought a handful of it, set it on fire and threw it into the room. By its light they could see that no man was concealed in the room, and they were, therefore, safe to put all their forces on the other end.
A part of them had already been engaged there. They had shot the southerly door to pieces, so that a determined rush would have broken it open, but a rush of that sort was what no Hatfield has the courage to make.
One of the gang, however, brought burning cotton and piled it against the door, but Mrs. McCoy had been churning the night before and had four gallons of buttermilk in churn. The old man took a tin cup and sitting down near the door dipped milk on the fire with one hand and held a revolver ready to shoot with the other.
Then they tried to fire the roof. Tom Mitchell climbed up the logs, and with one hand over the top log held a blazing torch against the clapboards. The old man saw the hand and, putting his revolver as close to it as possible, shot all four fingers off close to the knuckle. Cap tells gleefully to this day how Tom "cried like a baby over the loss of his fingers."
Calvin had not been idle all this time. He had mounted to the attic, and, kicking off the gable boards, and here and there a clapboard from the roof, had opened port holes through which he got several shots at the gang. One ball passed lengthwise through Ellison Mount's left forearm, soon after he had killed Allaphare, but it was from a thirty-two-caliber rifle, and did not make a permanent injury. However, Calvin drove the gang under the porch on the south side of his end of the building and between the buildings, and there they were secure. Calvin kicked off roof boards and strove to remove a part of the roof of the porch, but in vain. From their retreat under the porch the gang kept up a fire on the door, and, at the same time, kept applying torches to the house roof, while one or two others fired the roof successfully at the end where the girls were, and it began to get very warm for Calvin.
While the men were fighting, the old mother of the murdered girl had taken advantage of a lull in the shooting to slip out of the door facing the road to go around where the girls were. She had heard the other girls scream that Allaphare had been shot. As she went out the door Jonce Hatfield fired at a form on the bed, and the bullet cut the quilt over his own son. This story is told by the Hatfield crowd as one of the jokes of the feud. It would have been a good one on Jonce, Cap says, if he'd killed his own bastard.
CALVIN M'COY.
Mrs. McCoy started around to the door of the other part of the house. As she passed the space between the houses Jim Vance ordered her back with an oath and raised his gun with a threat to shoot her.
"I saw it was wrong end to for that," Mrs. McCoy said, when telling of it, "and kept on. But he struck me in the side with it and knocked me down. It broke two ribs. Pretty soon I got on my hands and knees. I felt so weak I couldn't get up, and so crawled on. Some one with a pistol got before me. 'For the Lord's sake, let me go to my girl,' I said. 'Go back, damn you, or I'll kill you,' he said. 'Oh,' I said, 'she's dead. For the love of the Lord, let me go to her,' and then I put out my hand. I could almost touch her feet as she lay there, and I could see her blood where it had run out of the door. Oh, my God! my God!"
In her grief in telling of the horrors of that night, the mother forgets what happened to herself as she put out her hand. The man who stopped her was Jonce Hatfield, and he struck her a blow with his revolver on the head that drove the hammer to the skull and left her senseless. They supposed she was dead.
It was not long after this before the fire drove Calvin from the attic. He said to the old man that he should strive to reach a corn crib about one hundred yards away across the yard to the northwest. From that point he could cover the retreat of of the old man, and both might then cross the fork and reach the woods. MR. AND MRS. RANDOLPH M'COY.
while they did not notice him. He With a box of cartridges in one hand and his rifle in the other Calvin leaped from the door and ran across the yard. As he cleared the corner of the house where the gang could see him they opened fire. It was a regular roar, and it roused the old man to action, and he followed. Calvin was by this time twenty-five yards away, in the shadow of some trees, and almost safe, but a bullet pierced his brain and he fell dead, unknown even to those who shot him.
The gang had spread out from their retreat at the west end of the house, where they had gone as Calvin came down the ladder, and as the old man sprang out he saw them before him, leveled a double-barreled shot gun at Jonce Hatfield and shot him in the right shoulder, and Jonce fell. Then he saw Tom Mitchell before him and fired. The shot pierced Tom's cartridge belt and entered the flesh of the abdomen, but the wounds, on account of the thickness of the belt, were of little account.
Then the firing at the old man began, and he ran the best he could and escaped untouched. He reached the corn crib, and from thence passed on up the mountain on the other side of the fork to JONCE HATFIELD AND HIS WIFE.
the woods. He was dressed in shirt and drawers only, and it was a very cold night. Had he not been lucky enough to find some hogs sleeping against some hay in an old barn on the next farm, he would probably have died from exposure. He routed the hogs out, and got into the bed they had left.
After the men left the house and the firing ceased the girls Addie and Fanny, finding the roof falling in, ventured to leave the house. They saw the gang just turning a point of the mountain on the road to Tug river. Then they picked up their dead sister, and, followed by the little orphan Cora, they dragged the body to the edge of the woods to the southwest of the house, and there built a fire and cowered down by it. Their mother had by this time revived enough to crawl after them as they drew the body of Allaphare away from the burning building. Little Melvin ran out at the time his grandfather did, and was clutching the old man's leg, but he tripped and fell at the door, and then crawled away around another corner of the house and was unnoticed. The women remained by the fire until morning without clothes or assistance.
On the morning of January 2, the family was cared for and sent to Pikeville. The old man and Jim and Sam came on ahead. The neighbors prepared Allaphare and Calvin for the grave, and buried them on the mountain side with their dead brothers. The graves are plainly seen from the road. They are surrounded by an old rail fence after the fashion of the country, and shaded by a peach tree that will not live to bear fruit another year.
The old farm is let to a tenant, and is rapidly going to ruin.
Such was the life of Ellison Mounts—that is, these were the capital crimes in which he participated before he was twenty-three years of age. Numerous minor crimes and misdemeanors he ha[s] been known to commit, and God only knowns the amount of sin and crime and wrong-doing he has engaged in that has never been brought to light.
A leading spirit in all these murders was Valentine Hatfield, a Justice of the Peace in Logan county, West Virginia, and a man of considerable local influence at the time the feud burst forth. He was a brother to Deacon Ellison Hatfield, who was the first victim of tho feud. At any time during the whole reign of terror he could have stopped the matter. But he was not built that way. He was director general of all the murders which the gang engaged in. When, in last September, he was sentenced to the penitentiary he informed the court that he "had been euchred out of his life and liberty."
The scene in the court when "Wall" Hatfield, Alex Messur, Doc and Plyant Mayhorn were sentenced to the penitentiary, was ridiculous and pitiful.. The Mayhorn boys merely maintained their innocence. "Wall" Hatfield censured the prosecuting attorneys, the witnesses, the jury and every influence. that aided in his conviction. When the court came' to that part of the sentence "confined at hard labor for the period of your natural life," in sentencing Alex Messur, he interrupted the Judge, saying: "It's mighty little work I can do, Judge, hain't bin able to work none of any 'count for several years."
When Ellison Mounts was brought into court, Judge Rice's countenance was most solemn. Judge Rice, it will be remembered, presided at the trial of, and passed sentence upon, Wm. Neal and Ellis Craft. of the Ashland horror. In sentencing Mounts his manner was very gentle, his language kind and his tones pitying; while the very spirit of compassion beamed from his countenance. More than once while pronouncing sentence did the Judge pause in order to regain control of his emotion. Outwardly Mounts was unmoved, and only said: "Judge, I was forced to go and do them crimes."
While W. H. Maynard is Sheriff of the county, the execution will be directed by Deputy Sheriff Harry Widdington, of Pikeville. At present everything points to a very orderly execution.
Louisa, Ky., Feb. 19.—(Special.)—Advice from Pikeville state that the execution of Ellis Mounts for the murder of vice Alafair McCoy was done according to law and without any interference from any source whatever.
For some days previous to the hanging the Sheriff had on duty a guard of fifty men, armed with Winchester rifles, in addition to about twenty special deputies appointed for the occasion. There was no particular reason to anticipate interference from Mounts' friends, but the Sheriff took the necessary caution to meet and repel any effort that might be made to prevent his execution.
From all accounts there was assembled the largest crowd that such an occasion ever brought together in the State, the throng of visitors being estimated by careful observers at from four to eight thousand.
About two miles from the Court-house, at the base of a low hill, the scaffold, from which Ellis Mounts was to take his last view of the sunlight, was erected. The great throng moved rapidly and soon covered the hill-top which afforded a magnificent view of the place where the last work was to be done.
A few moments after 12 o'clock the Sheriff appeared at the jail with the death warrant, which was read to the condemned man in a low, coarse voice, who seemed to listen to it without any apparent emotion. Religious services were conducted by the Rev. Dr. Glover, of the M. E. Church South.
The prisoner said, in a strong, firm voice, that he had no speech to make, but that he was ready to die, and he hoped that all of his friends would be good men and women, and meet him in heaven.
At six minutes to 1 o'clock the black cap was adjusted, the trap was sprung and the last of Ellis Mounts was dangling between heaven and earth, and was a sight that caused a shriek to go up from all parts of the crowd, which indicated that many were painfully affected.
After hanging ten minutes, the attending physician pronounced him dead, and the body was cut down and subsequently viewed by hundreds of curious people, and then turned over to his friends.