As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

July 1889

20 articles

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Frank Phillips, a member of the Hatfield-McCoy feud party wanted in West Virginia, went on a rampage with a rifle and revolver near Grundy, Va., pistol-whipping attorney Wm. Reiser. While a bystander tried to stop him, Phillips shot and killed Reiser before fleeing to the mountains.

Evening Star · 12 July 1889 · page 6

An Attorney Killed

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A dispatch reports that Frank Phillips, a wanted member of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, went on a rampage in Grundy, pistol-whipping attorney William Kaiser and then fatally shooting him when a bystander tried to intervene. The report notes no arrests had been made and that Phillips had fled to the mountains.

The Morning News · 12 July 1889 · page 1

KILLED IN COLD BLOOD.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Capital · Annapolis, Md.

Frank Phillips, described as a member of the Hatfield-McCoy gang, went on a drunken rampage in Grundy, Virginia, threatening to tear up the town. He pistol-whipped and then shot dead prominent lawyer William Keiser before riding off, with no attempt yet made to capture him.

Evening Capital · 12 July 1889 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Frank Phillips, described as part of the Hatfield-McCoy gang with a large reward on his head, is reported to have shot and killed attorney William Keiser. The report notes much excitement and that Phillips fled to the mountains.

Evening Tribune · 12 July 1889 · page 1

A Bad Man.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A special telegram reports that Frank Phillips, a wanted member of the Hatfield-McCoy feud faction, pistol-whipped and then fatally shot attorney Wm. Keyser at Grundy, Virginia after making threats against local citizens. Phillips reportedly fled to the mountains and remains at large, defying arrest.

Wheeling Register · 12 July 1889 · page 1

PHILLIPS' DEADLY AIM / ANOTHER UNPROVOKED MURDER AMONG THE HATFIELD-McCOY PEOPLE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

Frank Phillips, the Kentucky deputy who led McCoy raids into West Virginia, got into a quarrel with William Keyser, a Hatfield relative, in Tazewell County and shot him dead. Phillips, already blamed for killing several men during the raids, fled into the mountains and was not expected to be captured.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 13 July 1889 · page 1

ANOTHER VICTIM OF THE CELEBRATED HATFIELD McCOY FEUD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

The report claims a 9-year-old boy named Budd McCoy was responsible for an early stabbing that sparked the Hatfield-McCoy feud, while a Hatfield man was wrongly jailed for the crime. The story is framed as a little-known true account finally being told in print.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Pittsburg Dispatch · 15 July 1889 · page 8

THE STARTING POINT OF A FEUD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

This 1889 feature recounts the Hatfield-McCoy feud's background through the eyes of Budd McCoy, describing the large rival families, the hog lawsuit that started tensions, and the 1880 killing of Bill Staton. It sets up the story leading toward the 1882 election-day violence.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 15 July 1889 · page 8

ANOTHER BIG FAMILY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

This 1889 narrative recounts the 1882 Pike County election where Hatfields and McCoys gathered to support a mutual candidate, Thomas Stafford. A dispute over a small debt between Talbot McCoy and a Hatfield erupted into a fistfight, reigniting old animosities between the families.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 15 July 1889 · page 8

AN OLD-TIME ELECTION.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Somerset Herald · Somerset, Pa.

Kentucky Deputy Sheriff Frank Phillips, leader of the McCoy raids into West Virginia, killed William Keyser, a Hatfield relative, during a quarrel in Tazewell County. Phillips fled into the mountains and was expected to evade capture.

The Somerset Herald · 17 July 1889 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

A dispatch from Maysville, Kentucky reports that Alexander Messer, a Hatfield, is jailed for a murder actually committed by a boy named Bud McCoy, after officers mistakenly arrested the wrong person. The piece then recounts a 'late story' of the feud's origins, describing the Hatfield and McCoy families, their mountain warfare, and the killing of Bill Staton as background for young Bud McCoy's involvement.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 17 July 1889 · page 1

STARTLING STORY. An Incident of the Wild Kentucky Hatfield-McCoy Mountain Warfare.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

This narrative recounts how the Hatfield-McCoy feud began, including a lawsuit over hogs, the killing of Bill Staton, and the lead-up to the violent 1882 election-day confrontation in Pike County. It frames the story from young 'Rudd' McCoy's perspective, describing the family hatred and eventual brawl at the polling place.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Paper unidentified · 17 July 1889 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This human-interest piece, reprinted from the New York Sun, describes an arrest mistake involving a Hatfield man jailed for a killing actually tied to a 9-year-old McCoy boy nicknamed Budd. It digresses into extensive background on the large, intertwined McCoy and Hatfield families and their mountain community gatherings.

The Morning News · 18 July 1889 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

A BOY'S DOINGS IN A FEUD

ONLY 9 YEARS OLD, BUT WELL ABLE TO USE A KNIFE.

See moreSee less

An Incident in the Hatfield-McCoy War in the Mountains of Kentucky—It Was a Serious Case of Mistaken Identity.

From the New York Sun.

The arrest and imprisonment of Alexander Messer, one of the Hatfield faction, not long ago, for a murder committed in the course of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, recalls the fact that the crime which Messer committed was due to a mistake made by mountain officers in arresting a boy of 13 for a deed done by a boy of 9. The part which this boy—Budd McCoy—took in the feud has never been told in print.

Budd McCoy was 9 years old at the time to which reference is made in this story, and his home was on the Blackberry branch of Pond creek, in Pike county, Kentucky. It ougt to be said now that this is a true story, for otherwise the reader might think that the writer, in an attempt to be sensational, had drawn the long bow.

The McCoy family was a large one. Budd had eight brothers and six sisters, all of whom were older than he, some of them being m rried and having children quite as old as their uncle Budd. Besides these brothers and sisters, Budd had so many cousins living in Pike county that he couldn't for the life of him remember half their names, thoug he generally saw them all from two to three times a year, when they all went to the outdoor church gatherings, which in the mountains of Kentucky and West Virginia are called associations.

Over the state line in West Virginia was a family that consisted of no end of brothers and sisters, with cousins, also, just like the McCoys, whose name was Hatfield. Anderson Hatfield was the name of the father of this family, and Randolph McCoy was the fater of Budd. Between the McCoys and the Hatfields there was a deadly feud. As they say down there, the two families were at war, and that means that whenever three or four McCoys caught a Hatfield out by himself, they would hide in the brush on the mountain side and shoot him in the back, while the Hatfields were just as anxious to kill McCoys, and just as cowardly in their way of doing it.

In 1882, the year that Budd was 9 years old, but one man had been actually killed in this way. His name was Bill Sayton, and he was one of the cousins of the Hatfields. He had been waylaid by two of Budd's cousins and shot to death because he had once thrown a stone at Budd's father and knocked him down, and thus openly arrayed himself with the Hatfields. Little Budd knew all about the feud from the time it began, when his father sued one of the Hatfields for the value of two longnosed hogs and got beaten. He had listened to his father and older brothers as they discussed the chances of meeting the Hatfields and shooting them and getting shot by them, and the one thing that worried him most was that his father said he was too young yet to learn to shoot, and so he must wait an awful ti e, it seemed to him—two whole years—before he could hope to kill a Hatfield. However, he got a chance at one of them much quicker than he anticipated, and the revenge taken for the blood that he helped to shed was horrifying.

On the first Monday in August, 1882, there was a general election in Pike county, and among other candidates before the people was an elderly cousin of Budd, who wanted to be justice of the peace. Now it happened t at this man, who e name was Thomas Stafford, had married one of the Hatfield girls, and so was considered a member of that family, also. He was a discreet man, who had kept friendly with both families, and the consequence was that not only Budd's father and older brothers turned out on election day to help Mr. Stafford get elected, but the Hatfields, who lived in West Virginia, and who could not, of course, vote in Ke tucky, also came ove to the polls to work for the same end. Little Budd and his next older brother, Randolph, Jr., a lad of 13, both went to the election ground to play with the other boys sure to be there.

Up there in the mountains the elections are held in the open air. This time the judges of election had a table placed on the grass under a big beech tree over on Blackberry creek (on the branch Budd lived on), and the ballot box stood on the table before them. With the two families there interested in obtaining a common end, what easier than for a discreet man like Stafford to get them together, to shake hands and become friends again. It was done. But unfortunately there was no law against selling whisky there then, and in their excess of good feeling the Hatfields and McCoys all drank heartily from the same jug of moonshine whisky. All whisky is bad, at such gatherings, but moonshine is the worst sort, and to make matters still worse, when the jug of corn whisky was empty a jug full of mountain-made applejack took its place. The mixture made the men ugly.

After emptying the jug of applejack Talbot McCoy, one of Budd's grown-up brothers, was anxious for more, but had no money to buy it. Then he met one of the Hatfields who had borrowed $1 75 of him a long while before. Talbot asked for the money, and the next thing anybody noticed was the two men fighting. Immediately there was a rush made by the men about the polls, and the fighters were separated and arrested by two constables.

But the fight was destained to go on. A

McCoy had hit a Hatfield, and all the ill feeling that had existed between the families was aroused once more, and the truce which Stafford had brought about was forgotten. Deacon Ellison Hatfield, a brother of Anderson Hatfield, chief of the Hatfield faction, was the one to pick up the fight for his side. The deacon, in spite of his church office, had taken too much moonshine whisky and was anxious for a fight.

Drawing a big pocket knife, he opened the blade, and with many hard words called

Talbot McCoy a coward for pitching into one of the smallest of the Hatfields. The more he talked the angrier he got, and so, too, did Talbot, until finally the constable, who was holding Talbot, saw that the deacon was going to cut Talbot anyhow, and so concluded to get out of the way and let the two men fight it out.

The instant he was released, Talbot sprang back two steps, and with a quick motion drew a pocket knife and opened the blade. Then both men stooped a bit and jumped for each other with murder in their hearts, while the ring of eager mountaineers about them swayed to and fro as each one strove to see every move made. Talbot, who was the younger and quicker, drove his knife into the deacon's left side, missing a fatal wound only because the point of the knife struck a rib and glanced off. The deacon's knife descended on Talbot's head, slashing through the soft black hat and clear across the top of his head, laying open the scalp to the skull for over five inches.

At this the two separated and then closed in with a bound. Neither uttered a word or cry, although the Deacon's knife closed on his hand, cutting it half way across, so that he had to drop the weapon, while Talbot plied his stabbing the deacon again and again with the agility of an Italian desperado. But the decon, although mortally wounded, was a man of great strength and pluck, and closed in on his younger opponent, intending to throw him. Thereafter he had the advantage, for Talbot could no longer use his knife so well.

As the two men struggled from side to side, swaying first against one part of the ring and then another, the men of both families began to draw their weapons—here a pistol, there a knife. Squeezed in between two full grown men, with his head stretched eagerly forward, watching every movement, stood little Budd McCoy, with an open pocketknife clutched in his right hand. After a little the two fighters in their struggle half stopped in front of him, and in an instant he had reached out and plunged his knife repeatedly into the legs of Deacon Hatfield. Two of the blows were below the knee, but one was in the hip, and it was a deep cut for so small a hand to make.

Again the men struggled away, and again they got back before the boy, who plied his knife as before. This time he was seen by one of the Hatfields, who called a neighbor's attention to the act. But before they could do anything toward seeing fair play the Deacon, by a last desperate effort, threw Talbot McCoy to the ground, and, picking up a stone, raised it aloft to crush the skull of his enemy.

Among the spectators was Farmer McCoy, another brother of Talbot. He had drawn his pistol, as he said, to see fair play. Now he could stand the sight no longer, and shot the Deacon in the back.

That ended the fight. The deacon fell to the ground dying, while Farmer McCoy fled up the road with a lot of bullets from a Hatfield pistol flying past him, while young Budd threw his knife into the creek and slipped away unseen.

At the same moment Randolph McCoy, Jr., the boy of 13, came running up from a spring some hundred yards below, where he had been playing with a companion. He had heard the shooting and arrived just in time to see his brother, Farmer, arrested and brought back, and Talbot also arrested. Then the Hatfield who had seen Budd stabbing the deacon's legs pointed out Randolph to the officers and accused him of the crime of which little Budd was really guilty. It was an awful mistake, but a natural one. People could not be expected to distinguish between two small brothers in a family of fifteen.

Young Randolph, made wild by an intuition of his coming fate, an intuition that did not yet oppress his older brothers, protested his innocence, but his eagerness and fear only convinced the officers that he was guilty.

The officers kept the three prisoners in a house near by over night and next morning started for Pikeville to put them in jail to await trial. But they never got there. Old Anderson Hatfield, Deacon Ellison's brother —Bad Anse, he was and still is called—with a great mob of relatives and friends, took the prisoners from the officers and carried them over Fog river to West Virginia, and put them in a school house, there to await the result of the deacon's wounds.

Tho deacon had been carried over the river also, and lay in the house of Anderson Ferr ld, at the mouth of Mate creek. The school house where the prisoners were kept was half a mile away. The surgeon who was summoned found twenty-seven wounds in the deacons' body, one of which split his left lung half in two, and several others were as deadly, but still the wounded man did not die until Wednesday afternoon at 3 o'clock.

Meantime the prisoners were kept lying on the school house floor, bound with a rope so securely that their arms swelled to double size, and it was impossible for hem to rest or sleep. Hatfields, armed with all sorts of weapons, stood guard and discussed with each other the parts of the bodies of the prisoners that would be most painful when "shot full of lead." The mother of the p isoners and Talbot's wife, with a baby 4 months old in her arms, came to see them. There were tears and pleadings, such as might have melted the he rt of any one but a savage. But they were vain. The women were even brutally taunted with the fate these boys were to suffer. At last the hour arrived when the deacon ceased to breathe. A messenger on a mule rode madly up to the school house with the news, and then with cries like wild beasts many of the younger Hatfields ran around the school house peering through the cracks in the hope of getting a shot at the prisoners without endangering their own friends. But Valentine Hatfield, another brother of the deacon and a justice of the peace withal, stopped that by telling them to wait till light and then they could have their revenge.

Worn out by their long sufferings, the prisoners broke down and wept, but Talbot, who was, after all, a manly sort of a fellow for a mountaineer, soon recovered his composure. Turning to old Bad Anse and to Valentine Hatfield, he said:

"Gentlemen, when you shoot me I want you to look me in the face." Then he pleaded for the lad, Randolph. It appears that at this time both Bad Anse and his brother Valentine had been convinced that they had got the wrong one of the two little boys, and had determined to spare Randolph's life, but to teach him a lesson they meant to make him witness the death of his older brothers.

As night came on the prisoners were taken out of the school and driven down the road toward Tug river, the dividing line between Kentucky and West Virginia. As they reached the river, Farmer McCoy, overcome by fear, fainted and fell on the sand, but water was sprinkled on his face in order that he might be revived and realize his fate. The three were driven then over into Kentucky, and there, on the edge of the woods, were tied to some paw-paw bushes.

Talbot, who had remained silent and proud, was tied with his back to his executioners. Farmer, who was half dead with fear, was tied facing them, and the lad, little Randolph, was tied kneeling and facing his older brothers. Then the gang formed in line a few feet away, with their arms pointed at the two older brothers. Old Bad Anse shouted to his brother Valentine, who stood over on the Virginia side:

"All ready."

"Take aim, fire!" shouted Valentine.

There was a roar of guns and rifles, and Talbot and Farmer were no more. Their bodies were shot full of bullets.

The boy on his knees could only gasp with horror at the awful scene. The men formed in line and marched down the path a few rods on their way back across the river. Then one of the gang, named Alexander Messer, thought of the possibility of the boy becoming a witness against them should they ever be brought to trial for what they had done. Speaking to Bad Anse, who commanded the gang, he said:

"Dead men tell no tales."

"Go, you," said Bad Anse.

He obeyed. Loading both barrels of his shotgun with heavy charges of powder and rifle bullets, he went back. The boy did not notice him till he was but a few feet away, and could only give one wailing cry for mercy, which was heard by an elder brother a quarter of a mile away, and then Messer fired both barrels of the gun. The whole of the boy's head was shot off, and a piece of the skull was afterward picked up ten feet from where he knelt. Young as was little Budd, he fully realized that it was his act that had caused the arrest and murder of his brother Randolph. Six months later he was attacked with a sort of fever common in the mountains. From the first, he told his mother that he should not get well, and he did not. Within seven days the disease had run its course, much sooner than usual, and he was dead. The last words he spoke were an incoherent reference to the murder of his brother Randolph.

Of course the feud has not been ended. The laws of the state are openly defied, the officers seem to care nothing about it, and one deed of violence has followed another. Probably many other murders are yet to come, and not until this wild country is opened up by railroads and settled by law-abiding citizens from other states will life and property become safe from bushwacking mob rule.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The report recounts how young 'Budd' McCoy grew up steeped in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, recalling the killing of Bill Staton and the lawsuit over livestock that started the hostility. It sets the stage for the fateful 1882 election day at Blackberry Creek where members of both families gathered, foreshadowing violence to come.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Morning News · 18 July 1889 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This passage describes the Kentucky election day gathering where Hatfields and McCoys drank moonshine and applejack together, leading to a quarrel over a debt between Talbot McCoy and a Hatfield. The dispute escalated into a knife fight involving Ellison Hatfield after an initial brawl was broken up by constables.

The Morning News · 18 July 1889 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

The item reports that Frank Phillips, who gained notoriety during the Hatfield-McCoy feud in Pike County, murdered a young Virginia attorney in Buchanan County the previous week. It states the killing appeared to have occurred without any provocation.

The Big Sandy News · 18 July 1889 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Middleburgh Post · Middleburgh, Pa.

Kentucky deputy Frank Phillips, leader of McCoy raids into West Virginia, got into a quarrel with Hatfield relative William Keyser in Tazewell County and shot him dead. The report claims Phillips has personally killed at least three men during the feud raids and has now fled to the mountains to avoid capture.

The Middleburgh Post · 18 July 1889 · page 2

KILLED A DEPUTY

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

The report describes Hatfield-McCoy gang member Frank Phillips going on a violent spree near Grandy, Virginia, waving a Winchester rifle and revolver. It claims he pistol-whipped attorney William Keiser and then shot him dead despite a bystander's attempt to grab his arm, with no arrests made as Phillips fled to the mountains.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Shenandoah Herald · 19 July 1889 · page 2

A West Virginia Tragedy.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.

The report briefly notes that at Grundy, Virginia, attorney William Keiser was shot and killed by Frank Phillips, described as one of the notorious Hatfield-McCoy gang. This item appears as one of many short news briefs in a roundup column.

South Branch Intelligencer · 19 July 1889 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Savannah Tribune · Savannah, Ga.

Frank Phillips, a wanted member of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was reported brandishing a Winchester rifle and revolver near Grundy, Virginia, threatening to harm people. During this episode he struck attorney William Keiser on the head with a revolver, seriously wounding him.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Savannah Tribune · 20 July 1889 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come