As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

March 1904

11 articles

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

A rumor from Ontario, Oregon claims that a woman who disguised herself as a man named Joe Monaghan and worked as a cattle herder for twenty-five years was actually Kate Bender, the notorious Kansas murderess. The report notes there is no definite proof of this claim, but adds that Bender's parents are rumored to be living nearby on the Snake River.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 6 March 1904 · page 16

PHANTOM OF BENDER CASE BOBS UP AGAIN

CASE BOBS UP AGA1 N 4ONTARIO, Or., March B. That tho woman who, under tho namo -4of "Joe Monaghnn," herded cattlo and rodo tho rnngo in this section -lr for twenly-ilvo years In tho gulso -f 4of a man, and whoso real sex was not known until her death, was -f- -fnone other than Kate Bender, tho -fnotorious Kansas niurdress, Is tho -f 4rumor current here. Whllo there -f-

See the clipping

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

The article reports on the recent identification of "Joe Monaghan," a cross-dressing Oregon rancher who died revealing female anatomy, as the notorious Kate Bender. A Billings woman who knew the Bender family during the 1870s manhunt says she has reasons to doubt both that Monaghan was Kate Bender and that the elder Benders are still alive in Oregon as claimed.

The Billings Gazette · 8 March 1904 · page 2

POSITIVE IT WASN'T KATE BILLINGS LADY DOUBTS OREGON'S BENDER STORY

Tha .Pursued Family. Within the last few days news papers having the Associated Press service have printed a telegram from Ontario, Ore., in which it is stated that the woman, who under the name of "Joe Monaghan," rode the range there for 25 years in the guise of a man, and whose sex did not become known until after death was none other than the notorious murderess, Kate Bender. "ate Bender is a name still familiar to the older generation of newspaper readers, although prob ably unknown to any of the younger people, for it is many years since she disappeared and the many murders laid at the door of herself and parents have been about forgotten.

See moreSee less

The same dispatch adds that "Old Man" and "Old Woman" Bender, as the newspapers of that time were ac customed to refer to the father and mother of Kate, are now residing on the Snake river, not far from Ontario. The presumption is that they have a ranch there and the report of their proximity to the woman who is be lieved to have been their daughter is accepted by some as bearing out the story by which the identity of the murderous trio would be established.

See the clipping

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

A Billings woman who lived near the Benders in Kansas in the 1870s says she has reasons to doubt that the cowboy-turned-woman 'Joe Monaghan' was really Kate Bender, or that the elder Benders are still alive in Oregon. The article recalls the original Bender murders, including a lawyer's search for his missing brother that led to discovery of the gang's crimes.

The Billings Gazette · 8 March 1904 · page 2

HAS REASONS FOR DISBELIEF

What Billings Lady Knows. It is possible that "Joe Monaghan" was Kate Bender and that her parents are still alive and now reside in Ore gon, but there is at least one person in Billings who doubts it, and has good reason for doubt. This person is a lady. With the diffidence natural to her sex she is averse to have her name given, but she declares that she has every reason for not believing that the supposed cowboy who turned out to be a woman was not Kate Bender. The same reasons for doubt in this respect also prompt her to dis believe that the old Benders are still, alive.

See moreSee less

During the seventies, the decade when the Benders gained their noto riety 'by reason of the discovery of the numerous murders committed by them, a discovery that unfortunately was made too late to enable the ar rest of the murderers to be accom plished, the lady referred to was a resident of Kansas, and not so very far from where the Benders lived. She was then a young girl, but dis tinctly remembers many of the cir cumstances that occurred after the successful flight of the Benders and the discovery of the bodies found buried in and about the house they occupied. She even recalls some of the names of the men who were found to have been murdered by the outfit. The Benders, it will be remember ed, kept a road house and often ac commodated travelers overtaken by night. Railroads were not very plen tiful in Kafsas at that time and much of the travel was by team, particular ly in the case of emigrants, while salesmen of all kinds also traveled in that manner. Because of the sparsely settled country but little attention was paid to travelers, as they were common, and when occasionally it be came talked that some one had dis appeared, it was the subject of only passing comment. Finally, however, the sudden and mysterious disappear auces in that particular pocality be came so frequent as to be marked. Then came one that caused suspicion to attach to the Benders and they themselves turned up missing.

See the clipping

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

A woman recalls a lawyer judge who, after finding his murdered brother buried near the Bender house, led a posse that tracked down the Benders and hinted they would 'never bother anybody any more.' She remains convinced the woman later known as 'Joe Monaghan' was not actually Kate Bender.

The Billings Gazette · 8 March 1904 · page 2

HAS REASONS FOR DISBELIEF

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening Statesman · Walla Walla, Wash.

A report from Ontario claims that a person known locally as 'Joe Monaghan,' who herded cattle disguised as a man for twenty-five years, may actually have been Kate Bender, the notorious Kansas murderess. The article notes there is no definite proof, only local rumor and the claim that Monaghan's supposed parents live nearby on Snake River.

The Evening Statesman · 8 March 1904 · page 7

• ' •*• these SOU Dukhobors, although tiieil descendants may become tract removed from the influences sur f • ling the first settlers." rO BE KATE 3E \DER js to Identity of the Late "Joe Mon.-ighan.'' ONTARIO, . ire.. March B.—That the ider liename of "Joe - 11" n< rded cattle and rode the this section for twenty-five guise of a man, and whose is not known until her - none other than Kate • 'he notorious Kansas mur ' thi rumor current here. - no proof positive that '' is true.

See moreSee less

Joe Mona '■ d at < mtario a short time ' • - ape of Kate Bender. imed that Mr. and Mrs. • and mother of the no ix ' nov > reside on the Snake t far from < intario.

See the clipping

The River Press · Fort Benton, Mont.

A report from Ontario, Oregon says locals believe 'Joe Monaghan,' a woman who had lived disguised as a man herding cattle for 25 years, was actually the fugitive Kansas murderess Kate Bender. The story notes there is no definite proof, only circumstantial timing and a rumor that Bender's parents live nearby on the Snake River.

The River Press · 9 March 1904 · page 8

Jlclicvc She Was Kate 13ender. Ontario , Ore., March 5.—That the woman who, under the name of "Joe Monaglian," herded cattle and rode the range in this section for 25 years iu the jjuisa of a man, and whose real sex was not known until her death, was none other than Kate Bender, the notorious Kansas murderess, is the rumor current here. While there is no proof positive that this statement is true, Joe Monaghan appeared at Ontario a short time after the escape of Kate Bender. It is also claimed that Mr. and Mrs. Bender, father and mother of the notorious Kate, now re side oa the Snake river not far from Ontario.

See the clipping

The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.

A man claims to know the true story behind a lady's account of the last posse sent after the Bloody Benders, identifying the leader as 'Cap' York, brother of victim Doctor York. He asserts the posse caught and killed the Benders in Indian Territory, and that no one asked further questions afterward.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 348 days later.

Wrong

The Billings Gazette · 11 March 1904 · page 2

-Mont. 84-9 tainly knows something that not very many people ever learnedc; and she is not mistaken in her belief that none of the Benders will ever be seen again and that the supposed Oregon cowboy who was discovered to. be a woman was not Kate Bender. I lived in Kan sas at the time the Benders did, and not so very far from where they kept their murderous den. I knew Doctor York, one of the men murdered by the. gang, also his brother,, 'Cap' York, who headed the party that afterward gave, assurances that the Benders would never trouble any one any more.

See moreSee less

Cap' York is evidently the 'judge' of whom the lady spoke; she simply made a mistake in the title, that's all. The captain and his posse overtook the Benders after they got into the Indian country and they were. the last ones that ever saw any one of the family alive. Things were different those days than they now are. People were not so inquisitive and as every one knew that Captain York had a just grievance -against the outfit not many questions were asked after the posse said the Benders would not

See the clipping

Lincoln County Record · Pioche, Nev.

A report states that a woman who had herded cattle in Oregon for 25 years disguised as a man named 'Joe Monaghan,' her true sex unknown until death, is rumored at Ontario to have been Kate Bender, the notorious Kansas murderess. The claim is presented as current rumor rather than established fact.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Lincoln County Record · 11 March 1904 · page 2

That the woman who. under the name of "Joe Monaghan," herded cat tle and rode the range In Oregon for twenty-five years In the guise of a man, and whose real box was not known until her death, was none other than Kate Bender, the notorious Kansas murderess,. Is the rumor cur rent at Ontario. Will Schwlnk was almost Instantly killed, and his wife, Marie Schwlnk, probably fatally shot by John White,

See the clipping

In the story →

The Caldwell Tribune · Caldwell, Idaho Territory Idaho

A newspaper rumor claimed that Joe Monahan, a woman who died near Rockville, Idaho after decades disguised as a man, was actually Kate Bender, and that her parents still lived in Snake River Valley. The report then debunks this, citing a letter from Monahan's sister denying any connection and noting the Benders were likely dead, their remains buried along the Verdigris River.

The Caldwell Tribune · 12 March 1904 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

ANOTHER BENDER ROMANCE A rumor is current that Joe Monahan, the woman who recently died near Rockville, Idaho, after having successfully masked as a man for the past 25 years, was none other than Kate Bender, the notorious Kansas murderess, and that old man Bender and his wife are still living in Snake River Valley. The Bender family have been located a number of times and different people have beeen arrested on suspicion of being members of this family at various times, ever since their notorious crimes came to light and their mysterious disappearance followed, over 30 years ago; but it is more than probable that the remains of these human fiends lie buried in the sands of the Verdiges river.

See moreSee less

Who Joe Monnaghan was will probably never be known and still there is a chance that the mysteries that surrond her life may yet be unraveled. It is true she made her. appearance in this country shortly after the disappearance of the Bender family, but that she was the notorious Kate, we have not the slighest suspicion. The above is taken from the Ontario Argus The story is very improbable. Mr. W. T. Schnabel before leaving for Alaska received a letter from Joe Monaghan's sister in New York in regard to the estate left. Among other things she said that there was no reason why her sister should adopt a man,s attire, except a desire on the girl's part to be a man. There is no particular mystery concerning Joe Monaghan. The rumor is groundless.

See the clipping

Idaho County Free Press · Grangeville, Idaho Territory

The article revives speculation that the mysterious Oregon cowboy Joe Monaghan, who had worked unnoticed for decades in the Sweethome valley, was actually the fugitive murderess Kate Bender in disguise. It recounts rumors from twenty-five years earlier about a strange farmhand whose true identity was questioned but never confirmed until after death.

Idaho County Free Press · 17 March 1904 · page 2

The story published in the Tribune of a recent date relative to the indentilicatiou of the myster the ious Joe Monaghan as Kate Bender, ious the notorious murderess, has the brought forth a supporter of the theory in this city. The opinion is entirely based upon 'circumstan is ces, but has developed during a ces, period of years until there Beems to period be little doubt but what the daring be cowboy who had ridden the range of eastern Oregon and southern of Idaho for twenty-five years was Idaho none other than the much sought none Kate Bender.

See moreSee less

Kate The story commences in the Sweet homo valley, a small settle Sweet ment on the Santiam river, located ment in the wilds of the Cascade moun in tains. It was more than twenty tains. five years ago that a smooth faced five man, of middle age, located man, in the Sweethome valley and se in cured employment with a German cured farmer as a farm liaud. With tbe farm hand came a younger man farm who soon left for the eastern stock who ranges and was not seen again in the Sweethome valley. There the was a strangeness about the new was comers and it was rumored in ex clusive circles that the farm band was none other than Mrs. Bender, was whose name w\ s 0:1 every person's

See the clipping

Idaho County Free Press · Grangeville, Idaho Territory

A 1904 report speculates that a disguised woman farmhand who worked for decades in Oregon's Sweethome valley, only discovered to be female after her death, was actually Kate Bender. It connects this tale to the Joe Monaghan legend, admitting the truth may never be known.

Idaho County Free Press · 17 March 1904 · page 2

cured employment with a German cured farmer as a farm liaud. With tbe farm hand came a younger man farm who soon left for the eastern stock who ranges and was not seen again in the Sweethome valley. There the was a strangeness about the new was comers and it was rumored in ex clusive circles that the farm band was none other than Mrs. Bender, was whose name w\ s 0:1 every person's tongue at that time. As the farm hand perfectly concealed her ident hand ity, after a few inoutliB the suspic ity, ion was dispelled and in a few ion years the laborer was one of the most respected persons in the com most munity.

See moreSee less

The were peculiarities about the character that still puz zled the old residents but the Ger zled man farmer had seen nothing man suspicious and always spoke in the highest terms of his employee. At At the end of eight years the stranger the died and it was then discovered died that the laborer was a woman. that The Bender story was then revived The but no definite information could but

See the clipping