As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

February 1888

3 articles

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Fifteen years after the Benders vanished, a Kansas correspondent reports that talk of the Texas Kelley lynching revived discussion of the Benders' fate, prompting an old-timer to share new information. The piece recaps the Bender family's background and the 1873 disappearance of Dr. William York, who vanished en route to Independence.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 February 1888 · page 5

STORY OF A DYING MAN.

' Party of Saves Who Earliest Inves j" tigated Dr. York's Death. Americus (Kan.) Correspondent GlobeDemocrat. I Ever since the lynching of the Kelley family in the Texas Panhanule there has been more oi less told of the fate of the Benders. Several citizens of Amer icas, it seems, had been discussing the Benders and the Kellevs, and in the group was an old.forty-niner," whodis played such interest during the talk that he was pressed to tell what he knew. A hint of what was told or could be told led to the reporter's trip.

See moreSee less

~ It is nearly fifteen years since the Benders achieved a criminal fame. The family consisted of four persons— old man William Bender, a pretty stout German: his wife, a woman not particu larly different from the average German womanot low degree; a son, George, about twenty-two years old; a daughter, Kate, of fair complexion, with light eyes and yellow hair, who pretended to be a spiritualist, and who was decidedly uncanny, if she was nothing else. S -The Bender claim was located near Big Hill creek, in Labette county, and only a short distance from the town of Cherryvale. The house was a one-story two-room frame, the front room, or din ing-room, being separated from a scantily furnished sleeping room behind a canvas partition. There was an ordinary garden plot near the house, and a smali amount of stock. The Benders had come to their claim some time in 1871. and probably came from Indiana. They were an unsociable lot, and Kale's pretensions to occultism kept timid people still more aloof. It was on March 9, 1873, that Dr. Wil liam 11. York, brother of Colonel A. M. "i ork. who figured so conspicuously in the Pomeroy senatorial scandal, "left Fort Scott on horseback, bound for In dependence. Nothing being heard of him for nearly three weeks, mention was made in the press of his supposed disappearance. Colonel York worked hard to find his brother, and traced him to the Bender place. It could not be learned that Dr. York bad gone beyond this point, and as he was well mounted the question arose, what had become of his horse? It was believed to be impos sible to have got the horse out of that section without some one knowing it. After Colonel York's first visit to the Bender place he returned to his home, having, as the story goes, learned noth ing as to his brother's whereabouts. Later, early In April, men from Cherry vale went out to the Bender place and returned. On May sth it was learned that the Bender house was vacant and tireless, and that the stock were perish ing from starvation; A wagon and team were found hitched to the fence and abandoned at Thayer, a railroad station twelve miles from the Pender place. WIIKRE DID THE BENDERS GO?

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

This report recounts the Bender family's arrival in Labette County in 1871, Dr. William York's disappearance in March 1873, and the subsequent investigation that led to discovery of the abandoned house and buried bodies in the garden plot. It describes the trap-door cellar with blood traces and the method of probing the ground with iron rods to find victims.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 827 days earlier.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 February 1888 · page 5

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The report recaps the original 1873 discovery of nine bodies on the Bender property and the gruesome method of murder, then focuses on the enduring mystery of what happened to the Bender family afterward. It describes unconfirmed sightings, false arrests, lynching rumors, and a reporter's attempt to get Maj. Hicks to reveal what he allegedly knows.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 404 days earlier.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 February 1888 · page 5

WIIKRE DID THE BENDERS GO? When it was known that the Bender home was abandoned, two things hap pened. An enterprising citizen at once tacked his homestead claim papers ou the frame walk* of the house, and an in vestigation of the premises was insti tuted. The walls and floor Were care fully examined. In the back room a trap-door was found leading to a sort of cellar. The cellar floor was examined and showed unmistakable traces of blood, The garden-plot was probed with iron rods and nine bodies found buried, the first one discovered being that of Dr.

See moreSee less

W. M. York, whose brother was at once notified. All the bodies had their skulls broken and their throats cut, except a little girl, who was probably suffocated. The theory of the crime was that each person killed by the Benders was seated near the canvas partition between the two rooms; that a blow from a mallet or hammer on the head was given from the other side of the trail partition, and 'that • the unconscious victim was (bagged out to the trap-door to the cel lar, where his throat was cut, the body being buried in the garden lot at dead of night. The sensation created by these discoveries was tremendous, and the name of Bender has passed into his tory as descriptive of the coldest ■ thuggery known. What became of the Benders has never been definitely known. They were generally supposed to have taken the train at Thayer and gone no one knows where. From time to time par ties were arrested and held for quite long periods ou suspicion of being the real, original Benders or some one of that family, but the identifications were never successful, and no one suffered legally for the Benders' crimes. As late as the summer of 1883 a man and woman hung around the Globe-Demo crat office for days in the hope of being employed to guide its reporters to a point in Southern Arizona where it was claimed the Benders were still living. Then there was a story that the Benders had been lynched, but how. when and where was never accurately stated. It was always supposed that Col. York knew something as to the fate of the Benders, but if he did know Col. York never told.

See the clipping