As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

January 1887

4 articles

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A Chicago man recounts a deathbed confession claiming the Bender family was captured and lynched by a vigilance committee, with all hanged except Kate who was shot after resisting. He says a Kansas farmer later confirmed the story, suggesting authorities quietly let the matter rest.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 404 days later.

Wrong

The Sun · 9 January 1887 · page 1

THE FATE OF THE BENDERS

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Iowa Plain Dealer · New Oregon, Iowa

A dying man's deathbed confession, later confirmed by a Kansas farmer, claims the Bender family was captured and lynched, with Kate Bender bludgeoned after resisting hanging. The story places their fate in Indian Territory, offering a lurid explanation for their mysterious disappearance.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Iowa Plain Dealer · 20 January 1887 · page 1

The Benders. Newspaper readers will remember the notorious Bender family, and their peculiar if not mysterious disappearance is now explained in the following narrative made public at St. Louis. Paul Betts says that late in the seventies he was called to see an ac quaintance who was dying in a Kansas City hotel. The man wished to tell him uliout the fate of the Benders, the family that murdered so many trav elers. lie exacted a pledge that Mr. Belts would not reveal the story while his informant's wife lived. He said the Benders were lynched by a vigil ance committee.

See moreSee less

They were all hang ed except Kate Bender, who fought so hard they could not get the rope around her neck, and so she was shot. The following year the sto ry was coufirmed by a Kansas farmer living near the Benders. The farmer said: '•Did it never occur to you that it was very strange that so many mur derers as there were in the Bender family, and such stupid people as they were, could escape from the keenest detectives iu the world, who will fol low their game into the furtherest parts of the wcrld aud capture them? How do folks think that such a gang could get away iu a country where every man, woman, and child knows everyb .dy else and everybody's horses and wagons? No. sir: if any one wants what there is left ot the Bender* they will have to go over into the Indian Territory. They stretched hemp there, all but Kate. "I tell you. man, she was a bad one. She screamed and bit and cursed and kicked so that one could put the rope around her neck. So some onecrackcd her skull for her with a stick, and an other one put a bullet or two through he. brain," Mr. Bett.n has not felt free to tell the story until the present time.

See the clipping

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn.

A dying man in Kansas City reportedly confided to Paul Betts that the Bender family was lynched by a vigilance committee, with all hanged except Kate Bender who was shot after resisting. A Kansas farmer later added a similar but conflicting account, claiming the Benders were hanged in Indian Territory, with Kate again killed differently after violently resisting capture.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Mower County Transcript · 21 January 1887 · page 15

The Benders. Newspaper readers will remember the notorious Bender family, and their peculiar if not mysterious disappearance is now explained in the following narrative made public at St. Louis. Paul Betts says that late in the seventies he was called to see an ac­ quaintance who was dying1 in a Kansas City hotel. The man wished to tell him about the fate of the Benders, the family that murdered so many trav­ elers. He exacted a pledge that Air. Betts would not reveal the story while his informant's wife lived. He said the Benders were lynched by a vigil­ ance committee.

See moreSee less

They were all hang­ ed except Kate Bender, who fought so hard they could not get the rope around her neck. and so she was shot. Tin? following year the sto­ ry was continued by a Kansas farmer living near the Benders. The farmer said: "'Did it never occur to you that it was very strange that so many mur­ derers as there were in the Bender family, and such stupid people as they were, could escape from the keenest detectives in the world, who will fol­ low their game into the furtherest parts of the wcrld and capture them? How do folks think that such a gang could get away in a country where every man. woman, and child knows everyb .dv else and everybody'shorses and wagons? No. sir if any one wants what there is left of the Benders they will have to go over into the Indian Territory. They stretched hemp there, all but Kate. ••I tell you, man, she was a bad one. She screamed and bit and cursed and kicked so that one could put the rope around her neck. So some one cracked her skull for her with a stick, anil an­ other one put a bullet or two through he. brain," Mr. Betts has not felt free to tell the story until the present time.

See the clipping

The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich.

A dying man's deathbed story, later said to be confirmed by a Kansas farmer, claims the Bender family was lynched in Indian Territory, with Kate Bender shot after resisting hanging. The account is presented as unverified hearsay about the long-unsolved mystery of the Benders' fate.

The True Northerner · 26 January 1887 · page 3

Touching tho mystery surrounding tho fato of tho Benders, a St. Louis paper prints this: "Paul Petts says that lato in tho seventies be was called to see an acquaintance who was dying in a Kansas City hotel. Tho man wished to tell him about tho fate of tho Benders, tho family that murdered so many travelers. Ho exacted a pledge that Mr. Betts would not reveal tho story while bis informant's wife lived. Ho said tho Benders were lynched by a vigilanco committee. They wero all hanged except Kate Bender, who fought so hard they could not got tho rope around her neck, and so sho was shot.

See moreSee less

Tho following year tho story was confirmed by a Kansas farmer, living near tho Benders'. Tho farmer said: 4 Did it nover occur to you that it was very strange that so many mur derers as thero wero in the Bender family, and such stupid peoplo as they were, could escape from tho keenest detectives in tho world, who will follow their game into tho furthest parts of tho world and capture them? How do folks think that such a gang conld get away in a country whero every man, woman, and child knows everybody elso and everybody's horses and wag ons? No, sir; if any one wants what there is loft of the Benders they will havo to go over into tho Indian Terri tory. They stretched hemp there, all but Kate. I tell you, man, sho was a bad one. She screamed and bit and cursed and kicked so that no one could put tho rope around her neck. So sorao ono cracked her skull for her with a stick, and another ono put a bullet or two through her brain.' Mr. Betts bas not felt freo to tell tho story until the prosont timo."

See the clipping