As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

September 1926

2 articles

The St. Johns Herald · St. Johns, Ariz.

Writing decades later, John Holt Lacy recalls meeting Billy the Kid near Fort Selden in 1880 and recounts tales of the Lincoln County War, rustling feuds, and the Kid's trial and conviction. The account blends personal recollection with embellished legend, including exaggerated killing tallies and dramatic duels.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The St. Johns Herald · 2 September 1926 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

SEPT. 2, 1926 BILLY THE KID

(By John Holt Lacy in the Silver Belt)

See moreSee less

While at Fort Selden in 1880, I often took occasion to visit Las Cruces, a little town 19 miles below on the Rio Grande. Here I first met "Billy the Kid.", one of the most notorious outlaws of the west and whose name has gone down in song and story. What his real name was I never knew, but he was the leader of a band of rustlers and cattle thieves that terrorized southern New Mexico for a number of years.

In personal appearance he was fair and slight, and although 23 years of age, he did not seem to be more than 18. Enmity existed between the owners of large herds of cattle and those of the smaller ones, the big men charging that the small herd owners were illegally branding their calves. The rustlers, who preyed upon both, finally took sides with the small herd owners and it came to such a pass that it was war to the knife, each side killing the members of the opposite faction whenever they came together.

"Billy the Kid" was front and foremost in the killings' the deaths of no less than 23 men being charged up to him. It was called the Lincoln country war and it is said that more than 40 men lost their lives on one side or the other before it was finished.

A duel to the death between two of the opposing factions at Dowling's mill was rather interesting. One of the rustlers had followed a Chisholm man into that camp and had concealed himself behind some large logs in front of the cabin which the Chisholm man had entered.

The Chisholm man stood in the doorway looking out to see if the coast was clear before setting down to dinner. The rustler took deliberate aim and put a bullet through the pit of his stomach. Seeing him fall and thinking that he had got his man he unconcernedly approached the cabin, when the wounded man from where he lay on the floor and with barely strength enough to raise his gun, sent a bullet crashing through his assailant's head. Both were dead within two minutes.

I saw "Billy the Kid" just after he had been tried and convicted for some one of his innumerable murders. He had taken a change of venue from Lincoln to Doa Ana county. But the change did not benefit him, for he was convicted of murder in the first degree and sentenced to be hanged.

The officers took him back to Lincoln county jail where he was awaiting the day of execution.

One day the deputy sheriff came in to bring him his dinner. Shackled, both hand and feet as he was, he stealthily got behind him and brought his hand cuffs down on the deputy's head with all his might. The blow stunned him so that he fell to the floor. Taking the deputy's pistol, he shot him dead, then took his bunch of keys, unlocked the doors, armed himself to the teeth from the sheriff's armory and waited for the sheriff, who, alarmed by the shot, was speedily approaching by the front gate. Pushing a rifle through a window he killed him before he could enter the building.

Then he went down to a blacksmith shop and at the point of a pistol made the blacksmith knock off his hand and l[e]g irons. Now he was free again. The [next] visit he made was to a livery sta[b]le, where he ordered the keeper to saddle up the best horse he had. He then turned towards his favorite rendezvous near old Fort Summer and successfully evaded his persuers for some months.

Pat Garrett, the fearless sheriff of Lincoln county, and was later slain by outlaws determined to get him. So he secretly set to work, keeping completely out of sight. Finally he located a house that the kid visited. Concealing himself behind a bed, he waited for the Kid to enter, which he did about midnight. As soon as he recognized the Kid, the sheriff shot him through the heart.

So the Kid died with his boots on, just as did his innumerable victims.

Ben Tillett, famous British labor leader now in America, began his career as a circus roustabout.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A 1926 article on New York County crime statistics contrasts modern organized city gangsters with old frontier bandits like Billy the Kid, Jesse James, and Cole Younger, now reduced to historical myths. It argues old-time outlaws showed courage in open confrontations with posses, unlike cowardly modern gangsters who shoot indiscriminately.

Evening Star · 8 September 1926 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Criminal Fashions Change.

The number of indictments pending on June 11 was 400, as against 659 on the same date last year. The number of appeals pending in which defendants are on bail at present is 25, the smallest number in the history of the district attorney's office.

See moreSee less

The scope of Federal and State prosecutions such as are dealt with by the district attorney of New York County covers almost every variety of criminal activity. A noteworthy feature of the majority of cases that now engage the attention of prosecuting officials shows that fashions change in crime as in everything else.

The bandit of the old frontier days is gone. Billy the Kid, Jesse James, Cole Younger are now only historical myths. The bandit of the old frontier days specialized in holding up stage coaches and robbing railroad trains. He took a chance on every job. He lined up his victims, but never used his pistol except to resist capture. Then he fought it out in the open with grimly determined posses and vigilance committees, sometimes displaying rare courage against overwhelming odds.

The city bandit of today is utterly lacking in such courage as that displayed by the old-fashioned hold-up man. The city gangster is generally a coward and shoots down a woman with children clinging to her skirts with as little compunction as when he turns his gun against an armed policeman.

See the clipping