As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

July 1926

6 articles

In the story →

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

This single-item article remarks that stories claiming Billy the Kid survived his reported death and lived quietly in the southwest for forty-five years are interesting and make good hot weather reading.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 55 days earlier.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 1 July 1926 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

Billy the Kid Myths

All these stories of Billy the Kid being alive and living quietly in the southwest for forty-five years after his reported demise, are interesting and make good hot weather reading.

See moreSee less

But like other summer fiction they must be read with an eye attuned to fiction.

We, like the rest of the United States, are apt to regard Billy the Kid and his Nemesis, Pat Garrett, as almost legandary characters, and perhaps may give an open ear to legendary tales about them.

But we must remember that Billy the Kid was a very real character, known to many men still living in this part of the country, while Pat Garrett, the redoubtable peace officer who risked his life in the day's work to end the outlaw's lurid career, lived here honored and respected, a friend of most El Paso pioneers for a quarter-century after the Kid's end.

Sheriff Garrett's reputation for honesty, bravery and fair dealing, is too well established to suffer from the mythical tales about the outlaw. To the men who knew the details of the Kid's crime and his death and burial, there never has been an instant of doubt.

In the first place, all of the official records of the Kid's death and burial are in order; there were plenty of men in those days, some of them dead now, who knew of the demise of the Kid in all its details.

In the second place, Pat Garrett's personal record is such that any suggestion of a plot to permit Billy the Kid to escape in which he could have been engaged is unthinkable. Garrett's fidelity to duty never was questioned in his lifetime.

The story of the Kid's escape is like the stories of a good many other celebrated criminals who now and then are resurrected after most of the eye witnessed are dead.

Fortunately there are enough men left who knew Garrett intimately to set at rest any such rumors.

As fiction it is interesting. But only as fiction.—The El Paso Times.

See the clipping

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

The El Paso Times insists Pat Garrett's reputation for honesty and fidelity to duty makes any claim he conspired to let Billy the Kid escape unthinkable. It argues official records of the Kid's death and burial are solid and that surviving contemporaries confirm the facts, dismissing escape stories as mere fiction.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 1 July 1926 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

after the Kid's end.

Sheriff Garrett's reputation for honesty, bravery and fair dealing, is too well established to suffer from the mythical tales about the outlaw. To the men who knew the details of the Kid's crime and his death and burial, there never has been an instant of doubt.

See moreSee less

In the first place, all of the official records of the Kid's death and burial are in order; there were plenty of men in those days, some of them dead now, who knew of the demise of the Kid in all its details.

In the second place, Pat Garrett's personal record is such that any suggestion of a plot to permit Billy the Kid to escape in which he could have been engaged is unthinkable. Garrett's fidelity to duty never was questioned in his lifetime.

The story of the Kid's escape is like the stories of a good many other celebrated criminals who now and then are resurrected after most of the eye witnessed are dead.

Fortunately there are enough men left who knew Garrett intimately to set at rest any such rumors.

See the clipping

The Coconino Sun · Flagstaff, Ariz.

A satirical filler item mocks historians who claim Billy the Kid is not dead, suggesting it's because he has many imitators. It's part of a column of wry one-liners on current events of 1926.

The Coconino Sun · 2 July 1926 · page 4

Transcript to come.

No page image survives for this article

The Coconino Sun · Flagstaff, Ariz.

A former territorial treasurer, Howard Vaughn, recalls being mistaken for Billy the Kid and argues that Pat Garrett's long, fearless life after 1881 proves the outlaw was truly killed. Vaughn also recounts believing the Kid's body was genuinely displayed at the funeral, not a substitute.

The Coconino Sun · 2 July 1926 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

SHERIFF LIVED SO BILLY THE KID IS SURE DEAD

That is the way Howard Vaughn, of Santa Fe, former territorial treasurer, sizes up the situation.

"Garrett either had to shoot the Kid or get shot," said Vaughn. "And anybody who knew Garrett will tell you that, following the report of the death of the Kid, he never had any fear of running into Billy."

See moreSee less

Vaughn, then a youth with sandy hair, was once mistaken for the Kid, shortly after his arrival here on the first A. T. & S. F. train into the capital. As he walked into the old Exchange hotel, on the site of La Fonda, a cowboy, rushing up to him, said: "Hello, Kid." Seeing his mistake, he explained he thought Vaughn was Billy the Kid.

Vaughn is ready to deny to all comers, however, that he subbed for Billy at the funeral of the latter. On that occasion, he believes Billy was present in person, or, at least, what is sometimes referred to as his "remains." He believes Billy "as dead as a mackerel."

See the clipping

The Washington Daily News · Washington, D.C.

A film review of Zane Grey's 'Born to the West' jokingly compares star Jack Holt's gunslinging persona to legendary figures like Billy the Kid and Bill Hart. The piece focuses on the movie's plot, cast, and entertainment value rather than any historical account of Billy the Kid himself.

The Washington Daily News · 7 July 1926 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

Jack Holt Steals All Bill Hart's Thunder SHADES of Billy the Kid and Bill Hart! What a swashbuckling two-gun hombre our friend Jack Holt has turned out to be! Furthermore, he certainly makes 'em like it in Zane Grey's "Born to the West," which is now shaming F-st's less virile cowboys over at Loew's Columbia.

See the clipping

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

A newspaper advertisement lists dozens of new books available for sale, including popular fiction, biography, and humor titles. Among them is 'The Saga of Billy the Kid' by Walter Noble Burns, the influential 1926 biography that helped cement the outlaw's legendary status.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 9 July 1926 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Halman. Clara Barron, by Harvey O'Higgins. The Private Life of Helen of Troy, by John Erskine. The Saga of Billy the Kid, by Walter Noble Burns.

See the clipping