The Montgomery Advertiser · 24 October 1926 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
The proposal to erect a monument in Fort Worth to "Billy the Kid" has awakened widespread comment and evoked sharp criticism.
See moreSee less
Most of the killing exploits which made "Billy the Kid" notorious were staged in New Mexico and other States to the west. But the young outlaw was nutured in Texas and recruited his gang from renegade Texans.
The same State which developed his consummate skill on the draw whetted the talents of an avenging nemesis. Billy and his gang were captured at Stinking Springs, N. M., by a frontier Texas sheriff. When the young gunman killed two guards and escaped jail, to run amuck once more in the West, this same angular Texan stalked him to his lair and shot him dead.
When "Billy the Kid" was slain, he was 21 years old. His known killing record totalled twenty-one men, "not counting negroes and Mexicans." Many of his victims were aces themselves, with long killing records behind them.
If it is desired to honor the memory of the deadliest gunman which the American frontier produced, the distinction should go to this juvenile leader of the Lincoln county war. No other man, not even the notorious "Wild Bill" of Kansas, was so universally feared.
But if homicide is to be made a virtue and experts in the art of homicide held up as models to the youth of the land, why single out one killer of particularly despicable type? Why not plant a memorial group in Fort Worth where all the exponents of the draw might live in marble, each with a smoking forty-five in either hand?
As candidates for this frontier hall of fame many personalities suggest themselves—the James boys, the Dalton gang, Cole Younger, Sam Bass, John Wesley Hardin—why prolong the list?
In marble, as in life, distinctions should be preserved. The slayers of the old West fall into three main classes—those who killed incidentally as an aid to their profession of robbing stages, trains and banks; those who killed to satisfy their superiority complex, and those who killed under the guise of law enforcement.
It might be permissible to indicate a choice in each of these fields of professional endeavor. We should say that Jesse James deserves first rank among the outlaw killers; "Billy the Kid" among those who killed for pastime; and the long-haired town marshal of Abilene, Kan., among those who killed to expedite justice, according to their lights.
Thus, Missouri, Texas and Kansas might be induced to aid the Fort Worth project if its scope were enlarged.
Rather than to give sanction to the efficiency experts of the old West after such a fashion, however, it would be much better to choose a theme which embodies the real spirit and meaning of the pioneer era.
No better symbol could be used than a covered wagon with children's faces peering from the oval at the rear.—Houston Post-Ditspatch.