A Spokane carnival at Natatorium Park advertises 'The Gunness Farm Ghosts' as one of its spectacular attractions, alongside Ku Klux Klan and Kentucky Night-Riders displays. The listing is purely promotional, part of a Labor Temple benefit carnival with rides, vaudeville, and other entertainments.
The Spokane Press · 20 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening Statesman · Walla Walla, Wash.
A newspaper column discusses local matters like weather, directory statistics, and court costs for the Barnes murder case. It mentions being thankful the situation isn't as costly as 'a Gunness horror or a Thaw trial,' referencing the notorious case in passing.
The Evening Statesman · 20 May 1908 · page 2
Judging from the number of wit nesses subpoenaed by the prosecution in the Barnes murder case. Walla Walla county will have a pretty penny to pay. It is deplorable that the tax payers' good money, must of necessi ty be expended in thi s manner, yet so ciety and the law demands that crime be punished. Let us be thankful that it is not a Gunness horror or a Thaw
An autopsy on the exhumed remains at the Gunness farm confirmed one of the seven unidentified bodies was a female, renewing interest in the story of a professor and his wife who vanished along with Jennie Olson. Authorities speculated Mrs. Gunness may have murdered all three, though they considered it hard to believe before stating nothing seemed impossible for her.
The Yakima Herald · 20 May 1908 · page 4
FIND WOMAN.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis.
Frank Brodright, formerly of Richland County, is feared to have met his death at Mrs. Gunness' murder farm in LaPorte, Indiana. His friends are working through the LaPorte coroner to gather evidence about his fate.
Vernon County Censor · 20 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis.
Laporte investigators report new evidence that Belle Gunness had an accomplice who lured victims to her farm, citing a letter from a Cleveland man shown a photo of the 'rich widow.' A watch found in the farm's ruins was identified by serial number as belonging to victim Ole Budsberg of Iola, Wisconsin.
Vernon County Censor · 20 May 1908 · page 7
EVIDENCE SHOWS THAT MRS GUNNESS WAS AIDED BY ACCOMPLICES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis.
Kenosha residents wonder if a young woman named Tillman, who vanished two years earlier after leaving Laporte for a farm, might be among the bodies found at the Gunness farm. The report notes she was estranged from her mother and had last written that she was in poor health.
Grant County Herald · 20 May 1908 · page 3
FEAR KENOSHA GIRL MURDERED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 4 other papers
Crowds of sightseers overwhelm the LaPorte farm site, gawking at graves and the barn holding victims' remains while vendors profit from the morbid tourism. Meanwhile authorities examine two letters sent to Belle Gunness before the fire, with Sheriff Smutzer suspecting an accomplice, possibly Ray Lamphere, in her scheme.
Wood County Reporter · 21 May 1908 · page 2
MURDER FARM IS A MAGNET.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 4 papers
Dakota County Herald · Dakota City, Neb. · 15 May 1908
Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis. · 19 May 1908
Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D. · 22 May 1908
The Crook County Monitor · Sundance, Wyo. · 19 June 1908
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 1 other paper
The passage describes two scenes at the Gunness farm in Laporte where bodies have been discovered, including a barn used as a morgue that was broken into by two men claiming to be doctors. A woman named Bessie Wallace is noted to know Ray Lamphere and is expected to be an important witness.
Wood County Reporter · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis. · 19 May 1908
Pierre Weekly Free Press · Pierre, S.D. · and 9 other papers
A dentist's identification of a charred jawbone as Belle Gunness's was declared by the prosecutor to conclusively prove her death, countering escape rumors. Meanwhile, sluicing of the cellar ashes continued to yield bone fragments and metal globules, and Andrew Helgelein's body was buried after Bertillion identification.
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · Grand Rapids, Minn · 20 May 1908
Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D. · 21 May 1908
The Miller Press · Miller, S.D. · 21 May 1908
Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis. · 21 May 1908
The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D. · 22 May 1908
Golden Valley Chronicle · Beach, N.D. · 22 May 1908
The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D. · 22 May 1908
The Sisseton Weekly Standard · Sisseton, S.D. · 22 May 1908
The Wibaux Pioneer · Wibaux, Mont. · 28 May 1908
Courier Democrat · Langdon, N.D. · and 2 other papers
Dr. I. P. Norton, the dentist who had worked on Mrs. Gunness's teeth, examined a piece of jaw bone found on the farm and confirmed it was human and strongly resembled her lower jaw. A new suspicious grave site was also found about forty rods from where ten bodies had been exhumed, along with two other locations to be excavated.
MRS. BELLE GUNNESS. owner of the death farm, after he had examined the specimen brought to him by the coroner. A new grave has been found on the Gunness farm about forty rods from where ten bodies were dug up. The ground was soft, and when a pipe was pounded into the earth evidence was given that a body had been buried there. Two other suspicious places have also been located and will be ex cavated.
Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · 20 May 1908
The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · 22 May 1908
The Prescott Daily News · Prescott, Ark.
Searchers sifting the ashes of the burned Gunness farmhouse found upper and lower dental bridges with false teeth, seen as strong proof the burned female body was Belle Gunness. Authorities also received a letter describing a watch matching one found in the ruins, linking victim Henry Guerholdt to the case.
The Prescott Daily News · 21 May 1908 · page 2
FALSE TEETH FOUND.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Mena Weekly Star · Mena, Ark.
The report describes the arrest of Andrew Helgelien as the start of the final stage of the Gunness farm case, with two more bodies partially identified as Jennie Olsen and Olaf Budsberg while others remain unidentified. It notes that a grand jury will begin investigating the evidence gathered by the sheriff and prosecutor, though little new information is expected from their deliberations.
The Mena Weekly Star · 21 May 1908 · page 4
BEGINNING OF THE FINAL STAGE OF THE SENSATIONAL INDIANA MYSTERY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Nevada County Picayune · Prescott, Ark.
The grand jury was set to begin investigating the Gunness farm murders on Monday, focusing on evidence against Ray Lamphere, Mrs. Gunness' former hired man, whom the prosecutor expects to be indicted for arson and murder. The body identified as Andrew Helgelein was buried, while the remaining unidentified bodies were to be buried in potter's field.
The Nevada County Picayune · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Nevada County Picayune · Prescott, Ark.
The La Porte county council appropriated $9,000 to support officials investigating the Gunness case, ensuring Sheriff Smutzer's investigation at the death farm continues. The funds also guarantee Coroner Mack can proceed with a chemical analysis of portions of some of the victims' bodies.
The Nevada County Picayune · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Coroner Mack issued an official verdict declaring the adult female body found in the fire ruins of Belle Gunness's home to be hers, with death caused by felonious homicide by a person unknown. The finding followed dental evidence from Mrs. Gunness's dentist confirming bridgework and fillings matched hers, and further verdicts on other deaths were expected soon.
MRS. GUNNESS DEAD CORONER MACK MAKES PUBLIC HIS VERDICT.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Gilpin Observer · Central City, Colo. · and 4 other papers
An autopsy on seven unidentified bodies exhumed from Mrs. Gunness' farm revealed one was female, reviving interest in Emil Greening's account of Jennie Olson's disappearance in 1904. Greening described a mysterious "professor and his wife" who stayed the night before Jennie vanished, and the new female body was found in the same grave as Jennie Olson, Ole Budsberg, and an unidentified male.
The Elbert County Tribune · Elbert, Colo. · 21 May 1908
· · 22 May 1908
The Julesburg Grit-Advocate · Julesburg, Colo. · 22 May 1908
The Springfield Herald · Springfield, Colo. · 22 May 1908
Semi-Weekly Herald · Durango, Colo.
Mrs. Whitzer of Toledo arrived in La Porte to investigate whether her daughter, who disappeared in 1902 after attending a nearby university, was among Belle Gunness's victims. The daughter had written she was going on a visit and was never heard from again.
Semi-Weekly Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Gilpin Observer · Central City, Colo.
Sheriff Smutzer and an assistant sifting the ashes of the Gunness farm fire found upper and lower dental plates, which her dentist identified as hers. The sheriff declared this proved beyond doubt that Mrs. Gunness had burned to death in the fire.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Gilpin Observer · 21 May 1908 · page 2
La Porte Murderess Surely Dead
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.
A miner found dental bridgework in the ashes of the burned Gunness house, and the dentist who made it positively identified it as belonging to Belle Gunness. The coroner is now convinced the female corpse found earlier is indeed Gunness, while the grand jury continues investigating Ray Lamphere and the trial remains distant.
Connecticut Western News · 21 May 1908 · page 2
This Spring. Lapbrte, Ind., May 20. Louis Schultz, the expert miner, found In the ashes of the Gunness house the uppei and lower bridges, containing what the officials. here pronounce the false teeth of Mrs. Belle Gunness, who, It It thought, murdered a dozen persons. The lower set of teeth tally exactly with the description and diagram fur nished by Dr. I. r. Norton, the dentist who built the bridge and who identi fied the teeth positively as those of Mrs. Gunness. In view of the unmis takable evidence, Coroner Mack stated that he would probably render an offi cial jflndlng that the burned adult fe male body was that of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness. Dr. Norton, who built the lowei bridge, said: "The upper jaw was probably bridg ed In Chicago, but the work done in the lower Jaw I can positively identify as that done by me about a year ago. At that time I made a lower anterior bridge for Mrs. Gunness, consisting of six dummies and two crowns for the two remaining teeth, making a total of eight teeth, and swung them from the lower two cuspids. The gold In the rear of the crowns was of solid 18 carat and bears my private style of workmanship, thus eliminating any possibility that the teeth are those of any one else."
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · and 1 other paper
A dentist testifies he positively identifies a lower dental bridge as his own work made for Mrs. Gunness about a year earlier. The report also covers the grand jury's ongoing deliberations on Ray Lamphere, Sheriff Smutzer's investigation into additional possible victims including Riedinger and Gurholdt, and a tip about a possible accomplice in the matrimonial bureau scheme.
The Monmouth Inquirer · 21 May 1908 · page 2
IDENTIFIED BY HER DENTIST
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · 21 May 1908
Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper
The report details ongoing investigation into Belle Gunness's murder farm, including a watch found in the ruins matching a missing man's description, and the positive identification of another watch as belonging to victim John Moe. It also describes the discovery that one of seven unidentified bodies was a woman, corroborating a former chore boy's account of a Christmas 1906 party after which guests vanished.
Connecticut Western News · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Woman Employed Agent. A letter received by Chief of Tollce Cochrane from a man in Cleveland who describes an alleged advance agent or solicitor for the Gunness mat rimonial bureau compelled the authori ties to give more serious attention to the theory that the murderess worked with an accomplice and that further digging will find more of her victims buried about her den of crime. The inventory of the Gunness estate shows that the proprietress of the mur der farm was near the end of her re sources. She had spent all except $720 of the $3,000 which she took from
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 21 May 1908
The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.
A satirical newspaper column mixes jokes about politics, baseball, and daily life with pointed skepticism about the Gunness case. It specifically wonders if Belle Gunness was clever enough to plant gold-filled teeth and wedding rings in the ruins, and jokes that detectives would be disappointed if she really did burn.
The New Haven Union · 21 May 1908 · page 4
It will be a sad blow to would-be detectives all over the country If Mrs. Gunness was really burned. Something wrong about that story from Pittsburg about the Indictment
Coroner C.S. Mack of LaPorte County issued a verdict that the body found in the ruins of the April 28 fire was that of Belle Gunness, who died through felonious homicide by an unknown perpetrator. The finding followed dental evidence from Dr. I.L. Norton, who identified bridges with false and gold-filled teeth as belonging to Mrs. Gunness.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 21 May 1908 · page 6
CORONER'S VERDICT IN GUNNESS CASE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Coroner Mack officially ruled that the adult female body found April 28 was Mrs. Belle Gunness and that she died by felonious homicide at the hands of an unknown perpetrator. Prosecutors claim new evidence against Ray Lamphere, alleging he returned to the Gunness house after setting the fire, undermining his alibi defense.
The San Francisco Call · 21 May 1908 · page 1
CORONER'S VERDICT IS MRS. GUNNESS IS DEAD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Indiana prosecutors suggest Ray Lamphere returned to the Smith house after setting the Gunness farmhouse fire, then left again later toward Wheatbrook, undercutting his alibi. Separately, a mother from Ohio arrived in Laporte to determine if her missing daughter, last seen in 1902, was among Mrs. Gunness's victims.
Los Angeles Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 1
NEW THEORY EXPLAINS ACTIONS OF LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
A letter received by LaPorte's mayor claims Belle Gunness was seen alive at a train depot in Ogden, Utah on May 4, a week after the fire destroyed her home. The writer, Samuel Harvey, says he recognized her despite her attempt to conceal her identity and that she said she was heading to California.
Evening Journal · 21 May 1908 · page 3
SAY MRS. GUNNESS IS STILL LIVING LAPORTE, Ind., May 21—In spite of evidence to show that she died In tho lire which destroyed her home. Mrs. Belle Guinness was alive on May 4, a
Laporte Coroner Mack issued the first official verdict in the Gunness case, declaring the adult female body found after the April 28 fire to be that of Mrs. Gunness, with death ruled a felonious homicide by an unknown perpetrator. The finding followed her dentist's identification of dental bridgework found in the ruins.
New-York Tribune · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Authorities in Laporte, Indiana prepare to indict Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, plus the death of Andrew Helgelein, with one count as accessory. Defense counsel cables Scotland Yard and Canadian police about a $4,000 reward for information leading to the capture of Gunness, believed to still be alive.
The Washington Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 1
WILL INDICT RAY LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
State's Attorney Smith announces plans to seek a six-count indictment against Ray Lamphere, including murder charges for Mrs. Gunness and her three children, plus arson. Meanwhile, a $4,000 reward is being publicized internationally, a letter describes a possible Gunness sighting in Washington, and a gold ring found in the debris may help identify another victim.
The Washington Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
The Laporte grand jury plans to indict Ray Lamphere on six counts related to the murders of Belle Gunness, her three children, and Andrew Helgelein, plus arson. Meanwhile, a letter describes a woman matching Gunness's description seen in Washington, D.C., prompting her attorney to alert Scotland Yard and Canadian police about the reward.
The Washington Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 1
WILL INDICT RAY LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
State's Attorney Smith announces plans to indict Ray Lamphere on six counts including murder of Mrs. Gunness and her children, complicity in Andrew Helgelein's death, and arson. A letter describes a woman believed to be Mrs. Gunness seen in Washington, while sifting of fire debris yields another gold ring that may help identify a victim.
The Washington Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 1
WILL INDICT RAY LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A satirical news-roundup item notes that people who claim to have seen Belle Gunness alive since her house fire are struggling to explain the teeth found in the ashes. It treats the sighting reports skeptically, contrasting them with the physical evidence from the ruins.
Evening Star · 21 May 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Authorities discovered several new spots of suspicious appearance on the Gunness farm, with Sheriff announcing digging for new bodies will resume Friday after sluicing operations finish. An indictment against Ray Lamphere is expected soon, and the State's case was strengthened by a formal verdict.
The Washington Times · 21 May 1908 · page 5
GUNNESS VICTIMS MAY BE INCREASED
dences of More Bodies on “Murder Farm.” LA FORTE, Ind., May 21.—Observers ‘of the Gunness case anticipate that the big murder mystery is likely to be thrown anew before the public in a manner as sensationa! as its first ap pearance, Saveral new spots of susoiclous ap peerance were discovered vesterday on the Gunness premises, and Shenifl Sraut Zer. announced that digging for new bbdies will be resumed on Friday, by which time the sluicing operations at the ruins of the farmhouse will have been
Coroner C.S. Mack issued a formal verdict declaring the body found was Belle Gunness and that she died by felonious homicide at the hands of an unknown perpetrator, strengthening the case against Ray Lamphere. The report also notes new suspicious areas found on the property, plans to resume digging for more bodies, Jennie Olson's burial, and inquiries into possible additional victims.
The Washington Times · 21 May 1908 · page 5
GUNNESS VICTIMS MAY
Zer. announced that digging for new bbdies will be resumed on Friday, by which time the sluicing operations at the ruins of the farmhouse will have been finished and indictments probably will have been returned against Ray Lam phere, The position of the State in Lam phere’s case was materially strengthens ed yesterday a*ernecn by the formal verdict on the death of Mrs. Delle Gun ness, rendered by Coroner C. S. Mack. In this report the coroner said: “It is my verdict that th+ body so ‘viewed is that of Belle Gunness; that she came to her death through felonious ‘ homicide, and that the perpetrator” thereof is to me unknown.” Mrs.
See moreSee less
H. Whitzer, of Toledo, Chic, ar ‘rived in town vesterday morning to in vestigate the report that her daughter, who, in 1902 attended the University of Valparaiso, Ind., nine m.les west of La Porte, was among Mrs, Gunness* vic tims, The body of Jennie Olson, of Chicago, was buried yesterday afternoon. William Mingay., formerly coachman for a wealthy family at 66 West Fifty ‘second street, New York, may have fallen a vietim to Mrs. Gunness. He left New York about April 1, 1904, pre. sumably for the Gunness far a,
The coroner rendered a formal verdict that the body found is Belle Gunness, who died of felonious homicide by a perpetrator unknown, strengthening the case against Ray Lamphere. New suspicious digging sites were found on the farm, with excavation to resume Friday, while Jennie Olson's body was buried and others came forward fearing relatives were victims.
The Washington Times · 21 May 1908 · page 5
GUNNESS VICTIMS MAY BE INCREASED - The Authorities Discover Evidences of More Bodies on "Murder Farm."
A brief local-interest column remarks that the Gunness murders will discourage people from using matrimonial agencies to find spouses. It suggests traditional courtship among known community members is safer and preferable.
The Marietta Journal · 21 May 1908 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
This passage is largely an unrelated political opinion column discussing Taft, Roosevelt, and Iowa politics. It includes a brief aside noting that Mrs. Gunness has been dubbed a 'female Bluebeard' by some editors.
Evening Times-Republican · 21 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
A mother from Toledo, Ohio arrived in Laporte to investigate whether her daughter, who disappeared in 1902 while attending Valparaiso University, was among Belle Gunness's victims. The daughter had last written that she was going on a visit before vanishing.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 21 May 1908 · page 1
GIRL GUNNESS VICTIM?
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
Investigators discuss identification efforts for bodies found in the Gunness farm debris, including Andrew Helgelien (Moe) and Jennie Olson, with a witness describing a suspicious masculine-voiced woman present the night Jennie disappeared. Unidentified remains are ordered buried as paupers while identifiable victims like Jennie Olson are claimed by family for proper burial.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 21 May 1908 · page 2
DISCOVERY OF UPPER AND LOWER PLATES IN DEBRIS AND IDENTIFICATION BY DENTIST SETTLES QUESTION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
Investigators found Mrs. Gunness's dental plates in the fire debris, which Sheriff Smutzer claimed definitively proved she died in the blaze. Meanwhile, autopsy evidence suggested four victims were killed and buried around Christmas Eve 1906, and a $4,000 reward poster was being prepared for anyone producing Mrs. Gunness alive.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Investigators identify Abraham Phillips of West Virginia as a probable victim of Mrs. Gunness; he left home in February 1907 with a large sum of money to marry a wealthy widow in Laporte and was never seen again. The report notes he answered matrimonial advertisements and was believed to have gone to Laporte to wed an unnamed woman.
Paper unidentified · 21 May 1908 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The prosecutor and police chief investigating the Gunness farm case received letters threatening their lives unless they drop the inquiry. Separately, a Stanhope, Iowa doctor who vanished after corresponding with a woman is feared to be among her possible victims.
Paper unidentified · 21 May 1908 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa
A dentist identifies false teeth found in the ashes of the Gunness house as belonging to Belle Gunness, prompting the coroner to likely rule the burned female body hers. Meanwhile the grand jury continues investigating and the prosecutor vows to seek the death penalty for Ray Lamphere.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS IS CERTAINLY DEAD HER FALSE TEETH ARE FOUND IN ASHES OF HER HOME
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa
State's Attorney Smith expresses confidence Lamphere will hang for the Helgelein murder and children's deaths, while Sheriff Smutzer investigates claims that several more missing men—Riedinger, Graham, and Gurholdt—were victims of Mrs. Gunness. Evidence including a letter and a watch matching one found in the ruins is cited as proof of additional murders.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Milk River Valley News · Harlem, Mont. · and 5 other papers
Dental evidence confirms a found jawbone belonged to Belle Gunness, while two more bodies are tentatively identified as Jennie Olsen and Ole Budsberg. Authorities appropriate $9,000 for the investigation, with a $5,000 reward for Gunness's capture, and expect grand jury indictments for murder and arson.
Milk River Valley News · 21 May 1908 · page 3
GUNNESS FARM MYSTERY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 5 papers
Camas Prairie Chronicle · Cottonwood, Idaho · 22 May 1908
The Kendrick Gazette · Kendrick, Idaho · 22 May 1908
Investigators continue excavating the Gunness farm but on Saturday found no new bodies for the first time since digging began. Doubt persists over whether the body found in the fire ruins is Belle Gunness herself or another victim, with speculation she may be alive and in hiding.
Paper unidentified · 21 May 1908 · page 4
EVIDENCE OF WHOLESALE MURDER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho
Prosecutors say they have evidence Lamphere returned to the Smith house after setting the fire, then made a second trip past the burning Gunness farmhouse, undermining his alibi. Separately, a mother from Toledo arrives to investigate whether her missing daughter was among Gunness's victims.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 21 May 1908 · page 1
SEVERE BLOW TO LAMPHERE'S THEORY
FARM HOUSE. LA PORTE, Ind., May 21.—That Ray Lamphere, held in jail on sus picion of having caused the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and others at the Gunness farm, may have returned to the home of Elizabeth Smith after setting fire to the Gunness house and then made another start for the Wheatbrook farm, where he was employed, 1 b a new theory ad vanced by the state. Representatives of the prosecu tion profess to have discovered evi dence to show that not only was Lamphere seen to go towards the Gunness house at about 3:30 on the morning of April 28 but that he was also seen to retrace his steps.
See moreSee less
This was at about the time that other witnesses will testify they saw lire shooting from the Gunness house. This new theory is that after re turning to the Smith house Lam phere made A fresh start for the country about an hour after the first departure, but that on his second trip he took the Guenther road, from which he could have seen the lire. If the state is able to fully sup port this theory it will be a blow to Lamphere's defense, for the ac cused is somewhat relying on an ali bi that will show that he went north that morning on the Guen ther road about an hour after the fire was started. Mrs. H. Whitzer of Toledo, O., ar rived today to investigate whether her daughter, who in 1902 attended the University of Valparaiso, 10 miles west of La Porte, was among Mrs. Gunness' victims. The girl disappeared from school after writ ing her mother that she was going on a visit. She was never heard of afterwards.
A Toledo woman arrives in Laporte to investigate whether her missing daughter, a former Valparaiso University student, was a victim of Belle Gunness. Coroner C. S. Mack issues a formal verdict identifying the body as Gunness's and ruling her death a homicide, strengthening the case against Ray Lamphere as more digging and possible indictments are planned.
The Lake County Times · 21 May 1908 · page 3
ANOTHER VICTIM REPORTED AT LAPORTE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
The coroner formally ruled Belle Gunness died by homicide at an unknown hand's, while Jennie Olson was buried near Andrew Helgelein's grave. The grand jury heard witnesses against Ray Lamphere, and authorities investigated new leads, including a possible victim named William Mingay and a suspicious hedged rectangle on the farm.
The Lake County Times · 21 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The report lists twelve men believed to have been murdered by Belle Gunness, though only ten bodies have been recovered from her farm. It notes that identification remains difficult, with Coroner Mack refusing to release remains to Asle Helgelein until more certainty is established.
Paper unidentified · 21 May 1908 · page 1
CHARGED TO MRS. GUNNESS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
An autopsy on seven bodies exhumed from Mrs. Gunness's property revealed one was a woman, reviving interest in Emil Greening's account of Jennie Olsen's disappearance. The woman's body was found in the same hole as Jennie Olsen and Ole Budsberg, whose remains were identifiable, along with another unidentified male.
Paper unidentified · 21 May 1908 · page 4
TRIO KILLED IN ONE NIGHT AUTOPSY AT LAPORTE INDICATES A TRIPLE MURDER WATCH CARRIED BY LAMPHERE IDENTIFIED AS PROPERTY OF JOHN MOE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Investigators report that autopsies on bodies found in the same pit as Jennie Olsen revealed a woman, Ole Budsberg, and a male victim, suggesting Mrs. Gunness killed Jennie along with a visiting couple the same night. A relative identifies a watch taken from Ray Lamphere as belonging to missing John Moe, confirming he was likely another victim.
Paper unidentified · 21 May 1908 · page 4
OF JOHN MOE,
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Dr. L.P. Norton positively identifies gold bridgework found by placer miner Louis Schultz in the ashes of the Gunness farmhouse as teeth he made for Belle Gunness. A letter also surfaces identifying a missing Wisconsin farmer, Riedger, as a probable victim who left with $1,000 to marry a widow near Chicago.
Paper unidentified · 21 May 1908 · page 5
MRS. GUNNESS WAS BURNED MRS. GUNNESS' DENTIST POSITIVELY IDENTIFIES BRIDGE WORK TAKEN FROM THE DEBRIS OF HER HOME BY MINERS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A dentist's diagram helps Sheriff Smutzer identify a second set of riveted teeth found in the ruins, matching his description of dental work done for Belle Gunness. A letter from a Wisconsin farmer names a missing man, Riedger or Riedinger, as another probable victim who left home with $1,000 to marry a widow near Chicago.
Paper unidentified · 21 May 1908 · page 5
DEBRIS OF HER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A coroner's inquest formally ruled that the body found was Belle Gunness and that she died by homicide at an unknown hand's doing. Meanwhile, a letter to the mayor claimed a man recognized her alive in Ogden, Utah, on May 4, deepening the mystery as the grand jury met and new digging for bodies was planned.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 21 May 1908 · page 1
EVIDENCE AND THE CORONER DIFFER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Coroner C.S. Mack formally rules Belle Gunness's death a felonious homicide by an unknown perpetrator, strengthening the state's case against Ray Lamphere as digging resumes at the farm ruins. New evidence—a Swedish razor and an inscribed gold ring—is uncovered, and prosecutors advance a theory that Lamphere doubled back to watch the fire before fleeing north.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 21 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A Laporte correspondent, Charles Way, writes that local residents doubt Mrs. Gunness died in the fire, believing the dental plates found in the ruins may not be hers or were planted by friends to fake her death. The letter also claims that Ray Lamphere may be innocent of the arson and murder charges.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 21 May 1908 · page 7
BELIEVES THAT MRS. GUNNESS IS NOT DEAD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
LaPorte Coroner Mack concluded a two-week inquest, ruling that the body examined was indeed Belle Gunness and that she died by felonious homicide at the hands of an unknown perpetrator. Dental evidence was cited as the key link confirming the body's identity.
Rock Island Argus · 21 May 1908 · page 1
GUNNESS VERDICT IS ONE OF MURDER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Dziennik Narodowy · Chicago, Ill.
The coroner in Laporte issued an official verdict that the body found in the ashes was Belle Gunness, murdered by an unknown person, based on a dentist recognizing her gold teeth. The report also notes Jennie Olson's funeral, anonymous letters to the prosecutor including one claiming to be from Gunness, and a search for a Black cook who worked for her.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Dziennik Narodowy · 21 May 1908 · page 1
ROZPOZNANIE ZWŁOK. KORONER WYDAŁ WERDYKT O ŚMIERCI GUNNESSOWEJ
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Coroner Mack has officially ruled that the adult female body found April 28 in the fire ruins is that of Mrs. Belle Gunness. The verdict further finds she died of felonious homicide, with the perpetrator unknown.
The Topeka State Journal · 21 May 1908 · page 1
IT IS MRS. GUNNESS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Sheriff Smutzer finishes sluicing debris from the Gunness house and plans to resume digging for more bodies. Authorities also receive letters and inquiries about people connected to Mrs. Gunness, including a possible sighting and a missing suitor.
The Topeka State Journal · 21 May 1908 · page 10
Farm Tonight. Laporte. Ind., May 21. Sheriff Smutzer will this evening finish the sluicing of the debris of the Gunness house and tomorrow morning he will resume digging In the hope of finding more bodies. Mayor Darrow received an unsigned letter from Omaha, Neb., the writer claiming to have been in Laporte three times last year to visit Mrs. Gunness and to have met her in Ogden, Utah, on May 4, when she said she was on her way to California to visit Jennie Olsen. Inquiries were received today by the authorities regarding George W. Will lams of Wapawallopen. Pa., who is un derstood by friends to have come to Laporte. in answer to matrimonial advertisements from a rich widow. He never returned home.
Thousands of sightseers again visited the Gunness farm on Sunday, viewing the skeletal remains of unidentified victims and buying souvenirs amid a festive, picnic-like atmosphere. The LaPorte County grand jury was set to convene Monday to hear evidence, with dozens of witnesses summoned and a report expected by week's end.
Abilene Weekly Reflector · 21 May 1908 · page 9
WAS LIKE A COUNTRY FAIR
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Citizen · Berea, Ky.
Investigators report finding false teeth plates in the ruins of the burned Gunness farmhouse, said to be positive proof that Belle Gunness died in the fire. The discovery is presented as confirming her death after earlier doubts.
The Citizen · 21 May 1908 · page 1
MRS GUNNESS DEAD
Fuller who now holds the place would soon resign and it is not customary to appoint one of tho Associate Jus tices chief Mr Root is probably tho moat brilliant lawyer in flits country and there is no reason to believe that he will not make a great Chief Jus tics but ho was in his younger years connected with several big trusts and for that reason he will bo violently opposed by many men As Roosevelt has a sort of reputation for hating the trusts and as he has been In close contact with Mr Root for years it is likely that Mr Root Is pretty safe for tho country MRS iUNNESS DEAD Positive proot that Mrs Gunness tho great murderess was burned In the rulna of her home was found Tuesday when miners discovered the false teeth plates which bad been fastened In her moiith
Andrew Helgelein, the last known victim lured by Belle Gunness, was buried with Christian rites after Bertillon experts confirmed his identity through prison records. A dentist's examination of a charred jawbone fragment also confirmed it belonged to Mrs. Gunness, countering rumors she had escaped, while David Havens, a missing witness, was located in Michigan.
The Citizen · 21 May 1908 · page 5
GUNNESS VICTIM IS BURIED HELGELEINS BODY INTERRED AFTER IDENTIFICATION
Loporte IndThe first of tho Oun ness victims to be Interred with Chris tlon rites was burled Friday night In 1atlonn cemetery on the outskirts of aporte Tho corpse was that of Andrew K Helgeleln of Mansfield S D the last man to meet his death In the trap to which Mn Gunness lured her victims The body was released for burial after Coroner Mack had received the reports of the Dertlllon experts who hare examined It and compared their findings with figures taken from the records of the Minnesota penitentiary at Still water
A dentist's analysis of a charred jawbone found in the farmhouse ruins matched characteristics of Mrs. Gunness's teeth, leading the prosecuting attorney to declare this conclusive proof she was among the dead rather than having escaped. Separately, two men previously feared missing or murdered—David Havens and Charles Edmonds—were both located alive and well, having simply left the area for work.
The Citizen · 21 May 1908 · page 5
AFTER IDENTIFICATION
In Charles Kdrnonds a former em ploys ot Mn Gunness who was sup posed to have been one of her vie Urns He ban been working at a farm only a few miles from the Gunness
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Miner Louis Schultz found a set of false teeth in the ashes of the burned Gunness house, which dentist Dr. Norton positively identified as belonging to Mrs. Gunness. The coroner said he would likely rule the burned body was hers, while authorities also investigated reports of another missing man believed to be a victim.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 21 May 1908 · page 10
POINT GAINED IN GUNNESS CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Sheriff Smutzer investigates claims that farmers William Riedinger and Henry Gurholdt were victims of Mrs. Gunness, with a watch matching one found in the ruins confirming Gurholdt's fate. Separately, a watch found on Ray Lamphere is identified as belonging to another victim, John Moe, while seven unidentified bodies are buried and a sighting of Mrs. Gunness in Iowa is dismissed since she is believed dead.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 21 May 1908 · page 10
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Coroner Mack delivers his official verdict that the adult female body found in the fire ruins is that of Belle Gunness, and that she died by felonious homicide at the hands of an unknown perpetrator. This followed the dentist's identification of a dental bridge found among the remains.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Kennebec Journal · 21 May 1908 · page 12
THE CORONER'S VERDICT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · and 2 other papers
Investigators in Laporte reported finding three more suspected victims of Belle Gunness and evidence she had an accomplice luring men to her farm. A dentist identified jawbone fragments from the farmhouse ruins as belonging to Gunness herself, while identification of another body as John Moe failed and thousands toured the farm.
River Falls Journal · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 2 papers
The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich. · 22 May 1908
Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio · 22 May 1908
Belding Banner · Belding, Mich.
Mrs. Mary Newman of West Saginaw contacted La Porte authorities fearing her husband, about 65, may have been lured to the Gunness farm. She noted he was last seen in that area with a horse and buggy, speculating the many strange men who visited the Gunness place might explain his disappearance.
Belding Banner · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn. · and 1 other paper
Sheriff Smutzer and an assistant sifting the ashes of the Gunness farmhouse report finding upper and lower false teeth plates, identified by her dentist as belonging to Mrs. Gunness. The sheriff declares this proves beyond doubt that she died in the fire, though the prosecutor admits many locals still believe she is alive.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 21 May 1908 · page 2
FALSE TEETH FOUND Further Evidence That Mrs. Gunness Perished in Fire
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D. · 22 May 1908
The Taney County Republican · Forsyth, Mo.
Two additional bodies have been unearthed on Mrs. Gunness's farm near La Porte, Indiana, bringing the total number discovered to date to eleven. The report appears amid a roundup of brief national news items.
The Taney County Republican · 21 May 1908 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Ray Lamphere is reported near collapse, with authorities expecting a full confession soon after a Baltimore minister claimed Lamphere had partially confessed to him. That same minister, Rev. E. A. Schell, asserted that the body found in the Gunness house ruins was not Belle Gunness herself, and that the children had been chloroformed before the fire.
Mexico Missouri Message · 21 May 1908 · page 2
CRISIS NEAR IN GUNNESS CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Hattiesburg News · Hattiesburg, Miss.
Investigators in LaPorte, Indiana believe more bodies remain buried on the Gunness farm, and digging is set to resume. The prosecution's case against Ray Lamphere is said to be strengthened by what is called undisputed evidence that Belle Gunness died in the fire.
The Hattiesburg News · 21 May 1908 · page 1
ARE BURIED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wibaux Pioneer · Wibaux, Mont.
Authorities report positive identification of three additional victims at the Gunness farm, bringing the suspected death toll higher, with evidence pointing to at least nine more victims including men, a woman, a girl, and an infant. Thousands of sightseers continue to flock to the farm, some seeking information about missing relatives.
The Wibaux Pioneer · 21 May 1908 · page 2
MAKE PROGRESS IN MURDER MYSTERY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wibaux Pioneer · Wibaux, Mont.
Thousands of visitors toured the Gunness farm near Laporte, some seeking news of missing relatives while others treated the scene as a curiosity. Meanwhile, Dr. J.H. William Meyer reported autopsy findings on bodies believed to be Andrew Helgelein and Jennie Olsen, and witnesses recounted Belle Gunness's fear of arrest after her husband's death.
The Wibaux Pioneer · 21 May 1908 · page 2
RAY LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wibaux Pioneer · Wibaux, Mont.
The report covers testimony about Mrs. Gunness consulting an attorney before her husband's burial and digging suspicious ditches, alongside medical findings that Helgelein and Miss Olsen died unnatural deaths with evidence of a struggle. The grand jury is preparing to consider the case against Ray Lamphere as three more victims are identified amid contradictory developments.
The Wibaux Pioneer · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D. · and 4 other papers
Officials deny Rev. Schell revealed details of Lamphere's confession, while new evidence suggests Mrs. Gunness had an accomplice luring victims to the farm. A miner sifting the cellar ashes finds fused metal and bone fragments, and a witness describes Gunness's fear of Lamphere before the fire.
Union County Courier · 21 May 1908 · page 6
22 DEATHS LAID TO MRS. GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 4 papers
Golden Valley Chronicle · Beach, N.D. · 22 May 1908
The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D. · 22 May 1908
The Sisseton Weekly Standard · Sisseton, S.D. · 22 May 1908
The Wibaux Pioneer · Wibaux, Mont. · 28 May 1908
The Loup City Northwestern · Loup City, Neb.
This report describes storm damage from a tornado that struck Nebraska towns including Louisville and Bellevue, detailing property losses and appeals for aid. It includes official relief efforts, corrected damage estimates, and the dispatch of national guard tents and supplies to homeless victims.
The Loup City Northwestern · 21 May 1908 · page 1
AID FOR THE MANY SUFFERERS AN APPEAL FOR HELP FOR THE DEATH HARVESTER. A Crop on the Gunness Farm. AT LEAST SEVEN ABE DEAD FATALITIES OF EASTERN NEBRAS
The autopsy on seven unidentified bodies exhumed from Mrs. Gunness's farm showed one was female, reviving interest in Daniel Greening's account of Jennie Olson's disappearance. Grand jury proceedings began at Laporte as the sheriff continued gathering evidence and an officer received a threatening letter.
The Alliance Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 2
MRS. GUNNESS DEAD tLATE8 CONTAINING HER FAL8E 1 TEETH FOUND IN A8HE8. Sheriff Still Trying to Qet Evldtnca at Gunnesa Farm Grand Jury Bs gins Its Work at Laportt Offlcar
The Laporte grand jury began investigating the Gunness murders while more victims' remains were analyzed, including those of Olo Budsberg and an unidentified couple. Separately, dentist-identified false teeth found in the fire ruins led Coroner Mack to officially rule that the burned female body was Belle Gunness.
The Alliance Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 2
TEETH FOUND IN ASHES
Tho Laporte grand Jury convened ond began investigation of tho mys tery surrounding the death of fourteen persons nt tho farm of Mrs. Bello Gun ness. Prosecutor Smith questioned tho wltncssos and the testimony is be ing noted by a court stenographer. Prosecutor Smith received another threatening letter from Brooklyn, N. Y. Ho Is threatened with death un Icsb he resigns his office and drops the Gunness Investigation. He also re ceived a threatening letter from "Washington, D. C. Chief of Police Cochrane is In receipt of a letter from New York saying his life will pay for feit unless ho ceases his activity.
See moreSee less
The bodies of tho sovon unidentified dead will bo buried In tho pottersfleld. Mrs. Gunness' Teeth Found. That Mrs. Gunness died In tho ames which destroyed her home April 28 was conclusively shown when a searcher In the ruins discovered tlw upper and lower bridges, containing tho false teeth of the woman. Tho lower set of teeth tally exactly with tho description nnd diagram furnished Ty Dr. I. P. Norton, tho dentist, who "built the bridge, and who identified the teeth positively as thoso of Mrs. Gunness. in view qf the unmistakablo evidence, including the finding ouo week ago of rings belonging to tho murderess, Coroner Mack stated that ho would render an ofllclal finding that (he burned adult female body was that of Mrs. Gunness.
Coroner Mack declares the burned adult female body officially identified as Mrs. Gunness, based on dental bridgework matching dentist's records plus previously found rings. The report also details suspected victims Riedinger and Gurholdt, with evidence like a matching watch description tying Gurholdt to Mrs. Gunness.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Alliance Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 2
MRS. GUNNESS DEAD tLATE8 CONTAINING HER FAL8E 1 TEETH FOUND IN A8HE8. Sheriff Still Trying to Qet Evldtnca at Gunnesa Farm Grand Jury Bs gins Its Work at Laportt Offlcar Receive Threatening Letter. The autopsy hold nt Laporto, Ind., en the remains of tho seven un Identified dead exhumed from Mrs. Gunnese' privnto burial ground was complotcxl and revealed tho fact that lone of the sovon was a fcmalo. ThU has aroused new Interest in tho story tar Dinll Greening of Oklahoma City, Olcla., who was employed by Mrs. Gun biess In the fall of 1004.
See moreSee less
Greening Kvorkcd for Mrs. Qunness at tho tlmo that Jennlo Olson disappeared and ibis story was to tho offoct that on a certain day in September a man and n woman came to the house and that night Mrs. Gunncss asked Greening to sleep in tho bam, for tho couple, whom she said were the professor and Ills wife from the Los Angeles college which Jennie was to attend, would spend the night with her nt the house and would requiro Greening's bed room. In tho morning Crooning saw nothing of Jennie nor the man or womnn nnd was Informed by Mrs. Gunncss thnt they had left on an early train, taking Jennlo along. This body, which Is now dcclnrcd to be that of a woman, was taken from the samo holo ns was that of Jennlo Olson and In that holo also were the bodies of Olo Budsberg of Iola, Wis., trtid the re mains of a male person. All the bodies wore dismembered, but the trunks of the four woro such that It was possi ble to Identify the bodies of Jonnle Olson nnd Mr. Iludsborg, and It was made posslblo by tho autopsies to de termine thnt one-of the other two was that of a fonmle. The theory Is now ndvanced thnt Mrs. Gunncss may have on the samo night, the night that Greening slopt In tho barn, murdered not only Jennie Olson, but also the man and womnn. To Coroner Mnclc, Sheriff Smutzer and Prosecutor Smith this seems almost Inconceivable, but they consider In tho light of recent developments that nothing appeared Impossible for this nrch-murdercss. The stomachs of tho four victims In this holo hnvo been removed and' tho contents will bo analyzed for poison. The disappearance of Jennie Olson, as well as tho couple, occurred In Sep tember, 190G, whllo nud8berg wus dis posed of In May, 1007. His body was not nonrcr the surface than the others and his should havo been the last placod in the hole. Grand Jury Gets Busy, Tho Laporte grand Jury convened ond began investigation of tho mys tery surrounding the death of fourteen persons nt tho farm of Mrs. Bello Gun ness. Prosecutor Smith questioned tho wltncssos and the testimony is be ing noted by a court stenographer. Prosecutor Smith received another threatening letter from Brooklyn, N. Y. Ho Is threatened with death un Icsb he resigns his office and drops the Gunness Investigation. He also re ceived a threatening letter from "Washington, D. C. Chief of Police Cochrane is In receipt of a letter from New York saying his life will pay for feit unless ho ceases his activity. The bodies of tho sovon unidentified dead will bo buried In tho pottersfleld. Mrs. Gunness' Teeth Found. That Mrs. Gunness died In tho ames which destroyed her home April 28 was conclusively shown when a searcher In the ruins discovered tlw upper and lower bridges, containing tho false teeth of the woman. Tho lower set of teeth tally exactly with tho description nnd diagram furnished Ty Dr. I. P. Norton, tho dentist, who "built the bridge, and who identified the teeth positively as thoso of Mrs. Gunness. in view qf the unmistakablo evidence, including the finding ouo week ago of rings belonging to tho murderess, Coroner Mack stated that ho would render an ofllclal finding that (he burned adult female body was that of Mrs. Gunness. The town has been rent for two weeks by tho discussions over tho question, "Waa Mrs, Gunness burned to death, or did she escape?" But few skeptical persona now re main, and their argumeut is that Mrs. Gunness, after killing tho children and setting flro to tho house, threw her teeth Into the Are. Sheriff SmutEor Is investigating the claim that William Rledlnger, a farm er at Delaileld, Wis., was one of Mrs. dunness victims. In a letter, David Hicken, a friend living at Waukesha. Wis., tells of the disappearance from homo of Kledlnger, who, after a visit from Mrs. Gunness, sold some crops, which netted him $1,000, and left for (some place in northern Indiana "to suarry a wealthy widow," he said. A bionth later his hired mnn, John (HeinUselraan, received a letter, in structing him to sell tho stock and ifarm implements nnd put the money In the bank. Although tho letter was unsigned and not in the handwriting of Rledlnger, the hired mun followed the Instructions and deposited $900 in the bank, where it still Is, for Rledln ger nevor returned and was not heard from after that. Miss Jennie Graham lof Waukesha, Wis., is teeklng her brother, who left homo to marry a rich widow in Indiana and was never Iheard from after that. What is considered positive proof that Henry Gurholdt of Scandinavia, rwis., came to Laporto and was put out of the way by Mrs. Gunnes3 was supplied when Shorlff Smutzer re ceived a letter containing a descrip tion of Gurholdt's watch, which tallies with "no of the watches found In the ruins. DEQS AND HANFORD NAMED Socialists Nominate Standard Bearer for Presidential Race, Eugene V. Debs of Indianapolis was nominated for president and Benjamin Hanford of New York for vice presi dent by the Socialist party national convention at Chicago. A draft of the platform was pre tented to the convention. The demands tet forth in it Include national owacr ship of public utilities and of all great industries of national icop "In wklch competition has virtually ceased to exist," extension of the public domain to Include mines, quarries, oil wells, forosts and water power and iclaatilc reforestation of timber lands and rec lamation of swamp lands. Touching
A brief local-interest item recounts that a man who could not raise $1,000 to satisfy Mrs. Gunness' marriage demand was spared, as he later realized after the horrific discoveries at her farm. The item is embedded among unrelated local gossip, jokes, and business advertisements.
The Alliance Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.
A newspaper editorial column makes a sarcastic aside about the continued digging for victims' bones on the Gunness farm, questioning whether crops are being neglected during the search. The bulk of the passage is unrelated local commentary on weather, politics, and civic matters.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 21 May 1908 · page 2
While mucl), is said about the work of plowing up bones on the Gunness farm, no reference is made to the condition of this year’s wheat and . corn crops on the place. Are the crops suffering neglect while the vic tims of Mrs. Gunness are being col lected and invoiced? People are mistaken in assuming more right to hurt another by insin uation than by direct charges. Hint ing at “graft” is no more just, With out proof, than a positive allegation, for the injurious effect from the for mer may equal that from the latter, and it is the effect that counts.
Sheriff Smutzer and an assistant sifting the ashes of the Gunness farmhouse fire found upper and lower dental plates, which her dentist Dr. I. P. Norton identified as hers. The sheriff declared this proof that Mrs. Guinness died in the blaze.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Beatrice Daily Express · 21 May 1908 · page 2
MRS. GUINNESS WAS BURNED TO DEATH
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
A brief index entry notes that the coroner has made his official return in the case of Mrs. Gunness's death. No further details are given in this digest-style listing of news items.
Omaha Daily Bee · 21 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
State investigators claim Ray Lamphere may have returned to the Smith house after setting the Gunness house fire, then made a second trip past the blaze, undermining his alibi. Separately, a Toledo woman arrives to investigate whether her missing daughter, last heard from in 1902, was among Gunness's victims.
Omaha Daily Bee · 21 May 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE'S STEPS FOLLOWED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · Goldsboro, N.C.
The report describes the Gunness farm near LaPorte, Indiana, where the house burned and 14 bodies were found, including a headless woman and children. It states that no one yet knows whether Mrs. Gunness is alive or dead, or whether she committed murders, calling the case an unresolved mystery pending investigation.
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 21 May 1908 · page 4
WHEN SHE'S BAD, SHE'S BAD
Porte are completed no one will be in a position to say whether LaPorte has a horror or a mystery. If all reports be confirmed, then, indeed, we will have to accept the Italian proverb: "The woman is seldom wicked, but when she is, she surpasses the man."
The LaPorte grand jury continued its investigation into the murders at Belle Gunness's farm, with the prosecutor claiming enough evidence to hang Ray Lamphere. Autopsies revealed one of seven exhumed bodies was female, reviving theories about the disappearance of Jennie Olsen and a mysterious couple in 1904.
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 21 May 1908 · page 6
Threatening Letters. Special to The Argus. LaPorte, Ind., May 19. The grand jury today commenced the second day of its probing into the wholesale mur ders on the farm of Mrs. Belle Gun ness. Soon after the hearing began Prosecutor Smith sai i, "I have evi dence enoi'gh already toi hang Ray Lamphere ror his ymrt in the wholesale
Coroner's investigation reveals additional bodies in the pit, including Jennie Olsen, Ole Budsburg, and an unidentified man and woman, with theories about Mrs. Gunness murdering them together. A mysterious watch found on Ray Lamphere is identified as belonging to missing man John Moe, confirming another victim.
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 21 May 1908 · page 6
Gunness may have on th same night murdered Jennie Olsen and the man and woman who had come to take her to California and had buried all three bodies, dismembered, in the same pit. The body of Bndgburg, who was mur dered later than this night, was found nearer the surface than the other three. The mystery surrounding the watch iound on Kay Lampbere when he was arrested was cleared today when J. G. Ramden, of Manired, N.D., who came yesterday to investigate the disap pearance of his halt-brother, John Moe, of Elbow Lake, Minn., identified the time piece as the one owned by Moe -wh.cn he left home.
See moreSee less
Lamphere said that Mrs. Gunness gave him the watch. The bodies of the seven unide nti fied dead wili be buried tomorrow in the Potter's field. The body of Jennie Olsen has been turned over to rela tives. Ole Bmisbuig's body was today shipped to Iola, Wis., tor burial. Coroner Mack is still holding the tour bodies found in the fire ruins ol the burned Gunness home and which, according to evidence produced, are the bodies of Mrs. Gunnessg and her three children.
The Miller Press · Miller, S.D. · and 1 other paper
LaPorte officials deny Rev. Schell revealed details of Lamphere's confession, while new evidence suggests Mrs. Gunness had an accomplice who lured victims via a Cleveland contact. A miner sifting the farm's ashes finds fused metal and bone fragments, and a witness recounts the widow's fear of Lamphere before the fire.
The Miller Press · 21 May 1908 · page 2
22 DEATHS LAID TO MRS. GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D. · 22 May 1908
The Oakes Times · Oakes, N.D.
Dr. I. P. Norton, who had performed dental work on Belle Gunness, examined a jaw bone fragment found on the farm and confirmed it was human and strongly resembled her lower jaw. A new grave site was also discovered about forty rods from the location where ten bodies had already been exhumed, with two more suspicious spots marked for excavation.
The Oakes Times · 21 May 1908 · page 2
JAW OF MRS. GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.
Two additional watches were found in the debris of the ruined Gunness house, bringing the total to eleven watches found despite only ten male victims being unearthed. Sheriff Smutzer announced he would resume excavation, likely focusing next under the flooring of the barn basement.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 21 May 1908 · page 2
TWO MORE WATCHES FOUND
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.
Dr. I. P. Norton, who had performed dental work on Belle Gunness, examined a jaw bone fragment found on her farm and confirmed it was human and strongly resembled her lower jaw. The coroner had brought him the specimen for identification.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 21 May 1908 · page 4
JAW OF MRS. GUNNESS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.
Ray Lamphere, held as an accomplice in the Gunness farm murders, denies making any confession to a minister or anyone else. Laporte banks agree to supply transaction records to prosecutors, a mail carrier reveals Mrs. Gunness used three aliases, and a watch found in the ruins is identified as belonging to victim Ole Budsberg.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 21 May 1908 · page 9
DENIED BY LAMPHERE
Made No Confession. Laporte, Ind., May 14.—Mrs. Gun hess* hired man, Ray Lamphere, vig orously denies that he had made any confession' or promised any to Rev. E. A. Schell or to aay one else. Lam phere is under arrest here changed with complicity in the wholesale mur ders at the Gunness farm. Officials of the three Laporte banks held a conference to determine the most effective way In aiding the au thorities in untangling the murder mysteries. It was decided that the First National bank of Laporte, the Citizens' Savings bank and theState Bank of Indiana should furnish a list of all transactions In which Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gun ness -paid out, depositedor received money. With a complete list of this kind Prosecutor Smith expects he will be able to secure valuable Informa tion. B. J. Hunter, the mall carrier on the route on which tfco Gunness farm is situated, says that Mrs. Gunness carried on her matrimonial business under three names. He says he has delivered scores of letters to Mrs. Gunness under the names of ''Mrs. Bella Sorenson," "Mrs. Bella Gunness" and "Mrs. Jennie Hinkley "4' One of the watches found in the ruins of the Gunness home has been Identified as a watch of OleiBudBberg, one Of the supposed victims of Mrs.
Authorities in Laporte report rapidly accumulating evidence in the Gunness farm murders, with suggestions that an accomplice may be arrested and a witness may reveal further horrors. A minister's telegram adds to speculation that Ray Lamphere, already accused of arson, will soon confess.
The Bowbells Tribune · 21 May 1908 · page 6
AUTHORITIES EXPECT CONFESSION FROM LAMPHERE
Laporte, Ind., May 14.—Evidence which ithe authorities believe will go for toward clarifying the mystery of the murders at the Gunness farm ac cumulated with accelerated rapidity. From guarded statement by officials and a few faots which have leaked out it Is ibelieved generally that the inves tigators are preparing to spring a coup in the arrest of an accomplice of Mrs. Gunness in the murders and the production of a witness who will itell tales of horror surpassing anything that has been told since the dismem bered bodies were exhumed in Mrs.
Investigators are chasing a lead in another Indiana city that could affect Ray Lamphere's case, while a minister predicts Lamphere will confess. Prosecutor Smith says his evidence is strong, Lamphere's hair was cut for forensic use, and the defense plans to argue a letter from Gunness was meant to mislead Lamphere during the Helgelein murder.
The defense in the Lamphere trial will not dispute he was in Laporte the night Helgelein was likely murdered, but will argue a letter from Mrs. Gunness was used to send him away so she could kill Helgelein. New evidence also surfaced that John O. Moo, who withdrew $1,100 before vanishing from the Gunness farm around Christmas 1906, was likely another of her murder victims.
Coroner O. B. Mack delivered an official verdict that the body found in the ruins of the Gunness farmhouse fire was that of Belle Gunness, who died from felonious homicide at the hands of an unknown perpetrator. This followed dentist Dr. Norton's identification of dental bridgework recovered from the debris as belonging to Mrs. Gunness.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 21 May 1908 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.
Miner Louis Schultz found false teeth bridges in the ashes of the Gunness house, and dentist Dr. I. P. Norton identified the lower bridge as his own work made for Mrs. Gunness about a year earlier. Coroner Mack says he will likely rule the burned female body is Belle Gunness, while the grand jury continues investigating Ray Lamphere and reports of missing men.
The Monmouth Inquirer · 21 May 1908 · page 2
HID GUNNESS TEETH
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
A humor column about foolish love letters mocks Senator Platt and other men who write ridiculous letters to women. It references Mrs. Gunness, calling her operation a 'matrimonial slaughter house,' as an example of women skilled at manipulating men.
The Evening World · 21 May 1908 · page 14
FOOLISH LETTERS
J When a woman has arrived at o Mrs Mae Wood or Mrs Gunness matrimonial arcnrv men she un derstands how to handle men t Not throuch the bloom of beau I
A Cleveland man's letter describes being shown a photo of Belle Gunness and urged to visit her farm, suggesting she had an accomplice in luring victims. Meanwhile Lamphere's lawyer denies any confession, and prosecutor Smith receives a death threat along with a letter claiming Gunness is still alive.
The News-Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 2
GUNNESS WOMAN HAD ACCOMPLICE: CLEVELAND MAN WRITES ABOUT ATTEMPT TO LURE HIM TO THE FARM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The News-Herald · Hillsboro, Ohio
Prosecutor Smith receives death threats over the Gunness case while new evidence emerges including jawbone fragments and skin found in the farmhouse cellar. Helgelein's body is buried after Bertillon identification, and a dentist's analysis of charred bone confirms it matches Mrs. Gunness' teeth, countering escape rumors.
The News-Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Columbian · Bloomsburg, Pa.
Investigators found upper and lower artificial teeth plates in the ashes of the Gunness home, which Dr. L.P. Norton identified as belonging to Belle Gunness. Sheriff Smutzer declared this proved she burned to death, while Jennie Olsen's body was also officially identified and Ray Lamphere's murder trial was set no earlier than September 1.
The Columbian · 21 May 1908 · page 6
Mrs. Gunness Dead.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bon Homme County Independent · Tabor, S.D.
Frank C. Friend of Plainview, Nebraska, formerly of LaPorte, Indiana, says he knew Mrs. Gunness personally. He expresses surprise that she is even suspected of such terrible crimes.
The Bon Homme County Independent · 21 May 1908 · page 7
KNEW MRS. GUNNESS, SHE SURPRISED HIM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D.
The report describes Laporte overwhelmed by morbid sightseers at the Gunness murder farm, with vendors profiting from the crowds while authorities continue investigating. Sheriff Smutzer believes Belle Gunness had an accomplice in her 'marriage bureau' scheme, possibly Ray Lamphere, based on letters found after the fire.
Turner County Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D.
Laporte mayor Lemuel Darrow announces the investigation into the Gunness murders will be pushed more rigorously, suspecting more bodies may be found. Ray Lamphere is named as a suspect, alongside mention of witness Bessie Wallace who knows him.
Turner County Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 4
MURDER FARM IS A MAGNET.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Pierre Weekly Free Press · Pierre, S.D.
A dentist confirms a skull fragment belongs to Mrs. Gunness, while Helgelien's body is buried after identification is established. Investigators uncover evidence of a possible accomplice who lured victims to the farm, plus a threatening letter demanding the search be stopped.
Pierre Weekly Free Press · 21 May 1908 · page 2
HELGELIEN'S BODY INTERRED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Miller Press · Miller, S.D.
A Sioux Falls report quotes former Faulk County deputy sheriff J.E. Stevenson describing Andrew Helgelein, a presumed victim of Belle Gunness, as part of a troublesome family with a criminal reputation in South Dakota. Stevenson recounts Helgelein's past arrest for burglary, though he was acquitted for lack of evidence.
The Miller Press · 21 May 1908 · page 1
SO. DAK. VICTIM OF MURDER FARM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D.
Sheriff Smutzer and Miner Schultz recovered Mrs. Gunness's upper and lower dental plates from the fire debris, identified by her dentist Dr. Norton. The sheriff declared this proof beyond doubt that Gunness died in the blaze.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Reporter and Farmer · 21 May 1908 · page 9
HER FALSE TEETH FOUND
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Citizen-Republican · Scotland, S.D.
Andrew Helgelein, the last man lured to his death by Belle Gunness, became the first victim given a Christian burial in Laporte. The prosecutor cited dental identification of a charred jawbone as conclusive proof the remains found were Mrs. Gunness herself, meant to quash rumors she had escaped.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Citizen-Republican · 21 May 1908 · page 2
SOUTH DAKOTA VICTIM IS BURIED AT LAPORTE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Citizen-Republican · Scotland, S.D.
Frank C. Friend of Plainview, Nebraska, formerly of LaPorte, Indiana, knew Mrs. Gunness personally and expressed surprise that she was suspected of such terrible crimes. The brief item appears amid unrelated local news items.
The Citizen-Republican · 21 May 1908 · page 3
KNEW MRS. GUNNESS, SHE SURPRISED HIM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Bryan Morning Eagle · Bryan, Tex.
Expert miner Louis Shultz found upper and lower dental bridges in the ashes of the burned Gunness house, bridges reportedly belonging to Belle Gunness, prompting the coroner to consider officially ruling the burned body was hers. Separately, a letter describing a watch matching one found in the ruins was called proof that missing man Henry Guerholdt had been murdered by Gunness.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Bryan Morning Eagle · 21 May 1908 · page 4
Positive Proof of Another Crime Now Thought to Have Been Secured.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Spanish Fork Press · Spanish Fork, Utah
A searcher in the fire ruins found upper and lower dental bridges matching the exact specifications given by Dr. Norton, the dentist who made them for Mrs. Gunness. Coroner Mack declared this, along with rings found at the scene, conclusive evidence that the burned adult female body was indeed Belle Gunness, despite skeptics suggesting she threw her own teeth into the flames after killing her children.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Spanish Fork Press · 21 May 1908 · page 1
VICTIM WAS MRS GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Spanish Fork Press · Spanish Fork, Utah
Herman Rhode insisted he saw and spoke with Belle Gunness in St. Paul no later than Tuesday, convinced by her resemblance to published photographs. He went to the St. Paul Dispatch office and reaffirmed his identification after being shown her photograph.
The Spanish Fork Press · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
Coroner Mack's official verdict declared that the body found in the ruins of the Gunness farmhouse fire was that of Belle Gunness, who died by felonious homicide at the hands of an unknown perpetrator. This finding followed dental evidence from her dentist identifying bridges and gold-filled teeth as hers.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 21 May 1908 · page 1
VERDICT IN THE GUNNESS CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
A letter sent to La Porte's mayor from a man signing himself Samuel Harvey claims he saw and spoke with Belle Gunness in a train depot in Ogden, Utah, on May 4, a week after the fire destroyed her home. The writer says she initially tried to conceal her identity but admitted who she was and said she was heading to California.
Alexandria Gazette · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Says Mrs. Gunness Is Alive
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
A Spokane carnival advertisement for the Labor Temple benefit lists 'The Gunness Farm Ghosts' alongside other novelty attractions like the Ku Klux Klan exhibit and Kentucky Night-Riders. This shows the Gunness murders being commercialized as popular entertainment.
The Spokane Press · 21 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Aberdeen Herald · Aberdeen, W.T.
La Porte county commissioners set aside $7,000 reward for the arrest of Mrs. Belle Gunness if she is found alive, with additional funds allocated for coroner and sheriff investigation expenses. Digging at the farm has been largely abandoned as further corpses are not expected.
Aberdeen Herald · 21 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.
A humorous local news item notes that Richland county residents did not visit the Gunness farm near LaPorte for matrimonial purposes, pivoting into stories about freak four-legged chickens in the area. The Gunness reference is only a passing joke tying local color to the national scandal.
Wood County Reporter · 21 May 1908 · page 1
CHICKENS ARE FREAKS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.
Laporte's mayor vows to push the Gunness murder investigation with greater vigor, suspecting more tragedies will be uncovered. Meanwhile thousands of sightseers have swarmed the farm, trampling graves and the barn where victims' remains were found, while authorities examine letters sent to Belle Gunness before the fire.
Wood County Reporter · 21 May 1908 · page 2
MURDER FARM IS A MAGNET.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.
Residents of Kenosha speculate that Anna Tillman, a local woman who disappeared two years earlier after moving near Laporte, may be among the bodies found buried on the Gunness farm. She had last written that she was in poor health and had been invited to the countryside, and was estranged from her mother.
Wood County Reporter · 21 May 1908 · page 3
FEAR KENOSHA GIRL MURDERED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis.
The report describes the burial of Andrew Helgelein and states that identification of the remaining bodies found at the Gunness farm is proving difficult, with potter's field likely their final resting place. Experts confirm one jawbone belongs to Jennie Olsen and another body to Helgelein, but the methods of death and extent of Mrs. Gunness's involvement remain unknown.
The Manitowoc Pilot · 21 May 1908 · page 6
FINAL STAGES AT HAND
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis.
Friends of Frank Medinger, a Delafield farmer who vanished in 1907 after traveling to Indiana to marry a woman he met through a matrimonial ad, believe he may have been murdered by Belle Gunness. They plan to ask the German consul in Chicago to investigate his disappearance.
River Falls Journal · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.
A brief editorial comment expresses shock that the human race could produce such a monstrous woman as Mrs. Gunness of Laporte, Indiana. It offers no details of her crimes, simply reacting with moral outrage to her now-notorious reputation.
Mineral Point Tribune · 21 May 1908 · page 4
THURSDAY, MAY 21, 1908. It is claimed that two candidates for Supreme Judge spent between them $15,000 for campaign purposes. It seems almost incredible that the human race should have produced such a fiend in the form of a woman as Mrs. Gunness of Laporte, Indiana, has proven
A miner sifting the ashes of the Gunness farmhouse found dental bridgework that the dentist who made it identified as Belle Gunness's own. Based on this, the coroner stated he would likely rule the burned female body hers, while investigators also linked new Wisconsin disappearances to her as possible victims.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Iowa County Democrat · 21 May 1908 · page 3
LAPORTE MURDERESS' BODY POSITIVELY THAT FOUND IN RUINED HOME. IDENTIFICATION MADE CERTAIN BY THE FINDING OF HER FALSE TEETH. TWO MORE WISCONSIN MEN BELIEVED TO BE AMONG HER VICTIMS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.
Sheriff Smutzer reports finding Mrs. Gunness's dental plates in the fire debris, which her dentist identifies, declaring this proof she burned to death. The report also describes two more missing Wisconsin men, Riediger and Graham, believed to be additional victims, and confirms Jennie Olsen's body identification despite Gunness's cover story that she had gone to school in Los Angeles.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Iowa County Democrat · 21 May 1908 · page 3
TWO MORE WISCONSIN VICTIMS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.
A jawbone fragment recovered from the Gunness farmhouse ruins was identified by coroner's physicians as belonging to an adult human skull, supporting the prosecution's case against Ray Lamphere. Sheriff Smutzer continued sifting debris for further evidence, including fused gold globules possibly from Mrs. Gunness' dental fillings, which indicate the intense heat of the fire.
Iowa County Democrat · 21 May 1908 · page 4
FINDING OF JAWBONE IMPORTANT IN PROSECUTION OF LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.
The LaPorte county council appropriated $9,000 to continue the investigation into the Gunness case, including excavation work at the death farm and chemical analyses of remains. Saturday's digging at the farm produced no significant new findings.
Iowa County Democrat · 21 May 1908 · page 4
MONEY VOTED FOR GUNNESS INQUIRY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
A dentist who had treated Mrs. Gunness's teeth declared that a jawbone fragment dug up on her farm strongly resembled her lower jaw. Further searching of the farm that morning turned up nothing more.
The Clarksburg Telegram · 21 May 1908 · page 2
JAWBONE Dug Up On Gunness Farm Resembles Mrs. Gunness's Dentist Declares.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
The Laporte county grand jury began investigating the deaths of fourteen persons at the Gunness farm. Abraham Phillips of West Virginia, who came to marry the widow in 1907, is now considered a probable victim after disappearing.
The Clarksburg Telegram · 21 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Sisseton Weekly Standard · Sisseton, S.D. · and 8 other papers
Authorities report 22 deaths now linked to Belle Gunness, with the toll potentially reaching 26 if additional victims are confirmed. The first identified victim, Andrew Helgelein, was buried after Bertillon identification, while searchers continued sifting ashes and thousands of sightseers toured the farm.
The Sisseton Weekly Standard · 22 May 1908 · page 2
10,000 VISIT MURDER FARM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 8 papers
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · Grand Rapids, Minn · 20 May 1908
Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D. · 21 May 1908
The Miller Press · Miller, S.D. · 21 May 1908
Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis. · 21 May 1908
The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D. · 22 May 1908
Golden Valley Chronicle · Beach, N.D. · 22 May 1908
The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D. · 22 May 1908
The Wibaux Pioneer · Wibaux, Mont. · 28 May 1908
The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D. · and 2 other papers
A death certificate was issued for Jennie Olsen and her body released to relatives, ending controversy fueled by Mrs. Gunness's claims that Jennie had gone to Los Angeles. The seven unidentified bodies exhumed from the farm were buried in the potter's field under the coroner's direction.
The Washburn Leader · 22 May 1908 · page 2
BURIED IN POTTER'S FIELD
Gunness Farm. Laporte, Ind., May 20.—The issuing of a death certificate for Jennie Olsen and the turning over of the body by Coroner Mack to the relatives in Chi cago puts the official stamp of identi fication upon a body regarding which there has been much controversy. Al though identified by the brother and sister many refused to believe that the girl was dead for the reason that Mrs. Gunness had made it a point to inform a number of persons that Jen nie had gone to Los Angeles to attend school and had arranged little inci dents that would help to make this point strong with such people as might be a trifle inquisitive on the subject.
See moreSee less
In the course of the investigations that were carried on with reference to the reports that the girl had ac tually been sent away and was not among the dead in the little grave yard a letter was received saying that a girl answering her description had been seen in a convent near Los An geles. This story was believed by some, but the authorities found noth ing to substantiate it. The seven unidentified bodies, ex humed from Mrs. Gunness' barnyard, were buried In the potter's field under the direction of Coroner Mack.
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · 20 May 1908
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn. · 21 May 1908
The Chanute Times · Chanute, Kan. · and 1 other paper
The report describes the aftermath of the gruesome discoveries at the Gunness farm, noting that two more bodies have been tentatively identified while others remain unidentified. It states the case now moves toward the grand jury, which begins reviewing evidence gathered by the sheriff and prosecutor, while public excitement in La Porte subsides.
The Chanute Times · 22 May 1908 · page 7
THE GUNNESS CASE BEGINNING OF THE FINAL STAGE IN THE SENSATIONAL LA PORTE MYSTERY RESUMING ITS NORMAL CALM
1,000,000 Words Sent Out. Laporte, Iud., May 17. The burial Friday night of Andrew M. Helgelein marks the beginning cf the final stage of the Gunness farm mysteries so far as human knowledge is concerned. Two more corpses, supposed to have been these of Jennie Olsen and Ole O. Budsberg, have been partially iden tified but to the identity of the remain ing cadavers no clew exists that, gives promise of fulfillment. The relics tak en from the death farm, Buch as watches, and rings, may ultimately lead to the determination that some cer tain missing individual was caught in the Gunness trap but this will give
The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan. · 21 May 1908
The Prescott Daily News · Prescott, Ark.
Coroner Mack delivered his verdict in La Porte, Indiana, ruling that the body examined was that of Mrs. Belle Gunness, who died by homicide at the hands of an unknown perpetrator. The report quotes the coroner's official finding directly.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Prescott Daily News · 22 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
Sheriff Smutzer resumed digging under the Gunness house basement but found nothing new. County Prosecutor Smith plans to ask a grand jury to indict Ray Lamphere on four counts of murder, one of arson, and one of accessory to murder in the Helgelien case.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A satirical newspaper commentary column touches on various topics of the week, including a wry note that the country is trying to forget the Gunness murders and 'Indiana literature.' It reflects the case's pervasive media saturation rather than reporting new developments.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
The piece speculates that Mrs. Gunness may be fleeing to Europe to escape justice and enjoy her ill-gotten gains, noting she could be arrested there. It also questions a recent headline declaring her 'officially dead,' wondering how she could be tried for murder if legally deceased.
Coroner Mack will file official reports on the deaths of Mrs. Gunness's three children, and the grand jury will review the facts to possibly issue indictments. The sheriff will resume digging in the yard, and a public sale of her personal property is scheduled for May 29, drawing interest from museum owners nationwide.
Arizona Republican · 22 May 1908 · page 1
AN INTERESTING DAY IN THE GUNNESS CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.
A brief humorous one-line item remarks that everyone agrees Mrs. Gunness had 'killing' ways, punning on her reputation as a murderess. It is a passing joke embedded among unrelated local notices and political commentary.
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 22 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.
Coroner Mack will file official reports on the deaths of three Gunness children, and the grand jury will review the facts that day. Digging in the yard will resume, and a public sale of Mrs. Gunness's property is planned for May 29, drawing interest from museum owners.
Rochester police are told by an Indiana sheriff that an unidentified body exhumed on the Gunness farm may belong to Mae L. O'Reilly of Rochester, New York, based on jewelry found near the remains bearing her name and address. Detectives are checking city records, since no such woman appears in the Rochester directory.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Investigators at the Gunness farm in Laporte dug the cellar floor to a depth of three feet but found no bones in the suspected spot, so digging continued in other areas. Ash from the ruins was being sifted and saved for closer panning to recover gold melted from jewelry believed kept by Mrs. Gunness as murder mementoes.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 22 May 1908 · page 9
- Digging In Gunness Rulnai Laporte, Ind., May 22. The cellar floor of the Gunness house of crime was dug up to a depth of three feet, but the suspected spot revealed no bones of victims of the murderess. Digging, has been resumed in other suspicious places. The basement was cleared of ruins, and the placer min er's task of washing the ashes will be completed In a day or two. A bushel 'of "tailings," saved for closer observa tion from the process of sluicing, will be "panned" for gold melted from the Jewelry which Mrs. Gunness kept as mementoes of her crimes. -
In La Porte, Indiana, Coroner Mack is preparing his official report on the deaths of Mrs. Gunness's three children, while the grand jury nears completion of its work. A witness disputes an earlier denial, claiming Belle Gunness's father Peter Paulsen was a traveling magician in Norway whom he knew personally.
The San Francisco Call · 22 May 1908 · page 3
DECLARES MRS. GUNNESS' FATHER WAS MAGICIAN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
The coroner is set to file official reports on the deaths of Mrs. Gunness's three children, with the grand jury to review findings and digging for more bodies to resume in her yard. A Rochester, Indiana man disputes an earlier denial, claiming he personally knew Mrs. Gunness's family in Norway and recalls her as a girl performing tightrope walking with her father's troupe.
Los Angeles Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 2
WILL REPORT ON GUNNESS CASES DEVELOPMENT EXPECTED AT LAPORTE TODAY GRAND JURY WILL HEAR OF FINDINGS OF CORONER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A brief news summary item reports that the coroner has declared the badly burned body found at the farm to be that of Mrs. Gunness. This appears among many unrelated national headlines in a condensed news digest column.
The Washington Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Mrs Gunness Dead Says Coroner
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Coroner Mack's official verdict declares the charred bones found in the fire ruins to be Belle Gunness, with three other bodies identified as her children, all dead from felonious homicide by an unknown perpetrator. A separate pending verdict will name Gunness as the murderer or accomplice in the deaths of Andrew Helgelein, Ole Budsberg, Jennie Olson, and other unidentified victims, though the day brought no new discoveries despite continued searching.
The Washington Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 3
GUNNESS VERDICT - Coroner Says Woman's Body Is That of Murderess - OTHERS BELIEVE HER HIDING - Mystery of Indiana Tragedies as far from Solution as Ever - Other Victims Sought but Careful Search Falls to Reveal More Bodies in the Basement of Ruined Home
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Two more Pennsylvania men who left home to marry wealthy widows are reported missing, with their farms already sold off. Despite a dentist's claim to have identified Belle Gunness's gold dental work among the fire ruins, most Laporte residents still believe she faked her death and remains alive.
The Washington Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A woman seeks her missing brother at the Laporte morgue amid the ongoing search for clues. Despite a dentist's claim that gold fillings found in the ruins match Mrs. Gunness's teeth, most locals believe she faked her death and remains alive.
The Washington Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Coroner Mack filed his official verdict declaring the charred bones found in the fire ruins to be those of Belle Gunness, with three other bodies identified as her children, ruling the deaths felonious homicide by an unknown perpetrator. A separate verdict will name Gunness as murderer or accomplice in the deaths of Andrew Helgelein, Ole Budsberg, Jennie Olson, and other unidentified victims found in her private graveyard.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 3
GUNNESS VERDICT IN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Relatives of several missing men from Pennsylvania and Chicago who had gone to meet a wealthy widow fear they became victims at the Gunness farm, and plan to view remains at the morgue despite poor chances of identification. Despite a dentist's claim to have found Mrs. Gunness's gold dental fillings in the ruins, many locals still believe she faked her death and remains alive.
The Washington Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 3
OTHERS BELIEVE HER HIDING
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Digging resumed on the Gunness farm after a ten-day delay, with searchers set to excavate the garden, basement floor, and ground near evergreen trees for more bodies. Sheriff Smutzer found jewelry belonging to May O'Reilly, a missing Rochester, NY woman, and notified police there, who confirmed she had vanished months earlier.
Evening Star · 22 May 1908 · page 1
DIGGING ON GUNNESS FARM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Sheriff Smutzer and a detail of men began digging at dawn on the Gunness farm, searching suspected burial spots to a sufficient depth to uncover any additional graves. Ray Lamphere, showing signs of fear, awaits word on whether the grand jury will indict him for the murders of Mrs. Gunness and her three children and as an accessory in the murder of Andrew Helgelein.
The Washington Times · 22 May 1908 · page 1
DEATH FARM EXPLORERS DIG FOR GUNNESS GRAVES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
South Bend police arrested James Brimmingstall after his wife reported fearing for her life, and he has confessed to killing two people with suspicion of four more. The story is explicitly framed by the paper as a 'Gunness-like' tale of hidden, multiple murders.
The Washington Times · 22 May 1908 · page 1
MURDERER IS HELD; WIFE BETRAYS HIM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Sheriff Smutzer and his men resumed digging on the Gunness farm at dawn, searching for additional graves across every suspected plot. Ray Lamphere, visibly fearful, awaits a grand jury indictment for the murders of Mrs. Gunness and her children and as an accessory in the killing of Andrew Helgelein.
The Washington Times · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Iowa State Bystander · Des Moines, Iowa
An expert miner discovered the upper and lower dental bridges belonging to Belle Gunness in the ashes of her burned home, and a dentist positively identified them. The coroner is expected to officially rule the burned female body was Gunness, while the prosecutor says he is ready to try Ray Lamphere and expects a conviction.
Iowa State Bystander · 22 May 1908 · page 3
WOMAN IS CERTAINLY DEAD. FALSE TEETH OF MRS. GUNNESS FOUND IN ASHES OF HOME.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Iowa State Bystander · Des Moines, Iowa
The grand jury continues examining witnesses in the Lamphere case, with the prosecutor confident of conviction. An autopsy on seven exhumed bodies revealed one was female, and the coroner ruled the burned female remains were those of Belle Gunness, murdered.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Iowa State Bystander · 22 May 1908 · page 3
FOUND IN ASHES OF HOME
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
A La Porte grand jury returned seven indictments naming Mrs. Gunness, Ray Lamphere, Philip Gunness, Lucy Sorenson, and Myrtle Sorenson. The charges include arson, the murder of Andrew Helgelein, and being an accessory to that murder.
Evening Times-Republican · 22 May 1908 · page 1
SEVEN CHARGES MADE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
After a ten-day halt, excavation resumed on the Gunness farm searching for more bodies. Sheriff Smutzer found jewelry belonging to May O'Reilly of Rochester, N.Y., and local police confirmed she had disappeared months earlier.
Evening Times-Republican · 22 May 1908 · page 1
DIGGING FOR BODIES AGAIN.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Owosso Times · Owosso, Mich. · and 2 other papers
Despite lingering doubts, officials in Laporte conclude Belle Gunness died in the farmhouse fire with her children, based on further identification of remains. The prosecutor claims evidence to convict her hired hand Ray Lamphere of killing her and the children out of revenge, as the garden yields ten victims' bodies.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Owosso Times · 22 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 2 papers
· · 22 May 1908
Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn. · 23 May 1908
Paper unidentified
A fire destroyed Belle Gunness's farmhouse near LaPorte, Indiana, killing her and three children, but searchers investigating the ruins and grounds have uncovered numerous dismembered bodies buried on the property. The inquiry began after John Helgelein sought his missing brother Andrew, who had vanished after answering Gunness's matrimonial advertisement.
Paper unidentified · 22 May 1908 · page 2
Indiana Murder Farm
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Investigators report the death toll at the Gunness farm has reached fifteen, with more bodies expected under the cellar floor, including a body believed to be adopted daughter Jennie Olson. Ray Lamphere has been arrested as a suspect, and authorities theorize Belle Gunness is still alive, having killed another woman, her children, and burned the house to fake her own death.
Paper unidentified · 22 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · Decorah, Iowa
This report traces Belle Gunness's childhood in Norway, describing her father's grim circus act of beheading and sword-swallowing and her mother's work as a tightrope walker. It also states that dental remains found in the ashes have been identified with absolute certainty by her dentist, proving she died in the fire and dismissing rumors she survived.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · 22 May 1908 · page 8
Mrs. Gunness' Barndom
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Idaho Republican · Blackfoot, Idaho
The report states investigators have determined that Belle Gunness died in the fire at her LaPorte farm, her identity confirmed by a dentist who recognized his own dental work on a jawbone found in the cellar. It suggests Ray Lamphere, a rejected and jealous former employee, likely set the fire, while many victims lured by Gunness's matrimonial scheme have been exhumed and identified.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Idaho Republican · 22 May 1908 · page 1
6c HOUSE PASSES THE DRY FARM BILL. Washington, May 13.—After a brief debate the house yesterday passed the Mondell dry farm bill, per mitting homesteading of not to ex ceed 320 acres or non-irrigable, non mineral and non-timbered public lands. The bill was In charge of Chairman Mondell o'f the public lands committee, who made the principal speech in its suport. Other western members advocated its passage, in eluding Bonynge of Colorado. To facilitate the ultimate passage of the dry farm bill the house com mittee retained the title of the Smoot bill which passed the senate some time ago, but substituted the!
See moreSee less
provisions of the Mondell bill for those of the bill adopted by the sen-! ate. Because of this change the hill will be sent to conference for final adjustment. As it passed the house it requires residence lpon the land and also requires proof that an eighth of the entry was cultivated the second year and one-fourth tbe third year and •thereafter up to the time of making final proof. The sec ond Smoot bill, waving the residence requirement where there is not suffi cient water on the land for domes tic purposes, was eliminated. AT THE GUNNESS FARM. The investigation at the Gunness Farm at LaPorte, Indiana, where so many people have been put out of the way for their money, It has been determined that Mrs. Bella Gunness the widow and owner of the farm, met her fate and was burned in her own house, the remains found In the cellar having been identified by the dentist who had done work on her teeth and was able to positively Iden tify the jawbone by his work. How the house was set afllre has not been explained, but It probably came about through the jealousy of a man named Lamphere who worked for Mrs. Gunness and had fallen In love with her, been rejected, Injured and persecuted by her. The remains of many victims have been exhumed and some of them identified. They came from all parts of the country; she having conducted a matrimonial correspondence with men in many states, and lured them to her home to be quietly put out of the way for their money. Prof. McComb Goes to DosMonles Prof. McComb, superintendent of file city schools will leave with his family for DesMolnes, Iowa, as soon as school Is closed. HIs father Is <► very feeble and may not survive the <> summer, and on this account he will o return to DesMolnes for the summer. n The board has reelected him for an other year In Blackfoot. o o
A dispatch from Christiania, Norway describes Belle Gunness's childhood as the daughter of a traveling magician, performing as a rope dancer at fairs. It notes her father eventually retired on a small property near Trondhjem and that she still has relatives in Norway.
The Idaho Republican · 22 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho
A grand jury returned seven indictments against Ray Lamphere for the murders of Belle Gunness, Philip Gunness, and the Sorenson children, plus arson and charges related to Andrew Helgelien's murder. Excavators searching the Gunness farm found a human skull in the cesspool and continued searching for the rest of the body.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 22 May 1908 · page 1
GRAND JURY INDICT LAMPHERE - NEW DEVELOPMENTS IN LA PORTE MURDER MYSTERY - FIND SKULL AND SEARCHING FOR BODY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Jasper Weekly Courier · Jasper, Ind.
The Laporte county council appropriated $5,000 to support officials investigating the Gunness case. This funding ensures Sheriff Smutzer's investigation at the death farm continues and enables Coroner Mack's planned chemical analysis of remains.
The Jasper Weekly Courier · 22 May 1908 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
After discovery of bodies at the Gunness farm, people across the country are writing to LaPorte authorities trying to trace missing relatives and friends who may have fallen victim to Belle Gunness. Specific cases are cited, including a man who vanished after discussing marrying an Indiana widow, and others believed to have answered matrimonial ads.
The Lake County Times · 22 May 1908 · page 5
SCORES CONTINUE TO BE REPORTED MISSING
Murder Farm. Scores of people an over tTie United States are endeavoring to trace rela tlves and friends who have disappeared to the "Port of Missing Men" at LaPorte. . , Perhaps the most Interesting devel opment resulting from the discovery of the bodies of a dozen or more of the Gunnesa victims is the revelation of hundreds of cases of disappearance which have never been cleared up sat isfactorily. Mrs. J. H. Keeler, of McKeesport, Pa., has written Coroner Mack that she believes that her father. John E. Bun ter, who left his home Nov. 25, 1907, after having talked about marrying a widow in Indiana, came to LaPorte and is among those put out of the way
Authorities receive multiple inquiries about men who vanished after contacting Mrs. Gunness, including farmers lured by matrimonial ads, while tips pour in from across the country. Sheriff Smutzer finishes sluicing debris and prepares to dig under the barn's cement floor for more victims.
The Lake County Times · 22 May 1908 · page 5
Louis A. Behnker of Mount Vernon. 111., has written State's Attorney Smith that a woman answering Mrs. Gunness' description recently came to that neighborhood with a man said to be her husband and purchased a farm. Thejr refuse to talk of themselves or tell where they came from. The writer positive that the woman is Mrs. Gunness. Deputy Sheriff Anstiss today went to South Bend and secured possession of the shepherd dog stolen from the Gun ness farm by South Bend parties who desired the use of the dog for exhi bition purposes.
See moreSee less
No action will be taken against the men. Sheriff Smutzer this evening finished the sluicing of the debris in the Gun ness house, and tomorrow morning he will resume digging for more sup posed victims of the arch murderess. The first place investigated will be un der the cement floor In the barn, a spot which was very carefully covered by Mrs. Gunness under her personal su pervision. The general opinion is that bodies will be found there.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
As the grand jury's deliberations near completion, Ray Lamphere is reportedly showing nervousness and fear. Investigators found jewelry belonging to missing woman May O'Reilly, while searchers continued digging at the Gunness property and the coroner ruled the children's deaths felonious homicide by an unknown perpetrator.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Near Dowagiac, Michigan, James Brimmingstall was arrested after his wife revealed he planned to kill her to prevent betrayal; he is accused of six murders and has confessed to two. The report notes parallels to the Gunness murders, including victims who were killed for their money and property.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 22 May 1908 · page 1
SIX ARE KILLED BY A DEMON
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
Digging resumed at the Gunness farm after a 10-day delay, and Sheriff Smutzer found jewelry belonging to May O'Reilly of Rochester, N.Y. Rochester police confirmed O'Reilly had disappeared from her home several months earlier, suggesting she was a Gunness victim.
Rock Island Argus · 22 May 1908 · page 1
ROCHESTER WOMAN'S JEWELRY IS FOUND
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
A newspaper opinion column remarks that men can breathe easier now that it has been established beyond reasonable doubt that Belle Gunness, the 'whole tale murderer,' is dead, her body being one of those found partially incinerated in the fire that destroyed her Laporte, Indiana house. The item treats this as settled fact amid a roundup of other local and national news notes.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Topeka State Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
The Laporte grand jury returned seven indictments against Ray Lamphere, including murder charges for Belle Gunness, Philip Gunness, and the Sorenson children, plus arson and the murder of Andrew Helgelein. Friends of missing man Benjamin Carling also suspect he was among Gunness's victims after a skeleton resembling him was found on her farm.
The Topeka State Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 5
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Sheriff Smutzer and excavators found a human skull in a cesspool on the Gunness farm at 2:30 in the afternoon. A search for the remainder of the body was then undertaken.
The Topeka State Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 5
HUMAN SKULL FOUND
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Interior Journal · Stanford, Ky.
A brief news note reports that a grand jury has begun its investigation into the Gunness murders at La Porte, Indiana. It appears amid a roundup of unrelated national news items, including other crimes, suicides, and political matters.
The Interior Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 1
NEWS NOTES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Interior Journal · Stanford, Ky.
A Laporte, Indiana dispatch reports that Sheriff Smutzer and a miner named Schultz, sifting through the ashes of the Gunness farmhouse fire, found upper and lower dental plates containing false teeth. Dr. I. P. Norton, who made the lower plate and recognized the upper one, identified them as belonging to Mrs. Gunness, leading Sheriff Smutzer to declare this proof she died in the fire.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Interior Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Citizen · Frederick City, Md.
Prosecuting attorney Ralph Smith declares the Laporte mystery solved after a dentist identified charred bone fragments as matching Belle Gunness's dental work, confirming she was among the bodies found in the cellar ashes. Meanwhile Andrew Helgelein, the first lured victim to be buried, was interred, and searches of the farm turned up watches and surgical/hypnotism books but no further conclusive remains, with a list of missing men linked to Gunness provided.
The Citizen · 22 May 1908 · page 2
LAPORTE MYSTERY SOLVED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · and 1 other paper
Laporte officials obtained evidence that Mrs. Gunness had an accomplice who helped lure victims to her farm. A. K. Helgelein, her last known victim, was buried at Laporte, and dental identification confirmed the jawbone fragments found in the farmhouse ruins belonged to Mrs. Gunness herself.
The Kanabec County Times · 22 May 1908 · page 6
John Moe failed. That one of the seven unidentified bodies dug up in Mrs. Gunness’ barn yard near Laporte, Ind., is that of a woman was reveal by the autopsy, and it is thought to be the body of a woman who disappeared from the farm at the same time as Jennie Olsen. Postmaster Dury of Two Harbors, Mich., accidentally shot and killed himself. Miss Ethel Burroughs, a senior in Smith college, was killed in a run away accident at Northampton, Mass. The Southern Baptist convention at Hot Springs, Ark., adopted resolutions condemning the liquor traffic in all its poses.
The report says public interest in the La Porte farm murders remains intense for weeks. It presents two competing accounts of Mrs. Gunness's Norwegian origins—one claiming she was a hypnotic traveling performer's daughter from Kristiania, another saying she was from Selbu with a brother who called her ill-natured in youth—while noting it remains unclear whether she died in the fire or is still alive.
St. Paul Tidende · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Gunness Mordene
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
St. Paul Tidende · St. Paul, Minn.
The report reviews conflicting rumors about Belle Gunness's origins—one claiming she was a wandering Gypsy performer with hypnotic powers, another that she was born Brynhild Paulsen in Selbu, Norway. It then describes how a dentist matched gold dental work found in the farmhouse ruins to Gunness's jaw, concluding she died in the fire, and lists victims including John Moe and Abraham Phillips, with total losses near $47,000.
St. Paul Tidende · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Little Falls Herald · Little Falls, Minn.
This is a newspaper editorial column making brief political commentary, including a passing remark comparing Mrs. Gunness to Kate Bender, a notorious killer from Kansas. The piece is primarily focused on Bryan's presidential campaign and state political conventions, with the Gunness reference being a single incidental comment.
Little Falls Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 4
Mrs. Gunness must have been a sort of reincaraaton of Kate Bender of Kansas, of imfamous memory. Michigan, South Carolina, Missouri and Alaska also joined the Bryan pro
Dr. I.P. Norton, who had performed dental work on Belle Gunness, examined a jawbone fragment found on the death farm and confirmed it was human and strongly resembled her lower jaw. A new suspicious grave site was also found about forty rods from where earlier bodies were exhumed, with two other locations marked for excavation.
Little Falls Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 6
JAW OF MRS. GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Little Falls Herald · Little Falls, Minn.
Dr. I. P. Norton, who had performed dental work on Belle Gunness, examined a jawbone fragment found on the farm and confirmed it was human and strongly resembled her jaw. A new grave was also discovered about forty rods from where other bodies had been dug up, with additional suspicious spots to be investigated.
Little Falls Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 7
Dentist Identifies Specimen Found on Death Farm.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D.
The Laporte county council appropriated $9,000 to fund the sheriff's investigation and coroner's chemical analysis of bodies found at the Gunness farm. Bertillon expert Edward Evans completed identification of Andrew Helgelein's body and took specimens to Chicago for further testing.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 22 May 1908 · page 10
LAPORTE PAYS BILL - COUNTY SUPPLIES $9,000 FOR MURDER FARM INQUIRY
Coroner to Carry Out Plans. Laporte, Ind.: The Laporte county council late Saturday appropriated J99.000 for the use of officials concern ed in the development of the Gunnesi eaae. This action aasures the con tinuance of Sheriff Smutaer's investi gations at the death farm and also 'makes certain the plans of Coronet 'Mack for a chemical analysis of por tions of some of the bodies. Edward A. Evans, the Bertlllon ex pert of the Chicago police department, •who completed the identifications of the body of Andrew Helgelein Friday, took portions of that body back to Chicago with him Saturday afternoon.
See moreSee less
He said that some of the specimens will be submitted to Dr. W. A. Evans, city pryaloian of Chicago. The council made its appropriation only after a long discussion. The cor oner had asked for $6,000, the circuit court for |2,000 and the board oi ^commissioners, from which the sheriff !obtains his funds, for 17,000. At the Imorning session of the council an at Itempt wm made to have these jamounts denied in toto. In the afternoon it was announced [the matter had been postponed until |Monday. Later the council was again {convened and the appropriations fol 4$£&|lowed. Under the revised schedule the commissioners will have $5,000, the coroner $2,500 and the circuit oourt Jl.fiOO, The county treasury Is reported to .contain over $250,000, and ithe only debt is a small bond Issue 'floated repently for building purpose*
Andrew Helgelein, the last known victim lured by Belle Gunness, was given a Christian burial in La Porte after Coroner Mack received Bertillon identification reports. Prosecuting attorney Ralph Smith stated that a jawbone fragment found in the farmhouse ruins, matched by a dentist to Gunness's known dental work, conclusively proved she died in the fire and had not escaped.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 22 May 1908 · page 10
South Dakota Victim. Leporte, Ind.: The first of the Gun ness victims to be Interred with Chris tian rites was buried Friday in Pat ton's cemetery, on the outskirts of La porte. The corpse was that of Andrew K. Helgelein, of Mansfield, S. IX, the last man to meet his death in the trap to which Mrs. Gunness lured her vic tims. The body was released for burial Friday, after Coroner Mack had re ceived the reports of the Bertlllon ex perts who have examined It and com pared their findings with figures taken from the records of the Minnesota penitentiary at Stillwater.
See moreSee less
"Identification of the piece of jaw bone taken from the ruins of the Gilnness farm house as a portion of Mrs. Gunness' skull bears out most conclusively the contentions of the state regarding the Identity of the bod ies found in the cellar on April 28. It Is the clinching »bit of evidence which should set at rest the rumors that Mrs. Gunness has escaped." This statement was made by Ralph N. Smith, prosecuting attorney. It followed a report from Dr. C. P. Nor ton, a dentist, who found that the Ipiece of charred bone presented evi dence characteristic of which he had [Observed while working on Mrs. Gun ness' teeth.
Reports from Christiania, Norway reveal that Belle Gunness, central figure in the Laporte murder mystery, was remembered as a girl who assisted her father Petters Paulson, a traveling magician performing at Norwegian fairs. She worked as a rope dancer in his show alongside her three sisters and brother, and the family later retired near Trondhjem on the money he earned.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 22 May 1908 · page 10
1IER FATHER WAS A MAGICIAN. Mrs. Gunness Reihemljered In Norway as Girl. Chrlstiania, Norway: Mrs. Belle TunneBs, the central figure in the La porte, Ind., murder mystery, details of which have been received here, is remembered in Chrlstiania as a girl assisting her father. Petters Paulson, a traveling conjurer and magician, who gave performances at all the fairs In Norway. She performed as a rope dancer and often was seen in short skirts and fleshings, half frozen before the tent, extendlng.an invitation to the public to step Inside. Her three sis ters and brother also took part in the show. The father made enough money eventually to retire to a small proper ty near Trondhjem. Mrs. Gunness has many relatives In Norway.
Laporte's mayor vows to push the Gunness murder investigation with greater vigor, predicting more tragedies will be uncovered. The farm has become a morbid tourist attraction, with thousands trampling the site and crowding the barn-morgue to view victims' remains.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 22 May 1908 · page 11
MURDER FARM IS A MAGNET.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Holt County Sentinel · Oregon, Mo.
The report calls Belle Gunness one of history's most notorious criminals, with her victims possibly numbering around thirty, including children. It compares her crimes to other infamous Chicago-area murders like Holmes, Luetgert, and the Cronin case, expressing shock at the scale and motive for killing children despite her profit-driven murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Holt County Sentinel · 22 May 1908 · page 4
3 Wholesale Murder. The a6touuding developments at La Porte, Indiana, already places Belle Gunnes nmoDg the most notorious criminals of history Indeed, few have a longer record of lives taken than shp, her victims now numbering perhaps thirty. Not only adults but children are among them, and why the latter is most inexplicable, since she murdered for profit. According to the "evidence already at hand, Belle Gunness made a business of murder. Chicago aud its immediate vicinity have always supplied the most startling crimes of the country. The Cronin mur der, startling as it was at the time, paled into insignificance with the crimes com mitted in Holmes' castle, and even his butcheries were forgotten when Hock operated, and L-jetgert fed bis sausage factory with his wife's body.
See moreSee less
True, other ports of the country have had their sen sational crimes, but none has ever su perceded these in horror and diabolical fiendish neB:?. If Belle Gunness, is alive, she must begin to comprehend the depths of her depravity. If she is dead, she ia cer tainly scorching, if there is a hell; man or woman, no human being guilty of such crimes, can possibly escape deserv ed punishment.
Reverend Schell claims Ray Lamphere made a partial confession about his role in the Gunness tragedy, prompting expectations of a full public statement from the now-collapsing suspect. Meanwhile, bank officials investigate Mrs. Gunness's financial records, revealing usurious loan practices possibly aided by a Laporte public official.
The Montgomery Tribune · 22 May 1908 · page 2
CRISIS NEAR IN GUNNESS CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Tribune · Montgomery City, Mo.
Rev. E. A. Schell of the Laporte Methodist church claims the Gunness children were chloroformed and the house set afire over them, but insists the woman's body found in the ruins was not Belle Gunness herself. Schell received Ray Lamphere's first confession and reportedly more of his confidence than anyone else in La Porte.
The Montgomery Tribune · 22 May 1908 · page 2
SAYS MRS. GUNNESS IS ALIVE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Tupelo Journal · Tupelo, Miss.
The passage describes a photograph showing the Gunness property, with crosses marking the garden plot south of the burned dwelling's ruins. These crosses indicate the locations where bodies of murdered persons were exhumed.
The Tupelo Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 2
VIEW OF THE GUNNESS FARM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Times-Promoter · Hernando, Miss.
The LaPorte county council appropriated $9,000 to support officials investigating the Gunness case. This ensures Sheriff Smutzer can continue his search at the death farm and allows Coroner Mack to proceed with chemical analysis of remains.
Times-Promoter · 22 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Times-Promoter · Hernando, Miss.
An examination of exhumed bodies at the Gunness farm reveals one woman and six men among the remains, corroborating a former hired hand's account of a Christmas 1906 party after which guests vanished. Sheriff Smutzer concludes that Gunness killed two men and two women following that gathering and buried them together in one grave.
Times-Promoter · 22 May 1908 · page 2
MRS. GUNNESS BLOODY PARTY: Two Men and Two Women Thrown Into Same Grave
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Hattiesburg News · Hattiesburg, Miss.
A brief item reports that the Houston Chronicle has emphatically denied a claim that Mrs. Gunness was born in Texas. This appears amid miscellaneous local news and editorial notes in the Hattiesburg paper.
The Hattiesburg News · 22 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Hattiesburg News · Hattiesburg, Miss.
The report describes the discovery of a 'clearing house for murders' run by Belle Gunness at Laporte, Indiana, after her house burned down. Skeletons were found beneath the cellar, and it is believed she lured rich men via matrimonial ads and also served as a 'fence' for accomplices who sent bodies from Chicago for burial.
The Hattiesburg News · 22 May 1908 · page 7
THE LAPORTE MURDER FARM
MRS. GUNNESS AND THE RUINS OF THU HOUSE WHERE HER CRIMES WERE COM MITTED—THE ARROW INDICATES SITE. materials for the construction of the is She is strange story of her career, supposed to have lured rich men to her den by matrimonial advertisements and then made away with them for their money and also to have run a murder "fence" for the benefit of her partners In the awful trade of human slaughter, the latter operating In Chi cago and sendjnj' the Jtodles of their victims to her for burial. The burning of the house at La porte, In which Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness lived with her three little children a short time ago, led to the remarkable revela tions as to her history. The story of the Laporte murder farm recalls the notorious doings of the Bender family in Montgomery county, Kan., about forty years ago, and the famous ease of Henry H. Holmes, who swindled Insurance com panies and was held responsible for the murder of quite a long list of per sons. He was hanged in Philadelphia. The Benders, husband and wife and son and daughter, were supposed to have murdered nine or ten persona and buried the bodies in the vicinity of tbelr home, robbery being their mo tive. The Benders mysteriously disap peared. and their fate is unknown, al though rumors were abroad at the time that indignant citizens put an end to their infamous careers.
The grand jury will begin investigating the Gunness farm murders on Monday, focusing on evidence against Ray Lamphere, Mrs. Gunness' former hired man, who prosecutors believe will be indicted for arson and the deaths of Gunness and her three children. Andrew Helgelein's identified body was buried, while the other seven bodies found on the farm will likely go to potter's field.
Greene County Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 4
HELGELEIN'S BODY BURIED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
Deloss Snyder, a rancher near Billings who once lived near the Gunness farm in Laporte, recounts knowing Ray Lamphere since boyhood. He describes Lamphere as mischievous, cunning, and unrestrained by his intemperate father, though he says he never knew Belle Gunness herself.
The Billings Gazette · 22 May 1908 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
Coroner Mack was expected to file his official reports on the deaths of Mrs. Gunness's three children, while the grand jury neared completion of its work on possible indictments. Meanwhile, Sheriff Smulzer planned to resume digging for bodies, and conflicting reports emerged about whether Mrs. Gunness's father had been a traveling magician in Norway.
The Billings Gazette · 22 May 1908 · page 8
SHERIFF TO DIG AGAIN TODAY / GRAND JURY REPORT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
An Indiana man confirms Peter Paulsen was a Norwegian magician and recalls young Belle performing tightrope walking in his troupe. Meanwhile authorities receive new tips about men who vanished after visiting or corresponding with Mrs. Gunness, and an estate sale of her property is announced.
The Billings Gazette · 22 May 1908 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Red Cloud Chief · Red Cloud, Neb.
A searcher found false teeth bridges in the ashes of Belle Gunness' burned home, which dentist Dr. Norton identified as belonging to her based on his records. Coroner Mack prepared to officially rule the burned female body was Mrs. Gunness, despite ongoing public doubt about whether she died or escaped.
The Red Cloud Chief · 22 May 1908 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Among a roundup of miscellaneous national news items, a brief note states that a total of 11 watches have been found in the ruins of the Gunness home near La Porte, Indiana. No further detail or context is given about the significance of the find.
The Nebraska Advertiser · 22 May 1908 · page 5
A total of 11 watches have been found in the ruins of the Gunness home near La Porto, Ind. At the second day's session of the conference of governors at the White House, Gov. Johnson of Minnesota presided in the morning and Gov. Do-, neen of Illinois, in the afternoon. The Reserve Trust company of i Cleveland, has made an assignment. The liabilities are $2,700,000. The next national convention of the Kivers and Harbors congress will be
Coroner Mack filed the first official verdict in the Gunness case, ruling that the body found in the fire ruins was that of Belle Gunness and that she died by felonious homicide at the hands of an unknown perpetrator. The finding relied on dental evidence from her dentist identifying gold-filled tooth bridges, and relieves prosecutors of needing to separately prove her death in court.
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 1
MURDERESS OFFICIALLY DEAD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.
Frank C. Friend of Plainview, Nebraska, formerly of LaPorte, Indiana, said he knew Mrs. Gunness well. He expressed surprise that she was suspected of such terrible crimes.
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
Sheriff Smutzer plans to finish sluicing debris at the Gunness farm and resume digging for more bodies the next morning. Mayor Darrow received an unsigned letter claiming sightings of Mrs. Gunness in Ogden, Utah, while authorities also received inquiries about a missing man, George W. Williams, believed to have answered her matrimonial ads.
Omaha Daily Bee · 22 May 1908 · page 1
SHERIFF HUNTS FOR BODIES
" Irons Oman a. LA PORTE. Ind., May 21. Sheriff Smut aer will this evening finish the sluicing of tha debrla of the Guinness house and to morrow morning ha Will resume digging In tha hop of finding more bodies. Mayor Darrow received an unsigned let ter from Omaha, Neb., tha writer claiming to have been in La Porta three times last jeer to visit Mis. Guinness and to have , met her in Ogden. Utah, on May 4, when she aald she waa on har way to California to visit Jennie Olsen.
See moreSee less
Inquiries wea received today by tha au thorities regarding George W. Williams of Wspwallopen, Pa., who la understood by friends to have coma to La Porte in an swer to, matrimonial advertisements from a rich widow. He never returned home.
This is a newspaper's daily index of brief items, including one line noting that Sheriff Smutzer at La Porte continues his search for bodies on the Gunness farm. It appears among unrelated national and local news briefs of the day.
Omaha Daily Bee · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Sheriff Smutser at La Porte contlnuea his search for bodies on the Qunnesa farm.1 Pag 1 Robert C. P. Holmes - meets with strange death In Chlcags, with robbery vldantlyvthe purpose of tha crime. .
Sheriff Smutzer's crew, while sluicing the ashes of the burned Gunness home near Laporte, Indiana, discovered a hollow molar with a gold crown, indented and encrusted with cinders. Investigators believe the tooth came from the incinerated skull of Belle Gunness, the alleged multi-murderess.
The Washburn Leader · 22 May 1908 · page 2
CRIMINAL NEWS. A gold crown tooth has been found In the debris of the Gunness home near Laporte, Ind. It is believed to be from the head of Mrs. Bella Oun nesB. The tooth was found in the debris of the cellar while Sheriff Smutzer was continuing his prepara tions to begin the sluicing of the ashes. The relic Is a hollow molar, with a gold crown, the metal being Indented and to some extent encrust ed by cinders. The tooth, however, bears every evidence of having come from the incinerated skull of Mrs. Bella Gunness, the alleged multi-mur
Authorities in Laporte, Indiana officially conclude that Belle Gunness died in the fire along with her children, and that the blaze was arson. Ray Lamphere, her hired hand, is to be indicted as the arsonist and as an accomplice in the murders.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 22 May 1908 · page 8
OGRESS GUNNESS OFFICIALLY DEAD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
At Lamport, Indiana, investigators dug three feet into the cellar floor of the Gunness house but found no bones. Workers continued clearing the basement and panning ash residue for melted gold from jewelry believed kept as murder mementoes.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 22 May 1908 · page 2
Digging In Gunness Ruins
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Deming Graphic · Deming, N.M.
A brief editorial aside notes that an exchange paper remarked Mrs. Gunness had 'killing ways,' which this editor sarcastically affirms as 'very effectively so.' The comment appears amid a list of unrelated local news items about Deming, New Mexico.
Deming Graphic · 22 May 1908 · page 2
And the wind held its breath Sunday! An exchange remarks that Mrs. Gunness had killing ways. Yes, very effectively so. The sweet uirl graduite in
The coroner prepares official reports on the deaths of Mrs. Gunness's three children while the grand jury nears completion of its work, with any indictments to go before Judge Richter. Meanwhile the sheriff continues digging for bodies at the farm, and conflicting correspondence from Norway addresses whether Peter Paulsen was truly Belle Gunness's father.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 1
GUNNESS RELICS Sale of Indiana Woman's Fiend's Property to Attract Tourists from Big Cities
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · Tonopah, Nev.
The report from La Porte, Indiana says Coroner Mack will file official reports on the deaths of Mrs. Gunness's three children, and the Grand Jury is expected to complete its work with possible indictments. Sheriff Smutzer will resume digging for more bodies in the Gunness yard, and a public sale of her property is scheduled for May 29th.
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 22 May 1908 · page 1
FOR MORE BODIES (By Associated Press.) LA PORTE, Ind., May 21. Tomor row promises developmenst in the Gunness case. Early this 'morning Coroner Mack will file his official re ports on the death of the three chil dren of Mrs. Gunness. Some time during the day the Grand Jury will complete its labors.' If true bills arj voted, indictments will be reported to Judge-Richter in the Laporte Cir cuit Court. Sheriff Smutzer resumos the digging for bodies tomorrow in the Gunness yard. On Friday, May 29th, Executor Fogle will hold a pub lic sale of the personal property left
Autopsies on the seven exhumed bodies at Belle Gunness's farm revealed one was female, fueling theories she killed Jennie Olsen along with a man and woman who came to take her to California. The Laporte grand jury began hearing witness testimony as officials offered a $4,000 reward for Gunness if found alive.
Perrysburg Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 2
EXPECT WORLD-WIDE QUEST BIG REWARD OFFERED TO WHOEVER FINDS MRS. GUINNESS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio
The Laporte county grand jury began hearing witness testimony in the Gunness case, with investigators theorizing that multiple victims were buried together in the same pit. A watch found on Ray Lamphere was identified as belonging to a missing man, John Moe, while authorities offered $4,000 for Mrs. Gunness's capture alive.
Perrysburg Journal · 22 May 1908 · page 2
EVER FINDS MRS. GUINNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
Mayor Darrow seeks Scotland Yard's help to track Belle Gunness and disputes the dental identification of her remains. Coroner Mack nonetheless rules the body was hers, declaring death by felonious homicide with the perpetrator unknown, and finds the other victims died to cover up murder.
The Stark County Democrat · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
Coroner Mack rules Belle Gunness died by homicide at unknown hands, while Andrew Helgelein, Ole Budsberg, and Jennie Olson died from unnatural causes consistent with murder to cover up crimes. A grieving mother searches the morgue for her missing daughter, the grand jury nears indictments against Ray Lamphere, and defense attorney Worden continues to argue Gunness faked her death and escaped.
The Stark County Democrat · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
Coroner Mack's official verdict concludes that the burned remains found in the farmhouse ruins were those of Belle Gunness and her three children, killed by an unidentified murderer. Separate findings implicate Gunness herself as the killer or accomplice in the deaths of Andrew Helgelein, Ole Budsberg, Jennie Olson, and other unidentified victims, while a possible new victim from Pennsylvania is also reported.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Stark County Democrat · 22 May 1908 · page 2
A HUNDRED ARE YET UNSOLVED More Possible Victims of the Gunness Woman From Pennsylvania Are Reports of Men Who Announced That They Were Going West to Marry Rich Widow. Lnporto, Ind., May 21. Following the flling of his official report and verdict which declares the charred bones found In the Are ruins to be that of Mrs. Belle Gunness, Coroner Mack today completed his report and verdict finding that three bodies found In the debris were those of her children. The coroner finds that the death of Mrs. Gunness and the chil dren was due to "felonious homicide, the perpetrator of which is not known."
See moreSee less
Coroner Mack's verdict on the bod ies that were taken from the grave yard will declare Mrs Ounnees to be the murderer or accomplice In the cases of Andrew Helgeleln, Ole Buds berg and Jennie Olson and of the other unidentified victims. This ver dict will also bo filed tomorrow. Today has been devoid of sensations In the Gunness tragedy. There were no grewsome finds, no bodies taken from the pilvate cemetery, no iden tifications of skeletons were made at the two city morgues, but tomorrow, however, may bring results. Today the floor in the cellar of chamel house was torn out and exca vations made to a depth of three feet but no additional bodies were found. John E. Hunter, of Duquesne, Pa. will probably prove to be one of the victims of the murderess. He left his home November 25, 1907, for northern Indiana, as he told his fam ily, to marry a wealthy widow. He took with him a large sum of money, telling his sons and daughters that he did not know when he would re turn Today a daughter, Mrs. Kuler, of McKeesport, Pa., appealed to Cor oner Mack to answer her prayer by finding her father who is 52 years old, dead or alive, at the same time expressing the fear that he went to his death in the chamel house. George Wlllams, of Wapawallopen, Pa., and Ludwig Stoll, of Mt. Yeager, Pa were also reported to the au thorities today as having left their homes for the port of the missing. When Williams left home it was with the statement that when he returned It would be with a wife. Ludwig Stoll ,also a victim of tho matrimonial bureau, left a fine farm of several hundred acres In Pennsyl vania to marry, as he termed it, a wealthy widow of the west. Williams' farm was sold a few days after the flashing of the news of tho Gunness tragedy. Disposition was made in the same way of the Stoll farm. Penn sylvania relatives of the missing men will come to this city to view the keleton forms in the morgue, but with little hopes of identification, ow ing to the decomposed condition of the bodies which have yet to be buried In the pauper field. Mrs B. F Carllng, of Chicago, Pays her brother left home a year ago, tell ing a friend he was going to meet a widow with lots of money. She will be a visitor at the morgue. Despite the assertion of D. P. Noi ton, the dentist who filled the teeth of Mrs. Belle Gunness w&th gefd, that his fillings have been found in the ruins nt the house at least 75 per cent of the people in and about Laporto believe that the arch-murderess of Brookside farm Is still alive and is in hiding. After many days of Investigation by fifty special newspaper correspond ents, half a dozen Pinkerton detec tives, the entire staff of the sheriff's office at Laporte and the police force of the town, the terrible series of crimes perpetrated at the brick house on the hill remains as unsolved as it was in the beginning and there are Btlll one hundred mysteries In the Gunness tragedies. Lokevlew Hotel Dining Rooms open to the public, Sunday, May 24th.
Relatives of several missing men who left home to marry a wealthy widow now fear their kin were victims of Belle Gunness, prompting appeals to the coroner for identification among the unburied remains. Despite extensive investigation by detectives and journalists, most locals believe Gunness faked her death and remains alive, with the case still full of unresolved mysteries.
The Stark County Democrat · 22 May 1908 · page 2
UNSOLVED
Despite the assertion of D. P. Noi ton, the dentist who filled the teeth of Mrs. Belle Gunness w&th gefd, that his fillings have been found in the ruins nt the house at least 75 per cent of the people in and about
Patrick Griffin, a well-to-do railroad man, vanished over a year ago after corresponding with a woman near Laporte, Indiana, and is believed to be a victim of Belle Gunness. A letter signed 'Mabel Pierce' inquiring about his wealth is suspected to have been written by Gunness or an accomplice, and an Ohio woman says she has information for the prosecuting attorney.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
Coroner Mack filed official reports on the deaths of three of Mrs. Gunness's children, and the grand jury was expected to finish its work, with indictments to go to Judge Richter if true bills were voted. Sheriff Smutzer planned to resume digging in the Gunness yard, while women from Pennsylvania and Ohio wrote authorities claiming missing relatives might be among the victims.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Condon Globe · Condon, Or.
A La Porte dispatch reports that Belle Gunness's murder scheme is estimated to have netted her about $65,800, with sums attributed to her husbands, suitors, and victims found on the farm. It also notes insurance money and amounts allegedly extracted from men she corresponded with via lonely-hearts letters.
Condon Globe · 22 May 1908 · page 4
MURDERESS DID GOOD BUSINESS PROFITS OF KILLINGS NETTED ABOUT $65,800
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Condon Globe · Condon, Or.
A La Porte dentist, Dr. I. N. Norton, has positively identified a gold dental crown recovered from the ruins of the Gunness home as one he had placed in her mouth, seemingly confirming she perished in the fire. The report notes this removes doubt about her fate as the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of burning the house, is set to begin Monday.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Condon Globe · 22 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Condon Globe · Condon, Or.
The report reveals Belle Gunness's birth name, Bryndylld Pulsdattar, and her Norwegian origins, noting her sister's recent death and lack of recent contact. It also reports a coroner's death certificate confirming one of the farm victims as Jennie Olson, previously thought to have moved to Los Angeles.
Condon Globe · 22 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D.
Andrew Helgelein, the last man lured to his death by Belle Gunness, was buried in Laporte after Bertillon experts and a dentist confirmed the jawbone found in the ruins belonged to Mrs. Gunness. Prosecutor Ralph N. Smith declared this evidence conclusively refutes rumors that she had escaped.
The Mitchell Capital · 22 May 1908 · page 1
SOUTH DAKOTA VICTIM IS BURIED AT LAPORTE
IS BURIED AT LAPORTE I.:i ort!\ In.!.. May 19.—Th«» tlrst of Gunness victims to be interred with Christian rues was buried in Fatton's emetery, on the outskirts of Laporle. The corpse was that of Andrew K. 1-lelgeIein, of Mansfield, S. D.. th* last man to meet his death in the trap to which Mrs. Gunness lured her victims. The body was released for burial after Coroner Alack had received the leports of the Kertillon experts who have examined Ir and compared their findings with figures taken from the records of tho Minnesota penitentiary at Stillwater.
See moreSee less
"Identification of the piece of jaw bone taken from the ruins of the Gun ness farm house as a portion of Mrs. Gunness" skull bears out most con clusively the contentions of the state regarding the identity of the bodies found in the cellar on April 2S. It is the clinching bit of evidence which should set,at rest the rumors that Mrs. Gunness has escaped." Tins statement was made by Ralph N. Smith, prosecuting attornev. It fol lowed a report from Dr. C. P. Norton, a dentist, who found that the piece of charred bone presented evidence char acteristic of which he had observed while working on Mrs. Gunness' teeth.
Frank C. Friend of Plainview, Nebraska, formerly of LaPorte, Indiana, says he knew Mrs. Gunness well and was very surprised she was even suspected of such terrible crimes. The brief item appears amid unrelated local news items in the same column.
The Mitchell Capital · 22 May 1908 · page 2
KNEW MRS. GUNNESS. SHE SURPRISED HIM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Aberdeen Democrat · Aberdeen, South Dakota
Investigators report that a letter describing Henry Gurholdt's watch matches one found at the scene, offering strong proof he was a victim. An autopsy on seven exhumed bodies revealed one was female, while authorities also pursue leads on missing farmer William Riedinger.
The Aberdeen Democrat · 22 May 1908 · page 2
DESCRIPTION OF GURHOLDT'S WATCH TALLIES WITH THE ONE FOUND
Positive That She Is Dead. LaPorte, Ind., May 20.—If any thing additional were needed to prove the contention of Sheriff Smut zer and Prosecutor Smith that Mrs. Bella Gunness, at whose door are laid a dozen, deaths, two husbands and ten others, it was supplied yes terday when Louis Schultz, expert miner, found in the aShes oi the Gunness house upper and lower bridges, containing the false teeth of the woman, Smutzer is Investigating the claim that "William Riedinger, a farmer at Delafield, Wis., was one of Mrs. Gun ness' victims.
See moreSee less
In a letter received yesterday, David Hicken, a friend, living at "Waukesha, Wis., tells of the disappearance from home of Rie dinger, who, after a visit from Mrs. Gunness, sold some crops whic!h net ted him one thousand dollars and left for some place in northern In diana, "to marry a iwealthy widow" he said. (Miss Jennie Graham. Waukesha, Wis., is seeking her ibrother, who left Ihome to marry a rich widow In Indiana and was never heard from after that. What is considered positive proof that Henry Gurholdt of Scandinavia, Wis., came to LaPorte and was put out of the way by Mrs. Gunness, was supplied yestefday when Sheriff Smutzer received a letter containing a description of Gurholdt's watch, vrhiclh tallies with the one found. Gurholdt had fifteen hundred dollars in cash when he left home to come to LaPorte.
An autopsy on exhumed remains at Mrs. Gunness' farm reveals that one of the seven unidentified bodies is female, reviving interest in a witness's account of a mysterious couple who visited in 1906. Meanwhile, new missing persons are reported, including men lured by promises of marriage to a wealthy widow, and a watch found on Ray Lamphere is identified as belonging to a missing man from Minnesota.
The Aberdeen Democrat · 22 May 1908 · page 2
Ind„ May 19.—The au topsy held yesterday on the remains of the seven unidentified dead ex humed from iMrs. Gunness' private burial ground was completed last ev ening and revealed the astounding fact that one of the seven was a female. This has aroused new inter est in the story or ujmil Greening of Oklahoma City, Oklai., who was employed by Mrs. Gunness In the fall of 1906. His story was to the effect that on a certain day in September a man and a woman came to the ihouse and that Mrs. Gunness asked
Autopsies identified the remains of Jennie Olsen and Ole Budsberg among the dismembered bodies found in the pit, with investigators now suspecting a male and female victim beyond Jennie Olsen. A visiting relative identified a watch found on Ray Lamphere as belonging to his missing brother John Moe, though he could not identify any of the unclaimed skeletons for burial.
The Aberdeen Democrat · 22 May 1908 · page 2
"'Urr den is positive that his brother was murdered by Mrs. Gunness, but he was not able to identify any of the remaining skeletons and so will not be able to provide proper burial for his brother. The bodies of the sev en unidentified will be buried in the Potters Field. The christian ser vice will be conducted over them and a small stone will be erected with an inscription telling the circumstance of their death. The body of Jennio Olsen has been turned over to the relatives. Ole Budsberg's body was yesterday shipped to Iola, AVis., for burial.
The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · Rapid City, S.D.
A La Porte dentist positively identifies gold teeth found in the Gunness farmhouse ruins as belonging to Belle Gunness, leading the prosecutor to declare her death an established fact. The coroner also certifies that one of the farm's other bodies is Jennie Olson, while Lamphere's indictment and trial are expected to proceed.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · 22 May 1908 · page 3
SHE IS DEAD.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · Rapid City, S.D.
Investigators in LaPorte report finding a dental bridge with false teeth in the ruins of Gunness's burned home, matching the dentist's description exactly. Combined with previously found rings, the coroner states he will issue an official verdict that the burned body is that of Mrs. Gunness.
The Black Hills Union and Western Stock Review · 22 May 1908 · page 3
SHE IS DEAD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A photo caption describes daily attempts to wring a confession from Roy Lamphere, the hired man connected to Mrs. Gunness, since the discovery of her crimes at LaPorte, Indiana. It frames this as a recurring scene in the ongoing case.
Paper unidentified · 22 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Coroner Mack is set to file official reports on the deaths of Mrs. Gunness's three children while the grand jury completes its deliberations on possible indictments. Sheriff Smutzer plans to resume digging for more bodies on the Gunness farm, amid disputed claims about the identity of her father, Peter Paulsen.
The Salt Lake Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 3
WILL PROSPECT FOR MORE BODIES Sheriff Smutzer to Resume Digging Operations on Gunness Farm
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A letter from a Rochester, Indiana man to authorities describes Peter Paulsen, supposed father of Belle Gunness, as a well-known traveling magician in Norway who performed with his troupe in Fredrichsburg. The report also notes an upcoming public sale of Mrs. Gunness's personal property on May 29, which collectors from across the country are eager to attend.
The Salt Lake Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
The coroner will file official reports on the deaths of Mrs. Gunness's three children, and the grand jury is expected to complete its work and possibly issue indictments. Sheriff Smutzer will resume digging for bodies in the Gunness yard, and an estate sale is planned for Friday, drawing interest from museum owners nationwide.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 22 May 1908 · page 1
EXPECTING DEVELOPMENTS IN GUNNESS MURDER CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.
Dr. I. T. Norton of La Porte, Indiana, who had performed dental work on Mrs. Gunness for years, identified a human jawbone found in the ruins of the Gunness home as hers. This forensic identification was reported amid other local news items in the paper.
Shenandoah Herald · 22 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Press · Newport News, Va.
A brief sarcastic editorial comment suggests facetiously turning the Gunness establishment into a 'clearing house' for all unsolved disappearances. It appears amid unrelated miscellaneous editorial commentary on other public figures and topics.
Daily Press · 22 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Middlebury Register · Middlebury, Vt.
Autopsies on seven bodies exhumed from Belle Gunness's farm revealed one was female, reviving theories about Jennie Olsen and a man and woman who came to take her away in 1904. Investigators now believe Gunness murdered and dismembered all three the same night, while Ole Budsberg's body, found nearer the surface, was killed later; a watch found on Ray Lamphere was also identified as belonging to missing man Joe Moe.
Middlebury Register · 22 May 1908 · page 8
Mrs. Gunness Evidently an Expert In Human Butchery / REVELATIONS AT AUTOPSIES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Middlebury Register · Middlebury, Vt.
Investigators report finding false teeth in the ashes of the Gunness house, which officials believe prove the burned body is that of Belle Gunness herself. The report also details a new theory that she murdered Jennie Olsen and a couple on the same night, and that a watch taken from suspect Ray Lamphere was identified as belonging to missing man Joe Moe.
Middlebury Register · 22 May 1908 · page 8
REVELATIONS AT AUTOPSIES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
Investigators believe George Riediger of Delafield and John Graham of Waukesha, both missing men who left home to marry a rich widow, were victims of Belle Gunness. A strange note suggesting she changed her mind about marrying one victim is seen as a clue, while the body of Jennie Olsen has now been officially identified and released to relatives.
Eagle River Review · 22 May 1908 · page 2
HAD $1000 UPON LEAVING HOME
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
The report covers several developments in the Gunness investigation, including a Waukesha woman fearing her missing brother was a victim, official identification of Jennie Olsen's body, burial of unidentified remains, and discovery of Mrs. Gunness's dental plates confirming she died in the fire. Sheriff Smutzer declares the teeth evidence proof beyond doubt of her death.
Eagle River Review · 22 May 1908 · page 2
HAD $1000 UPON LEAVING HOME
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
Sheriff Smutzer and miner Louis Schultz continue sluicing ashes at the Gunness farm searching for the murderess's teeth among the debris, with excavation of the burial ground and pond dragging to follow. A tally of victims and the sums Belle Gunness allegedly extracted from each is provided, suggesting she amassed a fortune through murder.
Eagle River Review · 22 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
Authorities continue exhuming bodies and dragging the pond at the Gunness farm while tallying estimated sums she extracted from victims, totaling nearly $47,000. The grand jury began investigating the fourteen deaths as prosecutors and police received death threats demanding they drop the case.
Eagle River Review · 22 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Watertown Weekly Leader · Watertown, Wis.
Coroner Mack in LaPorte, Indiana issued his verdict that the body found was that of Mrs. Belle Gunness, who died by felonious homicide at the hands of an unknown perpetrator. This came after an investigation lasting two weeks.
Watertown Weekly Leader · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Gunness Verdict Says Murder
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Watertown Weekly Leader · Watertown, Wis.
The burial of Andrew Helgelein marks the start of the final stage of the Gunness farm mysteries, with dental evidence confirming remains as Belle Gunness and Helgelein. Several other bodies remain unidentified and likely to be buried in potter's field, while questions about the murder methods and Ray Lamphere's involvement remain unresolved.
Watertown Weekly Leader · 22 May 1908 · page 2
FINAL STAGES AT HAND
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Watertown Weekly Leader · Watertown, Wis.
Forensic identification confirmed the jawbone found in the farmhouse ruins belonged to Belle Gunness, while expert testimony established that the first body found in the barnyard was Andrew Helgelein. The grand jury is set to begin reviewing Sheriff Smutzer's evidence against Ray Lamphere the following Monday, with the case now resting on the courts to resolve.
Watertown Weekly Leader · 22 May 1908 · page 2
FEW DEVELOPMENTS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Watertown Weekly Leader · Watertown, Wis.
Sheriff Smutzer and expert miner Louis Schultz resume sluicing debris at the Gunness farm searching for Belle Gunness's teeth and gold, having finished screening the ashes. The report also tallies suspected sums she collected from various murdered victims, estimating a substantial fortune.
Watertown Weekly Leader · 22 May 1908 · page 2
SLUICE GUNNESS GOLD EXPERT MINER SEARCHES FOR LA PORTE MURDERESS' TEETH
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · Edgerton, Wis.
Autopsies at La Porte revealed that one of the seven unidentified bodies exhumed from Mrs. Gunness's farm was female, reviving interest in Emil Greening's account of a mysterious professor and his wife who visited the night Jennie Olsen disappeared. The body was found in the same grave as Jennie Olsen and Ole Budsberg, though only those two could be positively identified.
The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · 22 May 1908 · page 6
THREE MURDERS IN ONE NIGHT
Story That Greening Told. Greening worked for Mrs. Gunness at the time that Jennie Olsen disap peared, and his story was to the ef fect that on a certain day in Septem ber a man and woman came to the house, and that night Mrs. Gunness asked Greening to sleep in the barn, for the two, whom she said were the professor and his wife from the Los Angeles college which Jennie was to attend, would spend the night at the house, and would require Greening’s bedroom. In the morning Greening saw nothing of Jennie nor the man and woman, and was informed by Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness that they had left on an ear ly train, taking Jennie along. Buds berg in the .Same Grave. This body which is now declared to be that of a woman was taken from the same hole as was that of Jennie Olsen, and in that hole also were the bodies of Ole Budsberg, of loin, Wis., and the remains of a male person. All the bodies were dismembered, but the trunks of the four were in such condi tion that it was possible to identify the bodies of Jennie Olsen and Buds berg, and also possible by the autopsies to determine that one of the other two was that of a female.
Reports describe discovery of additional bodies in the same grave as Jennie Olsen and Ole Budsberg, including an unidentified male and female, with authorities theorizing Mrs. Gunness may have killed three people in one night. A watch found on Ray Lamphere is identified as belonging to missing man John Moe, strengthening suspicion of Gunness's guilt.
The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · 22 May 1908 · page 6
Three Murders in One Night. The theory now advanced is that Mrs. Gunness may have on the same night—the night that Greening slept ia the barn murdered not only Jennie. Olson but also the man and woman. To Coroner Mack. Sheriff Snnitzer and Prosecutor Smith this seems almost inconceivable; but they consider, in the light of recent developments, that noth ing appeared impossible for this arch murderess. The stomachs of the four victims in this hole have been removed, and the contents will be analyzed for poison. The disappearance of Jennie Olsen, as well as the couple, occurred in September, 1900, while Budsberg was disposed of in May, 1907.
The report recounts the April 28 fire at Belle Gunness's farm that killed her and her three children, and details suspicion falling on former hired man Ray Lamphere. It then describes how Asle Helgelein's search for his missing brother led investigators to dig in the farmyard, where a sack containing human bones was discovered.
The Webster Echo · 22 May 1908 · page 1
MURDERS This Woman Killed Seventeen. BONES FOUND.
BONES FOUND. Burning of House Leads to Dis covery of Line of Murders Without Equal in Annals of the Country. On the morning of April 2Stb, the citizens of Laporte, Ind., were shocked by the news that the home of Mrs. Belle Uunness, on a farm near the city, had burned to the ground and that she and her three children, two srirls and a boy, had been cremated. It was immedi ately branded as the work of an incendiary, and suspicion centered upon a former hired man, Ray Lamphere, who is said to have be come enamored of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness and to have annoyed her with his attentions to such a point that a week before the tragedy she had asked the authorities to declare him insane. A commission failed to discover that his mind was un balanced and nothing further was done. After the fire a search was made tor Lamphere and he was found hiding in the woods. When placed in jail he was so agitated and made so many unintelligible statements that he really did appear both guilty and insane. ^ His talk, however, appeared more coherent when Aste K. Ilel gelein appeared in Laporte with
A search prompted by Asle Helgelein, whose brother Andrew vanished after answering a matrimonial ad, uncovers a buried arm and then dismembered bodies on the Gunness property, including Andrew Helgelein's remains. The report also reveals Belle Gunness's background as a Norwegian widow whose first husband Sorenson died suspiciously in Chicago, and details her subsequent marriage to Peter Gunness.
The Webster Echo · 22 May 1908 · page 1
BONES FOUND.
Those familiar with Mrs. Gun ness and her manner of conducting her place, recalled that there was in her barnyard a ‘’soft place” which she insisted should be kept well covered with brush. In a search of the premises, which was inspired by the surviving llelge lein, this attracted attention and it was determined to dig into it. At a depth of about four feet the diggers found a gunny sack con taining the arm of a man. Other dismembered parts ot a human being were quickly unearthed, and when assembled were positively identified by Aste Helgelein as the remains of his brother Andrew.
See moreSee less
Stirred by this grewsome rind, the explorers continued their work eagerly and in a few minutes unearthed the badly decayed body of a girl and the dismembered body of another man. This startling development stim ulated an inquiry into the past of the woman, who, till then, was believed to have perished with her children in the burning of her home. She was found to be a Norwegian, who in 1900 lived in ■Chicago with her first husband, M. S. Sorenson. In that year So renson was found dead in the j kitchen of their home, his skull ■ fractured. Beside him lay a heavv meat grinder covered with blood. Mrs. Sorenson declared that the machine had accidentally fallen upon his head, and as there was no evidence supporting the belief that she had killed him, the case was dropped. Shortly afterward she went to Laporte, and it was remarked that many suitors for her hand ap peared on the scene. While not beautiful, she was rather comely ■and of the robust, seft-reliant type that seems to have appealed strongly to the opposite sex. It was also known that she had re course to the matrimonial papers to stimulate the contest for her affections, a contest seemingly not unpleasing to her. Phillip S. Gunncss, was the ap parently lucky man. They wore t-m ■■ ■;- ; c * ■ " ' ■ . •. . ■ * * i: tKo' ■ ' married in 1902, and npon his death a few months later, she seemed to have been much grieved. For two whole years she remained in comparative seclusion. She had three children, two daughters, Mary and Lucy Sorenson, by her first husband, and Phillip Gun ness, Jr. Maternal instinct seems to have been strong within her, for, in her second widowhood, she induced Jennie Olson, a young daughter of a Chicago acquaint ance, to make her homo with her. The child she adopted verbally, but no legal requirements wero complied with. She came in time, however, it appears, to tire of her loneliness and declared herself willing to consider an eligible third husband. This may also have been the result of financial needs, for it seems that creditors w'ore urging the fair widow to meet various obli gations. This third matrimonial campaign was fraught with more dire results than the first. Her hired mnn, Kay Lamphere, openly manifested a jealousy, expressing himself in a manner that twice caused Mrs. Gunness to have him arrested, ostensibly for the destruction of property. lie seems, however, each time to have been reinstated until the outbreak in April, which occasioned the lunacy proceedings already referred to. Jennie Olson, the adopted daughter, seems to have been .an clement of discord. She disap peared two years ago, Mrs, Gun ness stating that she had sent her to California to attend school. No tidings from her were ever re ceived and it is the belief that tho female body unearthed on tho first day of the search was her remains. Kay Lamphere insists that the third body dug up on that occasion was that of an admirer of Jennie Olson. What took place during these few months is yet to bo discovered. After the first brush-covered “soft spot” in the Gunness barnyard had given up its awful contents, prac tically the entire premises were explored, and counting the two husbands and the foqr deaths in tho burning building, 17 human lives are attributed at present to tho greed of the mysterious woman. ihe authorities are said to have evidence that heavy trunks wore shipped to Mrs. Gunness from Chicago, but those who have probed the case differ in view, some believing that the murders were committed in Chicago and the bodies shipped to Laportc, while others maintain the packing cases contained “quick-lime” with which to hurry the decomposition of the remains of the victims whose lives were ended on the Gunness farm. It has also been stated, and there is much to support the supposition, that the trunks sent to Mrs. Gunness contained the bodies of victims mysteriously slain in the Windy City, but which, instead of being buried in the soft spot, were strewn about the home on the night of the fire and were identified as the remains of Mrs. Gunness and her children, whereas that woman in reality had taken flight and was in hiding. It eveu may bo that the arch fiend in cluded her own offspring in her wholesale machinations and is the sole survivor of her series of hom icides. The authorities now insist that the adult body found in the burnt homo could not have been that of Mrs. Gunness and this deepens their conviction that she is still alive. What connection, if any, llay Lamphere, now charged with the original fire, may have had in the atrocities attributed to his mistress is at present conjecture, llis per sonal effects, seized at the home ho found after leaving Mrs. Gunness’ employ, include letters which at least induced him to retain the im pulse to expose circumstances that aroused his definite suspicion months ago. Other details and circumstances connected with the case and the probability that even more victims may bo added to the I long roll make the Gunness mur- \ der farm unique in criminal anj nals. i