The report recounts Belle Gunness's marriages, the disappearance of her adopted daughter Jennie Olson, and suspicions surrounding hired man Ray Lamphere's jealousy. It details the ongoing investigation into the farm, noting 17 attributed deaths and competing theories about whether bodies were shipped from Chicago or lime was used to speed decomposition.
The Webster Echo · 22 May 1908 · page 1
Kay Lamphere, openly manifested a jealousy, expressing himself in a manner that twice caused Mrs. Gunness to have him arrested, ostensibly for the destruction of property. lie seems, however, each time to have been reinstated until the outbreak in April, which occasioned the lunacy proceedings already referred to. Jennie Olson, the adopted daughter, seems to have been .an clement of discord. She disap peared two years ago, Mrs, Gun ness stating that she had sent her to California to attend school. No tidings from her were ever re ceived and it is the belief that tho female body unearthed on tho first day of the search was her remains.
See moreSee less
Kay Lamphere insists that the third body dug up on that occasion was that of an admirer of Jennie Olson. What took place during these few months is yet to bo discovered. After the first brush-covered “soft spot” in the Gunness barnyard had given up its awful contents, prac tically the entire premises were explored, and counting the two husbands and the foqr deaths in tho burning building, 17 human lives are attributed at present to tho greed of the mysterious woman. ihe authorities are said to have evidence that heavy trunks wore shipped to Mrs. Gunness from Chicago, but those who have probed the case differ in view, some believing that the murders were committed in Chicago and the bodies shipped to Laportc, while others maintain the packing cases contained “quick-lime” with which to hurry the decomposition of the remains of the victims whose lives were ended on the Gunness farm. It has also been stated, and there is much to support the supposition, that the trunks sent to Mrs. Gunness contained the bodies of victims mysteriously slain in the Windy City, but which, instead of being buried in the soft spot, were strewn about the home on the night of the fire and were identified as the remains of Mrs. Gunness and her children, whereas that woman in reality had taken flight and was in hiding. It eveu may bo that the arch fiend in cluded her own offspring in her wholesale machinations and is the sole survivor of her series of hom icides. The authorities now insist that the adult body found in the burnt homo could not have been that of Mrs. Gunness and this deepens their conviction that she is still alive. What connection, if any, llay Lamphere, now charged with the original fire, may have had in the atrocities attributed to his mistress is at present conjecture, llis per sonal effects, seized at the home ho found after leaving Mrs. Gunness’ employ, include letters which at least induced him to retain the im pulse to expose circumstances that aroused his definite suspicion months ago. Other details and circumstances connected with the case and the probability that even more victims may bo added to the I long roll make the Gunness mur- \ der farm unique in criminal anj nals. i t-m ■■ ■;- ; c * ■ " ' ■ . •. . ■ * * i: tKo' ■ ' married in 1902, and npon his death a few months later, she seemed to have been much grieved. For two whole years she remained in comparative seclusion. She had three children, two daughters, Mary and Lucy Sorenson, by her first husband, and Phillip Gun ness, Jr. Maternal instinct seems to have been strong within her, for, in her second widowhood, she induced Jennie Olson, a young daughter of a Chicago acquaint ance, to make her homo with her. The child she adopted verbally, but no legal requirements wero complied with. She came in time, however, it appears, to tire of her loneliness and declared herself willing to consider an eligible third husband. This may also have been the result of financial needs, for it seems that creditors w'ore urging the fair widow to meet various obli gations. This third matrimonial campaign was fraught with more dire results than the first. Her hired mnn, Kay Lamphere, openly manifested a jealousy, expressing himself in a manner that twice caused Mrs. Gunness to have him arrested, ostensibly for the destruction of property. lie seems, however, each time to have been reinstated until the outbreak in April, which occasioned the lunacy proceedings already referred to. Jennie Olson, the adopted daughter, seems to have been .an clement of discord. She disap peared two years ago, Mrs, Gun ness stating that she had sent her to California to attend school. No tidings from her were ever re ceived and it is the belief that tho female body unearthed on tho first day of the search was her remains. Kay Lamphere insists that the third body dug up on that occasion was that of an admirer of Jennie Olson. What took place during these few months is yet to bo discovered. After the first brush-covered “soft spot” in the Gunness barnyard had given up its awful contents, prac tically the entire premises were explored, and counting the two husbands and the foqr deaths in tho burning building, 17 human lives are attributed at present to tho greed of the mysterious woman. ihe authorities are said to have evidence that heavy trunks wore shipped to Mrs. Gunness from Chicago, but those who have probed the case differ in view, some believing that the murders were committed in Chicago and the bodies shipped to Laportc, while others maintain the packing cases contained “quick-lime” with which to hurry the decomposition of the remains of the victims whose lives were ended on the Gunness farm. It has also been stated, and there is much to support the supposition, that the trunks sent to Mrs. Gunness contained the bodies of victims mysteriously slain in the Windy City, but which, instead of being buried in the soft spot, were strewn about the home on the night of the fire and were identified as the remains of Mrs. Gunness and her children, whereas that woman in reality had taken flight and was in hiding. It eveu may bo that the arch fiend in cluded her own offspring in her wholesale machinations and is the sole survivor of her series of hom icides. The authorities now insist that the adult body found in the burnt homo could not have been that of Mrs. Gunness and this deepens their conviction that she is still alive. What connection, if any, llay Lamphere, now charged with the original fire, may have had in the atrocities attributed to his mistress is at present conjecture, llis per sonal effects, seized at the home ho found after leaving Mrs. Gunness’ employ, include letters which at least induced him to retain the im pulse to expose circumstances that aroused his definite suspicion months ago. Other details and circumstances connected with the case and the probability that even more victims may bo added to the I long roll make the Gunness mur- \ der farm unique in criminal anj nals. i
Sheriff Smutzer and Miner Shultz, sifting through the ashes of the Gunness farmhouse fire, found upper and lower dental plates identified by her dentist as belonging to Belle Gunness. The sheriff declared this proof beyond doubt that she had burned to death in the fire.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Wheatland World · 22 May 1908 · page 5
La Porte Murderess Surely Dead
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
A Wyoming newspaper editorial remarks that since teeth were found among the ruins of Belle Gunness's burned Indiana farmhouse, the sensational case may now be grouped with the old Bender murder affair and quietly dropped. It treats the discovery as effectively closing the matter rather than as ongoing news.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Laramie Republican · 22 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
The Laporte county grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere and also indicted Mrs. Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein, even though she had been declared officially dead by the coroner's verdict. The indictment of Gunness as principal was necessary to charge Lamphere as an accessory in the Helgelein killing.
A syndicated newspaper humor column reprints quips from the Birmingham Age-Herald, including one noting that the saying 'dead men tell no tales' is disproven by the discoveries at La Porte, Indiana, on Mrs. Gunness' death farm. The item is a lighthearted compilation of editorial banter rather than direct reporting on the case.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 4
AGE-HERALD ECHOES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
A LaPorte grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere and formally indicted Mrs. Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein, even though she is officially declared dead by the coroner's verdict. The indictment of Gunness as principal was a legal formality needed to charge Lamphere as an accessory, leaving him facing arson, five murder counts, and accessory charges.
Continued digging at the Gunness property uncovered a human skull believed to belong to one of the bodies found in the chicken yard two weeks earlier, when three skeletons were found but only two skulls. The skull, found in a cesspool rather than buried with the rest of the remains, had long hair suggesting it belonged to a woman.
Arizona Republican · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.
A La Porte grand jury returned true bills against Ray Lamphere for arson, multiple murders, and complicity in the death of Andrew Helgelein, and had to indict the presumed-dead Belle Gunness as principal to support the accessory charge. Fresh digging uncovered more human remains, including one believed to belong to a body already found, with hair suggesting a female victim.
In Killing, IlLLAGAINST MRS GUNNESS y to Indict Her to Get Lamphere Charged as Accessory. LA PORTE, Ind., May 22. In reLine H.VCU true bills against Ray BphtTf tins afternoon tho grand jury . . lj Tlitll. nnnnuDj ttr tYi INI .'" ""' ."-...- . - LrJor 'f Andred Hclgelein of Mansa I). No warrant was issued ; M I'unnosH, as who was declared ;mi' bo dead by tho verdict of rMpr Mark, but in order to vote a ' bJf igainst Lampbcro as an nc tviorv (lit killing of Hclgelein, it j nerrsian to indict Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness as , principal ILamphMo now stnnds before tho bar rHtifc ouimlly charged with arson, e murders and being the accessory another murder. Pigging today resulted in unearthing human kwl winch is believed be ep to one of the bodies dug up in the n yard two weeks ago. At the it three skeletons wero found in n -pool and why it was dropped thcro d tho rest of the body buried in the tit cemetery, the authorities cannot, plaia. Long hnir attached to the all is considered evidenco that it boswd to a woman. One of tho throe limbered bodies referred to was that ! a female.
A humor/commentary column touches on various odd topics, including a jab at La Porte police being unable to confirm whether Mrs. Gunness is alive or dead. It also references a man who visited her and survived, suggesting he could profit by selling his story.
The Idaho Springs Siftings-News · Idaho Springs, Colo. · and 3 other papers
Sheriff Smutzer and Miner Shultz, while sifting through ashes from the Gunness fire near La Porte, Indiana, discovered upper and lower dental plates containing false teeth believed to belong to Mrs. Gunness. The find was treated as a significant piece of evidence in the investigation into her presumed death.
The Idaho Springs Siftings-News · 23 May 1908 · page 6
was found guilty. Sheriff Smutzer and Miner Shultz, while sluicing the ashes in the debris of the Gunuess fire near La Porte, In diana, found the upper and lower plates which came from Mrs. Gunness’ mouth, both containing her false teeth.
The Colorado Statesman · Denver, Colo. · 23 May 1908
The Monte Vista Journal · Monte Vista, Colo. · 23 May 1908
The New Era · Walden, Colo. · 28 May 1908
The Glenwood Post · Glenwood Springs, Colo.
An autopsy performed on the seven unidentified bodies exhumed from Belle Gunness' private burial ground near La Porte, Indiana revealed that one of the victims was a woman. The finding came amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news items.
Sheriff Smutzer and Miner Shultz, sifting through the ashes of the Gunness farmhouse fire, discovered upper and lower dental plates with false teeth. Her dentist identified both plates as Mrs. Gunness's, leading the sheriff to declare it proof she died in the fire.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Glenwood Post · 23 May 1908 · page 7
La Porte Murderess Surely Dead.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Sentinel · Grand Junction, Colo.
The LaPorte county grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere and also indicted Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein of Mansfield, S.D. No warrant was issued for Gunness since Coroner Mack had officially declared her dead, but the indictment was legally necessary to charge Lamphere as an accomplice.
The Laporte County grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere and also indicted Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein, even though she had been declared officially dead by the coroner's verdict. Separate murder indictments were also returned against Lamphere for killing Gunness and her three children.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 23 May 1908 · page 1
INDICTS MRS. GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
The La Porte grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, including indicting the officially dead Belle Gunness for Andrew Helgelein's murder so Lamphere could be charged as an accessory. Separately, diggers found a human skull in a cesspool, believed to belong to one of the bodies previously unearthed in the chicken yard.
The San Francisco Call · 23 May 1908 · page 5
INDICTED THOUGH OFFICIALLY DEAD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
The Laporte grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, charging him with arson, five murders, and being an accessory in the murder of Andrew Helgelein, which required also indicting the officially deceased Belle Gunness as principal. Diggers also unearthed a skull believed to belong to one of the bodies found earlier in the chicken yard, found oddly in a cesspool rather than with the rest of the remains.
Los Angeles Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 1
MURDER AND ARSON IN GRAND JURY BILLS FIND SEVEN COUNTS AGAINST RAY LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
A dispatch from South Bend, Indiana reports that James Brimmingstall of Dowagiac, Michigan, is under arrest and accused of six murders, with police saying he has confessed to two after allegedly trying to kill his wife. The same digest notes that seven indictments for murder and arson have been found against Ray Lamphere in the Gunness case.
Los Angeles Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 1
MICHIGAN MAN'S CRIMES RIVAL MRS. GUNNESS SIX KNOWN MURDERS ARE CHARGED TO HIM HAS MADE CONFESSION OF TWO KILLINGS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
The Laporte County Grand Jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, charging him with arson, five murders, and being an accessory to the murder of Andrew Helgelein; Mrs. Gunness, declared legally dead, was also indicted as principal. Sheriff Smutzer's crew found another skull in the chicken yard dig and jewelry linked to missing Rochester woman May O'Reilly.
New-York Tribune · 23 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Gazette · Cleveland, Ohio
The item reports that Andrew Helgelein, the last known victim, was buried at Laporte while a jawbone fragment from the farmhouse ruins was identified by a dentist as Mrs. Gunness' skull. It also states that autopsy confirmed one of the seven unidentified bodies was a woman, and that finding her false teeth made it certain Mrs. Gunness was dead.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Gazette · 23 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
District Attorney Bresnahan said he questioned Brimmingstall about rumors he was an accomplice of Mrs. Gunness, but concluded he likely never knew her and only learned of her crimes from newspapers. Brimmingstall is expected to be arraigned Monday.
The Washington Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A grand jury investigating the Gunness farmhouse fire and its victims returned three indictments against Ray Lamphere, charging him with arson for setting fire to Belle Gunness's home on April 28, in which she and her three children died, and with murder as both principal and accessory. The report also notes ongoing efforts to identify other possible victims, including a Dayton man and a New Yorker's claim of seeing a woman after the tragedy.
The Washington Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 1
LAPORTE RAY LAMPHERE HELD - Laporte Man Is Indicted for Arson and Murder - OTHER VICTIMS ARE SOUGHT - Dayton Man Is Believed Among Those Murdered at Gunness Home - Sheriff Finds Skull on Farm - New Yorker Says He Saw Woman Several Days After the Indiana Tragedy
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
James Brimmingstall of Dowagiac, Michigan is arrested after his wife accuses him of killing a man, David Huff, by smothering him with pillows years earlier. The report notes his case rivals the Gunness murders in scale but states he was not an accomplice of the Laporte woman.
The Washington Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 1
CASE IN MICHIGAN RIVALS GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
District Attorney Bresnahan questions murder suspect Brimmingstall about rumors linking him to Belle Gunness as an accomplice, but dismisses the connection. Brimmingstall, held in Cassopolis on other murder charges involving his family's deaths, promises a statement but has not confessed to Michigan crimes.
The Washington Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A Laporte grand jury returned indictments against Ray Lamphere for arson in burning Belle Gunness's house and for the murders of Andrew Helgelein and of Gunness and her three children. The sheriff also found a skull on the farm, and investigators sought to identify other possible victims, including a Dayton, Ohio man linked to a watch found in the ruins.
The Washington Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 1
RAY LAMPHERE HELD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
This miscellaneous newspaper humor column makes a passing joke comparing the notoriety of Belle Gunness to Col. Raisuli, noting that despite her fame, Raisuli still outdoes her in periodically appearing to die and then resurrecting himself. The remark reflects public uncertainty at the time about whether Gunness was truly dead.
The Washington Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The Laporte grand jury returned seven indictments against Ray Lamphere, covering the murders of Belle Gunness and her three children, arson, the murder of Andrew Helgelein, and being an accessory to Gunness in that killing. Because Gunness was officially declared dead by the coroner, she too was indicted as principal in the Helgelein murder to allow Lamphere's accessory charge to stand.
Evening Star · 23 May 1908 · page 2
LAMPHEREIS INDICTED GRAND JURY FILES SEVEN BILLS AGAINST SUSPECT.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A grand jury returned indictments against Ray Lamphere for arson, the murders of Belle Gunness and her three children, and as an accessory in Andrew Helgelien's murder, requiring Belle Gunness herself to be indicted as principal despite being declared dead by the coroner. Diggers also found another skull, confirming a third body among the remains previously unearthed in the chicken yard.
Evening Star · 23 May 1908 · page 2
BILLS AGAINST SUSPECT.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
This is a newspaper's table of contents listing various stories, including an Iowa News item titled 'Not a Gunness Victim.' The surrounding text is unrelated political commentary about Iowa politicians Cummins and Boles.
Evening Times-Republican · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
Dr. Dresser, a Stanhope physician feared to be a victim of Belle Gunness's murder farm, was actually found to be alive in Colo, where he had been courting a widow. His disappearance had been wrongly linked to the La Porte case after he left for Indiana claiming he was going to marry someone there.
A grand jury in Laporte returned seven indictments against Ray Lamphere, covering the murders of Belle Gunness, her children, and Andrew Helgelein, plus arson and accessory charges. Separately, Sheriff Smutzer resumed digging on the farm and found jewelry belonging to a missing Rochester, N.Y. woman, May O'Reilly, suggesting another victim.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 23 May 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
7 INDICTMENTS RETURNED FOR RAY LAMPHERE
HIRED MAN ON GUNNESS FARM IS HELD FOR MURDER, ARSON AND AS BEING AN ACCOMPLI OF MURDERESS.
See moreSee less
TRACE OF ANOTHER VICTIM IS FOUND
JEWELRY BELONGING TO ROCHESTER, N. Y., WOMAN IS DUG UP AND IT IS FOUND SHE HAS BEEN MISSING FROM HOME.
Laporte, Ind., May 22.—The grand jury this afternoon returned seven indictments against Ray Lamphere, one each for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness, Phillip Gunness, Lucy Sorenson, Myrtle Sorenson, by destroying the Gunness home, one for arson, one for murder of Andrew Helgelein and one for being an accessory in assisting Mrs. Gunness in the murder of Helgeleln.
Laporte, Ind., May 22.—After ten lays' delay digging on the Gunness farm, in the search for more bodies was resumed today and jewelry belonging to May O'Reilly, who lived in Rockester, N. Y., was found by Sheriff Smutzer, who communicated the fact to the Rochester police. They replied today that the woman disappeared from her home several months ago.
More Discoveries Expected.
When asked whether he expects to find more dismembered bodies in the Gunness chicken yard, Sheriff Smutzer replied:
"I wouldn't be surprised at anything. We shall dig all over the chicken yard, and in several other places of suspicious appearance, and, if we can get to it, under the barn. The general belief that more bodies remain to be found probably is well founded."
Eleven razors, a heart shaped jewel box of gold, and a man's watch chain of foreign workmanship were added to Sheriff Smutzer's relics of the fire last night.
John E. Bunter of Duquesne, Pa., may have fallen victim to Mrs. Gunness. According to a daughter, Mrs. Kuler of McKeesport, Pa., Buntner left his home on Nov. 25, 1907, without telling his relatives where he was going. Butner had been talking about a woman he intended to marry "out in Indiana."
A short item states that the discovery of jaws and false teeth belonging to Mrs. Gunness should resolve questions about her current whereabouts. It implies the dental remains prove she died in the fire at her farm.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 23 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
American Falls Press · American Falls, Idaho
Herman Rhode insists he saw and talked to Mrs. Belle Gunness in St. Paul no later than Tuesday, convinced by her resemblance to published photographs of the alleged murderess. He went to the newspaper office and, when shown a photo, remained adamant in his identification.
American Falls Press · 23 May 1908 · page 6
Imagines He Saw Mrs. Gunnesa. 8t. Faul. Minn.—Herman Rhode Is positive that be saw and talked to Mrs. Belle Gunness In this city not later than Tuesday of this week. He was so firmly convinced that tha woman was Mrs. Gunness from her resemblance to the newspaper photo graphs published of tho alleged In fftaaa murderess that he carie to the K. Pkffl Dispatch office at noon on Tlmihj and when shown s photo msth et Mrs. Ounness, reiterated with
A humor column one-liner notes that La Porte has grown bored (ennui) because of the ongoing Gunness case, joking that even a dog fight would be welcome relief. It is surrounded by unrelated jokes, poems, and labor news items.
The Lake County Times · 23 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Reports indicate the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of complicity in Belle Gunness's murders, will likely be venued to the circuit court in Valparaiso due to difficulty finding an unprejudiced jury in LaPorte. The prosecutor and defense attorney have tentatively agreed to hold the trial in late June or early July.
The Lake County Times · 23 May 1908 · page 8
It Is probable that the trial ot Ray Lanipherr, who Is charged with com plicity with Mrs. Belle Gunness In the murder of Andrew Helgelin and others of Mrs. Gnnness' victims, will be venued to the circuit court In Valparaiso, In the adjoining county. t It Is anticipated that there will be great difficulty in obtaining an un prejudiced jury in LaPorte county. When it became apparent that the case would be tried outside of LaPorte, Judge Virgil S. Relter of the Lake su perior court was asked If there was any possibility of Its being venued to the court at Hammond or Crown Point.
The LaPorte grand jury returned indictments against Ray Lamphere and, necessarily, against Belle Gunness as principal in the murder of Andrew Helgelein, though no warrant was issued since she was declared officially dead. Simultaneously, Sheriff Smetzer recovered a human skull from the farm's catch basin, raising questions about whether it belonged to a previously exhumed body or an unknown new victim.
The Lake County Times · 23 May 1908 · page 8
NEW VICTIM'S SKULL FOUND
Indictments Are Returned. In returning seven true bills against -Ray Lamphere this afternoon the La Porte county grand jury also indicted Mrs. Belle Gunness for the murder of
Investigators are puzzled by a decomposed head found apart from four exhumed bodies, unsure if it belongs to a previously unidentified victim or one already found headless. Meanwhile, grand jury indictments against Ray Lamphere specify murder and arson charges covering Belle Gunness and three children killed in the house fire.
The Lake County Times · 23 May 1908 · page 8
NEW VICTIM'S SKULL FOUND
Found in Remote Position. A head was missing when four bodies were exhumed from one grave, after the discovery of the body of Andrew K. Helgelein. The head found today is badly decomposed, but not to such an extent as the body to which the author ities believe it belongs! It has dark hair clinging to it and a guess would place the victim as a man of middle age. Mrs. Gunness disposed of the head in a place of remote from the graves of other victims is one of the many un known quantities which figure in the Gunness story.
See moreSee less
Murder Bills Are Specific The indictments returned against Lampheile were even more sweeping than had been generally anticipated They assure a criminal trial which un doubtedly will attract attention all over the country. There are three, indict ments cnarging Lamphere with the murder of Mrs. Gunness and with arson by setting fire to the dwelling house. Three counts of this indictment are similar in form and are for the deaths of Myrtle Sorensen, Lucy Sorensen, and Philip Gunness, the children who were with Mrs. Gunness in the house at the time of the burning of April 28.
A Laporte, Indiana grand jury investigating the Gunness farmhouse fire returned three indictments against Ray Lamphere. He is charged with arson for setting fire to Mrs. Gunness's home on April 28, and with being a principal or accessory to the murders of Andrew Helgelein and Mrs. Gunness and her three children.
Rock Island Argus · 23 May 1908 · page 1
which has been investigating the GunInstitutions. The message i3 a stinging arraignment of the committee ness house on the bill and its trage for unfairness, and Is very lengthy. It dies came into Judge Richter's court is backed up by voluminous records yesterday afternoon and returned from the state institutions and reports . three indictments. Lamphere is r of the superintendents of the same. j charged with arson in setting fire to The governor charges the committee the home of Mrs. Gunness on the with being biased and not endeavoring morning of April 28.
See moreSee less
He is charged to ascertain the true facts in regard to also with being a principal and an ac the institutions. At the conclusion the I cessory after the fact in the mufder cf Andrew Helgelein of Aberdeen, S. governor-aays: D., and with the murder of Mrs. Gun lues Vigorous IianiniaKr.
A La Porte, Indiana grand jury returns seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, charging him with arson, five counts of first-degree murder (Belle Gunness and her three children, plus Andrew Helgelein), and accessory to Helgelein's murder. Because an accessory charge requires a named principal, Belle Gunness herself was indicted for Helgelein's murder, bringing the total to eight true bills.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Cairo Bulletin · 23 May 1908 · page 1
SEVEN COUNTS LAMPHERE FACES CHARGES OF ARSON, FIVE MURDERS AND ACCESSORY IN ANOTHER. MRS. GUNNESS INDICTED For Murder of Helgelein Grand Jury Return Total Eight True Bills Against Principals in Famous Case.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Cairo Bulletin · Cairo, Ill.
A grand jury returns seven indictments against Ray Lamphere, including arson for burning Belle Gunness's house, murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, murder of Andrew Helgelein, and acting as accessory to Helgelein's murder by Gunness. Separately, a search of the farm uncovers a third skeleton with long hair in a cesspool, believed to be female.
The Cairo Bulletin · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Dziennik Narodowy · Chicago, Ill.
The grand jury in Laporte finished hearing witnesses and named Belle Gunness as the murderer of Andrew Helgelein, but did not indict her because the coroner had certified her own death. Instead, seven indictments were brought against her former hired hand Ray Lamphere, accusing him of killing Gunness and her three children, aiding in Helgelein's murder, and killing her two former husbands and two children from her first marriage; a man's skull was also unearthed in the farm's garden.
Dziennik Narodowy · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Z KRONIKI MORDERSTW. SIEDM SKARG WYTOCZONYCH POWIERNIKOWI ZBRODNIARKI WDOWY.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A Dowagiac, Michigan painter named Brimmingstall was arrested after his wife accused him of murdering numerous people, with his crimes allegedly rivaling the infamous Belle Gunness case. Relatives claimed he killed as many as sixteen people, including unidentified victims and two previous wives and four children who died under suspicious circumstances.
Paper unidentified · 23 May 1908 · page 1
GUNNESS MURDER RECORD EQUALED BY MICHIGAN MAN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
The La Porte county grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, including murder charges for the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and her three children, and indicted the presumed-dead Belle Gunness as principal in the murder of Andrew Helgelein to support an accessory charge against Lamphere. Digging at the site under Sheriff Smutzer continued, turning up another human skull believed to belong to one of the previously unearthed bodies.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 23 May 1908 · page 12
LAMPHERE INDICTED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
A man named Carling, who reportedly went to La Porte to meet a rich widow, is believed by his wife to be one of the murdered victims due to matching dental features. Separately, Rochester police are investigating whether a body found on the farm is that of Mae L. O'Reilly, based on jewelry found nearby bearing her name.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 23 May 1908 · page 12
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Police in Dowagiac, Michigan report that James Brimmingstall has confessed to killing six people, with suspicions he murdered as many as sixteen, drawing comparison to the Gunness case. His wife's sworn statement describes witnessing him smother a victim named David Huff with pillows.
The Detroit Times · 23 May 1908 · page 1
BRIMMINGSTALL CONFESSION SAYS HE KILLED SIX — DOWAGIAC GORE OF MRS. GUNNESS TYPE SUSPECTED OF HAVING MURDERED TEN OTHERS — WIFE'S STATEMENT.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Sheriff Smutzer notifies Rochester police that a body exhumed on the Gunness farm is believed to be a Rochester woman, based on jewelry inscribed with the name Mae L. O'Reilly. The name does not appear in the Rochester city directory, leaving her identity still uncertain.
The Detroit Times · 23 May 1908 · page 4
ROCHESTER, N. Y., WOMAN MRS. GUNNESS' VICTIM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Police in Dowagiac, Michigan report that James Brimmingstall, 41, has confessed to killing six people, with his wife testifying she witnessed one murder. Authorities describe him as having a murderous urge 'of the Mrs. Gunness type,' suggesting up to sixteen victims may exist.
The Detroit Times · 23 May 1908 · page 1
James Brimmingstall. aged 41, is a murderous urge of the Mra. Gunness type Is now said to be fully estab lished by the police, who claim that the man has confessed to the killing of six persons, although it is believed his victims number at least IC. Briminingstall's wife, on whose ac cusation he was arrested, says shv saw him kill oue man —linvid Husf — smothering him with pillows as he lay In bed. Her husband then told her (CoatlniM-d on Seoon«l I'lisO,
A grand jury in La Porte, Indiana returned three indictments against Ray Lamphere, former farm hand of Belle Gunness, charging him with the murders of Gunness and her three children, arson in burning their house, and complicity in the murder of Andrew Helgelein. Meanwhile, another skull was found in a vault on the farm, and investigators were also looking into whether a missing Dayton, Ohio man might be among the victims based on a watch found among Gunness's effects.
The Detroit Times · 23 May 1908 · page 4
COMES TO LIGHT. LA PORTE, Ind., May 23.—Three tnfliotmeaLs, charging murder and arson against Ray Lamphere, Mrs Qonaeas’ former farm hand, were brought In by the grand Jury, yester day afternoon, lamp here Is charged with the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children Myrtle, lacy and i Philip; with arson In burning down the house In which they are bettered ' to here perished and with being a \ principal and an accessory after the 1 fact in the murder of Andrew Helgelein, of Aberdeen, 8. D. The. state sets forth, is keeping I with the provisions of the law, that ! It will .prove the material allegations ‘by the evidence-of John . Rye, William Anstlss, Charles Hralth. D. M. Hutson,
Sheriff Smutzer discovers a skull in a vault at the Gunness farm, prompting a full investigation into whether other victims are buried there. Multiple reports surface of missing men from Ohio and Michigan who may have been victims, while a New York man claims to have seen Belle Gunness alive after the fire.
The Detroit Times · 23 May 1908 · page 4
COMES TO LIGHT
JACKSON. Mich.. May A*—K surmised that Edward Swanson.'who disappeared from Jackson last Sep tember, may have been s victim of Mrs. Gunness, of Deports, Ind. His Uls
Coroner Mack's inquest report on the Gunness farm deaths could not determine causes of death for the 14 victims, nor positively confirm that the burned bodies were Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Prosecutors advanced a new theory that Ray Lamphere returned to a neighbor's house after setting the fire, based on witnesses who saw him near the scene around the time flames appeared.
The Irish Standard · 23 May 1908 · page 7
CAUSE OF DEATHS UNKNOWN THAT IS CORONER'S REPORT IN GUNNESS CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn.
An unidentified Gunness victim, found in the barnyard, was buried beside Andrew Helgelein with family present. Prosecutors advanced a new theory that Ray Lamphere returned briefly to Elizabeth Smith's home after setting the Gunness house fire before fleeing to the Wheatbrook farm.
The Irish Standard · 23 May 1908 · page 7
GUNNESS CASE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laclede Blade · Laclede, Mo.
Searchers sifting the ashes of Belle Gunness's burned LaPorte farmhouse reportedly found her upper and lower false teeth bridges, which authorities cited as conclusive proof she perished in the April 28 fire. The discovery was presented as settling the question of her death.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Laclede Blade · 23 May 1908 · page 7
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Southern Farm Gazette · Starkville, Miss.
A roundup item reports that Indiana has what promises to be a great criminal sensation: Mrs. Gunness enticed men with matrimonial ads requesting $1,000 as good-faith money, then murdered fourteen of them. The item appears as a brief aside within a broader review of national news and conservation conference coverage.
The Southern Farm Gazette · 23 May 1908 · page 8
It to be.—Congress has passed a number of appropriation bills, and an especially strong ef fort, barked by the Governors' Conference, u making to force action on the forest reserve bill. The llrownsvllle case has been postponed for final action till next December The political conventions held these last f.-w days have not al tered the outlook for llryan and Taft Roth In j North Carolina and Virginia last »wk negro It* publicans held Independent Stale Conventions and elected delegateo-at-Jarge to the National Republican Convention who will contest the seat* of delegates elected by the regular "Illy white" organizations.
See moreSee less
Kx-Governor Daniel L. Russel, of North Carolina, died near Wilmington. Thursday, ag«*d sixty-three years Indiana ha* what prom ises to he one of the great criminal sensations of our time. For years past a Mrs Gunness ha* en ticed men to her homo with a matrimonial advi-r tlsernent, asking suitors to bring $1,000 a* a guarantee of good faith. Hho has murdered fourteen such suckers In the course of her career The scheme for old age pensions Is now »erl .1 I .. 1* .m I — a.. L'l .4 .. t I_^ ... . t • i « u'ltiwi n ** in' in ' ii la to bo paid persona over Keventy. Cotton had a turn upward for a time laat week, but the gen eral business situation la Improving only slowly Many Southern cotton mills are not running on full time, and In Kngland 30,000 operatives In the Lancashire district are out of work - With our next issue the usual full review of the news .will be resumed. * Tin: I’AitMi:it’s intkickht in tiik wiiiti:
The Laporte county council appropriated $9,000 to support officials investigating the Gunness case. This funding ensures Sheriff Smutzer can continue his investigation at the death farm and allows Coroner Mack to proceed with chemical analysis of remains found there.
The Grenada Sentinel · 23 May 1908 · page 6
has The Laporte county council appropriated $9,000 for the use of of ficials concerned In the developments in the Gunness case. This assurer the continuance of Sheriff Smutzer's
The disappearance of two more Wisconsin men, David Hicken of Waukesha and Riediger of Delafield, believed to be victims of Mrs. Belle Gunness, was reported to Sheriff Smutzer. A letter indicated Hicken had disappeared a year earlier after announcing he was going to La Porte to marry a rich widow.
The Grenada Sentinel · 23 May 1908 · page 6
of The disappearance in Laporte two more Wisconsui men, believed to be victims of Mrs. Belle Gunne: was reported to Sheriff Smutzer. A letter from David Hicken, Waukesha, Wis., Wis., Riediger of Delafield. said G.
The report notes that citizens of La Porte believed Mrs. Gunness had perished in the fire that destroyed her home, and that Ray Lamphere was responsible for setting it. Many expressed anger that the children had also been killed in the blaze.
The Hattiesburg News · 23 May 1908 · page 4
Laporte citizens are convinced that Mrs. Gunness perished in the flames that destroyed her home, and that Ray Lamphere was responsible for the burning of the place. The general feeling is that it was wrong to burn up
The Laporte county grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, charging him with arson, five murders, and being an accessory in the killing of Andrew Helgelein. Mrs. Belle Gunness, though declared officially dead, was also indicted as principal in Helgelein's murder so that Lamphere could be charged as accessory.
Paper unidentified · 23 May 1908 · page 1
INDICTED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A grand jury formally indicted Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew K. Helgelein on January 14, 1908, with Ray Lamphere indicted as an accessory. Judge Richter also appointed an administrator for Helgelein's estate to pursue recovery of $2,900 allegedly taken by Gunness.
Paper unidentified · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
The Laporte county grand jury returned true bills charging Ray Lamphere with arson, five murders, and being an accessory to the murder of Andrew Helgelein, while also indicting the officially 'dead' Belle Gunness as the principal in that killing. Separate bills charged Lamphere with the first-degree murder of Gunness herself and her three children.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 23 May 1908 · page 2
GRAND JURY INDICTS MRS. BELLE GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
A La Porte grand jury returned three indictments against Ray Lamphere: setting fire to Belle Gunness's home, being an accessory and principal in the murder of Andrew Helgelien, and the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children. Separately, Sheriff Smutzer found a skull in a vault on the farm believed to belong to a body found in the graveyard, and a coroner received an inquiry about a watch matching one found in the fire debris.
The Sun · 23 May 1908 · page 8
RAY LAMPHERE INDICTED: Two Charges of Murder and One of Arson in the Gunness Case
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · Tonopah, Nev.
The LaPorte County Grand Jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, including five murder charges, arson, and being accessory to the murder of Andrew Helgelin. Mrs. Gunness was also indicted as principal in the Helgelin killing despite being declared officially dead, and diggers found another skull believed to belong to one of the chicken yard victims.
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Lamphere Indicted On Murder Charge
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Tonopah Bonanza · Butler, Nev.
The coroner will file official reports on the deaths of Mrs. Gunness's three children, and the Grand Jury is expected to complete its work with possible indictments reported to the court. Sheriff Smutzer will resume digging for bodies in the Gunness yard, with a public sale of her property scheduled for May 29th.
Tonopah Bonanza · 23 May 1908 · page 1
FOR MORE BODIES (By Associated Press.) LAPORTE, Ind., May 21. Tomor row promises developmenst in the dimness case. Early this morning Coroner Mack will file his official re ports on the death of the three chil dren of Mrs. Gunness. Some time during the day the Grand Jury will complete Its labors. If true bills ar; voted. Indictments will be reported to Judge Richter In the Laporte Cir cuit Court. Sheriff Smutzer resumes the digging for bodies tomorrow in the Gunness yard. On Friday, May 29th, Executor Fogle will hold a pub lic sale of the personal property left
The Laporte County grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, including indictments for the murders of Belle Gunness and her three children, and also indicted the officially dead Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein so that Lamphere could be charged as an accessory. Lamphere was served with bench warrants but not yet arraigned, and expressed little surprise at the indictments.
The Morning Tribune · 23 May 1908 · page 1
RAY LAMPHERE FACES SEVEN INDICTMENTS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
A grand jury indictment charges Ray Lamphere with the murder of Andrew Helgelein, and digging at the Gunness farm uncovers another skull believed to belong to one of the previously found skeletons. Separately, friends of missing Chicago insurance manager Benjamin Carling suspect he may be another of Belle Gunness's victims based on dental identification.
The Morning Tribune · 23 May 1908 · page 1
INDICTMENTS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Waxahachie Daily Light · Waxahachie, Tex.
The Laporte county grand jury returned indictments against Ray Lamphere for arson and the murders of Belle Gunness and her three children, as well as being an accessory in the killing of Andrew Helgelein. Because Mrs. Gunness was legally declared dead by the coroner's verdict, she had to be indicted as the principal in the Helgelein murder in order to charge Lamphere as an accomplice.
The Waxahachie Daily Light · 23 May 1908 · page 1
IS INDICTED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Garland Globe · Garland, Utah
A man named Herman Rhode insists he saw and spoke with Belle Gunness in St. Paul earlier that week, convinced by her resemblance to published photographs. He went to a newspaper office to assert his claim even after being shown her picture again.
The Garland Globe · 23 May 1908 · page 2
Imagines He Saw Mrs. Gunness.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
The La Porte county grand jury returned seven indictments against Ray Lamphere, including murder charges and arson, and also indicted Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein even though she had been officially declared dead by the coroner's verdict. No warrant was issued for Gunness since the indictment was needed only to charge Lamphere as an accessory.
The Salt Lake Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 1
SKULL OF A WOMAN FOUND Seven Indictments Against Ray Lamphere Other Developments at Laporte, Ind.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A grand jury indicted Ray Lamphere on charges of arson, five murders, and being an accessory to the murder of Andrew Helgelein, necessitating the formal indictment of Belle Gunness as principal. Diggers also unearthed another human skull believed to belong to one of the bodies found in the chicken yard, found oddly in a cesspool with long hair suggesting it was a woman's.
The Salt Lake Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A newspaper opinion column touches briefly on the case of the 'comely widow of Laporte,' noting that exposure of a dozen or more murders of moneyed men will likely make people wary of matrimonial advertisements and marriage bureaus. The remark appears amid a miscellany of unrelated commentary on politics, sports, and city affairs.
Paper unidentified · 23 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A miscellany column of brief editorial quips touches on various topics including automobiles, the navy, and politics. It includes a skeptical remark that until Mrs. Gunness is proven dead, widows seeking husbands through personal ads may have cause for concern.
Paper unidentified · 23 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Press · Newport News, Va.
The La Porte county grand jury returned seven true bills, indicting Ray Lamphere for arson, five murders, and being an accessory to the murder of Andrew Helgelien, while also indicting the officially-dead Belle Gunness as principal in that killing to enable Lamphere's prosecution. Lamphere, served with bench warrants in jail, expressed little surprise and said he would seek an early trial date.
Daily Press · 23 May 1908 · page 1
TRUE BILL AGAINST MRS. GUNNESS
her three children. Philip Gunness, Myrtle Sorensen and Lucy Sorensen. The unusual feature of the seventh true-hill is its Indictment of the dead woman. It reads: "The grand jury presents that Belle Gunness. late of the county of Laporf". and state of Indiana, on the Hth day of January. lJWIS, did unlawfully, feloniously, wil? fully and with premeditated malice kill and murder Andrew Helgelrln. th?? means and manner of stich kill ing being to the grand jury unknown." Lamphere Not Arraigned.
The LaPorte county grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere and also indicted Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein, though no warrant was issued since she was legally declared dead. Lamphere now faces charges of arson, multiple murders, and being an accessory in the Helgelein killing.
Alexandria Gazette · 23 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Spirit of the Age · Woodstock, Vt.
A Laporte dentist identifies a piece of jawbone found in the Gunness fire ruins as belonging to Mrs. Gunness based on distinctive features of her teeth. This follows an earlier report of two jawbone fragments found in the ruins, reinforcing belief that she died in the April 28 fire.
Spirit of the Age · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Spirit of the Age · Woodstock, Vt.
A coroner's report states one of the Gunness farm murder victims died of unknown causes. Separately, investigators discover that one of the unidentified bodies is that of a woman, suggesting a triple murder occurred around the time Jennie Olson disappeared in 1904.
Spirit of the Age · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Spirit of the Age · Woodstock, Vt.
Bridgework found in the ashes of the Laporte farm is identified as belonging to Mrs. Gunness's mouth, supporting the theory she died in the fire. William Riedinger and Henry Gurholdt are named as probable victims of the 'murder farm.'
Spirit of the Age · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Pullman Herald · Pullman, Wash.
Laporte county commissioners set aside $7,000 for a reward if Mrs. Belle Gunness is found alive, with $5,000 for coroner expenses and $2,000 for the sheriff's search. Digging on the 'murder farm' has largely stopped since no more bodies are expected to be found.
Pullman Herald · 23 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
Coroner Mack of LaPorte, Indiana filed his official report on the deaths of the Gunness children, ruling they died by felonious homicide. The perpetrators were listed as unknown to the coroner.
The Daily Telegram · 23 May 1908 · page 3
CORONER FILES REPORT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
A humor/commentary column notes there seem to be about as many women claiming to be Mrs. Gunness around the country as there are missing Gunness victims. The remark is a sarcastic aside amid other miscellaneous local jokes and trivia.
The Daily Telegram · 23 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The West Virginia News · Ronceverte, W. Va.
Sheriff Smutzer plans to drag the farm pond and possibly dig under the barn after an anonymous tip of bodies buried there. A West Virginia man, Abraham Phillips, is identified as a likely victim, while Coroner Mack confirms one exhumed body as Jennie Olson and orders autopsies on others.
The West Virginia News · 23 May 1908 · page 1
WEST VIRGINIAN A VICTIM
Drs. F. T. Wilcox and George R. Osborn t o hold autopsies o n bodies and skeletons of seven un known persons exhumed from the Gunness farm. Two of these have trunks which contain inter nal organs and so it is expected it will be possible to determine if death was caused by poison of any kind. Complete and careful descriptions of all marks, teeth, skulls, etc., will be taken of the seven skeletons and these will be filed for the purpose of identifi cation in future. Finding was made by Coroner Mack that the body of the female found in the ground is that of Jennie Olson, she having been identified by her father and sister at Chicago.
See moreSee less
Coroner Mack stated that he would soon render his verdict in the cases of the fourteen dead in the Gunness mystery. At Philippi, Barbour county, , Mrs. Martha Duckworth was awarded $1,500 damages in a suit brought against Floyd Stalnaker, a saloonkeeper, for injuries to her \ husband. Duckworth became in \ toxicated in Stalnaker’s saloon l and the latter threw him out, | breaking both bones in his leg.
The LaPorte county grand jury, investigating the Gunness farm murders, returned three indictments against Ray Lamphere, charging him with arson, the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children, and complicity in the murder of Andrew Helgelien. This marks a formal legal step following the investigation into the 'Gunness charnal house' tragedies.
The Laramie Republican · 23 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
LaPorte authorities begin preparing for Ray Lamphere's trial, with prosecutors signaling he may first be tried for the murder of Andrew Helgelien. Meanwhile, Coroner Mack filed official verdicts of felonious homicide for four more victims found on the Gunness farm, and a missing man named Olef Jensen is suspected of being another victim.
Arizona Republican · 24 May 1908 · page 8
MAYBE ANOTHER VICTIM OF THE LA PORTE WIDOW
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Coroner Mack filed official reports declaring that four more victims found at the Gunness farm—Jennie Olsen, Ole Budsberg, and two unidentified bodies—died through felonious homicide. The coroner stated the persons responsible were unknown to him, with six more bodies still to be reported on.
The San Francisco Call · 24 May 1908 · page 33
CORONER REPORTS ON MRS. GUNNESS f VICTIMS Holds That Four Were Feloniously Killed by Persans Unknown to Him IJL POBTB. Ind^ MarJa^-^peolarlnx Chat they came to their deaths through felonious homicide. Coroner Mack this •vening filed his c facial reports on' tne Ceaths of four more vctlms ot the GunSiess farm. ; Th« verdicts are In the'eases of Jen "sJeOlsen of Chicago, Ole : Budsbnrg "of lola, Wis., and two unidentified bodies, one male and one female. •. The coroner holds that the persons who are re sponsible for their deaths are to him unknown. Six bodies still remain to be reported or_
Preparations begin for Ray Lamphere's trial on charges of murdering five people, with prosecutors announcing he will first be tried for the killing of Andrew Helgelein. The defense states it will not rely solely on an alibi, while a related note suggests another missing man, Olaf Jensen, may have been one of Gunness's victims.
Los Angeles Herald · 24 May 1908 · page 1
HAS STRONG EVIDENCE ON HELGELEIN MURDER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
The La Porte coroner filed official reports on four more victims found at the Gunness farm, identifying them as Jennie Olsen of Chicago, Ole Budsberg of Iola, Wis., and two unidentified bodies. The verdicts declared the deaths caused by persons unknown to the coroner, with six more bodies still awaiting reports.
Los Angeles Herald · 24 May 1908 · page 2
CORONER FILES REPORT ON FOUR GUNNESS VICTIMS
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
State's Attorney Smith announces he will try Ray Lamphere specifically for killing Andrew Helgelien, the South Dakota rancher found dead at the Gunness farm in January. The state claims evidence will show Helgelien was lured to the farm while carrying over $2,800, which was taken from him before his death.
The Washington Herald · 24 May 1908 · page 3
RAY LAMPHERE IN NET Gunness Farmhand Blamed for Helgelein's Death
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
The report outlines the state's planned case against Ray Lamphere, alleging he conspired with Belle Gunness to murder Andrew Helgelien after learning he had over $2,800, and that he helped decapitate and bury the body. It also claims fresh evidence that Olaf Jensen of Capron, Illinois, was killed at the Gunness farm in 1906 after withdrawing $2,600 to marry the 'widow'.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Herald · 24 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Investigators found evidence suggesting Olaf Jensen was killed at the Gunness farm in May 1906 after withdrawing $2600 and claiming he would marry a wealthy widow in Indiana. Physicians confirmed a skull found at the site belonged to a woman based on nearby black hair, while authorities also sought to identify missing man Patrick Griffin and coordinated with the German consul on the investigation.
The Washington Herald · 24 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
State's Attorney Smith announced Lamphere will be tried first for the killing of Andrew Helgelein, alleging he conspired with Mrs. Gunness to murder the South Dakota rancher after duping him out of nearly $3,000. The state will seek the death penalty, presenting evidence that Lamphere assisted in decapitating and dismembering Helgelein's body.
The Washington Herald · 24 May 1908 · page 3
RAY LAMPHERE IN NET
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
State's Attorney Smith outlines evidence that Ray Lamphere helped Belle Gunness murder, decapitate, and bury Andrew Helgelein after luring him with his $2,983. Investigators also report new evidence linking missing men Olaf Jensen, Patrick Griffin, and Frank Riediger to the Gunness farm, while a found skull is confirmed to be a woman's.
The Washington Herald · 24 May 1908 · page 3
THE STATE CLAIMS HIS LIFE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Coroner Mack filed official verdicts of felonious homicide for four more victims found at the Gunness farm, including Jennie Olson and Ole Budsberg plus two unidentified bodies. Lamphere's attorneys also indicated they have defense strategies beyond an alibi as prosecutors weigh trying the Helgelein case first.
Paper unidentified · 24 May 1908 · page 1
FOUR MORE FOR
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Evening Tribune · Providence, R.I.
This miscellaneous editorial column briefly mentions that the Gunness case is getting more notoriety than expected following the burning of her house. The rest of the passage is unrelated commentary on other topics like library book borrowers and political figures.
The Evening Tribune · 24 May 1908 · page 12
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.
A painter named Jas Brimmingstall was arrested in Dowagiac, Michigan, accused of killing numerous men plus two wives and four children, with his own wife instigating the arrest out of fear for her life. The report explicitly frames his alleged crimes as rivaling the murder count attributed to Mrs. Gunness.
Laredo Weekly Times · 24 May 1908 · page 1
ANOTHER GUNNESS SHOWS UP IN MASCULINE FORM AT DOWAGIAC IN MICHIGAN
Hy Vwiled Pr.*« Do agiac Mich., May 23. - Jas Brimmingstall, a painter was ar rested and accused of a string of murders almost equaling the record of .Yrs. Gunness. His wife instigat ed bis arrest, claiming she feared he would murder her. The police allege that Baimmingstall killed six men in the West. While his wife and other relatives charge him with ten additional murders, it is claimed he killed men named O brien and Johnson, in Arizona, two unidentified men in Missouri. Smith Hotrum, and David Huff and an unidentified man at Daw agiac. Brimmingstall married twice, both wives with four cbil drend died mysteriously.
The report states that Brynhild Poulsdater has been identified as the maiden name of Mrs. Gunness. This detail emerges as authorities piece together her true identity during the investigation.
Laredo Weekly Times · 24 May 1908 · page 5
BRYNHILD POULSDATER Given As The Maiden Name Of Mrs. Gunness.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A former chore boy claims Belle Gunness poisoned four Christmas party guests in 1906, burying them together; a watch tied to victim John Moo was found on suspect Ray Lamphere. Gold teeth identified as Gunness's were found in the fire ruins, which the prosecutor says proves she died in the blaze.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Laredo Weekly Times · 24 May 1908 · page 5
THAT HOUSE OF HORRORS More Blood Curdling Murder Of Guests Coming To Light. By United Pte»» La Porte, Ind., May 19.—That Mr». B lie Gunness held a party on Christmas night 1906 and the next morning murdered all four of her gusests, is the startling story told by Emil Greening, formerly a chore boy for the murderess, who was located in Oklahoma City. Two of the guests were men and twu wo. men. All are buried in the same grave says Greening. A watch found on Ray Lamphere is positive ly identified today as belonging to John Moo, one of Mrs.
See moreSee less
GunneM* victims. Sheriff Smutzer, received word of Iwo more men missing believed to be Mrs Gunnes»’ victims. Both are Wisconsin men. ’¡he Grand jury is still investigating. The gold teeth which Mrs. Gun ness is known as having in her mouth were found in the ruins of her home today. The dentist iden tified them. The prosecutor says this fact established she is dead. Lamphere will be indicted this week. Mr. John Riba of Vining, la., says, “I have been selling DeWitt s Kidney and Bladder Pills for about a year and they give better satis faction than any pill I ever sold. There are a dozen people her»- who have used them anti they give |»er feet satisfaction in every case. I have used them myself with tine result».’ Sold by Reed's Drug i Store. • d 4
Sheriff Smutzer has resumed digging in the basement of the Gunness home searching for victims' remains, though nothing new has been found. County Prosecutor Smith is preparing to ask the Grand Jury to indict Lamphere on four counts of murder, one of arson, and one of accessory to murder in the Helgelein case.
Laredo Weekly Times · 24 May 1908 · page 13
STILL DIGGING BODIES.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.
A coroner's jury in La Porte, Indiana rendered a verdict that the body found in the ashes of the Gunness house was that of Mrs. Belle Gunness, who died by felonious homicide at the hands of an unknown perpetrator. The report also notes a razor sent to the sheriff, allegedly given away by Gunness herself, inscribed with a Chicago maker's name.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Laredo Weekly Times · 24 May 1908 · page 12
THE HOUSE OF HORRORS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.
Authorities in La Porte, Indiana issue subpoenas to 43 more witnesses as the inquest into Belle Gunness's farm continues. A tabulation lists sums she allegedly obtained from various victims, including insurance payouts and cash from suitors, while a relative partially identifies a skeletal body as John Moo.
Laredo Weekly Times · 24 May 1908 · page 9
45 WITNESSES SUMMONED MEN, WOMEN AND CHILDREN TO TELL WHAT THEY KNOW ABOUT GUNNESS FARM
By UwitMl hw. Laporte Ind., May 18.— J. G. Renden, of Manfred N. D. step brutherof John Moo,of Elbow Lake, Minn., one of the victims of Mrs. Gunness, arrived here today and partially identified another of the bodies. If the body recovered by Renden is that of Moo identifica tion is uncertain at best, because the corpse is little more than a skeleton. More sub|K>enas have been sent out for 43 men, women and children to tell their stories to the jurors. The following is a tabulation of I the money obtained by Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gun ness from various victims: Mars Sorenson, first husband life in surance Peter Gunness, second husband, life insurance IL 00b. Charles Erdman, New Carlisle, Ind., 15,000. Herman Knitter, Chicago |G,OOOOle Budtburg lola, VVis., 12,000 John C. Moo Elbow I «alce, Minn., 11,500. Andrew
A Chicago News feature imagines a hypothetical encounter between Belle Gunness and convicted serial killer Johann Hoch, each marrying for money and seeking to murder the other for profit. Chief Deputy Sheriff Charles Peters muses on the criminological parallels between the two murderers' methods of preying on spouses via matrimonial schemes.
Paper unidentified · 24 May 1908 · page 16
A DRAMA OF VILLAINY.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Coroner Mack officially ruled four more Gunness farm victims died by felonious homicide, including Jennie Olson and Ole Budsburg, with six bodies still unreported on. Meanwhile, both prosecution and defense began active preparations for Ray Lamphere's murder trial, with prosecutors signaling he would likely be tried first for killing Andrew Helgelein.
The Salt Lake Herald · 24 May 1908 · page 2
MURDER TRIALS WILL BE RUSHED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Prosecutors and defense began preparations for Ray Lamphere's trial, with the state announcing he will likely be tried first for the murder of Andrew Helgelein due to strong evidence. The defense indicated it will not rely solely on an alibi, while friends of a missing man named Olaf Jensen suspect he was also a victim of Mrs. Gunness.
The Salt Lake Herald · 24 May 1908 · page 2
MURDER TRIALS WILL BE RUSHED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
A brief index entry in the Tribune's table of contents reports that Ray Lamphere, alleged accomplice of Mrs. Gunness, has been indicted on five counts of murder. The full story is referenced on page 2 but not reproduced in this excerpt.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 24 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
Prosecutors and defense attorneys begin active preparations for Ray Lamphere's trial, with the state announcing it will likely try him first for the murder of Andrew Helgelein due to strong evidence. The defense indicates it will not rely solely on an alibi, while a separate note suggests Olaf Jensen of Illinois may be another victim of Mrs. Gunness.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 24 May 1908 · page 2
WILL FACE CHARGE OF MURDERING FIVE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Press · Newport News, Va.
Coroner Mack filed official reports declaring four more victims found in the Gunness farm yard died by felonious homicide, including identified victims Jennie Olsen and Ole Budsberg plus two unidentified bodies. The report states the person responsible is unknown to the coroner, and six more bodies remain to be examined.
Daily Press · 24 May 1908 · page 1
FOUR MORE VICTIMS OF GUNNESS FARM OF DEATH
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A La Porte, Indiana grand jury returned seven indictments against Ray Lamphere, charging him with the murders of Belle Gunness, Philip Gunness, Lucy Sorenson, and Myrtle Sorenson by destroying the Gunness house, plus arson, the murder of Andrew Helgelein, and acting as accessory to Mrs. Gunness in Helgelein's murder. The indictments mark the formal legal charges brought against Lamphere in connection with the case.
Digging for more bodies was set to resume on Belle Gunness's farm, with a lull expected in developments until Lamphere's trial in June unless investigators learn more about her alleged accomplices. About 4000 people visited the farm that day.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 25 May 1908 · page 8
Dig for More Bodies
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Semi-Weekly Herald · Durango, Colo.
Workmen demolishing an old tenement in Chicago found scattered human bones buried for 25-30 years, with no skull located. Though neighbors speculated the remains belonged to a Belle Gunness victim since she once lived nearby, physicians deemed this theory highly improbable given the bones' age.
Semi-Weekly Herald · 25 May 1908 · page 1
QUARTER CENTURY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Digging for more bodies at Belle Gunness's La Porte farm will resume, with a lull expected until Lamphere's trial, likely in June, unless information surfaces about possible accomplices. About 4,000 people visited the farm that day.
Authorities resumed digging for additional bodies on Belle Gunness's farm in La Porte, Indiana. A lull in developments is expected until Lamphere's trial, believed to be in June, unless officers learn more about her suspected accomplices; about 4,000 people visited the farm.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 25 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Thousands of curious sightseers continued visiting the Gunness farm via excursion trains and by wagon from the countryside. Tips came in claiming Gunness was alive and that other accomplices could be named, while the coroner's forthcoming verdict was expected to rule the deaths of Jennie Olson, Ole Budsberg, and two unidentified victims as homicide by unknown perpetrators.
The Washington Herald · 25 May 1908 · page 2
MORBID CROWD AT LAPORTE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
LaPorte's mayor and his law partner, representing accused murderer Ray Lamphere, received word from an unnamed man in Arkansas claiming Belle Gunness survived and escaped in men's clothing. The man says he received a letter from her around May 3 and will produce it if officials interview him personally.
Evening Times-Republican · 25 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE?
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
A table-of-contents listing on Page One references a telegraphic news item titled 'Mrs. Gunness Said to Be Alive.' No further details or context are given in this excerpt.
Evening Times-Republican · 25 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
A roundup of humorous local newspaper snippets from across Iowa touches on politics, fashion, and local news items. One joke from the Cherokee Democrat references a missing man named Shaw, speculating he may have wandered onto the Gunness farm.
Attorneys for Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her children, say they received a letter from an Arkansas man claiming Gunness escaped in men's clothing and wrote to him five days after the fire. The defense also now theorizes the body found in the fire was actually that of missing Mrs. May O'Riley, substituted for Gunness's own.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 25 May 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
BELLE GUNNESS STILL ALIVE
ALLEGED TO HAVE ESCAPED IN MAN'S CLOTHING—A LETTER RECEIVED FROM HER FIVE DAYS AFTER THE FIRE.
See moreSee less
LA PORTE, Ind., May 25.—Attorneys for the defense of Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Belle Gunness and her three children, are in receipt of a letter from a man in Arkansas whose identity they refuse to divulge, but who formerly lived in Marshall county, this state, who states that Mrs. Gunness escape in man's clothing and that on May 6, five days after she is alleged to have been burned to death, he received a letter from her. He says he will produce this letter and give other evidence.
That the body of Mrs. May O'Riley, who disappeared from Rochester, N. J., last fall, was substituted by Mrs. Gunness for her own in the fire is the latest theory of the attorneys for Yamphere, who claim to have evidence to substantiate such a conclusion.
This report summarizes Belle Gunness's background, including the suspicious deaths of her two husbands, and details the theory that she decapitated a female victim and placed the body in her burning house to fake her own death. It notes her extensive dental gold work as a key detail in the mystery of the missing head.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 25 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. BELLE GUNNESS, OF LAPORTE'S MURDER FARM
early yesterday. The destruction of, crops and vegetables, trees and ! shrubbery was the greatest reached: liyears. In numerous places houses *ere unrdofed and small v'lllages} and hamlets in manv Instances were Inundated by the terrific rain fall, ^blch In the space of four hours reached seven Inches In many sec tions. Austin was in the path of the Vf °rst of the storm gnd for hours tbç «treets were Impassible for either man or beast,' elhctTlc light and tele phone lines were damaged beyond immediate WMCr and many houses %ere unroofed.
See moreSee less
- '* * " »GOT-. *> now insane and that the commit he is still insane. MRS. BELLE GUNNESS, OF LAPORTE'S MURDER FARM. Mrs. Belle Gunness, the widow suspected of the murder of the persons whose bodies were dug up from the premises of her burned home s mile from Laporte, Ind., was s Norwegian woman whose maiden name was Paulson. 8he was married first to Max Sorensen, who died under suspicious circum stances. Her second husband, Philip Gunness, died under similar circum stances. It was reported at first that the body of Mrs. Gunness was found with those of her three children In the ruins of her houses. The head of the charred remains of the woman found in the ruins was missing, which fact caused the authorities to suspect that Mrs. Gunness herself had killed Hsr children and set fire to the dwelling nfter placing in the house the decapi tated body of one of her adult women victims in au effort to cause the belief that she had perished in the fire. Mrs. Gunness had had an enormous quan tity of gold work done on her teeth. The grewsome mystery of the missing head, it was Bald by those who held the theory of the flight of Mrs. Gunness, was explained by the woman's fear that If she left her substitute's head SB the body It would be evident that she herself was not a victim of the firs. SOUGHT BY CREDITORS PROMISES TO PAY WELL NO LONGER SATISFY MEN EMPLOYED ON SEVERAL SCHEMES OF PROMOTION IN THE LEWISTON CLARKST0N VALLEY— ALLE GE LEWISTON FEATURE OF THE WORK WAS ONLY A MAKESHIFT. - Mr. MacKean was Saturday evening Where is Frank MacKean, the
Only about 3,000 sightseers visited the Gunness farm, buying refreshments and souvenirs while digging was paused for the day. Sheriff Smutzer received a letter from a woman offering information for payment, including the whereabouts of accomplices, and a man from Elkhart came to check if a skeleton was his missing cousin.
The Lake County Times · 25 May 1908 · page 4
DROP GRIM FESTIVITIES; ONLY 3,000 VISIT LAPORTE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
Coroner Mack filed official verdicts declaring felonious homicide for four victims found on the Gunness farm, including Jennie Olson and Ole Budsberg, plus two unidentified bodies. The coroner states the responsible persons are unknown, with six more deaths still to be reported on.
Rock Island Argus · 25 May 1908 · page 1
UNKNOWN PERSONS GUILTY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
A theater advertisement announces that moving pictures depicting 'important scenes' from the Gunness Farm Tragedy are showing at the Elite theater this week. This reflects the rapid commercial exploitation of the sensational case in popular entertainment.
Rock Island Argus · 25 May 1908 · page 2
GUNNESS FARM TRAGEDY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
A brief advertisement announces that the Gunness farm tragedy is being shown as a moving picture feature at the Elite theater this week. It appears amid unrelated baseball box scores and other classified notices.
Rock Island Argus · 25 May 1908 · page 3
THE GUNNESS FARM TRAGEDY In Moving Pictures at the ELITE This week.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
A newspaper advertisement promotes a moving picture titled 'The Gunness Farm Tragedy' showing at the Elite theater. The ad indicates the case was already being adapted into sensationalized entertainment just weeks after the farm discoveries.
Rock Island Argus · 25 May 1908 · page 4
SEE THE GREAT MOVING PICTURE THE GUNNESS FARM TRAGEDY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
La Porte prosecutors announce Ray Lamphere will first stand trial for the murder of Andrew Helgelein, a South Dakota ranchman, citing strong evidence. The defense indicates it will not rely solely on an alibi, though its full strategy remains undisclosed; separately, friends of a missing Illinois man named Olaf Jensen suspect he was another Gunness victim.
The Topeka State Journal · 25 May 1908 · page 3
HELGELEIN MURDER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Attorneys for Ray Lamphere, including Darrow, advance a theory that the body found in the Gunness farmhouse fire was actually that of Mary O'Reilley, a woman who had disappeared from Rochester, New York. They claim to have evidence supporting the theory that Belle Gunness substituted O'Reilley's corpse for her own to fake her death.
The Topeka State Journal · 25 May 1908 · page 7
SUBSTITUTE BODY.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Excavation on Belle Gunness's La Porte farm is set to resume, with about 4,000 visitors touring the site that day. Officials expect a lull in developments until Lamphere's trial, likely in June, unless they gather new information on possible accomplices.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 25 May 1908 · page 2
Digging on Gunness Place At La Porte to Be Resumed Today. La Porte. Ind., May 24—Digging for more bodies will be resumed tomorrow oil the farm of Mrs. Belle Gunness. Un til the trial of Lamphere, who it is be lieved will be heard in June there will
A grand jury indicted Ray Lamphere, Belle Gunness's former farm hand, on charges of murdering Gunness and her three children and arson in burning her house, plus charges related to Andrew Helgelein's death. Sheriff Smutzer found another skull in a vault on the farm, and investigators were also probing a possible Ohio victim via a watch with matching initials.
The Detroit Times · 25 May 1908 · page 6
COMES TO LIGHT. LA PORTE. Ind., May 2 8 —Three* Indictment*. charging murder an<l arson against Hay iginiphere, Mrs. Gunnels' former farm hand, were brought in by the grand jury, yeiter day afternoon. Lamphere is charged ■with the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three childreu Myrtle, Lucy and Philip; with arson in burning down
Sheriff Smutzer discovers a skull in a vault on the Gunness farm, believed to belong to the body found in the graveyard, and orders further investigation into possible additional victims. Separate leads emerge connecting a Dayton, Ohio man and a missing Jackson, Michigan man to the case, while a New York man claims to have seen Mrs. Gunness alive after the fire.
The Detroit Times · 25 May 1908 · page 6
COMES TO LIGHT
Ohioan May Be Victim. A Dayton, 0., man may prove to be one of the victims of the Gunness charnal house. Investigation Is now being made to uncover another mys tery. Coroner Mack received the fol lowing telegram from C. W. M< l-Jine, Os the Ohio city: “Have you any Gunness effects marked 'L T. P.?' ” Coroner Mack found, on looking Over the watches, a time piece which rlteans the Initials named in the tele ((ram. This watch, which is of silver. &was found in the debris of the house
Sheriff Smutzer resumed digging at the Gunness farm after a ten-day delay, searching the garden, basement floor, and area near evergreen trees for more bodies. Jewelry belonging to a missing Rochester, NY woman named May O'Reilly was discovered, and a human skull was later found in a cesspool on the property.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 25 May 1908 · page 2
MORE JEWELRY FOUND.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Hattiesburg News · Hattiesburg, Miss.
A newspaper photo caption shows Belle Gunness with her three children, noting that detectives are puzzled by what happened to the children in the murder case. It suggests the discovery of the children's bodies in the ruins supports the theory that Gunness herself died in the fire rather than escaping.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Hattiesburg News · 25 May 1908 · page 3
pH , •4* f m ■ • * t •*" L i • MRS. GUNNESS AND HER THREE GHILDREN. r 55? * .,V. " ' : bad for old folks to read. \ 1 : ■ ... \ 1 'Mf. m : ft \ « • ■ VRl M ■ / V
Digging for additional bodies resumed on the farm of Mrs. Belle Gunness in Laporte, Indiana. Developments are expected to lull until Lamphere's trial, believed to be in June, unless officers learn more about suspected accomplices; about 4,000 people had visited the farm.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 25 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Roswell Daily Record · Roswell, N.M.
A man from Arkansas wrote to Mayor Darrow's law partner claiming Belle Gunness escaped the farm fire disguised as a man and that he received a letter from her five days after her reported death. He offered to share his information with officers investigating the case.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Roswell Daily Record · 25 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS AGAIN DISCOVERED La Porte, Ind., May 25. Mayor Dar row and his law partner, H. K. Worden who represents Ray Lamphere, who is charged with complicity in the Gunness murders, received a letter today from a man in Arkansas, form erly of Marshall county In this state, who declares that Mrs. Gunness es caped in man's clothing, and that on May sixth, five days after her 'death according to the coroner's finding, he received a letter from her. He of fers to give the information he pos sesses to the officers. o DR. PRESLUjt: ye. oar, nosa ind throat. Glasses fitted; 'phone 130.
A man from Arkansas, formerly of Marshall County, Indiana, wrote to Mayor Darrow's law partner claiming Belle Gunness escaped in men's clothing and survived. He says he received a letter from her on May 8, five days after her supposed death according to the coroner's findings, and offers to share all his information with authorities.
Albuquerque Citizen · 25 May 1908 · page 1
ARKANSAS MAN SAYS GUNNESS LIVES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Capital Journal · Salem, Oregon
In La Porte, Indiana, prosecutors preparing the case against Ray Lamphere for the murder of Belle Gunness and her alleged victims plan to argue that the charred body found in the ashes was not hers. Mayor Darrow claims the body is actually that of another young woman who disappeared a year earlier.
Daily Capital Journal · 25 May 1908 · page 1
FLAN Of MAYOR PROSECUTOR HOPES TO SHOW THAT MRS. GUNNESS IS STILT ALIVE. (United Prrti Leaned Wire.) Ln Porto, Ind May 25.. -In makworo burled, Mayor Darrow of, L
Mrs. Gunness and her three children's bodies were reportedly found in the ruins of her burned house, but detectives are reluctant to believe she actually killed the children to fake her own death. They suspect she may have used the bodies to stage her escape while she herself fled.
Daily Capital Journal · 25 May 1908 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Laporte county grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere and also indicted Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein, though no warrant was issued since she had been declared officially dead. Lamphere was separately charged with murdering Gunness and her three children, with arraignment delayed until June.
The Madison Daily Leader · 25 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS INDICTED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
A man from Arkansas sent a letter to Mayor Darrow and attorney H. K. Worden claiming Belle Gunness escaped in men's clothing and that he received a letter from her five days after her reported death. He offered to share further information with officers investigating the Gunness murders.
The Laramie Republican · 25 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
A report citing Martin Gurholt claims Belle Gunness had a male accomplice posing as her brother who lured victims to the farm. It also states Mayor Harrow obtained proof from an Arkansas man that a body found in the ruins was that of Miss May O'Reilly.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 26 May 1908 · page 1
Arkansas Man In Gunness Case
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A humorous political miscellany column jests that, unlike some other scandals, Tom Platt apparently had no dealings with Belle Gunness. The item reflects how the Gunness case had become fodder for satirical gossip amid ongoing public fascination.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 26 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
La Porte attorneys for Ray Lamphere report receiving a letter from an Arkansas man claiming Belle Gunness escaped the fire in men's clothing and later wrote to him. The man says he can produce her letter and further evidence if interviewed by officers.
MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE IMPORTANT NEW EVIDENCE COMES TO LIGHT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
The piece reports that the Albuquerque Journal doubts the body found in the fire was Belle Gunness. It notes the paper accepts the identification of her false teeth but suggests she deliberately left them behind to fake her death.
Arizona Republican · 26 May 1908 · page 2
The Albuquerque Journal does not believe that was Mrs. Gunness' body found in the debris of her burned home. It admits the identity of the false teeth but accounts for their pres ence on the theory that the murderess had burned her bridges behind her. After all, what dlference does it make whether Madame Anna Gould has already married the Prince de Sa gan or is yet to marry him or if she never marries him. Both of these peo ple have been given more attention than they have really earned.
See moreSee less
If Mrs. Evelyn Thaw harbors a de lusion -that she can find anything of the property of the late William Thaw of Pittsburg lying around loose and unprotected, she ought to be sent to join her husband in the asylum. Prohibition ' Oklahoma must have enough water now to suit it.
Attorneys for accused murderer Ray Lamphere report receiving a letter from an Arkansas man, a former Indiana resident, claiming that Mrs. Gunness escaped the fire disguised in men's clothing. The man says he received a letter from her five days after the coroner's verdict, describing her escape, and offers to share his information with officials.
A letter to Indiana's governor claimed a mysterious woman in black swindling people in eastern Connecticut might be Mrs. Gunness. The Associated Press investigated locally and found little credibility to the tip.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 26 May 1908 · page 1
MRS GUNNESS AGAIN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Attorneys for Ray Lamphere claim Belle Gunness substituted the body of missing Mrs. May Reilly for her own in the farmhouse fire. A letter from an Arkansas man asserts Gunness escaped in man's clothing and corresponded with him after the fire.
New-York Tribune · 26 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A theory emerged in Laporte suggesting the body found burned on the Gunness farm was actually that of May Reilley of Rochester. According to this theory, Belle Gunness escaped by disguising herself in men's clothing.
THE NEWS THIS MORNING. CONGRESS. —Senaie: The conference report on the sundry civil appropriation bill was adopted. leaving only two of the great supply measures 10 be disposed of. ——— House: Sev eral conference reports were adopted and a number of bills were passed by unanimous con sent: the proposed change in the hall of the House was defeated. FOREIGN .—King Edward welcomed President Fallidres on his arrival in London: cordial sen timents were exchanged at a state dinner. = The French Chamber of Deputies adopted the section of the income tax bill which places a éuty on dividends from French and foreign government bonds.
A theory circulating in Laporte suggested the body burned in the Gunness farm fire was actually that of May Reilley of Rochester, not Belle Gunness herself. According to this theory, Mrs. Gunness had escaped the fire disguised in men's clothing.
New-York Tribune · 26 May 1908 · page 6
more. The known dead in Texas and Okla ——— homa floods were reported to be seventeen: six persons were drowned when a railroad bridge gave way at Dallas. —=—— The theory was ad vanced in Laporte that the body burned in the fire at the Gunness farm was that of Mav Reilley, of Rochesier, and that Mrs. Gunness es
The report headline poses the question of whether Mrs. Gunness is still alive, suggesting doubt about her death in the farmhouse fire. The surrounding text is truncated before detailing the basis for this speculation.
New-York Tribune · 26 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE?
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Martin Gurholt testifies that a man posing as Belle Gunness's brother lured his sibling Henry Gurholt to the Laporte farm, where he is believed to have been murdered. The report states another man is now missing and suggests circumstantial evidence pointing to his death, while also raising the possibility that Mrs. Gunness herself is still alive.
The Washington Herald · 26 May 1908 · page 3
AID TO MRS GUNNESS / Witness Says Accomplice Posed as Her Brother / ANOTHER MAN IS MISSING / Gurholt Says Man Who Claimed Kin to Indiana Murderess Lured His Brother from Farm in North Dakota / Circumstances Point to His Murder on July 4 / Woman Is Alive
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Martin Gurholt's brother recounts how a man posing as Mrs. Gunness's relative lured Martin to La Porte via a matrimonial advertisement, after which Martin vanished following a buggy ride with Mrs. Gunness on July 4. He now believes his brother was murdered, and notes Mayor Barrow's claim that evidence would prove Mrs. Gunness is still alive.
The Washington Herald · 26 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
The report presents conflicting accounts: her parents believe Belle Gunness was murdered, while Mayor Barrow claims he has a letter proving she is alive and used an Arkansas suitor as evidence. The article also reveals a new angle—an accomplice posing as her brother—and disputes the dental identification of the body found in the ruins.
The Washington Herald · 26 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Martin Gurholt testified that a man posing as Belle Gunness's brother lured his brother Henry to her farm, where he was later murdered around July 4. The report states Gunness had an accomplice who traveled the country duping men into visiting her farm.
The Washington Herald · 26 May 1908 · page 3
AID TO MRS. GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A brother of victim Henry Gurholt testifies that an accomplice posing as Mrs. Gunness's brother lured victims to Laporte, confirming his brother's murder on July 4. Mayor Darrow announces evidence—including a recent letter—that Belle Gunness is alive and that the headless body found was a substitute victim, dismissing the dental identification.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Herald · 26 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A letter sent to Indiana's governor described a woman in black swindling people in eastern Connecticut whose appearance closely resembled Mrs. Gunness. The tip was forwarded to the Laporte county sheriff as a possible lead on Gunness's whereabouts if she is still alive.
Evening Star · 26 May 1908 · page 1
LOOKS LIKE MRS. GUNNESS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A newspaper filler item mocks the recurring theory that Belle Gunness is alive, comparing it to the frequent false rumors of a cabinet resignation. It treats the survival theory as an unreliable, recurring claim rather than confirmed fact.
Evening Star · 26 May 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Hawaiian Star · Honolulu Oahu
An autopsy on seven unidentified bodies exhumed from Mrs. Gunness' property revealed one was female, reviving interest in a witness's account of a mysterious couple who visited the night Jennie Olson vanished. Investigators now theorize Gunness may have murdered the couple along with Jennie Olson and Ole Budsberg on the same night.
The Hawaiian Star · 26 May 1908 · page 7
FRESH LIGHT ON THE CRIMES OF MRS. GUNNESS
THE DOCTORS SUED FltESII LIGHT ON THE CHIMES OF MBS. GUNNESS. LA POUTK (Ina.). May 18. The autopsy held today on tho remains of tho Bovcn unidentified bodies exhum
A newspaper opinion column briefly notes the claim that Mrs. Gunness' body was identified by her teeth, calling this 'risky proof' given how much about her was false. The rest of the column covers unrelated miscellaneous topics of the day.
Evening Times-Republican · 26 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · Decorah, Iowa
A telegram from Trondhjem dated May 20 describes Belle Gunness, now infamous as a mass murderess in LaPorte, Indiana, as remembered locally by various nicknames from her youth. It recounts that she was a wild, unruly, cunning, and deceitful girl who worked on a farm for Ole Rodde, was liked for her competence, and emigrated to America in 1888, later writing home that she had found work as a governess.
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · 26 May 1908 · page 1
Mrs. Gunness.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Boise Citizen · Boise, Idaho
A freight-rate economics editorial makes a sarcastic aside, joking that if Harry Orchard had answered one of Mrs. Gunness' matrimonial advertisements there would have been a 'hot time in LaPorte' before the fire that destroyed her home. The reference treats the Gunness case as already notorious shorthand, unrelated to the article's actual subject of freight rates and ship subsidies.
The Boise Citizen · 26 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Berne Witness · Berne, Ind.
James Brimmingstall is arrested for murdering David Huff, with police crediting him with up to sixteen killings, a toll nearly rivaling Belle Gunness's. Accounts conflict as to whether he is a genuine serial killer or merely a fabricator, with some deaths previously ruled accidental.
The Berne Witness · 26 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
This local news roundup from Gary, Indiana covers various community items including a man's recovery from a shooting injury and local social happenings. It briefly notes that Paul Siegert visited the Gunness tragedy site again, collecting photographs, and states he believed Mrs. Gunness, whom he knew personally, was dead.
The Lake County Times · 26 May 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Mrs. Emma Kolb of Coventry, Connecticut wrote to Sheriff Smutzer claiming she has a clue to Belle Gunness's whereabouts. She believes a woman who visited her home on May 4 may be the fugitive murderess.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 26 May 1908 · page 1
CLAIMS THAT MRS. GUNNESS IS LIVING
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Attorneys for Ray Lamphere advance a new theory that Belle Gunness substituted the body of missing Rochester woman May Griley for her own in the farmhouse fire. They claim to have evidence, including a witness who will testify to receiving a letter from Gunness dated May 4, after the fire.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 26 May 1908 · page 3
NEW CORPSE THEORY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
A letter sent to Governor Hanley by Emma Kolb of South Coventry, Connecticut, reports sightings of a mysterious swindling woman in black resembling Mrs. Gunness. The Laporte county sheriff is investigating this possible lead on Gunness's whereabouts if she is still alive.
The Topeka State Journal · 26 May 1908 · page 1
POSSIBLE CLEW.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Attorneys Darrow and Worden claim evidence suggests Belle Gunness used the body of missing Rochester woman Mae O'Reilly as her own in the farmhouse fire. Rochester police confirm O'Reilly cannot be found at her last known address after being contacted by the La Porte County sheriff.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 26 May 1908 · page 2
ANOTHER THEORY.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
The Laporte county grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere and also indicted the officially-dead Mrs. Bella Gunness as principal in the murder of Andrew Helgelein, necessary to charge Lamphere as an accessory. Separate indictments charged Lamphere with first-degree murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children, with trial proceedings expected in June.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 26 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Fergus County Democrat · Lewistown, Mont.
A dentist who made dentures for Mrs. Gunness has positively identified the teeth found in the burned ruins of her Laporte home, making it nearly certain the alleged murderess died in the fire. Meanwhile searchers continue to unearth more skeletons and bodies believed to be victims of her killing spree.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Fergus County Democrat · 26 May 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The La Porte County grand jury indicted Ray Lamphere for arson and complicity in the murder of Andrew Helgelien, while also charging the already-declared-dead Belle Gunness as the principal in that murder and in the deaths of her three children. The case against Lamphere is set to go to trial in June.
Paper unidentified · 26 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
Reports claim Belle Gunness used matrimonial ads and a traveling agent posing as her brother to lure victims to her farm. New evidence allegedly includes a letter from an Arkansas man claiming Gunness wrote to him days after her supposed death, suggesting she escaped disguised as a man.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Thousands of curious visitors continued flocking to the Gunness farm by excursion train and wagon. Authorities received conflicting tips claiming Mrs. Gunness was alive or that others were involved, while the coroner prepared verdicts of felonious homicide for four victims with perpetrators unknown.
The Stark County Democrat · 26 May 1908 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
GUNNESS FARM STILL A MECCA FOR THE CURIOUS
Laporte, Ind., May 24.—Thousands of morbidly curious people again wended their way today to the Gunness farm, excursion trains discharging big parties, while people drove from the countryside for miles around.
See moreSee less
Ola L. Brevrik, of Minneapolis, today advised the authorities that he has information proving Mrs. Gunness was alive and suggesting that communication be opened with him.
Mrs. Charles, writing from West Side Chicago, wrote that she possesses information which would warrant the arrest of other persons implicated in the operating of the murder farm.
Coroner Mack's verdicts which will be filed tomorrow morning will state that Jennie Olson, Ole Burdsburg and the unknown male and female, found in the same grave, came to their death from felonious homicide, the perpetrators of which Coroner Mack declares are unknown.
The report claims Belle Gunness had a male accomplice who posed as her brother and traveled the country luring victims to her farm under false pretenses of courtship. It cites Martin Gurholt, brother of victim Henry Gurholt, who says this accomplice tricked his brother into visiting Laporte.
The Stark County Democrat · 26 May 1908 · page 8
HE LURED ON VICTIMS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
Martin Gurholt describes how his brother Henry was lured to Laporte by a man posing as Mrs. Gunness's relative and was later murdered around July 4th, with the family only now realizing his fate. Mayor Darrow claims they have evidence, including a letter and witness testimony, proving Belle Gunness is still alive and that a substitute body was placed in the cellar fire.
The Stark County Democrat · 26 May 1908 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
The report discusses Henry Gurholt's suspected murder by Belle Gunness and the devastation of his parents. Mayor Darrow claims evidence will show Mrs. Gunness is alive, including a letter and testimony suggesting a substitute body was placed in the cellar while she fled, aided by an accomplice posing as her brother.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Stark County Democrat · 26 May 1908 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Martin Gurholt of Iola, Wisconsin travels to Laporte to investigate the disappearance of his brother Henry, who had been lured to work on Gunness's farm by a stranger claiming to be her relative. He examines skeletons at the morgue and a watch found in the ruins, while another man, Abraham Phillips, searches for his missing brother believed to be another victim.
The Morning Tribune · 26 May 1908 · page 8
MRS. GUNNESS IS BELIEVED TO HAVE HAD ACCOMPLICES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Waxahachie Daily Light · Waxahachie, Tex.
A humorous miscellany column riffs on astrology, weather, and local gossip, briefly noting that 'the Gunness investigation goes on' and mocking a Texas journalist's attempt to turn '23' into '35.' The reference is incidental to the column's comedic tone rather than a substantive report on the case.
The Waxahachie Daily Light · 26 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A woman in South Coventry, Connecticut wrote to the governor claiming she recognized a swindling woman in black as the fugitive Belle Gunness. The letter was forwarded to the Laporte county sheriff as a possible lead in the search for Gunness.
Paper unidentified · 26 May 1908 · page 1
GUNNESS CLUE IS FOUND?
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Fairmont West Virginian · Fairmont, W. Va.
A man in Arkansas claims he received a letter from Belle Gunness five days after her house burned, suggesting she escaped disguised as a man rather than dying in the fire. Separately, Martin Gurholt reports his brother Henry vanished after being lured to Gunness's farm by a stranger claiming to be her brother.
The Fairmont West Virginian · 26 May 1908 · page 1
LETTER FROM MRS. GUINNESS MAN DECLARES HE RECEIVED ONE FIVE DAYS AFTER HER HOME BURNED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Fairmont West Virginian · Fairmont, W. Va.
Martin Gurholt examines skeletons at the morgue trying to identify his missing brother Henry, who had written home from the Gunness farm before his letters stopped; a watch found in the ruins closely matches his brother's description. Attorneys for Lamphere advance a new theory that Mrs. Gunness substituted the body of missing woman May O'Rilley for her own in the fire.
The Fairmont West Virginian · 26 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
A brief item among local Wyoming notes mentions that a man from Casper had once visited the Gunness home in Indiana. The remark is presented as a passing curiosity rather than a detailed investigative finding.
The Laramie Republican · 26 May 1908 · page 2
WYOMING NOTES.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Prescott Daily News · Prescott, Ark.
Investigators at La Porte believe the discovery of Mrs. Gunness's false teeth in the fire debris proves she died in the blaze. The report sarcastically questions whether she might have left the teeth behind deliberately while fleeing in haste.
A newspaper miscellany column speculates that if reports of Mrs. Gunness still being alive prove true, it could spark new sensations and developments. The item notes the many strange and mysterious aspects of her case, contingent on her possible capture.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 27 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
A letter sent to Indiana's governor from a woman in South Coventry, Connecticut described a mysterious woman swindling people there whom she believed to be Mrs. Gunness. The letter was forwarded to the La Porte County Sheriff as a possible clue to Gunness's whereabouts, if she is still alive.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 27 May 1908 · page 13
A POSSIBLE CLUE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A Connecticut woman wrote to the Indiana governor claiming a mysterious swindling woman in black resembled Belle Gunness from newspaper photos. The letter was forwarded to the LaPorte sheriff, though locals noted the woman gave the name Mrs. Rowe and claimed to be from California.
Paper unidentified · 27 May 1908 · page 10
Indianapolis, In.'., May 2. Through a letter sent to Governor Hanly by Emma C, Kolh, of Smith Coventry, C'linn,, tlio Hliorllt of Imports county )ui3 ubtnlnoil a poKblfl cluo to the. sup pn.fil whereabouts of Mrs. Gunness, If ilio I.aporte womnn la still alive. The lot tor widen was received at the gov ernor's oflVe, was forwarded at once to tho Laporte county nhorlft. The Coven try womnn wrote at length, describing a mysterious womnn In black who has been swindling tho people over the eastern part of Connecticut nnd which tiho believes Is none, other thnn Mrs. GiiiiiiccK. The writer says she has seen a pleture of Mrs. dimness and that tho resemblance, between the mysteri ous swindler and Mrs. Gunness Is so
A woman going door to door collecting signatures for a pension petition, claiming to be a Civil War widow, was suspected by a Mrs. Kolb to be the missing Mrs. Gunness based on gold teeth and facial resemblance. Authorities in the area dismissed the theory, noting the woman's inconsistent stories and lack of credibility as evidence against the identification.
Paper unidentified · 27 May 1908 · page 10
Iter stories, It after appeared differed nt different places. iMrs. Kolb said the oman had gold front teeth, and this fact combined with her facial appear ance convinced her that the woman was the missing Mrs. Gunness. The authorities here and In "WII1Imantlo take no stork whatever, In the theory that the woman who has heen circulating a pension petition In Nor wich, Tiitnam, Kllllngly and other
A former employee, Harold Chapman, told authorities that Belle Gunness once had him build a fenced area where she claimed a 'favorite horse' was buried. Acting on this clue, Sheriff Smutzer's men began digging in a previously unsuspected part of the property.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 27 May 1908 · page 10
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A man who wrote to Ray Lamphere's defense attorneys claims he saw Mrs. Gunness alive in Ogden, Utah on May 4, and promises to testify to support the defense theory that she faked her death. The sheriff also received other letters from prisoners with undisclosed content relating to the case.
THINKS WOMAN ALIVE “H” Writes Laporte Sheriff About Mrs. Gunness. SAYS HE SAW HER ON MAY 4 Declares Arch Murderess Not Dead and Promises to Testify for Lam phere if Necessary—Othey Letters Received from Men in Prisons, but the Contents Are Kept Secret, Laporte, Ind., May 26.—The man who signed his letter “H,” giving the attor neys for Ray Lamphere the information that the arch murderess was allvg, reach ed Chicago to-day, and in a letter to Mayor Darrow informed him that he would come to Laporte when needed to give evidence bearing out the sensational theory of thé defense that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness is alive. This witness will testify that he saw Mrs. Gunness in Ogden, Utah, May 4. Sheriff Smulzer to-day received a letter from J. B. Chapman, of Donalson, Ind., in which he said that he was engaged by Mrs. Gunness to build a woven wire fence about the farm. She was his constant companion during the time he was em ployed, not permitting him to get out of her sight. At a certain place on the farm she wanted Chapman to make a crook in the fence, which he a! first refused to do.
Sheriff Smulser plans to dig at a suspected burial site, while Coroner Mack's inquest formally ruled three more unidentified bodies, believed male, died by felonious homicide. Mysterious letters from prisoners and mounting evidence suggest Mrs. Gunness had several accomplices in the murders.
The Washington Herald · 27 May 1908 · page 3
The State is slowly but surely weaving a network of evidence which will prove that Mrs. Gunness had several accom | plices in the murders she committed.
A man signing himself 'H' wrote to Laporte officials claiming he saw Belle Gunness alive in Ogden, Utah on May 4, and offered to testify for the defense in Ray Lamphere's trial. Separately, the sheriff received a letter about a horse burial site that may hide bodies, and the coroner filed three more inquest findings of homicide for unidentified male victims.
The Washington Herald · 27 May 1908 · page 3
THINKS WOMAN ALIVE
Laporte, Ind., May 26.—The man who signed his letter “H,” giving the attor neys for Ray Lamphere the information that the arch murderess was allvg, reach ed Chicago to-day, and in a letter to Mayor Darrow informed him that he would come to Laporte when needed to give evidence bearing out the sensational theory of thé defense that Mrs. Gunness is alive. This witness will testify that he saw Mrs. Gunness in Ogden, Utah, May 4. Sheriff Smulzer to-day received a letter from J. B. Chapman, of Donalson, Ind., in which he said that he was engaged by Mrs. Gunness to build a woven wire fence
A man hired by Belle Gunness to build a fence tells the sheriff she insisted on a strange detour in its path, claiming a horse was buried there, which authorities now suspect conceals human remains. The coroner has filed three more inquest findings of homicide for unidentified male victims, and investigators believe Gunness had accomplices.
During jury selection for the trial of Philip, accused of murder, potential jurors were questioned about their views on capital punishment, with one juror's scruples tested by referencing the notorious Gunness murder farm case. The defense and prosecution used peremptory challenges extensively as the panel was examined under Justice Barnard's close questioning.
Evening Star · 27 May 1908 · page 2
USE PEREMPTORY CHALLENGES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
This is a miscellany of newspaper humor quips from various papers, including one quip from the Milwaukee Sentinel joking that Johann Hoch should have courted 'the Widow Gunness' to have saved trouble. It reflects the Gunness case's notoriety as a punchline during the period of public fascination with her crimes.
Evening Star · 27 May 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Justice Barnard questions reluctant talesmen about their scruples over capital punishment during jury selection, dismissing one who could not commit to a death sentence for Mrs. Gunness as an alleged mass murderer. The accused, referred to as Philip, closely follows the proceedings and assists his counsel throughout the day.
The Washington Times · 27 May 1908 · page 9
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
During jury selection in the murder trial of Gaston Philip in Washington, Justice Barnard pressed a reluctant talesman by invoking Belle Gunness as an example of a 'wholesale murderer,' asking if he would hesitate to convict such a person. The rest of the item details courtroom challenges of jurors and Philip's demeanor, with Gunness mentioned only as a rhetorical comparison.
The Washington Times · 27 May 1908 · page 9
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
Hogs rooting in a pond at the edge of the Gunness farm unearthed bones from a human arm. Investigators plan to rake the entire pond to search for additional remains.
Evening Times-Republican · 27 May 1908 · page 1
MORE BONES FOUND.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
A one-line filler item among miscellaneous news notes states that Mrs. Gunness is officially dead, but adds that her deeds will live on long after her. It appears in a column of humorous and trivial news briefs rather than as a dedicated story.
Evening Times-Republican · 27 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Manchester Democrat · Manchester, Iowa
A La Porte, Indiana grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, charging him with arson, five murders, and being an accessory in the murder of Andrew Helgelein. Mrs. Belle Gunness was also indicted as the principal in Helgelein's murder, though no warrant was issued since she was officially declared dead.
Manchester Democrat · 27 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho
This article compares Belle Gunness's murder farm in Laporte, Indiana, to the earlier Bender family murders in Kansas, noting similarities in burying victims near the house. It recounts that Gunness insured and killed two husbands, her three children, and other victims lured to the farm or killed in Chicago.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 27 May 1908 · page 5
Bluebeard Woman of Laporte.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho
The report reviews the Gunness case, noting that the headless body found in the ruins is now believed to belong to another victim rather than Belle Gunness herself, with police theorizing she set the fire and escaped. It then draws a parallel to the earlier case of H.H. Holmes, detailing his insurance fraud and multiple murders before his execution.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 27 May 1908 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
This is a routine local news roundup from Gary and Valparaiso covering business visits, legal matters, and social notes. Amid the mundane items, it briefly notes that two women from Gary visited the Gunness farm in LaPorte, reflecting public curiosity during the investigation.
The Lake County Times · 27 May 1908 · page 6
VALPARAISO. Geo. Fassold of Indianapolis was Valparaiso visitor today. ftrnrtor W. B. Hutchinson, Jr. of TiTirhle-an City is in the city today look ing after his cement curb and gutter work here. James Burk of Laporte was in the city
A fence contractor hired by Mrs. Gunness reports she insisted on a peculiar crook in the farm's wire fence, claiming it was to encircle a buried favorite horse. Sheriff Smutzer suspects this spot may instead conceal human remains and plans to have it dug up.
The Lake County Times · 27 May 1908 · page 8
LOOK FOR NEW BURIAL GROUND
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A letter writer claims to have seen Belle Gunness in Ogden, Utah, supporting the defense theory that she faked her death. Meanwhile, Sheriff Smutzer investigates a suspicious fenced area on the farm believed to hide more victims' bodies, as coroner Mack files additional inquest findings for three more unidentified homicide victims.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 27 May 1908 · page 3
MAY BE IN UTAH
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Hogs wallowing in a pond on the Gunness farm near Laporte, Indiana, rooted up a human arm bone. Sheriff Smutzer believes more bodies may be buried in the mud and plans to rake the pond's bottom.
The Topeka State Journal · 27 May 1908 · page 1
ROOT UP AN ARM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Mayor Darrow of Laporte says he received a letter from an Arkansas man claiming Belle Gunness escaped the fire in man's clothing and later wrote to him, days after she was officially declared burned to death. The man promises to produce this and other letters to investigators.
The Topeka State Journal · 27 May 1908 · page 3
IN MAN'S ATTIRE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Sheriff Smutzer's men prepare to dig in a new spot on the Gunness farm after ex-employee Harold Chapman described building a fence at her direction around a supposed horse burial site. The report also claims Gunness had a male accomplice who posed as her brother to lure victims, including Henry Gurholt, to the farm.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 27 May 1908 · page 7
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Martin Gurholt describes how his brother Henry was duped by a male accomplice posing as Mrs. Gunness's relative into traveling to La Porte, where he vanished after a July 4th visit. He recounts Mrs. Gunness's later letter claiming Henry had left for Chicago, a story the family believed until now realizing he was murdered.
Paper unidentified · 27 May 1908 · page 7
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
A letter to Indiana's governor suggests a mysterious woman in black swindling people in eastern Connecticut resembles Belle Gunness. Local residents in South Coventry describe her collecting money under false pretenses, though they only took casual interest at the time.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 27 May 1908 · page 1
IS IT MRS. GUNNESS?
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
A woman going by the name Mrs. Howe visited a family seeking help with a pension petition, telling a rambling and inconsistent story about her late miner husband. A Mrs. Kolb thought she resembled newspaper photos of Belle Gunness due to gold teeth and facial features, but local authorities dismissed the theory entirely.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 27 May 1908 · page 1
IS IT MRS. GUNNESS?
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Alma Record · Alma, Mich.
Seven unidentified victims of Mrs. Gunness were buried in potter's field with memorial stones, while the coroner continued holding four bodies found in the burned house. Autopsies revealed one of the seven was female, reviving theories about Jennie Olsen's disappearance with a mysterious man and woman.
Alma Record · 27 May 1908 · page 7
BODIES ARE BURIED, Those Shin By Mrs. Gunncss Lie In Potter's Field. STONES TO MARK GRAVES.
Lamphere's Watch Mystery Solved. The bodies of the seven unidentified dead were buried la the potter's field. Christian services were conducted for them, and a small stone will be erect ed with an Inscription, telling the cir cumstances of their death. The body of Jennie Olscn has been turned over to relatives. Ole Cudsberg's body was shipped to Iola, Wis., for burial. Coroner Mack is still holding the four bodlt-H found in the fire ruins of the burned Gunness home and which, according to evidenced produced, are the bodies of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness and her three children. They will be held until Coroner Mack files his formal verdict. Autopsies of the seven unidentified bodies has revealed th fact, ac cording to the reports of Dr. F. T. Wilcox and George It. Osborne, who conducted the autopsies" undT the di rection of Coroner Mack, that one of the seven was a female.
Coroner's physicians confirm one of seven unidentified bodies found at the Gunness farm is a woman, reviving theories that Jennie Olsen and a mysterious couple were murdered together. The Laporte grand jury begins hearing witness testimony, and a watch found on Ray Lamphere is identified as belonging to missing man John Moe.
Alma Record · 27 May 1908 · page 7
Three Disappeared. This revelation aroused new In terest in the story that a man and a woman came to the house one night in i:m to take Jennie Olsen to a Los Anireli-s college, as Mrs. Gun cess told those about the place. Tho next morning Jennie and the man and woman were gone. Mrs. Gunness said that they had left on an early train for California. The body now declared to be that of a woman was taken from the same hole as was that of Jennie Olsen. In that hole also were the bodies of Olo Budsberg of Iola, Wis., and that of another man.
See moreSee less
The theory now ad vanced Is that Mrs. Gunness may have, on the same night, murdered Jennie Olsen and the man and wo man who had come to take her to California and buried all three bodies, dismembered, in the same pit. Tho body of Budsberg, who was murdered later than this nielit, wiss found near er the surface than the other three. The Laporte county prund Jury Monday heard the stories of a number of witnesses In the Gunness case. Ex cellent progress was made, but the greater part of th week will b con sumed in the investigation. In view of the offer of the county commissioners to pay $4,000 for the production of Mrs. Gunness alive, 1'rosecutor Smith expects that this search will be world-wide. The mystery surrounding the watch found on Ray Lamphere when he w;'s arrested is cleared. J. G. Itamden of Manfred, N. D., who came to investi gate the disappearance of his half brother, John Moe of Hlbow Lake, Minn., Identilled the timepiece as the one owned by Moe when he left horn'1. Lamphere said that Mrs. Gunness gave him the watch.
Coroner Mack sent the stomachs of Belle Gunness, her two children, and victim Andrew Helgelein to a medical expert to test for poisoning evidence using the Marsh test. The bodies will not be buried until the fate of Ray Lamphere, a suspect, is determined, as they are needed as court exhibits.
The Detroit Times · 27 May 1908 · page 1
TO ANALYZE STOMACHS FROM HOUSE OF DEATH
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Willmar Tribune · Willmar, Minn. · and 1 other paper
A.K. Helgelein, the last identified victim of Belle Gunness, was buried at Laporte, while a dentist confirmed jawbone fragments from the farmhouse ruins belonged to Gunness herself. Investigators also reported failed efforts to identify one body as John Moe, and an autopsy suggesting another was a woman who vanished with Jennie Olsen, while thousands toured the farm site.
Willmar Tribune · 27 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The L'anse Sentinel · L'anse, L.S., Mich. · 30 May 1908
New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn. · and 1 other paper
A Laporte County grand jury returned seven indictments against Ray Lamphere, including murder charges for Belle Gunness, her three children, and arson, plus being an accessory in the murder of Andrew Helgelein. Because Gunness had been declared officially dead by the coroner's verdict, she was indicted as principal in the Helgelein killing without a warrant being issued.
New Ulm Review · 27 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Oakes Times · Oakes, N.D. · 28 May 1908
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · Grand Rapids, Minn · and 1 other paper
A coroner's jury officially ruled that the body found in the fire ruins of Mrs. Belle Gunness' home was indeed hers, death by felonious homicide at unknown hands. Separately, Ray Lamphere was indicted on seven counts including arson, five murders, and being an accessory in the Helgelein murder, while a skull was dug up on the farm and other evidence (a ring, a razor) continued to surface.
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · 27 May 1908 · page 9
SEVEN TRUE BILLS AGAINST LAMPHERE
Two Weeks Ago. Laporte, Ind., May 22. — “It is my verdict that the body so viewed is that of Mrs. Belle Gunness, and she came to her death through felonious .homicide and that the perpetrator thereof is to me unknown. —"C. S. Mack, Coroner.” Such was the verdict rendered late yesterday afternoon by the coroner. The official declaration that the body of the adult female found in the ruins of the fire of April 28, which destroy ed the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness, was that of Mrs. Gunness is the se quel to the report Tuesday of Dr.
See moreSee less
I. P. Norton, Mrs. Gunness’ dentist, that the bridges holding various false ^nd gold-filled teeth were those of Mrs. Gunness. The official finding of the coroner will relieve the state's attor ney of the necessity of proving in court, should the occasion require, that Mrs. Gunness is dead.
Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis. · 28 May 1908
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · Grand Rapids, Minn · and 5 other papers
The La Porte county grand jury returned indictments against Ray Lamphere for the murders of Belle Gunness and her three children, arson, and being an accessory to Andrew Helgelein's murder. Because Gunness was declared officially dead by the coroner, she was indicted as principal in the Helgelein killing to support the accessory charge against Lamphere, while diggers also unearthed a human skull believed to belong to one of the previously found bodies.
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · 27 May 1908 · page 9
SKULL IS DUG UP ON FARM
Votes Separate Bills. Separate bills were voted against Lamphere for the murder, in the first degree, of Mrs. Bella Gunness and her three children. In charging Lamphere with the murder of Andrew Helgelein the in dictment says that ‘‘Ray Lamphere on Jan. 14, 1908, did unlawfully, feloni ously, purposely and with premeditat ed malice, kill and murder Andrew E. Helgelein.” Lamphere w-as not arraigned, and this will probably not be done until the cases are set for trial. Bench warrants were served upon Lamphere in the jail last evening. He express ed but slight surprise, as the return ing of the indictment had been antic ipated.
Pierre Weekly Free Press · Pierre, S.D. · 28 May 1908
The Bad River News · Philip, S.D. · 28 May 1908
The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D. · 29 May 1908
The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D. · 29 May 1908
The Sisseton Weekly Standard · Sisseton, S.D. · 29 May 1908
Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · and 3 other papers
The Laporte County grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, charging him with arson, the murders of Belle Gunness and her three children, and as an accessory in the killing of Andrew Helgelein. Since Gunness was officially declared dead by the coroner's inquest, she was indicted as the principal to allow the charge against Lamphere to stand.
Mower County Transcript · 27 May 1908 · page 6
RAY LAMPHERE INDICTED.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 3 papers
Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · 28 May 1908
Courier Democrat · Langdon, N.D. · 28 May 1908
Little Falls Herald · Little Falls, Minn. · 29 May 1908
Okolona Messenger · Okolona, Miss.
A LaPorte dentist's testimony about teeth found in the ruins has made it seem likely that Mrs. Gunness died in the fire with her house. Suspicion continues to center on Ray Lamphere as responsible for the deaths.
Okolona Messenger · 27 May 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Enterprise · Harlem, Mont.
Ten thousand visitors toured the Gunness farm near Laporte, Indiana, on Sunday excursions, while efforts to identify one body as John Moe failed. An autopsy revealed one of seven unidentified bodies found in the barnyard was a woman, possibly the missing Jennie Olsen's companion, and Belle Gunness's death was confirmed by her false teeth found in the fire ruins.
The Enterprise · 27 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Enterprise · Harlem, Mont.
The grand jury in Laporte returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, including murder charges for Belle Gunness, her children, and Andrew Helgelein, plus arson and accessory charges. Separately, the coroner officially ruled the deaths of the three Gunness children felonious homicides by persons unknown.
The Enterprise · 27 May 1908 · page 2
RAY LAMPHERE IS INDICTED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Western News · Stevensville, Mont.
Mayor Darrow of La Porte received a letter signed "Samuel Harvey" of Omaha claiming the writer visited Mrs. Gunness in May, June, and August 1907. The letter also claims the writer spoke with her at the Ogden, Utah depot on May 4, 1908, where she said she was traveling to California to enroll her daughter in school.
The Western News · 27 May 1908 · page 2
"SAM" VISITED MRS. GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb.
A brief item notes that thousands of people continue to visit the Gunness farm in Laporte, Indiana, to view the site where many victims were lured to their deaths. It is a short filler item among various unrelated news notes.
The Columbus Journal · 27 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
This is a newspaper's daily summary page listing brief references to many unrelated stories, including a note that 'many clues' exist regarding Mrs. Gunness and a La Porte officer, and mention of an investigation possibly tied to Jerome. The bulk of the page covers unrelated topics like weather, politics, floods, and sports.
Omaha Daily Bee · 27 May 1908 · page 1
SUMMARY OF THE BEE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
A man named Samuel Harvey claims he spoke with Belle Gunness in Ogden, Utah, six days after she was reported burned to death, while a convict and a Connecticut woman also report possible sightings or connections to her. Authorities are investigating these competing claims amid uncertainty over whether Gunness actually died in the fire.
Omaha Daily Bee · 27 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUINNESS UBIQUITOUS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
A former employee named Harold Chapman told authorities that Mrs. Gunness had instructed him to build a fence with a deliberate bend around a spot where she claimed a favorite horse was buried. Sheriff Smutzer's men began digging in this previously unsuspected area based on the tip.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 27 May 1908 · page 2
NEW GUNNESS CLUE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Forest Republican · Tionesta, Pa.
A La Porte grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, charging him with arson, five murders, and being an accessory in Andrew Helgelein's murder; Belle Gunness was also indicted as principal despite being declared officially dead. New digging uncovered another skull matching one of three skeletons previously found in a single hole with only two skulls.
The Forest Republican · 27 May 1908 · page 1
Lamphere Indicted Seven Times.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Forest Republican · Tionesta, Pa.
A brief news digest item reports that Indiana authorities have discovered a lead on another man believed to have been a victim of Mrs. Gunness. It appears among many other unrelated weekly news summaries.
The Forest Republican · 27 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
A letter sent to Indiana's governor describes a mysterious woman in black swindling people in eastern Connecticut, believed to resemble Mrs. Gunness. The tip was forwarded to the Laporte County Sheriff as a possible clue to her whereabouts if she is still alive.
The Morning Tribune · 27 May 1908 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.
This report announces the shocking discovery of multiple bodies buried at Belle Gunness's La Porte, Indiana property, alongside the fire that destroyed her home and apparently killed her and three children. It lists those closely associated with Mrs. Gunness who are believed dead or missing, including suitors, her husbands, and children, framing her as a suspected serial killer.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 27 May 1908 · page 2
BODIES OF FIVE SLAIN UNEARTHED IN YARD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.
The report catalogs bodies exhumed from Belle Gunness's property, including children, suitors, and her first husband, while identifying Andrew Heldgren and Jennie Olson among the dead. It states Gunness herself died with three children in the house fire and suspects Ray Lamphere of setting the blaze and dismembering victims.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 27 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.
Authorities believe Ray Lamphere, a carpenter, dismembered Andrew Heldgren's body with a saw and buried the parts in Gunness's yard. The report also details her suspected poisoning of her first husband, her matrimonial scheme to lure and murder wealthy men, and the ongoing excavation of her property for more victims.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Abbeville Press and Banner · 27 May 1908 · page 2
TO MRS. GUNNESS' DOOR
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.
A letter sent to Indiana's governor claims a mysterious woman in black swindling people in eastern Connecticut closely resembles Mrs. Gunness. The tip was forwarded to the Laporte county sheriff as a possible lead on her whereabouts if she is still alive.
The Madison Daily Leader · 27 May 1908 · page 1
THINKS IT'S MRS. GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Pigs rooting in a pond on the Gunness farm uncovered a human arm bone, convincing Sheriff Smutzer that more bodies lie beneath the mud. He ordered the entire shoreline raked to recover any additional remains from the water.
Paper unidentified · 27 May 1908 · page 1
FIND NEW GUNNESS MYSTERY
Their Dead. Laporte, Ind., May 27. —Several bogs wallowing in a pond at the edge of a lot on the Gunness farm this morn , Ing. brought up the bone of a human arm. The finding of the bone has convinced Sheriff Smutzer that other bodies are buried beenath the mud at the bottom of the pond. The entire Shore will be gone over with rakes, in an effort to bring any bodies the water may secrete to the surface.
Mayor Darrow receives a letter from Samuel Harvey claiming he met and spoke with Belle Gunness in Ogden, Utah, days after she was supposedly burned to death. Additional reports include a convict's claims about a crime gang and a letter about a mysterious woman resembling Gunness seen in Connecticut.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 27 May 1908 · page 8
BELIEVES MRS. GUNNESS WAS NOT BURNED TO DEATH
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis.
Coroner Mack officially ruled that the adult female body found in the April 28 fire was Mrs. Gunness and that she died by felonious homicide at an unknown hand. Prosecutors meanwhile advanced a new theory that Ray Lamphere doubled back toward the burning house before fleeing to the Wheatbrook farm.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Vernon County Censor · 27 May 1908 · page 7
WEB OF EVIDENCE AROUND LAMPHERE CORONER OFFICIALLY ESTABLISHES DEATH OF MRS. GUNNESS IN BURNED HOME. ALLEGED SLAYER SEEN BY A BOY RUNNING AWAY FROM THE FIRE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis.
The state advances a theory that Lamphere made a second trip toward the Gunness farm around 3:30 a.m. on April 28, timed with witnesses seeing fire at the house. A 14-year-old boy, Albert Zoinur, testified he saw flames and later identified Lamphere as the man he saw running from the scene.
Vernon County Censor · 27 May 1908 · page 7
THE FIRE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
A man named Samuel Harvey tells Mayor Darrow he met and spoke with Belle Gunness in Ogden, Utah, days after she was supposedly burned to death. Authorities are investigating his claims alongside other reported sightings and a convict's tip about her house being used by a Chicago crime gang.
The Laramie Republican · 27 May 1908 · page 3
MONSTER IS SEEN IN OGDEN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
A convict in Chester, Illinois prison claims Mrs. Gunness' house served as a fence for a Chicago gang of criminals, and says he has valuable information for authorities. Separately, Indiana's Governor Hanley forwarded a letter describing a woman resembling Mrs. Gunness seen in South Coventry, Connecticut.
The Laramie Republican · 27 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Audubon Republican · Audubon, Iowa · and 3 other papers
A news roundup reports that three more suspected victims were linked to Belle Gunness's farm near La Porte, and that officials found evidence she had an accomplice luring victims. It also notes the burial of victim A.K. Helgelein and a dentist's identification of a jawbone fragment from the farmhouse ruins as belonging to Gunness herself.
Audubon Republican · 28 May 1908 · page 2
GENERAL NEWS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 3 papers
The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb. · 20 May 1908
The Loup City Northwestern · Loup City, Neb. · 21 May 1908
The Greenville Journal · Greenville, Ohio · 21 May 1908
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D. · and 1 other paper
Sheriff Smutzer resumed digging at the Gunness farm after a ten-day delay, searching the garden, basement, and areas near evergreen trees for more victims. Jewelry belonging to missing Rochester woman May O'Reilly was found, along with a human skull discovered in a cesspool.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 28 May 1908 · page 10
MORE JEWELRY FOUND.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · 23 May 1908
The Miller Press · Miller, S.D. · and 8 other papers
Coroner Mack issues the first official verdict declaring Mrs. Gunness dead, with more verdicts expected in other deaths. The La Porte grand jury returns seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, including murder charges for Gunness, her children, and Andrew Helgelein, while new clues like a ring and razor fuel further inquiry into additional possible victims.
Grand Rapids Herald-Review · Grand Rapids, Minn · 27 May 1908
Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D. · 28 May 1908
Pierre Weekly Free Press · Pierre, S.D. · 28 May 1908
The Bad River News · Philip, S.D. · 28 May 1908
Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis. · 28 May 1908
The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D. · 29 May 1908
The Herald-Advance · Milbank, S.D. · 29 May 1908
The Sisseton Weekly Standard · Sisseton, S.D. · 29 May 1908
The Prescott Daily News · Prescott, Ark.
Sheriff Smutzer of Laporte County, Indiana, arrived in Sherman, Texas with two men before departing for Vernon, sending a telegram back to Laporte. He declined to be interviewed but is believed to have reason to think Mrs. Gunness is in Texas.
The Prescott Daily News · 28 May 1908 · page 3
Sheriff In Texas.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
Hogs rooting in lowland below the Gunness home uncovered an arm and a leg believed to belong to another victim of the murderess. A letter from Ashley, Minnesota reported that a man named Colseth from that town had traveled the countryside luring victims to the farm.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 28 May 1908 · page 1
Another Victim on Gunness Farm
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
A woman in South Coventry, Connecticut wrote to the Indiana governor claiming she recognized a mysterious swindler in her area as the fugitive Belle Gunness. The letter was forwarded to the LaPorte County sheriff for investigation.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 28 May 1908 · page 7
WOMAN BELIEVES SHE HAS LOCATED THE MULTI-MURDERESS OF INDIANA—SHERIFF OF LaPORTE COUNTY TO INVESTIGATE THIS LATEST CLEW
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Nevada County Picayune · Prescott, Ark.
The La Porte county grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, including murder and arson charges, and also indicted the officially-dead Belle Gunness as principal in Andrew Helgelein's murder to secure Lamphere's accessory charge. Diggers also found an additional skull, believed female, raising questions about the earlier discovery of three skeletons with only two skulls.
LAPORTE COUNTY GRAND JURY RETURNS SEVEN TRUE BILLS. MRS. GUNNESS ALSO INDICTED
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Sheriff A. F. Smutzer of LaPorte, Indiana, was confirmed to have spent the day in Sherman, Texas, before departing for Denison and then Vernon. He refused to discuss the Gunness case or confirm the purpose of his visit.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 28 May 1908 · page 7
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
This is a miscellaneous humor and filler column mixing jokes about graduation, politics, and oddities. One brief quip sarcastically attributes 'This is positively my last appearance' to Mrs. Gunness, mocking ongoing uncertainty about her fate.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 28 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · and 1 other paper
A former employee named Harold Chapman told authorities that Mrs. Gunness had instructed him to build a fence with a deliberate bend around a spot where she claimed a 'favorite horse' was buried, prompting Sheriff Smutzer's men to search there for bodies. Separately, the grand jury indicted both Ray Lamphere and the presumed-dead Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein, the indictment of Gunness being legally necessary to charge Lamphere as an accessory.
NEW GUNNESS CLEW. Former Farmhand Says Woman Spoke of Buried "Favorite Horse.” Laporte. I ml., May 27.—As u result of a statement made to the authorities by Harold Chapman, a former em ployee of Mrs. Belle Gunness, men un der the direction of Sheriff Smutzer began searching for bodies in a hither to unsuspected place. Chapman says that he was Instructed one day by Mrs. Gunness to build a wire fence around a certain part of the back yard. Mrs. Gunness superintend ed the work and watched every move very carefully.
See moreSee less
At a certain point she wanted Chap man to make a crook in the fence. There was considerable argument over the matter. Chapman said, but finally he yielded and made the bend around the place where Mrs. Gunness said she had a “favorite horse" buried. In returning seven true bills against Kay Lamphere the Laporte county grand jury' also indicted Mrs. Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein of Mansfield. 8. D. No war rant was issued for Mrs. Gunness, as she was declared officially dead by the verdict of Coroner Mack, blit in order to vote a true bill against Lamphere as an accessory in the killing of Helge lein it was necessary to indict Mrs. Gunness as the principal. Keystone Prohibitionists Meet. Sayre, Pa., May 27.--Bauners, flags and bunting in festoons and streamers greeted the delegates to the state pro hibition convention when they arrived In this village. No pains have been spared by the business men of this place to make the little town of Sayre as attractive as possible, and many were the commants spoken by the delegates of the handsome decora tions.
Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · 28 May 1908
The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.
This humor column jokes about various news items, including a suggestion that Laporte should turn the Gunness farm into a pleasure park with a scenic railway and chamber of horrors to cater to morbid public curiosity. It also includes a pun about a 'Mrs. Ghirtness' and other unrelated political satire.
The New Haven Union · 28 May 1908 · page 4
' : ‘ It’s the Louisville Courier-Journal ‘which perpetrates this: "Gentlemen who attended week-end parties at Mrs. \ Ghirtness’ home agree that the lady Was 'perfectly killing1 at times.” A shocking tragedy was narrowly ‘(averted when the Chicago Socialist ‘convention adopted a Prohibitionist plank by mistake but fortunately dis covered It just before adjournment. They say now the Hughes boom is reviving. Some sort of story has to , he started to keep up interest in the - Republican presidential contest, so this Is as good and as improbable as , any. Judging from the inclination of the morbid public, Laporte, Ind., would make a hit by turning the Gunness
A former farmhand named Harold Chapman told authorities Mrs. Gunness had him build a fence around a spot where she claimed a 'favorite horse' was buried, prompting new searches. The Laporte County grand jury indicted the (officially deceased) Mrs. Gunness as principal in the murder of Andrew Helgelein, needed to indict Ray Lamphere as accessory, while hogs rooting in her yard unearthed human arm and leg bones.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 28 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Hogs wallowing in a pond at the edge of the Gunness farm near LaPorte, Indiana, dug up a human bone, convincing Sheriff Smutzer that more bodies are buried in the mud. The entire shore of the pond will be dragged with long rakes to bring any additional remains to the surface.
Los Angeles Herald · 28 May 1908 · page 8
TURN UP HUMAN BONE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Hogs wallowing in a pond on the Gunness farm uncovered bones from a human arm and leg. Sheriff Smutzer believes more bodies are buried in the pond mud and plans to rake the entire shore to recover them.
New-York Tribune · 28 May 1908 · page 2
HOGS ROOT UP BONES.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Coroner Mack is nearing completion of inquests on bodies found at the Gunness farm, with each verdict ruling homicide by an unknown perpetrator. A newly found arm and leg bone in a pond behind the cemetery, in an area not yet dug, suggests further bodies remain to be discovered.
The Washington Herald · 28 May 1908 · page 3
WILL RESUME BODY SEARCH Laporte Officers Find More Bones on Mrs Gunness Farm Signs Point to Further Discoveries Where No Digging Has Been Done
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
More body parts were found in the hog pen area, prompting further search for victims' remains. Authorities are investigating a possible accomplice—a cousin of Mrs. Gunness living in Ashby, Minnesota—and have sent stomach samples from Andrew Helgelein and Mrs. Gunness to a Chicago expert to test for poisoning.
The Washington Herald · 28 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Coroner Mack nears completion of inquests on bodies found at Mrs. Gunness' farm, all ruled homicides by unknown perpetrator. New remains found in the pond suggest further search is needed, while authorities investigate a possible accomplice and send organs for poison testing.
The Washington Herald · 28 May 1908 · page 3
WILL RESUME BODY SEARCH
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · and 6 other papers
An autopsy confirmed one of seven bodies found in Mrs. Gunness' barnyard was a woman, likely the missing Jennie Olsen's companion. False teeth found in the fire ruins were said to prove Gunness was dead, and a grand jury indicted both Ray Lamphere and the deceased Mrs. Gunness for murder.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
River Falls Journal · 28 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 6 papers
Audubon Republican · Audubon, Iowa · 28 May 1908
The Loup City Northwestern · Loup City, Neb. · 28 May 1908
The Greenville Journal · Greenville, Ohio · 28 May 1908
The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · 29 May 1908
The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich. · 29 May 1908
The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn. · 29 May 1908
Paper unidentified
Ray Lamphere's attorneys received a letter from an unnamed Arkansas man claiming Belle Gunness escaped dressed as a man and that he had corresponded with her after the fire. He offered to produce the letter and more details if questioned by officers.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 28 May 1908 · page 6
SAYS MRS. GUNNESS ESCAPED FROM HIM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa
A doctor who had been courting a widow in Colorado left town before the Gunness farm story broke, telling someone he was going to Indiana to marry a woman he had corresponded with. He was presumed to be a Gunness victim until it was learned he was in fact alive and had simply relocated.