As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

April 1921

3 articles

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

An elderly Arizona pioneer recalls the rough mining-era Southwest of the late 1870s, including the rise of Tombstone, the Clanton gang, and the arrival of the Earp brothers as lawmen. He asserts the Earps and Clantons were business partners in stage operations before their famous shootout.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Bisbee Daily Review, 24 December 1919, Bisbee Daily Review, 26 December 1919.

Arizona Republican · 13 April 1921 · page 16 · transcribed from the page image

ROUGH AND TOUGH DURING LATE '70S

DAYS OF TOMBSTONE DURING LATE 70'S

Days when there were steamboats coming up the Colorado river, stage coaches plying between Tucson and Tombstone, and gangs of "bad men" in the latter city are recalled in the reminiscences of Daniel Eldredge of Chandler:

See moreSee less

"I came to Arizona March 3, 1878, and settled on the San Pedro river. There were only a few settlers on the river at that time, at Tres Alamos and a mail station. Soon after, Ed Schiefflin discovered the Doughnut mine. William Girard was interested with him and they developed it and built two mills at Charleston on the San Pedro river. Then Messrs. Parsons and White acquired the Contention mine and put up a mill at Contention, also on the San Pedro. George Warren discovered the Copper Queen mine at Bisbee and sold it to the Phelps-Dodge company, and a smelter was put up there. I was acquainted with both Schiefflin and Warren.

"Freight was hauled from Yuma, coming up the Colorado by steamboat. There were two six horse stages running between Tucson and Tombstone daily. One was owned by J. D. Kneer and Walker, and the other by 'Sandy Bob,' and there was much competition between them. They took great pride in their horses and coaches.

"A very rough element grew up around Charleston and Tombstone, known as the Clanton gang. Billy Clanton and Frank McCloury and Tom McCloury were shot in a fight with officers. The officers wanted them to give up their arms and the fight started on the street. I knew all the boys who were killed; worked for Frank putting up hay for the Huachauca government post.

"Then the Earp brothers came to Tombstone and they got to be officers. One worked in the express office. The Clantons and Earps were in together on the stage holdups. The Earp in the express office would tip them off when there was money on the stage and the Clanton gang would hold it up. The other Earps, who were officers, would go out to catch the robbers, and they would meet them and divide the spoils. The Earps would come back and report they had lost the trail.

"At last the Earps and Clantons fell out and they practically ran each other out of the country. That put an end to a great deal of the rustling around there. They weren't called robbers, but rustlers, and there used to be a lot of rustling of horses and mules and cattle. They would go over into Mexico and bring out cattle and sell them for a few hundred dollars, then go to Charleston, where there was a dance hall and saloons, and blow their money. A graveyard quickly grew up there, with from one to three additions a day. Jim Burnett was the justice of the peace. He was killed a few years later by Bill Green of Cananea, Mexico.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

A 1921 newspaper retrospective recounts Ed Schieffelin's founding of Tombstone and the lawless era of the Earps and Doc Holliday, as recalled by old-timer Mauk. It includes an anecdote about a stage holdup in which a man in a linen duster resembling Holliday's was blamed for the robbery.

Arizona Republican · 13 April 1921 · page 18 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

WILDEST AND WOOLIEST IN WEST

Pioneer history of Arizona, at least that part of it which relates to the wild and woolly days around Tombstone during the first big gold strike, was related recently by George A. Mauk, himself a pioneer of that district. Mr. Mauk, now of Phoenix, first went to Tombstone in 1880, and has been a resident of Arizona since.

Exciting experiences in the lives of Ed. Schieffelin, founder of Tombstone; Dr. Holliday, the linen duster physician; the Earp boys, hard riding, sure firing officers of the law; and Frank Leslie, known as Buckskin Frank; and his partner, Johnny Dean, were related by Mr. Mauk in his review of events that kept Tombstone residents continually on their toes during the early days.

See moreSee less

Schieffelin—Old Honest Ed they called him in those days—was the man who made the first rich silver strike in the Tombstone district, Mauk said. Today, his remains are buried amid the great granite boulders where he first camped while making his strike.

Schieffelin had long been a prospector around Arizona, but he had been only moderately successful. Things were quiet about Tucson, so Old Honest Ed trekked his way out onto the desert with the avowed intention of "making his fortune."

"You'll find your tombstone, that's what you'll find," his acquaintances shouted after him as he plodded along.

But Ed. never looked back. A great big strapping westerner he was, Mr. Mauk said, powerful of build and a fine looker, with his high hip leather boots and his red flannel shirt, open at the neck.

The next heard of Schieffelin was the news of his rich strike. He called his camp "Tombstone." When the news of the strike reached the outside world there was a rush to the field. Almost overnight a city arose. Then it was that Schieffelin built Schieffelin hall, a structure that still stands in Tombstone as a monument to the hardy pioneer.

Later, Schieffelin was one of the pioneers into Alaska during the great gold rush in the late 80's, but the cold weather finally turned him back.

Getting back to Tombstone, horse stealing and cattle rustling were every day occurrences during the early days, Mauk said. Prominent among the residents were Dr. Holliday and the Earp brothers. Stage holdups were as frequent as paydays. The gold to pay the workers was usually sent by stage from Fairbanks.

One holdup in particular was recalled by Mr. Mauk. As the stage with its six horses rounded a turn in the road, one of the two lead horses was killed from ambush. The express messenger, riding on top of the stage to guard the payroll, brought his gun to his shoulder, but before he had time to open fire he was shot dead by another member of the ambush party. He fell across the knees of the driver.

A man wearing a linen duster, very similar to the one always worn by Dr. Holliday, was identified as one of the bandits. After the robbery had been completed, the stage continued to Tombstone. Arriving there, it was met by Dr. Holliday and one or two of the Earp boys. The express messenger's body still lay across the driver's feet where it had fallen.

C. N. Mauk, father of George Mauk, was then expressman in Tombstone. Behind closed doors that night and in a whisper, the stage driver told the senior Mauk that Dr. Holliday was one of the robbers. No attempt was ever made to prosecute him, however. It was also generally believed in Tombstone that some of the Earp boys, although officers, took part in many of the stage robberies. The robbery was blamed on the Clanton boys, notorious bandits in that day. Three of the Clanton boys were later killed in a fight with officers in Tombstone.

A short time after this, a stranger from parts unknown, small of stature, with sharp steely blue eyes and a manner altogether unbecoming the times, arrived in Tombstone. He later was to be known as Buckskin Frank. He gave his name as Frank Leslie, but through all the years his identity has never been established. He was from a good family and presumably had had a college education.

To all appearances, Buckskin Frank was a man of delicate nature, but he soon established a reputation that made him one of the most feared men in the Tombstone district.

Shortly after his arrival, a dance was given in Scheffelin hall. Buckskin was one of the dancers. During the course of the evening he sought and was granted a dance with the wife of one of the "bad men" of Tombstone. At that time, however, he did not know the woman was married. When the husband learned of the episode, he invited Leslie into the street with the avowed intention of killing him.

Much to the surprise of all guests, Leslie accepted the invitation. The crowd parted as he walked from the building, men and women turning to one another and sympathizing with the newcomer.

Hardly had the stranger left the building when two shots were heard. There was a brief wait and Leslie walked in. "He's out there if you want him," he said in a quiet, well modulated voice.

His feat in killing the "killer" established his reputation as a "quick trigger" artist.

Later, Buckskin killed the notorious character, "Billie the Kid," not the original Billie, but the Arizona Billie. The Kid went to Tombstone for the avowed purpose of killing Buckskin,

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

An old-timer named Mauk recalls a stagecoach robbery in which the express messenger was killed, with rumors that Doc Holliday and some Earp brothers were secretly involved despite being lawmen. The account also introduces the arrival of gunman Buckskin Frank Leslie, whose mysterious reputation grew after a dance-hall confrontation over another man's wife.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 574 days later.

Wrong

Arizona Republican · 13 April 1921 · page 18 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

AND WOOLIEST IN WEST

Pioneer history of Arizona, at least that part of it which relates to the wild and woolly days around Tombstone during the first big gold strike, was related recently by George A. Mauk, himself a pioneer of that district. Mr. Mauk, now of Phoenix, first went to Tombstone in 1880, and has been a resident of Arizona since.

Exciting experiences in the lives of Ed. Schieffelin, founder of Tombstone; Dr. Holliday, the linen duster physician; the Earp boys, hard riding, sure firing officers of the law; and Frank Leslie, known as Buckskin Frank; and his partner, Johnny Dean, were related by Mr. Mauk in his review of events that kept Tombstone residents continually on their toes during the early days.

See moreSee less

Schieffelin—Old Honest Ed they called him in those days—was the man who made the first rich silver strike in the Tombstone district, Mauk said. Today, his remains are buried amid the great granite boulders where he first camped while making his strike.

Schieffelin had long been a prospector around Arizona, but he had been only moderately successful. Things were quiet about Tucson, so Old Honest Ed trekked his way out onto the desert with the avowed intention of "making his fortune."

"You'll find your tombstone, that's what you'll find," his acquaintances shouted after him as he plodded along.

But Ed. never looked back. A great big strapping westerner he was, Mr. Mauk said, powerful of build and a fine looker, with his high hip leather boots and his red flannel shirt, open at the neck.

The next heard of Schieffelin was the news of his rich strike. He called his camp "Tombstone." When the news of the strike reached the outside world there was a rush to the field. Almost overnight a city arose. Then it was that Schieffelin built Schieffelin hall, a structure that still stands in Tombstone as a monument to the hardy pioneer.

Later, Schieffelin was one of the pioneers into Alaska during the great gold rush in the late 80's, but the cold weather finally turned him back.

Getting back to Tombstone, horse stealing and cattle rustling were every day occurrences during the early days, Mauk said. Prominent among the residents were Dr. Holliday and the Earp brothers. Stage holdups were as frequent as paydays. The gold to pay the workers was usually sent by stage from Fairbanks.

One holdup in particular was recalled by Mr. Mauk. As the stage with its six horses rounded a turn in the road, one of the two lead horses was killed from ambush. The express messenger, riding on top of the stage to guard the payroll, brought his gun to his shoulder, but before he had time to open fire he was shot dead by another member of the ambush party. He fell across the knees of the driver.

A man wearing a linen duster, very similar to the one always worn by Dr. Holliday, was identified as one of the bandits. After the robbery had been completed, the stage continued to Tombstone. Arriving there, it was met by Dr. Holliday and one or two of the Earp boys. The express messenger's body still lay across the driver's feet where it had fallen.

C. N. Mauk, father of George Mauk, was then expressman in Tombstone. Behind closed doors that night and in a whisper, the stage driver told the senior Mauk that Dr. Holliday was one of the robbers. No attempt was ever made to prosecute him, however. It was also generally believed in Tombstone that some of the Earp boys, although officers, took part in many of the stage robberies. The robbery was blamed on the Clanton boys, notorious bandits in that day. Three of the Clanton boys were later killed in a fight with officers in Tombstone.

A short time after this, a stranger from parts unknown, small of stature, with sharp steely blue eyes and a manner altogether unbecoming the times, arrived in Tombstone. He later was to be known as Buckskin Frank. He gave his name as Frank Leslie, but through all the years his identity has never been established. He was from a good family and presumably had had a college education.

To all appearances, Buckskin Frank was a man of delicate nature, but he soon established a reputation that made him one of the most feared men in the Tombstone district.

Shortly after his arrival, a dance was given in Scheffelin hall. Buckskin was one of the dancers. During the course of the evening he sought and was granted a dance with the wife of one of the "bad men" of Tombstone. At that time, however, he did not know the woman was married. When the husband learned of the episode, he invited Leslie into the street with the avowed intention of killing him.

Much to the surprise of all guests, Leslie accepted the invitation. The crowd parted as he walked from the building, men and women turning to one another and sympathizing with the newcomer.

Hardly had the stranger left the building when two shots were heard. There was a brief wait and Leslie walked in. "He's out there if you want him," he said in a quiet, well modulated voice.

His feat in killing the "killer" established his reputation as a "quick trigger" artist.

Later, Buckskin killed the notorious character, "Billie the Kid," not the original Billie, but the Arizona Billie. The Kid went to Tombstone for the avowed purpose of killing Buckskin,

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page