As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

December 1919

3 articles

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

A 1919 feature recounts old frontier stories from Krigbaum, including a trivial Tombstone shooting over a shirt color and claims that the 'notorious Earp gang' committed stage robberies using inside tips from a deputy U.S. marshal among them. It then transitions into the 1883 Bisbee Goldwater's store robbery by Heath, Howard, Sample, Delaney, and Kelly.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 476 days later.

Wrong

Bisbee Daily Review · 24 December 1919 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

dead. As his victim fell, somebody tossed a revolver to his side, which was found, of course, when the authorities took charge of the body, and a verdict of justifiable homicide was returned by the jury. For anyone in Tombstone to have told the truth or to have interfered in any manner in the case would have meant his death in turn. In 1881 all freight came into Bisbee from Casa Grande via Tucson, and the wash now visible in Warren is said to be the remains of the old roads, down which the water would course in the rainy season, and which resulted in the old waterways now visible around the lower part of Lowell and near Warren.

See moreSee less

Stage robberies were frequent, many of these being accomplished in broad daylight, and by the notorious Earp gang of Tombstone, one of whom was deputy

See the clipping

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

A long retrospective interview with pioneer Frank Vaughn recounts his arrival in Arizona in the 1870s and his acquaintance with Tombstone-era figures including the Earp brothers, whom he describes as a notorious 'gang' that terrorized the region. He recalls the gunfight in which Billy Clanton and the McLaury brothers were killed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 474 days later.

Wrong

Bisbee Daily Review · 26 December 1919 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Phoenix was hardly more than a collection of tents, while its population was made up chiefly of Maricopa Indians.

In the spring of 1848 Vaughn started southwards with the building of the Southern Pacific railroad into Tucson, already famous as one of the oldest towns in the United States. The road was continued into Deming, N. M., and then the Santa Fe began building from Benson to Guaymas, Mexico. Vaughn threw in his lot with this road, and was master mechanic at Benson, and, later, at Charleston, near Tombstone. His work as mechanic was interrupted at intervals by his labors as school teacher.

See moreSee less

In Charleston and Tombstone he became immediately acquainted with all the characters, mostly bad, who made that section of country one of the noted "hot towns" of the West. He knew James Burnett, the famous wit, when the latter was justice of the peace, and he also numbered among his ac-

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A Regina dispatch laments Parliament's renaming of the Royal Northwest Mounted Police, crediting the force with keeping Canada's frontier peaceful. It contrasts this with the lawless American West, naming Wyatt Earp among outlaws and gunfighters like Billy the Kid and Doc Holliday.

Omaha Daily Bee · 29 December 1919 · page 7

OPPOSE PLAN TO RENAME POLICE IN NORTHWEST

States? The answer is the R. N. W. M. P. Why were there no counterparts in western Canada and Abilene, Dodge City, Hays City, Tombstone, Deadwood and the other classic type towns of the American frontier vhose early history was written with a six-shooter dipped in whisky and blood? The R. N. V. M. P.

See the clipping